042495 CC BR Min
.
.
.
,
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
BOARD OF REVIEW MEETING
MONDAY, APRIL 24, 1995
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
l\tIINUTES
1. RECONVENE BOARD OF REVIEW MEETING - FROl\tI APRIL 5. 1995
MEETING
Mayor Bean reconvened the Board of Review meeting at 7:04 p.m.
A.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Mayor Bean; Councilmembers Benson, Malam, McCarty, and Stover; City
Assessor Erickson, Administrator Hurm, City Attorney Keane, and Planning
Director Nielsen.
2 . APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Board of Review Meeting - April 5, 1995
Stover moved, Malam seconded to approve the April 5, 1995 Board of Review
Minutes as presented. Motion passed 5/0.
3. BOARD OF REVIEW
Mayor Bean stated this Board of Review meeting was continued from a meeting two weeks ago,
when residents had the opportunity to give public testimony on issues relevant to the assessed
value of 1996 tax payable. At that meeting, the residents had an opportunity to sign up for the
assessor's reviewal of property and other issues. Subsequent to that meeting, the assessor
developed recommendations on the subject for tonight's discussion.
City Assessor Erickson explained the valuation method, the appeal process, and the role of the
Board of Review. He indicated he was in attendance tonight to give his recommendations to the
Board of Review of which properties assessed values should or should not be changed.
Mayor Bean opened the meeting for public testimony to any persons who had not had the
opportunity to speak at the April 5, 1995 Board of Review Meeting.
Richard Larson, 5610 Vinehill Road, indicated his assessed value had increased by 10.1%. He
stated there had been no improvements made to the house and he felt this was an alarming increase.
City Assessor Erickson explained this was a common amount of increase for homes located in that
area. He suggested Mr. Larson apply to the Hennepin County Board of Equalization and ask for a
reappraisal of the property.
Mayor Bean closed the public testimony.
City Assessor Erickson reported he did have one addition, which was the property on page 57,
owner Naomi Carlson, 5955 Cathcart Drive. This valuation had been changed to $178,200.00,
with the land valuation of $40,000 and the building valuation of $138,200.00, as the house was
incomplete.
..
BOARD OF REVIEW
April 5, 1995 - PAGE 2
.
The Councilmembers discussed two particular property valuations. There were no changes made
as a result of this discussion.
The Council considered the recommendations of the Shorewood Assessor's Office to the January
2, 1995 assessment appeals made at the Board's April 5, 1995 meeting as follows:
NAME
.
John and Sue Moore
Amy White
John Bridge
Leroy Kramer
David Schaus
Elden Bechman
David Littlefield
Irene Chanin
Doug Anderson
James Wilson
James Wilson
Bob Rau
Don Kronberg
Mary McNutt-Platzer
Marc Gordon
Laura Berghoff
Dave Peterka
Darlene Da11mann
Jo Cunningham
Beverly Ginther
Dick Logelin
Phobe Harrington
Bingham Brokken
James and Kimberly Eddy
Dave Grove
Robert Manders
Michael and Janes Becker
Bill and Cheryl Vogel
David Froehling
Betty Pfiffner
Diana Pahl
Allen Vanderlinde
Sheldon Sparber
Carrie Tietz
Robert Walz
Margaret Lockovitch
Steve Martin
Paul Kaster
Terrance McNally
Francis Fallon, Jr.
MyrIe-MacKenzie
Donald Bongaards
Mark Kohls
Stephen Tierney
Karl and Patricia Tauscher
.
PROPERTY ID NO.
35-117-23320037
35-117-23330033
29-117 - 23 44 0007
30-117-23330002
36-117-23410055
35-117-23340019
33-117-23 120023
25-117-23440034
36-117-23440071
33-117-2341 0024
33-117-23410025
34-117-23320020
33-117-23-230029
36-117-23 120035
36-117-23440062
29-117-23340005
36-117-2321 0012
26-117-23 140029
31-117-23240010
31-117-23410023
34-117-23230012
34-117-23230038
34-117-23230029
34-117-23320014
30-117-23440014
33-117-23440040
36-117-23440049
26-117-23 140025
34-117-23230052
25-117-23230014
25-117-23230013
33-117-23240031
36-117-23310020
34-117-23440003
25-117-23320048
32-117-23 140032
35-117-23130019
28-117-23330024
25-117-23340020
35-117-23440007
34-117-23310028
28-117-23330028
26-117-23 11 0017
32-117-23 120033
36-117 - 23 44 0054
CHANGE IN ASSESSMENT
Reduce to $200,100
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $242,400
Reduce to $92,100
Reduce to $193,000
Reduce to $138,400
No Change
Increase to $20,000
Reduce to $5,000
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $545,000
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $148,000
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $130,900
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $164,500
No Change
Reduce to $192,900
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $435,000
Reduce to $131,000
Reduce to $267,500
No Change
No ,Change
No Change
.
.
.
..
BOARD OF REVIEW
April 5, 1995 - PAGE 3
NAME
PROPERTY ID NO.
CHANGE IN ASSESSMENT
Gerald and Susan Brokaw 31-117 - 23 44 0004
Robert Jochims 25-117 - 23 22 0049
Stuart and Gail Finney 36-117-23130026
Maud Wadsworth 31-117 - 23 11 0005
Richard Dyer 35-117-23430007
Dick Larson 36-117 - 23 14 0064
Jim and Connie Volling 36-117-23430029
Charles Fox 36-117-23 140059
Roberty Nygaard 30-117-23310002
Naomi Carlson 32-117-23310015
Joanne and Russel Aldrich 26-117-23 11 0030
Peter Fisher 36-227-12430040
Mangala Pai Panandiker 36-117-23 140022
Mark McArthur 36-117 - 23 41 0057
Kenneth and Beatrice Stabeck 25-117-23 32 0041
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $315,000
No Change
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $608,700
No Change
No Change
Reduce to $178,200
No Change
Reduce to $383,300
No Change
No Change
No Change
Stover moved, McCarty seconded to accept and approve all the recommendations
made by the Shorewood Assessor's Office on the residential appeals made at the
April 5, 1995 Board of Review Meeting, to include the addition of property
owned by Naomi Carlson, located at 5955 Cathcart Drive be reduced to
$178,200.00. Motion passed 5/0.
The following people withdrew their request to appear on the local Board list:
NAME
PROPERTY ID NO.
35-117-23420020
31-117-23340004
30-117-23310009
36-117-23 13 0024
34-117 - 23 23 0003
Ray Barton
Frank Fox
Mike McDonald
Judy Sirota
Tony Studer
The following people called in after the initial Board of Review and would like to preserve their
right to further appeal:
Richard Brown
Kristine Thayer
Robert Snyder
Blain Conant
Elizabeth N orthon
Robert and Elevlyn Thompson
33-117-23230047
26-117-23440057
36-117-23 13 0018
32-117-23440017
34-117 - 23 23 0030
36-117-23310016
.
.
.
..
BOARD OF REVIEW
April 5, 1995 - PAGE 4
3. ADJOURNMENT
Benson moved, Malam seconded to adjourn the Board of Review meeting at 7:38
p.m. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULL Y SUBMITTED,
Lorri L. Kopischke
Recording Secretary
TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial
ATTEST:
. It,
" l,t'\i\,~ Ct. ;\./VltVI
JA / ES C. HURM, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
\
I" ..... '\
i I V 1 ,:J.:J'j' ,
'f..,c 1.LJ.---:'\ -!'J.l~ .)LC\..L--
ROBERT B. BEAN, MAYOR