HomeMy WebLinkAbout072803 CC Reg AgP
~
'!'
~
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, JULY 28, 2003
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
1. CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
A. Roll Call
Mayor Love_
Garfunkel_
Liz4e_
Zerby _
Turgeon _
B. Review Agenda
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. City Council Regular Meeting Minutes, July 14,2003 (Att.- Minutes)
3. CONSENT AGENDA - Motion to approve items on Consent Agenda & Adopt Resolutions
Therein:
NOTE: Give the public an opportunity to request an item be removed from the
Consent Agenda. Comments can be taken or questions asked following removal from
Consent Agenda.
A. Approval of the Verified Claims List (Att.- Claims List)
B. Policy Regarding City Employees Carrying Firearms (Att.-Administrator's
memorandum)
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR (No Council action will be taken.)
5. REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS
A. Report on LMCD activities by Tom Skramstad (Att. - Report)
6. PUBLIC HEARING
A. 7:00 PM - Consider Revisions to Chapter 903 of the City Code Regulating Water Use
and Service (Att.- Planning Director's memorandum; Draft Ordinance)
B. 7: 15 PM - Consider a request to vacate a portion of undeveloped tax-forfeited City
property in exchange for property for right-of-way purposes for Enchanted Point (Att.-
Planning Director's memorandum)
'.".
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA - JULY 28, 2003
PAGE20F3
7. PARKS
A. Report on Park Commission Meeting Held July 8, 2003 (Att.- Draft Minutes)
8. PLANNING - Report by Representative
A. Setback Variance and Variance to Expand a Nonconforming Structure (Att.- Planning
Director's memorandum)
Applicant: John O'Donnell
Location: 27100 Edgewood Road
B. Shorewood Yacht Club Zoning Text Amendment and Conditional Use Permit
Amendment (Att.- Planning Director's memorandum; Planning Commission Fmdings)
Applicant: John and Judy Cross
Location: 600 WestLake Street.
C. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Fence Height (Att.- Planning Director's. memorandum;
Draft Ordinance)
D. Minor Subdivision and Combination (Att.-Planning Director's memorandum; Draft
Resolution)
Applicant: David LaRose and Jim Mahoney
Location: 5965 and 5985 Chaska Road
E. Minor Subdivision (Att.-Planning Director's memorandum; Draft Resolution)
Applicant: Mark Kawell (representing Richard Bowman)
Location: 20025 Manor Road
F. Our Saviors Lutheran Church request for Extension of Time (Att.-Planning Director's
memorandum)
G. Limited Certificate of Occupancy - Bayside Bank (Att.-Planning Director's
memorandum)
H. Second Amendment to Shorewood Village Shopping Center Development Agreement
(Att. Draft Amendment)
I. Development Agreement for Kelly Bosworth (Att. Draft Amendment)
9. GENERAUNEW BUSINESS
A. Approval of Lease for Shorewood Village Shopping Center Liquor Store (Att. - Finance
Director's memorandum)
B. Authorization to Purchase a Beverage Cooler (Att.- Finance Director's memorandum)
.
...,1
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA - Jt1L Y 28, 2003
PAGE30F3
10. ENGINEERING /PUBLIC WORKS
A. Authorization for Expenditure of Funds for used Paver (Att.- Public Works Director's
memorandum)
11. STAFF AND COUNCIL REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
1. County Road 19 Intersection
2. Public Safety Facilities
3. Smithtown Road
4. Water Report
B. Mayor & City Council
12. ADJOURN
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
July 28, 2003
PUBLIC SIGN-IN SHEET
For the record, please print your name and address below. Thank you.
Name
Address
1. ~ " ~ -e }{ ruM k
,
2..JQ tkvt ~1tUd)
s-1j( V:'utLr &(((0
0ZI&?i [;JvlhfJr I~
3. ..1fJ fI) F f J! lJ/'ItJ-OfJ/<(
,
-;J..?<Bt)1,? 1.JtVV7vNKA DR.
4.1it{~ O(O~
5~R- ~k
~ 1 (CD (ZZJ.g;tiN~
s: ~bS C kAS~ Rp~
\
6. lM A ft C ~ ,l..-~ l;f l.dr~
5- '-I L( S- i.:rl'-f. G If It L- fA jIJ.lf
L~ IZ-I.$ 1tF-/ b1flXJi( ~
8. Jk f-E.A/ fJ/ZE.J)(JFI/ L
bObS ~tLRLCJ&tJb {!7:
ri
/t
/(
9.
10.
,.
\"
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
~
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us.cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
Executive Summary
Shorewood City Council Regular Meeting
Monday, 28 July, 2003
.
An EDA meeting will immediately follow the Regular Council Meeting.
A Council Worksession will immediately follow the EDA meeting.
Agenda Item #3A: Enclosed is the Verified Claims List for Council approval.
Agenda Item #3B: With the recent adoption of the Minnesota Citizens' Personal Protection
Act (aka Conceal and Carry Law), the League of Minnesota Cities has recommended that
cities adopt policies if they wish for their employees not to carry weapons while
performing City business. Many cities have adapted the League's model policy. Staff
has prepared such a policy to be authorized by the Council. The SLMPD is agreeable to
be the repository for weapons of City employees who have permits to carry them.
Agenda Item #5A: Tom Skramstad, Lake Minnetonka Conservation District representative,
will be present this evening to report on current activities of the LMCD.
.
Agenda Item #6A: A 7:00 PM public hearing has been scheduled to consider a revision of the
City Code chapter relative to municipal water service. The revision is intended to clean
up a very cumbersome code section and to incorporate recently recommended policies
regarding municipal water service. A cleaned up draft with some additional revisions
will be e-mailed to Council this weekend.
Agenda Item #6B: Bill Zucco, representing his father's property at 4485 Enchanted Point;
proposes a land swap where the City would convey excess tax-forfeited property adjacent
to Enchanted Point for some of his father's property to be used as additional right-of-way
for Enchanted Point. The Planning Director suggests that the request has merit, similar to
the Cermak case on Vine Street and Manor Drive that was approved a couple of months
ago.
Agenda Item #7 A: Park Commissioner Paul Gilbertson will report on the July 8, 2003, Park
Commission meeting;
ft
~.1 PRINTEDON RECYCLE.D PAPER
it,
~
Executive Summary - City Council Meeting of 28 July, 2003
Page 20f3
r
Agenda Item #8A: John O'Donnell has requested variances to expand the nonconforming
dwelling at 27100 Edgewood Road. He proposes to raise the existing home which is less
than one foot from the west lot line and approximately three feet from the east property
line, and add a third level to the home. He also proposes to demolish the existing
detached garage and build an attached garage on the south end of the house. A second
story would be built over the new garage. Aside from the setback issues associated with
this request, the property has impervious surface amounting to 33 percent of the lot area,
eight percent over the maximum allowed. It is worth noting that the property was granted
two variances in 1986 to expand the house to its current size and to build the existing
garage. The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend denial of the
variance. Since the application is running up against the extended 60-day rule, staff has
prepared a resolution for your consideration at this meeting. Action must be taken at this
meeting to comply with state statutes.
Agenda Item #8B: John Cross, representing Shorewood Yacht Club, has requested
amendments to the Zoning Code and to his conditional use permit that would eliminate
the restrictions on power boats docked at the Yacht Club. The Planning Commission
voted unanimously to recommend against the amendments. Their findings are included
herein for your consideration. Similar to the O'Donnell case, a resolution has been
prepared, based on the Planning Commission's recommendations, for adoption Monday
night.
.
Agenda Item #8C: The Planning Commission agreed unanimously with a recommended text
amendment prepared by the Planning Director. The amendment allows fence posts to be
somewhat higher than the current maximum heights for fences. This is considered
largely to be a "housekeeping" measure.
Agenda Item #8D: Several months ago, David LaRose's request for a setback variance was
denied by the City. Mr. LaRose has now managed to purchase five feet of his neighbor's e.
property to the south, thereby eliminating the need for a variance. Staff strongly
recommends approval of this division/combination.
Agenda Item #8E: Mark Kawell, representing Richard Bowman, has requested approval of a
minor subdivision to split Mr. Bowman's homestead parcel. Both lots comply with the
requirements of the R-1A zoning district. The Planning Commission agreed with the
Planning Director's recommendation to approve the division.
Agenda Item #8F: Our Savior's Lutheran Church has requested additional time to correct
zoning violations relative to noise and lighting levels. Since nearby residents have been
more than patient in waiting for the corrections, some may attend Monday night's
meeting. We have advised church representatives that someone from the church must be
present to answer questions.
Agenda Item #8G: Bayside Bank has requested a possible limited certificate of occupancy to
move into the new CUB building earlier than CUB. Staff feels this is reasonable since
..
.
?
.
.
Executive Summary - City Council Meeting of 28 July, 2003
Page 3 of3
the bank is already in existence and should not generate any new traffic. It would allow
the bank to limit their relocation to one time.
Agenda Item #8H: This is an amendment to the Shorewood Village Center/CUB development
agreement providing for construction of city watermain, and for the financial agreement
consistent with the new water code.
Agenda Item #81: This is a brief agreement between the City and Kelly Bosworth
recognizing that he is participating in the Shorewood Village Center water main
extension project in lieu of paying connection charges.
Agenda Item #9A: The Liquor Committee and staff recommend approval of a five (5)-year
lease amendment for the Shorewood Village municipal liquor store, subject to review and
approval of the City Attorney. The lease terms include favorable rents and a $30,000
improvement allowance. Approval of this lease is the culmination of many hours of
discussion, meetings and negotiation.
Agenda Item #9B: In conjunction with the remodeling of the Shorewood Village Municipal
Liquor Store, staff has been reviewing specifications and quotes for the purchase of a
new beverage cooler. If the quotes are more than $50,000, a sealed bid purchasing
process must be followed. Staff is still pending key information and will have a full
report and recommendation at the City Council meeting.
Agenda Item #lOA: This item would authorize the expenditure of funds from the Equipment
Replacement Fund, for purchase of a used asphalt paver. This purchase is in cooperation
with the City of Excelsior. Shorewood's amount of the purchase equates to $3,750, plus
sales tax. Staff recommends approval by motion.
..,
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, JULY 14,2003
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
{) RI\ fl
1.
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 7:03 P.M.
A.
Roll Call
Present:
Mayor Love; Councilmembers Garfunkel, Lizee, and Turgeon; Administrator Dawson;
Attorney Keane; Engineer Brown; Finance Director Burton; and Planning Director
Nielsen
Absent:
Councilmember Zerby
B. Review Agenda
Mayor Love reviewed the Agenda. Engineer Brown requested Item lOA be deleted from the Agenda for
this evening. Administrator Dawson requested Item 9A be moved to Item 5A this evening, and that Item
5A be changed to 5B.
Garfunkel moved, Turgeon seconded, Approving the Agenda as amended. Motion passed 4/0.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. City Council Executive Session Minutes, June 23, 2003
Turgeon moved, Garfunkel seconded, Approving the City Council Executive Session Meeting
Minutes of June 23, 2003, as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
B. City Council Regular Meeting Minutes, June 23, 2003
Garfunkel moved, Turgeon seconded, Approving the City Council Regular Meeting Minutes of
June 23, 2003, as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
C. City Council Work Session Minutes, June 23, 2003
Turgeon moved, Garfunkel seconded, Approving the Work Session Meeting Minutes of June 23,
2003, as amended, on Page 2, Paragraph 2, Sentence 2, change "Srecent" to "recent." Motion
passed 4/0.
3. CONSENT AGENDA
Garfunkel moved, Turgeon seconded, Approving the Motions Contained on the Consent
Agenda and Adopting the Resolutions Therein:
-:#- d fr
/'
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
July 14, 2003
Page 2 of 5
A. Approval of the Verified Claims List
B. Authorization for Disposition of Equipment
C. Approval of the 2004 Budget of the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District
D. Reschedule Public Hearing for Partial Street Right-of-Way Vacation - Enchanted
Point
E. Authorization to Enter into Contract with Safe Assure Consultants
Motion passed 4/0.
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were no matters from the floor presented this evening.
5. REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS
.
A. Sale of Bonds - Presentation by Bond Consultant Paul Donna, Northland Securities
Bond Consultant Paul Donna, of Northland Securities, provided a report to Council regarding the 2003
Sale of Bonds for the General Obligation Refunding Bonds at a more favorable rate saving the City
approximately $35,000 in interest costs. Mr. Donna also congratulated the City on the upgrade found in
the Moody's Investor Services Report showing that the City's bond rating had been upgraded from Al to
Aa3. This upgrade also helped to provide the City additional savings in the refunding of bonds. Mr.
Donna stated the refunding was considered to be very successful overall.
Mayor Love thanked the City Staff and Mr. Donna for the exemplary job completed and report shared in
this matter.
Garfunkel moved, Lizee seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 03-058, "A Resolution A warding .
the Sale of $815,000 General Obligation Refunding Bonds of 2003." Motion passed 4/0.
B. County Road 19 Update
Jim Grube, Hennepin County Director of Transportation, provided an update to Council regarding the
progress being made on the County Road 19 intersection project. Mr. Grube congratulated the City on its
recent successful bond sale, and stated he was present to provide information regarding the progress
being made in working with the City of Tonka Bay to obtain control of the liquor store property located
at the intersection along County Road 19.
Mr. Grube stated the Hennepin County Capital Budgeting Task Force had included the County Road 19
project on its list of priority projects for the 2004-2008 Capital Improvement Plan programming
including additional monies being set aside for the project, assuming the CIP would be approved. He
also went on to explain the City of Tonka Bay continued to place a greater value on the business aspect
of the liquor store than the County had offered. He noted the County was seeking a fourth quarter
acquisition of the property so demolition could occur with suspension of utility services taking place
prior to the problems that would be incurred in abandonment of property during the winter. He stated the
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
July 14, 2003
Page 3 of5
City of Tonka Bay wished to reconsider the County's most recent offer and had also requested
acquisition of the property take place after the first of the Year 2004. Mr. Grube stated he remained
confident remedies could be discussed and negotiations finalized regarding this matter. He went on to
state the redesign of the project was now approaching a point where Staff could view it and begin to plan
for its inception. Furthermore, he noted, Commissioner Koblick remained interested in bringing a
successful closure to this issue so that the two cities could continue to be able to work together to
enhance the safety of the community.
Mayor Love stated the City of Shorewood had no conflicts with the City of Tonka Bay in this matter, but
remained concerned for the safety of all South Lake Minnetonka residents as the intersection continued
to pose a grave and serious safety issue that would only worsen in January of 2004 upon the opening of
the South Lake Minnetonka Public Safety Facility-West Side. Mayor Love offered the help of the City in
bringing quick successful negotiations.
.
Councilmember Turgeon requested Mr. Grube examine other potential safety measures for the
intersection that could reasonably be implemented prior to the completion of the intersection project.
Mr. Grube stated he recognized the concern for safety in this matter, and would examine all the available
options and report back at a future meeting. Mr. Grube assured Council he continued to move forward in
negotiations with the City of Tonka Bay noting that resolution would be forthcoming, and he too was
concerned for bringing all available options for enhancing the safety of the intersection forward in the
near future.
Attorney Keane questioned whether the property value had been substantiated through the opinion of an
appraiser.
At this point in time, the City Hall lost electrical power due to the severe weather in the area. Mayor
Love recessed the meeting at 7:38 P.M., and reconvened the meeting at 7:50 P.M.
Engineer Brown reported on the status of the loss of power, and noted Xcel Energy reported it would be
approximately 1 to 2 hours prior to the power being returned.
.
Council then discussed the merits and legality of continuing with the meeting given the current
circumstances. Administrator Dawson suggested the discussion with Mr. Grube be allowed to finish.
Council agreed.
Mr. Grube stated the County had received information from the City of Tonka Bay via Staff with that
recommendation coming from its financial advisor, and noted the elements of sale of liquor to be an
important aspect to the City of Tonka Bay. He also stated he would provide a plan of other options
developed with the help of Staffs of Shorewood and Tonka Bay as well as working with Staff to continue
redesign of the project. He stated his best intention was to work to complete negotiations with the City
of Tonka Bay in the very near future.
Mayor Love stated it was with great restraint and patience that the City had taken an observer role in the
negotiations related to the project, and he stated he would like to know how best to move negotiations
forward. Mr. Grube stated he would continue with his plans and hoped to return with a successful
closure of the property negotiations.
Mayor Love recessed the meeting at 7:57 P.M. and reconvened the meeting at 8: 13 P.M.
..
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
July 14, 2003
Page 4 of5
Since the electricity had not yet returned, Mayor Love requested all items remaining on the Agenda be
forwarded to the July 28, 2003, Regular City Council Meeting for consideration and discussion. Council
had no objection to this request.
Items 6-11 were placed on the July 28, 2003, Regular City Council Meeting Agenda.
6. PUBLIC HEARING
A. Consider Revisions to Chapter 903 of the City Code Regulating Water Use and
Service
7. PARKS
A. Report on Park Commission Meeting Held July 8, 2003
8.
PLANNING
A. Setback Variance and Variance to Expand a Nonconforming Structure
Applicant: John O'Donnell
Location: 27100 Edgewood Road
.
B. Shorewood Yacht Club Zoning Text Amendment and Conditional Use Permit
Amendment
Applicant: John and Judy Cross
Location: 600 West Lake Street
C. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Fence Height
9. GENERALINEW BUSINESS
A.
Sale of Bonds - Presentation by Bond Consultant Paul Donna, Northland Securities
(This item was moved to Item SA)
.
10. ENGINEERING/PUBLIC WORKS
A. Authorization for Expenditure of Funds for used Paver
This item was deleted from the Agenda for the evening.
11. REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
1. County Road 19 Intersection
2. Public Safety Facilities
3. Smithtown Road
B. Mayor & City Council
-
.
.
.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
July 14, 2003
Page 5 of 5
12. ADJOURN
Lizee moved, Turgeon seconded, Adjourning the Regular City Council Meeting of July 14, 2003, at
8:14 P.M. Motion passed 4/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Sally Keefe,
Recording Secretary
Woody Love, Mayor
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator
-
~
PAYABLESAPPROVALS
For 7/28/03 Council Meeting
.
c ~' fl/7~
_a ;U~ ~
Prepared by:
Catherine EIke, Sr. Accountant
Reviewed by: ~, ~_
'"
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director
Date: /- ~ 4--03
Date: 1-:tf-(J3
Approved by: Date: tJ1zi~3
Crai awson, City Administrator
.
#3ft
Check Approval List for 07/28/03 Sorted by Department
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35578 METLlFE DENTAL INS DEPOSIT 7/14/2003 $710.00
35579 ADVANCED IMAGING SO MONTHLY CONTRACT SV 7/16/2003 12381 $160.50
35581 EXCELSIOR-CITY OF 2ND OTR OAK ST SIGNAL 7/16/2003 $104.58
35583 ICMA RETIREMENT TRU ~1&03PAYROLLDEDUC 7/16/2003 302131-07 $1,088.51
35585 MN CHILD SUPPORT PM CHILD SUPPORT - C SCH 7/16/2003 $232.02
35586 ORONO, CITY OF JULY ANIMAL CONTROL 7/16/2003 2598 $1,579.08
35587 PAWS, CLAWS & HOOV JULY IMPOUNDS/BOARD I 7/16/2003 $79.88
35588 PAZANDAK, JOSEPH MILEAGE 6/30 - 7/11/03 7/16/2003 $70.56
35589 PERA 7/15/03 PAYROLL DEDUC 7/16/2003 762400-07 $2,242.05
35589 PERA ~1&03PAYROLLDEDUC 7/16/2003 762400-07 $2,431.11
35592 SCIENCE MUSEUM OF M WEB CLASSES-Po HELLlN 7/16/2003 C57802 $278.00
35594 AT&T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 4160966-0 $54.79
35594 AT&T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 4160966-0 $33.04
35595 BROWN, LAWRENCE CELL PHONE BELT CASE 7/24/2003 $13.79
35596 DJ'S MUNICIPAL SUPPL SHOVELS 7/24/2003 14853 $333.87
35598 ESS BROTHERS & SONS MANHOLE RING 7/24/2003 FF2902 $94.79 .
35602 LOCAL LINK USA BUSIN ADDL WEB PAGE SPACE 7/24/2003 95220466 $10.00
35603 LONG LAKE POWER EO CHAINSAW OIL 7/24/2003 48390 $22.34
35608 STATE OF MN, CPV PRO MEMBERSHIP FEE 7/24/2003 $500.00
35609 VIKING LAND TREE CAR STORM DAMAGE CLEAN 7/24/2003 2849 $100.00
35610 XCEL ENERGY 7/24/2003 1732-704- $2,435.06
35611 ZEE MEDICAL SERVICE 7/24/2003 54202619 $37.17
35613 AFSCME COUNCIL 14 AUG UNION DENTAL PRE 7/29/2003 $304.50
35617 BIFFS, INC. 7/29/2003 W195368- $649.10
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $81.00
35623 HENNEPIN COUNTY TRE JUNE ROOM/BOARD 7/29/2003 71 $312.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL GENERAL MATTERS 7/29/2003 437536 $1,750.40
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL LAND USE MA TTERS-L1N 7/29/2003 437537 $304.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL SMITHTOWN RD 7/29/2003 437538 $50.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL R. JOHNSON ET AL V. CIT 7/29/2003 437539 $162.50
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL SHOREWOOD YACHT CL 7/29/2003 437540 $224.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL CUB 7/29/2003 437543 $135.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL METRICOM BANKRUPTC 7/29/2003 437544 $560.00 .
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $8,638.61
35632 MIDWEST ASPHALT CO FINE MIX 7/29/2003 71235MB $533.16
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND OTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $86.80
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND OTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $662.32
35635 MTI DISTRIBUTING COM MISC PW SUPPLIES 7/29/2003 365701-00 $122.18
35636 OFFICE DEPOT 7/29/2003 20970167 $76.21
35636 OFFICE DEPOT 7/29/2003 21045096 ($11.72)
35642 RIDGEVIEW BUSINESS JOB PHYSICAL-M. NGUY 7/29/2003 $99.00
35643 SAFEASSURE CONSULT ANNUAL SAFETY TRAINI 7/29/2003 1 A $2,470.00
35645 SO LK MTKA POLICE DE AUG MONTHLY BUDGET 7/29/2003 $51,9n.00
35646 STAR TRIBUNE DAILY NEWSPAPER SUB 7/29/2003 $27.95
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND OTR CRESENT BEA 7/29/2003 $275.06
35650 TONKA PRINTING CO. ENVELOPES 7/29/2003 2959 $384.47
35654 WELLS FARGO BROKER SR CTR LEASE PYMT 7/29/2003 824996MA $18,771.97
35655 WESTSIDE WHOLESALE TRAILER/MOWER TIRES 7/29/2003 516485 $148.82
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES CUB WATERMAIN IMPRO 7/29/2003 01074-762 $4,098.50
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES GENERAL SVCS 7/29/2003 01074-990 $936.00
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES LK LINDEN PED TRAIL DE 7/29/2003 01459-013 $939.00
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0615-308- $3.14
,';':;:' -' .', ,', 'i;;:';:,,,,:,_,,:_:_,,,c,':_':~L::;,:,:',',:;),:-:,,','l,;:;;;;;~,:;:",;:::':;:.r,.:::i:;',~,~',,_::,:,,:_.:'c'.~::';.:,'_:;;':i;:;.:;.;z.-,;'.':_;;;.~.:' ,.
Thursday, July 24, 2003
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1605-305- $105.12
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1724-866- $84.20
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 2001-503- $21.28
TOTALFOR 101 GENERAL FUND $107,592.71
35653 US BANK INT-GO IMPROVE BOND 7/29/2003 14906750- $480.00
TOTAL FOR 302 1993 IMPROVEMENTS $480.00
35647 TECHIES AUG SVC 7/29/2003 $500.00
TOTAL FOR 401 PUBUC FACIUTIESIOFFICE EQUIPMENT $500.00
35638 PEARSON BROS. INC. SEALCOATING 2003 7/29/2003 718 $29,711.50
TOTAL FOR 404 STREET CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT $29,711.50
35605 MN POLLUTION CONTR PERMIT-SMITHTOWN RD 7/24/2003 $400.00
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES SMITHTOWN RD OVERLA 7/29/2003 01074-583 $851.25
TOTAL FOR 405 MSA CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT $1,251.25
35581 EXCELSIOR-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER CONNE 7/16/2003 $3,125.26
35591 QWEST 7/16/2003 $261.99
. 35591 QWEST 7/16/2003 $99.05
35599 GOPHER STATE ONE-CA JUNE SVC 7/24/2003 3060694 $33.33
35600 HAWKINS WATER TREA 7/24/2003 DM90871 $75.00
35606 MN SUN PUBLICATIONS WATER CODE REVISION 7/24/2003 613472 $35.75
35610 XCELENERGY 7/24/2003 1351-508- $1,355.16
35610 XCEL ENERGY 7/24/2003 2095-300- $2,031.15
35622 HAWKINS WATER TREA WATER CHEMICALS 7/29/2003 539962 $2,754.61
35624 INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY CO AIR COMPRESSOR MOT 7/29/2003 1123747 $221.01
35641 QWEST 7/29/2003 $58.10
35644 SEELYE PLASTICS INC PIPE FITTINGS 7/29/2003 653837 $105.54
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER/SEWER 7/29/2003 $371.86
35652 TWIN CITY WATER CLlNI JUNE WATER ANALYSIS 7/29/2003 9973 $60.00
35653 US BANK INT-GO WATER REV BON 7/29/2003 14150650- $13,231.25
35653 US BANK INT-GO WATER REV BON 7/29/2003 14922550- $26,070.00
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0145-009- $7.40
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1440-708- $176.07
TOTAL FOR 601 WATER UTIUTY $50,072.53
. 35594 AT&T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 2893733-0 $83.18
35594 A T& T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 4160966-0 $89.49
35599 GOPHER STATE ONE-CA JUNE SVC 7/24/2003 3060694 $33.32
35631 METRO COUNCIL ENVIR AUG WASTEWATER 7/29/2003 758924 $31,711.33
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER/SEWER 7/29/2003 $283.30
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0408-607- $72.97
35658 XCELENERGY 7/29/2003 1285-101- $19.00
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1373-808- $7.96
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1564-303- $8.26
TOTAL FOR 611 SANITARY SEWER UTILITY $32,308.81
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731880 $57.68
35582 HERMEL WHOLESALE 7/16/2003 421780 $389.48
35584 MIDWEST COCA-COLA B 7/16/2003 63276046 $132.90
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282549-00 $366.31
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282549-00 $48.39
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 38731930 $47.16
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 39631931 $59.16
35597 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/24/2003 418478 $2,382.30
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35601 LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/24/2003 101728 $142.50
35604 MARK VII 7/24/2003 556340 $934.20
35604 MARK VII 7/24/2003 556341 $22.40
35604 MARK VII 7/24/2003 556342 $28.00
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00 $37.32
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00 $656.15
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00 $446.71
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285074-00 $118.75
35614 ANDREWS, BETSY C. WINE CHARMS 7/29/2003 $66.00
35615 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY 7/29/2003 37243600 $69.09
35616 BELLBOY CORPORA TIO 7/29/2003 26800800 $1,360.55
35616 BELLBOY CORPORA TIO 7/29/2003 26856400 $568.69
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 225357 $1,233.90
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226371 $568.25
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226371 $18.40
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420337 $913.25
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $9.00
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739684 $32.25
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739820 $201.50
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 740322 $1,146.49 .
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742817 $305.15
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742818 $449.93
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742818 $23.95
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 743301 $15.34
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1auo 7/29/2003 1580996 $164.90
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1auo 7/29/2003 1580996 $3,461.12
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1auo 7/29/2003 1583316 $128.90
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1583317 $263.70
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1auo 7/29/2003 1583317 $841.16
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1auo 7/29/2003 1583318 $26.00
35626 LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/29/2003 101820 $142.50
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559051 $1,490.45
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559052 $89.60
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12899/929 $54.90
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12899/929 $54.90
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $505.50
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND aTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $32.04 .
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $n.20
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $126.00
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $458.50
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967266 $78.85
35639 PHJLLlPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967266 $1,052.15
35640 QWEST DEX 7/29/2003 01562617 $66.50
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302565 $26.30
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302565 $3,944.60
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303227 $13.15
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303227 $1,964.65
35651 TOWLE REAL ESTATE C AUG RENT 7/29/2003 $4,679.49
TOTAL FOR 641 SHOREWOOD PLAZA UQUOR $32,594.21
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731841 $65.80
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731860 $26.64
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731880 $27.96
35582 HERMEL WHOLESALE 7/16/2003 421779 $323.56
35590 aUALlTY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282547-00 $23.18
35590 aUALlTY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282547-00 $355.64
Check# Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282614-00 $633.60
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 38731930 $48.44
35604 MARK VII 7/24/2003 556353 $1,021.20
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00 $539.81
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00 $883.67
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00 $28.23
35607 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285073-00 $255.32
35616 BELLBOY CORPORATIO 7/29/2003 26800700 $1,513.40
35616 BELLBOY CORPORATIO 7/29/2003 26856500 $662.70
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 225356 $1,593.00
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226370 $368.85
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226370 $18.40
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420336 $2,069.45
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420336 $10.40
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $9.00
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739648 $0.85
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739685 $23.65
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739821 $363.62
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 740326 $1,389.85
. 35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742822 $35.10
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742823 $511.93
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1580995 $207.40
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1580995 $2,523.96
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1583315 $453.01
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1583315 $448.61
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 1583548 $27.55
35625 JOHNSON BROS L1QUO 7/29/2003 225520 ($11.25)
35626 LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/29/2003 101820 $142.50
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559039 $791.85
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559040 $15.20
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12898/928 $45.45
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12898/928 $45.45
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $558.70
35633 MIDWEST COCA-COLA B 7/29/2003 63283117 $101.90
35637 PAUSTIS WINE COM PAN 7/29/2003 8009855 $179.50
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $90.75
. 35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $242.35
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $668.50
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967265 $10.60
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967265 $806.40
35640 QWEST DEX 7/29/2003 01562617 $212.80
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302563 $3,091.95
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303226 $2,723.60
35656 WORLD CLASS WINES, I 7/29/2003 137389 $160.00
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0677-702- $661.93
TOTAL FOR 642 WATERFORD LIQUOR $27,001.96
TOTAL CHECKS $281,512.97
.- -~: ,."- ;'- ;;, :' "i-':,i:,,-: -,:"
Page 4 of 4
Check Approval List for 07/28/03 Council Meeting
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35578 METLlFE DENTAL INS DEPOSIT 7/14/2003 $710.00
TOTAL FOR METLIFE $710.00
35579 ADVANCED IMAGING SO MONTHLY CONTRACT SV 7/16/2003 12381 $160.50
TOTAL FOR ADVANCED IMAGING SOLUTIONS INC $160.50
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731841 $65.80
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731860 $26.64
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731880 $57.68
35580 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/16/2003 38731880 $27.96
TOTAL FOR ARCTIC GLACIER INC $178.08
35581 EXCELSIOR-CITY OF 2ND QTR OAK ST SIGNAL 7/16/2003 $104.58
35581 EXCELSIOR-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER CONNE 7/16/2003 $3,125.26
TOTAL FOR EXCELSIOR-CITY OF $3,229.84
35582 HERMEL WHOLESALE 7/16/2003 421n9 $323.56
35582 HERMEL WHOLESALE 7/16/2003 421780 $389.48
TOTAL FOR HERMEL WHOLESALE $713.04 .
