Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-14-26 CC WS MinutesCITY OF SHOREWOOD 5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MEETING COUNCIL CHAMBERS MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 5:30 P.M. MINUTES 1. CONVENE CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MEETING Mayor Labadie called the meeting to order at 5:30 P.M. A. Roll Call Present. Mayor Labadie; Councilmembers DiGruttolo, Maddy, Sanschagrin, and Gorham; City Administrator Nevinski, City Attorney Shepard, City Clerk/HR Director Thone, Finance Director Schmuck, Public Works Director Morreim, Planning Director Griffiths; South Lake Minnetonka Police Department Chief Ballsrud, and Lt. O'Keefe. Absent: None B. Review Agenda Sanschagrin moved, Maddy seconded, Approving the agenda as presented. Motion passed 5/0. 2. CLOSED SESSION -SECURITY BRIEFING — MINN.STAT.13D.05, SUBD. 3(D) A. Council Chambers Security Review (Closed Session) The statement below was read aloud by Mayor Labadie. Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, moving into closed session at 5:32 P.M. Motion passed 5/0. Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 13D. 05, subdivision 3(d), as permitted, this item may be closed to discuss security procedure and responses for City Council Chamber and City Hall with South Lake Minnetonka Police Chief Ballsrud and Lt. O'Keefe. Discussion included a review of the Council Chamber and City Hall attributes relative to safety and security, actions to be taken in the event of an emergency, and potential enhancements to measures and processes. Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, moving to reopen the closed session at 6:30 P.M. Motion passed 5/0. Mayor Labadie shared that the Council had been discussing policies, procedures, and security issues with the SLMPD Chief and Lieutenant. She asked whether Staff had anything to add to the discussion. CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 Page 2 of 6 Planning Director Griffiths shared that he was not at the last meeting. He noted that as the policies and procedures are being developed, both the Planning and Park Commissions need to be involved. Specifically, the Planning Commission, since many people are invited to many meetings. He stated that it is fortunate there are not many issues, but the commissions should still be involved. He added that, in an ideal world, the commissions would also know what is expected. 3. DISCUSSION A. Discussion of Policies and Practices City Administrator Nevinski stated that there was nothing further to discuss, but if Council wanted to discuss it further, they could. He shared that, now, Staff have direction on next steps. He suggested moving on, but that is Council's call. Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether the question of whether a speaker could speak twice needed clarification. Mayor Labadie stated that the question was raised at the last meeting. She noted that the Council never intended to have someone come for five minutes on whatever topic they wished. She agreed that the City's language is confusing. She suggested adding language, explaining that speakers can only come up once. Councilmember DiGruttolo disagreed; she pointed out that the resident wanted to make another comment, did not know he couldn't, and wanted to support the Center. She shared that she did not think the Council should ever abrogate people's First Amendment rights to comment. She noted that there has been another instance of wanting to speak twice while she has been on Council. If the person has not used their full five minutes, then that time should not go away. She noted that she has never supported abridging someone's First Amendment right to be heard. Mayor Labadie explained that she also opposes abridging First Amendment rights, which is why the City is giving people five minutes. If residents do not have all their thoughts together at one time, then it invites back -and -forth with a full business agenda to get to. Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that it has not been a problem in the past and she does not think a rule needs to be written. Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that he is always all for letting people speak, so as long as it is another topic, people should be allowed to speak, especially if they have not used up their five minutes. Councilmember Gorham asked if another meeting would be needed to amend the Matter from the Floor policies. Mayor Labadie shared that the Council could reach a consensus and direct Staff to amend the policy, and then the language could come back to the Council. City Administrator Nevinski stated that the item would likely be placed on the Consent Agenda with the changes. Councilmember Maddy asked what the amended policy would say. Mayor Labadie explained that the proposal is that a person can go to the podium to talk as many times as they want at the meeting as long as it is a different topic each time. Councilmember Maddy shared that allowing that is not a good use of time; it rewards people who have time to attend the meetings. Most of the time, people are just talking to the cameras. He added that he did not understand why so much time is given to people to talk about things that are not even on the agenda. He pointed out that many cities do not have Matters from the Floor; there is just email or dialogue. He is not a fan of one-way communication for those who have time to show up at a meeting. He stated CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 Page 3 of 6 that the five minutes has gotten exhausting and is not a good use of the Council's time or Staff's. He opposed any amendments that would allow people to talk off topic. City Attorney Shepherd explained that his only concern with the amendment is that it would include a time, place, and manner restriction. People have First Amendment rights to speak to the government, but the City has a valid time, place, and manner restriction: it is a limited public forum, and the person is allowed five minutes to speak. He shared that if the City started allowing other opportunities based on the subject