HomeMy WebLinkAbout120803 CC Ws AgP
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
City Council
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator I' ~
December 4, 2003 UV
December 8 Work Session Items
Two items are scheduled for tonight's work session. We begin at 6:00 p.m. (at which time food will
be available), interrupt it with a Council meeting at 7:00 p.m., and return to work session after the
regular Council meeting is adjourned.
I. City Hall Assessment (6:00 p.m.)
BKV Group will provide a progress report on the City Hall building and space assessment study.
They will also outline the work that remains to be done, and give us an idea about the timing for
another work session or two before the Council formally receives the study. BKV staff that we have
worked with most closely are David Kroos, Bill Baxley, and Suzy Groves.
II. City Council Meeting (7:00 p.m.)
III. County Road 19 Corridor Study
Brad Nielsen and Larry Brown will provide an update on the Corridor Study. The Planning
Commission reviewed it on December 2, and the Park Commission will review it on December 9.
They will seek some specific direction from Council as they prepare the final draft.
ft
\,J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
..
BKV
GROUP
City of
Shorewood
'City Hall
Needs Assessment
Study/Building
Evaluation
SHOREWOOD, MN
Summary
December 4, 2003
Architect:
Boarman Kroos Vogel Group
222 North Second Street
Minneapolis, Minnesota 5540 I
COMMISSION NO. 1613.01
Q/proj/1613.0 I/pro/program report.doc
SHOREWOOD CITY HALL BUILDING ASSESSMENT REPORT
November 2003
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Background
The original city hall structure was erected in 1979, some 24 ye;'lrs ago.
The size ofthe original structure was approximat~ly 78 feet'~~ the east!
west axis and approximately 48 feet on the north/south axis. The facility
was built to have 2 levels; a basement and a main level at grade. The main
level public entrance to the building is located off of the north parking lot,
on the north building elevation. The basement is a full 13 block courses
deep.)
An addition was added in 1988; - approximately 15 years ago. The size of
the new addition was 48 feet on the north/south access and 33 feet 4
inches on the east/ west axis. The floor levels of the new addition were
set to match the existing building
The new addition was constructed adjacent to the east exterior wall of
the existing facility so it butts up against, and is joined to the existing
facility to form one continuing structure.
The existing building is generally in fair shape, however there are several
significant issues that need to be evaluated and addressed relative to any
current or future scenario planned for the city hall. Some of these issues
include:
The envelope of the building needs to be replaced. This
includes siding, windows and roof.
The water incursion in the basement needs to be
mitigated and the mold abated. Further investigation as to
water table levels and proximity to foundation construction
needs to be evaluated to understand the long-term water
issues.
Several ADA accessibility items should be corrected and
upgraded with any substantial modifications.
The HV AC system should be replaced or substantially
over-hauled.
The lower level of city hall, though suitable for storage, is
not supportive of a productive work environment.
This report is a first step and outlines in depth issues relative to the
physical condition and issues of accessibility. This report also offers some
commentary on possible recommendations. Any recommendations
however need to be reviewed within the framework of a variety of
scenarios, which attempt to outline possible future uses of the building
and or grounds, and their relative cost implications. This phase of work
will be completed over the next couple of months and provide for review
objective solutions for prioritization and evaluation
The current condition at the Shorewood City Hall provides an
opportunity for the City to review services and facilities and to
reposition City Hall for the future. Municipal buildings should not impede
but support the important work of city government. A farsighted. .
approach to City Hall development is one that determines the long-range
plan and systematically moves toward a comprehensive resolution, not
one that invests in stopgap measures, which, in the end, are wasteful.
~"
SHORE WOOD CITY HALL
SPACE ANALYSIS FORM
ADMINISTRATION
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEDS ASSESSMENT
DATE: August 15,2003
SPACE DEPARTMENT:
SHEET
CODE
COMM.#: 1613.01
BOARMAN KROOS VOGEL GROUP
EXISTING
SPACE
REQUIRED NUMBER
OF SPACES
5-YR 10-YR
COMMENTS
0-216
0-144
W-168
W-168
W-64
Personnel Spaces
Craig Dawson, City Administrator
Jean Panchyshyn, Exec. Sec.lDeputy Clerk
Twila Grout, Park Sec.lReceptionist
Pat Fasching, PW. Sec.lReceptionist
Julie Moore, Communications Tech
168 216 216 216 21.6
135 144 144 144 144
84 84 84 84 84 Shared with Pat
84 84 84 84 84 Shared with Twila
36 64 64 64 64
Subtotal, Personnel Spaces 507 5 5 5 592 592 592 592
Departmental Spaces
R-1500 Archive file storage/file room See shared areas
R-120 Storage 120 120 120 120 h20 meters/supplies/recycl. bins
A-48 Work/Copy Area 48 48 48 48
A-48RECPT Service Counter 48 48 48 48
Subtotal, De artmental Spaces 216 216 216 216
Total Net SF 808 808 808 808
Efficiency Factor - Percentage of Total 10% 81 81 81 81
TOTAL PROPOSED/PROJECTED OCCUPIABLE 889 889 889 889
Total Existing Occupiable
(O)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (L)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
SHOREWOOD CITY HALL
SPACE ANALYSIS FORM
PLANNING
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEDS ASSESSMENT
DATE: August 15,2003
SPACE DEPARTMENT:
SHEET
CODE
COMM.#: 1613.01
BOARMAN KROOS VOGEL GROUP
EXISTING
SPACE
REQUIRED NUMBER
OF SPACES
5-YR 10-YR
COMMENTS
0-168
0-144
0-144
Personnel Spaces
Brad Nielsen, Planning Director
Patti Helgesen, Assistant Planner
Joe Pazandak, Building Official
253
132
99
168
144
144
168
144
144
168
144
144
168
144
144
layout table in office
Subtotal, Personnel S aces 484 3 3 3 456 456 456 456
De artmental Spaces
A-182 File Area 182 182 182 182 6-36" 5H, 7-4H v, 6-2H v,5H flat
A-32 Copy/File Area 32 32 32 32
C-120 Meeting Room 120 120 120 120 Directly adjacnet to Brad's off.
R-1500 Archive File Storage See Shared areas
Subtotal, Departmenta/ Spaces 334 334 334 334
Total Net SF 790 790 790 790
Efficiency Factor - Percentage of Total 10% 79 79 79 79
TOTAL PROPOSED/PROJECTED OCCUPIABLE 869 869 869 869
Total Existing Occupiable
(O)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (L)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
. SHOREWOODCITY HALL
SPACE ANALYSIS FORM
ENGINEERING & PARKS
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEDS ASSESSMENT
DATE: August 15,2003
SPACE DEPARTMENT:
SHEET
CODE
COMM.#: 1613.01
BOARMAN KROOS VOGEL GROUP
EXISTING
SPACE
REQUIRED NUMBER
OF SPACES
5-YR 10-YR
COMMENTS
0-168
0-120
W-168
W-168
W-64
0-120
Larry Brown,City Engineer
Boyd Bailey, Engineering Tech III
Twila Grout, Park Sec.lReceptionist
Pat Fasching, P.W. Sec.lReceptionist
Future Clerical/Support
Future Inspector
168 168 168 168 168
64 120 120 120 120
84 See Administration
84 See Administration
64 64 64
120 120
Subtotal, Personnel Spaces 400 4 5 6 472 288 352 472
Departmental Spaces
R-252 File Room 252 252 252 252 Central File/Flat files/Plotter
R-1500 Archive File Storage See Shared areas
252 252 252 252
Total Net SF 724 540 604 724
Efficiency Factor - Percentage of Total 10% 72 54 60 72
TOTAL PROPOSED/PROJECTED OCCUPIABLE 796 594 664 796
Total Existing Occupiable
(Q)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (l)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
SHORE WOOD CITY HALL
SPACE ANALYSIS FORM
FINANCE
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEl)S ASSESSMENT
DA TE: August 15, 2003
SPACE DEPARTMENT:
SHEET
CODE
COMM.#: 1613.01
BOARMAN KROOS VOGEL GROUP
EXISTING
SPACE
REQUIRED NUMBER
OF SPACES
5-YR 10-YR
COMMENTS
0-168
0-144
0-120
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director
Cathy Elke, Sr. Accountant
Michelle Nguyen, Accounting Clerk I
162
93
93
168
144
120
168
144
120
168
144
, 120
168
144
120
Subtotal, Personnel Spaces 348 3 3 3 432 432 432 432
Departmental Spaces
A-60 File Area 60 60 60 60
R-242 CopylWork Room shared with other depts
A-32 Printer Area 32 32 32 32
R.1500 Archive File Storage See shared areas
92 ,92 92 92
Total Net SF 524 524 524 524
Efficiency Factor. Percentage of Total 10% 52 52 52 52
TOTAL PROPOSED/PROJECTED OCCUPIABLE 576 576 576 576
Total Existing Occupiable
(O)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (L)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
..
SHORE WOOD CITY HALL SPACE ANALYSIS FORM SHARED AREAS
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEDS ASSESSMENT COMM.#: 1613.01
DATE: August 15, 2003 BOARMAN KROOS VOGEL GROUP
SPACE DEPARTMENT: EXISTING
SHEET SPACE COMMENTS
CODE
Genera/ Shared Areas
R-1345 Council Chambers 895 1 1 1 1,345 1,345 1,345 1,345
R-300b Kitchen/Break Room 65 1 1 1 300 300 300 300
A-100 Vestibule 95 1 1 1 100 100 100 100
A-350 Lobby 265 1 1 1 350 350 350 350
R-50 Janitor's Closet 50 1 1 1 Included wlW-340
R-340 Restrooms 110 1 1 1 340 340 340 340
C-345 Conference Room 180 1 1 1 345 345 345 345
C-216 Conference Room 1 1 1 216 216 216 216 Adj.. to Council Chambers
R-40 Public Coat Closet 40 1 1 1 40 40 40 40
R-18 Staff Coat Closet 1 1 1 18 18 18 18
R-242 Mail/CopylWork Room 1 1 1 242 242 242 242
R-200c Mechanical 1 1 1 200 200 200 200
R-32 Electrical Closet 2 2 2 32 64 64 64
R-1500 Archive Storage 1,344 1,500 1,500 1,500 1,500
R-150 Server/Computer Room 150 150 150 150
Subtotal, De artmental Spaces 5,178 5,210 5,210 5,210
Total Net SF 6,523 6,555 6,555 6,555
Efficiency Factor. Percentage of Total 10% 652 656 656 656
TOTAL PROPOSED/PROJECTED OCCUPIABLE 7,175 7,211 7,211 7,211
Total Existing Occupiable
(O)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (L)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
SHORE WOOD CITY HALL
SPACE ANALYSIS FORM
Shorewood, Mn
SPACE NEEDS ASSESSMENT
DATE: August 15, 2003
SPACE DEPARTMENT:
SHEET
CODE
SUMMARY TOTALS
~'
COMM.#: 1613.01
BOARMAN KROOS PFISTER VOGEL ASSOC.
