Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout08-18-26 Planning Comm Mtg MinutesCITY OF SHOREWOOD COUNCIL CHAMBERS PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING 5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD TUESDAY, AUGUST 18, 2026 7:00 P.M. MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Chair Huskins called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M. ROLL CALL Present: Chair Huskins; Commissioners Holker, Longo, Magistad, and Braithwaite; Planning Director Griffiths; Planner Osowski; and Council Liaison Gorham Absent: None APPROVAL OF AGENDA Longo moved, Braithwaite seconded, approving the agenda for August 18, 2026, as presented. Motion passed 5/0. APPROVAL OF MINUTES June 2, 2026 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes Chair Huskins noted that the zoning code update was referenced in the June 2, 2026 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes as potentially being on tonight’s agenda, but he did not see it on the agenda. Planning Director Griffiths shared that the zoning code update was not yet ready, and that it would likely be on the Commission’s next agenda for their September meeting. Holker moved, Magistad seconded, approving the Planning Commission Meeting Minutes of June 2, 2026, as presented. Motion passed 5/0. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR No one wished to address the Commission. PUBLIC HEARINGS COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT & REZONING DUE TO RECENT MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY ADJUSTMENT Planning Director Griffiths reviewed the Plan Amendment and Rezoning as found in the Agenda Packet. Chair Huskins asked whether the reason this is coming before the Commission is that the Joint Resolution is contingent upon the Commission's approval and transmission to the City Council. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it was not true. He explained that the boundary adjustment has already been completed. The reason this matter is before the Commission now is that the boundary between the two cities has changed; Shorewood must update its Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Map to reflect the change. Both of those updates are within the purview of the Planning Commission, so this is the follow-up in the process and the reason it is before the Commission. Commissioner Magistad stated that these properties are proposed to be designated Public/Semi-Public in the Comprehensive Plan and C-1 General Commercial on the City's Zoning Map. He asked how the two are compatible. Planning Director Griffiths explained that in the current Comprehensive Plan, the future land use designation is Public/Semi-Public. Still, the City Zoning Code specifies that the only district where semi-public uses are allowed is the commercial district. That Comprehensive Plan notes that these are typically commercial properties. He added that it is not a one-to-one district with the same name and title, but the Zoning Code implements the direction of this district through the C-1 zoning designation. The City does not currently have a semi-public zoning district. Commissioner Magistad asked if Xcel’s current use is not considered legally nonconforming. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it is a conditional use in the C-1 district and that Xcel has a conditional use permit from the City dating back to the 1960s that allows them to operate. Commissioner Magistad asked if the Comprehensive Plan is implemented, what are the potential implications for a new development. Planning Director Griffiths noted that the City's plans are currently inconsistent. He added that if a development proposal were submitted now, the City would have no rules for the back part of the property. By making the update, the City is ensuring consistency. He noted that it does not really change anything, but the reason for doing this is to ensure the City has the controls in place if something were to happen on the property. Commissioner Magistad asked whether an amendment is likely in the future. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it could be. He shared that Xcel has tried to market the property for sale, as they are not currently using it. He added that the City has not received any applications for that project. Chair Huskins asked if that is how it is currently guided with the current Codes. Planning Director Griffiths noted that to be correct. Chair Huskins asked whether anything would change in the Code updates underway. Planning Director Griffiths shared that it would not. He added that with the Comprehensive Plan update happening in the next few years, things could change. He imagined that there would be discussion about the property, but the City is not there yet. In the short term, the City needs to update now to ensure there are controls in place should something come to light. Chair Huskins opened the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:16 P.M. No one wished to comment on the application. Chair Huskins closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:16 P.M. Holker moved, Longo seconded, recommending approval for the Comprehensive Plan Amendment and Rezoning due to recent municipal boundary adjustments. Motion passed 5/0. Chair Huskins asked when the matter would go before the City Council. Planning Director Griffiths shared that it would be on September 14. 2027 ZONING & LAND USE FEE SCHEDULE Planning Director Griffiths reviewed the 2027 Zoning and Land Use Fee Schedule as found in the Agenda Packet. Commissioner Magistad stated that, in the interest of transparency, considerable thought went into the new fee schedule. He asked if there was a way to show examples of why some of these costs are being proposed. He noted that when the new fees are published, there should be reference material for residents who will be paying them, explaining why the fees changed or are perceived as expensive. