HomeMy WebLinkAbout020822 Park Minutes
CITY OF SHOREWOOD 5755 COUNTRY CLUB RD
PARK COMMISSION MEETING SHOREWOOD CITY HALL
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022 7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
1. CONVENE PARK COMMISSION MEETING
Chair Hirner convened the meeting at 7:00 p.m.
A. Roll Call
Present: Chair Hirner, Commissioners Gallivan, Heinz, Tauer, and Schmid
(arrived at 7:13 p.m.); City Council Liaison Callies; City
Administrator Lerud; Parks and Recreation Director Grout; and
Planning Director Darling
Absent: None
B. Review Agenda
Heinz moved to approve the agenda as written. Tauer seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote:
Ayes – all. Motion carried 4-0.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Park Commission Meeting Minutes of October 26, 2021
Tauer moved to approve the minutes of the October 26, 2021 meeting as presented. Gallivan
seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Motion carried 3-0-1 (Gallivan abstained).
3. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were none.
4. NEW BUSINESS
A. Review Christmas Lake Access Ordinance
City Administrator Lerud review some of the history and background surrounding public access
area on Christmas Lake and the work staff has done with the Christmas Lake Homeowners
Association (CLHA). He gave a brief overview of the agreements signed with the DNR in 1986
and 2015 for cooperation and maintenance of the public access and explained that it is the City’s
responsibility to maintain the access. He noted that last year, the City approved a site plan
amendment and variance will free up one parking space and allow the cleaning equipment to sit
off the space which led them to take a look at what is happening with parking, overall. He
explained that with regard to loading of the lake, the recommended amount is 20-30 acres/boat
to preserve the ecology of the lake, reduce the number of near misses, allow for a complete and
more thorough inspection. He gave an overview of the proposed amendments to the ordinance
and reviewed points such as; the landing is considered a park area, proper disposal of bait, no
overnight parking, and limiting the number of boats that can use the landing to the number of
parking spots available in the landing area. He noted that there is a gate there that has not worked
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 2 OF 7
for many years but has been repaired and is functional again. He stated that the proposal is to
increase the number of spots available for vehicles with personal watercraft, such as kayaks, but
limited to 7 spots for boats on trailers that are allowed in the lake at any one time.
Chair Hirner asked about the calculation of 20-30 acres/boat and if that took into consideration
the number of boats from the people who live on the lake, because that would end up being
significantly above the threshold and asked how that is factored into the conversation about safety
on the lake. City Administrator Lerud stated that the City does not have control of the number of
watercraft on the lake at any time. He explained that the only control that they would have would
be that the City is responsible for the landing.
Chair Hirner confirmed that the 7 parking spots refer to a boat and trailer parking and asked what
would happen if there were 14 cars with kayaks. He asked if it would be limited to just 7 vehicles
or if the larger number would be allowed to park there because there is space. City Administrator
Lerud stated that the ordinance allows them to park in those spots if one is available.
The Commission discussed details of the proposed ordinance and details surrounding use of the
gate and AIS inspections. Joe Schneider, CLHA, explained that they begin inspections as close
st
to ice-out as possible and continue through October 31 of every year and explained how they
taper the hours at various times of the year.
Council Liaison Callies stated that the CLHA sets the inspection times and asked that would work
if the City ended up hiring a part-time position for this purpose. City Administrator Lerud explained
that the Council had approved a DNR Delegation Agreement which commits the City to doing the
AIS work on behalf of the DNR. He stated that in turn, the City works with the CLHA and they
hire a contractor and agree to perform the inspection services that the City has committed to doing
under the Delegation Agreement.
Commissioner Gallivan asked what kind of engagement there has been with the CLHA regarding
this ordinance. City Administrator Lerud stated that the City has had extensive conversations with
representatives from the HOA and they are in support of the ordinance.
Commissioner Schmid arrived at 7:13 p.m.
Peter Lehman, 21285 Radisson Road and 21265 Radisson Road, explained that he lives adjacent
to the public access and has been there since 1986 when the public access was created. He
stated that he is not against anything in the ordinance, but there are some things that he believes
should be considered, for example, the possible side effect from these restrictions to the times
when boats, such as pontoons are transferred. He stated that he is concerned about the
occasional lines that form along Merry Lane for the AIS inspection and asked what would happen
to those boats when the access is closed. He explained that currently they would go through the
AIS inspection and then could park off site if this lot is full. He stated that when the gate is closed,
it will be difficult for a boat with a trailer to back out, if they got there and the lot was full. He noted
that his other concern is that many homeowners do not have their own pontoon trailers so the
contract companies end up staging boats along Merry Lane on concrete blocks during this
process. He stated that he is concerned about the effect this may have on traffic flow or
emergency vehicle access in the area. He reiterated that he is not against the ordinance but is a
bit concerned about the potential side effect on Merry Lane from not allowing boats to pass
through because of the gate.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 3 OF 7
City Administrator Lerud stated that they have talked about it this issue. He noted that they do
not have a solution yet but have discussed things like having some type of advance notice out by
the frontage road that shows how many parking spaces are available. He gave the example of
the electronic signs that are sometimes seen at rest areas that let people know how many spaces
there are, so the boats/trailers should not end up lining up on Merry Lane when there is no room.
