HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-14-26 CC Reg Mtg MinutesCITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
MINUTES
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
Mayor Labadie called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
A. Pledge of Allegiance
B. Roll Call
Present. Mayor Labadie; Councilmembers Maddy, Sanschagrin, Gorham, and DiGruttolo;
City Attorney Shepherd; City Administrator Nevinski; City Clerk/HR DirectorThone;
Planning Director Griffiths; Director of Public Works Morreim; Park and Recreation
Director Czech; Finance Director Schmuck; and City Engineer Budde
Absent: None
C. Review Agenda
Councilmember DiGruttolo requested that Item 5.A.i have a more recognizable title. She
suggested that it read Gravity Investment Lot Combination and Anticipated Residential
Development North of Watten Ponds.
Mayor Labadie stated that the Parcel ID usually describes the item. She asked if the amendment
would be acceptable. Planning Director stated that Staff is fine with the change. The Agenda
Item, as written, is the technical description of the property since there is no address, but Staff is
fine with the change.
Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Approving the agenda as amended.
Motion passed 5/0.
2. CONSENT AGENDA
Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that he had a question about the Claims List and had sent
the question in advance for Staff to answer. He stated that the City had $28,000 in Excel Energy
charges for numerous properties. He asked whether that is an increase in cost for the City, what
is driving the costs, and whether anything can be done to manage them. Finance Director
Schmuck shared that Excel Energy provides electricity and gas to the City. Electricity used to
pump the wells during drought and hot months is the most expensive of the year. She explained
that, on average, the City pays about $14,000 to $15,000 a month. She added that those are the
biggest drivers, and those expenses are funded with utility funds, not taxpayer dollars.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked if the average of $14,000 is going up over time. Finance
Director Schmuck stated maybe $1,000 a year.
Maddy moved, DiGruttolo seconded, Approving the Motions Contained on the Consent
Agenda and Adopting the Resolutions Therein.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 2 of 15
A. City Council Work Session Minutes
B. City Council Regular Meeting Minutes
C. Claims List
D. Tree Removal Quote and Service Agreement
E. 2026 Pavement Striping, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-53U, "A Resolution
to Award Contract for 2026 Pavement Striping City Project 26-02."
Motion passed 5/0.
3. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
No one wished to address the Council.
4. GENERAL BUSINESS
A. Shorewood Community & Event Center Operational Analysis
City Administrator Nevinski explained that ISG would be presenting to the Council, with time for
questions to follow. He noted that additional dialogue could follow in subsequent work sessions.
Claire Roth, Planner with ISG, explained that ISG is a multidisciplinary engineering firm that has
been working with the City on the Shorewood Community and Event Center (SCEC) Operational
Analysis. She shared that she has managed a variety of projects in the area. She noted that she
would give a brief overview of the project purpose, the process followed, engagement with facility
users, and the formation of a task force that helped guide the project and ultimately inform the
recommendation. The broad purpose of the project was to conduct a study of the current
operations of the facility, ultimately then develop a report which was shared in the Agenda Packet
informing recommendations to improve usage and overall position the SCEC for long-term
sustainability. She highlighted the project's key focus areas: facility operations, financial
performance, community use, and market positioning. She gave a broad overview of the
approach that was taken. Starting with a review of the available documents and data, next
engaging the facility users in a survey and the formation of a task force, then the facility and
operational assessment was done with a report being developed; ISG conducted things like
market and benchmark analysis by looking at similar facilities throughout the metro, then diving
into customer profile development and a marketing strategy, and finally providing a variety of
scenarios that could be taken to guide the future of the facility. She shared a timeline of the
project, with some conversation beginning in February 2025, which ultimately led to the facility
assessment being done in Fall of 2025, which outlined recommendations for deferred
maintenance for the facility for the next 15 years. This specific project kicked off in May with the
formation of a task force and a document and data review. ISG met with the Task Force four
times throughout the summer for two-hour sessions. She added that the Task Force was integral
to the process, informing ISG through firsthand use of the facility and providing ideas and
feedback as recommendations were developed. She noted that staff deployed a community
survey with 18 questions, and approximately 70 individuals completed it. She highlighted a few
survey findings. When asked about improvements or enhancements for the facility, respondents
indicated that expanded programming and community events were the most desired
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 3of15
improvements. She noted that most survey respondents were existing users, which strongly
supports increasing facility utilization. She noted that many survey respondents were recurring
users, especially senior programming users. Other strong themes throughout the survey included
the repeated need for marketing and facility awareness. She shared the Task Force
recommendations and the information that guided the report and recommendations. The Task
Force was a core group that served in an advisory capacity, providing community -based insight
to support the project. She stated that 10 people served on the Task Force and were selected
based on their past interactions with the facility or their current work or professional experience in
relevant areas. She noted that the report documented conversations with the Task Force. She
highlighted the key takeaways from the group: community value remains the foundation of future
decision -making; increased usage represents the greatest opportunity; phase and align
implementation with operational capacity; and, finally, the strongest theme was the need for
marketing, awareness, and a clear market position. She noted that other themes from
conversations with the Task Force included the value of future partnerships; the idea that
programming and rental strategies should reflect community needs and market demand; that
operational capacity and staffing influence long-term success; and that financial sustainability
should focus on cost recovery rather than full self-sufficiency.
