09-11-12 PK MINS
CITY OF SHOREWOOD 5755 COUNTRY CLUB RD
PARK COMMISSION MEETING SHOREWOOD CITY HALL
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2012 7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
1.CONVENE PARK COMMISSION MEETING
Chair Quinlan convened the meeting at 7:00 p.m.
A.Roll Call
Present: Chair Quinlan; Commissioners Edmondson, Kjolhaug, Swaggert,
;
Hartmann, Gordon, and MangoldCity Planner Nielsen, and
Finance Director DeJong
Absent: None
B.Review Agenda
Commissioner Edmondson moved to approve the agenda as written. Commissioner Mangold
seconded the motion. Motion carried.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Park Commission Meeting Minutes of August 15, 2012
Commissioner Gordon moved to approve the minutes of the August 15, 2012 meeting as
written. Commissioner Mangold seconded the motion. Motion carried.
3. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
None
4. PICKLEBALL PRESENTATION BY DAVID WARNER
Commissioner Quinlan noted Councilmember Woodruff has invited David Warner to discuss the
game of pickleball. He requested Warner provide insights on the game and what would need to
be provided. Nielsen presented a video on the game being played. Woodruff introduced Mr.
Warner who is the 65+ pickleball gold medalist in Florida. He also introduced Jerry Maas who
is the southwest metro pickleball ambassador. Warner stated the game can be played by elderly
people who aren’t normally active. He stated most of the play can be done on existing tennis
courts which are dual-lined, and portable nets are used. Quinlan asked what would be required
to convert a tennis court. Warner stated additional lines are all that is needed. The pickleball
nets are two inches shorter than regulation tennis net. Something would be needed to bring the
nets down two inches or portable nets used. He stated paddles and balls are relatively
inexpensive. He stated two pickleball courts can be placed on each tennis court. Warner noted a
lock box can be installed at the court where the nets and equipment can be held until someone
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2012
5
PAGE 2 OF
wants to play. Maas explained how a few people have grown to a 163-member pickleball club in
Eden Prairie. Maas stated it is not expensive to paint the lines on the tennis courts. In response
to a question from Quinlan, Maas stated pickleball does not play well on the versa-court type
surface. Gordon asked if this is something that would appeal to a younger demographic or is it
better suited toward older people. Maas stated he did not think it was better suited toward a
certain demographic. He stated the older residents are more available during the day to play
when others are at work or in school. He noted the Bloomington high schools have pickleball as
a course. Quinlan believed it was something that should be considered. Nielsen stated they have
a call into the tennis court manufacturer to see if it can be dual striped for pickleball. Mass
invited the Commission to come to Eden Prairie to talk to players. Mangold believed that now is
the time to start preparing for pickleball. Kjolhaug stated we should take every opportunity to
consider any case when multiple uses are options.
5. REVIEW PRICING FOR FENCING AT COMMUNITY GARDEN
Quinlan stated we had talked about the idea of providing fencing to border the community garden
and directed staff to come back with additional information on the cost of fencing. Nielsen stated
there were two quotes received for 5’ and 6’ fences. He has plugged $5,000 into the CIP should this
be approved. He was still unaware if sales tax is included. Nielsen stated a deer can jump a 5’
fence just as easily as they can a 6’ fence. He stated he liked the look of the 5’ fence. He stated the
larger gate would be at the short end, and the person gate would be in the longer section. In
response to a question about future expansion, Nielsen stated it could easily be expanded. He
discussed the size of the area which would be fenced. He stated if the $5000 amount is left in the
CIP, it can be discussed in the spring how big it should be. Kjolhaug stated he had talked to a
gardener in Excelsior who believed the plots are too small in Shorewood. Nielsen stated he would
have staff do a survey of plot sizes.
Commissioner Hartmann moved to recommend allocating $5,000 for purchase of a fence for
the community garden contingent on determining plot sizes for the spring. Commissioner
Swaggert seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
6.2013 CIP
Quinlan stated the allocation for improvements need to be reviewed this evening. He noted the
$5,000 needs to be added for the fence. DeJong discussed additions for Manor Park including
the construction of a well, the versa court purchase needs and improvements to Badger Park.
Gordon asked if the warming house repair is in 2014. DeJong agreed that was the proposal.
Nielsen stated that $60,000 is earmarked for Silverwood Park equipment, and it appeared to him
on the tour it was in good shape. Commissioners discussed playground equipment replacement.