OCCUPIABLE AREA REQUIRED
2-YR 5-YR 10-YR
PROJECTED PROJECTED PROJECTED
NET
Total
ADMINISTRATION
PLANNING
ENGINEERING & PARKS
FINANCE
5
3
4
3
5
3
5
3
5
3
6
3
889
869
594
576
Subtotal, Departments
15
16
17
2,928
Shared Areas
GENERAL SHARED AREAS
7,211
Subtotal, Shared Areas
7,211
Total Net SF
Efficiency Factor - Percentage of Total
TOTAL PROJECTED GROSS
TOTAL EXISTING GROSS
DIFFERENCE
1.0,139
2,535
12,673
(9,200)
3,473
25%
889
869
664
576
2,999
7,211
7,211
10,209
2,552
12,761
(9,200)
3,561
889
869
796
576
3,131
7,211
7,211
10,341
2,585
12,926
(9,200)
3,726
(O)Office (W)Workstation (R)Room (A)Area (L)Lobby (SW)Shared Workstation (M)Millwork
SHOREWOOD CITY HALL BUILDING ASSESSMENT REPORT
November 2003
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Backl:round
The original city hall structure was erected in 1979, some 24 years ago. The size of the original structure was
approximately 78 feet on the eastl west axis and approximately 48 feet on the north/south axis. The facility was built to
have 2 levels; a basement and a main level at grade. The main level public entrance to the building is located off of the
north parking lot, on the north building elevation. The basement is a full 13 block courses deep.)
An addition was added in 1988; - approximately 15 years ago. The size of the new addition was 48 feet on the
north/south access and 33 feet 4 inches on the eastl west axis. The floor levels of the new addition were set to match
the existing building
The new addition was constructed adjacent to the east exterior wall of the existing facility so it butts up against, and is
joined to the existing facility to form one continuing structure.
The existing building is generally in fair shape, however there are several significant issues that need to be evaluated and
addressed relative to any current or future scenario planned for the city hall. Some of these issues include:
The envelope of the building needs to be replaced. This includes siding, windows and roof.
I. cu
CU.Q
.&. 0
t..
::s III
LL"'C
CU
o CU
"'C C
CU
.. C
nI 0
.Q o.ti
nI u
"'C ::s
'Ob
E ~
CU 0
.&. u
.. C
"'C 02
c ..
nI nI
"'C"'C
CU C
.. ::s
:o~
o.ti 0
'E ~ ~
CU 'E- ~
.Q ,!!!
o ')( I.
.. 0 CU
III I. ..
"'C Q. nI
~ "'C ~
C ; E
.. III I.
C - cu
cu cu ..
E > ~
cu .! c
III '" 0
n1'::-
.Q.Qcu
'" n1.&.
w....
'&'1._
.. cu ...
c .. c
0- nI nI
C ~ t:
,2 0 t
III""'C
I. III C
a nI ::s
ceo
,- 0 ..
~ '.ti "'C
W nI cu
~ l)O..
~ ,- nI
~ t: ::s
cu cu-
.&. > nI
I- c >
0_ cu
-;
'.ti
c
nI
..
III
.Q
::s
III
>-
C
nI
.c
..
oi
"'C
cu
"'C
nI
I.
l)O
Q.
::s
"'C
c
nI
"'C
cu
..
u
cu
I.
I.
o
U
cu
.Q
::5!
::s
o
.&.
III
III
E
cu
o~
,~
-
:s
'ijj
III
cu
U
u
nI
<C ~
C 0
<c o.ti
nI
- u
n1\i::
I. ,_
CU"'O
> 0
~ E
o
"'C
.!
::s
nI
.&.
.
I.
cu
>
o
~
ii
o.ti
c
nI
..
III
.Q
::s
III
I.
o
"'C
cu
u
nI
Q.
cu
I.
cu
.Q
::5!
::s
o
.&.
III
~
I.
o
~
cu
>
'.ti
u
::s
"'C
o
I.
Q.
nI
...
o
cu
>
'f
o
Q.
Q.
::s
III
..
o
c
,!!!
GS
l)O
nI
I.
o
..
III
I.
~
cu
:E
nI
,~
::s
III
.&.
l)O
::s
o
.&.
..
E
cu
..
III
>-
III
U
<c
>
J:
cu
.&.
I-
a
ii
.&.
l;-
Ov
...
o
1)
> ..J
~ C
I. CU
; ~
o 0
- I.
CU 0-
.&. >
I- ~
III 110
.r:. c:
I- .- .....
J:! 0
>.. ~ ':; Q)
.~ ..0 c..
..0,- B Q) :J
.r:. 0
III "'0 ..... u
1IlQ).....
e Q) 0 ><
u c: III Q)
~ L. Q) c:
..... Q) III Q)
o > :J.r:.
III ~ Q) .....
Q) > L. L.
:J 0 :J Q)
1Il.r:.~>
III Ill..... 0
"'0 c: Q) "'0
c: .Q ..0 Q)
~ ~ 'Vi ~
c: "'0 11I-
oc:oa.
'p Q) a. E
:.oEQ)85
c: E c: .-
o = Q) .....
uO.......o~
u:J :J
fa Q) 0 ._ fa
u L. 0 ~ >
III >-..... >Q)
>-5 ......:::t. "'0
.r:. ...... a. L. c:
a. E 0 ~
Q) vi Q) ~ c:
.r:.c:H.....O
..... 0 ~ O'p
o 'P.r:. Q) ~
..... ~ U III .!:::!
Q) "'0 ._ ~ .....
> c: .r:. .r:. . C
'p Q) ~ a. 0
~ E _ III 'C
Q) E 1Il:.c a.
L. 0 .Q I- L.
~ ~; .-E
:J L. c: III III
III Q) c: c:
.!!! ~ ~ ,Q 0
..0 ..... .-
-5 'Vi '0 G ~
a. III .- (5
Q)0b-c..1Il
"'0 a. Q) E
c: c: 'C .- ~
o ~ t: 'p
~ t- 0 u
c: ~ ~ u .~
"P.....'OQ)"O
:J c: > 0
o Q) ~ 'p ~
E 0 ..!l! Q)
-g E ~ e 'S;
~ 0 Q) L. Q)
a. u E ._ L.
Q) Q) ~ Q) L.
t:E..::-5-E
..... 0 Q) "'0 Q)
~1Il.r:.C:"'O
(,i:: ~ ..... ~'S;
~ Q) c: III 0
!+- .- "'0 L.
.!!! '0 -5 c: a.
~ 0 .~ 5 -g
O...!!!"'OL.~
a. ~ Q) 110 III
e~~6-5
III 0 .~ "'0 c:
.r:. g. ~ c: 0
I-L.L.~E
III
:E'O -g
.~ ~ "'0 ~
..... 0 c: .r:.
"'O~~"'"
~ ..... ~ .!:
1Il~c....c
e ~ Q) .~
.- 0 11O.r:.
~a.c:~
~ E r:
-- b.o ~
Q)~ ~ c: L.
,_ ..... 0 ~
~ ~ ~ ~
L. o.r:. Q)
o a...... E
..... a. III a.
.... :J Q) ~
"'1IlC:11O
o ~ 'E a.
-- L. B
Q) ..0 Q) III
.r:. Q) .....
..... "'0 Q) .!:
L. Q) "'0 III
-E a...... .....
E ~ III
b-.- -5 ~
'c '0 Q) .!:
~ c: 5 ~
o J:! 1Il.r:.
a. :J .- .....
a.0.....Q)
o.r:. c: c:
III Q) 0
c: III E .....
~ 110 a. 0
~ .!: 0 c:
"'O"'OQ)c:
'S; ':; ~ 0
e ..0 "'0 'p
a.-- :J
_[fao
fa 'u I ~
I 'c b- L.
>- :J .- Q)
.~ ::r: u .~
U 0 III
. ..... c:
"'0 Q) Q)
0L..r:..r:.
o :J U Q)
~ ~ l:l 5-
Q).....L.E
L.Q)a.0
.2-5 ~U
V)L."'O~
Q) -E Q) "'0
.r:._~L.
::: I~ ,~ ~
~ ~ 0
c: >- ~ .....
o .~..... III
:E U <( ~
"'0 c: +-3 0
5 .Q c: E
U ,~ Q) ~ .
~&.~G.2
Q) Q) L. ._ Q)
t L. ~ ~ t:
:J 0 0 E ~
U.....I1OQ)~
~ "'0 b- t: Q)
I- ~ 'u 1;;- ;
ADA SITE AND BUILDING ACCESS SURVEY & PHYSICAL CONDITION ASSESMENT REPORT
For the
Shorewood City Hall.
Shorewood, Minnesota
Date:
Buildings and Areas Surveyed:
October 16,2009
Shorewood City Hall facility, and the surrounding green spaces & parking lot & pavements.
Site Address:
City, State:
Building Contact:
Building Contact Phone #:
Survey Completed By:
5755 County Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
Larry Brown, Director of Public Works
(952) -401-1637
Jon T. Rail, Construction Administration
BKV Group
222 N. Second Street
Minneapolis, MN 55401
The following report has been prepared for the City of Shorewood Commissioners and the City staff. The purpose of this report is to
assess the existing Shorewood City Hall Facility & grounds for compliance to the American With Disabilities Act of 1990, (ADA).- and
also to assess the physical condition of the facility for future remodeling or addition. The information gathered in this audit is the first
step toward a barrier-free facility that ensures accessibility and usability for the physically challenged. While this survey addresses
issues under Titles I _ IV of the Act, the main focus will be on the requirements of Title III of the Act prohibits discrimination on the
basis of disability in the full and equal use of public facilities and services. The facilities identified herein were evaluated to determine
if all limitations can be "reasonably accommodated", both environmentallyand in policy, procedure, and practice. See the Last
section of this report (TITLE III: PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS) with regard to recommendations as to what modifications
and accommodations to a public facility are required, and when, and to what extent.
