HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-01-26 Planning Comm Mtg MinutesCITY OF SHOREWOOD COUNCIL CHAMBERS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING 5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 1, 2026 7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Huskins called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
ROLL CALL
Present: Chair Huskins; Commissioners Holker, Magistad, and Braithwaite; Planning Director Griffiths; Planner Osowski and Council Liaison Gorham
Absent: Commissioner Longo
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Braithwaite moved, Holker seconded, approving the agenda for September 1, 2026, as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES - NONE
MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
No one wished to address the Commission.
PUBLIC HEARINGS - NONE
OTHER BUSINESS
DISCUSS ZONING CODE UPDATE
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed the Zoning Code Update as found in the Agenda Packet.
Commissioner Braithwaite asked whether the old Shoreland Ordinance had to be approved to approve the change. Planning Director Griffiths shared that the DNR approved everything right
away; they did not require the City to go back and rehash anything. Staff was appreciative of that.
Planning Director Griffiths continued his presentation of the Zoning Code.
Chair Huskins asked whether it is fair to say there will be a phase 1A between phases 1 and 2 to make changes, such as tree preservation, before the Comprehensive Plan is approved.
Planning Director Griffiths shared that topical amendments will still come up, and the annual Code update will still happen; this is not meant to be the end-all, be-all. Chair Huskins
asked whether this update would be held hostage until the Comprehensive Plan is completed if there is a reason to update the Code. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the City
will continue to update the Code as it makes sense and as directed.
Planning Director Griffiths continued to review the Zoning Code update.
Chair Huskins noted that the discussion portion of the meeting report mentioned the 221 properties that will require public hearings due to Code changes. He asked whether all the public
hearings would be held at the same time. Planning Director Griffiths shared that all public hearings would be held at the same time and that he would explain this further in his presentation.
Planning Director Griffiths continued his presentation of the Zoning Code update.
Chair Huskins asked whether the Commission wanted Planning Director Griffiths to walk through all the sections or focus on the sections with questions. Commissioner Holker stated that
she would prefer to focus on the areas where the Commission has questions. Planning Director Griffiths shared that he has a slide for each section to provide a high-level overview
and that he can answer questions about individual sections on those slides.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed Section 1201.10 Introductory Provisions as found in the Agenda Packet.
Commissioner Holker stated that, regarding 1201.14, there is no date for the Comprehensive Plan, which makes it unclear which plan is being worked on. She added that Staff had said
it would be updated once the 2050 Comprehensive Plan is released. She asked if the date should be updated every time. Planning Director Griffiths explained that he has seen it done
both ways, with a date and without. He shared that the date could be added; the City needs to remember to update it every 10 years. He suggested updating the language to say “current”
Comprehensive Plan.
Chair Huskins stated 1201.12 Applicability, unless otherwise stated. He asked Staff to interpret what that means. Planning Director Griffiths shared that the City Code includes sections
addressing nonconforming uses and variances. He explained that this section allows the City to maintain those functions. It acknowledges that some community elements do not currently
meet the Code and may never do so because they are grandfathered in.
Chair Huskins asked about page 10 of the Agenda Packet, Subdivision 2 under 1201.13 Authority, which states “this title”. Planning Director Griffiths noted that this title refers to
the entire Zoning Code, while the chapter refers to its individual components. He asked if that made sense. Chair Huskins stated that it does to him, but not to the casual reader.
He wondered whether there was a way to note that so readers would understand. Planning Director Griffiths noted that they could add language to help explain.
Chair Huskins suggested removing the word "the" from 1201.14, Subdivision 3a, at the end of the second sentence. He added that 1201.14, Subdivision 5d, states that the masculine gender
includes the feminine and neuter. He pointed out that, when updating the Code, the City should conform as much as possible and avoid differentiation or masculine terminology. He noted
that this is a personal preference. He asked if it could be reworded to be gender neutral. Planning Director Griffiths explained that Staff is trying to avoid listing out every gender
every time. So, Staff has been trying to remove the language and may update it to "their," but will review the information.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.20 Definitions as found in the Agenda Packet.