35583 ICMA RETIREMENT TRU V1~03PAYROLLDEDUC 7/16/2003 302131-07 $1,088.51
TOTAL FOR ICMA RETIREMENT TRUST-457 $1,088.51
35584 MIDWEST COCA-COLA B 7/16/2003 63276046 $132.90
TOTAL FOR MIDWEST COCA-COLA BOTTLIN $132.90
35585 MN CHILD SUPPORT PM CHILD SUPPORT - C SCH 7/16/2003 $232.02
TOTAL FOR MN CHILD SUPPORT PMT CTR $232.02
35586 ORONO, CITY OF JULY ANIMAL CONTROL 7/16/2003 2598 $1,579.08
TOTAL FOR ORONO, CITY OF $1,579.08
35587 PAWS, CLAWS & HOOV JULY IMPOUNDS/BOARDI 7/16/2003 $79.88
TOTAL FOR PAWS, CLA WS & HOOVES PET $79.88
35588 PAZANDAK, JOSEPH MILEAGE 6/30 - 7/11/03 7/16/2003 $70.56
TOTAL FOR PAZANDAK, JOSEPH $70.56
35589 PERA V1~03PAYROLLDEDUC 7/16/2003 762400-07 $2,242.05
35589 PERA V1~03PAYROLLDEDUC 7/16/2003 762400-07 $2,431.11
TOTAL FOR PERA $4,673.16 .
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282547-00 $23.18
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282547-00 $355.64
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282549-00 $48.39
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282549-00 $366.31
35590 QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/16/2003 282614-00 $633.60
TOTAL FOR QUALITY WINE & SPIRITS CO $1,427.12
35591 QWEST 7/16/2003 $99.05
35591 QWEST 7/16/2003 $261.99
TOTAL FOR QWEST $361.04
35592 SCIENCE MUSEUM OF M WEB CLASSES-Po HELLlN 7/16/2003 C57802 $278.00
TOTAL FOR SCIENCE MUSEUM OF MN $278.00
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 38731930 $47.16
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 38731930 $48.44
35593 ARCTIC GLACIER INC 7/24/2003 39631931 $59.16
TOTAL FOR ARCTIC GLACIER INC $154.76
35594 AT&T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 2893733-0 $83.18
35594 AT&T WIRELESS SERVI 7/24/2003 4160966-0 $33.04
Check # Vendor Name
Description
Check Date Invoice #
35594
35594
Amount
35595
35596
35597
35598
35599
35599
35600
35601
.
35602
35603
35604
35604
35604
35604
35605
35606
.
35607
35607
35607
35607
35607
35607
35607
35607
35608
35609
35610
35610
35610
35611
7/24/2003 4160966-0
7/24/2003 4160966-0
AT&T WIRELESS SERVI
AT&T WIRELESS SERVI
TOTAL FOR AT&T WIRELESS SERVICES
BROWN, LAWRENCE CELL PHONE BELT CASE
TOTAL FOR BROWN, LAWRENCE
DJ'S MUNICIPAL SUPPL SHOVELS 7/24/2003 14853
TOTAL FOR DJ'S MUNICIPAL SUPPLY INC
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/24/2003 418478
TOTAL FOR EAST SIDE BEVERAGE COMPAN
ESS BROTHERS & SONS MANHOLE RING 7/24/2003 FF2902
TOTAL FOR ESS BROTHERS & SONS INC
GOPHER STATE ONE-CA JUNE SVC 7/24/2003 3060694
GOPHER STATE ONE-CA JUNE SVC 7/24/2003 3060694
TOTAL FOR GOPHER STATE ONE-CALL, IN
HAWKINS WATER TREA 7/24/2003 DM90871
TOTAL FOR HAWKINS WATER TREATMENT
LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/24/2003 101728
TOTAL FOR LAKESHORE WEEKLY NEWS
LOCAL LINK USA BUSIN ADDL WEB PAGE SPACE 7/24/2003 95220466
TOTAL FOR LOCAL UNK USA BUSINESS SERVIC
LONG LAKE POWER EQ CHAINSAW OIL 7/24/2003 48390
TOTAL FOR LONG LAKE POWER EQUIPMENT
7/24/2003 556340
7/24/2003 556341
7/24/2003 556342
7/24/2003 556353
7/24/2003
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
TOTAL FOR MARK VII
MN POLLUTION CONTR PERMIT-SMITHTOWN RD 7/24/2003
TOTAL FOR MN POLLUTION CONTROL AGENCY
MN SUN PUBLICATIONS WATER CODE REVISION 7/24/2003 613472
TOTAL FOR MN SUN PUBUCATIONS
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285035-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285036-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285073-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRIT 7/24/2003 285074-00
TOTAL FOR QUAUTY WINE & SPIRITS CO
STATE OF MN, CPV PRO MEMBERSHIP FEE 7/24/2003
TOTAL FOR STATE OF MN, CPV PROGRAM
VIKING LAND TREE CAR STORM DAMAGE CLEAN 7/24/2003 2849
TOTAL FOR VIKING LAND TREE CARE INC
7/24/2003 1351-508-
7/24/2003 1732-704-
7/24/2003 2095-300-
XCEL ENERGY
XCEL ENERGY
XCEL ENERGY
TOTAL FOR XCEL ENERGY
ZEE MEDICAL SERVICE
TOTAL FOR ZEE MEDICAL SERVICE
7/24/2003 54202619
$54.79
$89.49
$260.50
$13.79
$13.79
$333.87
$333.87
$2,382.30
$2,382.30
$94.79
$94.79
$33.33
$33.32
$66.65
$75.00
$75.00
$142.50
$142.50
$10.00
$10.00
$22.34
$22.34
$934.20
$22.40
$28.00
$1,021.20
$2,005.80
$400.00
$400.00
$35.75
$35.75
$28.23
$539.81
$883.67
$37.32
$446.71
$656.15
$255.32
$118.75
$2,965.96
$500.00
$500.00
$100.00
$100.00
$1,355.16
$2,435.06
$2,031.15
$5,821.37
$37.17
$37.17
Thursday, July 24, 2003
L-;;:i,; , .. _;..c.";'''-..---:'..::..' .-... '';'_~-_. '.C"'.
Check# Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35613 AFSCME COUNCIL 14 AUG UNION DENTAL PRE 7/29/2003 $304.50
TOTAL FOR AFSCME COUNCIL 14 $304.50
35614 ANDREWS, BETSY C. WINE CHARMS 7/29/2003 $66.00
TOTAL FOR ANDREWS, BETSYC. $66.00
35615 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY 7/29/2003 37243600 $69.09
TOTAL FOR BEUBOY BAR SUPPLY $69.09
35616 BELLBOY CORPORATIO 7/29/2003 26800700 $1,513.40
35616 BELLBOY CORPORATIO 7/29/2003 26800800 $1,360.55
.35616 BELLBOY CORPORA TIO 7/29/2003 26856400 $568.69
35616 BELLBOY CORPORA TIO 7/29/2003 26856500 $662.70
TOTAL FOR BELLBOY CORPORATION $4,105.34
35617 BIFFS, INC. 7/29/2003 W195368- $649.10
TOTAL FOR BIFFS, INC. $649.10
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 225356 $1,593.00
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 225357 $1,233.90
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226370 $18.40
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226370 $368.85
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226371 $18.40 .
35618 DAY DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 226371 $568.25
TOTAL FOR DAY DISTRIBUTING $3,800.80
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420336 $10.40
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420336 $2,069.45
35619 EAST SIDE BEVERAGE 7/29/2003 420337 $913.25
TOTAL FOR EAST SIDE BEVERAGE COMPAN $2,993.10
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $9.00
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $9.00
35620 FORTIS BENEFITS INS C STD-AUG PREM 7/29/2003 $81.00
TOTAL FOR FORTIS BENEFITS INS CO $99.00
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739648 $0.85
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739684 $32.25
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739685 $23.65
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739820 $201.50
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 739821 $363.62
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 740322 $1 ,146.49 .
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 740326 $1,389.85
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742817 $305.15
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742818 $23.95
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742818 $449.93
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742822 $35.10
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 742823 $511.93
35621 GRIGGS, COOPER & CO 7/29/2003 743301 $15.34
TOTAL FOR GRIGGS, COOPER & COMPANY $4,499.61
35622 HAWKINS WATER TREA WATER CHEMICALS 7/29/2003 539962 $2,754.61
TOTAL FOR HAWKINS WATER TREATMENT $2,754.61
35623 HENNEPIN COUNTY TRE JUNE ROOM/BOARD 7/29/2003 71 $312.00
TOTAL FOR HENNEPIN COUNTY TREASURER $312.00
35624 INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY CO AIR COMPRESSOR MOT 7/29/2003 1123747 $221.01
TOTAL FOR INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY CO INC $221.01
35625 JOHNSON BROS UOUO 7/29/2003 1580995 $207.40
35625 JOHNSON BROS UOUO 7/29/2003 1580995 $2,523.96
35625 JOHNSON BROS UOUO 7/29/2003 1580996 $164.90
35625 JOHNSON BROS UOUO 7/29/2003 1580996 $3,461.12
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583315 $448.61
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583315 $453.01
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583316 $128.90
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583317 $263.70
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583317 $841.16
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583318 $26.00
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 1583548 $27.55
35625 JOHNSON BROS L10UO 7/29/2003 225520 ($11.25)
TOTAL FOR JOHNSON BROS LIQUOR CO. $8,535.06
35626 LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/29/2003 101820 $142.50
35626 LAKESHORE WEEKLY N ADS 7/29/2003 101820 $142.50
TOTAL FOR LAKESHORE WEEKLY NEWS $285.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL GENERAL MAlTERS 7/29/2003 437536 $1,750.40
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL LAND USE MAlTERS-L1N 7/29/2003 437537 $304.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL SMITHTOWN RD 7/29/2003 437538 $50.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL R. JOHNSON ET AL V. CIT 7/29/2003 437539 $162.50
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL SHOREWOOD YACHT CL 7/29/2003 437540 $224.00
35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL CUB 7/29/2003 437543 $135.00
. 35627 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DAL METRICOM BANKRUPTC 7/29/2003 437544 $560.00
TOTAL FOR LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DALY... $3,185.90
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559039 $791 .85
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559040 $15.20
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559051 $1,490.45
35628 MARK VII 7/29/2003 559052 $89.60
TOTAL FOR MARK VII $2,387.10
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12898/928 $45.45
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12898/928 $45.45
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12899/929 $54.90
35629 MARLIN'S TRUCKING 7/29/2003 12899/929 $54.90
TOTAL FOR MARLIN'S TRUCKING $200.70
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $505.50
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $558.70
35630 MEDICA AUG MEDICAL PREM 7/29/2003 10321313 $8,638.61
TOTAL FOR MEDICA $9,702.81
. 35631 METRO COUNCIL ENVIR AUG WASTEWATER 7/29/2003 758924 $31,711.33
TOTAL FOR METRO COUNCIL ENVIRONMENT $31,711.33
35632 MIDWEST ASPHALT CO FINE MIX 7/29/2003 71235MB $533.16
TOTAL FOR MIDWEST ASPHALT CORP. $533.16
35633 MIDWEST COCA-COLA B 7/29/2003 63283117 $101.90
TOTAL FOR MIDWEST COCA-COLA BOTTUN $101.90
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND OTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $86.80
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND OTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $662.32
35634 MINNESOTA UC FUND 2ND OTR UNEMPLOYME 7/29/2003 $32.04
TOTAL FOR MINNESOTA UC FUND $781.16
35635 MTI DISTRIBUTING COM MISC PW SUPPLIES 7/29/2003 365701-00 $122.18
TOTAL FOR MTI DISTRIBUTING COMPANY $122.18
35636 OFFICE DEPOT 7/29/2003 20970167 $76.21
35636 OFFICE DEPOT 7/29/2003 21045096 ($11.72)
TOTAL FOR OFFICE DEPOT $64.49
35637 PAUSTIS WINE COM PAN 7/29/2003 8009855 $179.50
TOTAL FOR PAUSTIS WINE COMPANY $179.50
Check# Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35638 PEARSON BROS. INC. SEAlCOATING 2003 7/29/2003 718 $29,711.50
TOTAL FOR PEARSON BROS. INC. $29,711.50
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $668.50
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $90.75
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965522 $242.35
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $458.50
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $126.00
35639 PHilLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 965523 $77.20
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967265 $10.60
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967265 $806.40
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967266 $78.85
35639 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRIT 7/29/2003 967266 $1,052.15
TOTAL FOR PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRITS $3,611.30
35640 QWEST DEX 7/29/2003 01562617 $212.80
35640 QWEST DEX 7/29/2003 01562617 $66.50
TOTAL FOR QWEST DEX $279.30
35641 QWEST 7/29/2003 $58.10
TOTAL FOR QWEST $58.10
35642 RIDGEVIEW BUSINESS JOB PHYSICAl-M. NGUY 7/29/2003 $99.00 .
TOTAL FOR RIDGEVIEW BUSINESS HEALTH $99.00
35643 SAFEASSURE CONSULT ANNUAL SAFETY TRAIN I 7/29/2003 1A $2,470.00
TOTAL FOR SAFEASSURE CONSULTANTS $2,470.00
35644 SEELYE PLASTICS INC PIPE FITTINGS 7/29/2003 653837 $105.54
TOTAL FOR SEELYE PLASTICS INC $105.54
35645 SO LK MTKA POLICE DE AUG MONTHLY BUDGET 7/29/2003 $51,977.00
TOTAL FOR SO LK MTKA POllCE DEPT $51,977.00
35646 STAR TRIBUNE DAILY NEWSPAPER SUB 7/29/2003 $27.95
TOTAL FOR STAR TRIBUNE $27.95
35647 TECHIES AUG SVC 7/29/2003 $500.00
TOTAL FOR TECHIES $500.00
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302563 $3,091.95
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302565 $26.30
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 302565 $3,944.60
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303226 $2,723.60 .
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303227 $13.15
35648 THORPE DISTRIBUTING 7/29/2003 303227 $1,964.65
TOTAL FOR THORPE DISTRIBUTING COMPA $11,764.25
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER/SEWER 7/29/2003 $371.86
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND QTR CRESENT BEA 7/29/2003 $275.06
35649 TONKA BAY-CITY OF 2ND QTR WATER/SEWER 7/29/2003 $283.30
TOTAL FOR TONKA BAY-CITY OF $930.22
35650 TONKA PRINTING CO. ENVELOPES 7/29/2003 2959 $384.47
TOTAL FOR TONKA PRINTING CO. $384.47
35651 TOWLE REAL ESTATE C AUG RENT 7/29/2003 $4,679.49
TOTAL FOR TOWLE REAL ESTATE COMPANY $4,679.49
35652 TWIN CITY WATER CLlNI JUNE WATER ANALYSIS 7/29/2003 9973 $60.00
TOTAL FOR TWIN CITY WATER CllNIC $60.00
35653 US BANK INT-GO WATER REV BON 7/29/2003 14150650- $13,231.25
35653 US BANK INT-GO IMPROVE BOND 7/29/2003 14906750- $480.00
35653 US BANK INT-GO WATER REV BON 7/29/2003 14922550- $26,070.00
TOTAL FOR US BANK $39,781.25
Check # Vendor Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
35654 WELLS FARGO BROKER SR CTR LEASE PYMT 7/29/2003 824996MA $18,771.97
TOTAL FOR WELLS FARGO BROKERAGE SVCS LLC $18,771.97
35655 WESTSIDE WHOLESALE TRAILER/MOWER TIRES 7/29/2003 516485 $148.82
TOTAL FOR WESTSlDE WHOLESALE TIRE $148.82
35656 WORLD CLASS WINES, I 7/29/2003 137389 $160.00
TOTAL FOR WORW CLASS WINES, INC $160.00
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES SMITHTOWN RD OVERLA 7/29/2003 01074-583 $851.25
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES CUB WATERMAIN IMPRO 7/29/2003 01074-762 $4,098.50
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES GENERAL SVCS 7/29/2003 01074-990 $936.00
35657 WSB AND ASSOCIATES LK LINDEN PED TRAIL DE 7/29/2003 01459-013 $939.00
TOTAL FOR WSB AND ASSOCIATES $6,824.75
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0145-009- $7.40
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0408-607- $72.97
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 0615-308- $3.14
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 06n -702- $661.93
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1285-101- $19.00
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1373-808- $7.96
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1440-708- $176.07
. 35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1564-303- $8.26
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1605-305- $105.12
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 1724-866- $84.20
35658 XCEL ENERGY 7/29/2003 2001-503- $21.28
TOTAL FOR XCEL ENERGY $1,167.33
TOTAL CHECKS $281,512.97
.
PAYROLL APPROVALS
For 7/28/03 Council Meeting
Prepared by: ()O:tkMl/t1~ cl~ Date: 7-.;7t1-0j ·
Catherine E~e, % Acc~untant
Reviewed by: ~ ~ Date: 7-~f-03
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director
Date: tl121. O"??
wson, City Administrator
.
. Payroll Register
Check # Last Name First Name MI Check Amt Check Date
2228 BAILEY BOYD C 1,409.21 7/15/2003
2229 BURTON BONNIE M 1,923.96 7/15/2003
2230 DAVIS CHARLES S 1,116.67 7/15/2003
2231 EISCHENS JAMES E 871.50 7/15/2003
2232 ELKE CATHERINE M 913.02 7/15/2003
2233 FASCHING PATRICIA L 835.78 7/15/2003
2234 FIELD DALE F 695.50 7/15/2003
2235 GARFUNKEL JOHN J 184.70 7/15/2003
2236 GROUT TWILA R 901.05 7/1512003
2237 HELLING PAMELA J 635.65 7/15/2003
2238 HIRSCH DANA M 70.34 7/15/2003
2239 JOHNSON DENNIS D 1,223.17 7/15/2003
2240 LIZEE CHRISTINE G 184.70 7/1512003
. 2241 LUGOWSKI JOSEPH P 1,371.70 7/15/2003
2242 MASON BRADLEY J 1,007.32 7/15/2003
2243 MOORE JULIE K 93.03 7/15/2003
2244 NGUYEN MICHELLE T 763.11 7/15/2003
2245 NIELSEN BRADLEY J 1,174.26 7/15/2003
2246 PANCHYSHY JEAN M 1,350.35 7/15/2003
2247 PAZANDAK JOSEPH E 1.513.90 7/1512003
2248 RANDALL DANIEL J 1,367.41 7/1512003
2249 SCHMID CHRISTOPHER E 668.36 7/15/2003
2250 STARK BRUCE H 1,272.67 7/15/2003
2251 SW ANDBY DONALD R 1,349.22 7/1512003
2252 TOWER TERRY R 1,022.66 7/15/2003
2253 TURGEON LAURA 184.70 7/15/2003
. 2254 ZERBY MICHAEL S 184.70 7/15/2003
217874 ARMSTRON MICHAEL R 113.42 7/1512003
217875 BAKER RICHARD M 121.91 7/15/2003
217876 BROWN LAWRENCE A 2.030.51 7/15/2003
217877 DAWSON CRAIG W 1,814.29 7/15/2003
217878 DUFFY DAVID C 67.10 7/1512003
217879 HELGESEN PATRICIA R 1,120.33 7/15/2003
217880 LATTERNER SUSAN M 132.84 7/15/2003
217881 LOVE CLIFFORD W 222.15 7/1512003
217882 MADSEN ANDREW G 624.99 7/1512003
217883 OLIVEIRA CHRISTOPHER L 41.07 7/1512003
217884 PARENT MICHELLE L 182.58 7/15/2003
217885 PLATHE CRAIG V 134.97 7/15/2003
217886 THURSTON DOROTHY M 55.79 7/15/2003
Total of Checks $30,950.59
Thursday, July 24, 2003 Page 1 ofl
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 · www.cLshorewood.mn.us · cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
City Council cb
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator
July 24, 2003 .
Policy regarding City Employees Carrying Firearms
The 2003 . Legislature approved, and the Governor signed into law, the Minnesota Citizens' Personal
Protection Act. The Shorewood City Council has adopted a resolution stating its disagreement with a
provision in the Act that prohibits the City from being able to ban firearms from its facilities. The
Council is concerned about the personal safety of its employees, and of other persons visiting or
using City facilities.
The Act specifically allows an employer, public or private, to establish policies that restrict the carry
or possession of firearms by its employees while acting in the course and scope of employment.
These restrictions serve to address safety concerns of employers and employees, and also to limit the
liability exposure of the employer.
The League of Minnesota Cities has provided a sample policy that reflects employers' prerogatives
under the new Act. It appears that most cities are adopting the sample policy after making minor
modifications.
The Act contains one key exception to the employers' prerogative: permit-holders shall be able to
carry firearms in their vehicles, and leave the firearms inside them in their employers' parking lots.
The LMC policy suggests that-if permit-holding employees use their personal vehicle for City
business, their firearms could be left with the police department. The policy drafted by City staff
directs that the firearms be left with the SLMPD (to which the police chiefhas concurred). As an
alternative, the City could install firearm lockers at City buildings (owned or leased), and establish a
procedure regarding access to them. As a practical matter, no one on staff has indicated an intention
to obtain a permit in the near future, and around the first of the year the new SLMPD facility will be
occupied and thus convenient to City employees.
Given the importance that Council has given to this issue, a policy has been prepared for formal City
Council action.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the City Council approve the "Policy Prohibiting Firearms while
Performing Work for the City" that will apply to City employees.
ft
~.1 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
f~~
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
POLICY PROHIBITING FIREARMS
WHILE PERFORMING WORK FOR THE CITY
Background: In its 2003 session, the Minnesota Legislature approved and the Governor signed into
law the Minnesota Citizens' Personal Protection Act. This law is also commonly referred to as the
"Conceal and Carry" weapons law.
The Act provides that, with certain exceptions, Minnesota residents shall be issued permits to carry
weapons. The City of Shorewood respects the rights accorded in the Act to its employees as private
citizens. The purpose of this policy is to state that City employees shall not carry weapons while they
are performing City business.
Policy: The City of Shorewood hereby establishes a policy prohibiting all employees from carrying .
or possessing fIrearms while acting in the course and scope of employment for the City. The
possession or carrying of a fIrearm by employees is prohibited while working on City property or
while working in any location on behalf of the City. These circumstances include but are not limited
to:
. Driving on City business
. Riding as a passenger in a car or on any type of transit on City business
. Working at City Hall or any other City-owned work site
. Working off-site on behalf of the City
. Performing emergency or on-call work after normal hours and on weekends
. Working at private residences and at businesses on behalf of the City
. Attending training or conferences on behalf of the City
An exception to this policy is that City employees may carry and possess fIrearms in City-owned
parking areas if they have obtained the appropriate permit(s). Therefor, if a City employee must .
drive his or her personal vehicle on City business, he or she may check afrrearm with the South Lake
Minnetonka Police Department (SLMPD) during the workday and retrieve it after work. The
SLMPD will establish procedures to ensure that the fIrearm is locked up and is not able to be
retrieved by anyone other than the owner/employee.
When responding to on-call work from home after regular work hours, an employee is prohibited
from bringing a fIrearm in his or her private vehicle unless the vehicle remains in a parking lot and is
not needed in order to respond to the call.
Violations of this policy are subject to disciplinary action in accordance with the City's disciplinary
procedures policy.
Approved by the Shorewood City Council July 28, 2003
To: City of Shorewood City Council
From: Tom Skramstad, LMCD Representative
Subject: LMCD Newsletter
Date: July 22,2003
Here is my "periodic" report of the activities of the LMCD.
1 July 4th drownina near Bia Island: Since this unfortunate incident there have been discussions about adding additional
safety lanes at Cruiser's Cove, adding a no-parking buffer along the shoreline and marking the Cove as a quiet water area. Lt.
Johnson and Capt. Chandler will be at the July 23rd LMCD Board meeting to participate in the discussions.
.3.
2. 2004 Budaet.: The Board decided that, due to the widespread economic challenges that city governments are facing, to cut
money from the 2004 budget. We had planned for a very modest increase, but now have approved a budget that will be
slightly lower than 2003. The impact on individual cities will vary, as the formula is based on the taxable value of a city's
properties. Shorewood's property value increased by about 12% (2002 versus 2001) but their LMCD levy (for 2004) will go
down slightly.
Water Patrol Deputies: Two additional deputies were added to the Water Patrol during the summers of 2001, 2002 and 2003,
with very positive results. In 2003 Hennepin County is funding the entire program, however they have let us know that they
cannot be sure that funding can be supplied in future years, due to the budget deficit. This is simply a reminder: the LMCD and
the member cities may have to find other ways to continue this program.
4. Solar Liahts on Buoys: Lights are installed on the following red and green channel buoys: 1) both ends of the Arcola Bridge
and the immediate area of the western part of Smiths Bay leading from the Arcola Bridge, 2) both ends of the Narrows
Channel, 3) the southeast side of Spray Island on the western section of East Upper Lake, 4) the east side of Coffee Cove
Channel (by Lord Fletchers), 5) the Emerald Bay Bridge in Cooks Bay, 6) the channel on the north side of Wawatossa (Boy
Scout) Island, and 7) the Cedar Point east channel in Wayzata Bay. An improved method of attaching the lights to the buoys
was implemented in June, which helps keep the lights standing up straight.
5. Howards Point Marina: Howard's Point Marina applied for permission to store 38 boats on the east side of Howard's Point
Road. The LMCD Board determined that this is not appropriate and our lawyers are writing up "findings of fact" that will deny
this request.
.
6. Milfoil Harvestina Proaram: The program commenced on June 10th and will run until August 15. The harvesting "fleet" now
consists of 4 harvesters (two older and two new) and a "high speed" transport that will take the harvested milfoil to shore,
thereby allowing the harvesters to stay productive.
1. Zebra Mussels: As previously reported, the LMCD, the LMA and the DNR are running a pilot zebra mussel inspection
program at the public launch ramps at Grays Bay, Maxwell Bay, North Arm and Spring Park. Coverage will be done on a
rotating basis and the program will run until mid-September. The LMCD feels that combating the threat of zebra mussels must
start with a public education program and Shorewood should expect an email from the LMCD office with a public education
message The LMCD is evaluating the effectiveness of the program at the moment.
! Web Pa~e: The LMCD's Web site is http://www.lmcd.org
As always, I am interested in feedback regarding the content, frequency, and level of detail contained in this report.
Tom Skramstad
tomslalmr. net
952-474-5374
1fSA
MEMORANDUM
TO:
.
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
FILE NO.:
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen
24 July 2003
Water Code Amendment - Final Draft
City Code (Chapter 903)
Your 14 July packet included a draft code amendment revising the City's municipal
water use and service requirements. The forwarding memo for the amendment stated that
staff would present some additional changes at the meeting. These additional changes
have been incorporated into a second draft (attached) for your consideration on 28 July
2003. Since two items on the agenda, having to do with the water main extension for the
Shorewood Village Center, are dependent upon the new ordinance, staff is hopeful that
the Council will adopt the amendment on Monday night.
.
In order to facilitate the adoption, please call me this weekend if you have any questions.
Mid-day on Sunday, or Monday would be best.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Bonnie Burton
ft
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#- it, . A.
SECTION:
.
903.01 :
903.02:
903.03:
903.04:
903.05:
903.06:
903.07:
903.08:
903.09:
903.10:
903.11:
903.12:
903.13:
903.14:
903.15:
903.16:
903.17:
903.18:
903.19:
.
-S-E-C-O-N-D--D-R-A-F- T-
CHAPTER 903
WATER USE AND SERVICE
Purpose and Intent
Compliance With Provisions
Private Wells
Water Service Connections
Water Tum-On and Shut-Off Fees
Installation and Construction Requirements and Specifications
Service Pipes
Meters
Water Rates and Charges
Water Connections Served by Adjacent Municipalities
Authorized Water Shut Offs
Conservation Measures
Restricted and Prohibited Acts
Discontinuance of Service
Mandatory Hook Up, Commercial and Multiple-Family
Residential Users
Right of Entry Powers
Disclaimer of Liability
Water Improvement Process
Violation
903.01: PURPOSE AND INTENT: The City Municipal water system (hereinafter
called the water system) shall be operated as a public utility and convenience
from which revenue will be derived, subject to the provisions of this Chapter.
903.02: COMPLIANCE WITH PROVISIONS: No person shall make, construct or
install any water service installation, or make use of any water service
connected to the water system except in the manner provided in this Chapter, nor shall any
person make, construct, install or make use of any installation connected to the water system
contrary to the regulatory provisions of this Chapter.
903.03 PRIVATE WELLS: Pursuant to the current State Well Code and the
Minnesota Plumbing Code, private wells may be constructed or maintained and
continued in use whether or not connection is made to the water system. In no event shall
there be a means of cross-connection between the private well and the Municipal water system
at any time. Hose bibbs that will enable the cross-connection of the two (2) systems are
prohibited on internal piping of the well supply system. The threads of the boiler drain of the
well volume tank shall be removed or the boiler drain hose bibb replaced with a sink faucet.
903.04:
WATER SERVICE CONNECTIONS:
Subd. 1. Existing Service Stubs: Service stubs have been installed to serve some homes and
businesses presently located in the City. For those homes and businesses, the
connections are ready for use by the existing structures in the City.
a. Permit to Connect, Fee: A permit must be obtained to connect to the water system.
The fee for each permit shall be as set by Council resolution. Such fee shall include
inspection and turn-on services performed by the City.
b. Conditions of Permit: The permit fee shall be paid at the time of making application
for water service. In addition thereto, before any permit shall be issued, the following
conditions shall be complied with:
(1) No permit shall be issued to tap or connect with any water main or water
system of the City either directly or indirectly from any lot or tract of land unless it .
shall be determined that:
(a) The lot or tract of land to be served by such connection or tap has been
assessed for the cost of construction of the water main and water plan system
with which the connection is made; or
(b) The proceedings for levying such assessments have been or will be
commenced in due course; or
(c) A connection charge has been paid.
(2) A water meter, meter horn, and remote reader shall be purchased from the
City at the time permit is applied for.
(3) If the lot is served by the Southeast Area or Boulder Bridge water systems .
and is below an elevation of nine hundred seventy five feet (975'), a pressure reducing
valve (PRV) shall be purchased from the City at the time the permit is applied for if a
new connection or upon notice by the City if an existing connection.
(4) Inspections: All property service lines shall be inspected by the City Water
Inspector before the lines are covered to insure proper construction of the line and
connection to the service stub. The owner or contractor shall give at least twenty four
(24) hours advance notice to the City Water Inspector when the service pipe is ready
for inspection.
(5) Turn On and Shut Offs: Only an authorized City employee shall turn on or
shut off any water supply at the curb stop.
Subd. 2. New Service Stubs: Application for Water Service Connection: In the event
additional connections or stubs to existing water trunk or lateral facilities are required
or desired, applications shall be made at the City Hall on forms furnished by the City.
-2-
.
.
Subd.
a. Applications: All such applications for service stubs shall be made by the owner of
the property to be served, or his duly authorized agent, and shall state the size and
location of the service connection required, and the applicant shall, at the time of
making application, pay to the City the amount of fees required for the installation of
the service connection as hereinafter provided. The application shall also contain the
name of the owner, a description of the property, lot, block and addition, name of road
upon which the property fronts and the signature of the applicant, or his agent,
agreeing to conform to the rules and regulations that may be established by the City as
conditions for the use of water.
b. Performance Bond: For the purpose of assuring and guaranteeing to the City that the
installation of the service connection shall fully comply with all of the other terms and
provisions of this Chapter, the applicant agrees to furnish to the City either a cash
deposit or a corporate surety bond in the sum of four thousand dollars --
approved by the City and naming the City as obligee thereunder.
c. Inspections: All property service stubs shall be inspected by the City Water
Inspector before the stubs are covered to insure proper construction of the stubs and
connection to the water main.
d. Additional Requirements: All requirements set forth in Subdivision 1 of this Section
shall be applicable to this subdivision.
I
_.'......01,....
;,,/:--'/>"k
"'''~!'.<
-3-
.