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it can be done. He asked whether it should be more than what is already in the Staff Report regarding the explanations of the fees. Commissioner Magistad stated that he is thinking of more information. He asked if the City could show a worksheet showing how the calculation changed. Planning Director Griffiths explained that he could try to add more language for the changes in the fee schedules. He shared that some of the changes lack an explanation for why they are being made, such as the elimination of the PUD fee and the escrow language. Staff would like to make the charging of the costs a little more equitable. He stated that if there were wholesale changes, then he could provide better calculations. Commissioner Magistad stated that Staff has expanded the items subject to an escrow deposit. He has had to pay an escrow before and wondered what he was paying for. He asked if there is a way to clarify what people are paying for. For example, if the deposit itself has not changed but the list of items that go into it has, he asked the City to explain what goes into the deposit. Commissioner Holker noted that a person may request a refund of unused escrow funds. The City must have a calculation for when a person puts $5,000 into escrow and then wants to get the extra back. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it is currently itemized by hours, so anyone who has an escrow on file with the City can request a list, and the City will provide it as a receipt. He noted that he could provide hypotheticals or examples of how that might change. Commissioner Magistad shared that examples would be all he needed. Planning Director Griffiths asked whether the Commission should see that, or whether Staff should include it in the City Council memo. Commissioner Magistad stated that it could be presented to the City Council. Planning Director Griffiths noted that Staff could put together some real-life examples to share. Commissioner Holker asked how many people actually request the reconciliation and money back. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the scope of the project is what makes the difference. He shared that at the last meeting, there were simple garage applications, and all of those applicants are getting money back; the City is not spending $1,000 in escrow costs for those projects. Larger projects are much more complex, and the City typically bills the owners because it has run over the escrow amount. He shared that once the project is complete, the City receives notice and automatically refunds the money; the City does not rely on people to reach out. Commissioner Magistad stated that there have been questions in the past that Staff has clarified, but providing some examples could save Staff time. Chair Huskins stated that in the case where the City ends up billing more than the escrow, he asked whether the resident or whoever paid the escrow is notified when the escrow has been exhausted and given the option to contribute additional funds, or whether the City simply bills for any costs exceeding the escrow. Planning Director Griffiths noted that Staff keeps good track of it. As part of the City Council approval of invoices for the City, Staff goes through the cycle once every two weeks. If something is really close or he thinks it will run over, then he will let applicants know ahead of time. He shared that they have the option from there. He added that most applicants wait until they receive an invoice to know how much they owe the City. Larger developers will sometimes overpay the escrow upfront because they do not want to deal with the hassle halfway through a project. He noted that if it were his project, he would want to know how close the cost is. Staff is also upfront with people about whether they will receive a refund. Chair Huskins asked if there is a written process that states what Planning Director Griffiths shared. Planning Director Griffiths said that on the application form, Staff walks through the escrow process, so when people sign the form, it is on there, and that is communicated as well. Chair Huskins asked whether there is any guarantee that the escrowed amount will be sufficient. Planning Director Griffiths stated that there is not, but the amounts are what a typical application might expect based on trends. Chair Huskins asked whether people knew in advance that more money might be needed. Planning Director Griffiths stated that people do know. He added that escrows are nice round numbers and are best guesses based on trends, but there is so much variety that the amounts are flexible. Staff notifies applicants as escrow amounts are nearing depletion. Chair Huskins opened the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:29 P.M. No one wished to comment on the application. Chair Huskins closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:29 P.M. Holker moved, Magistad seconded, recommending approval of the 2027 Zoning and Land Use Fee Schedule as presented by Staff. Motion passed 5/0. Chair Huskins asked when the matter would go before the Council. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the exact date is being finalized to align with the Council budget calendar. He noted that he would inform the Commission and include the additional information for the Council. OTHER BUSINESS – DISCUSS TREE PRESERVATION POLICY UPDATE Planner Osowski reviewed the Tree Preservation Policy as found in the Agenda Packet. Commissioner Holker stated that the Wayzata tree removal permit was discussed. She asked whether, under the current Code, property owners would be permitted to clear-cut a property with trees if they wanted to. Planning Director Griffiths stated that, under Shorewood’s current policy, there are no mechanisms for existing properties. The property owner can essentially clear-cut their property and nothing can be done. He noted that there are some caveats to that: lake-shore properties have different rules because State laws govern them. Commissioner Holker stated that this leads her to believe that eight trees per acre seems light, especially if someone is developing