Chair Huskins stated that the definition of division appears at the top of page 14 of the Agenda Packet. He asked if that is a common use of the term. Planning Director Griffiths stated
yes. Chair Huskins noted that subdivisions are a completely different kind of division from those found
in the Code. He asked if there is a need to qualify that. Planning Director Griffiths stated that a short sentence could be added after the definition to clarify that it is not to
be confused with subdivision. He pointed out that it is an industry term for dividing the surface water.
Chair Huskins pointed out on page 14, for the definition of fence – boundary line, that it includes the eight feet, and the Commission had determined that it could be shortened to three
feet. He asked why it is still eight feet. Planning Director Griffiths explained that, during a conversation with the City Council, there was no consensus to change this requirement.
Ultimately, Staff was directed to leave things as the status quo in this department and return to this topic in the future. There was also discussion about privacy fences, which remained
the same for now.
Commissioner Magistad asked whether there was a vote. Planning Director Griffiths shared that the discussion was part of a City Council work session so that no vote could be taken,
and there was no consensus on either change. Council Liaison Gorham shared that the Council had a brief discussion but set it aside because the fence discussion needed more time than
it could have at the time. He noted that part of it also involves waiting to see how the Comprehensive Plan will inform fence decisions. Many residents' opinions on the topic have
been heard. Chair Huskins added that it sounds completely reasonable to defer the topic.
Chair Huskins asked about the fire lane. He pointed out that he understands the definition. One application came before the Commission with a road in and out, a building along one
side, and the entire curb painted yellow so there is no parking. He asked if there is a definition for that particular use. Planning Director Griffiths explained that there is not
because fire lanes are outside of the Zoning Code; they are part of the State Fire Code. For the Zoning Code, the only references are to the City-designated fire lanes, which are the
accesses to Lake Minnetonka. Defining fire lanes this way does not specify which other fire lanes exist; rather, it refers to what Shorewood calls fire lanes. He noted that a sentence
could be added at the end to state that it is not to be misconstrued as fire lanes defined by the State Fire Code. He added that fire lanes are outside the scope of Phase 1, as it
is not a brief topic that will come back before the Commission.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.30 General Zoning as found in the Agenda Packet.
Commissioner Magistad asked how 1201.34 was overhauled in 2025. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it was a stand-alone update to the City Code. Some provisions in the Code were
inconsistent with State law, such as the old Code requiring a variance to build a home on an existing property when the property was already approved and had a home on it. The update
clarified that people have land rights; if someone has a grandfathered home, they can rebuild it as long as it does not violate any terms of the current City Code. He added that the
City also clarified how nonconformities are regulated. For example, shorelines and floodplains are outside the City's purview; State law handles those, so the references were removed.
The update also provided more flexibility for property owners because many properties were grandfathered in. He shared that the City worked with the City Attorney to update the language
and systematically overhaul it from the old rules.
Commissioner Magistad asked whether the number of variances would decrease as a result of the update. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it already has, which is a good thing.
If the City is granting many variances for the same thing over and over again, it is a sign that the Zoning Code is not great. He added that the changes have allowed common sense
projects to move forward. Chair Huskins shared that, over the years, it was rare to have a meeting without contemplating a variance request. Commissioner Magistad noted that the information
should be promoted. Planning Director Griffiths shared that although it has only been a year, it has been a
great policy change. He added that under the old rules, practically any project would have needed a variance.
Commissioner Holker stated that the Commission had discussed a homeowner's request for a variance for a structure on Christmas Lake. She asked whether the Code has been adjusted to
make those structures acceptable. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it has not been adjusted. He explained that it would require the City to significantly update its shoreland
regulations. Staff identified this as something to do after the Comprehensive Plan, as part of a future phase, because other parts of the shoreland regulations also need updating.
He noted that updating shoreland regulations can take 12 to 18 months because working with the DNR can be difficult. The conversation will come in the future.