Jay Lotthammer, Development Strategist with ISG, stated he works on many park master plans,
facility analyses, and business plans for community centers. Before joining ISG, he worked with
the city of Brooklyn Park and Eden Prairie and oversaw other facilities like the SCEC that were
similar in size and components. He hoped to bring that perspective to the Council. He noted that
the Task Force wanted ISG to show the intangible benefits in the findings: community connection.
The Task Force had a good mix of people, and ISG appreciated the opportunity to meet with them
to get their perspective. He explained that many days at the SCEC look just like a senior center
in other communities. Other intangible benefits include recreation, enrichment, and learning
classes; civic life and community engagement; community identity and pride; and, finally, Staff
offices and internal City events. He provided the current conditions, focusing more on operations
and going beyond the facility assessment. The facility is active and appreciated, but ISG looked
for opportunities, and there are certainly many. He shared that, given current affordability, cost
increases could help revenue. ISG reviewed similar facilities to gauge local costs, which will give
a good sense of where things are and identify opportunities to raise prices while still feeling
valuable. He noted that SCEC staff is at capacity. He explained that sometimes two people work
in the facility, but they are not fully working for the SCEC, with heavy reliance on volunteers.
When ISG started the project, they discovered that the senior partners would be leaving at the
end of the year. Based on what the seniors were doing, it is a good half-time position. He added
that the City has been fortunate to have volunteers fill a part-time position. The volunteers answer
phones, keep the building open when no one else is there, and organize the senior programs. He
explained that during Task Force meetings, people commented that programs run themselves,
but he pointed out that nothing really runs itself. When seniors step away, real people need to
keep things going. He noted this is an opportunity for the new staff to serve more effectively. He
said there are growth opportunities, which does not mean people are not trying, but the people
there are at capacity. So what is being seen is a facility operating at the level it can with the effort
currently allocated. He pointed out that capital investments need to continue to keep an aging
building usable. He explained that, in talking about physical update opportunities, the first is the
kitchen. The kitchen is full right now, though not fully functional, but with the events that have
been taking place, it is more of a warming and cooling kitchen. The good news is the City does
not have to replicate what is there, because that would be very expensive, but it could be changed
to match how it is actually being used. The next update would be the activity room; the Task
Force suggested slight modifications, such as updating the floor to accommodate the dance and
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 4 of 15
general use. He noted that the overall decor could be phased in, but it generated a lot of
discussion. Then, following the guidelines laid out in the facility assessment, there are
opportunities to improve the mechanical system. He shared that ISG suggests expanding the
recurring uses, such as dance, looking at the underutilized time blocks, diversifying program
offerings, and strengthening target market development. He noted many opportunities to improve
social media and draw people in with different techniques. He explained that a few operational
scenarios were put together based on a few accurate scenario assumptions. Current Staff are at
capacity and have duties outside the SCEC; the South Shore Senior efforts have effectively
created a half-time staff. He added that marketing efforts can increase, but with more people
being driven to the SCEC, there needs to be enough staff to follow up on that increased use. He
noted that each scenario is interchangeable and can be implemented over time. He asked the
Council to keep that in mind. He explained that option one is recognizing that, as the senior effort
pulls back, we stabilize things and do it as if staffing doesn't change. He added that fewer things
will be offered and there are strategies to do that, but there is a potential for not having the SCEC
open because there is not enough Staff. He noted the next option is to maintain, which could be
done by adding a half-time person, so the current half-time person would go to full time and would
be elevated in status as well. He shared that it does not provide much more activation of the
facility, but it backfills what the seniors did. He added that having a Staff person in the role would
be beneficial. The final option is to grow and activate, which would mean growing the half-time
person into a full-time person and then adding another half-time person. The half-time person
would recruit programs, seek out contractors, and follow up on new marketing initiatives to help
the new use of the facilities grow. He shared the cost impact of each option. He noted going
back to 2025 and talking about cost recovery because that came up as part of the Task Force. In
2025, the last actuals were $87,000 in revenue and $175,000 in expenses, so cost recovery was
50 percent. He encouraged the Council to base cost recovery on operating costs, not the total
capital invested. One year could be $20,000, and the next $100,000. Cost recovery is a year -
by -year operational metric, as 2025 points out. He added that in 2025, the City added $122,000
to the budget, which increased the fund balance. He shared that 2026 is tracking to budget, and
2027 reflects what the Council has heard, especially turning the part-time person into a full-time
person. Scenario 1 would provide slightly better revenue and keep expenses lowest, with a
$66,000 difference. Scenario 2 is close to the 2027 budget proposal. Scenario 3 increases the
half-time person and then adds another half-time person, which could be phased over time, but it
would scale things up. Revenue would go up, and expenses would also go up, with a difference
of $151,000. ISG played out what Scenario 3 would look like in a few years, and cost recovery
could increase to 56 percent. He noted that it is hard to change cost recovery much because of
the facility's small size and scale. He noted that the changes are based on increased volume and
price increases, since it has been a while since that has happened. He added that one
recommendation is to increase prices every year. He pointed out that, moving forward, it will be
important to get direction from the Council on where they want it to go in terms of use, the types
of use, and how much. He added that it takes people to do that, and staff is working as hard as
they can at capacity right now. He noted another takeaway is the marketing portion and getting
more expertise to handle some of the marketing. Over time, enhance customer experience and
implement improvements.
Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that he was confused by the reports because one strength
was the facility's flexibility, but at the same time the facility is inflexible because of its size. He
asked how that is reconciled. Mr. Lotthammer stated that the facility's flexibility is that the rooms
can be used for a variety of things. The facility is what it is and cannot accommodate certain
things. He shared strategies that could accommodate larger events. He noted a concern about
parking and that, for a large event, the whole facility may need to be rented out.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 5 of 15
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether the loss of volunteers could cause ISG to pause
future energy around the facility. Mr. Lotthammer suggested viewing the situation as fortunate,
with volunteers doing things that Staff would usually do. Many of the volunteers were like staff
and deserve thanks and recognition for what has been done over the years. He stated that
volunteers do not need to go away, but need to come back differently, in the usual intent of
augmenting or enhancing the programs. He added that coordinating the volunteers would fall on
the City Staff person. Volunteers are not necessarily looking to never volunteer again and will
probably not just go away. Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that the City was basically
misusing the volunteers. Mr. Lotthammer noted they were very generous in what they were doing.
Councilmember Sanschagrin shared that the Council has been discussing a 70 percent cost
recovery, which is not reflected in the scenarios. He asked whether that is not possible. Mr.
Lotthammer explained that some programs at the SCEC operate at 70 percent, while many
programs have expenses only related to them. He shared that 50 percent is a really good number;
to get closer to 70 percent, the City would need to be more of a community center with more
fitness and other amenities, and people would be charged $70 a month. He shared that some
programs could be brought in to get closer to 50 to 60 percent, but getting there is not attainable.
He added that because of the building's size and scale, some costs are fixed. Councilmember
Sanschagrin pointed out that, on top of the capital investments, the City is underwater on the
facility.
Councilmember Gorham stated that, looking at the scenarios and the summary budget, things
look a little grim. He pointed out that revenues in Scenario 1 would not really grow if all of the
programming is cut. Mr. Lotthammer explained that, for Scenario 1, if the programs being charged
for- rentals and dance classes- are cut, the cost could go up five percent, and that is driving the
revenue. For programs that are not driving revenue, they may need to happen only on certain
days of the week to make up for the lack of volunteers. He added that ISG did not try to be
aggressive on the revenue, but rather realistic and maybe even conservative.
Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that Shorewood is a relatively wealthy zip code. She asked
whether the County or State provides any grants or services for senior programming. Mr.
Lotthammer shared that there may be partnerships, but the money is generally used for specific
programs, not to add to rental costs or pay rent. Those sorts of things rarely bring dollars, but
they do bring people. He added that there would be things to explore, like naming rights or other
types of donations, that may be possible. Getting the word out that there is a need may bring the
right person forward. Councilmember DiGruttolo shared that she did some research and that
grants are available for upgrading facilities, especially when there are seniors, to make the
building ADA compliant and accessible. She asked if the options had been explored. She said
the seniors have done a great job bringing in programming, but she read about programs in places
like Northfield doing incredible 50/50 programs, and that program grants could help with the cost
burden and provide new ideas and options. Mr. Lotthammer explained that seniors currently pay
a membership, which is voluntary but could change if it is city -run. Part of the recommendation
is that seniors would pay the membership so the free programs would generate some revenue.
He added that they could look into grants, but that would take people and time.
Councilmember Sanschagrin noticed on the survey that over 25 percent of users are not
Shorewood residents. He asked how to handle that fairly for taxpayers. Mr. Lotthammer stated
that this is usually handled as a non-resident fee policy, and that is one of the recommendations.
That can be seen across the metro area and is done in a variety of ways, but it would be a policy
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 6 of 15
determination. Councilmember Sanschagrin asked if that had already been factored into the
model. Mr. Lotthammer stated that it had.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked if the actual number of users was collected. Mr. Lotthammer
stated that the number of uses was the available number. No one is tracking the number of users,
and that would be hard to do. He added that few community centers do that. He added that some
programs require registration and that could be looked up, but it has not necessarily been
tabulated. He shared that right now the hard count is on the number of uses, not users.