In Minnesota alone there are over 870,000 individuals who have some type of disability. However, everyone benefits from a barrier-
free environment. There is a benefit to all with wider doorways, non-slip surfaces, low pile carpeting, automatic entrances, and wider
aisles. Parents with small children appreciate larger toilet stalls, lever handles and easy operating controls benefit everyone. As we
all age, most of us will likely need some sort.of accommodation that we do not require now. We may be affected by hearing loss; we
may develop a certain limiting loss in mobility, deteriorated sight, or develop difficulty in grasping or manipulating. objects with our
hands. Providing accessibility to government facilities not only allows citizens with disabilities use of the facility, but allows you to
continue, over time, -to serve the citizens you currently serve, who are not now, but may become disabled.
Building Survey
0:\ 1 G13-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
C:h"~"",,,,,rI Minnp~otR
Meeting the need is accommodating for all functional limitations, understanding that:
1 . All disabilities are not observable.
2. The observable disability may not be the actual barrier to receiving services. (For example, a person in a wheelchair
may also be blind and need Braille assistance.)
3. Accessibility is particularly important because people who have disabilities may have more frequent need of
government agency services that the general, non-handicapped population.
4. Citizens should be able to call a government facility for emergencies, and to obtain information on everyday issues.
They should be able to communicate both from the outside and the inside in any government building.
Communication for disabled citizens should be available in the form of people and equipment. Internal
communications system should be evaluated from both a service and an information perspective.
5. Generally the density of government buildings has presented difficulties in accommodating equipment, support
accessories, and space to work and serve the disabled public.
This survey does not address the Owner's systems furniture, desks, or personal workstations, etc., with the exception of areas that
will be used by a rotating public such as the council chambers bench in a meeting room, etc.
SITE EVALUATION (INCLUDING SIDEWALKS, ENTRANCES, AND PARKING FACILITIES) & RECOMMENDATIONS:
NORTH ELEVATION (This section also addresses the main parking lot serving the existing city hall facility)
1. 29 parking spaces are provided. (28 non handicapped, 1 handicapped) Plus there are an additional 5 stalls of park and ride
space available at the north end of the north parking lot. Access to parking is via 2 curb cut entrances off of County Club
Road located to the west of the site. There needs to be two handicapped spaces per 25 parking spaces. One is missing
from the current layout.
2. The Facility is adjacent to the Badger Park parking lot, park, and a public park-and-ride lot. There are two Park tennis courts
located just to the east of the existing City Hall building. The parking lot lighting consists of one 30-foot high pole mounted
light fixture that is controlled by a time clock.
3. The parking lot is in reasonably good shape and so are the concrete,gutters and curbs. However the handicapped parking
stall and the adjacent side access aisle should be relocated to the main front entrance. The relocated handicapped parking
access aisle could be made 8 foot wide and could serve as both a restricted loading zone for Van accessible handicapped
parking, as well as an unrestricted path to allow access into and out of the, facility from the parking lot to the main building
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
2
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
entrance. The handicapped parking spaces should be relocated to be closer to the main front entrance to City Half. This will
also mean that the handicapped curb cut can be located at the main front entrance - which is a much more accessible
location than where it is currently located.
4. Existing sidewalks are in pretty good shape, - with some chatter and edge damage to the stright cubs along the main front
sidewalk. This damage is likely from snow removal activates over the years. No great variations in the surface plane of these
walks, (which are not ADA compliant) were noted. There is an area of damage to the sidewalks between the sidewalk
running parallel with the end of the parking lot and the entry sidewalks that run perpendicular to the building. This damage
portion should be should be repaired / replaced with new work.
5. Egress lighting at the main entrance is from two bollard type light fixtures that are located at the juncture of the main entrance
sidewalk paving and the sidewalks running parallel to the building at the west elevation. The City needs to verify whether or a
minimum illumination level of % candle-power is provided to assist exiting in darkness. (This should be all right since _ there is
enough additional ambient borrowed light generated by the parking lot lost-mounted light fixture, (located in the west parking
lot).
6. If it becomes necessary at a later date to look at the north parking area as a possible alterative site, we recommend that the
following take place as pre-requisites for site planning and development strategies:
a. Have a full set of soils borings completed, - as this area was at one time a swamp and marshland. (See 1966
Topography Map). The grades descended from the existing roadbed, down about 4-6 feet into the parking lot, which
was a marshy area.
b. There should be Phase 1 and Phase 2 environmental studies done, including securing additional information from the
MPCA, - since they did maintain a monitoring well that was installed, (at one time), adjacent to the fire hydrant on
County Club Road.
......
7. Staff advises that when the water main was repaired in the green space north of the north parking lot adjacent to the BMJ
Auto shop - there was quite the stench of contamination in the excavated soils. I believe at one time this land was also used
as a dump of sorts and a waste area for things such as vehicles & other trash. Therefore soils corrections may need to be
done, as well as decontamination of the site. Contaminated soil abatement may be necessary to take care of existing soil
contamination. This can be a very costly undertaking.
8. The City of Shorewood has installed a wooden engraved sign, (red ba~k round with yellow letters), that identifies the site as:
City Hall
City of Shorewood
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
3
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
0100 vuulHry GIUD Hoad.
This sign sits in a landscaping bed, with no flood lighting or ground set lights directed on to the sign to illuminate it after
working hours.
9. Overall the landscaping surrounding the parking lot is mature. The trees and shrubs seem to be in good health and the
sodded areas are well maintained. The maintenance of the parking area has been good. The stripping & pavement markings
are new. There is adequate positive drainage a storm sewer catch basin at the north end of the parking lot. Parking "lot
drainage also runs parallel to the east edge of the parking lot, where the lot'is sloped down a bituminous service road, and
then off to a woodland drainage area further east. Behind the tennis courts.
General Notes:
The original city hall structure was erected in 1979, some 24 years ago. The size of the original structure was approximately 78
feet on the easV west axis and approximately 48 feet on the north/south axis. The facility was built to have 2 levels; a basement
and a main level at grade. The main level public entrance to the building is located off of the north parking lot, on the north
building elevation. The basement is a full 13 block courses deep.)
An addition was added in 1988; - approximately 15 years ago. The size of the new addition was 48 feet on the north/south
access and 33 feet 4 inches on the easV west axis. The floor levels of the new addition were set to match the existing building
The new addition was constructed adjacent to the east exterior wall of the existing facility so it butts up against, and is joined to
the existing facility to form one continuing structure.
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION
1. Reinforced concrete cast-in-place strip footings support a 12-inch b'lock foundation walls that extend to grade.
2. The insulated exterior walls are framed with 2 x 6's at 16 inches on center. Exterior wall sheathing is half inch plywood siding
with 1 x 3 vertical trim at 16 inches on center. The plywood siding is installed over 5/8" insulated sheeting. The stud cavities
are insulated with fiberglass insulation. A vapor barrier and interior finish taped & painted gypsum board wall complete the
construction. '
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
4
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
3. The roof is a comprised of engineered wood trusses at 2 foot on center. The trusses run north & south. The roof features a
Boston ridge and individual roof vents (1-300).
4. The building roof drainage is accomplished by a galvanized pre-finished metal, type "K" Gutter system with 2 x 4 rain water
leaders, (and extensions) on the south elevation and north elevation of the original building and the addition.
5. The exterior aluminum windows are approximately 2 foot wide by 6 foot high and are double-glazed. A number of wind9ws
have failed seals and some have bullet or BB holes in the exterior pane. The finish on the windows is a color polyester finish,
which is most cases, is de-laminating. The finish and has worn off most of the sills and the bottom of the f1anking,jam
extrusions. These windows should be replaced with new work, (New 1" tinted or clear IG glass with Iowa soft e-coating).
6. The aluminum storefront entrance system is approximately 12 foot by wide by 7 foot high. The aluminum framing features two
3 foot wide side lights flanking each side of the double entry door pair, (of 3'-0" x 7'-0" doors). The doorframes are narrowed
style, - with full glazing lites of IG glass. The aluminum doorframes consist of 2-inch wide side rails, 3-inch high head rails
and 3.5-inch high bottom rails. The doors are fitted with insulated 5/8" IG glass vision lites, and % -1 inch thick IG glazing
installed in the flanking sidelights. I assume that the vision lights in the storefront system are either tempered or safety
laminated. The aluminum thresholds are in good shape, - but do not appear to have been set in a full bed of sealant. The
active leaf of the entry door pair is a features a keyed deadlock and a pull handle, which appears to be ADA compliant. The
other leaf of the entry door pair is fitted with flush bolts & and pull handle Ipush plate. There are no interior or exterior power
assisted low energy swinging door operators for the front entry vestibule door pairs. Adding interior & exterior entry vestibule
power assisted door openers should be a part of any retrofit or remodeling of the facility.
7. The exterior wall cladding system is comprised of 3/8 inch, (vertical), sheets of exterior siding, (4'-0" foot wide x 8'-0" tall.
The vertical butt joints between siding sheets are trimmed out vertical and horizontal 1" x 3" rough sawn battens.
8. The roof edge Fascia is a rough-sawn 2" x 12" with a strip of soffit between the fascia and the wall sheathing, serving as a
soffit vent at the eave edge.
9. Along most elevations of the building there appears to be uniform water damage at the lower section of the siding _ including
the water damage to the horizontal & vertical trim strips. There is algae growing on the moist I soft I blackened surfaces of
the stained siding & trim at the base of the wall above grade. A lot of the 'siding trim boards are in good to very good shape
but many are showing signs of rot on the top of the horizontal trim me~bers, and exposed edges.
10. The roof is clad to what appears to be 3-tab composite asphalt shingles. The shingles are not the new interlocking style and
they look like they have exhausted their. useful service life. The remodeling of this facility should include a new shingle roof
Building Survey
Q:\1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
5
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
J 1- -' J ..._.... ..
the new roof is to be a shingled roof system, - I recommend that a composite fiberglass shingle be used to replace the current
roof membrane. There is a good possibility that some of the roof sheeting boards may need to be replaced when the roof is
re-shingled. (Larry Brown noted that there are many "soft spots" on the roof. Roof venting is currently provided only on the
south elevation of the roofs and appears to be a standard 1/300 venting profile.
11. An 8-inch chimney vent stack penetrates the roof.
12. There are other penetrations though the building envelope on the west elevation and on the north elevations and some HV AC
penetration on the south elevation.
13. The existing roof exhibits signs of ice damming damage on the lower 4 -5 feet of the roof eave edge, indicating a need for
additional insulating and air sealing. On the east end of the north elevation, at grade, the exposed concrete block work shows
signs of repeated wetting. There are indications that this foundation block work has been inundated with water from the
exterior.
