03 02 2021 Journal of Votes
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION
JOURNAL OF VOTES
Meeting Date: TUESDAY, MARCH 2, 2021
Member Attendance
Present: Chair Maddy; Commissioners Gorham, Eggenberger (arrived at 7:03 p.m.) and
Riedel;
Absent: Commissioner Gault
Action Item Votes
Gorham moved, Riedel seconded, approving
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
the agenda for March 2, 2021, as presented.
Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion passed 3/0.
Riedel moved, Gorham seconded, approving
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
the Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of
February 2, 2021, as presented. Roll Call
Vote: Ayes – all. Motion passed 3/0.
Minor Subdivision Riedel moved, Gorham seconded, to
Application: Michael and Melissa Foster and recommend approval of the lot line adjustment
Janet Malotky and Steve Dietz request for properties located at 24680
Location: 24680 Smithtown Road and 5675 Smithtown Road and 5675 Christopher Road,
Christopher Road subject to the conditions listed in the staff
report, and direct staff to work with the
applicants to re-write the legal descriptions of
the 10-foot drainage and utility easements.
Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion passed 4/0.
Variance Vote #1: Riedel moved, Eggenberger
Applicant: Cyclone Construction seconded, to recommend that the City Council
Location: 25360 Birch Bluff Road approve the variance requests for setbacks for
the property located at 25360 Birch Bluff
Road, subject to conditions as outlined in the
staff report, including that the shed/boathouse
be removed.
Roll Call Vote: Ayes – Riedel; Nay – Gorham,
Eggenberger, and Maddy. Motion failed 1/3.
Vote #2: Eggenberger moved, Gorham
seconded, to recommend that the City Council
approve the variance requests for the property
located at 25360 Birch Bluff Road, subject to
conditions as outlined in the staff report,
except removal of the shed/boathouse.
Roll Call Vote: Ayes – Gorham, Eggenberger;
Nay – Riedel, Maddy. Motion failed 2/2.
Vote #3: Riedel moved, Gorham seconded, to
recommend that the City Council approve the
variance requests for setbacks for the property
located at 25360 Birch Bluff Road, subject to
the staff conditions included in the staff report,
with the exception of removal of the shed. Roll
Call Vote: Ayes – Riedel, Gorham,
Eggenberger; Nay – Maddy. Motion passed
3/1.
Vote #4: Riedel moved, Maddy seconded, to
recommend that the City Council require the
removal of the nonconforming lakeside shed
for the property located at 25360 Birch Bluff
Road. Roll Call Vote: Ayes – Riedel,
Eggenberger, Maddy; Nays – Gorham.
Motion passed 3/1.
Election of Officers and 2021 Work Program Gorham moved, Eggenberger seconded, to
nominate Dustin Maddy to continue serving as
Chair and Marc Riedel to continue to serve as
Vice-Chair. Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion
passed.
Riedel moved, Eggenberger seconded,
ADJOURNMENT
adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting
of March 2, 2021, at 8:44 P.M. Roll Call Vote:
Ayes – all. Motion passed 4/0.