a ton of land with a ton of trees on it. She added that it would be hard for her to require one-for-one or one-for-two replacement of the trees if the next-door neighbor could clear-cut their trees. That is something the City should deal with. Planner Osowski noted that the one-for-one is the more stringent, and the two-for-one is used when a person cuts down trees they should not have and must replant them. He added that cities have a range of replanting ratios. Planning Director Griffiths shared that another trend in recent ordinances is the inclusion of a look-back period for tree removal. He gave an example of someone coming in with a development application: there are currently no trees on the property, but in the last year the site was clear-cut. Many cities have added that they would review old photos of the property, and if trees were cut down recently, the applicant would still have to accommodate them. That is something Staff would recommend. Commissioner Holker stated that with the two-year look-back for trees, a bulldozer could be parked on the roots now and it looks fine, but later it does not. She asked if the City polices that. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the City does police that. He added that, especially for larger development projects, a development agreement is in place that includes a two-year warranty for trees. He explained that after the project is complete, the City conducts annual inspections of the trees during the warranty period. If a tree is dead, the money will be returned to the property owner once a tree is planted. For larger projects, the City will hold funds for the two-year warranty period, so if the developer does nothing, the City can step in and plant the trees. He shared that, for smaller projects, there is insufficient coverage because there is no tool to conduct follow-up visits under the current Code. Commissioner Longo stated that in some developments, there are trees the builder did not remove, but over the years they have started to die. He asked if the City is checking on those trees. Planning Director Griffiths shared that under the current policy, tree protections apply only during the development window, after which property owners can cut them down. He noted that this is something to consider as part of this update: how the City ensures the trees are protected. There will always be some level of tree removal that occurs without the City's knowledge. He shared that an example of that would be the Country Club; it was a golf course, so there were not many trees out there, and the trees that were saved were really important. Now it has been a few years, and some of those trees are gone. He added that Staff can look into ways to ensure the trees are protected for as long as possible. Chair Huskins asked why an eight-trees-per-acre replacement was being suggested. Planning Director Griffiths stated that he is not sure. He shared that, at the time it was adopted, the current policy was reviewed by an arborist, but there are no clear records explaining why the number was set to eight. Chair Huskins stated that a property may not be able to support eight trees per acre, and those trees would be donated to a public property. He asked whether that occurs and how often. Planning Director Griffiths stated that during his time in Shorewood, he is not aware of any such situations. He shared that the City's view of the issue is that the eight-trees-per-acre threshold is pretty low, and most properties can accommodate eight trees. Some properties are heavily wooded and would struggle to follow the rule. Chair Huskins explained that it would be difficult to follow. Still, most would agree with it: whatever the density of development in the surrounding area, that density of trees should somehow be reflected, depending on the size of the structure or development. He added that, however many trees are taken out, they should be replaced. He noted that many are concerned that too many trees are being taken down to support the most recent developments. Planner Osowski shared that removing as many trees as possible could be helpful. If 80 percent of the top diameter of the trees is being replaced and that work is done off-site, then even if the site cannot accommodate the trees, they are still being planted somewhere in the City. Planning Director Griffiths pointed out that, after speaking with city staff in Minnetonka, Minnetonka made a very conscious effort to emphasize that trees are important to them, and that this may mean some projects cannot proceed because trees need to be saved. Minnetonka did not just mean development projects; it meant that homeowners might not be able to build a deck or a pool where they want to because of the tree on the property that needs to stay. Shorewood could consider that as an option. He noted that if the Commission is looking for a range of options, then the three examples in the packet are representative of the spectrum. All three cities do things very well and make compromises based on the unique character of their city. He added that most people agree that preserving trees is really important; it is just a matter of how to get there in this situation. Commissioner Holker asked if there would be a formal public hearing once the policy is ready. Planning Director Griffiths explained that tonight is the kickoff for the discussion. Staff has done extensive internal research but wants to hear from the Commission on what to prioritize and consider as the policy is developed. In the next newsletter, there will be a survey on tree preservation that allows community residents to provide input. That feedback will serve as the basis for developing the policy. Staff is hoping to have this back to the Commission for a public hearing in November, but since it is a City Code update, if more time is needed, that can happen as well. Chair Huskins pointed out that the City contracts with an arborist to conduct a review and then charges the applicant for those fees. He presumed that the applicant would