Councilmember DiGruttolo stated it is difficult to prioritize when that type of data isn't available. It
would be good information to have. Mr. Lotthammer explained that a page in the report shows
678 different types of uses, broken down by program. That will give a good feel, but the programs
do fluctuate. He added that a third party is dancing, so that information is not in the system for
calculation.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether, during the review, ISG considered which events
and markets cost the City money. Mr. Lotthammer shared that, in general, the one-time rentals
are making money. The senior programs and programs the City might offer itself are not covering
their costs. The rentals and the dance programs are making the most money. The task force
asked about finding more of that because it would help the cost recovery, so that would be one
area to explore. Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether that is an area that could be
improved and is not currently reflected in the model. Mr. Lotthammer said that is true. He added
that the model reflected with dance is a good example of that.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked if the 47 to 56 percent cost recovery is the norm for most
community centers. Mr. Lotthammer shared that, looking at senior centers, community centers,
and art centers, the SCEC mix is absolutely the norm. He stated that the City has to get toward
something like a Lifetime Fitness to charge more, but very few are above 70 percent.
Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that the Minnetonka Community Center seems to hover around
70 percent, but it does not have any major amenities. She asked if the City could aspire to that.
Mr. Lotthammer shared that a childcare component could help cover the cost or provide enough
amenities.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether it is feasible for the SCEC to use part of it as a
childcare facility. Mr. Lotthammer shared that, considering the amenities needed to support
childcare, the building would probably become a childcare facility.
Mr. Lotthammer thanked the Council for the honor of working with the Task Force and everything
that they brought to the table.
Mayor Labadie shared that Staff is hoping the Council will accept the analysis and the study. She
asked whether Staff or the Council had any discussion points. Councilmember Sanschagrin
pointed out that it would be good to get Park and Recreation Director Czech's feedback.
Park and Recreation Director Czech said that, from his perspective, ISG did a great job on the
report overall. The Task Force was a very skilled group that came from many different segments
of the community. He shared that the loss of the Senior Partners is huge. Senior programming
in other communities does not make much money but is a huge community asset and vital for
members. He pointed out that the volunteers probably will not leave, but the City wants to make
their experience enjoyable. For many of the volunteers, it is a job right now. He shared that
having a skilled staff person would help direct the volunteers and improve their experience. He
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 7 of 15
explained that some things can be done, with marketing being a big one because many people
did not know there was a community and event center, which is a problem. There were many
ideas to get more people into the building and then offer more programs. He shared that many
impactful things are happening right now. The Council will need to decide where the line is
between cost recovery and utilization. He pointed out that the building is underutilized, but
decisions will need to be made about whether utilization goes up and such. Councilmember
Sanschagrin agreed that the volunteers should feel like it is less work.
Mayor Labadie noted that she is worried that with the sheer number of volunteers and the super
volunteers that were there all the time, a half-time person would not be able to duplicate that. She
said stacking the time and making things more efficient would help. She asked if a half-time
person would fill all of the hours. Mr. Czech stated that the City has to be realistic in its execution
and that there will be an implementation phase, but the City will have to be flexible. He noted that
he would hate to bring on a full team of people and not know what to do with them, but as things
increase, the City could look more closely at something like the Scenario 3 model.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked if the City could write a letter of appreciation to all Task Force
volunteers for the time and effort put into the meetings. City Administrator Nevinski stated that it
could be done.
Mayor Labadie shared that she understood the desire to increase the numbers, but she does not
want to lose the existing programming. The programs at the SCEC have existed for a long time,
and many people use them. Volunteers have tailored the programs to residents' interests, and
many people participate. She pointed out that many SCEC events benefit the whole City, and
she did not want to see any of that go away. She liked the concept of slowly increasing revenue
and looking at it that way.
Maddy moved, Gorham seconded, Accepting the SCEC Operational Analysis.
Motion passed 5/0.
Mayor Labadie shared that Council would continue to discuss this analysis. She asked if Staff is
looking for anything else at this moment. City Administrator Nevinski asked whether Council had
anything they felt strongly about regarding staffing, marketing, and the fee schedule.
Mayor Labadie stated that she is concerned about marketing, specifically for Senior Partners
members, because they sent out a newsletter. Hence, the City needs to find a way to keep people
informed about upcoming events and ongoing activities. She noted that someone will need to do
senior outreach to the community.
Councilmember Gorham stated that step one is reviewing staffing. He would like to see an
analysis of what maintaining does versus 1.5 FTE versus 2 FTE. What would that mean for
programming? He added that it's hard to make a judgment call based on what each does on its
face. He added that the analysis has some snippets, but he would want to see the duties of each
FTE.
Mayor Labadie stated those are great things that can come back in the future. Her concern is not
losing programming, as well as adding additional programming.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 8 of 15
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked what is in the current budget. City Administrator Nevinski
stated it is Scenario 2, with the $67,000 needed to make up for a half-time FTE. Councilmember
Gorham stated that the City currently has a half-time FTE, the budget includes one FTE, and this
analysis recommends moving to two FTEs. City Administrator Nevinski pointed out that Scenario
3 would include two and a half FTEs. Mr. Lotthammer stated that it is important to recognize that
currently, it may be reflected as one and a half, but not all of the effort is reflected in the SCEC.
