08-13-18 CC WS MinutesCITY OF SHOREWOOD 5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MEETING COUNCIL CHAMBERS
MONDAY, AUGUST 13, 2018 5:30 P.M.
MINUTES
1. CONVENE CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MEETING
Mayor Zerby called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
A. Roll Call
Present, Mayor Zerby; Councilmembers Johnson, Labadie, and Siakel; Planning Commissioners
Gorham, Davis, Eggenberger, Maddy, and Reidel; City Administrator Lerud; Planning
Director Darling; Director of Public Works Brown; Finance Director Rigdon, and City
Engineer Fauske
Absent: Councilmember Sundberg
B. Review Agenda
Labadie moved, Siakel seconded, approving the agenda as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
2. COMP PLAN
A. Transportation
Planning Director Darling explained that the transportation consultant had a family emergency, so she
would be reviewing the PowerPoint slide presentation. She reviewed what was included in the
Transportation Chapter and noted the primary components are the roadway system and the non - motorized
transportation. She explained the roadway system functional classification and access points.
Mayor Zerby noted that he felt that Vine Hill Road, Old Market Road and even Delton Avenue may also
be considered collector roads.
Planning Director Darling explained that will be discussed in the Implementation Chapter and noted that
they are looking to increase the classification of a few roadways. She reviewed the map of the functional
classification, jurisdictions and existing traffic volumes as well as the expected traffic volumes. She
explained the traffic analysis zones that show the number of people and businesses in these areas. She
stated that the non - motorized transportation for the City is essentially the trail system. She gave a very
brief explanation of the existing freight and transit services. She reviewed the next steps: revise function
classification system; CSAH 19 improvements; development of traffic studies; Highway Seven traffic flow;
Smithtown Road /Country Club Road/ Yellowstone Trail /Lake Linden Drive Traffic Committee
Recommendations; Roadway Design and ROW Standards Following Subdivision ordinance; traffic
calming. Traffic device evaluation process; complete street process; sidewalk and trail locations; sidewalk
and trail design.
Mayor Zerby noted that he noticed that CSAH 19 that goes in front of the public safety facility has half the
traffic count as Highway Seven.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
AUGUST 13, 2018
Page 2 of 5
Commissioner Reidel asked about the long -term plans for Highway Seven and whether it can transition
into a freeway at some point.
City Engineer Fauske stated that she knows that MN DOT did an extensive study on it years ago when they
were considering access control. She knows that they have stated that it is a unique corridor and she is not
aware of any plans for widening the road. She has had numerous discussions regarding the intersection at
Church and Minnewashta Parkway and the volumes in that area. The feedback the City has gotten from
MN DOT is that the numbers are not triggering any changes,
Councilmember Siakel stated that she questions the accuracy of some of the numbers regarding traffic
volumes especially with some of the large developments that will be going in.
Councilmember Labadie agrees with Councilmember Siakel and would like to know how long of a time
period was used to determine the road capacity and volume numbers, including what time of the year and
what time of the day the data was gathered. She thinks the school traffic needs to be given consideration
because a study done in July will be very different than a study done during the school year.
Councilmember Johnson stated that the population of our school district between 2012 and now has
increased by over 3,000 students and the majority are due to open enrollment.
Councilmember Labadie stated that she agrees and there are a lot of open enrollees coming to Minnewashta
for Spanish, or driving through to go to Excelsior for Mandarin.
City Engineer Fauske stated that she can check with MN DOT on their protocols for taking the counts.
Councilmember Labadie stated she is more concerned about the traffic counts from the roads that are not
even mentioned such as Church Street, Vine Hill Road, and Eureka Road, for example, that are high traffic
roads.
Commissioner Reidel stated that lie feels technology may greatly change traffic in 20 years. He also stated
that he feels that Highway Seven is a very dangerous road because people drive freeway speeds with
stoplights and open access to the road. He stated that he would be curious to know mortality statistics for
that type of highway versus a freeway.
Mayor Zerby reiterated that he would like them to take a closer look at Delton Avenue.
Public Works Director Brown noted that Delton Avenue is actually named Brahms Boulevard once it enters
Shorewood.
Councilmember Labadie stated that she would like to have all the feeder roads from the western edge of
Highway Seven up to the first stoplight, be considered in totality, because in her opinion, there needs to be
another stoplight in that area.
Public Works Director Brown stated that Chanhassen has been asking MN DOT for a signalized
intersection at Minnewashta Parkway and suggested that perhaps the Council could band together with
Chanhassen and work at lobbying MN DOT. He suggested passing something in resolution form.
Councilmember Johnson stated that he would also like to know what criteria is used for a signal versus a
roundabout.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
AUGUST 13, 2018
Page 3 of 5
B. Surface Water Management
Bill Alms, project manager at WSB gave an overview of the surface water management plan and noted that
it had last been updated in 2008. He noted that because the City is relatively flat, as more development and
redevelopment happen, drainage issues are more prevalent. He reviewed some of the problem areas in the
City, such as the western area including Freeman Park.