Commissioner Holker stated that, in the Shoreland area, there was a section on variances, but variances in general were in a different section. That seemed like the exception to combining
things in one section. Planning Director Griffiths noted that Shoreland variances have different criteria than other variances, so the DNR wants the City to keep them as a separate
section of the Code. He explained that the DNR does that because if the City makes changes, the DNR would have to review the entire Zoning Code.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.40 Base Zoning Districts as found in the Agenda Packet.
Chair Huskins noted that a few lines in the tables did not have any characters. Planning Director Griffiths noted that Staff removed those because the thinking is that if nothing is
listed in a line, then it is not allowed anywhere. The Code states that if it is not listed, then it is not allowed, so it is duplicative.
Commissioner Braithwaite stated that the interim use he saw was the cannabis business. Planning Director Griffiths stated that is correct. Commissioner Braithwaite asked for further
explanation as to why. Planning Director Griffiths explained that when the cannabis law changed in Minnesota, the State law allows cities to regulate where those businesses are located.
Under a separate section of the City Code, buffer distances apply: cannabis businesses cannot be within 700 feet of a school or 500 feet of a park. The other thing the State law allowed
cities to do was require a conditional use permit or an interim use permit for these types of applications. He shared that when the rules were put in place, the City opted for the
interim use permit route because interim uses give the City greater flexibility to revoke approval if issues arise with the use. A conditional use permit is an indefinite use. He
stated that if an interim use permit were approved, there would be conditions tied to factors such as repeated violations of the City Code, in which case the permit would be revoked.
That is unique to the interim use permit process. He explained that part of the reason the current Code has no other interim use permits is that interim use permits are relatively
new in Minnesota, having been introduced only in 2014. The State Legislature created them because cities wanted a little more flexibility than the conditional-use permit process allowed.
From Staff’s perspective, he supports the interim use permit process for many different uses, but those changes are not being made now because the rules have been in place for so long.
Chair Huskins pointed out that many counterparts exist, such as a fire permit, which is an interim use permit for one year. He added that a fishing license, dog license, or even a
driver’s license is conceptually an interim use permit that needs to be justified or renewed in one form or another. Planning Director Griffiths stated that cannabis businesses are
the only interim use permit right now, but that may change in the future, especially if State law changes regarding zoning authority.
Commissioner Magistad noted that firearm dealers are omitted from the table. He asked whether they fit anywhere on the table. Planning Director Griffiths explained that, since it is
not currently listed anywhere, the City Code would state that it is not allowed in the community. Commissioner Magistad asked whether that is stated explicitly somewhere. Planning
Director Griffiths noted that the Code states that if it is not listed, it is prohibited. He shared that he would make sure that it is clear by reviewing the language.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.50 Overlay & Special Zoning Districts as found in the Agenda Packet. He pointed out that he would change the section titles so that the Shoreland
title comes before the word.
Council Liaison Gorham stated that, after reviewing page 55 of the Agenda Packet, some instances read "S District" or "Shoreland District." He asked why it was called the S District.
Planning Director Griffiths shared that, unfortunately, the DNR asked Shorewood to do that. He shared that the DNR likes to do that for floodplain as well, and he agreed that it is
a little cumbersome. Chair Huskins noted that it raises the question: if there is Floodplain F, where are floodplains A through E? Planning Director Griffiths noted that it can cause
problems.
Council Liaison Gorham stated that the Code sometimes reads "S District" and sometimes "Shoreland District." Planning Director Griffiths stated that Staff can review with the DNR to
see whether the issues can be fixed, but if not, it may need to be addressed as a future project.
Commissioner Braithwaite referred to a map on page 8 of the Agenda Packet. He asked if the Shoreland protection zone is the same thing. Planning Director Griffiths stated yes. Commissioner
Braithwaite asked how far that is from the water. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it is 1,000 feet from the high-water level of any lake. Commissioner Braithwaite asked whether
or not the Shoreland regulations applied to the whole lot, or only the portion of the lot within the 1,000 feet of a lake in the property was partially in a Shoreland overlay district.