So, Scenario 2 takes the half -timer to a full timer, with those efforts filling all the work of the senior
volunteers. He added that having one Staff member instead of multiple volunteers creates
efficiencies. He explained that Scenario 3 takes Scenario 2 and adds .5 to it. He noted that even
though bodies are doing the roles, they are not solely dedicated to the SCEC. Councilmember
Sanschagrin pointed out that the SCEC is budgeted separately from parks, so the FTE being
discussed should be limited to the SCEC budget. Mr. Lotthammer shared that FTEs differ from
personnel expenditures, so only a small portion of Mr. Czech is reflected in the SCEC budget,
and the same applies to the current half -timer. He added that the 2027 request is to add .5 FTE
to the SCEC.
B. Preliminary 2027 Budget, Proposed 2027 Tax Levy, and Establish Budget
Hearing Date
Finance Director Schmuck reviewed the preliminary 2027 budget, proposed 2027 tax levy, and
established the budget date as found in the Agenda Packet.
Mayor Labadie thanked Ms. Schmuck for all of the work that she has done.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked if the reduction for the UPS equipment for police and fire was
included in the budget. Ms. Schmuck stated that it is not at this time because the equipment still
needs to be purchased, even though fire did not approve it. Once the dollars are vetted, then the
levy can be lowered, but doing that now is not recommended because someone will have to
finance the other half. Councilmember DiGruttolo said it would make a difference because
Shorewood's share differs for police and fire. City Administrator Nevinski stated that police is
about 50 percent and fire is about a third. He shared that the system has been reviewed; it is
currently a 60-kilowatt system, and they are looking into a 20-kilowatt system. How that translates
into costs and pricing: the boards will meet next month, and there will be some cost savings.
Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that Shorewood residents have been talking a lot about
decreasing the levy. After reading the notes from the last meetings about antenna revenue, he
proposed using the $177,000 of antenna revenue to cover SCEC costs, so that revenue would
cover the SCEC shortfall. Ms. Schmuck stated that Staff would not recommend it, but if the
Council wanted it, it could happen. Mayor Labadie asked Ms. Schmuck to elaborate on why Staff
does not recommend that. Ms. Schmuck explained that the antennae are on Shorewood's water
towers. The water fund infrastructure, staffing, property, taxes, insurance, and operations must
support the antennae being on top of the water towers. Revenues should be in the same category
as the related expenditures, so Staff recommends that the water fund receive those revenues as
it did when the antenna rents originated. Councilmember Sanschagrin stated that he understands
that position. A different perspective is that costs have been reduced in the water fund through
decisions not to continue certain capital expenditures, and that this revenue is for the good of the
community, as it was part of the general fund last year. He added that, at least to phase it in,
Staff proposed using a portion of the antennae revenue for the general fund. He noted that it
would be logical to tie that to the SCEC shortfall, so there is a revenue source to cover the cost
for residents. Ms. Schmuck shared that, as indicated in the SCEC analysis presentation, the
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 9 of 15
shortfall is never going to go away for the SCEC, so the recommended phased approach was
phased in over a couple of years and then eventually became 100 percent in the water fund. If
the City does the stopgap in the SCEC fund, she did not see the revenues being returned to the
water fund in a phased process. She added that only 50 percent of the residents in Shorewood
are connected to City water, and they are the people paying for the water expenditures. So taking
revenue that should be affiliated with those residents and turning it into a reduction for all
Shorewood residents does not seem equitable either. She noted that the decrease of $49 or
$138 in the annual increase in property taxes will warrant a larger increase in water rates.
Councilmember Sanschagrin stated that they will increase less as a result. Ms. Schmuck
explained that it would not be that significant. Staff will pull together the Long -Term Financial
Management Plan, and it will be reflected there, but it would not have much impact. That will be
before the Council in October. Councilmember DiGruttolo said it would have been great to have
it before the decision needed to be made.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked if the 2025 audit is complete. Ms. Schmuck stated that it is just
wrapping up and they are finalizing the next financial report, which will come at the next meeting.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked if Ms. Schmuck could tell the Council about the actual balances
that might change. Ms. Schmuck shared that she is still entering the numbers in the correct spots,
so she does not have the final numbers yet. She would not know them off the top of her head
when looking at the Long -Term Financial Management Plan, which will put it all in perspective
with the fund balances and the reserves the City has to accommodate the policies in place.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked whether anyone had shown the Council the table of increases.
Ms. Schmuck stated that it would be part of the Long -Term Management Plan presentation. She
shared that she has been short-staffed for a year and a half, and she is trying to get caught up,
so she apologized but did not have that update yet.
Maddy moved, Gorham seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-52, "A Resolution
Adopting the 2027 Preliminary Tax Levy, Preliminary General Fund Budget, and
Establishing the Budget Meeting Date."
Motion passed 3/2 (Sanschagrin and DiGruttolo).