14. There is also some kind of a 20 - 40- mil hard plastic water proofing sheeting that has been applied to the exterior of the
exposed foundation wall above grade, (extending down below grade). This membrane does not appear to have been a part
of the original foundation wall construction. The top edge of his WP membrane was terminated with a steel termination bar
fastened at 12 " on center. In most places, - this failed waterproofing membrane has separated from the termination bar. This
system is not working. I suggest that the exterior of the foundation walls be water proofed, and a new perimeter drain system,
(that circles the whole building), be installed. The plans of the building & addition indicated that there is a perimeter drain tile
system that goes to daylight - I could not find the daylight point. The public works director says the perimeter drain tile
system empties into the basement sum pit, located in the lower by the entrance to the mechanical area. The sump pump
runs a LOT.
15. The north building elevation features a tapered aluminum flagpole with a brushed / spun aluminum finish. The flagpole is
approximately 35 feet tall and it is topped with a 4" diameter gold finial ball. There is a non-revolving truck at the top of the
pole that serves the exposed lanyard system. (The pole flies 2 flags, - the US Flag above the Minnesota State flag).
East Elevation:
1:: The east elevation features a 13'-0" wide paved asphalt covering that separates the east facade of the addition from the
adjacent Badger Park tennis courts. This asphalt pavement consists of old weathered macadam surfacing that is in fairly
good shape - until you get to the areas adjacent to the timber retaining wall on the east side of the road. This pavement
drains to the rear of the building, and then directs surface water to the~ast - into woodland. The east elevation features a
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
6
1613.01 .
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
are d. I ew UI lilt: UII~IIId.1 WUOu f-IlL,;Kt:l~ 1111~"1118 li leH "IIUUlu Uc: I Cf-IlctGcu al li Ie; Id11U1118, lu Illaht: ~UI c: li Ictl IIV IIIVI t: li IW I a -.,.-lIlvll
sphere can pass between them.
2. The bottom two steps of the existing wood stairs should be replaced with new work and I would recommend a side handrail
be installed along the building wall.
3. The main gas service enters the lower level at the addition on this elevation. The Minnegasco meter is located on the east
side at the northeast corner of the building. I suggest adding concrete filled 6" diameter steel protection bollards around this
meter. The exposed block along this elevation shows signs of a continual moisture infiltration problem.
4. The blacktop-paved area adjacent of the bottom of the wooden stairs has begun to crack up and heave and is probably
ponding water and creating a slip hazard in the winter.
5. At the point where the blacktop abuts the building, the pavement is actually pitched towards the building, - thereby directing
water to the foundation walls.
6. Fascia boards on this elevation of the building are cracked in several spots. The l' x 3' rough-sawn trim which runs
horizontally underneath the sheeting, shows signs of dry rot in many areas. There are also areas of de-lamination starting on
the exterior plywood sheeting. (Which has been kept in fairly good condition - it has now aged beyond its useful life and is.
now getting to the point where it cannot hold stain or paint. This indicates that you have failure of the exposed surface of the
exterior sheeting). Replace the wood siding & trim on all evaluations of the facility.
South Building Elevation;
1. The property between the exterior face of the building on the south elevation and the property line is about 3D-feet wide. This
elevation of the building descends from the west elevation to the east and is tiered and graded and held back by two dry laid
segmental concrete unit landscape retaining wall systems. The lower retaining wall at grade is 6 courses of dry laid
segmental concrete units. The upper retaining wall system is 3 courses high above grade.
2. This elevation features a small wooden porch area off of the council chambers. There is a wood privacy screen and a wood
hand railing systems that provides access to the council meeting area and the corridor off the main lobby, (east of the break
room). -
3. Adjacent to this wood patio / deck is a telephone pole with a short wave radio set up mounted at the top of the pole.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
7
1613.01
. Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
~~t up ~hich ~erve 3 of the 5 co~mercial furnaces located in the facility. One conaenslny Ullll I::' ct \JUI",-, ,-,v.~, _
other two condensers are 2 Lennox units. These condensing units all look like they are fairly new. They are served by wall
mounted disconnects. The condensation return piping that is exposed is for the most part insulated, (the black closed cell
Armatex pipe insulation is in relatively good condition).
5. The 4th, (new), condenser unit (Bryant Model), is located on the second tiered landscaped area to the east of the wood~n patio
area - west of the lower level west entrance.
6. This elevation of the building also features a knock out panel that is approximately 7 feet long and 32 inches high and there is
a duct that vents to the outside coming through this plywood access panel. I am not sure what the original intended use of
the knock out panel was for, maybe for HV AC penetrations, but at present it does not seem to serve an purpose. In my
opinion the existing plywood should be replaced with solid block infill for security reasons - and to make a better weather tight
barrier. The grading on this elevation of the building is flat and in some areas it actually directs water towards the building. In
other areas the drainage slopes gently away from the building to the south.
7. The gutters on this elevation, (and those on the north side of the building are set up with after-market heat tracings.
8. The high-pitched Boston roof on the south end of the council area is covered with heat tracing to melt snow.
9. Exposed block on this building elevation also shows signs of past, (and present), water infiltration up to a level of about 2-3
courses above grade.
10. The wood trim around the windows on this elevation is deteriorating & rotting due to the weather.
11. There are areas of foundation wall block that have been at some time treated with a glue, mastic, or some type of damp
proofing membrane. It almost looks like this mastic was used to set decorative tile. This exposed mastic has not been
removed and is unsightly.
12. The supplies and exhausts for the residential type furnaces exit this elevation of the building.
13. The rainwater leader drop footer at the southwest corner is crushed and. needs to be replaced with new work. The footer that
replaces this element should be a roll out type that can discharge water 10-20 feet away from the building. Currently the
existing damaged footer extension it is only about 3-4 feet in length. At the juncture between the old building and the new
addition block foundation walls, the control joint is mudded with m'ortar. The mortar should be removed, and the joint should
be should be caulked in with exterior urethane sealant.
Building Survey
Q:\1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
8
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
-
14. Areas of spauled brick should be repaired.
15. The existing rainwater leader drop that feeds into a 3 foot long rainwater diverter, ( that is supposed to direct water away from
the foundation), actually directs water toward and not away from the foundation. The rainwater leader located at the
southeast corner of the addition does not have anything other than 90-degree footer directing water away from the base of
the wall. Expelled rainwater ends up being directed back to the foundation wall and the service door at the SE corner o.f the
addition - and not away from the building, as it should. .
16. Both of the new entry doors installed at the lower level installed as a part of the 1988 work are insulated steel doors with non
ADA compliant - non-lever type handles.
17. The site soils are thought to consist of mostly clays and silty clays, and silty sand. These soils types are very frost susceptible.
This has been a problem for quite some time at the existing building and to some extent the new addition; in that as the frost
enters the ground and leaves it again - there is a considerable amount of building movement and settlement. The result is
doors with pinched hinges and locks that become loose. Both the new addition and the existing facility are consequently
subject to seasonal elevation shifts due to frost action. This has increased in times when there is a wet fall and a hard frost
early.
18. The grading on this side of the building should be redone to provide positive drainage away from the building foundation
rather than toward it. .
19. It appears though at least 2 insulated windows lites on this elevation have failed. I recommend replacing the existing
windows with new work. Overall I see 6 windows with failed glazing seals that need to be replaced with new work. The 3/8
inch plywood siding on the exposed wall area above the low roof and the adjoining new roof section of the council chambers
and existing facility at the step flashing level is starting to become rotted out from water and movement. The fascia is cracked
along this elevation and quite a bit of the existing trim and plywood siding should be replaced with new work.
20. The existing bird screen on the 4'-0" x 4'-0" louver on this elevation of the-building should becheck and cleaned if it is
clogged.
, .
21. There is also no apparent roof aCcess, (other than by ladder - and 'although this keeps people off the roof, - there are enough
trees on this elevation, whose falling leaves will clog the gutter system.: This is an on-going maintenance issue. Perhaps
adding gutter shields would be an effective means to keep the gutters.C1ean.
West Building Elevation:
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
9
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
-
1. For the most part, the grade along this side of the building appears to be either flat - or sloped back towards the building. A
drainage swale should be cut in along this elevation of the building, (between the evergreens and the building) so that surface
water can be directed out of this area out towards Country Club Road.
2. The trim boards on this elevation are starting to come loose at the 9 ft. high level. There is also some buckling in the siding
that means water infiltration into the wall system. The siding on this side of the building needs to be replaced with new work
along with new trim and insulation. The fascia is starting to split, and the 2" x' 12"s and window trim should be replaced with
new work.
3. The 2 window frames on this elevation are showing considerable wear and the southern most window has a bullet hole in the
glazing. The aluminum window framing finish is failing on both windows (typical at all locations on all elevations).
4. At the northwest corner of the building a section of drain tile is exposed to daylight near an electrical "LB" at grade. I've no
idea what this DT does, or why it is open to daylight. (Could at one time the adjacent RWL been piped into the perimeter DT
system?)
Exterior Site General Notes:
1. Several of the bushes on the west elevation should be removed. The landscaping on the north, west, and south elevations of
the building should be removed, and the area around the building re-graded to provide positive drainage away from the
existing structure and the addition. This will help to clear up foundation water infiltration problems.
2. Where the siding is buckled on the west elevation, (this is the exterior west all of the Council Chambers), water is getting into
the wall system and is causing a problem. This is why the room is cold. The wet insulation has lost its insulating value.
3. I was not able to get access to the roof.
4. I recommend that the following be replaced:
./ Roof (Replace with a new metal standing seam roof and covered gutter system)
./ Siding & trim (Replace with EIFS - provides more exterior '(Jail insulation)
./ Windows (Replace with 1" low-E coated IG glazing in thermall{broken aluminum frames. (Suggest that operable
casements be considered as replacements to the fixed windows).
./ Storefront system (Replace with new low-E coated IG glass in thermally broken wide sytle aluminUm frames. Add low
energy power assisted swinging handicapped door openers at b'oth the exterior & interior main entry vestibule pair.
. .
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey .doc
10
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
~
,",' \
',)
i"
-
y' Replace the eXisting wouu Ut;;0r- "villi u. II,," '-'~w, ." r'-"
y' Infill the foundation wall "knock out" panel with new eMU construction.
y' Replace the existing wood stairs with new steel stairs.
./' Remove & replace the existing blacktop paving on the east & south elevations. Re-grade to provide positive drainage
away from the building, replace exciting paving with new bituminous paving.
y' Cut back the trees along the south elevation of the building to let sunshine in - to help allow this elevation of the site to
"dry" out.
y' Replace the single handicapped parking space with two handicapped parking spaces, install with an 8'-0" wide
stripped access aisle between the spaces, - and center the "access aisle" on the main entry sidewalk. Install a new 8'.
