HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-13-24 CC Reg Mtg Agenda PacketQuestions received regarding the Proposed Sign Regulations:
Why is the ordinance being adopted with no public comment at tonight's meeting?
State statute and the City Code requires the planning commission to hold a public meeting when
ordinance amendments are being considered. That meeting was held on March 19,2024. The planning
commission is tasked with accepting public comments and considering those comments when they make
their recommendation to the City Council. In addition to the public hearing, the Planning Commission
also discussed the potential sign code amendments at the following meetings:
March 19, 2024: Planning Commission held a public hearing.
February 6, 2024: Planning Commission discussed the entire ordinance.
December 5, 2023: Planning Commission discussed general and commercial sign regulations.
May 2, 2023: Planning Commission discussed potential residential sign regulations.
February 1, 2023: Planning Commission discussed the issues with the sign regulations.
Why not have a different process for ordinance amendments that starts at the City Council, with a
public forum and ends with a final public hearing?
The issues with the sign code are complex and were brought to the forefront by a resident as being
problematic. Over two years ago, these regulations were moved closer to the top of the City Council's
priority list for that reason. The changes are proposed to protect the city and the residents' tax dollars
from lawsuits which the city can't win based on the age and structure of the current code. Staff tried to
keep the impacts to residents at a minimum while correcting the issues with the codes. Staff followed
the city's known procedures for amending the code.
Improve the ordinance's user friendliness through its structure and format. Make carveouts easier to
find and track so that residents don't have to read the entire code only to find out it does not apply to
them. Provide hyperlinks and index like Victoria does to make it easier to find things.
The ordinance is a draft ordinance and changes with each public meeting and hearing. Due to these
changes, staff has not included hyperlinks with drafts in the past. Victoria's codes are adopted into their
code of ordinances and their codification service adds the hyperlinks. Shorewood's codification services
will provide links when the ordinance is incorporated into the Code of Ordinances.
Does Shorewood even have to have a sign code?
Yes. While the sign regulations are not required by statute, their presence creates the suburban
environment that the residents in Shorewood have long enjoyed.
The substitution clause is hard to understand, why not leave it out?
The substitution clause is imperative. It helps the city to avoid claims that the ordinance favor
commercial signs over noncommercial messages or discriminate against one noncommercial message
over another. In these times of endless court challenges, the city must protect itself against the
countless frivolous lawsuits that its own citizens submit.
The city has not tasked anyone with enforcement.
Untrue. While the city may not have a full-time proactive code enforcement staff person, many staff are
involved in enforcing the city's code, including planning and protective inspections staff, administrative
staff, and public works staff.
A couple of years ago, the City Council revised the sign ordinance restricting citizens' rights to display
their own non-commercial signs, even when those signs are own their own property, while
simultaneously increasing commercial entities rights to advertise on rights -of -ways.
Untrue. The city has not initiated any amendments to this effect. Shorewood's regulations are becoming
clearer and more open to noncommercial speech. In the past, Shorewood did not allow any
noncommercial signs outside of the election period. It did allow an owner occupant sign with two
square feet and one holiday sign up to 32 square feet. Because of the Reed court decision, the city did
not enforce having more signage up to 3 square feet because the potential connection between
directional signs (which could be construed as allowed) but are a sign typically approved on commercial
and other nonresidential properties.
Citizens cannot place non-commercial signs within a certain distance to public roads, even if their
property runs right up to the road, but businesses are free to do so.
Untrue. The city allows residents to place signs on their property at any time. Any resident or property
owner may place a noncommercial sign as close as five feet to the street during any election period.
Noncommercial signs outside of an election period must be five feet back from the front property line.
Commercial signs are not permitted in the public rights -of -way and are limited in application to
residential properties. Just because business owners put the signs in the rights -of -way, doesn't mean
they've asked for permission or are allowed. City staff removes them frequently as we see them.
Why not allow businesses to have signs on residential properties? Residents on their private property
should be allowed to place a small number of commercial signs. Many residents with small businesses
would benefit from this.
This was a community decision long ago. Home -based businesses were allowed within the community if
they were invisible, and the residential feel of the area preserved. Other commercial signs are limited
because the community decided to keep residential areas residential. Thus, people that work for
corporations can't place their corporate signage on their property nor rent their property for commercial
signage applications.
The proposed ordinance seems to ban Christmas decorations and signage.
Christmas and other holiday decorations are not banned. Signage is regulated, not decor. Everyone is
Shorewood can still install the earth flags, bent over grannies with the bloomers showing, coffins with
skeletons slipping out, etc. Residents can use their two 15-day allowance for larger signs whenever they
want: for holidays, elections, neighbor disputes, ugly divorces, etc. but just one at a time.
Private property lawn signs are free speech.
Agreed. The proposed ordinance puts limits on the total amount of signage that residents can install,
but residents may install them up to that amount. Staff has driven through Shorewood and there are
few properties with more than three square feet of signage installed and staff has only seen one larger
sign decoration at Christmas and that was several years ago.
Theft of signs should be identified as deprivation of free speech rights and should be included in this
ordinance.