C. Comprehensive Plan Amendment & Rezoning Due to Recent Municipal
Boundary Adjustment
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed the Comprehensive Plan Amendment and rezoning in the
Agenda Packet.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked what is driving this. It is because Excel Energy owns that
property, so the City is annexing that, and then three other plots were found to trade. Planning
Director Griffiths stated that a year ago, the City Council held a work session where Staff
explained the situation. Staff found that people in the community generally know Excel no longer
operates out of that facility, so when Staff looked at the area, they realized the City of Tonka Bay
owned part of the property. When properties fall under multiple jurisdictions, it creates a tricky
situation. He added that Staff also discovered three other properties in a similar situation, where
existing owners must deal with multiple cities for everything from property taxes to utility bills to
voting. At the Council's direction, Staff worked with Tonka Bay to clean up the properties so all
the small slivers of property shown on the map go with the larger piece of property. He noted that
Excel did not request this; the city initiated it. If Excel Energy ever wanted to change this, they
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 10 of 15
would have to apply for a separate Comprehensive Plan Amendment in the future. He pointed
out that the boundaries have already shifted and, from Staff's perspective, changes are needed
so regulations are in place if anything happens in the future.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked about a property on the map and if it was the same parcel as
the parent property next to it. Planning Director Griffiths shared that they are two separate
properties. He noted that Excel owns three parcels, and he pointed them out on the map on the
screen. He stated that the municipal boundary has already shifted, so the properties are now in
Shorewood, but no Comprehensive Plan or Zoning District is assigned to the properties. Staff is
working to put the rules in place so they are prepared.
Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that the last time the Council talked about the Comprehensive
Plan, they were forced to change some zoning from commercial to residential. She asked why it
would not be done now if it could happen again in the future. Planning Director Griffiths noted
that he expected the Council would have to go through the process again as part of the
Comprehensive Plan update. He pointed out that the Council could wait; however, the question
is who is leading the charge. Typically, a project proposer would initiate this, and the City would
know exactly what is coming forward. During the previous Comprehensive Plan update, the City
discussed the property, but decided to hold off and leave things as they are. Staff is working with
that direction. He stated that Council could wait and play the Met Council's number game, and
that waiting would offer little benefit because the City would get more credit with the Met Council
in the density calculations. He noted that those conversations would come with the
Comprehensive Plan update.
Councilmember DiGruttolo noted a mismatch in the information: the Staff letter and the future use
land maps stated public/semi-public, but the language in Resolution No. 26-51 states commercial.
She said she did not know whether it mattered. Planning Director Griffiths said that was a good
catch and asked when the motion was made to make it public/semi-public.
DiGruttolo moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Changing the language to say public/semi-
public instead of commercial on Resolution No. 26-51.
Motion passed 5/0.
Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-51, "A Resolution
Approving a Comprehensive Plan Amendment for 5 Parcels Located at Parcel ID
3311723110089, 3311723110045, 3311723120020, 3311723120001, and 3311723120090 Due
to a Recent Municipal Boundary Adjustment with the City of Tonka Bay." ORDINANCE NO.
633, "An Ordinance Amending Section 1201.09, Subd. 2 of the Shorewood Zoning Code —
The Shorewood Zoning Map for 5 Parcels Located at Parcel ID 3311723110089,
3311723110045, 3311723120020, 3311723120001, and 3311723120090." RESOLUTION NO.
26-56, "A Resolution Approving the Summary Publication for Ordinance 633 Amending
Section 1201.09, Subd. 2 of the Shorewood Zoning Code — The Shorewood Zoning Map for
5 Parcels Located at Parcel ID 3311723110089, 3311723110045, 3311723120020,
3311723120001,and 3311723120090."
Motion passed 5/0.
D. Street Sign Sale
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 11 of 15
Public Works Director Morreim reviewed the street sign sale as found in the Agenda Packet.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked if all the signs were street signs or if there were other types.
Public Works Director Morreim stated that the ones saved are all street signs; others are recycled.
Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Approving the Plan to Sell the Retired Street Signs.
Motion passed 5/0.
E. Safe Routes to School Grant — Galpin Lake Trail
City Engineer Budde provided an overview of the Safe Routes to School grant, as included in the
Agenda Packet.
Councilmember DiGruttolo stated that in December, when the Council asked about the grant,
Staff estimated the City portion would be roughly $112,000, and it is now $134,428, which is
$22,428 more. She asked why that is. City Engineer Budde explained that two factors are at
play: the grant dollars have slowly gone down because, based on what the City initially identified
in previous estimates, construction costs have been coming down, so MnDOT bases it on the low
bid. He reminded the Council that the project is in MnDOT right-of-way, so staff had Council
approve the plan set in January or February. The design was completed and submitted to
MnDOT, but it must go through their review process, which has drawn significant criticism. When
MnDOT came back to the City, they said they needed more information on the proposed retaining
wall design. He continued that Staff intended to get soil borings before presenting it, but access
to the area was so challenging that it was not done, and the intent was to get the borings when
the contractor came in to clear the trees. MnDOT was not okay with that, so the City awarded a
separate contract to remove the trees to get a soil boring. Once that was done, it identified about
10 to 15 feet of poor soils beneath the lake. Hence, the City worked with MnDOT and the
geotechnical engineer to determine the best solution for constructing something in that location.