0" wide handicapped curb cut at this location.
y' Install new egress bollard lighting at main entry.
y' Add lights to illuminate the existing Monument sign, or replace the existing wood sign with a new backlit cabinet sign.
-
5. I recommend the removal of all perimeter building landscaping, and that the entire foundation be excavated & water proofed,
and the DT system be replaced with new work, and run to daylight.
6. Most of the roof areas on the existing building and the new addition at least on the north elevations are a 3-12 slope. I would
strongly suggest the city replace this sloping asphalt shingled roof membrane with a standing seem metal roof with an ice &
water shield membrane under the metal roofing. This would also allow for additional insulation on the roof and the siding clip
system would defeat any ice damming problems they would be experiencing.
7. Keep a 2'-0" wide maintenance strip most around the perimeter of the building.
8. I recommend replacing the HV AC systems completely to provide for better air exchange and air quality.
9. I recommend that the city add a security system to cover the exterior perimeter and to monitor the main entry and parking lot
after business hours. (It is also understood the city rents out the council chambers / meeting room and the conference rooms
to civic groups after hours, - and this is another good reason why th~y should have an enhanced security & video monitoring
system to (at least), cover the main lobby areas, the restroom corridor, the break room, the council chambers, and the
conference rooms). While they are doing that I would set up peripheralcameras to cover all elevations and especially the rear
of the building, which is in a blind.
10. Additional site lighting is also a good idea around the perimeter of the building. It will provide a nice aesthetic plus it will
enhance the overall security as well. .
Building Survey
Q:\1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
11
1613.01
. Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
.. -
open rail picket system, for security
vandals.
12. Get rid of the existing propane grills and go with natural gas grill set ups that are the permanent in-ground type. Install the
grilles at least 10'-0" away from the building exterior. (Install the gas grille shut ofts and control valves on the interior of the
building). This will prevent the possibility that people could start up the grills, (as they are now), and set them up against the
building and cause a fire. .
13. Replace the existing hose bibs on the building with new frost-free / anti-back siphon type hose bib with removable keys..
14. There is no emergency power to the building at this time. Not sure if there is an overlapping grid that is available as an
alternative to emergency power, or if the city should consider installing an emergency generator & A TS switch that would
provide overall emergency power to the building.
Landscaping & Site Amenities Review:
1. All plantings located around the perimeter of the building need to be removed to accommodate new positive drainage re-
grading around the building. Overall paving sections are in good shape, curbs in relatively good shape.
2. Add new exterior egress lighting.
3. I suggest that the City replace the existing treated timber retaining wall along the east edge of the property between the
Badger Park tennis courts and the east property line with dry laid segmental concrete retaining wall units.
4. The City should replace the existing bituminous paving along the east elevation and the rear of the new addition to promote
drainage away from the building.
5. The storm sewer system serving the front parking lot should be checked and cleaned and vacuumed out. The drain is now
clogged.
6. I suggest that the City consider adding a payment drop box at the drive up island in front the main entrance - for the
convenience of residents. . .
7. (The City could also use a new "decorative" post office box but that is an ascetic issue).
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
12
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall .
Shorewood, Minnesota
::~:
.<
8. Also cut back some of the trees along the south elevation ot the bUilding as eVluellCt: UI lilt: ct18W:; IIIVIU 8' v,,"" V" ~~.. - -
trim work. This elevation is getting wet and not getting dried out and we have water damage to the siding and trim on this
elevation of the building.
9. Some of the existing landscape edging is in deteriorating shape and as a part of a retro fit that all the plastic edging be
replaced with steel edgings.
10. Install an in ground lawn irrigation system for water conservation.
INTERIOR ROOM-BY-ROOM SURVEY:
Vestibule 101: (main entrance)
Entrance mats should be replaced with recessed flush type pediment or use a single entry mat should be used rather than the 2
separate mats being used. The double entry mat creates a condition in which it is hard to maneuver across in a wheel chair
when passing through a double door vestibule.
Doors should be set with closure pressure no more than 5 pounds of force required for operation.
According to section 4.0.42.10 door surfaces within 10 inches of the floor or ground, (measured vertically), shall be a solid
unbroken surface on the push side of the door, and the unbroken surface shall extended the full width of the door. Parts
creating horizontal of vertical joints in the surface shall be within 1/8 inch of the same plane of the other cavities created by an
added kick plate shall be capped. This is another reason that the full glazed narrow style doors need be be replaced with wide
style doors with minimum 10-inch bottom rails.
Door closures shall be adjusted so that from an open position of 70 degrees, the door will take at least 3 seconds to move to a
point 3 inches away from the latch measured to the leading edge of th'e door.
I suggest that the City install a pair of low energy power assisted swinging handicapped automatic door openers to serve at
least on leaf of each door pair at the interior & exterior. Include push plate operators to complete the installation. Set up the
power assisted door opener controls so that only the interior or the exterfor door will be able to open - via the powered door
opener - at any given time. (Both doors should not be open at the s?me'time.
,
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
13
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
Space heater: There is an electronic space heater installed in this entry vestibule. I am not sure if heat generated by this small
unit is adequate for the size of the vestibule served, - but it looks rather small.
Vestibule Light fixture: The entry light fixture in the vestibule I would recommend replacing with better lighting fixture.
Vestibule Interior doors: See the recommend changes noted f?r the exterior door pair.
Lobbv 102:
Recommend that if the existing exit sign in the lobby is not a battery back-up type that should be changed out to a battery back
up type. There are battery back up lights installed in this lobby. Raise them up 4 inches more to get them out of the 80-inch
clear zone requirement above finish floor for projections of more than 4 inches into the corridor path of travel. '
The fire extinguisher mounted in the surfaced mounted cabinet projects approximately 6 1/2 inches out from the wall and is
within the 27-80 inch designated clearance zone. This semi-recessed cabinet should be replaced with a different semi-
recessed cabinet that will project no more than 4 inches out from the face of the wall.
I recommend that the light fixtures be switched out - the existing lighting levels are poor.
At the main service counter, a portion of the service counter should be lowered to be ADA compliant, this would be 48-inch
wide section with a surface not more that 34" AFF, and with at least a 9" deep knee space that has 30" clear opening under the
counter per ADA requirements. An option to remodeling the main service counter would be to provide a freestanding desk area
in the lobby where a person in a wheel chair could sit and work in compliance with the "reasonable accommodation"
requirement of ADA.
The wood folding counter door that is used to seal off the reception counter should be replaced with a fixed operable metal
coiling roll down shutter which can be properly secured and locked after business hours, - since the lobby will be open to
groups that are renting the conference rooms or meeting room spaces. The existing wood accordion door is not a secured
c1~ure. '
The kick down door hold open on the entrance door leading into the servige area beyond the service counter should be
removed and replaced with an overhead type stop. (Better yet put an electronic lock on this door, and leave it "closed" for a
more secure installation."
-
Consider adding a telephone with TOO ,device to serving hearing-impaired residents.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey ,doc
14
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
_.. . ~,..__...._ 4_ ._..____.._.~....._~.............-.~.~ ~._-,-.- .--..-.. --- ~,-
7'C'-'~...
Vllj 11.....-...........-.) "''-' 1"'-'..---..... .~~..,- ..~..) '-'
contrasting letters & back ground colors to accommodate visually impaired persons.
The entire facility should be fitted with a new fire alarm system which is addressable and monitored, - and a new automatic fire
sprinkler fire suppressed system.
The Fire Alarm system strobes and horns should all meet ADA requirements and meet the mounting heights for pull statJons
etc.
Coatroom # 103
Somewhat undersized considering the allowable occupancy of the Council Chambers / meeting room. However it will work if
the handicapped coat rack that is currently obstructed with recycling containers, an office machine, and other material is made
accessible. This is a cloakroom - not a storage room - clear out all the stuff stored in this room - except for the cloak racks and
(possibly), the soda machine.
A split transition threshold should be installed between the carpeted surface of the coatroom and the adjacent paver surface of
the lobby. There is a half-inch difference of height. This should be accomplished with an ADA compliant threshold.
I recommend that the cloakroom light fixture be replaced with a "night light" type light fixture and something that puts out more
light.
Meetinq room #104
The operable leaf of the door pair leading into the Council Chambers meeting room drags on the floor. It should be shaved on
the bottom. I also recommend that this door be fitted out on the active leaf with an automatic power assisted door opener that is
operable by push plate from both sides of the door.
The door pulls should be changed to offset wire pull type, - which is more accessible friendly.
Recommend the City consider installing assisted listening devices in at least two locations in the spectator area in the meeting
room.
The Council bench should be moved ahead approximately 48 inches: t,o provide clearance for ADA around & behind the council
bench seats - and the back wall of the meeting room. Also replaced the step up to the raised dais - on one'side at least, with a
code compliant ramp, with no more than a 1-12 slope up from the floor to the raised dais.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
15
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
One seat section of the council bench shall be modified to provide for a handicapped accessible space. WI e an enc
raised so that the surface is no more than 34inches above finished floor and the clearance under the work surface provides for
a minimum of 30 inches above the floor. The floor registers on the raised dais should be taken out of the floor an installed in the
walls so that they don't create a tripping hazard or an impediment to wheel chair access. The rear exit behind the council
chambers bench - out to the patio area that has a step down "well" at the in front of the door should be modified so that there is
no difference in the level of the walking surface on either side of the door..
Lighting levels in the council chamber are poor. I recommend replacing the light fixtures.
Recommend that throughout the facility that automatic fire suppression fire protection system along with a full addressable fire
alarm system, including pull stations, horns and strobes etc.
There is no maximum occupancy load posted in this space.
I recommend that, (at a minimum). The Council Chambers, as well as the lobby, the coatroom, and the conference room, and
the corridor to the restroom be covered with video surveillance equipment as well as motion detectors and infra red motion
detectors.
A transitional threshold shall be installed to replace the termination strip between the carpet and the tile of the junction between
the lobby paving floor system and the carpet in the meeting room. The transition should provide for full width of the opening of
the double doorframe.
Name plaques at the council bench should be replaced with better signage that is more readable. The aspect of being visually
impaired from audience area, suggest that the nameplates have 2-3 inch high letters and be of bright contrasting colors.
I recommend that this room be fitted out with emergency battery backed lighting, And that the exits lights also be battery back
up type if an emergency generator system is not installed as part of a remodeling or renovation.
Floor registers should be changed to wall type registers.