Councilmember Johnson stated that he has mentioned before the issue at Freeman Park and dealing with
the Railroad Authority. He had heard from multiple sources that the Railroad Authority will not allow the
City to go in and remove the debris from their ditches that is causing issues. He stated that received a letter
from the Railroad Authority as a gentle reminder not to throw stuff onto their property. He stated that he
called the name listed on the bottom of the letter and talked through the idea of removing some of the dead
vegetation and things that were causing drainage problems. He stated that this individual indicated that
there was an openness from the Railroad Authority to work with the City and the watershed district to help
make that happen.
Mr. Alms reviewed the goals and policies that will be carried over from the 2008 surface water management
plan. He reviewed the priority projects for implementation such as: Freeman Park outlet; outlet for
landlocked Lake Mary; various street reconstruction projects; slope stabilization for Silver Lake; and
projects in conjunction with Minnehaha Creek Watershed District.
Mayor Zerby noted the table in the packet that outlined the priority of the projects lists the first project as
TBD and $100,000. He stated that seems to say that the City does not know what our top priority is. He
noted that the second priority lists storm sewer improvements with a cost of $4.5 million.
Mr. Alms stated that this language can be updated. City Engineer Fauske explained the process and
considerations when staff began to look at the surface water management plan. She stated that the intent
was to provide a placeholder within the plan using the average replacement costs. Mayor Zerby stated that
he has a problem with the general language of those top two items.
Commissioner Reidel stated that it appears that the higher priority items relate to drainage and are probably
things that are complained about the most. He stated that the lower priority items appear to be things related
to water quality improvement. He would like to see this table broken down by what it is targeting in addition
to priority and cost. He noted that he would also like to see a cost /benefit analysis.
Councilmember Siakel stated that her biggest question is whether this is a complete list. She stated that in
her mind the biggest threat to the City is stormwater management. She stated that she does not want it to
become all talk and no action and expressed concern that the City may not be budgeting and planning
appropriately for this area.
Mr. Alms stated that the Riley Purgatory Watershed District has approved the plan and noted that they now
have a fully functioning staff and rules. He stated that in the past they did not have that and the LGU status
was transferred to Minnehaha Creek Watershed District. He stated that they are recommending transferring
that back to the Riley Purgatory Watershed District for the City.
Commissioner Reidel asked about the rules and regulations between the City and the watershed district and
noted that sometimes the City has stricter rules. He stated that he feels that should be coordinated better.
CITE' OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
AUGUST 13, 2018
Page 4 of 5
3. CIP — CONTINUE DISCUSSION
City Engineer Fauske stated that at the last work session, the Council had a brief opportunity to begin
discussion of the Capital Improvement Plan. She explained that staff has gone through and provided the
Council with some additional information that they had requested.
Public Works Director Brown reviewed the rankings and how they change with sealcoating and mill and
overlay. He explained how the pavement ratings were compiled and noted that there are a few discrepancies
because he and City Engineer Fauske were working from different year reports. He discussed the
competing needs of road rebuilding and watermain access. He stated that there are a lot of factors that are
considered in ranking the roads.
Mayor Zerby stated that he noticed some of the discrepancies in the rankings and he does not know how to
interpret the information. He stated for example, the Enchanted roads are listed as a seven in one place and
in the other are listed for consideration of reclamation. He stated that he would like to be able to look at
where the money would be best spent.
Councilmember Siakel stated that there have been many discussions about water hook ups and she believes
that if someone wants water and is willing to sign up, that those projects become priority because it would
help the City reach its goals. She stated that this may relate to the next agenda item but asked whether the
three streets recommended were the best use of the bonding.
City Administrator Lerud explained that the three recommended areas: Glen Road -Amlee Road - Manitou
Road; Woodside Road, and the islands, can be completed with no impact to or from the other projects the
city needs to consider. He noted that in the other areas being considered, there are other factors to be
weighed, such as storm water and sequencing. He stated that the debt service bond was roughly half of
what is currently being set aside for street maintenance each year. The City will continue to be able to
have funds to do additional project. He said this proposal jump starts road reconstruction plans and gives
some time to sequence the other roads.
Councilmember Siakel stated that Mayor Zerby had mentioned something at the last meeting that she now
feels has some validity. He had questioned why the City is spending the money on infrastructure to put in
watermain hook ups and then leaving it up to the residents to choose to hook up or not. She stated that
perhaps the shift needs to be towards making sure there is good drainage and stormwater management rather
than making sure the City installs water hook ups that people are not going to use.
Commissioner Eggenberger asked what the tipping point would be for how many people need to sign up
before water is put in. Councilmember Siakel stated that she believes the current rule is two- thirds of the
residents on the street need to sign up. She thinks this issue warrants more discussion.
Councilmember Labadie stated that at the last meeting, Mayor Zerby talked about some possible incentives
for people to hook up to water. She stated that she would prefer to explore that option rather than penalizing
residents by not putting in the infrastructure. She stated that she would like to look at this with hard numbers
and consider incentive -based programs.
4. WATER CONNECTIONS
City Administrator Lerud noted that the next work session on August 23, 2018 is scheduled for discussion
of the operating budget and CIP. He suggested that because there was not time at this meeting to discuss
this item, that it be put on the August 23 work discussion for discussion.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
AUGUST 13, 2018
Page 5 of 5
5. ADJOURN
Johnson moved, Labadie seconded, Adjourning the City Council Work Session Meeting of August
13, 2018, at 7:00 P.M. Motion passed 4/0.