903.05: WATER TURN-ON AND SHUT-OFF FEES: A fee as established by
resolution of the City Council1 shall be charged for turning on or shutting off
water except in instances where a connection permit has been obtained by the property owner.
903.06:
INSTALLATION AND CONSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS AND
SPECIFICATIONS:
Subd. 1. Supervision: All work performed within the limits of the City shall com I .
re uirements of the Minnesota Plumbin Code as amended and the
and shall be under the direct supervision
of the City Water Inspector and Public Works Director.
Subd. 2. Authority to Do Work: Only persons authorized by this Chapter shall tap any
distributing main or pipe of the water system, or insert stopcocks or ferrule therein.
Subd. 3. Excavations:1 If the installation is to be in a surfaced street, the location of the water
main shall be ascertained from the City Engineer and, upon completion, such
installation shall be inspected by the Public Works Department. Prior to construction
within the street, notice shall be given to the City Water Inspector, School District,
United States Post Office, Police and Fire Departments, and City Public Works
Director. Such notice must be given at least three (3) days prior to the excavation for
laying of the service pipe, and the connection must be made before three o'clock (3:00)
P.M. After approval by the Public Works Department, the street shall be restored to its
previously existing condition as directed and approved by the Public Works
Department. The expense of such construction and restoration shall be borne by the
applicant.
-4-
..
Subd. 4. Separate Connections and Meters: No more than one housing unit or building shall
be supplied from one service connection except by special permission of the City
Council. Whenever two (2) or more parties are supplied from one pipe, connecting
with the distribution main, each building or part of the building must have a separate
stop box and a separate meter.
Subd. 5. Property Service Lines: All installations of property service lines shall comply with
the following:
a. Property service pipe must be laid with sufficient waving to allow not less than one
foot (I') extra length and in such manner as to prevent rupture by settlement.
.
b. Property service lines must be placed not less than seven and one-half feet (71/2')
below surface or finished grade, whichever is lower, and arranged so as to prevent
rupture by freezing.
c. A shut off or other curb stop shall be installed at the property line and placed so as
to be protected from freezing.
d. All underground joints are to be mechanical (compression or flared, not sweated)
unless otherwise approved by the City Inspector.
e. Joints shall be kept to a minimum with not more than one joint used for service up
to seventy feet (70') in length.
f. All piping joints and connections shall be left uncovered until inspected and tested at
normal water line pressure.
g. Connections at mains for domestic supply shall be at least one inch (1 ").
.
h. No water pipe shall be connected with any pump, well, tank or piping that is
connected with any other water supply other than the Municipal water system.
i. Not more than one building shall be supplied from one service connection unless by
special permission from the City Council.
j. When two (2) or more buildings are supplied from one pipe, each building must
have a separate stop box and separate meter.
k. Prior to connection with the Municipal water system, all means of cross-connection
to a retained private water supply shall be eliminated.
903.07:
SERVICE PIPES:
Subd. 1. Maintenance and Repair: It shall be the responsibility of the property owner to
maintain the service pipe from the curb box into the structure. In the case of failure
upon the part of the property owner to repair any leak occurring in his pipe within
-5-
twenty four (24) hours after verbal or written notice thereof, the water will be shut off
and will not be turned on until the service charge, as established by resolution of the
Council, has been paid and the leak repaired. When the waste of water is great, or
when damage is likely to result from the leak, water may be turned off immediately
pending repairs.
Subd. 2. Abandoned Service Installations: All service installations that have not been used
for one year, or for any reason have become useless for further service, shall be shut
off at the curb stop. Any expense of the City shall be charged to the property and, if
not paid within thirty (30) days, shall be treated as a delinquent account pursuant to
this Chapter.
903.08: METERS:
Subd. 1. Meter Use Required: Except for extinguishing of fire, no person except authorized .
City employees shall use water from the water supply system or permit water to be
drawn therefrom unless the same be metered by passing through a meter supplied by
the City.
Subd. 2. Installation of Meters: All water meters shall be installed by a licensed plumber in
accordance with the following rules:
a. The service pipe from the water main to the meter shall be brought through the floor
in a vertical position. The stop and waste valve shall be installed approximately twelve
inches (12") above the floor.
b. The meter shall be located so that the bottom is from twelve to twenty four inches
(12"-24") above the finished floor line. The meter shall be set not more than twelve
inches (12"), measured horizontally from the inside line of the basement wall, unless
an alternate method is approved by the City Water Inspector. .
c. All meter installations shall have a stop and waste valve on the street side of the
meter. In no case shall there be more than twelve inches (12") of pipe exposed between
the point of entrance through the basement floor and the stop and waste valve.
A stop and waste valve shall also be installed on the house side of the meter. Meter
setting devices shall be of copper pipe or tubing from the terminus of the service pipe
up to and including the house side stop and waste valve.
d. A remote reader shall be installed on the outside of the building in which the meter
is contained at a height of three feet to five feet (3'-5') above grade.
Subd. 3. Maintenance, Repair and Replacement:
a. Replacement of Meter: All water meters shall be and remain the property of the City
and may be removed or replaced or changed as to size and type by the City whenever
deemed necessary.
-6-
b. Maintenance and Repair: The City shall maintain and repair all meters when
rendered unserviceable through ordinary wear and tear and shall replace them if
necessary. However, where any replacement or repair or adjustment of any meter is
necessary because of damage from hot water backup, damage from freezing water, or
damage from any act, carelessness or negligence of the owner or occupants of any
premises, any expense incurred by the City to repair said damage shall be charged
against and collected from the property owner, and water service may be discontinued
until the cause is corrected and the amount charged collected.
.
Subd. 4. Meter Tests: When a consumer makes a complaint that the bill for any past services
has been excessive, the City shall, upon written request, have such meter re-read. If the
user remains dissatisfied and desires that the meter be tested, said user shall then make
a deposit in an amount established by resolution of the City Council 1 , and the City
shall test the meter. The user shall, ifhe so desires, be present when such test is made.
In case a test should show an error of over five percent (5%) of the water consumed in
favor of the City, the deposit will be refunded to the user and a correctly registering
meter will be installed and the date of written request and the minimum charge shall
not be affected. In case the test shows an accurate measurement of water or an error in
favor of the user, the amount deposited shall be retained by the City to cover the
expenses of making such test.
Subd. 5. Unauthorized Tampering With Meter: All water meters shall be inspected and
sealed by the City Water Inspector. No person not authorized by the City shall connect,
disconnect, take apart, remove the seal, or in any manner change or cause to be
changed or interfere with any such meter or the action thereof.
.
Subd. 6. Calibration of Water Meter and Remote Reader: Each year, the City shall mail to
each consumer a meter reading card. The consumer shall be responsible for recording
the readings for the water meter and remote reader upon such card and shall return
such card to the City by the date specified on the card. Failure of the consumer to
return such card to the City by the date specified on the card will result in a late fee
being assessed to the consumers account, such fee to be established by City Council
resolution. The City shall analyze such cards and identify those which indicate a
difference in excess of ten thousand (10,000) gallons. The City shall calibrate water
meters and remote readers which have a difference in excess of ten thousand gallons
(10,000) and shall inform the consumer of any difference in the readings and of the
amount due thereon. The consumer shall be responsible to pay for any and all
differences in readings between the water meter and remote reader which indicate
amounts due for water consumption.
903.09:
WATER RATES AND CHARGES:l
Subd. 1. Rates and Charges Established:
a. Water Service Rates: The water rate due and payable to the City by each water user
for water taken from the Municipal water system shall be at a quarterly rate established
-7-
by a resolution of the City Council1. Where service is for less than a quarterly period,
the quarterly charge will be prorated on a monthly basis.
(1) Minimum Rate for Low Income Residents: A mmnnum charge is
established for residents having low incomes. The charge shall be at two-thirds (2/3) of
the regular minimum rate; provided, that consumption is under ten thousand (10,000)
gallons per quarter. Should the consumption exceed this minimum, the minimum rate
reverts to the regular minimum rate. The criteria for determining low income is as set
by the Hennepin County CDBG Program Income Limits for Very Low Income and
'=~;~~.~~~~~J&:e ~~~i~~4~~~~':~~oo~: edil.'s~blOl s~orer
~._~~~~:. ;~:.:t.L."""B_" 19l e
this rate.
b. Meter Charges: A charge for a water meter shall be made by the City. Property
owners or users shall pay in advance before delivery of the water meter for installation.
Said charge shall be as established by the City Council by resolution. .
c. Water Turn On: The established turn-on fee will be charged for turning on water
where service has been shut off for nonpayment of water billings, failure to repair a
leak, discontinuance of service, or other reason specified in this Chapter.
d. Estimated and Adjusted Rates:
(1) In the event the water meter servicing any property is found to be operating
in a faulty manner or to have become inoperative, the amount of water will be
estimated in accordance with the amount previously used in comparable periods of the
year.
(2) The City Council shall be authorized to make adjustments in water charges
when the amount billed is erroneous due to a meter deficiency or other mistake.
.
e. Rates Outside City Limits: Rates due and payable by each water user located beyond
the territorial boundaries of the City shall be determined by special contract.
Subd. 2. Listing of Accounts: All accounts shall be kept on the books of the City in the name
of the owner of the property served. All bills and notices sent out by the City shall be
sent to the address of the property served. If nonresident owners or agents desire
personal notice sent to a different address, they shall file an application therefor with
the City. Any error in address shall be promptly reported to the City.
Subd. 3. Bills for Services, Delinquencies, Discontinuance, Tax Assessments:
a. Billing: Statements for charges for water service for a quarterly period shall be
mailed to each property owner or user on or before the tenth day of the first month
following the end of the quarter and shall be due and payable on or before the last day
of the months of January, April, July and October following the quarterly period
covered by the statement.
-8-
b. Delinquencies: After the last day of the month in which payment is due, a penalty of
ten percent (10%) of the unpaid account balance will be assessed and added to the
amount due on the account. If the balance due on the account is not paid in full within
forty five (45) days of the day on which the account became due, a notice shall be sent
to the property owner or user informing the property owner or user that the account is
delinquent and that unless the account balance, is paid in full within fifteen (15) days,
the water will be shut off and the prescribed shut-off fee will be assessed.
c. Discontinuance of Service: If the property owner or user does not respond to the
notice given above, prior to the date indicated in the notice, and the statement remains
unpaid, the water shall be shut off at the curb stop. Prior to the water being turned back
on again, the property owner or user shall be required to pay all delinquent charges,
plus penalties and shut-off fees, and the prescribed turn-on fee.
.
d. Appeals to Discontinuance of Service: The property owner or user may appeal the
notice to the City Council during the fifteen (15) day period set forth in Subd. 3(b).
Water service shall continue to the appealing property owner or user pending the
decision of the Council on the appeal. Upon the determination of the Council, the
water may be shut off pursuant to Subd. 3( c) as set forth above.
e. Tax Assessments: All delinquent accounts may be certified by the Clerk who shall
prepare an assessment roll each year providing for assessment of the delinquent
accounts against the respective property served. This assessment roll shall be delivered
to the City Council for adoption prior to November 30 of each year and upon approval
thereof, the Clerk shall certify to the County Auditor the amount due, plus a
certification fee as established by resolution of the City Council, and the County
Auditor shall thereupon enter such amount as part of the tax levy on such premises to
be collected during the ensuing year. Such action may be optional or subsequent to
taking legal action to collect delinquent accounts.
.
903.10: WATER CONNECTIONS SERVED BY ADJACENT
MUNICIPALITIES: The City Council has heretofore and will in the future
enter into contracts with adjacent municipalities to provide water service to properties located
within the City. All permits to be issued under this Chapter shall comply with the terms of
such agreements. In instances where the cost of the water hook-up from the supplying city is
included in full or in part as a quarterly charge, then such shall be added to the billing for the
minimum quarterly water charge to be paid by the recipient.
903.11: AUTHORIZED WATER SHUT OFFS: In case of fire or alarm of fire, water
may be shut off to insure a supply for the fire fighting; or in making repairs or
construction of new works, water may be shut off at any time and kept shut off as long as
necessary.
903.12: CONSERVATION MEASURES: Whenever the City Council shall
determine that a shortage of water supply threatens the City, it may, by resolution, limit the
time and hours during which water may be used from the water system for lawn and garden
-9-
sprinkling, irrigation, car washing and other uses specified therein. Appropriate notice of such
limitation shall be given prior to the enforcement thereof.
903.13: RESTRICTED AND PROHIBITED ACTS:
Subd. 1. Unauthorized Turn On or Shut Off: No person, except an authorized City employee
or agent, shall turn on or off any water supply at the curb stop. A turn-on or shut-off
fee in an amount equivalent to twice the prescribed fee shall be charged for the
unauthorized turn on or shut off of any connection to the M~icipal water system.
Subd. 2. Unauthorized Use of Hydrants, Interference With System: No person, other than
employees or agents ofthe City, shall operate fire hydrants or interfere in any way with
the water system.
Subd. 3. Supplying Water to Others: No person shall permit water from the water system to .
be used for any purpose except upon his own premises unless written consent is first
obtained from the City.
903.14:
DISCONTINUANCE OF SERVICE: Water service may be shut off at any
curb stop connection whenever:
Subd. 1. The owner or occupant of the premises served, or any person working on any pipes
or equipment thereon which are connected with the water system, has violated,
threatens to violate or causes to be violated, any of the provisions oftms Chapter.
Subd. 2. Any charge for water, service, meter or other financial obligation imposed on the
present or former owner or occupant of the premises served is unpaid.
Subd. 3. Fraud or misrepresentation by the owner or occupant of the premises served in .
connection with an application for service.
903.15: MANDATORY HOOK UP, COMMERCIAL ANDMULTIPLE-FAMILY
RESIDENTIAL USERS
1~.~~~_,~1rC'i,.',;']rl'~: The owner of a property used for commercial purposes or for
_L..~ -#;Ba
multiple-family residential purposes, involving four (4) or more dwelling units, situated
within the City and abutting on any street, alley or right-of-way in which there is located a
municipal water trunk or lateral facility, is hereby required at its expense to connect to such
facility in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter within nine 90 days after the date
of official written notice b the Ci Council to so connect.
-10-
903.16: RIGHT OF ENTRY POWERS: Authorized City employees shall have free
access at reasonable hours of the day to all parts of every building and premises
connected to the water system necessary for reading of meters and inspection. City employees
shall be properly identified and shall display such identification upon seeking admittance to
the building.
903.17: DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY: The City shall not be liable for any
deficiency or failure in the supply of water to property owners or users, whether
occasioned by shutting the water off for the purpose of making repairs or connections, or from
any other cause whatever.
.~ll~I_1Iif~BRL~~.~~.~
__~II_~~B~it__~1__.~~8
.
.
-11-
.
.
-"""" '.-'.,"'''''.'''' " "'''
',+~~: ,. ,0;.',. ',.' '.> ;." '. .~:,~"'~~t..._.". ","~~!~~;l~";::"',, ',' ,,,,,,,'1:,,:,~,_^,'f~5:,,'d?
'.' -1 .,.'" ,'i, _. ":', ".' ';', _,';j: ,,}; ,','.:f '~'.' , i ~ T,_)~;, '.-,; ",''''.' ~', :' __ "'~
-12-
..
,
_,". .. .me,...' ._.... """',
',,_', :' ,"~, "i':'~f'\~:,,;"}Uk'-:~":'-"," ~'" (,,\>Itf ,_,":;~~t<-"""+'.",,1ilio'-jl;:1\!P:;,'
"1',:,_ ,_ - '~ ' ,"', '. ; ,. "'f''', ~;-" '. 'H ','~ :1..-' _._<,.,',', ,:; "~;"o:'!
~ " , '.. , . - ',.' : . .' "'"" ' ,,- ",
_."'.......II&II.._cw
...". . ' .' '..... ."',.'. '_, ',,'.,' '. ~'.""..'..'.'.. '~.'W' ':'~'."'.
' , - " , .,'
~ .' " '... ..'C' .,' . <, . .,' '" . ~"'" ' ',: ~:. " .'.;' 'i
, ,'" lllllll'" 1I'~~~..!a1":'11
, '~, ,;[ -""'," '" ~i,',,, ", ' ";,"'; ~
~', ," "idfi', "',,, <~
.
Subd. 3. Deferred Assessments:
.
a. The City Council may defer special assessments: On homestead property owned
by a person who qualifies under the hardship criteria set forth below.
b. Procedure: The property owner shall make application for deferred payment of
special assessments. The application shall be made within 30 days after the adoption
of the assessment roll by the City Council and shall be renewed each year upon the
filing of a similar application no later than September 30. The City Administrator
shall establish a case number for each application; review the application for
complete information and details and make a recommendation to the City Council to
either approve or disapprove the application for deferment. The City Council by
majority vote, shall either grant or deny the deferment and if the deferment is granted,
the City Council may require the payment of interest due each year. Renewal
applications will be approved by the City Administrator for those cases whereby the
original conditions for qualifications remain substantially unchanged.
If the City Council grants the deferment, the City Administrator shall notify the
County Auditor who shall in accordance with Minnesota Statutes, Section 435.194,
record a notice of the deferment with the County Recorder setting forth the amount of
assessment.
-13-
"
J
Interest shall be charged on any assessment deferred pursuant to this Section at a rate
equal to the rate charged on other assessments for the particular public improvement
projects the assessment is financing. If the City Council grants an assessment deferral
to an applicant, the interest may also be deferred, or the interest may be due and
payable on a yearly basis up until the assessment period terminates and only the
principal is deferred. The decision as to whether the principal and interest or just the
principal is deferred is decided by the City Council when considering the application.
Conditions of Hardship:
a. Any applicant must be 65 years of age, or older, or retired by reason of permanent
or total disability and must own a legal or equitable interest in the property applied
for which must be the homestead ofthe applicant, or
oss income of the a licant shall not be in excess of the
.
Income specified in the application should be the income of the year proceeding the
year in which the application is made, or the average income of the three years prior
to the year in which the application is made, whichever is less, and
c. Permanent and/or total disability shall be determined by using the criteria
es~bli~hed for" ermanent B?d total disability" for Workman's Compensation _
,>,lil,. ,,'.' "_,,' '" , ,h~
Subd. 4. Policies: The City Council shall establish and may from time to time modify
policies pertaining for the fair, equitable and consistent allocation of the cost of water
improvements. Such policies may relate to factors for determining economic
feasibility, fees and charges for connecting to the system and such additional matters .
as the Council shall determine appropriate in its reasonable discretion.
903.19:
VIOLATION: Any person violating any provision of this Chapter shall be
guilty of a misdemeanor.
-14-
<~
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 · www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
10 July 2003
RE:
Proposed Code Amendment - Municipal Water Use and Service
FILE NO.
City Code (Chapter 903)
For quite some time staffhas advised the Council that the code relative to municipal
water service is extremely difficult to interpret and enforce. Recent discussions
relative to connection charges have provided an opportunity to incorporate
recommended water policies into the Code that make the cost of providing water
more equitable.. We have also cleaned up the ordinance so as to be .easier to read,
understand and enforce. You will note that this one ordinance replaces two
ordinances tied together with a resolution. Substantive changes have been highlighted
m gray.
Staffproposes this draft of the revisions to be a "first reading". Some granunatical
changes will be presented at the meeting. Th~ intent would be to hold the hearing on
Monday night, adopting a final draft on 28 July.
If you have any questions relative to this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me
prior to Monday night's meeting.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Bonnie Burton
ft
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
:/I~A
SECTION:
903.01 :
903.02:
903.03:
903.04:
903.05:
903.06:
903.07:
903.08:
903.09:
903.10:
903.11:
903.12:
903.13:
903.14:
903.15:
903.16:
903.17:
903.18:
903.19:
..
-D-R-A-F-T-
CHAPTER 903
WATER USE AND SERVICE
Purpose and Intent
Compliance With Provisions
Private Wells
Water Service Connections
Water Turn-On and Shut-Off Fees
Installation and Construction Requirements and Specifications
Service Pipes
Meters
Water Rates and Charges
Water Connections Served by Adjacent Municipalities
Authorized Water Shut Offs
Conservation Measures
Restricted and Prohibited Acts
Discontinuance of Service
Mandatory Hook Up, Commercial and Multiple-Family
Residential Users
Right of Entry Powers
Disclaimer of Liability
Water Improvement Process
Violation
.
903.01: PURPOSE AND INTENT: The City Municipal water system (hereinafter
called the water system) shall be operated as a public utility and convenience
from which revenue will be derived, subject to the provisions of this Chapter.
.
903.02: COMPLIANCE WITH PROVISIONS: No person shall make, construct or
install any water service installation, or make use of any water service
connected to the water system except in the manner provided in this Chapter, nor shall any
person make, construct, install or make use of any installation connected to the water system
contrary to the regulatory provisions of this Chapter.
903.03 PRIVATE WELLS: Pursuant to the current State Well Code and the
Minnesota Plumbing Code, private wells may be constructed or maintained and
continued in use whether or not connection is made to the water system. In no event shall
there be a means of cross-connection between the private well and the Municipal water system
at any time. Hose bibbs that will enable the cross-connection of the two (2) systems are
prohibited on internal piping of the well supply system. The threads of the boiler drain of the
well volume tank shall be removed or the boiler drain hose bibb replaced with a sink faucet.
903.04:
WATER SERVICE CONNECTIONS:
Subd. 1. Existing Service Stubs: Service stubs have been installed to serve some homes and
businesses presently located in the City. For those homes and businesses, the
connections are ready for use by the existing structures in the City.
a. Permit to Connect, Fee: A permit must be obtained to connect to the water system.
The fee for each permit shall be as set by Council resolution 1. Such fee shall include
inspection and turn-on services performed by the City.
b. Conditions of Permit: The permit fee shall be paid at the time of making application
for water service. In addition thereto, before any permit shall be issued, the following
conditions shall be complied with:
.
(1) No permit shall be issued to tap or connect with any water main or water
system of the City either directly or indirectly from any lot or tract of land unless it
shall be determined that:
(a) The lot or tract of land to be served by such connection or tap has been
assessed for the cost of construction of the water main and water plan system
with which the connection is made; or
(b) The proceedings for levying such assessments have been or will be
commenced in due course; or
( c) A connection charge has been paid.
.
(2) A water meter, meter horn, and remote reader shall be purchased from the
City at the time permit is applied for2.
(3) If the lot is served by the eastern service district water tower and is below
an elevation of nine hundred seventy five feet (975'), a pressure reducing valve (pR V)
shall be purchased from the City at the time the permit is applied for if a new
connection or upon notice by the City if an existing connection.
(4) Inspections: All property service lines shall be inspected by the City Water
Inspector before the lines are covered to insure proper construction of the line and
connection to the service stub. The owner or contractor shall give at least twenty four
(24) hours advance notice to the City Water Inspector when the service pipe is ready
for inspection.
(5) Turn On and Shut Offs: Only an authorized City employee shall turn on or
shut off any water supply at the curb stop.
Subd. 2. New Service Stubs: Application for Water Service Connection: In the event
additional connections or stubs to existing water trunk or lateral facilities are required
-2-
Subd.
or desired, applications shall be made at the City Hall on forms furnished by the City.
a. Applications: All such applications for service stubs shall be made by the owner of
the property to be served, or his duly authorized agent, and shall state the size and
location of the service connection required, and the applicant shall, at the time of
making application, pay to the City the amount of fees required for the installation of
the service connection as hereinafter provided. The application shall also contain the
name of the owner, a description of the property, lot, block and addition, name of road
upon which the property fronts and the signature of the applicant, or his agent,
agreeing to conform to the rules and regulations that may be established by the City as
conditions for the use of water.
b. Performance Bond: For the purpose of assuring and guaranteeing to the City that the
installation of the service connection shall fully comply with all of the other terms and
provisions of this Chapter, the applicant agrees to furnish to the City either a cash
deposit ... of,a ....~orporate surety bond in the sum of two thousand dollars
I.~~_j approved by the City and naming the City as obligee thereunder. .
c. fuspections: All property service stubs shall be inspected by the City Water
fuspector before the stubs are covered to insure proper construction of the stubs and
connection to the water main.
d. Additional Requirements: All requirements set forth in Subdivision I ofthis Section
shall be applicable to this subdivision.
.
~Il'l~:s.e
~1f~~lI!f~f~~~:!i~ti!L"~
j}1.m.;,;!rr~~~~
lEriQHftt~
~
~
mll.Jll~lJIIi~llLlllfl~
!i.t~I.11
If~ifJI:tl~i1
~~
.~
i~Jit~im:g:1[~ll,m~~~~:~
_"...._iittl!!~qllliy@;~nt21ID1~~ltl~~ili~li~~~f!?~ITQn~f~~~R~~
-3-
.
903.05: WATER TURN-ON AND SHUT-OFF FEES: A fee as established by
resolution of the City Council 1 shall be charged for turning on or shutting off
water except in instances where a connection permit has been obtained by the property owner.
903.06:
INSTALLATION AND CONSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS AND
SPECIFICATIONS:
.
Subd.
1. S~pervision: All work. performed wi~n the limits of the City shall coml?,!.~..;r,"t:.:'~.':'J!".!~..;,'.''''!..'.'
reqUirements of the Minnesota Plumbm Code as amended and the ~.l&.ifi.a.()Qj
and shall be
under the direct supervision of the City Water Inspector and Public Works Director.
Subd. 2. Authority to Do Work: Only persons authorized by this Chapter shall tap any
distributing main or pipe of the water system, or insert stopcocks or ferrule therein.
Subd. 3. Excavations:1 If the installation is to be in a surfaced street, the location of the water
main shall be ascertained from the City Engineer and, upon completion, such
installation shall be inspected by the Public Works Department. Prior to construction
within the street, notice shall be given to the City Water Inspector, School District,
United States Post Office, Police and Fire Departments, and City Public Works
Director. Such notice must be given at least three (3) days prior to the excavation for
laying of the service pipe, and the connection must be made before three o'clock (3 :00)
P.M. After approval by the Public Works Department, the street shall be restored to its
previously existing condition as directed and approved by the Public Works
-4-
Department. The expense of such construction and restoration shall be borne by the
applicant.
Subd. 4. Separate Connections and Meters: No more than one housing unit or building shall
be supplied from one service connection except by special permission of the City
Council. Whenever two (2) or more parties are supplied from one pipe, connecting
with the distribution main, each building or part of the building must have a separate
stop box and a separate meter.
Subd. 5. Property Service Lines: All installations of property service lines shall comply with
the following:
a. Property service pipe must be laid with sufficient waving to allow not less than one
foot (1 ') extra length and in such manner as to prevent rupture by settlement.
b. Property service lines must be placed not less than seven and one-half feet (71/2') .
below surface or finished grade, whichever is lower, and arranged so as to prevent
rupture by freezing.
c. A shut off or other curb stop shall be installed at the property line and placed so as
to be protected from freezing.
d. All underground joints are to be mechanical (compression or flared, not sweated)
unless otherwise approved by the City Inspector.
e. Joints shall be kept to a minimum. with not more than one joint used for service up
to seventy feet (70') in length.
f. All joints and connections shall be left uncovered until inspected and tested at
normal water line pressure.
g. Connections at mains for domestic supply shall be at least one inch (1").
.
h. No water pipe shall be connected with any pump, well, tank or piping that is
connected with any other water supply other than the MuniCipal water system.
i. Not more than one building shall be supplied from one service connection unless by
special permission from the City Council.
j. When two (2) or more buildings are supplied from one pipe, each building must
have a separate stop box and separate meter.
k. Prior to connection with the Municipal water system, all means of cross-connection
to a retained private water supply shall be eliminated.
903.07:
SERVICE PIPES:
-5-
Subd. 1. Maintenance and Repair: It shall be the responsibility of the property owner to
maintain the service pipe from the curb box into the structure. In the case of failure
upon the part of the property owner to repair any leak occurring in his pipe within
twenty four (24) hours after verbal or written notice thereof, the water will be shut off
and will not be turned on until the service charge, as established by resolution of the
Council, has been paid and the leak repaired. When the waste of water is great, or
when damage is likely to result from the leak, water may be turned off immediately
pending repairs.
Subd. 2. Abandoned Service Installations: All service installations that have not been used
for one year, or for any reason have become useless for further service, shall be shut
off at the curb stop. Any expense of the City shall be charged to the property and, if
not paid within thirty (30) days, shall be treated as a delinquent account pursuant to
this Chapter.
.
903.08:
METERS:
Subd. 1. Meter Use Required: Except for extinguishing of fire, no person except authorized
City employees shall use water from the water supply system or permit water to be
drawn therefrom unless the same be metered by passing through a meter supplied by
the City.
Subd. 2. Installation of Meters: All water meters shall be installed by a licensed plumber in
accordance with the following rules:
a. The service pipe from the water main to the meter shall be brought through the floor
in a vertical position. The stop and waste valve shall be installed approximately twelve
inches (12") above the floor.
.
b. The meter shall be located so that the bottom is from twelve to twenty four inches
(12"-24") above the finished floor line. The meter shall be set not more than twelve
inches (12"), measured horizontally from the inside line of the basement wall, unless
an alternate method is approved by the City Water Inspector.
c. All meter installations shall have a stop and waste valve on the street side of the
meter. In no case shall there be more than twelve inches (12") of pipe exposed between
the point of entrance through the basement floor and the stop and waste valve.
A stop and waste valve shall also be installed on the house side of the meter. Meter
setting devices shall be of copper pipe or tubing from the terminus of the service pipe
up to and including the house side stop and waste valve.
d. A remote reader shall be installed on the outside of the building in which the meter
is contained at a height of three feet to five feet (3'-5') above grade.
Subd. 3. Maintenance, Repair and Replacement:
-6-
a. Replacement of Meter: All water meters shall be and remain the property of the City
and may be removed or replaced or changed as to size and type by the City whenever
deemed necessary.
b. Maintenance and Repair: The City shall maintain and repair all meters when
rendered unserviceable through ordinary wear and tear and shall replace them if
necessary. However, where any replacement or repair or adjustment of any meter is
necessary because of damage from hot water backup, damage from freezing water, or
damage from any act, carelessness or negligence of the owner or occupants of any
premises, any expense incurred by the City to repair said damage shall be charged
against and collected from the property owner, and water service may be discontinued
until the cause is corrected and the amount charged collected.
Subd. 4. Meter Tests: When a consumer makes a complaint that the bill for any past services
has been excessive, the City shall, upon written request, have such meter re-read. lfthe
user remains dissatisfied and desires that the meter be tested, said user shall then make .
a deposit in an amount established by resolution of the City Council 1 , and the City
shall test the meter. The user shall, if he so desires, be present when such test is made.
In case a test should show an error of over five percent (5%) of the water consumed in
favor of the City, the deposit will be refunded to the user and a correctly registering
meter will be installed and the date of written request and the minimum charge shall
not be affected. In case the test shows an accurate measurement of water or an error in
favor of the user, the amount deposited shall be retained by the City to cover the
expenses of making such test.
Subd. 5. Unauthorized Tampering With Meter: All water meters shall be inspected and
sealed by the City Water Inspector. No person not authorized by the City shall connect,
disconnect, take apart, remove the seal, or in any manner change or cause to be
changed or interfere with any such meter or the action thereof.
Subd. 6. Calibration of Water Meter and Remote Reader: On or before May 1 each year, the .
City shall mail to each consumer a meter reading card. The consumer shall be
responsible for recording the readings for the water meter and remote reader upon such
card and shall return such card to the City on or before May 20. Failure of the
consumer to return such card to the City by May 20 will result in a late fee being
assessed to the consumers account, such fee to be established by City Council
resolution 1. The City shall analyze such cards and identify those which indicate a
difference in excess of ten thousand (10,000) gallons. The City shall calibrate water
meters and remote readers which have a difference in excess of ten thousand gallons
(10,000) and shall inform the consumer of any difference in the readings and of the
amount due thereon. From and after May 20, 1993, the consumer shall be responsible
to pay for any and all differences in readings between the water meter and remote
reader which indicate amounts due for water consumption.