Staff informs me that the meeting room is cold during the heating season, this could be because of the failed insulation, which I
feel is probably the problem on the west elevation of the room. Also ther:e may be a need to install additional insulation in the
vaulted ceiling. Further investigation of the structure is needed to d~terrriine how the cavity and the attic areas above the
finished ceilings are insulated, so that auxiliary insulation can be added as required. Also the addition of two or more air
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
16
1613.01
. Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
would provide for better air movement and reduce "cold spots
Mechanical Room #105
Recommend the door to this room be fitted out with an overhead door hold open device.
.
Recommend that the 2 walls flanking the janitors slop sink be covered with RFP panels to 48 inches above finished floor.
Suggest a floor sink be considered as a replacement to the existing janitors sink, - and that a mop holder and shelf be installed
above the new floor set slop sink.
Suggest that when the fire alarm monitoring system is installed that this space be fitted with BOTH rate of rise heat detectors,
and ion type smoke detectors.
Emplovee break room/Kitchen 106:
The break room is small for the amount of staff. An increase in the size of this space, plus direct access to the exterior would be
desirable. Not sure how that is going to be achieved at this juncture, - but it is a rather small space. Recommend the
replacement of the range with a smooth top electric type with front accessible controls.
Recommend of the replacement of the kitchen sink faucet with new lever handled unit, - as it is leaking.
The microwave should be relocated in a remodeling to an accessible height, (with the controls no more than 48 inches above
finished floor). The refrigerator should also be changed out when it's warranty expires to be an ADA compliant type, (a side by
side type), which will allow equal access to the freezer and refrigerator sections.
The exhaust fan installed over the sink should be reviewed as far as CF exhaust requirements go. I suspect that we would be
would want to "up" the CFM. (This might prevent kitchen odors - such 'as microwave popcorn to filter into the lobby, - and
beyond.
Recommend the toaster oven currently be removed and disposed of. I c~:msider them to be a fire hazard. (This is a personal
observation) .
. -
Replacement / remodeling the kitchen sink to make it ADA compliant at some future time would require that the garbage
disposal unit be removed and ADA compliant accessible panel be installed. I strongly recommend replacement of the kitchen
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
17
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
In consideration of accessibility issues - if at some future time the kitchen is remodeled, then a section of the new counter top
should be built to be accessible, - at no more than 34 inches above finish floor with clearance under the counter to
accommodate a wheel chair. I also recommend that the Dutch door set up that is currently installed betwe.en the break room
and the Council Chambers be replaced with a solid core 3'-0" x 7'-0" door with smoke gasket, closure, - etc. When they
relocate the microwave they can put a pass through above the sink area with a shelf and add a roll down shutter or a pull
across type closure. Might make it a more utilizable kitchen when less people have to come in and outof it.
The door closure on the door that leads from the lobby corridor into the break room is disabled. Reconnect it. Also add smoke
gaskets to the frame. The privacy latch set on the same door should be replaced with commercial type lever handled lockset.
Men's & Women's Restrooms 107 & 108 & adiacent hallwav:
Neither of these restrooms are ADA / Minnesota Handicapped code compliant. I recommend that they be re configured to be
code complaint. The work would include replacement of the lav, lav faucets, repositioning of the paper towel dispenser and
waste. Remove the existing toilet partitions and replacement with new code compliant work. In the women's restroom - at least
one of the toilets will have to be relocated, to be code complaint; including the removal and replacement of the existing
handicapped grab bar set up. The toilet paper dispenser and sanitary napkin waste will also need to be removed and relocated
to be code complaint. The existing toilet fixture appears to be code compliant handicapped toilet unit, but I would replace the
toilet seat assembly with a self-checking lid set up.
Wall tiles on the wet wall are stained and I would recommend they be replaced with new work. Also add another light fixture
over the toilet stalls and update the finishes. I would also update the floor"to new ceramic tile with %" high sanitary base..
The existing set up for mirror and shelf should be replaced with a tilted mirror and shelf set. I recommend that a purse shelf be
installed along with the new code compliant toilet fixture accessories. Also recommend both restrooms be fitted out with
electronic hand dryers as well as the paper towel sets ups that curren'tly are there. All fixtures and accessories should be
mounted at ADA compliant mounting heights including ADA compliant knurled finish handicapped grab bara. The single sink
waste plumbing should be installed with ADA compliant padding and burn. shields and the new faucet should be a lever type
compatible with ADA requirement, and Minnesota Accessibility Code. .
I would sound insulate all the walls of these rest rooms and also the area of the ceiling above. I would replace the existing
louvered wood doors with solid core wood doors with smoke-gasketirlg installed around the perimeter of the doorframe on the
stop face to reduce the amount of noise transmission from inside the rest rooms to the hall and the areas beyond.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
18
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
I n~ SIII~It:l ~~I VI(';~ ~1t;(';lIIC wd[81 ",UUIt;1 IIIUUIIle::U III 1I1e:: ;:'111011 Ql(.;UVe:: U8lvve::c:ll llle:: LVVU I t;;:,[1 UUIII~ ~IIUUlU U~ (';lldll~~U UUl LU Uc: d
high/low split ADA compliant type unit and the size of the alcove adjusted to meet the ADA clearance requirements.
Replace the hallway lighting, (as well as the lighting in the 2 toilet rooms).
In the men's rest room we need to have urinal screen installed between the urinal and the sink as well as changing the fixture
heights for both the urinal and the sink. Men's rest room toilet will need to be relocated, and I recommend the seat and lia
assembly be switched out to a split seat and a lid with a self-check / back-check. Provide the following clearances between
fixtures:
1. Provide a minimum of 15" clear from the Centerline of sinks and toilets to adjacent wall.
2. Provide 42" clear between the centerline of the toilet and the edge of the sink.
The signage for both of these should be changed out to indicate handicapped accessibility and the doors to the restrooms
should be changed as well
Furnish and install FA horns & strobes plus smoke detectors, fire protection heads, etc. Suggest the rear exit out of the corridor
be fitted with alarm panics rather than the lock set it is currently set up with. Change the exit light above this exit out for a
battery back up type.
Reception Area 109:
If at some future time a handicapped individual is ever assigned or hired, - accommodations will have to be made to the
reception desk / service counter - including the relocating of systems of furniture, and remodeling of built ins to provide
adequate code compliant clearances. Until that happens, I do not see the need for any changes on the staff side of the service
counter being required at this time under the current handicapped code requirements.
Recommend changing out the existing light fixture types to newer energy efficient t-8 Fluorescent light fixtures and electronic
ballasts. The lighting levels are quite harsh in the offices and open office area. This should be addressed as a part of any
renovations.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
19
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
Work Area 115:
I recommend the addition of an automatic fire suppression system (AFS) plus a new fire alarm system; complete with off site
monitoring. I suggest that the City also consider installing a security system as well.
Add a safety gate to the head of the stairs to the lower level. Install with a positive latch and stop tab, and self-closing hinges.
This gate should be able to with stand 350 Ibs of lateral force applied to the upper level side of the gate. .
Add emergency battery back-up lighting to this area. - in addition to night-lighting fixtures with battery back up.
All of the signage in the administration & office areas should be changed out to provide better code compliant way finding,
including raised Braille lettering.
Recommend all HV AC floor outlets be converted over to wall type supply air registers instead of floor mounts. (Typical at all
locations).
COpy Area / Open office Area 117:
Recommendations for improvements to this area includes expanding the copy area into the open office space to create an
"island work station" and peripheral countertops around as much of that area as possible for additional work surface space. The
outgoing fax machine is housed in a shared area with outside vendors, this fax machine should be relocated to the remodeled
copy center area. Also - faxes that come in through the network show up at the incoming fax copy machine, which is outside of
the copy area and is actually located in work area by reception. I suggest that we gather all office machines in one area (in copy
center).
The main server is located in an office that is also shared by outside vendors. This server should be secured and locked up in
an IT closet. I also feel that the shared space should be separate from and locked off from the administration areas.
I, .
The IT person should have a lockable office. (If nothing else the main server should be placed in that same lockable office).
The, building expansion joint installed in the floor between the new additioriand existing facility is puckered at both sides of the
aisle. This joint should be replaced with a factory built expansion joint system that will accommodate vertical & horizontal
movement. ' .
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
20
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
heaving & settlement taking place within and between the eXisting !aCillty dllU lIle [Iew aUUlllUtl. I""~I" U~ ~~ ..~~,,~. ~ . ~
control joints. No apparent cracking has developed in the ceiling between the old and new addition - which is surprising.
The lateral file system set up in the open office area is extremely heavy and is imposing some pretty good loads on the existing
floor system. Staff is also short of filing space here and I see no fire cabinets or fire-rated file/storage room for permanent
record storage. Without fire protection, - a fire suppression system or a fire alarm system, or fire proof storage cabinets - any
type of fire incident could cause public records to be lost. I assume that at this juncture that there is no archiving backup'on disk
or other means. Is off site storage also is being used - due to the lack of space, and the water & mold in the basement?
Copy machine paper is also stored on the floor in this same area - added floor loading. A lack of shelf and work counter space
is obvious. AIl-in-all there could be twice as much space available in this same area if there were a secure, dry fire proof
storage room in the new addition lower level. A separate plan document room would also fit in the lower level - but it is
inhabitable at present due to water and mold problems.
. The HV AC system throughout this facility should be replaced with a new and updated multi-zone forced air system. Perhaps
stand-alone air handling units could be used to replace the residential furnaces?
The following notes apply to the four offices spaces along the north elevation of this part of the existing facility that includes
both the addition area and the existing faculty:
1. It is evident after reviewing these spaces that they're over-crowded and suffer from a lack of storage space and work
surfaces.
2. Most of the offices in the facility are double or triple occupied while paperwork, documents. plans, forms, and files are
stock piled everywhere. Their needs to be a central filing and plan rack system and more space available and a
separate fire rated file storage room on site.
3. All of these offices should be covered with file alarm systems and fire suppression systems.
4. Overall the finishes are in pretty good shape.
5. I suggest that further sound insulating between offices be done.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
21
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
This conference room is located between the reception area and lobby area on the north side of the building. This space is also
used, (rented), by the public after working hours. The existing key lock system should be changed out. They have a best lock,
double cylinder set up at this time. The City should consider up-grading to a double grand master key system. Also the building
finish hardware could stand to be upgraded, - including replacing all hinges and lock sets - partially because of the seas<;mal
frost movement of the facility during the year. The heaving and settling has caused damage to a lot of the hinges and lock sets
and at times doors are binding and will not latch because of frost coming in'- or going out.
There was one failed vision light noted in this room. (I recommend that all windows get replaced with crank out casement type
window units).