The City had to go through more revisions and iterations to get something MnDOT was okay with
building into their right-of-way and to address the underlying poor soils without completely
excavating them out. Ultimately, they landed on constructing a reinforced soil slope, which is
different than a retaining wall that was proposed. He shared that they had many conversations
about staging and timing, so if this is approved, the process would allow time for the fill to settle
over the winter, and final paving would take place in spring 2027. Construction costs went down,
but engineering costs went up to address the problems. He pointed out that this section of the
project is pinched between the Highway 7 guardrail and the lake. Permitting requirements for the
lake means the City cannot go closer to the lake; the trail has a limited footprint.
Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that it looks like a challenging design. He asked how
confident Staff is that it will last. City Engineer Budde explained how it is set up: Staff completed
a preliminary design of the reinforced soil slope. The City requires in the contract that the
contractor submit an engineer -approved reinforced soil slope design. That ensures the design
cost is a contractor cost and is reimbursed through the grant. He added that he is confident the
contractor will develop an engineered, constructible solution that helps balance the risks of the
underlying poor soils.
Councilmember Gorham asked if the design is a delegated design and the contractor will submit
something when they start. City Engineer Budded shared that if the City awards the contract, one
of the first things the contractor will do is engage their wall designer to get a design as a shop
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 12 of 15
drawing. The City will review it with the structural and geotechnical engineers to confirm the
proposed solution is the best option. Councilmember Gorham shared that another project on
Yellowstone is similar and complicated. He noted that it is an exciting project for the people on
that side of Highway 7, phase one of access in that area. City Engineer Budde noted that at least
three parents reached out saying they thought it would be ready for school, but he told them it
would not be this year. Parents are paying attention to the project.
Mayor Labadie asked what year the City did the Legislative bus tour in the project area. City
Engineer Budde stated it was in 2021, before the Planning grant.
Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-055, "A Resolution
Approving the Safe Routes to School Grant Agreement for the Galpin Lake Trail Project;
City Project 25-01 Grant Terms and Conditions SAP NO. 216-010-010."
Motion passed 5/0.
F. Galpin Lake Trail Construction Contract
City Engineer Budde further explained the Galpin Lake Trail Construction Contract from the last
Item, as found in the Agenda Packet.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked how long it would be before more maintenance is done on it
for the settlement after the June 18 date. City Engineer Budde said he is not sure and will not
know until they go out there, clear some of the soil, and work with a contractor to see what it looks
like. The soil borings that were received indicated up to three inches of settlement, so they hope
most of that will go away. He pointed out that it is pitched to Highway 7, so even if it settles to the
lakeside, it flattens out a little better and still stays ADA compliant. He noted that there is some
risk with it. The ultimate solutions brought up were hundreds of thousands of dollars more
expensive, more damaging to the environment, and required more coordination with MnDOT.
This is the economic trade-off between being able to do the project and fitting into the existing
footprint.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked if there would be a fence along the lakeside. City Engineer
Budde shared that there would be a fence along the entire lakeside, essentially closing off the
area because there is a drop-off of five to six feet at the worst. Councilmember Sanschagrin
asked if the cost was already included for the fence. City Engineer Budde shared that it is.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked who pays for additional fill, testing, drainage plates, or
settlement beyond the assumptions. City Engineer Budde explained that, as part of construction
and because it is State Aid funded or eligible, the City must follow a materials -control schedule
that specifies how often testing is needed for the fill and the pavement. That has to be followed.
Any testing beyond that would be a City expense.
Councilmember Gorham asked whether Staff had any concerns about Boulder Creek, Inc. doing
the work. City Engineer Budde admitted he had never worked with them, but he had reached out
to some colleagues. Boulder Creek, Inc. is based in Wilmar and is a fairly new company, but he
spoke with the owner, who has a solid resume with the last 20 years working on similar projects.
He added that Boulder Creek, Inc. is a general contractor, so they do little of the work themselves
and subcontract most of it. He noted that it is a unique model, but after speaking with the owner,
he feels confident moving forward with Boulder Creek, Inc.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 13 of 15
Councilmember Gorham asked if Highway 7 will need to be shut down. City Engineer Budde
stated that Highway 7 will not be shut down, but a lane will be closed. The contractor plans to
close a lane when bringing in the material; this requires a permit, and the contractor must submit
a traffic control plan that both the City and MnDOT approve. Councilmember Gorham asked if
MnDOT is okay with a lane closure. City Engineer Budde shared that they are. There has not
been much discussion, but the field manuals allow it; it is usually not allowed during peak hours.
The City will see what MnDOT says.
Sanschagrin moved, Gorham seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-054, "A
Resolution to Award a Construction Contract for Galpin Lake Trail Project; City Project 25-
01."
Motion passed 5/0.
G. Limited Use Permit with MnDOT — Galpin Lake Trail
City Engineer Budde reviewed the Limited Use Permit as found in the Agenda Packet.
Councilmember DiGruttolo asked whether, if MnDOT decides in the future to cut off access or
remove the trail, the City would have to pay back the grant. City Engineer Budde stated no. He
is not aware of any timeframe with the grant to keep the structure in place. Councilmember
DiGruttolo stated that with all the uncertainty, she did not want the City to be on the hook to pay
it back.
Maddy moved, Gorham seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 26-057, "A Resolution for
a Limited Use Permit for the Galpin Lake Trail Project; City Project 25-01 SAP NO. 216-010-
010."