Planning Director Griffiths shared that it is a math problem. He said the answer is both yes and no. Only the portion of the property within the Shoreland District is subject to
the Shoreland regulations. In practical terms, that means if the property is subject to Shoreland rules, they apply to the entire property. He noted that if there are things like
impervious surface calculations, because Shoreland allows 25 percent hard cover per property instead of 33 percent, then that becomes a math problem. The way the DNR has Shorewood
do that is to take the area of the property within the Shoreland District and multiply it by 0.25, then the area outside it by 0.33, and combine the numbers; that is the maximum for
the property. He pointed out that the rules are applied a bit case by case. Many properties in Shorewood are split.
Commissioner Braithwaite asked whether the Code clarifies that information or addresses it by stating the 1,000-foot Shoreland. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it is clarified
that way. He added that the Zoning Map on page 8 of the packet could be revised to align the wording with the Code and clarify things. Chair Huskins pointed out that the Code states
that if a chart or table conflicts with the text, the text supersedes the chart or table.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.60 Use-Specific Standards as found in the Agenda Packet.
Chair Huskins noted that data centers have received a lot of press lately, especially in Minneapolis. He asked whether the City would ever take a position on Data Centers. He explained
that if the self-storage business went out of business, someone could put a data center there. Planning Director Griffiths shared that he has spoken with the City Attorney because
this
is such a hot-button topic right now. Currently, data centers are not listed as an allowed use in the City Code, so they are not allowed anywhere in Shorewood. Chair Huskins asked
if that creates any legal issues. Planning Director Griffiths said it does not, at this point. He noted that he would not be surprised if, in the next few years, there were Federal
laws on Data Centers, because the pro-data-centers argument is that they are the only industrial growth the Country is seeing right now. Many cons have been raised as well. He shared
that, at this point, he is not anticipating a discussion about data centers because it is not allowed right now. He pointed out that, in his research, data centers are not being considered
in cities like Shorewood because the City lacks the necessary amenities. Staff has not been contacted about building a data center, but he is aware of it. Chair Huskins asked if there
is any legal exposure to not having anything about it in the Code specifically. Planning Director Griffiths stated no; he has spoken with the City Attorney, and this is fairly standard
for other cities. He pointed out that Plymouth has the same interpretation in its code and that it just survived a legal challenge. The court looks at the ordinance's plain language.
He said data centers are an emerging field, and he is surprised there have not been more questions.
Commissioner Braithwaite stated that firearm sales are not listed, so they are not permitted, and data centers are not listed, so they are not permitted. He asked if a new, not-listed
business would be handled as a conditional use. Planning Director Griffiths directed the Commission to page 45 of the Agenda Packet. He read section 1201.41, Subdivision 1b: in the
event a proposed use is not listed in the use table, the Zoning Administrator is authorized to classify the proposed use into an existing use type as outlined in the use table. He
explained that he is getting at the fact that many things are retail, so not all of those are listed. He added that part two of the Code then states that if the Zoning Administrator
makes no similar-use determination, the proposed use is prohibited. He shared that things are not automatically subject to conditional use permits, because the City would have to designate
them as conditional use permits to require one. If something is proposed that is not allowed, Staff would propose that the applicant go through the Zoning Code amendment process and
apply for that as a stand-alone application.
Commissioner Magistad stated that there were some comments regarding subjective language, such as compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood or complementing the character of existing
buildings. He asked how the Commission addresses that. Planning Director Griffiths shared that, for many uses, the Planning Commission and City Council decide, typically through a
conditional use permit. He added that some of the language comes from State law. For example, under State law, a conditional use permit must be within the essential character of the
neighborhood. He pointed out that, unfortunately, it is not clear, but part of that is giving the City a little flexibility to decide what will be a good fit. He noted that he reviewed
the Code extensively, and if there is wishy-washy language he has to enforce, he has made it clear, because he does not want to be put in a position to make that call, or it will come
before the Commission or Council.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.70 Development Standards as found in the Agenda Packet.