have an arborist contribute, at their cost, to put forward a proposal, and that if the City arborist disagrees or recommends not approving, it would be a double cost to the applicant. He wanted to think about how that process will be arbitrated between the arborist representing the applicant and the arborist representing the City. The easy approach may be not to use an arborist, but to be very strict about which trees can be removed for a project. Commissioner Longo noted that the City would have to be careful, because if someone wants to install a pool and needs to remove a tree to do so, there is no other option for the City to say that tree cannot be taken down. Chair Huskins stated it sounds like Minnetonka has made that choice. Planning Director Griffiths shared that Minnetonka has, but the other communities do have arborists on staff. When speaking with arborists for research, Staff found that tree preservation can be as detailed as the City wants, and that there is more to it than just the trees. That is where Staff feels the City could benefit from an arborist to help them know what else is important beyond the trees. He noted that Staff has not thought through how this would be arbitrated, but they recognize that the City does not have enough projects to need an arborist, so having someone to lean on would be helpful. Natalie Jennings, 25500 Nelsine Drive, stated that she has been a lifelong resident of Shorewood. She noted that what brought her to the meeting was an Eastern White Pine at the corner of Birch Bluff and Eureka North, a tree she has long loved. She pointed out that during the Watton Ponds Environmental Assessment Worksheet process, she learned that the pine sits on a City easement and could be at risk of being cut down to provide access for the Watton Ponds developer. She started asking what Shorewood has in place to protect a tree and found that there is not much protection. She shared that, on her own time and at her own expense, she hired an arborist, Don Mueller, to assess the tree. She has the full report and can send it to anyone who would like it. Mr. Mueller found that the pine is roughly 125 years old. She noted that if the tree were anything other than that, it would be in a museum. She added that Mr. Mueller, the arborist, stated that the pine is remarkable for its size and species; it is unique to the area, and it would be a great shame to lose the tree now. The tree itself is 100 feet tall, 36 inches in diameter, healthy, and poses no risk to people or property. She shared that the arborist checks whether it is dying because the tree would not be approved for a specific designation if it were. She shared that under Wayzata’s heritage standard of 25 inches for diameter, it would qualify immediately for protection. She noted that she is a fan of planting new trees, but planting a new tree alone is not always the answer for mature trees. She shared that if a sapling were planted today, it would be close in size to the white pine she is talking about in 2150, which is not really in anyone’s lifetime. She added that when a mature tree comes down, the web of life and the understory are lost as well. From the DNR website, she found that a single mature tree usually supports 20 to 50 bird species and 200 to 500 insects depending on the tree. She pointed out some of the things other cities do: the one-to-one replacement and the look-back period. She asked the Commission to consider, when reviewing the policy, making some form of heritage tree designation. Some tags on the trees could be done, and cities all do it differently, but there seems to be room in Shorewood for something to be done. She noted that, in speaking with others in the community, many would like to see trees designated. She asked that in Shorewood the policy coverage extends to City-owned land and easements. She also asked that the City require the one-to-one replacement, as it is a great policy for the already designated trees. She added that she is not there to stop development, but that it can be done with care and respect for the land being developed. She explained that she comes back to Shorewood because of the ecosystem, and at the center of a healthy ecosystem are mature trees. Stephen Mastey, 6340 Aster Trail, thanked the Commission for taking the time to discuss the topic. He added that White Pine has always been one of his favorites, as there was one on the property where he grew up in North Central Minnesota. He noted that it is nice to have the tree icons in place, and that removing them is quite devastating. He shared that he is a landscape architect who owns his own business in Excelsior. He shared that his company was invited to consult on a small tree preservation and replacement plan for the City last year. He noted that in consulting on the project, he realized how horribly underwhelming the tree preservation ordinance is. He shared that he has a greater vested interest because, by traveling to and from home, he can experience the amazing resources the City offers. He stated that he believes a tree preservation ordinance is a design tool that should help inform design. He pointed out that Austin has a heritage tree designation, and it is amazing that developers and landowners are challenged to think about the resources they have. He noted that when talking to clients, they ask whether the tree can be replaced, how that would be done, or whether it would be done in their lifetime. When there are provisions in the City ordinance that challenge a design team to work around things, in the end, it is amazing how the elements are embraced and celebrated. He shared that eight trees per acre make no sense to him as someone with extensive experience and education in landscape; there is no metric for that, and it is horribly underwhelming. He added that, in some instances, when only the trees are considered, other wonderful on-site resources may be overlooked. He noted many opportunities to enhance the City's existing Code. He added that his business is happy to be a resource in