Plannina Space 110, Office 111 , Office 112, Book Keepina 113, and Finance 114:
I recommend installation of fire alarm system and fire suppression system, automatic fire protection, - in addition to a security
system with motion sensors and infra-red detectors.
All finishes are in fairly good shape.
The lighting should be upgraded to T-8 lamps & electronic ballasts. Also the light levels are very harsh, - I would redo the
lighting through out the facility.
I recommend that all of the existing fixed windows be replaced with new IG glazed casements with double cam-Iock operable
sashes, with insect screens.
The walls and floors are for the most part in good shape.
Staff notes they would like to see improvement in the over-hang of the eave edge and rake soffit system. Ideally the soffits
would be extended out 2-3 feet or more and help would create a better sunscreen. Extended soffits would also help direct rain
water away from the building.
Overall the air quality has been improved by setting the residential furnace units to the setting where the fan is running all the
time. This is a good idea and to take it one step further - if the existing furnaces are not replaced with new HV AC system, they
, .
should be supplemented with an automatic building air exchange system - which can be adjusted to accommodate more air
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
22
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
EXISTING BUILDING BASEMENT AREA:
Some of the existing electrical service panels look like they are all full up. However, overall - the electrical service looks like
taken all together, different electrical panels do have a lot of "spare" capacity.
All areas that have sheet rock walls, (whether finished or unfinished), shouldbe fitted out with vinyl base to preserve the
integrity of the sheet rock wall systems and to help keep them from getting wet at the base. This will help to inhibit problems
such as mold growth - which is evident in a portion of the new addition basement.
Most all elevations of the basement, - including the new addition exhibit varying degrees of water infiltration problems. This is a
sign that the grading around the building needs to be adjusted and perhaps a waterproofing membrane needs to be applied to
the exterior face of below grade foundation walls. My recommendation would be to address the grading to improve the positive
drainage away from the building, then cleaning up exposed foundation walls visible in the basement - to see if this does not
clear up this water infiltration problem. If grading alone does not resolve the problem, then water proofing of below grade
foundation walls may be necessary. I do not recommend hydrophobic grouting of the below slab-on-grade fill at this time.
The 40-gallon water heater looks like it is fairly new and in good shape. Noticed that there is no water treatment or softener
being used. Not sure if water is hard or if a water treatment set up would be something that the staff would like to see
addressed.
Two of the three residential furnaces in the existing building basement area look like they have been replaced recently. These
newer forced air up-flow furnaces all look like 90 plus units.. There is a an existing Carrier unit down here that is quite a bit older
than either the Bryant or the Lennox units, (in the 15-20 years old range). At some point they should be considered replacing
the Carrier unit also.
The City Building official noted that there is no one-hour separation between the basement and the first floor level. This would
severely limit the ability to build out the basement space.
However other staff have identified the fact there is a problem with mold in the basement and people who work down there for
more than a day become sick and have to go home to recover. I did not have any reaction to being in the basement _ but that
does not mean that there is NOT a problem here. '. .
'-
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
23
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
Archiving paper materials & old files & plans in this space - at present - is not a good idea.
There is a sump pump located in the new entry between the new facility and the existing facility that runs just about
continuously when during any wet spells. I believe that the water table is not too far below the slab-on-grade, and as a re.sult I
believe that there are likely to be continuing water problems in the basement spaces. As I understand it there have been times
where water has actually come up through the cracks in the basement floors. Obviously the vapor barrier has failed or the water
is just overwhelming it.
There is also no smoke fire dampers installed anywhere in the' HV AC system.
In the northwest corner of the new addition, - and all along the northern elevation of this basement area there is evidence of
mold growth on the lower portion of the sheet rock wallboard. All of this sheet, insulation, and VB materials in the affected
areas should be carefully removed in sections, encapsulated in plastic and sealed, removed and legally disposed of off-site.
The remaining block and steel stud furring should be treated with a 10 - 20 % bleach solution and completely dried out. At that
point, I recommend that an industrial hygienist be retained to come in test for the presence of mold. If there is still mold
present, then hire a licensed mold abatement contractor to come in and abate & encapsulate the mold until there is no longer a
problem. I HOWEVER, UNTIL THE WATER INFILTRATION PROBLEM IS RESOLVED, - THERE IS ALWAYS THE
LIKELIHOOD THAT THE MOLD ISSUE CAN RE-DEVELOP.
Also note that the return air system in the basement is fully ducted, (there is not an open return air plenum system, (although I
did not go up into any "attic" spaces above any of the main level ceilings. I did see what I took to be an access scuttle installed
in the janitor's closet.
The computer mainframe is currently housed in the basement of the new addition. I would suggest that at some point in time,
that the City may want to enclose this in a locked room. I also suggest installing an auxiliary ventilation system to protect the
equipment from over heating. .
GENERAL EXTERIOR NOTES:
1. Include in the renovation plans for the exterior sections to replace the existing siding system, windows, exterior doors,
hardware, roofing membrane and HV AC system, and re grade all around the perimeter of the building - after removing all of
the landscaped areas around the bu.ilding to promote positive drainage away from the building. .
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
24
1613.01
. Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
2. Re pave the roadway on the eastern portion of the site to provide better positive drainage and to repair areas that are not
satisfactory, and which do not drain properly.
3. Replace the existing timber retaining wall on the east side of the site with dry tack concrete segmentai retaining wall units.
4. Remove the cedar porch and replace it with a concrete patio.
5. Replace the existing wood stairway with a metal stairs with steel tube steel hand railings.
6. Remove and dispose of the existing propane fueled BBQ's, and replace them with fixed natural gas units, (with the gas
controlled on the inside of the building and the grill is located on the edge of the patio away from the building).
7. Replace the existing roofing system, and incorporate of deeper soffit overhangs, add additional insulation and install a pre-
finished metal standing seem roof with snow clips.
8. I also think that the tree line along the south elevation of the building should be cut back to promote sunlight hitting this
elevation to "dry this area up".
9. The exterior lighting bollards should be replaced with new work as well as the exterior lighting in general.
10. The parking lot lighting seems adequate.
11. The curbs and gutters are overall in pretty good shape considering the age of the facility.
12. Add one handicapped parking space that is van accessible. Move both the non-van-accessible and the van-accessible
parking handicapped spaces and side aisle to the front entrance and let the side aisle striped area be the identified entry
into the building and relocate the handicapped curb to this location as well.
GENERAL INTERIOR NOTES:
1. I would install a security system.
2. Install an automatic fire suppression and an Fire Alarm system that a:re both ADA compliant, (with an addressable warning
system. combination audible and flashing strobes, and manual pull st"ations. Provide for the installation of a dry type or wet
type fire sprinkler system on both levels in the addition and the existing facility with Siamese connection .as directed by the
local fire department.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
25
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
3. Replace the existing lighting. (Some areas are over-lit and some are under-lit). Provide for individual workstation task
lighting to achieve a better over-all lighting scheme that will increase the productivity and effectiveness of the staff and also
reduce the glare of VDT's.
4. There should be a separate IT office with a lockable door that the server can be secured in.
5. Create a lockable area around the basement server.
6. There is a mold problem in the basement that needs to be addressed. The area where mold is present should all be abated
and then waterproofing steps taken including exterior re-grading - to see that it does not re-occur.
7. Create a 2-hour fire containment file storage area in the basement to maintain permanent records.
8. Expand some of the open spaces work areas by combining open office work areas and a copy center to better utilize the
space. I think that with better space planning and taking advantage of the basement areas after they have been cleaned up
to accommodate more storage would allow this facility to function more efficiently and would "open it up" considerably.
9. For the most part all of the building interior and exterior spaces could be adjusted or reconfigured to comply with ADA.
10. Barrier removal is not really a problem.
11 . The existing toilet rooms will have to be expanded to meet the requirements of ADA, but other areas - such as the break
areas and individual staff offices do not necessarily need to be changed to meet ADA.
12. The raised portion of the meeting room should be remodeled.
OVERVIEW OF THE TITLE III RULES:
1. Auxiliary aids in public accommodations. As of January 26,1992 a " publ.ic accommodation" must provide auxiliary aides and
services when they are necessary to ensure effective communications with persons with hearing, vision, speech impairments
provided that such action does not constitute a "un-do burden" on the facility. Towards that end the City should consider
changing the exterior signage to provide better way-finding for visually impaired persons.
2. What are auxiliary aides? These services include to, but are not necessar.ily limited to:
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
26
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
o Assertive listening devices
o Telephone handset amplifiers
o Note takers
o Written materials for persons with hearing impairments
o Telephone communications devices for deaf persons (TOO's) with video text displays
o Qualified readers
o Taped texts of written materials,
o Brail & large print text for persons with vision problems.
3. If the provision of a given auxiliary aid or service would resqlt in a undo burden, the public accommodations should provide an
aid or service the ensures, to the maximum extent feasible, that persons with disabilities will receive the same goods,
services, facilities, privileges, or accommodations that are given to everyone else being served by that facility.
4. What is an undo burden? The ADA defines an undo burden as a "significant difficulty or expense ". Whether an action is an
undo burden will be determined by a case-by-case basis. No numerical form or threshold was set up by the Justice
Department. However the following factors are to be considered:
A. The nature and cost of the action needed.
B. The over-all financial resources of the site or sites involved; the number of persons employed; the effect on expenses
and resources; and the impact on the operation of the site.
c. The geographic separateness.
D. Administrative or fiscal relationship of the site or sites to a parent corporation or entity.
E. If applicable, the over financial resources and size of any corporation or entity.
F. If applicable, the type of operation or any parent corporation or entity.
G. The factors above are identical to those to be used in determine if barrier removal is readily achievable. However
"undo burden" is a higher standard than that set for "readily achievable" in that it requires a bigger effort and a greater
expense the part of the public accommodation.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
27
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
..... -------~
the physical structure of the building - such as bearing walls or columns. Communications barriers can include alarm systems
and permanent signage. Note: communications equipment and devices such as TOO's and other assisted listing devices are
included under the requirements for auxiliary aids, - if there are public telephones in the facility.
6. What is readily achievable? "The ADA defines readily achievable as "easily accomplished" and "able to be carried out with out
much difficulty or expense". Whether or not the action is readily achievable is determined on a case-by-case basis. Examples:
installing ramps; making curb cuts on sidewalks and entrances; repositioning shelves; re-arranging tables, chairs, vending
machines, display racks, and other furniture. Re-positioning phones; adding raised markings on elevator control buttons,
installing flashing alarm lights, widening doors, installing off 'set hinges to widen door ways, installing accessible door
hardware, installing code compliant grabs bars in toilet stalls, re-arranging toilet partitions to increase space, insulating
lavatory pipes under sinks to prevent burns, installing raised toilets or toilet seats, installing full length bathroom mirrors, re-
positioning paper towel dispensers in bathrooms, creating designated accessible parking spaces, installing an accessible
paper cup dispenser at an existing inaccessible water fountain, and removing high pile - low density carpeting.