matter, that would be very hard to police in a nondiscriminatory way. In other words, how does the City distinguish between different new topics, and then if someone wants to come back and split hairs about what is a new topic, that can lead to constitutional trouble. Whereas if there is a strict time limit, it does not depend on the content of the speech. He understood the position of Councilmembers who wanted to allow more time to talk to Council, but he advocated for a finite time rather than basing it on the speech's content. Councilmember Gorham stated that it would be wonky if someone were allowed five minutes to talk about x and then another five minutes to talk about y. He pointed out that he would worry someone would have to watch the clock if it were only about the time. He noted that the five minutes would need to be a little lenient, but Staff would have to manage that. City Administrator Nevinski said that whatever time the Council decides would be a clear boundary. He added that they could have further conversations with individuals in the future. A big reason cities allow open forum is to tee up issues, not to resolve them. Councilmember Gorham noted that they needed clarification on whether someone could come back to speak if time remained. Mayor Labadie shared that allowing people to speak multiple times, even within the under -five-minute time limit, would set a bad precedent. She noted that she did not know of any other city that did that and, in fact, many cities require people to sign up beforehand, which the Council discussed and decided against. She explained that she would like a rule with a timeframe rather than trying to figure out the content of the speech, and that would treat everyone the same. Councilmember Gorham asked whether Mayor Labadie wanted to restrict returning to the podium. Mayor Labadie said she would like to do that, and that if someone has more to say, they can come back at a future meeting. Councilmember Gorham stated that it is not about the time limit but the trips to the podium. Mayor Labadie noted that is why she suggested the word once or one time, because that would make it clearer to the residents. A person can come to the podium once with a maximum of five minutes. Councilmember Gorham asked whether the City Attorney recommended that as well. City Attorney Shepherd stated he is only arguing that the policy should not include a content -based decision. The time does not matter, and what the Mayor is suggesting with the one-time limit of a maximum of five minutes is a time, place, and manner restriction and is something that could be done. He added that it gets a little more difficult allowing someone to come back up if they did not use their full five minutes, but it is feasible because it is not content -based. Councilmember Gorham stated that he supports going to five minutes and that having more avenues for resident voices is important. He added that if someone has five minutes and has not used the full time, then they should be allowed to come back up to speak. That would bring another resident perspective to another resident issue. Mayor Labadie shared that inserting the word once would be sufficient and keep everyone on the same playing field. She asked who would keep track of the time. She explained that the clock is CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 Page 4 of 6 shown, and when the time is up, Council asks the speaker to wrap it up, but since the policy has gone to five minutes, very few have spoken the whole time. When residents comment on issues that come up in the meeting, it is a reactionary response that has not necessarily been thought out. She suggested keeping it simple by allowing residents to come up only once. Councilmember DiGruttolo pointed out that residents do not come up for the entire meeting to speak; they do so only during Matters from the Floor. Mayor Labadie pointed out that the item is on during a work session. She noted there is no consensus of direction for Staff. Councilmember Maddy said allowing people to come up only once would be simpler and would prevent people from yelling about having ten seconds left or needing someone to keep track of the time. He stated that he would suggest coming up once, and ideally zero times, and sending an email. Mayor Labadie shared that she believes people can come to the podium once, for a maximum of five minutes, and if they don't use the full time, that is just the way it is. Coming back to the podium is not fruitful. She added that if the person did not have it together the first time, then they are just reacting to other people, and that is not what Matters from the Floor is meant for. It was meant to bring a concern to the Council and the Staff. Councilmember Sanschagrin stated that he would like residents to have their full five minutes and should be allowed to come back to the podium if they have time left over. Councilmember DiGruttolo agreed. Councilmember Gorham also agreed. Mayor Labadie explained that Staff is being directed to change the language, and she would need help keeping very accurate time while residents are speaking because she does not want anyone to get more time than others. She pointed out that this is a can of worms the Council has opened, and people may not know the expectations or be treated fairly. She added that one time at the podium for five minutes is how she knows other councils handle Matters from the Floor and could be even more restrictive, requiring people to sign up ahead of time. Councilmember Gorham stated that one of the important rules from Robert's Rules is that the Council is not commenting on the decisions that are being made. He added that the Council knows the Mayor does not agree on the matter, but she did not need to comment. Mayor Labadie stated that the Council is in a work session and it is a time for discussion. Councilmember Gorham stated that that is true, but the decision did not need to be trashed. Mayor Labadie stated that it can be done any time. Councilmember Gorham added that it is not constructive, though. Mayor Labadie pointed out that she has every right to have an opinion. Councilmember Gorham stated that he reads the Code of Conduct differently. Mayor Labadie noted that it is an informal work session and directed staff accordingly. With time running short, Mayor Labadie asked whether the next Item should be tabled or recessed until after the regular meeting. City Administrator Nevinski stated that if Council is unsure what it wants to do, the Item can be recessed or done on a different night. He pointed out that the Item has been on the Council's list, but it is not pressing. Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that it is an important topic and preferred to take up the item at the end. CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 Page 5 of 6 Sanschagrin moved, DiGruttolo seconded, Moving the Work Session to the end of the Regular Meeting. Motion passed 4/1 (Maddy). Mayor Labadie recessed the meeting at 6:50 P.M. The meeting reconvened at 9:51 P.M. B. Citywide Speed Concerns and Speed Limit Discussion Councilmember Gorham suggested moving the item to October 12, as there are no items on the work session for that day. He stated it seems like a big discussion if the mile -per -hour structure will be overhauled. City Administrator Nevinski stated that it is a good point. He noted that Staff is wondering whether Council thinks the City should pursue this idea. If there is interest, Staff would pursue it. Councilmember Gorham pointed out that cities seem to be taking initiative to align more. He added that a few cities are paying more attention to making the speed limit more uniform and sharing information. It seems like a worthwhile investment of the City's time. Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that if the Council is going to look at it, the Police Department should have a representative. Mayor Labadie agreed. Councilmember Maddy noted that he has no interest in the matter. He shared that a great way to judge a city is by what it does not do, and all the empirical evidence says the City does not have much speeding. Councilmember DiGruttolo stated she did not think that was true. Councilmember Maddy pointed out that the Agenda Packet states that most streets in the City hardly get sped on. There are outliers, yes, but they are trying to solve a problem that does not exist. He would be happy to kick it out and not deal with it. He noted that he is just one of five, and if the City wanted to go against State guidelines, it could make that decision. Mayor Labadie stated that she is leery of taking streets that are 20 miles per hour and making them faster. Some residents on those roads may not want that, such as on Howard's Point Road. She added that she lives on that road but did not have an opinion either way; she pointed out that many heavy trailers with boats and SUVs would be easier to stop if something ran out in front of them while they were traveling slower. Councilmember DiGruttolo shared that her road speed limit is 20 miles per hour, and many people speed. She stated she did not know where the empirical data came from, but on her road, people are always speeding. She added that it was a big topic during her campaign. Just because tickets are not being given does not mean that people are not speeding. She agreed with the Mayor that she did not want the speed limit on her road to change. City Administrator Nevinski said it would be a challenge if some speed limits are 20 miles per hour while the City is trying to set them uniformly at 25 miles per hour. He shared that the City could go lower, but it would take a much longer process. He noted that SLMPD and other cities on the committee support this. One issue is consistency for the SLMPD. Public Works Director Morreim shared that from the Public Works standpoint, they do not get as many calls about speeding. He pointed out that 20 miles per hour may not be enforceable, but that would need to be checked. He noted a few consistency reasons: to reduce confusion; the CITY OF SHOREWOOD WORK SESSION COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 Page 6 of 6 City is not aware of why certain roads have posted speeds of 20 miles per hour. The State Statute points out that consistency is key with the lower speed limits, which the City does not have. He noted that the City is not following State Statute for speed limits, which makes enforcement difficult. Only so many engineering measures can slow people down. He added that in many cities, bump -outs are the craze, which is not doable for Shorewood. The City receives many complaints. He shared that consistency would help, and lower speed limits would help with road size, too. He explained that signs are being moved to where speeding is seen, and that seems to help as a temporary fix. Ultimately, a consistent speed limit would reduce confusion and improve enforcement. Councilmember DiGruttolo asked what it would cost. City Administrator Nevinski said the cost would likely be relatively low to replace the signs, and not all signs might be replaced. Councilmember DiGruttolo said she asked to compare the cost of speed trailers with the signs, since the trailers might be more effective. Public Works Director Morreim shared that a radar speed sign costs about $4,000, and buying 200 25 miles per hour signs costs about $4,000 to $5,000. Neither of those costs includes installation. He did not know whether there would be 200 signs. Councilmember Gorham asked if the signs are solar -powered. Public Works Director Morreim stated that the City's signs are solar -powered. Mayor Labadie stated that one Councilmember does not wish to discuss the topic further, one Councilmember has suggested moving the topic to a different night, and others have suggested doing so when a Police Officer is here. City Administrator Nevinski suggested that Council seems to want to pursue something with this; staff has received some direction and can do a deeper dive and then come back at the end of the year or the beginning of the next. 4. ADJOURN Sanschagrin moved, Gorham seconded, Adjourning the City Council Work Session Meeting of September 14, 2026, at 10:05 P.M. Motion passed 5/0. ATTEST: OnifeAabadie, Mayor I Sandie Thone, City Clerk