The criminal code addresses crimes. Similarly, if one neighbor lights off fireworks that burns down
another's shed, the zoning ordinance does not ban fireworks.
Signs in the right of way.
Staff has heard comments on both sides of allowing signs in the rights of way. Staff recommend that the
city preserve the rights -of -way for all the people of Shorewood and not allow the City's rights to the area
become compromised with private improvements.
Enforce the traffic visibility code.
The traffic visibility code is located in section 1201.03 Subd. 2 h. These regulations pertain to corners
and preserving visibility at corners. The sign code refers to these regulations throughout the code. The
public works department clears corners as allowed with other duties. Complaints on traffic visibility may
be reported through See Click Fix, or by calling the front desk at 952-960-7900.
Ron Goetz
5790 Echo Road
Resident 2003
Presentati n Obilective:
Inform of the profound impacts the lacrosse field has on my property and propose
suggestions on how to mitigate said issues.
Immediate proposed actions to reduce noise issue:
-Field lights turn off at 9pm(minimum week nights)
-instruct coaches to use the north end of the field for all Y2field drills
-Restrict scheduled practices/games one Saturday per month & 1 night per week
-Reduce the number of games on weekends to avoid 12 hour straight noise irritatio
-Restrict 12 hour straight games on weekends
Other solutions:
-Install acoustic fence the length of the south end of the lacrosse field
-Install a noise barrier (berm) on the south end of the lacrosse field(I will donate
property for redesign of path if needed).
At issu :
High decibels of noise created by the following:
Spectators of games
Whistles related to games
Over -zealous Coaches
Screams/yells from random users of the field
Large music speakers from random users of the field
12 hrs straight of games at extreme noise decibels
Lacrosse balls nestled in my lawn created a danger when mowing
History I. contacts to city regarding noise issues:
- 5/1/18 initial in -person contact to discuss noise levels issue with Marie
Darling(Planning Director at that time)
- 6/12/18 addressed city council regarding field noise
- 7/6/18 city installed trees on my property line to create a noise barrier
- 7/16/18 flawed sound test was done on a mid afternoon weekday
- 9/26/22 contact Marie regarding noise issue
- 9/18/23 in -person contact with Jason Carlson (Plan ni ng Technician) regardi
extreme noise levels coming from the now football practices/games
,W20123 emailed Jason and did not receive a response
•
0642-18 CC Reg Mtg Minutes
6 P D F 8.53 A x 1019 in
lift
Zoom Top~ If View Plain ex
rVIi
it Nil IL 2011{
MW 2 d'N
M0EMzMrMTMM=EB
3. NIATTFR`k FROM Fj(W)R
Ht'r ( i. wit. 5 7�0 ld . �j' I !g he JH, 't" -11 j� 't rIc4 -'aaf: t a --ad IE,x1`lailo 111 , 1 fit C
1 Mv hr %OHM AW I 1 mdWe Wd c*j h- &A awj,,Irtq k j. il b.I-A fii Ivt dt, titq
hav�LLI Aranixt""IN Ica:W0 410 ro,'k Ko.�i
k-11 Nximic c!,'Ihv po,itbn MAw God aW W p, Am k y X, r,", W, , t�
tl�k k,
1,0AWO We"dwa NMI Q ome A= a =low gme MAMI Wenmy pzmc
and srtc utliinaiE to I %kh blWanwrjou Inn wag Welt v"WWW"W
M owl! 0 A pta"Myt
—fic ,Gwt In (lei °ct the k • 'c' h�Iv the hlcr"'e Ge""i III "Gi.
"IdA -, Out %0*' ahk-'w
M xUaw mum, Vitae IWAIWWOWI; ha, IXVI "Wild %XaLW t0d,
n vM cleov a MAO mafh"�.
Urn My- QAd danvmd Mnitbg lhwy� lboogwid Awity c.mcup shh,Ira NSON,
MA C�a,
Owmin; no. ax the C ooadtnaw vy k" W" Q. A"M vkwc Th"Waf
Hut %in M IN 4mfj"t� 1 sl,'f c-4' tttolic it, planwnw r- -.H't IN—,
tls-x;ftva to Ilctf! +i6'cat, up the lice iint-
mw hate &,k:r Loadw a0ced lKnnne hwN hd on om"i Mr uvcv>, tvjxriv
heNtAl wMeOfIcir lit, pir,?vrl=Hromo; ea,i,,it I ke11�. III, itliet,', t�tj:tj he 1,1,
oi pr.'jertih-
labadictik--if il.,11 the j,':L pht,fic
MYN Al I1V 1 101. IM: ntACd AlICtC NIA lit-11 ,tik, beif flw,.\,H lHev
,t vd Jut N-, hi4J—k WIFy FW retie "hm K m.H& them
(OMy;?WCMice Lormn M40 I, W no, A v: (�;rvnoavclv M wm"4 me 11— WqWWd I, in inme,
Q Unit sr. tcki that the 1x,mc ttv hN nM k a m0l Wme, ar,.l the j-,ilvru :sn fi�•n Itc 3&cnl
wlee t1r PIANIv'wO k ptal III jlftice' tic Nlafc-d 0111 1.4- 406 a k Wy 0% ham" ma &W a MOW
the Oart,.1 �.vm, n, Amno W to hmel --C�a- --fthouph—he 'nloi I'vit Ole That
ltlr'v'ro rf'H 'wit ha n th,:can I:-7r i'%- r0cf. ji
41 111,141.1v IIFARFN(i - N"Mr
k REPOR IF% A14111 PRUSENTATRINS - %ttntv
PARKS - Nanc
PLANN11%
GO to Go
UW study: Exposure to chemical 'in
91
Roundup mincreases risk for cancer
Jackson Holtz
UW News February 23, 2019
Exposure to glyphosate — the world's most widely used, broad-spectrum herbicide and
the primary ingredient in the weedkiller Roundup — increases the risk of some cancers
by more than 40 percent, according to new research from the University of Washington,
Various reviews and international assessments have come to different conclusions about
whether glyphosate leads to cancer in humans.