Nielsen suggested the Building Inspector inspect all the equipment in the parks. Quinlan asked if
the building needs to be repainted. Nielsen stated the Building Inspector could include that in his
review. Nielsen stated it may be more of a maintenance item rather than a CIP item. Kjolhaug
asked if the asphalt trail sealing is showing up on a maintenance budget. Nielsen stated it would
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2012
5
PAGE 3 OF
be researched as well. Kjolhaug stated there is nothing earmarked for the Cathcart basketball
court. Nielsen stated that could be researched. Quinlan stated there should also be a line item
for resurfacing the court. DeJong stated the resurfacing for the court was $2100 and was
included with the tennis court and has been completed. Hartmann suggested the Badger Park
green space and swing set be moved out. Nielsen stated the intent was it would be a place holder
but move it out further once you take a look at the plan. Kjolhaug suggested parking for Gideon
Glen. Quinlan stated we need parking, but he was unsure of what is going on with Smithtown
Crossing where parking would be located. Nielsen stated staff could take a look at whether
parking was ever considered there. They could sketch some area where parking might be a
possibility. He stated it is fairly unusable other than by bike or foot. He stated it has been
brought up on more than one occasion. He stated a parking lot there would not be large.
Edmondson was concerned about a bus going in there and being able to turn around. Nielsen
stated that would be taken into account. Gordon stated signage is also needed. Nielsen stated it
would seem appropriate to have some kind of signage. He stated he would work out numbers for
the parking lot and signage. He stated the options for parking are quite limited. Nielsen
discussed plans for Gideon Glen and Smithtown Crossing.
Hartmann suggested the amounts for the hockey rink be amended. She believed it should be
increased to $200,000 for both of them. Commissioners discussed the amounts suggested for
Badger and Freeman hockey rinks. It was the consensus to amend the amounts to $200,000.
Commissioner Swaggert recommended to approve all changes to the CIP (eliminate the
tennis court lighting, eliminate Freeman Park hockey rink and raising Badger Court up to
$200,000, add parking lot for Gideon Glen and signage, and backboard for Cathcart), and
Commissioner Kjolhaug seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
Hartmann believed the motion needed to be more specific, and the Commission discussed this
item in detail. DeJong discussed his plan to take a budget amendment to the City Council. He
noted the backboards can be included in the amendment. He stated it could be added for this
year.
Commissioner Kjolhaug moved to reconsider the previous motion, and Commissioner
Edmondson seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
Gordon asked how something can be added to the CIP if we don’t know how much it will cost.
Quinlan stated we can make an estimate. If we know we want the item, we should include it.
Nielsen reviewed what was discussed and included in the CIP: Cathcart backboards, Gideon
Glen parking, bus turnaround and sign, and adjustment of numbers for Badger Park and
eliminated numbers for Freeman. The cost of the Cathcart backboards and Gideon Glen parking
and sign are not known. Swaggert encouraged the Commission to discuss each item by year
and questioned how close we needed to be for future years. Nielsen stated we try to be close,
and next year should be accurate. He stated the unknowns can be determined easily. Swaggert
stated if we decide it should be 2013 then we should determine the cost. If we want it in another
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2012
5
PAGE 4 OF
year, then we don’t need to hammer it out. Commissioners and staff discussed the unknown
items. Nielsen stated staff will get the numbers prior to its final adoption and in time for the Park
Commission to review again. Commissioners discussed whether the bridge and rustic trail in
2014 should be moved to 2013. It was agreed to move it to 2013.
Commissioner Swaggert moved to approve the changes added, Hartmann seconded the
motion which carried unanimously.
7.DISCUSS WINTER AND SUMMER (2013) ACTIVITIES
Commissioners received a summary of summer activities for 2012. He asked the Commissioner
to consider any larger activities for the summer. He suggested having Music in the Parks again
with catering. They also discussed: Movie in the Park, talent show, making surrounding cities
aware of what is going on, having more family events, theatre events, band performances,
partnering with the St. Paul Chamber, and carnival or circus event. It was generally agreed there
should be some kind of cornerstone event in the summer. Nielsen stated it is important to make
the decisions as early as possible in order to get the best performers and advertise in plenty of
time. Quinlan stated discussion will continue at the next meeting.
8.DETERMINE PARK COMMISSION DATE FOR NOVEMBER
Quinlan noted the Council will meet on November 13 due to Veterans Day on Monday,
November 12.
Commissioner Gordon moved to move the November meeting to Wednesday, November
14. Swaggert seconded the motion which carried unanimously.
9.NEW BUSINESS
None
10. STAFF AND LIAISON REPORTS/UPDATES
A. City Council
Nielsen noted the Comp Plan amendment is moving forward. All Park Commission recommendations
have been approved by the City Council.
B. Staff
Nielsen stated we are still trying to complete the rustic trail. Commissioner Mangold has offered to do
some Bobcat work to get the work done.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2012
5
PAGE 5 OF
14. ADJOURN
Commissioner Swaggert moved, Commissioner Hartmann seconded, to adjourn the Park
Commission Meeting of September 11, 2012, at 9:15 p.m. Motion carried.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Clare T. Link
Recorder