903.09:
WATER RATES AND CHARGES: 1
Subd. 1. Rates and Charges Established:
-7-
a. Water Service Rates: The water rate due and payable to the City by each water user
for water taken from the Municipal water system shall be at a quarterly rate established
by a resolution of the City Council1. Where service is for less than a quarterly period,
the quarterly charge will be prorated on a monthly basis.
(1) Minimum Rate for Low Income Residents: A mlmmum charge is
established for residents having low incomes. The charge shall be at two-thirds (2/3) of
the regular minimum rate; provided, that consumption is under ten thousand (10,000)
gallons per quarter. Should the consumption exceed this minimum, the minimum rate
reverts to the regular minimum rate. The criteria for determining low income is as set
by the Hennepin County CDBG Program Income Limits for Very Low Income and
family size. Residents must submit the proper application and income disclosure to be
eligible for this rate.
.
b. Meter Charges: A charge for a water meter shall be made by the City. Property
owners or users shall pay in advance before delivery of the water meter for installation.
Said charge shall be as established by the City Council by resolution.
c. Water Turn On: The established turn-on fee will be charged for turning on water
where service has been shut off for nonpayment of water billings, failure to repair a
leak, discontinuance of service, or other reason specified in this Chapter.
d. Estimated and Adjusted Rates:
(1) In the event the water meter servicing any property is found to be operating
in a faulty manner or to have become inoperative, the amount of water will be
estimated in accordance with the amount previously used in comparable periods of the
year.
.
(2) The City Council shall be authorized to make adjustments in water charges
when the amount billed is erroneous due to a meter deficiency or other mistake.
e. Rates Outside City Limits: Rates due and payable by each water user located beyond
the territorial boundaries of the City shall be determined by special contract.
Subd. 2. Listing of Accounts: All accounts shall be kept on the books of the City in the name
of the owner of the property served. All bills and notices sent out by the City shall be
sent to the address of the property served. If nonresident owners or agents desire
personal notice sent to a different address, they shall file an application therefor with
the City. Any error in address shall be promptly reported to the City.
Subd. 3. Bills for Services, Delinquencies, Discontinuance, Tax Assessments:
a. Billing: Statements for charges for water service for a quarterly period shall be
mailed to each property owner or user on or before the tenth day and shall be due and
payable on or before the last day of the months of January, April, July and October
following the quarterly period covered by the statement.
-8-
b. Delinquencies: After the last day of the month in which payment is due, a penalty of
ten percent (10%) of the unpaid account balance will be assessed and added to the
amount due on the account. If the balance due on the account is not paid in full within
forty five (45) days of the day on which the account became due, a notice shall be sent
to the property owner or user informing the property owner or user that the account is
delinquent and that unless the account balance, is paid in full within fifteen (15) days,
the water will be shut off and the prescribed shut-off fee will be assessed.
c. Discontinuance of Service: If the property owner or user does not respond to the
notice given above, prior to the date indicated in the notice, and the statement remains
unpaid, the water shall be shut off at the curb stop. Prior to the water being turned back
on again, the property owner or user shall be required to pay all delinquent charges,
plus penalties and shut-off fees, and the prescribed turn-on fee.
d. Appeals to Discontinuance of Service: The property owner or user may appeal the
notice to the City Council during the fifteen (15) day period set forth in Subd. 3(b). .
Water service shall continue to the appealing property owner or user pending the
decision of the Council on the appeal. Upon the determination of the Council, the
water may be shut off pursuant to Subd. 3( c) as set forth above.
e. Tax Assessments: All delinquent accounts may be certified by the Clerk who shall
prepare an assessment roll each year providing for assessment of the delinquent
accounts against the respective property served. This assessment roll shall be delivered
to the City Council for adoption on or before October 10 of each year and upon
approval thereof, the Clerk shall certify to the County Auditor the amount due, plus a
certification fee as established by resolution of the City Council, and the County
Auditor shall thereupon enter such amount as part of the tax levy on such premises to
be collected during the ensuing year. Such action may be optional or subsequent to
taking legal action to collect delinquent accounts.
.
903.10: WATER CONNECTIONS SERVED BY ADJACENT
MUNICIPALITIES: The City Council has heretofore and will in the future
enter into contracts with adjacent municipalities to provide water service to properties located
within the City. All permits to be issued under this Chapter shall comply with the terms of
. such agreements. In instances where the cost of the water hook-up from the supplying city is
included in full or in part as a quarterly charge, then such shall be added to the billing for the
minimum quarterly water charge to be paid by the recipient.
903.11: AUTHORIZED WATER SHUT OFFS: In case of fire or alarm of fire, water
may be shut off to insure a supply for the fire fighting; or in making repairs or
construction of new works, water may be shut off at any time and kept shut off as long as
necessary.
903.12:
CONSERVATION MEASURES: Whenever the City Council shall
-9-
determine
that a shortage of water supply threatens the City, it may, by resolution, limit
the time and hours during which water may be used from the water system for lawn and
garden sprinkling, irrigation, car washing and other uses specified therein. Appropriate notice
of such limitation shall be given prior to the enforcement thereof.
903.13: RESTRICTED AND PROHIBITED ACTS:
Subd. 1. Unauthorized Turn On or Shut Off: No person, except an authorized City employee
or agent, shall turn on or off any water supply at the curb stop. A turn-on or shut-off
fee in an amount equivalent to twice the prescribed fee shall be charged for the
unauthorized turn on or shut off of any connection to the Municipal water system.
.
Subd. 2. Unauthorized Use of Hydrants, Interference With System: No person, other than
employees or agents of the City, shall operate fire hydrants or interfere in any way with
the water system.
Subd. 3. Supplying Water to Others: No person shall permit water from the water system to
be used for any purpose except upon his own premises unless written consent is first
obtained from the City.
903.14:
DISCONTINUANCE OF SERVICE: Water service may be shut off at any
curb stop connection whenever:
Subd. 1. The owner or occupant of the premises served, or any person working on any pipes
or equipment thereon which are connected with the water system, has violated,
threatens to violate or causes to be violated, any of the provisions of this Chapter.
.
Subd. 2. Any charge for water, service, meter or other financial obligation imposed on the
present or former owner or occupant of the premises served is unpaid.
Subd. 3. Fraud or misrepresentation by the owner or occupant of the premises served in
connection with an application for service.
903.15: MANDATORY HOOK UP, COMMERCIAL ANDMULTIPLE-FAMILY
RESIDENTIAL USERS : The
owner of a property used for commercial purposes or for multiple-family residential purposes,
involving four (4) or more dwelling units, situated within the City and abutting on any street,
alley or right-of-way in which there is located a municipal water trunk or lateral facility, is
hereby required at his expense to connect to such facility in accordance with the provisions of
this Chapter within ninety 90 da s after the date of official written notice b the City
Council to so connect. '\"'i1
-10-
:.
~~~ir~~!lJ1lf~t.~~~~~Qp.f~Q:~1~gl[$li~i;i~:;I)Jg~i(im~~~Il~J
903.16: RIGHT OF ENTRY POWERS: Authorized City employees shall have free
access at reasonable hours of the day to all parts of every building and premises
connected to the water system necessary for reading of meters and inspection. City employees
shall be properly identified and shall display such identification upon seeking admittance to
the building.
903.17: DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY: The City shall not be liable for any
deficiency or failure in the supply of water to property owners or users, whether
occasioned by shutting the water off for the purpose of making repairs or connections, or from
any other cause whatever.
~l&af'Il1\\(.(>,\'l~~~]!~lWr'II'/~1'm1B'RDIIJ. -''''.'".'~1j;;~~'''B'ii''''W'''''''e",''8~'
~~~~Nit.~~iil.1i~~~~i~~~:~'..~,-.',~';I}i~fI~~lAl~gJ~
.
~':;r"QliQrl~""'I'!~f1:"';~~'ilT'..AIll.~.,,!I"'I':~~_ l!f.'l. 1~'l~M1i'l;~~IlW~~w"miIl""'>I':e,""'~""-i'\"':~ut'!~t;;\!':l'\rA""S:",,~)l;
iQ;~ll;i";;I''''l\\it)7f<''~j,C\I''''''~'~~i'!l;(t<''",,''I''''6t;:;;:.tl -~,~ 'ra:t~~~!i.iiiffiiil"f",
~~~~1_h{~l~~~~~~:g~~;;.;~~1'.~~!~
.
-11-
!
.
.
ry~1.'~
"e~
t
mlfM\\tEi!'1~If~lgllll~m
~'iIFI.;';I;~~~r~.~'T~ifit0f~~"'il.~~"~~~C~(;f(ii!!;1t,,~~~~;,';":'~~j
....,"", ."e.J, .' _",~")!"JiI:.~..,,:e:,. ).l4J;,...":l!:Tn1"\J:~",._.~.~~"n;.....}"
~~ .... ..--_!,.D''--...__n... .""..~".....1:.~~~i..-.,_...."""_...,'"'_ ...."""'.........
~!Bi~;!Il;"I~~~~1r~'k.iIi~'l,>,"1l"'I.~
~~,~..~;~ '~~~~~~~,.,~~~
~>!V!~~~~li~"'W~~Ff;l~~~if!w.:--:;l~;J;\~~
~~1~tt~W'..P~~g~~g!'~191~~q,~~~
.
Subd. 3. Deferred Assessments:
a. The City Council may defer special assessments: On homestead property owned .
by a person who qualifies under the hardship criteria set forth below.
b. Procedure: The property owner shall make application for deferred payment of
special assessments on a form prescribed by the Hennepin County Auditor and
supplemented by the Shorewood City Administrator. The application shall be made
within 30 days after the adoption of the assessment roll by the City Council and shall
be renewed each year upon the filing of a similar application no later than September
30. The City Administrator shall establish a case number for each application; review
the application for complete information and details and make a recommendation to
the City Council to either approve or disapprove the application for deferment. The
City Council by majority vote, shall either grant or deny the deferment and if the
deferment is granted, the City Council may require the payment of interest due each
year. Renewal applications will be approved by the City Administrator for those cases
whereby the original conditions for qualifications remain substantially unchanged.
If the City Council grants the deferment, the City Administrator shall notify the
County Auditor who shall in accordance with Minnesota Statutes, Section 435.194,
-13-
.
record a notice of the deferment with the County Recorder setting forth the amount of
assessment.
Interest shall be charged on any assessment deferred pursuant to this Section at a rate
equal to the rate charged on other assessments for the particular public improvement
projects the assessment is financing. If the City Council grants an assessment deferral
to an applicant, the interest may also be deferred, or the interest may be due and
payable on a yearly basis up until the assessment period terminates and only the
principal is deferred. The decision as to whether the principal and interest or just the
principal is deferred is decided by the City Council when considering the application.
Conditions of Hardship:
.
a. Any applicant must be 65 years of age, or older, or retired by reason of permanent
and/or total disability and must own a legal or equitable interest in the property
applied for which must be the homestead of the applicant, or
b. The annual gross income of the applicant shall not be in excess of the very low
income limits (50% of median) asset forth by family size in Hennepin County's
Section Eight guidelines. Calculation of the total family income shall be determined
by the summation of all available income sources of the applicant and spouse.
Income specified in the application should be the income of the year proceeding the
year in which the application is made, or the avera~come of the three years prior
to the year in which the application is made, whichever is less, and
c. Permanent and/or total disability shall be determined by using the criteria
established for "permanent and total disability" for Workman's Compensation, to wit:
(1) The total and permanent loss of the sight of both eyes.
.
(2) The loss of both arms at the shoulder.
(3) The loss of both legs so close to the hips that no effective artificial
members can be used.
(4) Complete and permanent paralysis.
(5) Total and permanent loss of mental faculties.
(6) Any other injury which totally incapacitates the owner from working at an
occupation which brings himlher an income.
An applicant must substantiate the retirement by reason of permanent and/or total
disability by providing a sworn affidavit by a licensed medical doctor attesting that the
applicant is unable to be gainfully employed because of a permanent and/or total
disability.
-14-
Subd. 4. Policies: The City Council shall establish and may from time to time modify
policies pertaining for the fair, equitable and consistent allocation of the cost of water
improvements. Such policies may relate to factors for determining economic
feasibility, fees and charges for connecting to the system and such additional matters
as the Council shall determine appropriate in its reasonable discretion.
903.19:
VIOLATION: Any person violating any provision of this Chapter shall be
guilty of a misdemeanor.
-15-
..
.
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 · www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
21 July 2003
RE:
Zucco, William - Request to Exchange Tax-Forfeited Property for
Additional Right-of-Way on Enchanted Point
FILE NO.:
Streets (Enchanted Point)
BACKGROUND
.
Mr. William Zucco, representing his father, has requested that the City convey a portion
of property on Enchanted Island (see Exhibit A, attached) in exchange for additional
public right-of-way for Enchanted Point (see Exhibit B). The subject property was
obtained by the City several years ago through tax-forfeiture. As set forth in his request
letter, dated 18 April 2003 (Exhibit C), Mr. Zucco wishes to even offthe boundaries of
his father's land, located at 4485 Enchanted Point.
It is worth noting that a request by Mr. Zucco's father to buy the entire parcel was turned
down in 1988 because the traveled surface of Enchanted Point cuts across the property.
Mr. Zucco now proposes to obtain only that portion of the city property that is not needed
for the road and a reasonable width of right-of-way. He proposes to convey to the City
an equal area of land to be used for right-of-way for Enchanted Point. Enchanted Point is
currently very substandard in terms of right-of-way width.
While the proposed land trade does not resolve the substandard width of Enchanted Point,
it does provide additional width where the traveled surface of the road encroaches on the
Zucco land. Additional right-of-way would be obtained by the City in the event the
property is ever replatted.
ft
'w~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
it 6. 8.
Memorandum
Re: Zucco Land Exchange
21 July 2003
If the Council agrees that the proposed trade has merit, the transaction should be
approved subject to the following:
1. Mr. Zucco shall, at his expense, commission the necessary survey work to
describe the parcels being exchanged.
2. The amount of area to be conveyed shall be based upon the City Engineer's
recommendation as to how much right-of-way should be retained for Enchanted
Point.
3. Mr. Zucco shall reimburse the City for the expense of any legal work necessary to
complete the transaction.
.
A public hearing has been scheduled for Monday, 28 July 2003 to consider this request.
If you have any questions relative to it, please contact me prior to the meeting.
Cc: . Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Bill Zucco
.
-2-
Q)
a Q)
aU.
q
....
::)
l::
::)
Z
c:(
.
~
CO
C/)
0..
..J
W
I
0..
z......c:
a
a
It)
a
It)
N
a
;2
Z
o
I-
UJ
Z
Z
-
~
W
~
<(
..J
o
z
<(
....J
C/)
U)
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
Zucco/R.O.W. exchange
Nt
-
.~
./
/'
/
/
I
I Swp,p
I
I
........
.
Zu-ee. 0
.
ZCA.C..~ 0
L a. ke
Exhibit B
PROPOSED TRADE
April 18, 2003
4PfI
2 1 2003
Brad Nielson
City Planner
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
AND VIA FAX 952/474-0128
Dear Mr. Nielson:
Re: 4485 Enchanted Point
Proposed Swap of Land with City
. We recently had my father's home surveyed at 4485 Enchanted Point. The survey
revealed that the city road encroached on the northeast portion of our property.
My father, who turns 91 in December, would like to see any inconsistencies in the survey
and the current use by the city corrected prior to his death. It probably isn't practical to
reroute the existing road and that would also cause disruption and inconvenience to the
neighbors. What makes sense is to swap the city land that borders the northwest comer of
our property with land from our northeast comer where the city road encroaches (see
sketch attached). I am also sending this letter today by regular mail with a copy of the full
survey.
.
The swap is of benefit to both parties. We will swap enough land to allow someday for
the city to be able to widen the road. The piece we receive from the city is an isolated
parcel between the city road and our land. It will eliminate confusion over the care and
clean up of the city piece. It will also round out the northwest comer of our property
making it a more conventional lot. Finally, a new survey and description would be
accurate.
If this proposed swap could get preliminary approval by the city, we will have a survey
completed on the two pieces of land to be swapped in anticipation ofa formal hearing
on this matter. I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.
Thank you in advance for reviewing this request.
Yours truly,
~~f!:r
952/830-0314
Exhibit C
ZUCCO REQUEST LETTER
Dated 18 April 03
.
DRAFT
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PARK COMMISSION PARK TOURS
TUESDAY, JULY 8, 2003
6:00 P.M
SHOREWOOD PUBLIC WORKS
SILVERWOOD PARK
SOUTHSHORE COMMUNITY PK
DEEPHA VEN BEACH PARK
CHANHASSEN SKATE PARK
CHAN. LAKE ANN PARK
SEDGE MEADOW @ARBORETUM
MINUTES
1. CONVENE PARK COMMISSION PARK TOUR
Chair Arnst called the tour to order at 6:00 P.M.
A. Roll Call
.
Present:
Chair Arnst, Commissioners Young, Meyer, Davis, Callies, and late arrival
Gilbertson; City Engineer Brown; City Administrator Dawson; Park Secretary
Grout; and Engineer Bailey.
Absent: Commissioner Palesch
2. PUBLIC WORKS FACILITY TOUR
Brown gave the Commission a brief tour of the facility, shop, and equipment garage.
3. SIL VERWOOD PARK TO-DO LIST
. Refurbish the backboard in-house
. Sealcoat the half court surface in-house and repaint lines
.
Engineer Brown pointed out that this park is a high use neighborhood park.
Discussion surrounding the use of the tennis backboard and installing a multi-purpose surface
arose. Bailey suggested the Commission consider installing a second set of hoops at the opposite
end of the half court or moving a smaller piece of skateboarding equipment from the Community
Park to Silverwood for the youngsters to practice on.
4.
SOUTHSHORECO~TYPARK
.
Consider low-level landscaping for the berm, potentillas, dogwood, etc.
Apply a coat of paint to the equipment to clean it up
.
Although the park is heavily used, Brown indicated that there had been a slight decrease in
activity lately. Chair Arnst indicated that she and Brown would be meeting with Tim Hughes,
one of the original designers of the park, to discuss adding an additional piece of equipment and
redesigning the layout.
While the American Legion does not have the funds currently, Brown reported that the Legion
has promised to honor their commitment to providing $1,000 annually for improvements to the
park.
#74
PARK COMMISSION PARK TOURS
JULY 8, 2003
Page 2 of3
Chair Arnst encouraged the Commissioners to consider if, and where, a bike park might fit in the
greenspace of the park. While additional thought should be given to benches or something for
adults to use at the park.
5. DEEPHA VEN PARK
Deephaven City Administrator Dana Young met the Commission at the main beach area to view
the new multi-purpose surface installed at the tennis courts. Administrator Young explained that
the new Sport Court surface, combined with blacktop improvements, cost approximately
$18,575., and were part of an overall improvement project. Administrator Young reported that
the surface had a life expectancy of 20 years, would be left down during the winter, and had, so
far, meant less maintenance.
With regard to questions about vandalism, the playing surface, and designs, Administrator Young
indicated that other cities have had few vandalism problems, the tennis action is a bit slower for
medium play, and that numerous design surfaces are available, including hopscotch, magic
square, roller hockey, basketball, etc.
.
In response to Chair Arnst's question regarding public reaction, Administrator Young stated that
public reaction, although first mixed, had since warmed to the change. He indicated that the Park
Commission took on an ambitious improvement project that was downsized a bit and included
new lighting at $65,000, boardwalk improvements and gazebo, as well as the court changes for a
total of approximately $135,000, paid for via park dedication fees. He noted that future
improvements would likely be funded through their CIP, since the accessibility of park dedication
fees would be declining.
6. CHANHASSEN SKATE PARK
Todd Hoffman, Chanhassen's Park and Recreation Director, met the Commission to provide a
brief overview of current park improvements and activities. Hoffman reported that the skate park
continues to be a hot destination across the metro area hosting 150 visitors a day. He believed the
accessible, convenient location, proximity to shopping, and configuration of the park has helped it .
to succeed. Hoffman pointed out that the park was gated to contain the litter and access to the
park, with the north gate closed at all times to separate the park from the elementary school.
Hoffman explained that the City is awaiting $15,000 in new True Ride equipment, which will
consist of 2 new pieces and a new configuration. He stated that phase one included the half pipe
and grind rail for $15,000, phase two included other pieces for the same money, and currently
phase three includes the fence, landscaping, and the $12,000 metal shelter. Hoffman maintained
that the return on the dollar spent at the park has been phenomenal, with greater use.seen here
than any other park.
Hoffman indicated that he had seen no decline in usage at the park and credited its location
between the fire station and city hall for helping to monitor the use. When asked about a bike
park, Hoffman stated that the City was giving consideration to converting a rink near the
recreational center to a bike track. He suggested the City contact Playworld Systems in Chaska
for their equipment needs and pointed out that the life expectancy of the equipment was less than
10 years. Hoffman further suggested the City talk to his public works department about a new
granular product they use in their trash cans to deter the bee problem.
.
PARK COMMISSION PARK TOURS
JULY 8, 2003
Page 3 of3
Commissioner Gilbertson arrived at 7:55 P.M.
Upon returning to the bus, Commissioners acmowledged the usefulness of the cement benches
and metal shelter as potential elements to be considered for the Shorewood Skate Park. It was
noted that the Chanhassen Skate Park was littered and in need of maintenance.
7. CHANHASSEN LAKE ANN PARK
.
Chanhassen Park and Recreation Director Hoffman accompanied the Commission on its visit to
the Lake Ann Park facilities. He gave a brief history of the 102 acre park, explaining that the first
portion of the park was purchased back in 1969 for $6,000 with a vision that encompassed the
entire area as part of the Master Plan. The west portion was later purchased in the 70's for about
$10,000. an acre and includes 40 acres of beautiful woods, which by today's standards would be
worth more than $40,000,000. Hoffman pointed out that the park has 3lit ball fields (thanks to a
$100,000 donation from the Lions), 3 unlit fields, full size and youth size softball fields, and 3
full size soccer fields. He noted that the Chanhassen Athletic Association donated a set of batting
cages for their use.
With regard to scheduling, Hoffman explained that the Chanhassen Park Rec department
schedules the field use in cooperation with the sports organizations at a meeting to negotiate
space. The most recent trends he noticed were that the diamond sports participation numbers
were decreasing dramatically, as well as, adult softball, and soccer from a highpoint not so long
ago. He pointed out that they have recently begun to offer Lacrosse at Vandemeer Park.
Similar to other communities, Hoffman indicated that the park and rec department has been
encouraged to increase revenues and decrease costs via raising rates for the rec center and cutting
labor and maintenance costs. He added that the front half of the park could always be changed to
a water park if interest in ball dropped off significantly.
8. SEDGE MEADOW AND OAK SAVANNA AT U OF M ARBORETUM
.
Commissioner Davis led the group into the Sedge meadow at the Arboretum explaining that the
25 acre, 50 year experiment, was a work in progress to restore what was once a farm to its natural
state. She pointed out that the arboretum acquired the land in 1995 with lottery money, and has
since obtained numerous grants to plant from seed, as well as, starter plants the native vegetation
seen today.
While drawing a comparison to Freeman park wetland area, Davis believed the effort to restore
the wetland and provide cleaner water could be accomplished using a similar small scale ponding
system to that of the arboretum's.
9. ADJOURNMENT
The tours adjourned at 9:20 P.M.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Kristi B. Anderson
RECORDING SECRETARY
....
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, JULY 1, 2003
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
~\\~~"\
CALL TO ORDER
Vice Chair Pisula called the meeting to order at 7:03 P.M.
ROLL CALL
.
Present:
Vice Chair Pisula; Commissioners, Gagne, Packard, White (arrived 7:04 P.M.), and
Woodruff; Council Liaison Zerby, and Planning Director Nielsen
Absent:
Chair Bailey and Commissioner Borkon
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
· June 3, 2003
Gagne moved, Woodruff seconded, Approving the June 3, 2003, Planning Commission Meeting
Minutes as amended on Page 9, Item 6, Sentence 1, change "examined" to "continued." Motion
passed 4/0/1, with Packard abstaining due to absence at that meeting.
1. FINDINGS OF FACT - L-R DISTRICT AND c.u.P. AMENDMENTS - SHOREWOOD
YACHT CLUB
Director Nielsen reviewed a previous motion made by the Planning Commission at the June 3, 2003,
Planning Commission Meeting regarding the applicant's request for an amendment to the provisions set
forth in the L-R zoning district that restricted multiple dock facilities in Gideon's Bay to sailboats only.
He then went on to briefly review the history of the case regarding this request. Director Nielsen then
reviewed the findings of fact associated with this case for the Commission.
Commissioner Woodruff commented she had reviewed findings from the Minnehaha Creek Watershed
District regarding high phosphate levels in Gideon's Bay as a result of the historic use associated with a
sewage treatment plant in the area near the Shorewood Yacht Club.
Vice Chair Pisula stated he would like to request a "Conclusion C." be added to the Findings of Fact as
follows:
C. The Planning Commission recommends the Applicant's request for an amendment to
its Conditional Use Permit be denied, since the applicant failed to demonstrate a
compelling public purpose for changing an agreement freely entered into three years
prior to this request, and the justification presented appeared to be economic in
nature.
Vice Chair recognized the applicant's desire to speak and allowed further testimony in this case.
John Cross, representing Minnetonka Moorings, Inc., located at 600 West Lake Street, stated he had
contacted Mr. Bob Keiser, Vice President of American Engineering Testing, Inc., located on Cleveland
Avenue in St. Paul, Minnesota, to request testing be conducted on the soil content of the lake floor near
"..
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
July 1, 2003
Page 2 of5
the Shorewood Yacht Club. Mr. Keiser was present this evening to present his findings of this study to
the Commission.
Mr. Keiser stated heJ1ad more than thirty years experience in working with water quality issues and soil
cleanup projects. :Mr. ~il)er stated he"had taken samples off the lake bottom at the end of each of the
four piers located at the sUbj~ct< Pl'ppertx and had sampled in two different places on the fourth pier
located on the westernmost side of the property. He noted these samples were obtained with a hand outer
core sampling device operated in approximately 8 feet of water and shallower depth closer to shore
collected at 0 to 10 inches below the surface of the lake bottom. He then reviewed the testing procedure
and metallurgy that could be identified as part of this testing. He stated there was not a great deal of lake
sediment data available, but he had compared the findings to a Minnesota Pollution Control Agency
(MPCA) report from March, 1996.
According to his research, his findings indicated the metals found were consistent with those identified in
the MPCA study. The single aspect found to be significantly different included the total phosphorus
findings detailed in the MPCA report as being 1000 milligrams per kilogram and the Shorewood Yacht .
Club findings were listed as 100 milligrams per kilogram, thus there was little concern necessary for
phosphates in the sediment in the water near the Shorewood Yacht Club. He also commented total
sediment did not demonstrate any correlation with poor quality. He went on to comment the phosphorus
available to algae could only occur in certain soluble phases.
Mr. Keiser stated he had spoken with John Barton of the Three Rivers Park District regarding a report
released in 1999 regarding the stratification of lakes that stated phosphorus would be located naturally at
the bottom of the lake stratification, and would be distributed through the water column in an event such a
storm. He also summarized data from 2001 which noted that phosphate would most likely be discharged
into water as it passed through treatment plants unless tertiary treatment had taken place. He stated it was
thus considered likely that no phosphorus had been distributed near the Shorewood Yacht Club, but more
realistically distributed throughout the lake area near the plant.
Judy Cross, applicant, stated attempts had been made to address concerns heard in the Public Hearing on
this matter. She stated the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District (LMCD) map shared with
Commissioners indicated the speed in the area as being 5 miles per hour, and requested the help of the .
Planning Commission, Council, and neighbors to sign a petition regarding the designation of a No Wake
Zone in the area utilized by the Shorewood Yacht Club. She noted there had not been any reports or
complaints received by the Hennepin County Sheriffs Department Water Patrol regarding activity at this
location, and noted the dredging company did not object to this change in designation, and she could not
imagine residents of Timber Lane would object either.
Mr. Cross presented an aerial photo of the area from 1945, and reviewed history of the area of the
Shorewood Yacht Club. He stated the LMCD had been designated by the State to study matters on the
lake, and he believed it would be most appropriate for the LMCD to decide the designation on this matter.
Mrs. Cross stated she thought Items 1-4 listed in the Findings of Fact Conclusion Section Item A were
ambiguous and subjective. Mr. Cross stated he was not sure why this issue was posing a problem, as
other uses near the Shorewood Yacht Club were more intensive. He also stated the Shorewood Yacht
Club had worked hard to be good neighbors and provide a necessary business to the lakeshore residents.
Mrs. Cross expressed concern for a gap in the minutes from the June 3, 2003 Planning Commission
Meeting as the recording machine was not working properly.
Vice Chair Pisula stated that was not the case, as the recording secretary was taking notes this evening in
the same way the recording secretary had done at the last meeting, including the use of a recording
...
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
July 1,2003
Page 3 of5
machine and scripting of notes as the meeting transpired. He stated the Commission had reviewed the
minutes previously in this evening's meeting and found them to be in order and accepted them as
accurate. He requested Mrs. Cross share the perceived missing information with the Commission.
Director Nielsen stated the use of the recording machine was not required by law, but was utilized as a
tool by the recording secretaries for the transcription of minutes.
Vice Chair Pisula then requested any additional comment by the Commission, and thanked the Crosses
for sharing information with the Commission this evening regarding the case.
Commissioner Gagne stated he was pleased the quality of Lake Minnetonka was better than anticipated in
this case.
.
Commissioner Woodruff stated she had heard no evidence to change her mind in this matter. She stated
she remained concerned for the phosphorus in the sediment at the lake bottom as it would be impossible
for power boats not to disturb it much the same way storm wave action would as boats moved through the
area.
Commissioner Packard stated, while she was absent at the June 3, 2003, Planning Commission Meeting,
she did not see a reason for amending the Conditional Use Permit at this time as she did not think it would
benefit the environment and there was not a compelling reason for change.
Commissioner Gagne agreed, noting he thought the request was economic in nature, and there was no
need to change an agreement entered into with the applicant only three years prior.
Commissioner White stated she was curious whether the testing would prove the same fmdings had
samples been taken closer to the island. She did not see a reason to change as the phosphates were clearly
in the water, and the powerboats would stir it up.
.
Woodruff moved, Gagne seconded, Recommending Acceptance of the Findings of Fact for the L-R
District and C. U.P. amendments for the Shorewood Yacht Club, with the inclusion of Conclusion C.
as:
C. The Planning Commission recommends the Applicant's request for an amendment
to its Conditional Use Permit be denied, since the applicant failed to demonstrate a
compelling public purpose for changing an agreement freely entered into three
years prior to this request, and the justification presented appeared to be economic
in nature.
into the Findings of Fact for this matter. Motion passed 5/0.
Vice Chair Pisula noted this case would appear on the July 14, 2003, Regular City Council Meeting
Agenda.
2. 7:00 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - REVISIONS TO SECTION 1201.03 SUBD. 2.f. (FENCE
REGULATIONS)
Vice Chair Pisula opened the Public Hearing at 7:40 P.M., noting the procedures utilized in a Public
Hearing.
Director Nielsen explained revisions were need to Section 1201.03 of the City Zoning Code that governed
fencing regulations. He stated clarification was needed with regard to Subd.2.f. to allow fence caps and
posts to extend beyond the previously designated maximum height of fencing since many manufacturers
..
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
July 1, 2003
Page 4of5
and installations resulted in posts that extended over the top of the plane of the fence. Staff recommended
the following amendment for consideration.