Mr. Schneider stated that if this ordinance is approved there will need to be a fair amount of
communication with the community. He stated that he likes City Administrator Lerud’s idea about
utilizing electronic signage and explained that the CLHA would be happy to be involved in that
effort. He noted that the CLHA is also committed to getting more cameras up at the landing. He
noted that he feels that Mr. Lehman’s concern about the transferring of pontoons won’t be a large
issue because it does not happen during the busy season on the lake because they happen in
May and then September/October at the beginning and end of the season.
Mr. Lehman noted that he would like the staging of the pontoon transfers to take place inside the
public access in the vacant bays rather than along Merry Lane. He stated that the new area that
is being set up for the power washer is less than 100 feet from his beach and would prefer, if there
is an expansion of the public access, that the City consider relocating that equipment to the west
side.
Chair Hirner asked staff to take note of the preference from Mr. Lehman if the topic of expansion
comes up in the future. Planning Director Darling stated that she can but noted that when the
Council granted the variance for the existing location, there were several reasons why the
alternative location recommended by Mr. Lehman did not work. Mr. Lehman stated that he had
proposed another location on the island and now he is asking that it be considered because there
seems to be an interest in acquiring additional land.
City Administrator Lerud clarified that this would not be additional land and is land that the City is
already occupying with the landing. The acquisition would just be transferring it into the City’s
name. Mr. Lehman stated that he believes he saw 4 parking spots for single vehicles penciled in
on the engineering drawing and explained that his idea was that if there are additional parking
pads constructed, they should be considered for the power washing equipment.
Gallivan moved to recommend approval of Ordinance 576, An ordinance Establishing
Section 902.05, Subdivision 4 of the Code of Ordinances, Establishing Regulations for the
Christmas Lake Boat Landing and Adjacent Parking Lot. Heinz seconded the motion. Roll
Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion carried.
B. Review and Discuss Donation for a Bench at Freeman Park
Chair Hirner gave an overview of the request by Charles Babcock to donate a bench for Freeman
Park so people could watch their children go sledding. He noted that he had gone to take a look
at a similar bench to what is being proposed that is being used in Deephaven and felt that it looked
good, seemed sturdy, and also seemed to be holding up really well.
Parks and Recreation Director Grout asked if the Mr. Babcock was aware that a concrete slab
would also need to be installed with the bench.
Chair Hirner noted that he had brought that issue up to Mr. Babcock.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 4 OF 7
Commissioner Heinz stated that as long as the bench reflected the high quality of the City’s park
system, he would support accepting this donation. He noted that he would like to make sure that
moving forward that these things are consistent with the image the City is trying to protect.
Chair Hirner stated that someone from the City will need to let Mr. Babcock know what the cost
of the concrete slab would be if he is expected to cover those costs as well. He stated that before
the bench is ordered the color should be checked to ensure it fits in with what the City would like.
Planning Director Darling noted that the concrete slab work may be quite expensive and will likely
have to be combined with another larger project in order to get the work completed.
Chair Hirner asked if the Commission should table action until all the details discussed regarding
concrete slab costs and design consistency are ironed out with Mr. Babcock.
Planning Director Darling asked the Commission how they felt about accepting an atypical park
bench.
Commissioner Heinz reiterated that he feels the City should be consistent with the amenities that
are put into the park.
Commissioner Tauer stated that in her opinion, the bench needs to match the integrity of the park,
but does not necessarily need to be identical to the other benches. She gave the example of
eyebrows, which are sisters, but not twins. She stated that she thinks things can still look nice
throughout the park, but look a bit different, because that can bring something special to the park.
Commissioner Gallivan stated that he thinks the City needs to be consistent with things such as
color, but thinks a slightly different style would not bother him.
Commissioner Schmid stated that she would like it to blend in with the other benches in the area.
Chair Hirner stated that this bench is likely to be the only one that is over in this area on the edge
of the parking lot, so there will be nothing else around it. He stated that he does not think the
proposed bench is completely out of character from the park, but would agree that the City may
want to have a say in the color of the bench. He reminded the Commission that a similar bench
to what is being proposed can be seen in Deephaven. He suggested that perhaps the other
information such as the color and cost for the concrete pad be reviewed with Mr. Babcock before
this moves onto the Council. He stated that he would like to continue this item to a future agenda
in order to have that conversation with Mr. Babcock so they have a complete picture of the cost
that will be related to the donation.
Hirner moved to table discussion of the donation of a bench at Freeman Park until the
March 2022 Park Commission meeting. Gallivan seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote:
Ayes – all. Motion carried.
C. Discuss Options for Southshore Community Park
Chair Hirner noted that he would like the Commission to discuss options and ideas for Southshore
Community Park. He reviewed some of the ideas that came out of the survey such as pickleball
or a splash pad and whether the focus should be on being family friendly or focus on seniors.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 5 OF 7
Commissioner Gallivan stated that given the proximity to the highway, the idea of making this into
a playground or large scale project is not appealing. He stated that the 2 best options that stand
out to him beyond expanding the community garden, is either the pickleball courts or some of the
senior equipment that has been considered in the past.