Commissioner Braithwaite stated that this is a general formatting observation; the 1201.70 series leaves no room for expansion. He asked whether Staff feels comfortable placing the
future item there. Planning Director Griffiths noted that if a tenth chapter were needed, the City would add another digit: 1201.710. The intent is that this format would avoid the
same problem in the current Code: having to move sections around and renumber things. This makes it easier to update over time.
Chair Huskins pointed out that on the bottom of page 67 of the packet, there is a formatting issue with the (10). Commissioner Braithwaite added that happens whenever there is a ten
in parentheses. Planning Director Griffiths stated that some of the formatting is odd because Staff is writing it for website formatting, not necessarily for print, but there will
be a change to clarify things. He added that the public had some responses about the tables, and the response was that the website is being designed since that is how most people will
view the Code.
Chair Huskins stated that they are not making the wetlands date specific. He asked whether someone has a property on the wetlands that conformed with whatever it was pre-1971, and whether
that language will be removed in the new Code. Is the property grandfathered in, or subject to whatever is necessary in the new Code? Planning Director Griffiths shared that, just
like any other standard that has changed, if someone is legally existing under the old standard and rules, they are grandfathered in. The change applies to new projects, so everything
is treated under the same regulations. He explained that an existing home that fell under the old rules would remain, but if they wanted to build a shed, the shed would fall under
the new rules or require a variance.
Commissioner Magistad stated that, regarding tree preservation, the Commission reviewed the 2004 Tree Management Update at the last meeting. He pointed out that it will be a high-impact,
low-cost change that will be pretty popular. He asked when the City would not only promote the change but also integrate it with the Zoning Code. Planning Director Griffiths noted
that once the Tree Preservation Code update is complete, one thing that needs to be fixed is that it is currently a stand-alone policy outside the City Code. The City would make Tree
Preservation an ordinance, which would then be incorporated into the Zoning Code once it is adopted. He shared that an ordinance has more weight than a policy. It is an important
regulation that should be included in the City Code. He explained that the Tree Preservation policy will be looked at for incorporation into the Zoning Code once it is adopted, and
then it can be promoted. The next newsletter includes an article about it, and the website has a survey with 25 respondents. He envisioned updating the policy in the future to include
many more things. Commissioner Magistad asked if that would happen before or after the Comprehensive Plan. Planning Director Griffiths said Staff anticipates it before the Comprehensive
Plan and is working on it now, with more information coming at the December meeting. He added that after the Zoning Code is completed, Tree Preservation will be the next-highest priority,
other than the Comprehensive Plan.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.80 Signage as found in the Agenda Packet.
Commissioner Braithwaite shared that he read an article about a commercial sign that used no lettering, only themes. He imagined a coffee shop with a painted mural of steaming cups
of coffee, so the business is being advertised, but with no words. He asked whether the sign ordinance covers that as well. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it does. He explained
that the Sign Code states that any commercial business, for example, anything that is used to attract people to the property, is a sign. He noted that, in practice, many cities handle
these types of signs through variances, and commissions and councils then weigh in on whether they are signs. From Staff’s perspective, when signs are looked at, a sign is anything,
whether it has words or not. He pointed out that, fortunately for Shorewood, there are not that many commercial properties, but from time to time there are some sign issues, so the
section in the Code is helpful.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1201.90 Procedures and Enforcement as found in the Agenda Packet.
Council Liaison Gorham asked about 1201.98 Subdivision 1c(1) and whether it would override the City Council's power to approve a vacation. Planning Director Griffiths explained that
under State law, it goes to a simple majority vote if the abutting owners request it. He further explained that under the State statute, if the City were to vacate right-of-way, it
is a supermajority requirement, four-fifths vote; however, if two-thirds of the abutting property owners petition the City Council to vacate, it is a simple majority, three-fifths vote.
Council Liaison Gorham asked whether, in cases where a resident has an easement they want to build on, they can request a vacation of it, and whether, in cases where they have received
compensation for that easement, they would have to pay it back. Planning Director Griffiths shared that it is case by case. Most easements that the City is vacating are old and unnecessary.