"(12) Fence Height: The height of fences prescribed herein shall be considered to be the
maximum height allowed. Fence posts may extend above the specified height b no more than eight inches
(8 "). "
Director Nielsen also explained Section 1201.03, Subd.2.f.(7) had as its primary intent, the safety of small
children and occasional stray pets from falling into unattended swimming pools. He noted clarification
was needed regarding the need for a self-closing gate and screening. Setback issues regarding
aboveground swimming pools also were in need of clarification due to concerns for the ultimate height of
the structure. Subd.3c.(6) could be modified as followed:
"(6) The minimum rear year setback for swimming pools shall be sixty percent (60%) of that
which is required for the zoning district in which the pool is located. No oart of anv such 0001. including
guardrails. shall exceed six feet (6') above grade in height. Decking. patios. and oools aprons shall not .
encroach into the required rear vard setback area. Rear yard setbacks for lakeshore lots shall be as
provided in Section 1201.26 of this Ordinance."
Commissioners Gagne, Pisula, and Woodruff stated they liked the idea of having a fence remain around
the pool area.
Gagne moved, Packard seconded, Recommending Approval of the Fence Ordinance Amendment
Regarding Height and Aboveground Pool Setbacks as proposed. Motion passed 5/0.
3. DISCUSS PLANNING COMMISSION LIAISON TO CITY COUNCIL ROTATION
The Liaison schedule for Commission Liaison to City Council was established as follows:
July
August
September
October
November
December
Commissioner Gagne
Commissioner White
Commissioner Pisula
Commissioner Woodruff
Commissioner Borkon
Commissioner Packard
.
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
The Commission requested information on the potential for milfoil compost, a trail on Lake Linden, and
the "Opt Out" plan for the City.
5. DRAFT NEXT MEETING AGENDA
Director Nielsen noted issues regarding the Sign Ordinance Amendment, Review of Lake Uses
(Recreational Equipment), and review of the City's Dog Ordinance were slated for the July 15, 2003,
Planning Commission Agenda.
..
.
.
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
July 1,2003
Page 5 of5
6. REPORTS
· Liaison to Council
Council Liaison Zerby reported on matters considered and actions taken at the June 23, 2003, Regular
City Council Meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting).
· SLUC
Commissioner Woodruff reported on the Sensitive Lane Use Coalition meeting regarding NPDES Phase
II Stormwater Management Plan.
· Other
Commissioners reported concern for a property on County Road 19 where dogwood trees were dying and
landscaping had not yet been completed.
7. ADJOURNMENT
Gagne moved, Packard seconded, Adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of July 1, 2003, at
8:37 P.M. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULLYSUBMUTTED.
Sally Keefe
Recording Secretary
..
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, 3 JUNE 2003
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Vice-Chair Pisula called the meeting to order at 7:07 P.M.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Vice-Chair Pisula; Commissioners Gagne, White, and Woodruff, late arrivals
Chair Bailey and Commissioner Borkon; Planning Director Nielsen and Council
Liaison Lizee
Absent:
Commissioner Packard
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
. May 20, 2003
Gagne moved, White seconded, Approving the May 20, 2003 Planning Commission
Minutes as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
1. 7:00 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - CU.P. FOR ACCESSORY SPACE OVER 1200 S.F.
Applicant: Todd Hermann
Location: 5915 Mton Road
Vice-Chair Pisula opened the Public Hearing at 7:08 P.M., noting the procedures utilized in a Public
Hearing and reviewing the criteria for granting C.D.P. 's.
Nielsen explained that the applicant, Mr. Todd Hermann, had applied for a conditional use permit to
construct accessory space in excess of 1200 square feet on the property located at 5915 Afton
Road. Mr. Hermann was proposing to build a new detached garage to the north and east of the
house. Since the area of the garage, combined with a small utility shed on the site and an
existing attached garage, exceeds 1200 square feet, a C.D.P. was required.
Nielsen reported that the property is zoned R-1A, Single-Family Residential and contains 42,092
square feet in area. The new garage contains 720 square feet. Combined with the utility shed
and the existing garage, the amount of accessory space on the site will total 1538 square feet.
The proposed garage will be 50 feet from the rear (east) lot line and approximately 27 feet from
the northerly lot line. Nielsen added that the existing home contains 1560 square feet offioor
area in one and one half stories.
With regard to Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.d.(4) of the Zoning Code prescribing criteria for granting
conditional use permits for accessory space over 1200 square feet, Nielsen explained how the
applicant's plans comply with the Code:
..
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 2 of 10
a. The total area of accessory buildings (1538 square feet) does not exceed the proposed
floor area (1560 square feet) above grade ofthe existing home.
b. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed 10 percent of the minimum lot size
for the R-IA zoning district (.10 x 40,000 = 4000 square feet).
c. The proposed garage complies with R-IA setback requirements. The total area of
impervious surface on the property will be only nine percent. Nielsen felt it was worth
noting that the applicant does not propose to construct a driveway to the new building, as
it will be used primarily for storing his boat, and for workshop space. Since the structure
will be tucked into some rather large evergreen trees, no additional landscaping is
considered necessary.
Nielsen pointed out that the garage was placed on the site in this location in order to avoid a
rather significant drainage swale that extends through the middle of the site.
.
d. The architectural character of the new building will be the same as the existing house.
Siding and roofing will match the house.
Based upon the preceding analysis, Nielsen stated that staff would recommend that the
applicant's request for a conditional use permit be granted, subject only to the standard warning
that such structures are for residential use only, and that any type of home occupation conducted
within an accessory building must obtain a separate permit.
Mr. Hermann had nothing to add.
Woodruff moved, White seconded, recommending approval of the C.U.P for Accessory
Space in Excess of 1200 Square Feet for the property located at 5915 Afton Road. Motion
passed 4/0.
Woodruff moved, White seconded, to revise the Agenda, moving item three before item two.
Motion passed 4/0.
.
2. SIMPLE SUBDIVISION
Applicant: Dewey Carter
Location: 5655 Fairway Drive
Nielsen explained that, Mr. Dewey Carter, representing Tradewinds Concepts and Design, has
requested a minor subdivision of the property located at 5655 Fairway Drive. The property is a
vacant lot that is part of the Country Club Meadows plat containing 86,515 square feet of area
and is zoned R -1 C, Single-family residential.
Nielsen indicated that the applicant proposes to divide the property into two parcels, as was
originally platted, however, when the final plat of Country Club Meadows was approved, the
developer chose to combine the two parcels in order to avoid having to establish a homeowner's
association to own and maintain the southerly parcel. The southerly parcel, previously platted as
an outlot, is predominantly wetland and ponding area for Country Club Meadows.
Planning Conunission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 3 of 10
Nielsen explained that the reason for putting it back to two parcels is that when it was combined,
the required setbacks, by definition, changed to make the northerly parcel unbuildable. Rather
than apply for a variance, the applicant has chosen to separate the parcels
With regard to the recommendation, Nielsen stated that staff would recommend the division be
approved. He pointed out that the application was very much a "housekeeping" measure that
should have been caught in the original platting of the property and reminded the Commission
that no buildable area exists on Parcel B. As such, Nielsen recommended that the applicant's
attorney prepare protective covenants for both parcels containing the following provisions:
1. The parcels shall not be conveyed separately from one another.
2. Parcel B shall not be built upon.
3. The owner of Parcel A shall remain responsible for the maintenance and taxes for
Parcel B.
.
Mr. Carter had no further comments.
The Commission was comfortable with the proposal.
White moved, Gagne seconded, to recommend approval of the Minor Subdivision for the
property located at 5655 Fairway Drive, subject to staff recommendations. Motion passed
4/0.
Nielsen stated that this, and other resolutions, would likely appear on the City Council's June 9,
2003 agenda.
Upon receiving the paperwork and wording from Nielsen, Mr. Carter indicated that he would
have their attorney handle the required documentation.
.
Chair Bailey and Commissioner Borkon arrived at 7:22 P.M.
3. 7:15 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - ZONING ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT TO
L-R DISTRICT/C.U.P. AMENDMENT FOR SHOREWOOD YACHT CLUB.
Avvlicant: John and Judy Cross, Minnetonka Moorings, Inc.
Location: 600 West Lake Street
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 7:22 P.M., reiterating the procedures utilized in a
Public Hearing.
Nielsen explained that he had received quite a bit of response from neighbors with regard to this
application over the past week and had distributed copies of those contacts to the Commission
for review.
Nielsen explained that Mr. John Cross, representing the Shorewood Yacht Club (SYC), located
at 600 West Lake Street, had requested an amendment to the provisions set forth in the L-R
zoning district that restrict multiple dock facilities in Gideon's Bay to sailboats only. He also
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 4 of 10
was requesting that a similar requirement contained in his present conditional use permit, be
amended as well.
SYC was rezoned nearly three years ago to be included in the L-R, Lakeshore Recreational
zoning district, and was granted a conditional use permit to operate a multiple dock facility.
Although Nielsen noted that there was considerable background associated with those previous
actions, they would not be reiterated this evening, rather, the resolution, staff reports, and
minutes from related meetings were included for the Commission's review.
With regard to the current requirements, Nielsen stated that the SYC operates under a conditional
use permit, pursuant to Section 1201.24 of the Shorewood City Code. Section 1201.24 Subd.
10.d., which states:
"d. Issuance of a license shall take into consideration the historic use of the site under
consideration with respect to the use of power boats. With the exception of power boats .
necessary for the operation of the facility, water harboring of boats on any site located in
Gideon's Bay shall be limited to sailing boats only. "
Nielsen continued, stating that the conditional use permit contained the following references to
sailing boats:
Pg.3 "1. That based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby grants the
Applicant's request for a conditional use permit for a sailing yacht club at 600
West Lake Street. " (emphasis added)
"2. c. The permit shall be limited to the docking of sailboats. except for three
power boats used by the management of the Yacht Club. In addition, the dock
located at the westernmost end of the subject property shall be limited to one boat
owned by the residents of 5585 Timber Lane. Weed harvesting equipment shall .
not count against the allowable number of power boats." (emphasis added)
Since a number of restrictions accompanied the latest Resolution, the applicant was requesting a
language change in order to allow him to house powerboats. Nielsen pointed out that these were
the provisions that the applicant proposed to change, which would eliminate any distinction
between power boats and sailboats.
Section 1201.04 Subd. I.d.(l) ofthe Zoning Code sets forth the factors to be considered in
evaluating zoning text amendments and conditional uses:
"(1) The Planning Commission shall consider possible adverse effects of the
proposed amendment or conditional use. Its judgment shall be based upon (but not
limited to) thefollowingfactors:
(a) The proposed action has been considered in relation to the specific policies
and provisions of and has been found to be consistent with the official City
Comprehensive Plan.
(b) The proposed use is or will be compatible with present and future land uses of
the area.
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 5 of 10
(c) The proposed use will not tend to or actually depreciate the area in which it is
proposed.
(d) The proposed use can be accommodated with existing public services and will
not overburden the City's service capacity. "
Nielsen reported that it would be staffs recommendation that the Planning Commission and City
Council review policies set forth in the Comprehensive Plan, particularly the Natural Resource
section and the Land Use section of the Plan, in conjunction with this request.
.
Section 1201.04 Subd. 1.d.(2) goes on to say:
"(2) Upon consent of the City Council, the Planning Commission and City staff
shall have the authority to request additional information from the applicant concerning
operational factors or to retain expert testimony with the consent and at the expense of
the applicant concerning operational factors, said information to be declared necessary
to establish performance conditions in relation to all pertinent sections of this
Ordinance. "
One of the most significant concerns raised during the redrafting of the L-R District requirements
and in the review ofthe SYC conditional use permit, was the potential for environmental
disturbance. Specifically, people were concerned that power boats may stir up phosphates
suspended in the silt in Gideon's Bay from the old Excelsior sewage treatment plant, which
discharged through the SYC site. While no studies were available when the SYC application
was being considered, it was suggested that the MPCA was going to be conducting soil sampling
of various parts of the lake in the (then) near future. Nielsen noted that staff could not determine
if such a study was ever done.
.
Nielsen pointed out that the applicant's request letter mostly references an increasing demand for
power boat slips, but fails to address the market for sailboating. In discussing this with a
member of the Wayzata Yacht Club, they apparently have a waiting list of people who want
sailboat slips. In this regard the City may wish to require a market study of boat slip demand on
Lake Minnetonka.
With regard to the current zoning status, Nielsen explained that the City cited the Yacht Club last
year for operating without a license and in violation of the existing conditional use permit. The
violation was resolved in the City's favor in District Court. At this time, Nielsen stated, the SYC
has a license for 2003 and does not appear to be renting slips for power boats. There are,
however, two items which need to be addressed at this time: 1) the access to the property was to
have been "gated and locked" except for occasional maintenance; and 2) not all of the required
landscaping appears to have been installed. He felt that these matters should be resolved prior to
any official actIon being taken on the present application.
John and Judy Cross, of SYC, gave a brief history ofthe marina, explaining that over a four year
CUP process the SYC was finally built in 1979 to accommodate a need for sailboating. While
the SYC used to have a waiting list for its 125 slips, Mr. Cross explained that, in recent years,
after adding 35 more slips, the demand had declined.
Mrs. Cross pointed out that the SYC has provided many services to the community over its life
span, including, a sailing school, slips, kids camp, boat rentals, etc. She indicated that 98% of the
calls they'd received over the past two years had come from powerboat owners; whereas,
demand for sailboat rental slips had been declining. She explained that, due to the economy and
since 9/11, the discretionary spending of sailboat owners has declined. Mrs. Cross urged the
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 6 of 10
Commission to enable them to keep the SYC a viable business by allowing them to rent to
powerboat owners.
With regard to a market survey, Mr. Cross indicated that they had performed an unofficial study
of their own based on the number of contacts they received off of two newspaper and trade
journal ads. He passed out copies of the ads and stated that they received little or no calls from
the advertising. In addition, Cross stated that he contacted other marinas in the area and found
that most of them had experienced a decline in sailboat slip rentals. He distributed an LMCD
boat density study of the surrounding marinas, a 1999 Lake Minnetonka Water Quality Study
performed by Hennepin Parks, and an aerial photo of the SYC, its neighbors and bay.
Relative to the phosphates being stirred up that sit on the bottom of the bay, Mr. Cross argued
that the sailboats probably stir up the bottom even more than powerboats would due to their deep
berth and motors pushing them out of the marina. He pointed out that the Wayzata Bay Marina
was the only marina with a small sailboat wait list, due in part to their inexpensive slip rates, and
that only racers can slip there. Mr. Cross maintained that their lake access directs patrons to head
directly out straight past Frog Island and into Gideon Bay, without disturbing neighbors. He
added that their street access, off County Road 19, does little to disturb neighbors either. Mr.
Cross acknowledged that their preference would be to continue to rent to sailboats; however, he
explained that alone was not working for them.
Steve Haskins, 5455 Timber Lane, indicated that, as representative for the 9 houses along
Timber Lane, they felt the proposed changes were in an effort to revise their business plan. He
pointed out that many of the same questions Mr. Cross raised were also examined in 1979 by the
Supreme Court in its original permitting plan. Although Mr. Haskins enjoyed the SYC's
presence and agreed to allow them the additional 35 slips several years ago for more sailboats, he
and his neighbors this time around would fight any effort to allow powerboats. He pointed out
that the neighbors were the ones who informed the City of the SYC's C.U.P violations and
number of powerboats last year.
In addition, Mr. Haskins stated that, with the water level at 1.8', there would be no question that
powerboats would chum up sediment and phosphates at the bottom. He pointed out that Frog
Island itself would be in danger of falling back into the lake due to erosion if more and more
powerboats were allowed to access the lake from the SYC. He explained that, in 1953, Frog
Island was elevated to 8-10' above water level and the boy scouts went to great lengths to plant
trees on the island. Since 1953, because the LMCD and Watershed has done little to preserve it,
the island has been eroding and is in danger of being lost.
Mr. Haskins urged the Commission to deny the C.U.P., adding that his business, too, had
suffered great losses since 9/11; however, the City did not see him asking for help in revising his
business plan.
Nick Reuhl, 456 LaFayette Avenue, stated that, as a resident of the peninsula, he supported the
original C.U.P for sailboats, not powerboats or a gas station, in 1975. In the early years, Mr.
Reuhl indicated that he had written numerous letters to the City and Mr. Cross regarding their
marina, and believed them to be a good neighbor for many years. In March of 1999, Reuhl
.
.
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 7 of 10
stated that, once again, he supported the addition of 35 sailboat slips, and read a letter from that
time.
Over the past 2-3 years; however, Mr. Reuhl stated that things had changed and issues had come
out which upset and bewildered him, including the change in use ofthe marina facility by the
Cross', even after being reassured by the Cross' over the years that this would not happen.
Reuhl, too, stated that his business had been down since 9/11, and indicated that he had no plans
to approach the City to ask to be rezoned. He believed the addition of 125 powerboats would be
a disaster for the neighborhood and encouraged the Commission to deny the expansion.
.
Harry Ryan, 430 Lafayette Avenue, echoed the comments of the two previous residents and
emphasized his concern with regard to the negative impacts the stirring up of the phosphates
would have on the lake. He argued that the impacts felt by a 250 horsepower motorboat would
far outweigh those of a 5 horsepower motor guiding sailboats to the bay. He stated that, to his
knowledge, financial hardship alone was not grounds for granting a variance or C.U.P request.
While he loved the sailboats at SYC, he indicated that powerboats would altogether give a
different feel to the neighborhood, and be detrimental to property values.
Chris Maller, 446 Lafayette Avenue, in addition to the earlier comments, she stated that,
although she enjoyed the atmosphere provided by the sailboats at SYC, she was concerned most
about the safety of children in the area who swim and play to and from Frog Island if powerboats
were allowed to race out of the marina.
Marjorie Yaeger, 5445 Timber Lane, indicated that, indeed, Mr. Haskins was speaking for the
residents of Timber Lane.
.
James Hancock, 23800 Lawtonka Drive, as a member of the Yacht Club, he felt the SYC had
been a good neighbor and needed to be allowed the ability to remain viable by bringing in more
powerboats. He stated that the SYC did an excellent job of enforcing the quiet hours from
10PM-8AM and would impose fines for excessive noise.
Ben Faust, 452 Lafayette Avenue, stated that, having lived at this address for 55 years, he
believed the sailboats had added a pleasant New England feel to the neighborhood. He was
against the addition of the powerboats for this, and earlier reasons mentioned.
Cindy Faust, Ben Faust's daughter, stated that having grown up on the water here, she was
frightened for the safety of the children by what the additional powerboats might cause.
Dorothy James, 450 Lafayette Avenue, disagreed with Mr. Cross, stating that the powerboats
and sailboats do cruise by Lafayette.
Steve Haskins added to his original comments, asserting that it was the business decision to add
35 more slips that had caused the Cross' this difficulty.
Mr. Cross maintained that the original Supreme Court case recognized that the residents of the
area did not wish to see anything, sailing or powerboats, in this area of Shorewood. He indicated
.
Planning COrnnllssion Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 8 of 10
that they do encourage their patrons to avoid cruising past LaFayette, adding that he believed the
area should be changed to a no wake zone altogether.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 8:17 P.M.
Woodruff indicated that she was present when the Commission granted the initial C.U.P
changing the lakeshore district to the L-R zone, she pointed out that she objected to it then, and
would so now again. She stated that her concern continues to be environmental. With regard to
the clarity of the bay, she stated that the water is filtered as it passes through the upper bays
traveling downward. She was hesitant to allow the SYC to stir up the phosphates present near the
marina since there would be little way to filter the water.
Borkon stated that she, too, echoed Woodruffs thoughts and believed the Commission had been
through this process back and forth in an effort to examine the applicant's request. She was
concerned how the addition of powerboats would impact the lakeshore.
.
Pisula stated that he had not heard anything with regard to the how the public purpose would
support this change. In fact, Pisula maintained he had heard more evidence against turning the
marina over to powerboats than that supporting their request for changing the public purpose. He
felt it was inappropriate for the Cross' and SYC to come back to the Commission merely three
years after helping shape the very rules they wished to see changed because they may have made
a poor business decision.
Gagne agreed with the comments made by the other Commissioners, adding that, in his many
years with the City, he had learned that a Commissioner should never make a decision based
solely on economic conditions.
As a sailing enthusiast, White stated that the SYC is a desirable location for Minneapolis
powerboat or sailboat owners, since their marina is the most conveniently located to the City. .
Although it did not help their case, White complimented the Cross' on providing the
Commission with the aerial photo which easily shows the shallow areas surrounding Frog Island.
Chair Bailey agreed with the Commission's comments, stating that, he too, approved the L-R
zoning change in 2000. Today, however, Chair Bailey indicated he would not support changing
the code once again and upsetting the covenant or balance that exists between the SYC, its
neighbors, and the City.
Borkon moved, Gagne seconded, to deny the Shorewood Yacht Club request for an
Amendment to the Provisions set forth in the L-R zoning district that restricts the number
of multiple dock facilities in Gideon's Bay to sailboats only. Motion passed 6/0.
Nielsen indicated that he would compile a findings-of-facts to be presented at the next Planning
Commission meeting.
Borkon moved, Gagne seconded, to deny the Shorewood Yacht Clubs request to revise
their C.U.P to reflect the proposed amendment change based on the findings-of-fact.
Motion passed 6/0.
'.
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 9 of 10
Recess taken from 8:29 - 8:35 P.M.
3. Discussed before item #2.
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were none.
5. DRAFT NEXT MEETING AGENDA
.
Nielsen indicated that the next Planning Commission Meeting would be a Work Session
scheduled for June 17,2003. He stated that items for the agenda would include the findings of
fact from the Shorewood Yacht Club discussion this evening, an additional element from the
recreational lake use discussion of the last work session, above-ground pool fencing regulations,
and one other 'planners choice' item.
6. REPORTS
· Liaison to Council
Woodruff reported that the Council continued the variance request for the Edgewood property
and approved the three accessory use applications from the last meeting. She stated that
Hennepin County Commissioner Linda Koblick also spoke to the Council with regard to the
County Road 19 intersection assuring the Council that the project would be completed at 'some
point' .
· SLUC
. Nielsen encouraged Commissioners to contact him by mid June if they wished to attend the
SLUC meeting of July 30, 2003, titled Stormwater; Are we all Wet Yet?, A look from the storm
clouds at Water Regulatory Issues.
· Other
Gagne pointed out that the Blue two-story at Eureka RoadlSmithtown Road was demolished and
removed. In addition, Gagne questioned the status of the Cub Foods Lake Linden trail
construction, reminding the Commission that the group, technically, has just 90 days to complete
the trail and landscaping before the intended store opening. He asked if the store opening would
be held up if the trail and landscaping weren't complete.
Nielsen stated that the Cub Foods developer was required to complete the trail and landscaping
before the store opening. He indicated that it would be in their best interest to complete these
things, so as not to hold up the grand opening. Nielsen added that the Cub Foods development
has agreed to hook up to City water.
.f!..,
Planning Commission Meeting
June 3, 2003
Page 10 ofl0
..
Lizee reported that during the recent City Council meeting, they reviewed bids for the
Smithtown Road reclamation project, after a delay due to a misprint by the newspapers. She
indicated that she was recruiting volunteers for the 4th of July Fireworks celebration, including
parking attendants, people to man information booths, etc. She stated that she would send out a
blanket memo to everyone requesting assistance.
With regard to the reclamation project, White suggested Nielsen relay to Brown the suggestion
that they complete the middle phase, near Minnewashta School, prior to either outer edge, in
order to avoid any conflicts with the start of school in the fall.
7. ADJOU~ENT
White moved, Borkon seconded, Adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of June 3,
2003, at 8:50 P.M. Motion passed 6/0.
RESPECTFULLYSUBNUTTED.
.
Kristi B. Anderson
Recording Secretary
.
"
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, 6 MAY 2003
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Bailey called the meeting to order at 7:08 P.M.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Chair Bailey; Commissioners Gagne, Borkon, White, Pisula, and Woodruff; Planning
Director Nielsen and Council Liaison Lizee
Absent:
Commissioner Packard
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
. April 15, 2003
Gagne moved, Pisula seconded, Approving the April 15, 2003 Planning Commission Minutes as
presented. Motion passed 6/0.
1. 7:00 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - SETBACK VARIANCE
Applicant: John O'Donnell
Location: 27100 Edgewood Road
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 7:08 P.M., noting the procedures utilized in a Public Hearing
and reviewing the criteria for granting variances.
Nielsen reported that the applicant, Mr. John O'Donnell had requested variances to enlarge his home and
build a new garage at 27100 Edgewood Road. The property is located in the R-1A1S, Single Family
Residential/Shoreland zoning district and contains only 12,141 square feet of area.
As explained in his request letter, Mr. O'Donnell proposes to raise the existing home approximately seven
feet, converting what is currently crawl space into habitable space. He also proposes to demolish the
existing detached garage and attach a new garage to the home, adding a second level above the new
garage. Nielsen noted that access to the new garage would necessitate extending the driveway
approximately 36 feet further into the lot.
Nielsen pointed out that the subject property is substantially nonconforming with several of the R-1A1S
zoning requirements. As mentioned above, the lot area is only 12,141 square feet, whereas 40,000 is
required. The lot is only 40 feet wide instead of the 100 feet required by the Zoning Code. The side yard
setbacks for the R-1A1S zoning district are a total of30 feet with no one side being less than 10 feet. At
present the existing home is less than one foot from the west property line and three feet from the east lot
line (not including a small deck on that side of the house. Nielsen explained that the impervious surface
on the property amounts to 41 percent, while 25 percent is the maximum allowed in the Shoreland overlay
district.
Nielsen stated that it was worth noting that the previous owner of the home was granted two variances in
1986 to build the existing two-car garage and to add a second level to the house.
Planning Commission Meeting
.' May 6, 2003
Page 2 of 13
With regard to issues and analysis, Nielsen stated that most zoning ordinances contain provisions that
address nonconforming structures. These are structures that were built before current regulations were in
place. Shorewood's original zoning requirements simply prohibited the expansion of nonconforming
structures, for example, they were not allowed to be expanded or extended in any fashion. In the mid
80's, the City relaxed these provisions for single-family dwellings. Nonconforming, single-family
dwellings were allowed to be enlarged or extended, provided that the new construction complied with
zoning requirements. This included upward expansion as well as outward expansion.
Nielsen maintained that the applicant's request involved expansion of the nonconformity of the property
in several ways. The entire house would be raised approximately seven feet to accommodate a new third
level of living space. Which, Nielsen explained, brings up the question of floor elevation. If the addition
of the raised lower level extends from the ground over 6', it would be considered a full third story of
living space, thus requiring another variance to the 2 Yz story height restriction.
.
In addition, in order to accommodate the proposed expansion of the home, the applicant has requested
variances from the requirements of the Zoning Code. Specifically, the new garage and the second story
above it require a variance of 15.2 feet on the east side of the lot. Instead of a total side yard setback of
30 feet, the total will be 14.8 feet.
Although the drainage issue deserves some discussion, Nielsen pointed out that this issue was not raised
in the previous request. Both the Building Official and the City Engineer have looked at this property and
agree that the problem is more of a landscaping issue at best, an engineering problem at worst. Without
addressing it as such, relocating the garage may simply relocate the problem area as well, either on the
applicant's property, or to someone else's. Drainage is not considered justification for increasing the
nonconformity of this property. If drainage is to be considered a factor in this request, it is recommended
that the applicant have the property examined by a professional civil engineer who could discuss
alternatives for resolving the problem.
.
Nielsen continued that, while the applicant indicated that impervious surface on the site will be reduced,
despite the lengthening of the driveway and the construction of the new garage, this does not appear to be
the case. The hardcover calculations prepared for the original survey do not appear to reflect the
proposed site plan. It is recommended that a very detailed breakdown of hardcover be prepared by the
applicant's consultant. For example, our review of the survey suggests that there is closer to 40 square
feet of retaining wall area, not the 400 square feet suggested by the surveyor.
Before the applicant was directed to elaborate on his plans, Nielsen urged the Commission to give serious
consideration to the issue of reasonable use. While it is not unreasonable to want 3200 square feet of
living space, not all lots can accommodate that much house. It is just as reasonable to expect that a house
of that size be place on a proportionately sized lot. The Planning Commission has stated in the past that
there is such a thing as a lot being full. Nielsen maintained that this would appear to be such a case.
Mr. O'Donnell approached the podium stating that while the central issue is his reasonable use, he wished
to focus on other parts of the application to begin with. He believed the assumption of the 'lot being full'
was an arbitrary and subjective supposition. He maintained that if he were to use a ratio of 30% floor to
lot calculations, he would be maintaining his coverage at 22%. With regard to the 1986 discussion of 'no
further expansion' permitted on the parcel, O'Donnell questioned why this language was not incorporated
into the resolution if that was the intent at that time.
O'Donnell argued that the narrowness of the lot itself was the true hardship, and by definition this meets
the State Statute hardship classification, since this is unique to the property. He believed the narrowness
was sufficient hardship to warrant approval of his application. He did not feel it was necessary to go to the
Planning Commission Meeting
May 6, 2003
Page 3 of 13
additional expense of consulting a civil engineer and maintained that his proposal reduced, or at least
sustained, hardcover levels.
With regard to the objections posed by Mrs. Lovrien and her attorneys, O'Donnell maintained that his
home was not out of character of its locality nor would it obstruct neighboring views of the lake. He
stated that the majority of his neighbors support his request and have signed a petition to that affect. He
indicated that his wish to provide maximum living space for his family would not cause unreasonable
interference to Mrs. Lovrien enjoyment of her property.
George Lovrien, son and representative of Mrs. Lovrien, stated that her 20' parcel of the lake is very
important to her and that they do not wish to see the O'Donnell's infringing on her reasonable use. He
indicated that, currently, it is almost impossible to walk around the O'Donnell home without trespassing
or stepping on adjacent properties. It was their belief that the proposed home was just too much house for
the narrow lot and would be an even larger presence 4.8' from the property line. Mr. Lovrien felt the
construction alone would damage the surrounding areas due to the proximity of adjacent properties.
.
Mark Nesset, Architect for the 0 'Donnell's, stated that raising the roof would not require any additional
excavation. Since crawl space exists, additional wall space would be added to raise the height of the lower
level. He pointed out that others in the area could do the same and the trend in Lake Minnetonka is to
build up and, potentially, out, similar to homes in Mound. By attaching the garage, he believed the
impact of the total residence is decreased. In addition, the use of stone around the lower level would
create the illusion of a smaller scale cottage.
Dave Layton, 27150 Edgewood Road, adjacent neighbor to the Nelson's, stated that, while they are
fortunate to have a larger lot for the neighborhood, the variety of homes varies. With regard to the issue
of hardship, he questioned if Mrs. Lovrien was really being hurt by this development. In fact, he argued
that he and the Nelson's believed the improvement would benefit their properties as well. He felt these
issues would continue to come up as Shorewood lake shore is redeveloped and asked what could be done
to reasonably consider O'Donnell's request.
.
Paul Nelson, 27120 Edgewood Road., voiced his support for the project and desire to keep good
neighbors in Shorewood. Having worked in commercial construction, Mr. Nelson believed there was
much that could be done to limit the impacts on neighbors during construction.
Kelly Snodgrass, 27135 Edgewood Road, pointed out that the project would vastly improve the aesthetics
of the home and reminded the Commission that many of the homes in the area would be redone in
upcoming years. She rejected Mrs. Lovrien's concern of interference with her reasonable use.
Mr. O'Donnell added that, based on recent approvals he'd obtained on similar properties across the
community, he believed that his hardcover figures were in line with those he'd compared.
Nesset pointed out that Mound allows residents up to 40% hardcover allowances.
Mrs. O'Donnell explained that the road elevation is higher than at the lake; therefore, the sight elevations
for Mrs. Lovrien would be higher.
Mike Newberg, 26045 Birch Bluff Road, indicated that neighbors are never happy to see construction or
progress moving in next door, however, City's do grow. He believed, in this area oflake cabins, the City
may be forced to give a little bit.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony at 7:48 P.M.