7. Recommended priorities for the removal of barriers: The ADA contains priorities that a public accommodation should consider
when deciding what is readily achievable. These are priorities are not mandatory, but rather suggestive ways to determine
what types of barriers should be mitigated or eliminated first. The priorities are as follows:
A. Access from public sidewalks, parking, or public transportation stops to a building entrance. (Such measures include
installing an entrance ramp, widening entrances, and providing accessible parking spaces.
B. Access to any area where goods and services are made available to the public. (Examples include: Adjusting layout of
display racks, rearranging tables, providing Braille and raised signage, widening doors, and installing visual alarms,
and installing ramps.)
C. Access to restroom facilities. (Examples include the removal of obstructing furniture or vending machines, widenng
doors, installing ramps, providing accessible signage, widening ~oilet stalls, installing grab bars, re-installing toilet
accessories at accessible locations.
O. Access to the ancillary goods and services provided.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
28
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Snorewood, Minnesota
.~.
- - - - -........ .... ... . . .... ..
consult with local organizations representing persons with disabilities and solicit their suggestions for cost-effective
means of making individual places of public accommodation accessible. Before determining if barrier removal is
readily achievable, a public accommodation must first justify any existing barriers. The most appropriate way of doing
so is through self-evaluation, (by comparing the existing building or facility to the requirements of a newly constructed
facility.or any recently altered facility - whose up-grades included updating for compliance to the MN Handicapped
Code & the ADA. .
F. Once all existing barriers have been identified, determining what is readily achievable can begin. The priorities and the
input of local disability organizations should be used as a guide to determine what barriers are most critical. All
existing barriers that can be removed through readily achievable measures should then be removed.
G. When there is a barrier that cannot be removed by readily achievable means, the public accommodations should
establish a periodic review process, if the barrier removal is something that could become readily achievable at some
future time.
H. The entire self-evaluation process and the subsequent determination of readily achievable measures should be fully
documented. In particular the list should be maintained to identify existing barriers that are not removed, along with the
specific reasons why the removal was not readily achievable.
I. Through this process the building owner, in this case the City of Shorewood, must be aware of decisions to remove or
not remove barriers that may be subject to scrutiny by others. in the event of a subsequent discrimination complaint.
By involving local organizations that represent people with disabilities and the identification of certain barriers, the
likelihood of future of complaints should be greatly diminished.
J. Primary Function Areas. The "primary function area" is any'room or space where the major service or activity that the
facility is intended to provide are carried out. Examples include, are, but not limited to, the customer service lobby's of
the city hall, the break room, the conference and meeting rooms, The Council Chamber, as well as offices and work
areas in which the activities of the public accommodation are carried out. Areas such as mechanical rooms, boiler
rooms, copier rooms, employee locker rooms and lounges, janitorial closets, employee entrances and service
corridors and employee only restrooms are NOT necessarily automatically considered primary function areas.
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
29
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
. .... .
p ry pp"
facility and other parts of the facility. Minor alterations to individual elements of primary function area do not trigger a
path of travel of obligation automatically. In other words alterations to such elements as windows, hardware, light
switches and thermostats, electrical outlets, and signage. (However these elements must be made accessible if they
are altered.)
If alteration work is solely work is limited electrical, mechanical, plumbing, system, or a hazardous material abatement
or two automatic sprinkler retrofitting and does not involve any alteration of any element required to be accessible.
There is no obligation to provide a path of travel.
L. Disproportionate costs: In some instances the cost of providing an accessible path of travel to an altered area may be
disproportionate to the alteration cost of the primary function area. Costs of providing accessible path of travel will
likely be considered "disproportionate" when the cost exceeds 20% of the overall cost of the alteration of the primary
function area.
When the path of travel costs are disproportionate, the path of travel shall be made accessible to the extent that is is
not disproportionate. According to an interpretation from the Justice Department, this does not necessarily mean this
is an expenditure of the full 20%. In cases where a full expenditure of 20% would not increase the accessibility along
the path of travel, alterations should be made to the extent that they would result in an increase in accessibility. When
the costs of alterations necessary to make an accessible path of travel is disproportionate to the cost of overall
alterations, priorities should be given to those elements which will provide the greatest access in the following order:
3. Accessible entrance and route to the altered area.
4. At least one accessible restroom for each sex, (applies to both single sex and unisex toilets).
5. Accessible telephones drinking fountains
6. Additional elements such as parking, storage, and alarms.
M. Alterations over time: The obligation to provide an accessible path of travel should not be avoided by performing a
series of small alterations to the area if those alterations could have been done as a single undertaking. If a primary
function area has been alternated with out providing an accessible path of travel, in subsequent alterations of that
area or a different area are on the same path of travel are undertaken within 3 years of the original alteration, then the
total cost of the alterations to the primary function areas on th,e path of travel during the preceding '3 year period
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey.doc
30
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shcirewood, Minnesota
. . .
N. Accessible parking. The minimum number of accessible spaces reqUired for this facility IS not 1 It IS 2 spaces. er
the total spaces parking it provided are 26-50 and 2 spaces shall be accessible and one of those shall be van
accessible.
Accessible parking spaces serving a Public Accommodation such as the City Hall building should be on the shortest
and most direct accessible route of travel from adjacent parking to an accessible building entrance. Accessible spaces
shall have a the minimum following dimensions:
1. Parking space width: 96 inches.
2. Access width to the space shall be 60 inches minimum, and not less than 80 inches vertical.
3. Van accessible parking spaces shall be a minimum of 96 inches wide, and they shall also have an
adjacent accessible aisle not less than 96 inches wide.
O. Entrance requirements: The number of accessible entrances shall be equivalent to the number of exits required by the
applicable buildings/fire code. (Examples: if a building is being designed that has 5 public entrances and four exits are
required by local code, then at least 4 of the public entrances must be accessible. Note: This section does not involve
an increase in the plan number of entrances to buildings. ADAAG section #4.1.3 (8AII) Note: When alterations are
made to existing conditions, if alterations are undertaken on an existing entrance and the building already has an
accessible entrance the entrance being altered need not be accessible unless it affects the usability of, or the access
to, the area containing a primary function.
P. All of the signage at the facility should be updated and changed and much more visible and ADA compliant with
regards to raised Braille lettering etc. .
Q. Interior Accessible Route Requirements:
Minimum clear widths and accessible routes are 36 inches except as allowed at door openings: (32" clear at door
openings). .
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01 \bus\ADASurvey .doc
31
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
- - - -
- - - . .--. u .. ~; .
Passing space: if an accessible route is less than 60 inches wide, then passing space is required at a minimum
interval of every 200 feet. Passing space may be either 60 inches by 60 inches or the intersection of 2 walks or
corridors.
Head room requirements: Minimum 80 inches clear. If a vertical clearance of an area joining an accessible route is
reduced to less then 80 inches, a barrier shall be provided. .
Slope: Running slope shall not exceed 1 :20 interior, -and 1: 12 for exterior ramps & walking surfaces, and if it does
that you have to go to a limitation on ramps. Cross slope sections shall not exceed 2%. Changes in level up to a %
inch require no edge treatment. A %-1/2 inch difference requires that the edge shall be doubled with a slope no
greater than 1-2 and the transition shall be no greater than a Y2 inch a ramp at the entrance to an elevator or a lift.
Stairs are not a part of an accessible route.
Ground and floor surfaces shall be firm stable and slip resistant along the accessible route. If carpeting is used along
an accessible route, it should be securely attached with a firm cushion or pad or backing, (or none); and a the pile
shall be level loop, textured cut pile, level cut pile, or an uncut pile texture with a maximum pile thickness of Y2 inch for
any carpeting used. All exposed edges shall be fastened to the floor surfaces with carpet edge trim.
Protruding objects: Objects protruding from walls with there leading edges between 27 inches and 80 inches above
the finished floor shall protrude no more than 4 inches into walks or corridors. Objects projecting from walls with there
leading edges at or below 27 inches from above finished floor may protrude any amount. Free-standing objects on
posts or pylons may overhang 12 inches maximum from 27-80 above the finished floor or ground. Protruding objects
shall not reduce the required width of an accessible route or a maneuvering space. With regards to clear floor space.
The minimum clear floor space required to accommodate a single stationary wheel chair is 30 inches by 48 inches for
forward approach. If the forward approach clear floor space extends more than 24 inches into an alcove the minimum
alcove width is 36. If a parallel clear floor spaces extends more than 15 inches into an alcove than the minimum
alcove shall be 60 inches.
END OF REPORT
Building Survey
Q:\ 1613-01\bus\ADASurvey.doc
32
1613.01
Shorewood City Hall
Shorewood, Minnesota
r,
z '''!'I
o~:~
:-~!
~."'~;; ~
:2::zg
z -( yo i
_" z
~ u.. i
wO::5
:r:",-~
u"';~
"?<,,,i;i
ac z!
a::~ov
O......@
~ -;II
.~
..;jI -ill
-ill ~I
~1 ~I
-11
"'ll -;;II
-;;II
.;fJ ~I
~-:jl
..'
..
->II -ojl
.Zl
=
..8
~I
>-'
gfi
en
.i;
II>
0..
~
o
o
0,
U
V)
o
III
c..
tl!
IJ'l
o
o
01
U
V)
o
<II
c..
Q)
0'
o
o
01
U
V)
o
VI
a.
Q)
M
o
o
d
Vl
o
'"
c..
Ql
'"
o
o
I
U
V)
Cl
!'n"'~[""~-
~
..... ~'
'1 I
~~_.:~ ,<
" i
7
"~
l"-~4
. -"- -. "...\'
- . ~
" -~.
,~~
'"r.,
III
c..
~
C"l
o
01
~
L
fi. /1)
III
c..
Ql
0'
t"l
o
01
l:J
~
~
'"
~
Q)
r-.:
Lt'l
C>
C>
I
l:'
L
VI
0-
<I!
Lt'l
-.0
o
o
I
l?
L
.
III
Co
Q)
0'
'-0
o
01
l'J
~
I
~'1/
. \ '
~t/
"
"j
I
\
k'~
;. ~ "
'"
,7 I I )"" };~: ,
!,. r,
~/~
III
c..
~
M
......
o
01
~
L
<II
0..
Q)
,...:
"
o
01
l?
~