He stated that in Shorewood in the mid-80s, the City required large rear-yard easements, 20 to 30 feet wide, whereas today the City requires only a 10-foot easement. So, if the resident
came in today to vacate 20 feet to match the current rule, Staff would be open to that. However, for construction projects, if the City had to pay for an easement and then it is vacated,
that would fall in the City Council’s purview. He added that the statute gives a lot of discretion as to how and when to vacate an easement, and the Council could say no. He explained
that right-of-way has its own rules; if the City Council wanted to vacate a road for some reason that was giving somebody access, the City may have to pay that property owner damages.
Planning Director Griffiths pointed out that the information is a little wordy, but Staff thought that since it is in the application form, the Code should refer to the statute.
Commissioner Magistad asked about zoning amendments and, for example, when a developer requests a zoning amendment, what the hurdles are for them, and whether all zoning amendments are
equal in terms of the hurdles they have to overcome. Planning Director Griffiths stated that they are all equal. He explained that for a zoning amendment, the developer applies on
an application form, there is a public hearing before the Planning Commission, surrounding property owners are notified, and it is published in the newspaper. The application is reviewed
against the standards in the Comprehensive Plan. If the application meets the Comprehensive Plan, the Commission has discretion because it is making a law. Ultimately, the Planning
Commission makes a decision and sends it to the Council. The application is subject to the 60-day rule, so the City has to decide within 120 days. He added that the City has not received
a lot of these types of applications recently.
Commissioner Magistad asked what the fee is. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it is on the application form and it is at least $1,000 up front, but he did not remember the exact
amount. Planner Osowski shared that it is $1,600. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it could be more depending on how complicated it is.
Planning Director Griffiths shared that this is all the text the Commission would go through, but the second part is that since all the zoning districts have been changed, 221 properties
need to be rezoned. He pointed out that the properties had their current zoning district removed, the current zoning district is being combined with another zoning district, or many
properties were split between multiple zoning districts, which is not allowed under State law. He added that it was always clear which zoning district the properties should be in,
and many were oversights. Staff is fixing everything on the zoning map. He explained that whenever this update comes back before the Commission, there will be two items on the agenda.
The first will be a public hearing on the text amendments, and the second will be a public hearing on all zoning changes. The Commission will repeal the current zoning map and adopt
a new one. He stated that, for public notice, state law requires publication in the newspaper like a normal code update notice, and each
of the 221 property owners will also receive a mailed notice of the changes. He shared that Staff was careful when making the changes so no problems were created for people, and most
of the changes have no practical implications for property owners.
Chair Huskins asked what a letter to the property owners would say. He also asked whether the letter would include language to help residents determine that the change is benign. Planning
Director Griffiths said the letter would include language to convey that. He added that they did not want to discourage participation, but Staff notes on notices for these types of
changes that the City is initiating the change, not requesting it; it is more of a housekeeping update. A QR code is also included to visit the website and learn more about the project.
He pointed out that zoning changes often raise questions. He reiterated that only one public hearing will be held, as allowed under State law.
Commissioner Holker asked if Staff thought that all 221 properties would be benign. Planning Director Griffiths shared that if any property owner came to him, he would explain that
they are all benign. He noted that the standards are changing, but they are not more restrictive than anyone’s current zoning district. He pointed out that he does not know how many
will come because some never call and come to the meeting to see what is going on.
Chair Huskins said he is concerned that they need a contingency plan in case there are more people than seats. Planning Director Griffiths stated that he did not anticipate 221 homeowners.
If he gets that sense, he will plan accordingly.
Planning Director Griffiths explained that it is part of the process and that the residents will be notified. Looking at the updates, the R-2 districts have the bulk of the changes.
Planning Director Griffiths reviewed 1202.00 Park Dedication as found in the Agenda Packet. He noted that this is a high priority because it is an area where cities get into litigation.