Planning Commission Meeting
May 6, 2003
Page 4 of 13
White asked why the language stating that no additional variances be granted this property did not make it
into the resolution.
Nielsen stated that this type of language cannot be included in the resolution, since it is the right of any
resident to make an application. Also, Nielsen indicated that it would be difficult to tie the hands of future
City Councils in this way.
Gagne stated that, in 1986, the City went thru this process with the applicant and made the house usable,
which it has continued to be since that date. He agreed that it was difficult to traverse around the
applicant's property without stepping on neighboring properties. He could not support the application and
felt it would make the situation worse. He likened the request to putting' 50 pounds in a 10 pound bag' .
Gagne added that, Mound, and other lakes communities, have different building requirements, and
pointed out the monstrosity Tonka Bay had allowed to be built along County Road 19 which is built lot
line to lot line.
.
Woodruff asked if the address file reflected any restrictions on the property when the applicants
purchased it in 1995.
Mr. O'Donnell indicated that the title search had been clean.
Pisula stated that if the issue is of reasonable use, to him, an 1800 s.f. home is reasonable for this parcel.
While the Commission recognizes that there will be continuing expansion in the Shoreland district, Pisula
stated that it is their job to take into consideration the size of the lot. He indicated that Shorewood does
not support building homes lot line to lot line. Pisula pointed out that, while the applicant's family
situation had changed since they first purchased the property, the home has been put to reasonable use for
many years. He agreed with Gagne, and could not support the application.
Chair Bailey questioned the accuracy of the impervious surface figures.
.
Nielsen indicated that the impervious surface calculation from the survey was 41 %, while he had trouble
fmding the 400 s.f. of retaining wall the applicant referred to in the existing hardcover calculations he
provided.
Chair Bailey asked what the impact of the proposed height would have on the application.
Although he had not been supplied with floor elevations, Nielsen stated that if the lower level protruded
6' above ground level it would be considered a full story.
Chair Bailey further commented that it was a new argument to him, that an applicant could consider the
undeveloped unbuildable parcel to the east as a buffer to meet one's own open space requirement.
Nielsen stated that an applicant can not use someone else's land for consideration as part of their
application to meet their own open space requirement. ill addition, Nielsen questioned whether the 20'
parcel would remain that way indefinitely. Although unbuildable as it stands, the parcel could be legally
combined at a later date.
Chair Bailey felt the reasonable use hardship did not adequately support the application. While the fact
remains that the applicant would like more space, it does not mean this home cannot be put to reasonable
use. He was not comfortable that bigger families should warrant bigger spaces or buildings. Bailey could
not support the variance requests.
Woodruff concurred.
Planning Commission Meeting
May 6, 2003
Page 5 of 13
Borkon moved, Gagne seconded, recommending denial of the setback variance request to enlarge
the home and build a new garage at 27100 Edgewood Road. Motion passed 6/0.
2. 7:10 P.M. PUBLIC BEARING C.U.P FOR ACCESSORY SPACE OVER 1200 S.F.
Applicant: Mark and Kim Welty
Location: 5330 Howard's Point Road
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 8:00 P.M., reiterating the procedures utilized in a Public
Hearing.
Since the following three applications were all requests for CUP's for Accessory Space over 1200 s.f.,
Nielsen reviewed the criteria for Conditional Use Permits for Accessory Space over 1200 s.f. one time.
.
Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.d.(4) of the Zoning Code describes four criteria for granting conditional
use permits for accessory space over 1200 square feet:
a. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed the floor area above grade of the existing
home.
b. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed 10 percent of the minimum lot size for the
zoning district
c. The proposed accessory space complies with zoning setback requirements.
d. The architectural character of the new building will be the same as the existing house. Siding and
roofing will match the house.
The criteria being said, Nielsen explained that the applicant, Mr. Mark Welty had applied for a
conditional use permit to construct accessory space in excess of 1200 square feet on the property located
at 5330 Howard's Point Road. Mr. Welty proposes to build a new detached garage to the north of the
house. Since the area of the garage, combined with an existing attached garage on the property exceeds
1200 square feet, a C.u.P. is required.
.
The property is zoned R-1A1S, Single-Family Residential/Shoreland and contains 67,801 square feet in
area. Nielsen pointed out that the site is occupied by the owner's home and attached garage, and a small
10' x 12' shed which would need to be moved to a conforming location. The new garage contains 1290
square feet. Combined with the existing garage, the amount of accessory space on the site will total 1839
square feet. The proposed garage will be on the north side of the existing home, 48-53 feet from the side
lot line, approximately 65 feet from Lake Minnetonka, and 200 feet back from Howard's Point Road.
Nielsen reported that the proposed accessory use meets the four criteria as follows:
a. The total area of accessory buildings (1839 square feet) does not exceed the floor area (3700
square feet - main floor) above grade of the existing home.
b. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed 10 percent of the minimum lot size for the
R-1A1S zoning district (.10 x 40,000 = 4000 square feet).
c. The proposed garage complies with R-1A1S setback requirements. Despite the size of the
proposed structure, it is relatively hidden from adjoining properties. A large hill and existing
vegetation buffer the new building from its nearest neighbor to the north.
Nielsen felt it was worth noting that the proposed hardcover for the site would be 24.99 percent,
including the shed, the maximum allowed in the "S", Shoreland overlay district.
d. The architectural character of the new building will be the same as the existing house. Siding and
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
23 July 2003
RE:
O'Donnell Variance /SYC Amendment - Deadlines for Action
FILE NO.:
405 (03.09 and 03.16)
Since a power outage abbreviated the 14 July Council meeting, the above-referenced
items were not acted upon. Both items require action at the next meeting in order to
comply with statutory review requirements. Consequently, there is no time for the
Council to direct staff to prepare findings of fact for subsequent action at another
meeting.
.
The draft findings for both of these items have been prepared based upon the Planning
Commission's discussion and recommendations. Please review them and be prepared
with any modifications you may have at the meeting.
If you have any questions relative to either item, please contact me prior to Monday
night's meeting.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
John O'Donnell
John Cross
ft
~., PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Rl SA +88
-';0
,
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us · cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
10 July 2003
RE:
O'Donnell- 2nd Revision Hardcover Cales
FILE NO.
405(03.09)
Mr. O'Donnell has submitted a second revision to his hardcover calculations. By
subtracting the street pavement and the land beneath it from the lot and hardcover
calculations, the new number is 33% for both the existing site and the proposed plan.
.
Also note, for your convenience, that we have copied the material that was sent to
previously. One new item is a letter - dated 8 July 2003 - from Glenn Froberg, an
attorney representing one of the adjacent neighbors.
If you have any questions relative to this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me
prior to Monday night's meeting.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
John 0 'Donnell
~
toJ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#
8,A,
,..
4 -
EXISTING HARD COVER TABULA T ION:
EXISTING HOME 1) 062 SQ. FT,
EXISTING GARAGE 450 SQ. FT,
DECKS 268 SQ. FT.
BIT, DRIVEWAY 956 SQ. FT,
RETAINING WALLS 121 SQ, FT.
ROCK BANK 363 SQ, FT.
WALKWAY 488 SQ, FT,
TOTAL HARDCOVER 3)708 SQ. FT.
PARCEL AREA 11) 122 SQ. FT.
. % COVERAGE 33%
BITUMINOUS ROAD 1)019 SQ, FT. *
* (not counted In parcel a.rea. or hard cover)
PROPOSED HARD COVER TABULATION:
.
EXISTING HOME
PROPOSED GARAGE
PROPOSED WALK
DECKS
BIT. DRIVEWAY
RETAINING WALLS
ROCK BANK
PROPOSED STEPPING
TOTAL HARDCOVER
PARCEL AREA
% COVERAGE
1) 062 SQ.
450 SQ.
104 SQ.
214 SQ.
1)422 SQ.
9 SQ.
363 SQ.
STONES 32 SQ.
3) 656 SQ.
11) 122 SQ.
33%
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT.
FT,
FT.
BITUMINOUS ROAD 1) 019 SQ. FT. *
* (not counted In pa.rcel a.rea. or ha.rd cover)
r;:;~!~~ fl_ -.~ 7=" r \", -~T~r:~:1
f, ,..,
.
'.
.,
w
12 :I: ,
"
\ "
934.3
,929.4---=-
\ f
'- ORDINARY HIGH I
WATER MARK I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
,
I
X934.6
'"
;;i
X936.0
;:::
(}O
. -......:..:.~.~:-'::. :':Siiili
944.4
I
\
\
\ .
\ L- ROCK RETAINING WALL
936.8
fl)UNO ," ,--
X
943.5
S90'00'OO"E
r 47.00
945.0
EPCErrOOIJ
ROA.lJ
.oRA IrINC NO.
030096
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
See.
htAyl,7
pcclt4.f 10,..
-J1, I' /k,,..
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
.
':e
DATE:
30 April 2003
RE:
O'Donnell, John - Setback VarianceNariance to Expand a
Nonconforming Structure
FILE NO.:
405 (03.09)
BACKGROUND
..
Mr. John O'Donnell has requested variances to enlarge his home and build a new garage
at 27100 Edgewood Road (see Site Location map - Exhibit A, attached). The property is
located in the R-INS, Single Family Residential/Shoreland zoning district and contains
only 12,141 square feet of area. As shown on Exhibit B, the subject property is occupied
by the owner' s home and a_ detached garage.
As explained in his request letter (Exhibit C), Mr. O'Donnell proposes to raise the
existing home approximately seven feet, converting what is currently crawl space into
habitable space. He also proposes to demolish the existing detached garage and attach a
new garage to the home, adding a second level above the new garage. Access to the new
garage would necessitate extending the driveway approximately 36 feet further into the
lot. Plans for the proposed expansion of the home and relocation of the garage are shown
on Exhibits D-J.
The subj ect property is substantially nonconforming with several of the R -1 NS zoning
requirements. As mentioned above, the lot area is only 12,141 square feet, whereas
40,000 is required. The lot is only 40 feet wide instead of the 120 feet required by the
Zoning Code. The side yard setbacks for the R-INS zoning district are a total of30 feet
with no one side being less than 10 feet. At present the existing home is less than one
foot from the west property line and three feet from the east lot line (not including a small
ft
t.J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#3.A.
Cl.
FILE COpy
(), i' I!A..,,, .- ;1'/
~..- ~'1!"'.:'~~;~"&'~C/~"\,..~;", .-,_~.'t
As Brad Nielson concluded in the recommendation of staff report, the primary issue with
regard to my request is whether or not the proposed changes constitute "reasonable use".
I believe they do, and I will elaborate on my reasoning in support of that belief in a few
minutes.
Before turning to the central question of Reasonable Use, I would first like to respond to
some of the comments contained in the staff report, and those submitted by Mrs. Lovrien
and her attorney, Mr. Mark Kelly.
.
Brad's recommendation states that there is such a thing as a "lot being full", and that this
is one such case. This conclusion seems rather arbitrary. How does one measure the
relative "fullness" of a lot? The only codified measurement I can find in the Shorewood
Zoning Ordinance is the maximum ratio of floor area of all structures to lot area. For
non-conforming lots, the maximum is set at 30%. By maintaining the footprint of the
existing house and garage in my proposal, I maintain the 22% ratio cited in the Staff
Report dated the August 28, 1986, still below the city requirements. Based on this
criterion, I would argue that the lot is not full.
In his staff report for the original Bergstrand variance request, Brad recommended that
the City Council resolution approving the original variance should contain language
stipulating that no further expansion of the structure should be allowed. It should be
noted City of Shorewood Resolution number 103-86 contains no such restriction,
suggesting that the Planning Commission and City Council rejected Brad's
recommendation, and leaving the door open for future expansion.
Given the position of the proposed structure on the lot and the relative position to
adjacent structures, there is ample room to accommodate the proposed design. The scale
of the structure is appropriate for the size of the lot and the surrounding community.
.
In support of my hardship case, Brad points out that some of the arguments used to
support my request are the same as those used in support of the variances granted in
1986. The City of Shore wood has acknowledged the undue hardship represented by the
narrowness of the lot in the staff report prepared in August of 1986. The report points out
that narrowness was one of the criteria specifically cited for consideration of a variance
by the state of Minnesota. The dimensions of the lot have not changed. The arguments
are still valid and the undue hardship still exists with regard to the narrowness of the lot.
Contrary to the assertions of Mr. Kelly, the hardship is due to circumstance unique to the
property, not of my creation, and the City has already found that the narrowness does
satisfy the state statutes of undue hardship.
Brad indicates that drainage is not a consideration for increasing the non-conformity of
the property. I believe that the hardship represented by the narrowness of the lot has
already been established and is sufficient for justifying the approval of the requested
variances. As such, I would ask that I not be burdened with the cost of an engineering
study to provide additional justification unless it is absolutely necessary to my case.
K.t2~C2 ~ ~~ J -fro 'f'W"'. ~u l'"'A, ~ 'r'j .~ &- "'- (f r~ ^ D' D 0 ~r"~ \ \)
6( Db'r\"'-t l \ retlJ + ~~ S tJ.t -1- h~ fu "o. ~<<J'
.#- 8.A.
'.
The comments regarding the discrepancies in the survey and hardcover calculations are
valid. After reviewing the staff report late Friday, I immediately called Jim Parker of
Advanced Survey and asked him to make the necessary additions and corrections to
prove my claim that the current level of ground cover will be maintained or reduced.
Focusing now on the comments offered by Mrs. Lovrien and her attorney, I find the
characterization of the proposal as "altering the character of the immediate locality"
particularly specious. If Mrs. Lovrien was so concerned about altering the character of
the community, she would have refrained from subdividing her lot to allow for the
development of Heritage. I cannot think of a more drastic alteration to the character of
the immediate locality than that development. Mr. Kelly refers to my plan creating a
"towering, imposing structure" which ironically, is the precise nature of Heritage. The
duplicity of Mrs. Lovrien's argument seems obvious.
.
One other point regarding the "character of the immediate locality", the area we live in is
very diverse, ranging from multi-million dollar mansions to cabins that are rented out. I
have taken photos of several homes in the 500 foot radius used for the mailing list. You
can see from the photos that it is common in the neighborhood for properties to have
three levels of living space, which is what I am attempting to do by raising my existing
house.
.
In his letter, Mr. Kelly states that the variance request constitutes an "unnecessary
encroachment on the reasonable code required side yard set back", the key word here
being reasonable. Brad stated in the May 28, 1986 staff report for the Schultz variance
request that "the increased side yard setback attempts to change the character that has
already been established, contrary to the City's expressed intent of adjusting zoning to
reflect existing development". He also urges that the City contemplate changes to the
side yard setback requirements for lakeshore lots, going as far suggesting that a 10 foot
setback would be adequate for existing construction and lots of record. It is interesting to
note that at the time, the city had just instituted the 20 foot side yard set back. Brad
offered that the new requirements would be "extremely difficult to enforce" for lakeshore
property.
Under the current Shorewood code only 6 feet of my property could be built on without a
variance. In the case of my non-conforming lot, the code required side yard set back
requirement does not provide for reasonable use and therefore necessitates the
encroachment.
Furthermore, the intent of the side yard set back requirement is to prevent houses from
being too close together and to preserve open space. The mere existence of the Mrs.
Lovrien's 20-foot wide parcel adjacent to my land accomplishes the intent of the side
yard set back, and this primary peculiarity of my property was recognized by the City as
fulfilling the intent of the zoning requirement in the both the staffreport dated August 28,
1986 and in resolution 103-86. The parcel still serves the same purpose.
In stating that there remains a reasonable use of the property, Mr. Kelly he implies that
the current configuration is the only reasonable use or alternately that my proposal is
unreasonable. I will demonstrate shortly that the proposed changes meet the standard of
reasonable use.
With regard to Mrs. Lovrien's concerns about trespassing, 4.8 feet is more than ample
room to traverse from the road side of my house to the lake without using her property if
it were necessary. Furthermore, the necessity of using the side yard to access the front
yard will be reduced because the proposed configuration actually directs people away
from the eastern lot line, and toward the entrance to the home. A more detailed review
of the plans for the construction shows that the door and walkway on the eastern side of
the house (which Mrs. Lovrien points out are not shown on the site plan) have been
eliminated by the proposed project The reconfigured floor plan encourages the flow of
traffic through the house, which is not the case in the current residence. The proposed
configuration actually decreases the likelihood that we would inadvertently trespass on
her property.
.
Mrs. Lovrien's final concern relates to the impact the proposed changes will have on her
view of the lake. Mrs. Lovrien's view will be impacted minimally, if at all, by the raising
of the house. I have had an architectural rendering prepared to demonstrate the specific
impact to Mrs. Lovrien's view. Based on that rendering, her concerns are unfounded. .
As I stated in my application, sight lines from the road to the lake will actually be
improved by moving my garage closer to the lake. I hope that when weighing the
concerns of one neighbor vs. those of the broader community, the planning commission
will recognize the improved sight lines to the lake from the road will offset the
insignificant decrease in Mrs. Lovrien' view.
.
Wrapping up my response to the comments provided thus far, I would like to reiterate
that the vast majority of neighbors with whom I spoke about the plans were supportive,
and documented their support by signing a petition encouraging the approval of the
required variances. I appreciate those who took the time from their busy scheduled to
show up here tonight and would like to thank them for their support.
Returning to the central matter raised by Brad's report, the issue of reasonable use must
be addressed. Reasonable use is defmed as: a use of one's property or of water that is for
a suitable and beneficial purpose and that does not lead to unreasonable interference with
another's use of property or with the natural flow of water.
The proposed design represents the highest and best use of my property, while respecting
the limits represented by the current floor area to lot area ratio on the property. The
improvements contemplated are beneficial both to me, and to the immediate locality, by
improving both the aesthetic appeal and value of my property. I am simply maximizing
the living space for my family within those constraints. The result of the project will be a
dwelling that is consistent with the character of the neighborhood and one that is more
suitable to the needs of my family. Simply put, the proposed plan meets the requirements
for suitable and beneficial purpose.
.
.
The final question to be addressed in order to satisfy the definition of reasonable use is:
does my proposal represent unreasonable interference with another's use of the property?
Brad has not claimed in his report that any component of my plan creates unreasonable
interference. The only claims Mrs. Lovrien has made with regard to unreasonable
interference with her use of her property is her visual enjoyment of the lake and the
looming threat of trespassing. I have previously addressed her concern related to her
view of the lake, and remain convinced that her view will be substantially unaltered.
There is absolutely no impediment to her access and egress to the lake created by my
project and isolated instances of someone occasionally stepping on her property fails to
meet the standard of unreasonable interference with her use of her parcel.
Based on these facts, the proposed project meets the key definitional requirements of
"reasonable use" and I hope the Planning Commission will find as such.
In closing, I respectfully request that Planning Commission recommend in favor of the
requested setback variances as I have proven hardship as required by state statures due to
the excessive narrowness of my lot, supported by official findings of the City of
Shorewood and have satisfied the legal definition of reasonable use. Thank you for your
consideration
q~q~
Attorney at Law
(952) 474-2100
17736 Excelsior Boulevard
Minnelonka, MN 55345
I .... .~
.Qr rs ~ ~ n \\'1 F; Pf\\U
'I 'I r..u.I.~:~...:.- L':.-: l' \.i'";'.' ,,1.
I t. .1. '., r. ........." .-.-.- ". '1 '.!i ,: '.
!~, ,if. j',! .f~
lit.... . i1 I'S
Iflii JUl ~~_ ~l
July 8, 2003
Mayor and City Council
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood,:MN 55331
.
Re: Variance Appliance Application of John O'Donnell
27100 Edgewood Road, Shorewood, MN
PID # 29-117-23-33-0012
Dear Mayor Love and Members of the Shorewood City Council:
My client, Phyllis Lovrein, who owns the property at 27095 Edgewood Road, has asked that I
write you following the Planning Director's Report and the Planning Commission's
recommendation to deny Mr. O'Donnell's variance request for additional construction on his lot.
.
As a long time resident of Shorewood, Ms. Lovrein has seen what she believes to be substantial
over-building on the lots in her neighborhood. She wonders when, if set-back requirements and
building restrictions are ignored, will such over-building end. As stated in her hand written memo
dated May 1,2003, she has been careful to preserve her adjacent 20 feet strip ofland completely
open, without trees or vegetation so as not to interfere with anyone's view of the lake. She feels
that applicant's proposed additional construction would impair her view of the lake from her
property and would tend to diminish the value of her land. In addition to her own loss, she
believes that the proposed construction of such a massive nature on such a small lot would
definitely alter the essential character of the locality.
The Shorewood City Code and the Minnesota Statutes set out distinctly the criteria for the
granting of a variance, the main .criteria being that of establishing a hardship. "Undue hardship" as
used in connection with the granting of a variance means the property in question cannot be put to
a reasonable use if used under conditions allowed by the official controls. The plight of the
landowner is due to circumstances unique to the property not created by the landowner, and the
variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the locality. Minn. Stat. Section
462.357, subd. 6 (2).
. .
...;.
.
.
Mayor and City Council
City of Shorewood
July 8, 2003
Page 2
In the case of Mr. O'Donnell's request, it appears that none of these criteria apply, inasmuch as
the property is already being put to a reasonable use. The fact that his family has now grown
larger than the family of previous owners of the property cannot be considered a reason for
determining that the property is can no longer be put to a reasonable use. Furthermore, Mr.
O'Donnell purchased the property well aware of the size of the building in relation to the size of
the lot, and, therefore, cannot be considered to be a victim of circumstances created not by
himself. Also, continuous over-building on the parcel will most certainly alter the essential
character of the locality
. The state statute goes on to state "economic considerations alone shall not constitute an undue
hardship ifreasonable use of the property exists under the terms of the ordinance." Again, it has
been established that reasonable use of the property already exists, therefore, economic situations
cannot be considered a.factor in considering the variance request.
Mrs. Lovrein hopes that the mayor and city council will consider her feelings as a long time
resident and responsible citizen of the City of Shorewood, as well as the legal aspects of Mr.
O'Donnell's request, and follow the recommendations of the City Planning Director and the City
Planning Commission, and deny the variance request of Mr. O'Donnell.
Very truly yours,
cc: Phyllis Lovrein
July 24", 2003
JUL 2 4 2003
,----
. ! i
: Ii
~j
--~~_.J
-.. ---.... - .
Mayor and City Council
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
Re: Variance Application, John O'Donnell, 27100 Edgewood Road, Shorewood, MN
PID No. 29-117-23-33-0012
Dear Mayor Love and members ofthe Shorewood City Council:
.
My name is George Lovrien and I am representing my mother, Phyllis, who owns the
twenty-one foot lot adjacent to the O'Donnell property on the east. I would like to
reiterate some of the points she and I feel invalidate the O'Donnell variance request.
Her basic objection to this request is that too much house is proposed for too small a lot.
Even using creative architecture and keeping the foundation size the same, lifting the
house by seven feet creates a much larger building presence. This definitely will impair
her view of the lake.
Beyond this, the O'Donnell's lack of yard space creates a need for trespassing on my
mother's property. Connecting a two-story garage to their house will direct traffic from
its back door to the front yard, deck and lake. Since this garage will be less than five feet
from the property line, there will be a greater need for the Levrien lot to be used "as the
front and side yard of the O'Donnell house.
.
As this house sits today, it is almost impossible to walk from the front yard to the back
yard without walking on someone else's property. Clearly...there is already enough house
on this lot.
In conclusion, I am concerned about basic fairness. Is it fair that a home expansion is
predicated on the use of someone else's property? I think not.
Thank you very much for your consideration of this important matter.
Sincerely,
&.e--\.~~ rk~~
George Lovrien
P.S. Pictures enclosed.
~
-D-R-A-F-T-
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION DENYING A SETBACK VARIANCE TO O'DONNELL
WHEREAS, John O'Donnell (Applicant) proposes to raise the existing home located at
27100 Edgewood Road, to add another level ofliving area to the home on the property, said
property being described in Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant proposes to demolish an existing detached garage on the
property and build an attached garage, the location of which garage does not comply with the
setback requirements of the Shorewood Zoning Code, and the Applicant has therefore made
application for a variance; and
.
WHEREAS, the Applicant proposes to build a second story over the attached garage, the
location of which second story does not comply with the setback requirements of the Shorewood
Zoning Code, and the Applicant has therefore made application for a variance; and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held and the application was reviewed by the Planning
Commission on 6 May 2003 and, after deliberation, the Planning Commission recommended
denial of the requested variances; and
WHEREAS, the City Council at their regular meeting held on 28 July 2003 reviewed the
material submitted by the Applicant, written and oral public testimony, the recommendation of
the Planning Commission and the Planning Director's staff report, dated 30 April 2003, which
report is on file in the Shorewood City Hall.
.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The Applicant's property is located in an R-1A/S, Single-Family Residential/Shoreland
zoning district which requires a 35-foot front yard setback, a 50-foot setback from the
ordinary high water level of Lake Minnetonka, and a total side yard setback of thirty feet,
with no one side being less than 10 feet.
2. The Applicant's house is located less than one foot from the west property line and three
feet from the east property line, making it a nonconforming structure within the R-1A/S
zoning district.
3. The R-1A/S district requires 40,000 square feet of area and 120 feet of width at the
building line, whereas the Applicant's property contains 12,141 square feet of area and
ranges from 30.52 feet to 47.00 feet in width.
..,
4. The R-INS district provides for a maximum impervious surface ratio of25 percent,
whereas the applicant's property currently has 33 percent impervious surface.
5. The Applicant's property was granted two variances in 1986, allowing a second story to
be added to the home and allowing a two-car detached garage to be built on the lot.
6. The Applicant proposes to increase the floor area of the home from approximately 1800
square feet to approximately 3200 square feet.
7. The Shorewood Zoning Code imposes restrictions on the enlargement, extension, or
structural alteration of nonconforming structures, provided that such expansion does not
increase the nonconformity and complies with height and setback requirements of the
district in which it is located.
.
CONCLUSIONS
1. That the variance requested by the Applicant constitutes a significant deviation from the
requirements of the Shorewood Zoning Code.
2. That the Applicant's property can be put to a reasonable use under the conditions imposed
by the Shorewood Zoning Code.
3. That the Applicant has not met the criteria for the grant of a variance under Section
1201.05 of the Shorewood City Code and has failed to establish any undue hardship as
defined by Minn. Stat. Section 462.357, Subd. 6(2).
4.
That the Applicant's request for the variance set forth above is hereby denied.
.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 28th day of
July, 2003.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
CRAIG W. DAWSON, CITY ADMINISTRATOR/CLERK
~
.
.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
That part of Block 3, Sampsons Upper Lake Park, Hennepin County, Minnesota, lying westerly of
the East line of said Block 3 and its northerly extension (said east line being assumed to be a line
drawn north perpendicular to the south line of said Block 3 from a point thereon distant 323.00 feet
east, as measured along said south line, from the southwest comer of said Block 3) and easterly of a
line described as follows:
Commencing at the southeast comer of said Block 3; thence on an assumed bearing of West along
the south line of said Block 3 a distance of 47.00 feet to the point of beginning of the line to be
described; thence North 3004'30" East to the shore of Lake Minnetonka and said line there ending,
Exhibit A
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD' SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927' (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us' cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Cammissian, Mayar and City Cauncil
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
.
DATE:
29 May 2003
RE:
Sharewaad Yacht Club - Amendment to. L-R District
Requirements/Amendment to. Existing C.D.P.
FILE NO.
405(03.16)
BACKGROUND
.
Mr. J 0.00 Crass, representing the Sharewaad Yacht Club (SYC), lacated at 600 West
Lake Street (see Site Lacatian map - Exhibit A, attached), has requested an amendment
to. the provisians set farth in the L-R zaning district that restrict multiple dack facilities in
Gidean's Bay to. sailbaats anly. He also. requests that a similar requirement cantained in
his present canditianal use permit, be amended as well. His request is explained in a
request letter, dated 30 April 2003 (see Exhibit B).
As most afyau are aware, SYC was rezaned nearly three years ago. to. be included in the
L-R, Lakeshare Recreatianal zaning district, and was granted a canditianal use permit to.
aperate a multiple dack facility. There was cansiderable backgraund assaciated with
those previaus actians that will nat be reiterated here. Rather, the resalutian, staff
reparts, and minutes fram related meetings are attached far yaur review:
. Attachment I - Original Court-ardered C.D.P.
. Attachment n - Planning memarandum, dated 27 Sept 2000
. Attachment Ill- Engineer's memarandum, dated 1 Nav 2000
. Attachment N - Planning memarandum, dated 1 Nav 2000
. Attachment V - Planning Cammissian and Cauncil meeting minutes
. Attachment VI - Resalutian No. 00-111
n
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#8. B.
Memorandum
, Re: SYC Zoning and C.D.P. Amendments
29 May 2003
In addition to this background material, you are urged to review Section 1201.24 (L-R,
Lakeshore Recreational District) of the City Code.
ANALYSISIRECOMMENDATION
A. Current Requirements.
The Yacht Club operates under a conditional use permit (see Attachment VI), pursuant to
Section 1201.24 of the Shorewood City Code. Section 1201.24 Subd. 10.d., which states:
.
"d. Issuance of a license shall take into consideration the historic use of the site
under consideration with respect to the use of power boats. With the exception
of power boats necessary for the operation of the facility, water harboring of
boats on any site located in Gideon's Bay shall be limited to sailing boats only. "
The conditional use permit contains the following references to sailing boats:
Pg. 3 "1. That based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby grants the
Applicant's request for a conditional use permit for a sailing yacht club at
600 West Lake Street. " (emphasis added)
"2.c. The permit shall be limited to the docking of sailboats. exceptfor
three power boats used by the management of the Yacht Club. In addition,
the dock located at the westernmost end of the subject property shall be
limited to one boat owned by the residents of 5585 Timber Lane. Weed
harvesting equipment shall not count against the allowable number of
power boats. "(emphasis added)
.
These are the provisions that the applicant proposes to change, eliminating any distinction
between power boats and sailboats.
B. Zoning Text Amendment.
Section 1201.04 Subd. 1.d.(l) of the Zoning Code sets forth the factors to be considered
in evaluating zoning text amendments and conditional uses:
"(1) The Planning Commission shall consider possible adverse effects of
the proposed amendment or conditional use. Its judgment shall be based upon
(but not limited to) thefollowingfactors:
(a) The proposed action has been considered in relation to the specific
poliCies and provisions of and has been found to be consistent with the
official City Comprehensive Plan.
(b) The proposed use is or will be compatible with present and future land
uses of the area.
-2-
.
.
" - Memorandum
Re: SYC Zoning and C.U.P. Amendments .
29 May 2003
(c) The proposed use will not tend to or actually depreciate the area in
which it is proposed.
(d) The proposed use can be accommodated with existing public services
and will not overburden the City's service capacity. "
It is recommended that the Planning Commission and City Council review policies set
forth in the Comprehensive Plan, particularly the Natural Resource section and the Land
Use section of the Plan, in conjunction with this request.
Section 1201.04 Subd. I.d.(2) goes on to say:
"(2) Upon consent of the City Council, the Planning Commission and City
staff shall have the authority to request additional information from the applicant
concerning operational factors or to retain expert testimony with the consent and
at the expense of the applicant concerning operational factors, said information
to be. declared necessary to establish performance conditions in relation to all
pertinent sections of this Ordinance. "
One of the most significant concerns raised during the redrafting of the L-R District
requirements and in the review of the SYC conditional use permit, was the potential for
environmental disturbance. Specifically, people were concerned that power boats may
stir up phosphates suspended in the silt in Gideon's Bay from the old Excelsior sewage
treatment plant, which discharged through the SYC site. While no studies were available
when the SYC application was being considered, it was suggested that the MPCA was
going to be conducting soil sampling of various parts of the lake in the (then) near future.
Staff will attempt to find out if such study was ever done.