Commissioner Heinz stated that he agrees that anything that is done in this location should be
more adult oriented.
Chair Hirner asked about the trees along the highway and what their expected lifespan is because
if they are nearing the end of that cycle it may open up what can be done with this park.
Planning Director Darling explained that pine trees usually have a lifespan of 40-70 years, but she
is not sure when those were planted. She stated that she can go back through the aerial photos
and try to determine their general age.
Chair Hirner stated that he feels the City should take a look at what some options may be for
providing a barrier between the park and the highway, such as a fence or sound wall. He stated
that he agreed with the recommendation that the focus remain more adult oriented and likes the
idea of pickleball courts.
The Commission discussed ideas of additional usage options that may be appropriate for this
park considering its proximity to the highway.
Planning Director Darling noted that this is just a continuing discussion item for the Commission
and explained that the City is not scheduled to begin doing the Master Plan until 2024.
D. 2022 Work Schedule/Park Meeting Schedule
Chair Hirner reviewed the 2022 Work Program Schedule for Commission action and asked if there
was anything the Commissioners would like to add.
Commissioner Heinz explained that he has been working on a way to keep the City’s park on the
top of the list for attractiveness and usage. He explained that he has been doing interviews in the
City parks and has gotten very interesting feedback and would be happy to present his information
at an upcoming meeting.
Park and Recreation Director Grout suggested that it be put on the agendas for discussion in
March and/or April.
Chair Hirner stated that he would like to discuss this information prior to conducting the park tours
because he believes the information gathered may be helpful to those conversations during the
tours.
Tauer moved to approve the 2022 Work Program, as revised, and the Park Commission
meeting schedule as proposed. Gallivan seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all.
Motion carried.
E. Determine Liaisons for City Council Meetings
February 28, 2022 – Commissioner Gallivan
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 6 OF 7
March 14, 2022 – Commissioner Tauer
April 25, 2022 - Commissioner Schmid
F. Accept the 2022 Concession Agreement
Park and Recreation Director Grout gave an overview on the history of concession services being
provided by members of the Withum family.
Heinz moved to recommend approval of the 2022 Concession Agreement, as presented.
Tauer seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion carried.
5. OLD BUSINESS
A. Senior Programs
Park and Recreation Director Grout reminded the Commission that she had reached out to
Mound, Chaska, Eden Prairie, Victoria, and Minnetonka about what senior programming they
have available in their parks. She reviewed the information that she found out from each city as
outlined in the October 26, 2021 staff report. She reviewed some of the programs that the City
has held in the parks in the past. She asked if the Commission had suggestions for other
programs that could be tried for the seniors.
Commissioner Heinz noted that the Music in the Park was well attended by the senior
demographic.
Chair Hirner reviewed some of the activities that are available in the senior community where his
father-in-law lives.
Park and Recreation Director Grout reviewed some of the groups and activities available at the
senior center, such as a knitting group, cribbage, woodworking.
Chair Hirner stated that they also had things like tai chi, yoga, and other more outdoor activities.
He noted that perhaps those could be organized via the park rather than with the other activities
at the senior center.
Park and Recreation Director Grout noted that they do offer pickleball lessons at Badger Park.
She stated that they have had tai chi in the past, but there was not enough interest to continue
that activity, but she is open to trying some of these activities again and see if the interest has
increased.
Commissioner Tauer stated that she likes the idea of doing some sunrise yoga classes during the
warmer months, and suggested that it be more ‘community’ focused than just ‘senior’
programming.
Chair Hirner stated that he also likes the idea of creating a walking group, for example, at Freeman
Park.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2022
PAGE 7 OF 7
Park and Recreation Director Grout stated that she will check into some of these ideas and see
about getting them scheduled at the parks.
6. STAFF AND LIAISON REPORTS / UPDATES
A. City Council
Council Liaison Callies gave an overview of recent City Council activities.
B. Staff
a. Update on Grant for Freeman Field 2 Fencing
Park and Recreation Director Grout noted that the City had received a grant for Freeman Park
Field 2 to fix the footings and the fencing which will take place this coming spring.
b. Update on January 15, 2022 Arctic Fever Event
Park and Recreation Director Grout reported that Arctic Fever was held on January 15, 2022.
She stated that there was a really nice turnout from the public for this event and noted that there
demonstrations on outdoor camping and a story stroll that were new this year.
Chair Hirner asked when the contractor would finish the work at Silverwood Park.
Planning Director Darling stated that they do not have a timeline yet because it is still pretty early
in the year. She explained that she knows it will be one of their first projects in order to finish the
install of the swing sets and the awnings. She stated that she will be working with engineering to
finish the improvements so the slides can be installed.
7. ADJOURN
Tauer moved to adjourn the Park Commission Meeting of February 8, 2022 at 8:58 p.m.
Schmid seconded the motion. Roll Call Vote: Ayes – all. Motion carried.