The research team conducted an updated meta -analysis — a comprehensive review of
existing literature — and focused on the most highly exposed groups in each study. They
found that the link between glyphosate and Non -Hodgkin Lymphoma is stronger than
previously reported.
Their findings were published this month in the online journal Mutation
Research/Reviews in Mutation Research.
"Our analysis focused on providing the best possible answer to the question of whether
or not glyphosate is carcinogenic," said senior author Lianne Sheppard, a professor in
the UW departments of Environmental & Occupational Health Sciences and Biostatistics.
"As a result of this research, I am even more convinced that it is."
By examining epiderniologic studies published between 2001 and 2018, the team
determined that exposure to glyphosate may increase the risk of Non -Hodgkin
Lymphoma by as much as 41 percent. The authors focused their review on
epidemiological research in humans but also considered the evidence from laboratory
animals.
"This research provides the most up-to-date analysis of glyphosate and its link with Non -
Hodgkin Lymphoma, incorporating a 2018 study of more than 54,000 people who work
as licensed pesticide applicators," said co-author Rachel Shaffer, a UW doctoral student
in the Department of Environmental & Occupational Health Sciences.
"These findings are aligned with a prior assessment from the International Agency for
Research on Cancer, which classified glyphosate as a'probable human carcinogen' in
2015," Shaffer said.
Glyphosate first was introduced as an herbicide in 1974. Usage in the agricultural
industry has soared, particularly since the mid-2000s when the practice of "green
burndown" was introduced, in which glyphosate-based herbicides are applied to crops
shortly before harvest. As a consequence, crops now are likely to have higher residues
of glyphosate.
Researchers say more studies are needed to account for the effects of increased
,*xposures from green bumdown, which may not be fully captured in the existing studies
reviewed in this new publication.
Co-authors include Luoping Zhang and lemaan Rana in the Division
Berkeley,Health Sciences at the University of California,
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York.
Funding was provided by the National Institutes of Environmental Health Sciences
award T32ESO 1151459 and the University of Washington Retirement Association Aging
Fellowship.
y Mari Baines Ooe,�Zv;cj Mike Cetera
Roundup, the most popular and profitable weed killer ever sold, uses glyphosate as its most active
ingredient. Glyphosate is toxic to most broadleaf plants and grasses. It kills most plants it comes
into contact with, instead of targeting certain weeds or plants.
Monsanto, a now defunct company, developed the product. Because glyphosate kills anything it
touches, Monsanto developed plant seeds that were genetically modified to resist the damage of
Roundup. 'Phis is when residential Roundup sales skyrocketed.
However, as the years went on, science questioned the safety of glyphosate. Studies hai el
shown that the chemical might cause illness to humans and cause damage to the environment.
The Inter tic nal, A ge_ic�N
_-((?K Research of C ncc r categorizes glyphosate as possibly
carcinogenic to humans —essentially, the IARC is saying this toxin may cause cancer.
In 2018, Roundup was purchased by Bayer. By then, consumers had filed thousands of lawsuits
linking Roundup to cancer. The most common cancer associated with Roundup is non -Hodgkin's
lymphoma. 11a� c r comynitted to begin in 2023 replacing "its glyphosate-based products in the
U.S. residential Lawn & Garden market with new formulations that rely on alternative active
ingredients."
Monsanto has settled over,100,000 Roundup lawsuits, paying out. about $11 billion as of May
2022. There are still 30,000 lawsuits pending. This includes 4,000 cases in multidistrict litigation
(MDI) in California. MDL cases are not class-action suits. Instead they group cases together so
that instead of answering the same question repeatedly in each separate lawsuit, the courts can
resolve some specific issues for all of them at once.
In June 2022, the Xiii1h Circi it lIle_i a ciccisiloi� in a Roy€ndjjj case. In the court's opinion, the
Ninth Circuit urged the 1 'M i1o11tnc°11tal Protc c ion � Lycjicv- (EPA} to reconsider its conclusion that
Roundup does not cause substantial harm to people or the environment. Also in that month,
the€ 11cal by Bayer in another Roundup case.