The applicant's request letter mostly references an increasing demand for power boat
slips, but fails to address the market for sailboating. In discussing this with a member of
the Wayzata Yacht Club, they apparently have a waiting list of people who want sailboat
slips. In this regard the City may wish to require a market study of boat slip demand on
Lake Minnetonka.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
-3-
,
i po
..
i
.
'.
~
, -
.
"
.;-
#
,
~
"
~
~.
~
I
.il
,;
!! .
\ \
\'
'.
z~
'.
II
.'
.'
'.
~.s.
\,
T.s.
""'>
. .
~
.
"
I ...
d.
,.
8,1
~~I .
~..
ffi51
a:
'"
.-
"
"-.
~...
'";".
(jj ..
a Ql ..~'"
au.. .. ,
a. " .*
"""'....-
--
dill
a
a ILl
It) >
'"
~
a g
It) " '"
N
,,~~
" .
.
a
......
-o.
"tt11t""
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
SYC - Code amendment/C.D.P. amendment
MINNETONKA
MOORINGS
2 2003
. '. .,.,,--.--. _-I .... "'___.,.;.'.._." .l....._.~_....-J
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
.
Shorewood Yacht Club (SYC) was designed in 1979 to be a first class
Yacht Club for approximately 130 boats, to serve the residents of
Shorewood and the surrounding area. It was recognized that many of the
residents of Shorewood needed good access to Lake Minnetonka, one of the
great assets of the City. The location ofSYC on County Road #19 is one
that affords good access without generating traffic through a residential area
of the City and sits next to a commercial dredging company. It is well
separated frOln the residential areas of the city by the Hennepin County
Trail. It was to be built in phases. Phase I was constructed in 1978 and
involved the construction of three piers for 82 boats.
.
Phase II, the second and final phase, of SYC was worked on by the
owners of SYC for many years. Finally in 1998, SYC was able to purchase
the land west of Phase I so as to complete the initial design of SYC. At that
time Pier Four was added bringing the total number of slips to 117. The
land west of SYC was historically used for the docking of seven powerboats
being owned by several neighboring residents. The docking of 4 powerboats
is permitted by present zoning and permitting.
Discussion
Lake Regulation Regulation of the boating on Lake Minnetonka has
been granted to the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District (LMCD by the
cities surrounding the lake. LMCD does not limit any marina on the lake to
that of docking of sailboats only. In fact the Howard's Point Marina in
Shorewood, about one mile west of SYC, is not restricted by the City of
Shorewood or LMCD as to the rental of its slips to only sailboats. LMCD
has no objection to the docking of powerboats in Gideon's Bay by SYC. In
fact LMCD has not even imposed a no wake area in Gideon's Bay.
NORTH OFFICE
600 WEST LAKE STREET. SHOREWOOD . MINNESOTA 55331
phone: 952.474.0600 fax: 952.474.9755
SOOTH OFFICE
1585 TARPON CENTER DRIVE. SUITE 28 . VENICE. FLOR
phone: 941.485.6700 fax: 941.486.9119
Email: onboarc/@onboarc/sail.colll www.onboarc/sail.c
Exhibit B
APPLICANT'S REQUEST LETTER
Dated 30 April 2003
Page Two
Current Changes In recent years powerboats have becon1e quieter.
LMCD regulates and limits the noise generated by boats on the Lake.
Powerboats continue to be popular for lake recreation. The number of slips
on the Lake has been reduced in the last several years with the conversion of
Marinas' into townhouse use and other residential uses and the restructuring
of Gray's Bay Marina into a public access. Thus the demand for powerboat
slips has increased on the Lake.
.
Sailboats and Power Boats Both power and sailboats have fossil fuel
engines to provide for propulsion. There is no evidence mown to SYC that
either type of boat is more or less damaging to the environment. Both boats
have propellers to move them in the water. Boats are required by Minnesota
law to operate in a safe manner so that they do not endanger other boats or
persons or property by their wakes. SYC requires that all boats in their
marina operate as "no wake" or at idle speed as they exit the marina and
proceed through the channel to the center of the bay. Powerboats from other
parts of the Lake operate in Gideon's Bay and generate much nlore noise and
wake than that of boats exiting SYC.
.
Conclusion SYC is a long time resident of Shorewood, a taxpayer, a
service to the residents of Shorewood and the surrounding area. In order for
it to continue as an asset to the City and be competitive with other m~inas it
should be allowed to dock both power and sail boats. There is no reasonable
public purpose to impose a limitation on SYC prohibiting renting dockage to
powerboats.
Request Therefore, SYC respectfully requests that the City of
Shorewood amend its ordnance and special use permit to SYC to permit SYC
to rent its docks to either sailor powerboats.
Sincerely,
,- ..":".:;,,.?
" , j 'i{ 1-'" ')- /l -"".-2.
.,"""""Q .~;~-- LI"'" . - _/} ~- -'->- _"_"'0""<-"" ".
{ '\~..... '. -,-'.. -
John H. Cross, President
Minnetonka Moorings, Inc.
dba Shorewood Marina & Yacht Club
JHC/jal
;..<....:...
..t
I,
.,
..'
I.
"
;
. ,.
. For eo slips
1 :
.: I
r
i.
. l
RESOLUTION NO.24-'(9
.:. .WHEREAS, in March of 1976 Minnetonka Moorings, Inc., made
~pp1icati~n:to the City of Shorewood requesting .~ conditional
use permit to use part .of' Lot 25, Auditor's Subdivision No. 313,
and Lots 288, 297, 304 and part of Lots 305 and 290, in Auditor's
~Ubd'ivisi~n'No.. 135, for a yacht .ciub with 125 slips to store
.sa,i~boats,. for game. courts such as tenni.s, the use of. a structure
...located on the property for a ciubhou.se, and for parking and
I '. .' .
wintel;'storage.of sailboats,. and
WHEREAS;th.e property in question is located in theR-l
.. ~in:gl. ei'am.:.:1.1Y residence district wherein a "yacht club'l; is a
. ~~ated C01;diti~hal ~se ,a~d..' .
. WHERE,AS, . the ~lannihg Commission of :the City of Shorewood
held pub~icpearings on the reque~t for the conditional use permit
,I . '. .' . '. ._. ,. . " "
.ap.d theCity'~ouncil did receiv.e the recommendations of the Planning
C:ommission;and
! ~. . I '". __ , .' . . '.
. ~AS' t~~"Ci tyCouncii" d1.d:"i tself hold public hearings
on the l"eque:st ~t which. parties'. desirIng to be heard. were heard,
arid . ". .
WHEREAS,.the."Shorew6odZoning'Oroinance~beingOrdinance No. 77,
I :..... -. '.' ,
in Section. 7, sets' forth the. .standards and conditions by which the
. 1 ". .. '. . . .' " '.
.c\i ty . Council, may'grant conditional Use pernii ts, and
t t...' . . '.- .. .
! wHEREAS', theC.i ty Council did consider the' nature of the
.r~quest; '. I"~COmmendation~. of the pianningCommissio:ri,' testimony of
t~e public' and tbe requiremen~s ?f Ordinance Nd~'77,.and did deny
the' requ~ste~ c~nditionaluse permit on a'3 to 2 vote by Resolution
No. 50~-77; adopted July 25, 1977. and
W~~AS, the applicant thereafter qommenced an a~tion in
H~nnepin County District Court to' obtain a writ of mandamus to
cpmpe1the City Council to issue the requested conditional use
, permit and: the' Court did, on August 21, 1978, enter its Findings
of Fact, C?n~lusions of Law and Order for Judgment finding that
t:p.e City C?Wlcil' s deni.al of .the reque st for said condi, ti~:mal use
'. . p~rmi twas'; arbi trary, '~eaSOi1able, .capricious and void and did
. ". t , ., . '. .
,., c(jriclude' that the applicant was anti tIed to a judgment i'compelling
t~e~ityof Sho~ewood and its C?uncil to issue a conditional use
permit to petitioner for a yacht.club as applied' for by petitioner";
. .
8!ld
Attachment I
'j
.
"l
.
~
: I
WHEREAS; the City Council did subsequently vote to forego
. .
.' art appeal :of. said Order, but the Gideon's Bay Homeowners Associa-
.. .
tion did petition the Court and was permitted to.' intervene in said
m~tter an~ file an.appeal of said Order to the Minnesota Supreme
Cpurt and said appea;I. is. now under consideration by the Supreme
Court; and
WHEREAS, as a result of the terms of permits as granted by
the. Lake Minrietonka Conservation District, the Department of
Natu~lR.e.s.ourGesap.d the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District,
.i ~ne . app~:j.e:ant has subml tted a .revisedplan to the' ~i typroV' iding
'.... f:(j~"80:'sa.i:lbbat 'slips', . x:ath~r than '125, and reducing the number
:....df parking spac'~s from'that originally requested,
..:. NqW, ;THEREFORE, BE'IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the
. C,ity ofS~ore~ood,as follows:
" .. . ,L:.~hat ac6nditicinal Use permit fora yacht club pursuant
t,o 'Orctiriarice No, 77, .Sec. 18, Subd. 3D, and the conditions here-
. '.
'. a.fter 's~e~ifie~ .is hereby granted to the Shorewood Yacht Club. Inc.
. " .2. . 'That'said. 'cortditional'use permit is subject to the effect
, '.o.f.~JC;isti~g 'prd'e~s of th.e. Herin.e~in County District Court and the
./.: r.ign~ toooriti~ue' operatioIlof the yacht club 'pur~uant to said
'j :p'e~itis.:sUbject.to .ariy' ;further orders of said. Court and is
iurther's~~ject~o~isposition of:the appeal currently before
the Mi.nnesota Supreme Court and shall terlit1riate in. the event said
qourt .should:rev-erse. the:. judgment entered in the Hennepin County
.~istr;c.t dqurtcompelling the Council to issue this permit.,
.:: . . .,. ~~tnotWithstai1ding that .the original application pro-
..... . .pos.e.d" in~~;allati.on of 125 sailboat slips and the Hennepin County
;. .' ".. .' .
, . I)istrict Co~ ordered ,i~suance cif e. pet'mit lias applied for",
:. in light of the :fact. that the applicant has now submit~ed a re-
'Vised'plan proposing SO 'slips, the conditional use permit hereby
grant~d shall be for ~.'slipsonly, as described in the revised
plans .bf March .9, 1979,b:ut 'is nevertheless i.ssued Un~er and pur-
suant to the original application and the order o;f the Court of
August 21,. i97~.
4. That said conditional use permit shall' be' valid and
. . ..
effective ,only so long'as and during such period of time as the
applicant continues to hold valid permits for 80 sailboat slips
. granted by the Lake Mihnetonka Conser'V'ation District, the Depart-
. .
ment of Natural Resources, and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed
District.
-2'-
,
",
,
,.
'., .
" :,
: -';:: -."
.1.;' .
..-. ;....
" .:. ....
. !. ',-,' . . .,,' . . . " "'. .
: ":' .5 +' That said,' :condi ti6:ti~1 use permit is' grari.t~d subject
to Cbmpli~c,e by Shor~,,9od 'Yacht Club' wi th-the fol~owing bondi tions:
.:; .,.... a.: The:~nii~:':Shailbe::' ~ff~.ctiV~.fOf.~:'~~ri6a; '01' .
...f 'one'.year'frolIrthe effective date .theredfsubject~.
'. ,.. howe:ver, to. anrii1al ,.rer1-:(;!,wal. under~ppi'opria 1;;e cir.":
.' :" cuInstances. . .
".' .' :i..:::...... '. '. ..\~.:,;:..::;:.}(;:;~..:.i':\).<... " .....:
,.' ..:, c.' .constrUc~fcin affecting .d'rainage 'patterns Shall be
., . :l.n"accordance with.:thepE!r~it app1;'O\7als gran-:t;e& 'by.
..theLM1miehalul,Creek Vlate~shed District. dateo.'DecElmber 7,
. .19,78 and the' Minnesota Department of Natural. Resources
.!ia;ted.March ;l5~..1979.. .." ..." .'
." :, ...' {_ ,.:.- .~. .'. .':,.' '. " .. " . ./: . ", . " .:: . .F. "
.+ '~.';'.The' numbl:ii.,ofpar1tIng;spaces prpylded,' shali
" .... ~ :~~~ . ~~C~~~q:n~~~~";';~4~l;:.~siri~~~~;:~~t~~~1 .
'.' '. ,.the.Minnehaha .Creek Watershed District' dated.
.,..../.;.. '.' '" ':.D.e;c,~IIl~er 7,.:1978.~., ..' .:. >. . . ..'. .
;' .;'.'; e/'The. permi t,S};lall . be iiml ted to the' mooring of.
. .1 ~;:ii+boatsi.'except:':.t.Wo,,:power'boa.t$used py the
.'. mailage.ment..in th~:,~~i.l;~:sdhoCiL. '. . . .
".t:~::.::'~h~' foilOW'ihg;::~~cii.{ti~s' sh~ii:.b~: :t'or .the 'use
; of:. 'm~mbe:rIt'bnlY'_:.. ': -,.,.:-,:~ . .~. . ..' 1
,. ,.' '- """ . ......... -' ...",
. .',' ..'lei)" :'Lafu16hlrig ;fam~' '.
. . : ..' . .;~ . _.' ...: ~ - . .. - " """. -.'.. ':
:' {2) Parking: ar.eas.
.... . '. ..: . ,{3,). Clubho~se. ,'.
. .:...,.., ;:~: :(J):'~~it~~i~~' fa~i~'i ties
.f
tit.
.....:.. .
.' ~. - .1
1
..... i
.' I .
. .....
. ....
. ..,
.
'.'
. ,
",.'
,::,.-:. ';:"
." ;
'~;.:.::..""_...::: ."
. r~.~.~ '., .::':.::
::: '"7
..' ..!.:
-'. i'
. \ .
b.~:The,'pertl1it. shall be 1'01" the 1Emd~l~gaUyd.escribed
'on, plan sheet.2 of the plans submitted to' t~e", Ci ty
, da1;e'd March 9'- 2979. '. . ". .
'. .'. \ ., ' .,.
. ,., .
.,' : ::. . '.~
" .~
;" .:,(.~.),::PUmp 'out.'.
(6)' Suimher/Winter storage
'.. 'h ..Hours , of: club operati~rt'i .
. ':. ": "Closing.time'. (Su';lday tbrO~gh 'Thursday):':lO:OO p..m.
.' '. ': ".< .' . (Fr.~day t~o'.lgh Satur:t~!):.. '1:00 a.m.'
'; .:'..:i.:e:'DOck ~id.et:h6~s sheiJ.1 be: betweeri>th~ hdtirs:o:t'. '"
....}b,.:~ p.m~:~d'8.=O~ a.m....: .' "'. :. :'"."
. ':, j.:'::Sailboats when hot ,in use :shali ha:ve:theii>:
.haly'ards~E!el.tred , by: sUchdev~c~s as,wi.ll ini!limi~e.
':~y'<n:Oise,WhiCh'.~i~ht. ~e ?a~sed bYthe~...." ..-:
: k.: "Right-of:':way'..Shall be 'given to all,barge.~arid
.work boats 'beiilg:u:s~d ,:P1 theadj~ge~t dredging cqmpany.
;....
.~3-::-
. . .~. ..
1.: Membership shall be geared as much as possible
to'accomodate Shorewood residents.
m. Anv radios utilized on-board sailboats shall be
kept below decks with their volume at a discreet
le~el. '
n.: No members' pets'shall be allowed on the premises.
o. Pedestrian crossings of the railroad right-of~way
shall be permitted and provided on the blacktop access
dri v:eway only.
~~ That th~ conditional Use permit herein granted shall not
,b13 effective until the applicant has provided the City wi t.h the
f?llowirtg ~tems;
a.: Evidence that Minnetonka Moorings, Inc. has
co~p~etedpurchase under a previously documented
Purchase Agreement with Chicago. Northwestern ,
,Transportation Company for the acquisition of .two
parc'els' of railroad right-of-way (described on plan
shee.t 2 of the revised plans dated March 9, 1979)
such that it "possesses 'the requisite control :and
,dominion'over said railroad right-of-way parcels
re~u~red by Ordinance No. 77. Sec. 7, Subd. 3.C.2.
!,
"
'~.. .'
,b. Evidence of a,license from Chicago, Northwestern
Transportation Company for purposes of access across
the railroad right-of-way to that portion of the
subject property which lies northerly of the rail-
ro~d rightrof-way. .
c.~ An executed lease 'between Minnetonka Moorings,
,Inp.', and Shorewood Yacht Club, Inc., coveriIfg ,
parc,els A artdB, the two parcels of railroad right-
of~way acquired, and the access 4riveway as described
o~plan, sheet 2 of the revised plans of March 9, 1979,
prpv~dingthe beneficia+ use thereof to Shorewood
Yacht Club, Ine. '
Uporif1ling of sueh~eVid~n?e with ~heCity the same shall be
're~erred ~o,the City Attorney for review :and upon his written
approval thereof, filed with the,C1ty, tlle permi~ shall become
ef.fective.
..:7 ~ That the conditional use permit hereby granted shall not
" "bonstitute authorization to place fill upon wetlands nor constitute
a buiidingperoii t for any alterations or improV'ements' of any
structures located on the subj~ct property. Separate permits
'~allbe requited ,from the CitY,.for such of these activities as
... . aire contemplated, if any.
-4-
~-T-----=----
-,-
"i.
"f.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
'.
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 . www.ci.shorewood.mn.us. cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, M~yor and City Council
.
FROM:
DATE:
Brad Nielsen
27 September 2000
RE:
Shorewood. Yacht.Club - Proposed Rezoning, Comprehensive Plan
Amendment, Conditional Use Permit and Variance
FILE NO.:
405 (00.27)
BACKGROUND
.
John and Judy Cross, Representing Minnetonka Moorings, have submitted an application
for the rezoning of their property at 600 West Lake Street (see Site Location map -
Exhibit A, attached) from R-IAlS, Single-Family Residenti8.llShoreland to L-R,
Lakeshore Recreational. They also request a conditional use permit for the existing
caretaker dwelling on the site and for the outdoor storage of boats on the property.
Certain existing conditions on the site necessitate the processing of a variance
application. Finally, since the applicants propose to add property and dockage to the
existing site, they have requested an amendment to the Shorewood Comprehensive Plan.
The existing yacht club contains approximately 2.4 acres of land, separated through the
middle by the Hennepin County Regional Railroad Authority right-of-way. The site
abuts and is accessed by County Road 19. The applicants have acquired additional
acreage to the west of the existing yacht club and north of the H.C.R.R.A. r.o.w. This
property contains an additional 19,200 square feet of area(.44 acres). Both sites are
presently zoned R..1A1S. Land use and zoning surrounding the sites are as follows:
ft
~.. PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Attachment II
.
.
..
, Memorandum
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.D.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
North:
East:
Lake Minnetonka
Minnetonka Portable Dredging; zoned C-4, Service Commercial
and Single-Family Residential; zoned R-IA/S
County Road 19, then commercial (The Garden Patch and
Shorewood Nursery); zoned C-4, Service Commercial and R-C,
Residential Commercial
Townhouse common area, then single-family residential; zoned R-
IBIS, Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland
South:
West:
A clubhouse facility, caretaker dwelling, a launch ramp and boat docking for 80 sailboats
occupy the existing site. The applicants' application describes a variety of activities that
occur on the property (e.g. sailboat rental, sailing school, incidental boat sales, storage of
weed harvesting equipment, etc.). The expansion site is currently occupied by three
docks, the use of which does not conform with current zoning requirements. The
applicants propose to use the property to provide 35 additional boat slips. Except for a
small pedestrian bridge and a storage rack for small sailboats, the expansion site will be
left in its natural state. The additional dockage will extend westerly from an existing
pier.
Plans for the existing property, as well as the proposed expansion are contained in a
notebook prepared by the applicant and enclosed for your review.
ISSUES AND ANALYSIS
Before addressing the proposed expansion of the yacht club, it is important to review how
the existing facility complies with the L-R zoning district requirements. As you know,
the L-R District was amended'in September of last year, in order to encourage two of the
existing multiple dock facilities in Shorewood to apply for the zoning. During the
amendment process it Was understood that these facilities would not necessarily comply
with all elements of the Code, and that certain nonconformities would simply have to be
recognized as existing deficiencies.
I. The Existing Site.
A. Comprehensive Plan. Any rezoning must be guided by the Comprehensive
Plan. The Land Use section of Shorewood's Comprehensive Plan shows the
property in question as an area of further study. Under ''Lake Access" it
mentions that the L-R District has been revised "to encourage the marina on
Howard's Point Road and the yacht club north of County Road 19 to comply
with City standards." The Chapter Summary goes on to say:
"10. Recognizing certain existing nonconformities, seek ways to bring
the Howard's Point Marina and the Shorewood Yacht Club into
-2-
~ Memorandum
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.U.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
substantial compliance with the revised Lakeshore Recreational
(L-R) zoning district."
B. L-R Zoning Requirements.
1. Permitted Uses. The only permitted use in the L-R District is water-
harboring of boats. This is subject to an annual licensing procedure
whereby specific standards and conditions are reviewed (see below).
.
2. Accessory Uses. The L-R District lists off-street parking, a clubhouse
building, one storage building, gas dispensing equipment, and boat rental
as allowable accessory uses. The yacht club has an exi~ting clubhouse
that the applicants propose to expand. Their plans are considered to be
consistent with the Code. The applicants propose to add a storage
building to the south end of the clubhouse. It is consistent with the 1200
square foot maximum area requirement. A small storage building already
exists on the site. Staff's initial recommendation to remove this structure
has been reconsidered in view of its proposed use as a dumpster enclosure.
While a fenced or walled enclosure would typically be sufficient for such'
storage, having a roof over the dumpster area will enhance screening it,
particularly from the elevated H.C.R.R.A. trail. The applicants' site plan
should be modified to show the location of this structure. It is worth
noting that neither the expansion of the clubhouse or the construction of
the storage building would be allowed under the yacht club's current
nonconforming use status.
.
The yacht club does not dispense gas, even to its members: Gasoline used
for their own purposes is stored in a small shed located to the east of the .
clubhouse. building. Final approval of the applicants' request should
include a condition that the gas storage be approved by the local fire
marshal.
The applicants' application to the }:..MCD references public rental of five
or more boats with outboard motors. The L-R District specifically states
that water-harboring of boats in Gideon's Bay must be limited to sailing
boats.
3. Conditional Uses.
a. Single-Family Dwelling. One of the significant changes to the L-R
District was the allowance of one single-family dwelling to serve as a
caretaker residence. In this case the caretaker residence complies with
the setback requirements for the L-R District. It is located 55 feet
-3-
· Memorandum
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.D.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
from the shoreline. . The only other requirement for the dwelling is that
it comply with Shorewood's Rental Housing Code. Any approval of
the SYC request should include a condition that the existing house be
inspected and conform with the Rental Housing Code.
b. Open and Outdoor Dry Land Storage of Boats and Trailers.
.
(1) Storage of boats must be screened from view of neighboring
residential uses. Since boats are stored in the parking area to the
west of the clubhouse, this applies mostly to the homes west of the .
SYC property. In this regard it is worth noting that the nearest
homes that can see the property are the Gideon's Cove twinhomes
(500+ feet to the west) and homes on Timber Lane that are
approximately 700 feet away to the west. The view of the site is
quite well screened from view of Gideon's Cove by existing trees.
.
Despite the proximity of boat storage to the lakeshore on the west
side of the site, there is some opportunity to enhance the
landscaping between the parking lot and the shoreline. As part of
any approval it is recommended that the applicants submit a
detailed landscaping plan for this area that introduces some sort of
evergreen tree. It is not suggested that this be a solid screen, but
. should include enough trees to soften the view from the west.
(2) Storage of boats must be screened from the street. Although
property to the south of the site is zoned for commercial use, boats
stored on the south side of the H.C.R.R.A. r.o.w. are somewhat
visible. As in (1) above, there appears to be some opportunity to
enhance screening by adding evergreen trees along the south edge
of the property, along County Road 19. These should also be
included in the applicants' landscape plan.
(3) Storage should be landscaped to buffer other public r.o.w. (in this
case the H.C.R.R.A. trail). Opportunities here are limited due to
the narrow space between the boat storage area and the trail f.O.W.
It is important that existing vegetation abutting the f.O.W. be
maintained. Where possible some evergreen trees should be
incorporated into these areas.
(4) Storage areas must be grassed or surfaced to control dust. . Boat
storage is limited to the existing parking areas. According to the
applicants they presently store mOfe than just their members'
boats, using up virtually all of the existing parking areas. It is
-4-
. Memorandum
· Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.D.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
recommended that future outdoor storage of boats be limited to the
spaces currently being used. If the expansion of the site is
approved, this may limit the number of non-member boats that can
be stored on the site.
(5) Lighting of the storage areas does not appear to be an issue. Based
upon a visit to the property, lighting appears to be well managed
and unobtrusive. Any additional lighting proposed in the future
should be subject to Council approval.
.
(6) Some of the existing parking is occasionally used for storage of
boats during the boating season. The applicants maintain that this
does not adversely affect parking. It is recommended that parking
be periodically monitored. If it is found that parking becomes a
problem (e.g. people begin to park outside of areas designated on
the site plan), the applicant should discontinue such storage during
the boating season. As an alternative, overflow parking or storage
could be acCommodated in the vacant southwest comer of the site
abutting County Road 19. Since this area provides an effeCtive
natural buffer, its use should only be required if parking becomes a
problem.
.
c. Lot requirements and Setbacks. The site complies with the minimum
area, width and depth requirements of the L-R District. With the
exception ~f parking and outdoor dry land storage of boats, the site
also complies with setback requirements. Perhaps the single most
significant deficiency on the site is the proximity of parking and
storage to the shoreline. It has already been recommended herein to
mitigate the visual impacts by enhanced landscaping. It is further
recommended that the parking areas near the lake be examined by the
,City Engineer, the DNR,and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District
for possible ways to address drainage directly into the lake.
d. Building Requirements. The clubhouse, caretaker residence and
proposed storage building comply with setback requirements of the L-
R District. Although the proposed storage building is 20 feet high on
the east side, the fact that it is attached to the clubhouse and only the
dIedging company property can see that elevation mitigates the height.
There is also merit in being able to house the portable boat hoist inside
the building during the off season.
e. Special and Specific Conditions.
-5-
} Memorandum
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.D.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
1. The site is located on a lake with at least two public accesses and is
located at least 5000 feet from any other multiple dock facility.
2. Any future construction must comply with State Building Code
requirements. The caretaker residence should be su,bject to
inspection and compliance with the Shorewood Rental Housing
Code.
.
3. The number of slips authorized must comply with the requirements
of the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District Code. The
applicants were in the process of receiving LMCD approval when
the City requested that no action be taken.pending the. City's
approval process. The draft findings of fact prepared may be of
some use in the City's licensing of the facility.
4. Parking. The applicants' plans illustrate parking for 121 cars.
This more than complies with the Code for the existing facility's
80 boat slips (one parking space per slip). If the site and dockage
are to be expanded the total parking requirement would be 115.
.
As mentioned earlier in this report, the westerly parking area and
four parking spaces on the north side of the site are closer than
fifty feet from the shoreline. Since the westerly parking area is
crucial to the use of the clubhouse and docking facilities, their
elimination is not practical. As recommended earlier, ways to
mitigate the proximity of parking to the lake should be further
explored.
While paving of the parking areas is not recommended in this case,
the applicants have agreed to pave the driveway entry into the site,
up to the H.C.R.R.A. r.o.w. This is consistent with the Code and
plans for paving the driveway should reflect the heavy weights of
the boats as well as'other heavy vehicles using the Minnetonka
Portable Dredging Company which shares this driveway.
5. Signage. The L-R District allows two signs on the site, one facing
the street and one facing the lake. The existing facility has one. of
each, plus an additional sign on its entry canopy facing the east
(Dredging Company).
6. lllumination. Lighting at the existing facility is considered to be
very well managed, balancing safety, security and impact to
surrounding properties.
-6-
, Memorandum
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.U.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
7. Noise. There is no record of complaints of noise in recent years
relative to the SYCfacility. Early concerns of halyards rattling in
the wind were easily addressed by having members wrap the
halyard around the masts. The SYC has gone so far as to impose a
strict fine for members who violate this rule.
.
8. Drainage. No additional grading is proposed for the property,
except for the construction of the new storage building. Standard
erosion control will be required as part of the building permit
process. As mentioned earlier the City Engineer, DNR and
MCWD engineers will be asked to review and comment on the
existing drainage of the site.
9. Historic Use. The L-R District references the historic use of the
site. It goes on to specifically restrict multiple dock water-
harboring facilities on Gideon's Bay to sailboats. In the past, the
storage of power boats for management of the club has been
limited to two. Any such limitation should not include the weed
harvesting equipment kept at the site.
IT.
The Expansion Site. While expansion of the existing multiple dock facilities was
not specifically referenced in the L-R District, it was known at the time that at
least the Howard's Point Marina was considering some expansion. The applicants
have acquired the property immediately west of the SYC site, north of the
H.C.R.R.A. r.o.w. This property was allowed years ago to have three docks for
the use of certain residents on Timber Lane. Over the last several years it appears
to have evolved into a dock rental operation for as many as seven boats. The
docks have been accessed by a gravel driveway from Timber Lane
.
The applicants' intent is to add a fourth pier to their existing dock system,
providing an additional 35 slips. One of those slips provides a dock for the
property owner at 5585Timber Lane. They also propose to maintain the
easternmost of the three docks for one. of their management boats. This also is
. included in the 35. The additional shoreline on this site allows the applicants to
comply with LMCD boat density requirements. In addition to the additional
dockage, the applicants would like to use the newly acquired land for their kids'
sailing school and camp(not overnight). In this regard, they propose to store
several small sailboats on a rack at the east end of the parcel. They also propose a
boat dock canopy on the east end of the parcel to protect students from the
elements. This canopy would be removed at the end of the boating season. The
applicants propose to access this portion of the site by means of a small foot
bridge connected to their main facility.
-7-
.. Memorandum
~ Re: Shorewood Yacht Club
Rezoning, Comp Plan Amendment, C.D.P. and Variance
27 September 2000
With respect to the expansion, several factors should be taken into consideration:
A. Parking and Access. As mentioned earlier in this report, the applicants
propose parking for 121 cars. With the new docks the total number of slips
required under the Code is 115. It is highly recommended that access for the
westerly parcel be limited to emergency vehicles only. With the exception of
the proposed canopy and the sailboat storage rack, the westerly parcel should
remain in a natural undeveloped state.
.
B.Boat Traffic. The proposed docks arrangement suggests approximately a 40
percent increase in boat storag"e and, presumably, 40 percent more boat traffic.
The applicants estimate that their average use on weekdays is up to 10 percent
of the members, with weekends up to 30 percent (approximately 24 boats
currently). Multiplying these figUres by 40 percent suggests 11 boats on
weekdays and 34 boats per day on weekends.
It is worth noting that out of necessity the sailboats using the facility must
follow a well defined channel, marked by buoys. The applicants advise us
that no additional dredging of the lake bottom will be required to
accommodate the new slips. Those on the inside, where the water is
somewhat more shallow, will accommodate smaller sailboats that have swing-
up keels.
.
C. Existing Dock Rights. If the expansion is approved, a stipulations should be
placed in the permit for the site that the westerly dock must be strictly limited
to one boat, for the exclusive use of the residents at 5585 Timber Lane. The
dock shall not be rented out.
RECOMMENDATION
The rezoning of the 'existing site is relatively uncomplicated, provided the
recommendations included herein are included in the approval. The expansion is
somewhat more challenging, but presents an interesting opportunity for the City to
achieve greater control over the property. Input from area residents will undoubtedly
raise issues not addressed herein. Assuming those issues can be adequately addressed by
the City,,it is recommended that the rezoning and Comprehensive Plan Amendment be
favorably considered. The applicants' next step would then be to make a formal
application for a Comprehensive Plan amendment, during which time staff should be
directed to prepare an ordinance and resolution approving the rezoning and conditional
use permit, respectively.