Commissioner Holker asked whether this leaves the City open to retroactive lawsuits based on what it was before, or whether it can go back to the number of people added to the Minnetonka
Country Club, for example, and have a rationale for that higher fee. Planning Director Griffiths stated that, in most cases, no, because developers agreed to the fee as part of the
development agreement. He noted that the developer of the Country Club neighborhood could have challenged the fee in court if they wanted to. Typically, cities like Shorewood do not
see that. He shared that one of the things he is most concerned about in the current Code is fixing this, because it is one of the biggest areas of exposure for the City.
Chair Huskins asked if there is any exposure if collected monies are not spent. Planning Director Griffiths stated that it depends on the rationale. The plan can always be changed
as long as the City follows the process to change the Capital Improvement Plan. He noted that typically the City is okay. He added that part of the money has been spent on parks;
by State law, the money can only go toward new park improvements. Many cities do not charge park dedication fees because it is so restrictive. He thought it was a valuable fee to
charge, but it is not meant to be the only source of income for funding park systems.
Commissioner Braithwaite asked if the current budget meetings are factoring in this revenue reduction. Planning Director Griffiths confirmed that they are. He explained that under
the current budget, the City does not project any park dedication contributions because the development activity in Shorewood has been relatively low. So, if the City gets money, that
would be a bonus.
Shorewood has not approved a new residential development to charge the fee in over 18 months. He added that most of the projects left in Shorewood are small.
Commissioner Magistad asked whether the City has to look at park capacity and which parks can be used. Planning Director Griffiths stated that the Parks Commission did that as part
of the Master Plan, which is why Staff waited until it was done.
Commissioner Magistad asked if the density categories map back to the new residential districts. Planning Director Griffiths stated that they map back to the Zoning Code and the Comprehensive
Plan. He pointed out that the language added to the subdivision code allows some flexibility in the numbers. Park dedication is not meant to be a fixed amount; for example, if senior
living were to come in, State statute is clear that it should not be charged the same park dedication fee as a typical single-family home because they do not use the parks the same
way as other homeowners. The fees are the maximum per unit and are negotiable. He noted that people can request a reduction with supporting facts, and that is fairly common for cities
that see larger projects.
Commissioner Braithwaite asked whether the number of houses matters, such as whether a lot split would still require park dedication. Planning Director Griffiths noted that it is any
new property that has not paid the fee before. If a lot split occurs, Staff would check whether the lot paid the fee originally; if it did, the City pays only one park dedication fee
for the new property. He added that most properties have not paid it because the houses were developed before the City even existed.
Planning Director Griffiths stated that park dedication is in the subdivision section of the City Code, so it may require a separate public hearing, but will come forward as an update
to the Code. He thanked the Commission for reviewing the Code and the feedback provided. He shared that Staff has been taking notes on the feedback and will incorporate it into the
Code; the matter will then likely return to the October 6 meeting for a public hearing on the Zoning Code update.
Chair Huskins noted that Staff has worked very hard and made many improvements. Planning Director Griffiths shared that Staff is excited to use the new Code soon.
REPORTS
CITY COUNCIL
Council Liaison Gorham gave a brief overview of recent Council discussions and decisions.
Commissioner Magistad asked when the SCEC task force report would be produced. Planning Director Griffiths stated that he believed it was on the next Council agenda. Council Liaison
Gorham added that it got pushed back because the task force had another meeting.
STAFF
Planning Director Griffiths shared that the next meeting is October 6 and will include the Zoning Code update and an update on the Comprehensive Plan. He added that Staff tabled at
Concert in the Park and had good conversations with people about the Comprehensive Plan. He plugged an upcoming event: September 16 Community Visioning Event. He shared that the Tree
Survey would be in the next newsletter and many people are already finding it. He reminded Chair Huskins that he was the liaison for the next Council meeting on September 14.
COMMISSION
The Commission had nothing to share.
ADJOURNMENT
Holker moved, Magistad seconded, adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of September 1, 2026, at 9:21 P.M. Motion passed 4/0.