any way possible, even if that means just attending meetings and offering comments. Commissioner Longo noted that the information is a lot to take in and that there is a lot of feedback to provide. He asked what the next step would be, given all the feedback the Commission has received. Planning Director Griffiths stated that if there are Commissioners who have feedback, they can certainly send it to Staff, along with anyone from the community. He added that sharing the survey that will be in the newsletter will be important. He explained that, moving forward from this meeting and incorporating all the feedback received, Staff will try to draft a policy to be brought back to the Commission for review. He added that he does not have a certain path in the future. Staff is hoping to get this done by the end of the year, but because it is City-initiated, any time can be used. Chair Huskins shared that he would like to take some time to address the questions framed in the Staff Report to see what Commissioners are thinking. He asked whether there should be a maximum number of tree replacements per acre to be maintained. Commissioner Magistad asked whether any of the more stringent cities have scoring cards that assess a tree's ecological value or resilience rather than just counting trees. Planner Osowski noted that they do; Minnetonka, for example, gives greater preference to native species. Another city has a rule that if a deciduous tree is cut down, at least 80 percent of the replacement trees must be deciduous. He added that the primary determining metric is size and should be what the City uses, but there can also be a certain preference for other things. Commissioner Magistad suggested that the City could develop a tool for Staff or a developer to evaluate the developer's plan. Planner Osowski stated that if the City wanted to go that route, he would recommend contracting with an arborist, as that is beyond Staff’s ability to develop something initially. Commissioner Magistad asked whether the City has an inventory of heritage trees, especially those that exist in rights-of-way. Planner Osowski stated that the City had completed a tree management plan. Planning Director Griffiths stated that no Citywide tree survey has been conducted, but the Public Works Department is generally aware of many of the trees. The surveys can be quite expensive to complete, but they are an actionable step. Commissioner Longo asked whether there is a registry of the trees with tags on them. Planning Director Griffiths shared that for certain recently completed development projects, the City is aware of those trees. For trees on City land in particular, there is no comprehensive record, but staff does know where some are. Planner Osowski shared that the City completed a Forest Management Plan in 2017, during which 4,412 publicly managed trees were inventoried. Commissioner Holker noted that the City should not have a maximum requirement for tree replacement. Chair Huskins sensed that the Commission did not consider a metric such as the number of replacement trees per acre helpful. Chair Huskins stated that the Commission had already begun discussing tree size and the distinction between native and non-native trees. He did not think it was an either-or; it can be both: designating heritage trees and clarifying which trees are acceptable for planting in Shorewood. He asked if anyone else had comments about size versus native, or size and native. Commissioner Longo pointed out that the attachment sent was self-explanatory. Chair Huskins noted that Staff asked about hiring a certified arborist to review tree preservation plans. He asked what the Commission thinks about creating a system in which the City would contract with an arborist. Commissioner Magistad noted that some form of professional review would be required in at least some situations, and he is in favor of that. Planning Director Griffiths stated that Staff can flesh this point out more, and it will probably be one of the final things to look at once a policy is in place. He noted that the Commission would like Staff to evaluate this more. Chair Huskins shared that the next set of questions concerned native areas rather than tree replacement. He asked if the Commission thought it was valuable for further discussion. Commissioner Holker stated that there are no policies in place to preserve prairie or other land features. She noted that the question asks whether, if ten more trees are not going to be planted, a prairie could be planted instead. She added that it would be interesting to see whether any other cities are considering prairie preservation as part of their tree preservation efforts. Planning Director Griffiths noted that there are, and that Staff can look into it holistically rather than just focusing on trees. Commissioner Longo shared that on his lot, he has four large trees and there is not room for any more. Planner Osowski noted that other cities have policies that encourage tree species diversity and that these could be achieved using different metrics. He added that the metric would have to be created. Chair Huskins stated that the next set of questions had to deal with trees planted on properties other than the applicant's. He asked if there should be a case against planting the trees on a neighboring property. Commissioner Holker stated that it is an interesting concept, but there would need to be a mechanism in place to ensure that someone does not take 100 trees off their property and then put only 10 back on that property and 90 on others. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the cities reviewed require an arborist to make that determination and that Shorewood could include such a requirement in the policy. Planner Osowski explained that the requirement for all cities is that the trees be planted on the property, and a certified arborist must show that this many trees cannot be replanted on the property, which would then trigger private or public replanting. Planning Director Griffiths stated that in Shorewood, the City could benefit from some of these measures because distinctive topographic features make it difficult to plant trees. This would be seen on the smaller properties in town. Chair Huskins recalled an issue with extensive clear-cutting, in which neighboring communities lost their view, so a concession was made to plant trees to create a buffer. If there had been a policy, then that buffer could have been extended. He liked the idea of having options for going beyond public property. Planning Director Griffiths pointed out that another reason this is seen is because of the tree canopy. The idea is that if trees are removed from an area, there should also be tree replacement to restore the tree canopy in the future. There is a lot of research coming from the Met Council on tree canopy and climate change that Staff has been reviewing. Chair Huskins stated that the next question on the list was on enforcement. The Commission did not speak too much about that. He asked how the Commission feels about stronger enforcement. Commissioner Longo shared that if trees need to be preserved, there must be enforcement in place. Chair Huskins shared that would be more post-development. He added that the City is covered during development because no funds will be released. Planning Director Griffiths noted that Staff was looking for measures such as a look-back period for when people were skirting the rules, and that the City could do so. He added that there are pretty good enforcement mechanisms that could be better during construction. The City lacks in the current policy on what happens afterward. Staff is looking for a general sentiment from the Commissions. These rules are not just about developers but also about the individual property owners who are doing most of the projects. He shared that most cities have something; in Wayzata, a permit is required to cut down any tree. Planner Osowski clarified that anything six inches or greater in diameter needs a permit. Planning Director Griffiths stated that many options are available. Staff is looking to see whether enforcement will be strict and whether the City would be prepared. Chair Huskins pointed out that the policy should include design elements that encourage consideration of situations that would not be permissible. Commissioner Holker noted that she did not know whether Shorewood should be as strict as Wayzata, but that current property owners somehow need to fall under the policy as well. Commissioner Magistad added that it would be helpful to see a visualization of this process, including a workflow. Commissioner Holker added that she loves the concept of heritage trees. That is key. Chair Huskins noted that for diseased trees, there should be a statement emphasizing the importance of their removal. Planning Director Griffiths stated that Staff knows that the City was heavily planted with ash trees and buckthorn, so there is a lot to get rid of. Hennepin County has removed tons of trees, but the policy does not cover that. Chair Huskins noted that the policy should address the City's removal of diseased trees. Commissioner Braithwaite pointed out that there are so many considerations. One being that Staff will need more tools. He noted that, along with the tools, the City needs to ask how much time is realistic to be using the tools. The burden should be placed on the developer during development. He asked how much burden the homeowner will accept, and even if the City has the strictest policies, how will Staff enforce them? He added that it is something he is struggling with. He agreed with what was said and that the City needs more tools to unlock design creativity. He shared that another consideration is whether there is a way to approach incentives rather than penalties. He asked whether there was a way to build a tree fund in time and incentivize tree planting. He pointed out that this policy has many layers and that he is interested in public feedback. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it is a major project that has been on the City's to-do list for years, and Staff is very happy to be getting to it finally. Planning Director Griffiths shared that, in the future, there will be a survey in the newsletter; the Commission will not see much about this in September or October. He added that other projects are underway, such as the Zoning Code update. That update was designed to leave space for the tree preservation policy. He noted that this deserves to be its own separate conversation. If anyone has ideas, they can reach out to Staff. Council Liaison Gorham stated that this is a major legacy project and that there will be strong community interest. He asked if this would be a full rewrite of the policy. There are many good ways to change it, but it is not clear who would be driving this and crafting the document, or whether the Park Commission would be involved. He added that if there are enough items, this may not be possible by the end of the year. Planner Osowski stated that, based on the Commission's and public feedback, Staff would flesh out some of the ideas further, but before bringing a draft in November, there are a step or two to take. Chair Huskins thanked Councilmember Gorham for pointing out that the Park Commission may need to be included. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it would be good feedback, and that where things go will be based on it. From the Staff’s perspective, they anticipated this would be a full update to the policy, as there is a lot to be done. Council Liaison Gorham asked how that would be done. He noted that a Code update could take hours, but this is bigger than that. He asked how priorities would be established and who is in charge of drafting. Commissioner Braithwaite noted that the framework was set by going through the questions, which showed the Commission's agreement and gave Staff room to craft. He added that if there are sticking points, then it could be brought back to the Commission. One of those bullet points from the Report could take a whole night, but in general Staff has received enough feedback. Planner Osowski stated that he did not want to go too deep or show all the policies from different cities because it could be confusing. He suggested that the Commission review policies from other cities to better understand what Shorewood would like to do. Planning Director Griffiths explained that the three cities are models of what is currently being done. He added that Edina’s policy was challenged by the Building Association and successfully upheld, which shows it is a good, updated policy. Commissioner Magistad noted that it would be good to see a summary table of how the City is benchmarking. REPORTS CITY COUNCIL Council Liaison Gorham gave a brief overview of recent Council discussions and decisions. Chair Huskins asked whether Council had made any land-use decisions. Planning Director Griffiths pointed out that the July meeting was canceled and that the Council approved three garage developments that are now under construction. Commissioner Longo asked about Eureka. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the lots are there and are for sale. He believed one had been sold, but the two lots on the corner were still there. Commissioner Longo asked about the concept plan. Planning Director Griffiths noted that the City Council denied the application and that no reapplication has been filed. Chair Huskins stated that if the Community Center were to go away, a precinct would go away as well, and it would need to be considered where it would go. Council Liaison Gorham stated that many events take place there in addition to senior programming, but the Council would like to see the center become more self-sustaining. He added that it is a very important piece of the community and questioned how the City can maintain it without causing too much strain on the budget. He added that a task force is working on recommendations to align with the budget. STAFF Planning Director Griffiths shared that there would be a Planning Commission photo after the meeting. He shared that on September 1, at the next meeting, no applications are planned, but the meeting will serve as a final walkthrough of the Zoning Code update. He noted that the DNR sidetracked the Zoning Code update in June. The issue was that the DNR had no record that the City’s original shoreland ordinance from the 1970s was ever approved, and the City could not find any record of it either. This meant the City had to undergo the full DNR review of the shoreland ordinance, which was passed. There will not be enough time to notice a public hearing before September 1, so the Commission will walk through the Zoning Code update and make tweaks where necessary. He noted that many events for the Comprehensive Plan update are coming up, and he strongly encouraged the Commission to attend the citywide visioning session on September 16, where they will have a chance to engage in an in-depth conversation about where the community wants the City to be. He will be sending out a press kit, and he asked the Commission to share it. Many of the open houses will be held in neighborhoods to encourage participation. He added that Phase One is wrapping up at the end of August and is mostly behind the scenes. At an upcoming meeting, he would have more information on the feedback received. He asked for a Commissioner Liaison for the September 14 City Council meeting. Chair Huskins volunteered. Council Liaison Gorham asked whether the citywide visioning session is a workshop run by the consultant with easels or whiteboards. Planning Director Griffiths explained that the session will be held at the Community Center and will start at 6:00 P.M., with a presentation by City Staff outlining what a Comprehensive Plan is and sharing some of the survey feedback that was received. The rest of the time will be spent conducting whiteboard and tabletop exercises to develop a vision for the future. He noted it would be a cool event and that it would be nice if Commissioners could be there. Council Liaison Gorham asked what the difference is between the visioning session and other open houses. Planning Director Griffiths shared that the visioning session will be more hands-on, and the open houses are being advertised with the message that Staff will be in the neighborhoods and that people should stop by to share their thoughts. Invitations will also be sent to neighborhoods and their contacts; the City is trying to make it easier for residents to share their feedback. Staff is excited to meet people and to offer many geographical options. Chair Huskins asked if the expectation is that the Commission will identify themselves with the City. Planning Director Griffiths noted that, if they wished, they could. Chair Huskins stated that the intent should be to listen far more than to talk. He added that the Commission’s presence will be valuable. Council Liaison Gorham stated that, in the visioning session, the Commission is there because they have more input into what happens in the City. Planning Director Griffiths asked that the Commission attend the visioning session, talk to the people there, and engage with them. Chair Huskins noted that the dynamics can be really messy, as he will try to participate without dominating, and he does not want to be expected to have the answers. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it will be communicated that there is no plan yet and that Staff is trying to get the community's vision. Commissioner Longo asked whether having more than three Commissioners present would be a problem. Planning Director Griffiths explained that the City has the ability to notice a potential quorum to avoid an open meeting law violation. Everyone from the Commission can attend; they cannot discuss items on the Commission's agenda. The Comprehensive Plan can be talked about. COMMISSION The Commission had nothing to share. ADJOURNMENT Longo moved, Braithwaite seconded, adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of August 18, 2026, at 8:54 P.M. Motion passed 5/0.