Motion passed 5/0.
5. STAFF AND COUNCIL REPORTS AND DISCUSSION
A. Staff
i. Gravity Investment Lot Combination and Anticipated Residential
Development North of Watten Ponds
Planning Director Griffiths provided an overview of the request, as outlined in the Agenda Packet.
He noted that this process is normally handled administratively, not on the Council's Agenda.
City Attorney Shepherd noted that this is routine. Still, given its proximity to the Watten Ponds
project and the adjacent subdivision, the City provided extra notice to the Council and the public.
Regarding the EAW, he reminded the Council of their decision. He noted that the EAW petition
requested that it involve not only the two lots in the Watten Ponds subdivision proposals, but also
other lots. The Council's resolution, however, confined the project to the two -lot Watten Ponds
subdivision; it does not include this parcel. He shared that, as the EAW process plays out, it does
not give the Council any ability to impact the lot combination.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 14 of 15
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked whether it is appropriate for the City to work with Gravity
Investment, since it is involved in litigation against the City. City Attorney Shepherd shared that
the City is not really working with them; they are a property owner and have property rights.
Gravity Investment is complying with Hennepin County and the City's codes; they cannot be
treated differently because they are litigating against the City for a different matter. The City must
follow its policies and not apply them discriminatorily because it has a beef with them.
Councilmember Sanschagrin noted that he was concerned that it would impact the litigation
somehow. City Attorney Shepherd shared that it would not.
Tentative Upcoming Agenda Topics
Mayor Labadie shared that the document would stand on its own.
Public Works Director Morreim shared that the pavement sealing and crack filling projects were
completed last week. Some sweeping of material on the pavement -sealing streets will begin
soon. Fiber installation for Midco continues mostly on the East side of Shorewood, and progress
is posted on their website; they hope to be done this fall. He said the City is still in a drought, and
less water is being pumped with the cooler weather, but the City is seeing the effects of not having
much rain; more rain is needed.
Councilmember Sanschagrin asked how the wells are doing in terms of water capacity. Public
Works Director Morreim stated that the City is fine.
Public Works Director Morreim explained that during drought months, the wells run 10 to 12 hours
a day to meet demand; in January, the wells run four to five hours every other day. That is a
significant difference between the months. Councilmember Sanschagrin said he has not seen
the pumps, but they are pretty big. Public Works Director Morreim agreed.
Planning Director Griffiths shared that the most recent Shore Report includes several Planning
Department activities. Staff is seeking resident feedback on trees, and the Planning Commission
is taking the first steps to update the Tree Preservation Policy. He happily reported that the City
already has about 40 responses and asked the Council to share survey information. He said staff
is working hard to get the deer management program up and running for the fall. They will work
with hunters to get things going in early October, with hunt dates to follow and more information
to come. He shared that many Comprehensive Plan update events are coming up: September
16 at the SCEC from 6:00 P.M. to 8:00 P.M.; there will be a Citywide visioning session. He shared
that everyone is invited and much of the Planning Commission would be in attendance. He hoped
to see Council at Movie in the Park on September 19, or to host an open house on the islands
the next week. He mentioned that he would have information from the first survey at the next
meeting.
Councilmember Gorham asked what the movie would be at Movie in the Park. Planning Director
Griffiths stated Zootopia 2.
City Administrator Nevinski shared that the Public Safety Open House is October 1 at Station 1.
He noted that the Interim Fire Chief is working with a candidate for the interim administrative role,
which will hopefully be finalized soon. Fire has advertised the Fire Marshal/Assistant Chief role
and has several candidates, and there have been discussions about how that role will interact
with the cities.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
Page 15 of 15
B. Mayor and City Council
Councilmember DiGruttolo thanked City Administrator Nevinski for the email sent before Labor
Day and would like to see more of those.
Councilmember Gorham agreed. He pointed out that there is no work session on October 12,
and the speed -limit discussion from the work session could be moved to that day.
Councilmember Sanschagrin shared that he would be at the Comprehensive Plan update on
Wednesday.
Mayor Labadie shared that that morning there was a Highway 7 discussion as part of the
Southwest Corridor Transit Coalition. They went through Highways 5, 212, and 7. The first two
are underway and nearing completion. The Coalition highlighted where the funds for Highways
5 and 212 came from, and much of it came from the county. So, for Highway 7, the County will
be a place to try for more funding. She added that federal fly funding is important, but no one is
applying for Highway 7. She added that she was going to get some slides from the meeting on
successes at different levels. She noted that that afternoon she met with the Regional Council
of Mayors, with the first speaker being Secretary of State Steve Simon. She encouraged
everyone to hear him speak if they were able. It gave all the mayors in the room confidence in
the election system. She added that the speech was bipartisan.
6. ADJOURN
Maddy moved, Sanschagrin seconded, Adjourning the City Council Regular Meeting of
September 14, 2026, at 9:50 P.M.
Motion passed.
ATTEST: e_44'e Z:n�_
P16fet/Labadie, Mayor
Sandie Thone, City Clerk