Cc: Larry Brown
John and Judy Cross
-8-
DUCK ISLAND
A FROG ISlAND
N
"
500
I
o
500 Feet
I
EXhibit A
SITE LOCATIO~
Shorewood Yacht Club - Rezoning
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.ci.shorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
DATE:.
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen, Acting City Administrator
Lany Brown, Director of Public WOrksiJYj t /
:p
November 1, 2000 .
TO:
FROM:
BE:
Shorewood Yacht Club Proposed Rezoning, Comprehensive Plan Amendment,
Gonditional Use Permit and Variance
Existing Conditions:
. The existing site is located at.600 West Lake Street, and is presently owned and operated by John
and Judy Cross as the Shorewood Yacht Club (refer to Attachment 1 for the site location map). The
existing site is 2.4 acres in total that is bisected by the Hennepin County Regional Rail Authority
(HCRRA) right of way, in an east-west direction. ..
.
The portion of the site north of the HCRRA right of way is bounded: by shoreline of Lake
Minnetonka on the north, Minnetonka.Portable Dredging Company on the east and the HCRRA
right of way on the south. . For reference of this report, this portion of the parcel will be referenced
as "Parcel Al." (Refer to Attachment 2).
. .
The remaining portion of' the parcel is immediately south of the HCRRA right of way, and is
comprised largely of wetland area. Approximately 0.3 acres of upland also exiSts.that is utilized as
additional boat storage space. For reference of this report, this portion' of the existing parcel will be
~eferenced as "Parcel A2." ,K. ..
. Mt'
The applicant has acquired. an addition~~4 acres located immediately west of parcel A~ and north
of the HCRRA right of way, an~f Timber Lane. This site currently'exists as open field.
For reference of this report, this parCel is referenced as "Parcel B."
ft
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Attachment ill
Planning Commission,
Mayor and City Council
Shorewood Yacht Club
November 2, 2000
Page 2 of4
Right of Way, Easements and Parking
.
The survey for the existing site indicates that the proposed parking shown along the northerly edge
of Parcel A2 is within the HCRRA right of way (refer to Attachment 3). The applicant will be
. required to obtain an easement from the HCCRA for this parking area to be utilized.
Plans also indicate several parking spaces around the structures. It appears that these areas may
.double as boat storage, during the off-season. While it is reasonable to double up on the use of the
impervious surface for both parking and boat storage, the City requires that one parking stall per
boat slip be provided. It appears that the swapping of the use of the parking and storage area
dependant upon customer demand is an efficient use of the space. The Planning Commission and
City Council will need to. determine if the joint use of the spaces is acceptable.
The plan does not indicate any designations to comply with the American with Disabilities Act
(ADA) requirements. Under state law, the new addition requires the designation of handicapped
accessible parking spaces. Under this proposal, the applicant will need to provide one ''van
accessible" parking space and four additional handicapped parking spaces (refer to Attachment 4).
All of the parking spaces must be paved to provide a suitable surface for ramp loading and
.unloading.
.
It should be noted that the ADA requirements call for five designated parking" stalls, based upon the
total number of parking stalls proposed. At the time of this report, it is unclear as to whether a fewer
" .
number of stalls would be required based upon parking requirements versus floor space as cited in
the Uniform Building Code (versus tile City's Ordinance). City Staff's recommendation is to remain
with the five designated handicapped parking stalls indicated above. However, if the applicant's
engineer can adequately certify that the State ADA requirements may justify a fewer number of
stalls, then the recoinmendationcan be revised to reflect such a finding.
Grading and Drainage and Erosion Controls
Parcel AI: With the exception of the entrance drive, the topography for Parcel Al varies from 934.0
at the southeast comer of the site to 931.5 at the shoreline. The offices for the yacht club reside on
this portion of the property.
This parcel is largely an aggregate sutfaced area used for boat storage. The proposal indicates that
the parking area is to remain as an aggregate surface. Staff has considered the tradeoffs for a gravel
surface versus a paved sutface, as it relates to water quality.
Planning Commission,
Mayor and City Council
Shorewood Yacht Club
November 2, 2000
Page 3 of4
The following is a comparison of the issues of an aggregate surfaced lot versus a paved lot
Issue - Consideration
A2'2're2'ate Lot
Paved Lot
Expense
Cost Effective
Expensive
.
Transport of fine particulates
from surface to the lake
High probability
during severe rainfall
. events
None
Minor spills ( drips) of gas
or oil
Can be addressed with
minimal expense
Typically not
addressed -:- too
expensive
.
In general, there is very little absorption of surface runoff that occurs on an aggregate lot. These
types of surfaces tend to become very compact due to traffic, and operate similar to a paved surface.
Inspections of the site after minor rainfall events show that there are various pools and depressions
that pocket some water. This typically would not occur under a paved scen8.rlo. Therefore, the
recommendation is to remain with an aggregate surface, with exception of the handicapped parking
area described above.
This site is located within the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District. Under the District's
requirements a storm water quality basin is not required for the site. However, the Lake Minnetonka
Conservation District (LMCD) has recommended that storm water quality basin be constructed for
the site (refer to Section 2g of Attachment 5). The applicant's engineer will need to submit a revised
plan indicating the location of such a facility..
Parcel A2 is comprised largely of an existing wetland. The City of Shorewood's Comprehensive
Stormwater Management Plan does designate lower quality wetlands to be utilized for storm water
management. This particular wetland qualifies for such a use. Therefore, the proposed use appears
reasonable, subject to the other recommendations of this report.
Parcel B appears to remain as a turf area with minor modifications. These minor site improvements
have little implications with regard to drainage.
.
.
Planning Commission,
Mayor and City Council
Shorewood Yacht Club
November 2t 2000
Page 4 of4
Plans do not indicate any erosion controls for the construction of the new structure. The applicanes
Engineer will need to provide an erosion control plan which is acceptable to the City's Building
Official and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, as part of the building permit application.
Recommendations:
StaiIis recommending approval of the applicationt contingent upon the following conditions:
1.
A parking and storage easement shall be obtained from the Hennepin County Regional Rail
Authority for the proposed use. A certified copy of the easement documents shall be
supplied to the City of Shorewoodt and shall be in such a form as to be recorded against the
subject property. .
2. . The plans shall be revised to incorporate the necessary number of designated handicapped
parking stalls in accordance to State and Federal American with Disabilities Acts. Such plans
shall include a designated ADA route to and from the main facilities.
3._bn Erosion Control Plan shall be reviewed and approved by the City of Shorewoodts
Building Official and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District.
-- - ~r? ~)
; -IW~
1 t J I ~ . !1FROG ISlAAD
~~.~ N .~
1-.............. ~..-(G
I I~I.. -4
\~I'i~ . ..~ - _ ~
c ~I'/ ----~ I III -"'!: [~
.i Iy1 ~ I ,I ~'- ~ I"'"
~. . /. IJ!... ~R . ~~t:! . r1~, _ .
o I .~,.- I I I . I ~\ t)
x -. ~~ . \
. tIl J N'i:!.ili l~ ~-' -1 I .GILLt!. ~ .~.l-- \
II I -_,I I v;
~-L- __ .
. I J C --J 1"-, C1L",/i . ~ ..
~/I -,--Cr--,~ !'1c .....~ .~ ILL
.~- '1J v. 0 A I . L::S
9~ ~ ... /"'- I I j~
~ ~. . L......J . _ t
r \ .~ ____ I I i""
I I \ ~ 1.TJ-rr-:- ~
\\7 ~;
.\ MAl"\. '\ ,"-.. - IA~' ~ ~
I LAKE) \_ ~ L ~A'1 r- JA'.JE: I I I JF
\ \ ~ I v/ \ \ \ \ I
Attachment 1
Shorewood Yacht Club
Site Location Map
~
~
~.
~ ^
)~
.~
l.
oJ'
-
t
"
500
I
o
500 Feet
~
.
.
4.
ill
i
North
~
Attachment 2
Shorewood Yacht Club
Parcel References
.
.
4
~1
.
"1. " .
~~--::-:
.~,
:",
I,.
...i
".\
~
, 1!
. ":" t '"
, '- III
, O~
," : ,; i' T.~ ..
. . ,
, "
~.
: ('f':', ~
".I
"~itj'\\ '
~'A .1
."'\, J,.~, "
o.,"lto :.... .
"o."!'J;.o:-'; ,
' 't"','.;
:.J.:...:\.... . . .
".':;~...' .
.:'t tCi "
"./.~;"::"
"~~' : ',':: , ,
~Z
..,: '.'
.-. .
~~ '
.' '.j'!' .
.~ '
,,(.;,-\ .
'/;~'" "
, .
v__
I
',.~,.
'~;~~:I
. :-"r:-;
"
"
a)
CO
Attachment 3 acht Club
Shorewood Y Easements
Excerpt Survey-
.
U.S. Department of Justice
~ Civil Rights Division
Di.vabUity Rights Section
ADA
Design Guide
D
Accessible Parking Spaces
When a business, State or local
government agency, or other covered
entity restripes a parking lot, it must
provide accessible parking spaces as
required by the ADA Standards for
Accessible Design. Failure to do so
would violate the ADA.
.
In addition, businesses or privately
owned facilities that provide goods
or services to the public have a
continuing ADA obligation to
remove barriers to access in existing
parking lots when it is readily
. achievable to do so. Because
restriping is relatively inexpensive, it
is readily achievable in most cases.
This ADA Design Guide provides
key information about how to create
accessible car and van spaces and
how many spaces to provide
when parking lots
are restriped.
.
Accessible
Parking Spaces for Cars
Accessible parking spaces for cars
have at least a 60-inch-wide access
aisle located adjacent to the desig-
nated parking space. The access
aisle is just wide enough to permit a
person using a wheelchair to enter or
exit the cat. These parking spaces
are identified with a sign and located
on level ground.
page 1 of2
Restriping Parking Lots
Van-Accessible Parking Spaces
Van-accessible parking spaces are
the same as accessible parking
spaces for cars except for three fea-
tures needed for vans:
· a wider access aisle (96") to .
accommodate a wheelchair lift;
· vertical clearance to accommo-
date van height at the,van park:-
ing space, the adjacent access
aisle, and on the vehiCular route
to and from the van-accessible
space,and
· an additional sign that identifies
the parking spaces as "van
accessible."
e
One of eight accessible parking
spaces, but always at least one, must
be van-accessible.
Minimum Number of Accessible Parking Spaces
ADA Standards forAccessible Design 4.1.2 (5)
Total Number Van Accessible Accessible
of Parking Parking Spaces Parking
spaces with min. 96" Spaces with
Provided wide access min. 60" wide
(per lot) aisle aee.... aisle
1 to 25 1 0
26 to 50 1 1
51 to 75 1 2
76 to 100 1 3
101 to 150 1 4
151 to 200 1 5
201 to 300 1 6
301 to 400 1 7
401 to 500 2 7
501 to 1000
1/8 of Column A. 7/8 of Column A""
1/8 of Column A. 7/8 of Column A-
· one out of every 8 accessible spaces .. 7 out of every 8 accesslbl. parking spaces
Attachment 4
Shorewood Yacht Club
ADA Requirements
Location
· Accessible parking spaces must be
located on the shortest accessible
route oftrave1 to an accessible facil-
ity entrance. Where buildings have
multiple accessible entrances with
adjacent parking, the accessible
parking spaces must be dispersed
and located closest to the accessible
entrances.
.
When accessible parking spaces are
added in an existing parking lot,
locate the spaces on the most level
ground close to the accessible en-
trance. An accessible route must al-
ways be provided from the acces-
sible parking to the accessible en-
trance. An accessible route never
has curbs or stairs, must be at least 3-
feet wide, and has a firm, stable, slip-
resistant surface. The slope along
the accessible route should not be
greater than 1:12 in the direction of
travel.
Accessible parking spaces may be
clustered in one or more lots if
equivalent or greater accessibility is
provided in terms of distance from
the accessible entrance, parking fees,
and convenience. Van-accessible
parking spaces located in parking ga-
rages may be clustered on one floor
(to accommodate the 9S-inch mini-
mum vertical height requirement).
.
Free Technical Assistance
Answers to technical and general
questions about restriping parking lots
or other ADA requirements are avail-
a~le by telephone on weekdays. You
may also order the ADA Standards for
Accessible Design and other ADA
publications, including regulations for
private businesses or State and local
governments, at any time day or night.
Information about ADA-related IRS
tax credits and deductions is also
available from the ADA Information
Line.
Department of Justice
ADA Information Line
800-514-0301 (voice)
800-514-0383 (tty)
page 2 of2
Features of Accessible Parking Spaces for Cars
Sign with the international symbol of accessibility mounted high
enough so it can be seen while a vehicle is parked in the space.
If the accessible route is located in front of the space. install
wheelstops to keep vehicles from reducing width below 36 inches.
accessible route (min. 36-1000 width)
.. .Il....:..~:'..~.... ~.........
.::::.....
-:::::::;:-.
.............
.:::::::::.
.~::::::::..
.:~;::::::.
IIC::::::::~.
.:::::::::.
.:::::::::.
.~::::::::.
.::~::::::.
.:::::::::.
.:::::::::.
.,.:........
-.:::::::.
... ".i'.
} 96" min j~O" minJ 96" min. ~
2440 1525 2440
Access aisle of at least 6o-inch width
must be level (1 :50 maximum slope in
all directions). be the same length as
the adjacent parking space(s) it
serves and must connect to an ac-
cessible route to the building. Ramps
must not extend into the access aisle.
Boundary of the access aisle must be
marked. The end may be a squared
or curved shape.
Two parking spaces may share an
access aisle.
Three Additional Features for Van-Accessible Parking Spaces
Sign with "van accessible" and the international symbol of
accessibility mounted high enough so the sign can be seen when
a vehicle is parked in the space
accessible route
.......
... -.r.~~.~.~:.~...~..".. ~......
-:.:.:::::.:::::-
'lIIl::.:::::::::::_
00:::::::::::::::*
lIIl:: ::; '.. ....
I(~: .:::::::: :::*
:;;;;~~i~im;~:
llIC::::::::::::::_
lI!::::::::::::::.
.. ..........
J/96" min. 1/ 96" min. J 96" mint
2440 2440 2440
Internet
You may also review or download
information on the Department's
ADAlnternet site at any time. The
site provides access to ADA regula-
tions, technical assistance materials,
and general ADA information. It
also provides links to other Federal
agencies, and updates on new ADA
requirements and enforcement
efforts. Internet address:
www.usdoj.gov/crtlada/adahom1.htm
96" min. width access aisle, level
(max. slope 1:50 in all directions). l0-
cated beside the van parking space
Min. 98-lnch-high clearance at van
parking space. access aisle. and on
vehicular route to and from van space
Reference:
ADA Standards for Accessible
Design (28CFR Part 36):
~ 4.1.6A1terations;
~ 4.1.2 Accessible Sites and Exte-
rior Facilities: New Construction,
and
~ 4.1.6 Parking and Passenger.
Loading Zones.
Duplication of this document is encouraged.
The Board further finds that the proposed facility meets the requirements of LMCD Code Section
2.03 for a multiple dock license subject to the conditions and limitations hereinafter specified.
The proposed facility requires variances for dock length, side setback and dock use area. The Board
finds that a hardship exists within the meaning of LMCD Code Section 1.07 by reason of shallow
water conditions for the requested length variance and that the granting of the length variance is
warranted.
Side setback and jock use area variances are required between Sites One and Two because the
applicant proposes to gain access to the dock use area of Site Two by constructing a dock
connection to the facilities at Site One. Parking and access for Site Two would be through Site One.
.
The applicant asserts as a hardship or practical difficulty that there is not reasonable access for cars,
parking and pedestrians from Site Two. The applicant further asserts that Site Two is cmrently in a
relatively natural state which would be destroyed if Site Two were fully developed with adequate
parking, access and required amenities. However, there is adequate parking on Site One for both
sites, and amenities may be provided from Site One which would allow 1;he maintenance of Site
Two in a natural state.
TI1e Board finds that a hardship or practical difficulty within the meaning of LMCD Code Section
1.07 exists which justifies, the side setback and dock use area variances provided for herein subject
to the conditions and restrictions hereinafter set forth.
As noted above the dock use areas for Sites One and Two established by previous order of the
Board were based on erroneous information about ownership and boundary lines of riparian
properties. Because Site One and Site Two are now under common ownership, it is not necessary at
this time to specify dock use areas as between Sites One and Two based on corrected land title
information. However the variances and licenses granted hereby are conditioned on Sites One and
Two continuing to be under common ownership or control. In the future if the two sites cease to be
under common ownership or control, it will be necessary to reevaluate multiple dock licenses and
variances for both sites and the special density license for Site Two.
.
ORDER
On the basis of the foregoing, IT IS ORDERED that a new dock license, special density license and
length, setback and dock use area variances are granted for the proposed facility on the following
conditions: .
1. The dock facility shall be constructed and maintained in conformance with the dock plan
attached hereto as Attaclunent One and hereby made a part hereof.
2. The facility shall provide and maintain the following public amenities at Site One for the
special density license for Site Two:
a
Public rental of five or more boats with outboard motors.
b.
Provide free charter boat excursions or fishing trips for at least 100 handicapped or
underprivileged persons per year.
2 AnachnrentS
Shorewood Yacht Club
LMCD Order
CLL.182866v 1
LKIIO-4
-r
..
.
c. On site distribution of boating safety and environmental literature.
d. Sanitary pump out facilities available to the public at a reasonable charge.
e. Meeting rooms available to the general public.
f. Slip and boat use for emergencies and governmental agency'use.
6~ < Ho~_pond"furrun:fIwater2-quality~ --'"
"--=--c _~~
h. Vegetative screening and cover.
1. Shoreline protection.
. J. Eurasian watennilfoil off-load site.
k. Sailing school and camp.
1. Safety and lake use educational program.
m. Marine towing service.
n. Marine emergency repair service
o. Ramp use for emergencies.
3. Following the end of each license year, the licensee shall report on amenities provided
during such year, giving such information as is required by the Executive Director.
. '4.
Except for structures directly associated with slips having access from Site Two, all
eqUipment: goods, debris and structures will be removed from Site Two before the end of
2000 and Site Two shall be left in a natural, unimproved state.
S. No dockage at the facility shall be limited or restricted to use by persons having an interest
in specified riparian or non-riparian real property.
6. The licenses granted hereby shall automatically terminate without any action by the LMCD
at any time Site One and Site Two' cease to be under common ownership or control.
7. Neither Site One nor Site Two may be used for the off lake storage of watercraft in violation
ofLMCD Code, Section 2.045.
The license granted herein shall grant no vested right to the use of Lake Minnetonka. Such use shall
~t all times remain subject to regulation by the District to assure the public of reasonable and
equitable access to the Lake.
CLL-I82866vI
LKll().4
3
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD. MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us'cityhaJl@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
1 November 2000
RE:
Shorewood Yacht Club - Comprehensive Plan Amendment,
Rezoning, Conditional Use Permit and Variance
FILE NO.: .
405 (00.27)
This report is in response to issues raised at the last Planning Commission meeting
regarding the SYC application. Engineering issues will be addressed under separate
cover.
1.
Staff met with the applicant to suggest locations where additional landscaping
might enhance the buffering of the site. Exhibit A, attached, shows new
evergreen trees in the following locations on the site: two pines on the west side
of the main parking area to the west of the clubhouse; two pines between the
auxiliary parking area just south of the LRT trail; and six pine along County Road
19, south of the auxiliary parking area. These trees will help to fill in gaps in the
existing vegetation. The minimum size for these trees should be six feet in height.
.
It will be too late to plant these trees this year, so it is recommended that the
applicant submit a bid for the work to be done next spring. A letter of credit for
one and one half times the amount of the bid should be required, and should
extend for two growing seasons.
2. The Fire Marshall has inspected the gasoline storage shed and recommends the
installation of a solid core steel door.
ft
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Attachment IV
Memorandum
. Re: SYC
1 November 2000
..
3.
.
.
Commissioner Woodruff has spent a considerable amount of time trying to track
down information regarding the concern over suspended phosphates in the bottom
of Gideon's Bay. Neither the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District, the
Department of Natural Resources, nor the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District
have information or appear concerned about this issue. The Pollution Control
Agency has recently completed core sampling of various locations on Lake
Minnetonka. Their data has been turned over to the University of Minnesota for
analysis, which will not be completed for six months. Their samples only extend
six inches into the bottom.
Staff has contacted the Army Corps of Engineers, assuming they might have
information from their dredging permits. It turns out that they no longer have
jurisdiction over dredging permits on Lake Minnetonka. Even if they did, pile
driving for docks does not require a permit from them. We may still receive some
additional information from them.
The most enlightening information we have received to date comes from one of
the hydrologists at WSB, Shorewood's engineering consultant. Apparently,
phosphates do attach to silt and will eventually settle out to the bottom of the lake.
However, wave action in shallow areas will typically suspend the particles until
they can settle out in quieter, deeper waters.
It is recommended that the City suggest to the LMCD that it examine this issue as
part of their future studies of the lake.
4.
The applicants have state that they do not wish to have parents drop their children
off at Timber Lane for the sailing camp. The current process requires the parents
to check their children in at the main clubhouse each morning. The children
would then go over to the sailing camp area as a group. It is recommended that
the chain across the old driveway from Timber Lane be replaced with a gate. Use
of the driveway should be restricted to maintenance for the Yacht Club, and
access for the homeowner with the dock on the west end of the property. This
situation should be monitored in the future and the City should consider posting
"no parking" signs along Timber Lane if parking or access become a problem.
5. The sailing camp includes a storage rack to hold small sailboats. The original
plan by the applicant was to erect a boat dock canopy near the storage rack to
serve as a shelter for children at the sailing camp. The applicant now shows a
more permanent structure (a roof supported by wooden posts). It is recommended
that the earlier proposal should be approved, and that the canopy would be taken
down at the end of the boating season (e.g. the end of September). The storage
rack must be located 50 feet from the ordinary high water level of the lake.
-2-
.
.
Memorandum
· Re: SYC
1 November 2000
6. Any approval should be subject to the requirements of the LMCD through their
dock permitting process.
If the Planning Commission takes action on Thursday night, this matter will appear
before the Council at its 13 November meeting. The Council will direct staff to prepare
findings of fact, and formal action could occur at the 27 November meeting.
Cc: Larry Brown
John Cross
-3-
.
~
t--
.
t~~
rt~~~11
_ :;:. :t ",.-
~' ",
t . I
i; ',. i ... .~
rl t:l:
'h,";,~
,tel
't--...
e;J
) :~
V,! l\
~~
o : fl\
~
t
fTTi""i
I:..',
i ;~'l-' iT!
;.....
t. *.-!i!
ljihr
'I' " I
l't~i~:,
~ ': :;. ~:
h)
~.,:' :
.'.~~
~
~
~
~
'~,,:' ,",."
r-, '
"!"',
,
\ .
,,-,.
."\ .
. 'Of , ,
", \ ~"
...... \'
'( '\
., .
.\ '::
'J,\ "
", '- 'f.\ "(\
',~ .~~\
\ \...:.,
\ '"
~ ~\
\ .....,
\ .~
\ ~..,.
.,\..;,\...
oe..t.
". ~...\ ~
..\........x\
. . . ' ",Ii' ,: : ,;~".Ii,<
I. ~ I' ...... #.~ ~ 11-"", :;lh ~tf'; ",,'" .4\ 1,,",",
.....~17..;J', "'L:..Jt...-..t~~~~:
~\. ~--:-",,:"'-r:" ~.lt" -jl~
J'~;~::~~' ::.~~~.,~.~~:t ~~~:1.: r~:" .~ ~"
~ .. .~;,;'" . . \ . ,. :' .
'-'~'~.: : ~:' '/, .;:
\~\
,': ~l
~v~~
~:l'~
~
.....-0 . -'.
--........._~--.... .'~-'~~"'"
....~~~,,~"'" "t.. . <.., ','
0- ,. [l - '-~:t~';'~.
~:; .~ '7 ':;~;:.:;.. '..~ WI
.; ~ ' , ~ :~::'.~ --'l(~
t>;ltIt~r "
........ ~"'ft U.... t" :",t :~
~ _....~=!. r..~.......;\"
.. ~ I'
\'X ,\
.,!
S .
~
..: ~....
-.-..
\
"
.\........"''"'./"
""",~
\\~. 1;
.,
~:J
,.
f". ~.....,r........' ....
-.J... ~ v
~.. "J: )f'......i
'3
.), ./
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEgTING MINUTES - December 11, 2000
Page 7 of 10
.~
Discussion ensued regarding the potential verbiage regarding resolutions of these recommended areas of
concern.
Stover moved, Lizee seconded continuing this matter to January 8,2001, in an effort to allow the
City Planner to resolve the last three items with the applicant. Motion passed 5/0.
E. Ratification of Terms of Approval- Shorewood Yacht Club
A$ had happened in the past, Mayor Love recused himself from his position and turned the gavel over to
Councilmember Stover for action in this matter.
Director Nielsen stated this would be more of a report than an action item at this time. He explained the
applicant's difficulties in obtaining financing necessary for the legal combination of parcels to occur on
site. He stated the applicant was willing to place a deed restriction on the land related to these parcels
which granted the City a bit more control over the site. He noted all requests by the applicant were being
held until the deed restriction was recorded properly.
.
Stover moved, Garfunkel seconded, amending two actions-Ordinance No. 368 and the approval
of the Conditional Use Permit and Variance-taken at the November 27, 2000, City Council
Meeting, subject to the deed restriction being approved by the City Attorney.
Councilmember Zerby noted all information pertaining to this matter did not list the operation of the
Yacht Club as a marina. Director Nielsen responded all information did, however, consistently refer to it
as a Yacht Club.
Motion passed 4/0.
Acting Mayor Stover returned the gavel to Mayor Love. for action on the remainder of the Agenda.
8. FINANCE
A.
Consideration of a Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving the 2001 Budgets and
Approving the 2000 Property Tax Levy Collectible in 2001
.
Finance Director Burton reported on the following Resolutions noting the General Fund budget was in
the amount of $3,127,790.
Stover moved, Lizee seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-121, "A Resolution Approving the
2001 Budgets and Approving the 2000 Property Tax Levy Collectible in 2001." Motion passed 5/0.
B. Consideration of a Motion to Adopt a Resolution Establishing the 2001 Pay Scale
and City Insurance Contribution
Zerby moved, Garfunkel seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-122. "A Resolution
Establishing the 2001 Pay Scale and City Insurance Contribution." Motion passed 5/0.
C. Consideration of a Motion to Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the Transfer of
Funds
Lizee moved, Zerby seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-123, "A Resolution Authorizing
the Transfer of Funds." Motion passed 5/0.
Attachment V
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - November 27,2000
~ Page 3 of7
Commissioner Turgeon reported on the October 3, 2000, and November 21,2000, Planning Commission
Meetings.
A. Shorewood Yacht Club
1. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving an Amendment to the
Shorewood Comprehensive Plan - Land Use Plan
Director Nielsen confirmed Councilmember Zerby's understanding that this Resolution was not available
for action this evening. This resolution would be on the December 11, 2000, Regular City Council
Meeting Agenda.
2. A Motion to Adopt an Ordinance Amending the Zoning for the Shorewood
Yacht Club from R-IAlS and R-3A1S to L-R, Lakeshore Recreational
.
Director Nielsen noted the applicant was still trying to arrange financing for the legal combination of
parcels relative to this matter.
Councilmember Lizee stated she was very hesitant to make or vote on any motion related to this matter
until those lots were legally combined as requested earlier in this process.
Attorney Keane assured the Council this matter could be brought before the Council again for review in
ninety days if the combination had not been approved in that timefrain~. Also, Attorney Keane stated no
permits for any work on the site would be issued until these parcels were combined.
Garfunkel moved, Zerby ~econded, adopting ORDINANCE NO. 368, "An Ordinance Amending
the Zoning for the Shorewood Yacht Club from R-IAlS and R-3A1S to L-R, Lakeshore
Recreational," subject to withholding the publication for ninety days until the Applicant
demonstrates evidence of joinder of the property. If the Applicant fails to do so in ninety days, this
Ordinance will be brought back to the City Council for reconsideration. Motion passed 4/0.
.
3.
A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit and
Variance for the Shorewood Yacht Club.
In review of the proposed resolution, Director Nielsen noted he had reviewed a previous resolution
related to this matter from 1979, and had incorporated minor additions into this resolution from the 1979
resolution. He had picked items that were appropriate to this matter, but had not been addressed in this
process prior to this evening. He stated he had spoken to Mr. Cross, the applicant, and Mr. Cross had
only one comment related to the number of power boats requested for dockage. Mr. Cross had
previously expressed a need for two power boats, but would now like permission to dock three boats on
site in addition to a weed harvester-one of these would be a work boat used for towing boats back to the
Yacht Club in the event of problems, a second would be a cabin cruiser for use as a race commissioned
vessel, and a third runabout-style boat would be used as part of the sailing camp. Another item addressed
in the 2000 resolution included the ownership of the dock as related to the property owners at 5585
Timber Lane.
Councilmember Lizee noted these matters required passage by the City prior to Lake Minnetonka
Conservation District approval.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - November 27, 2000
Page 4 of7
Councilmember Stover confirmed the inclusion of Item "t." stating no permits would be issued without
meeting previous conditions set forth in this process.
Much discussion ensued related to the wording of Item ''t.'' with final determination being a request for
the item to read, "Prior to any further work alterations, including but not limited to dock pilings or
expansion, being done on the site, the Applicant must provide evidence that the land described on Exhibit
A, attached hereto and made a part hereof, has been legally combined into one tax parcel."
Garfunkel moved, Zerby seconded, adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-111. "A Resolution
Approving a Conditional Use Permit and Variance for the ShorewoodYacht Qub. Motion passed
4/0.
Acting Mayor Stover returned the gavel to Mayor Love for action on the remainder of the Agenda items.
B.
A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit for the
Expansion of the Clubhouse Facility at the Minnetonka Country Club
. Applicant: Bo Witrak representing the Minnetonka Country Club
Location: 24575 Smithtown Road
.
Director Nielsen reviewed background on this matter, noting th~s matt~r h~d been approved by Council in
1998, however, the construction had not taken place prior to exprratiof!. ~fthat permit. Whilec~clusions
were still valid from the previous application, the applicant had re~olved the golf cart storage issues of
concern to nearby residents through the proposed screening with shru~b~ along the westerly lot line to
take place next spring. . . ,. . .
Councilmember Lizee conflI'1lled the golf carts would be park~d b~eath the new Qverhang area created
in the construction of the ballroom addition: ., ",., . ... , , . ., .
.
Zerby moved, Stover seconded, adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-112, "A Resolution Approving a
Conditional Use Permit for the Expansion of the Clubhouse Facility at the Minnetonka Country
Club for Bo Witrak representing the Minnetonka Country Club, 24575 Smithtown Road." Motion
passed 5/0.
C. A Motion Directing Staff to Prepare a Resolution Approving a Lot Line
Rearrangement
Director Nielsen provided historical information related to this matter. He noted this request would
allow the lots to comply more equally with the RI-C zoning district. Also, this matter was only slightly
complicated by the fact that with the subdivision, the existing Shenehon cabin would become
nonconforming. In addition, the applicants plan to sell the property; and the new owner planned to
demolish the cabin in the spring.
Wheeler Smith, attorney for the current property owners, addressed Council, noting he would be
available for any questions anyone may have of him.
Gerald Goodlund, owner of the adjoining property, also addressed Council and stated the cottage had
been there for fifty years, and he had no objection to the cottage remaining an additional two months as
requested by the buyer for the property. He also stated, it would be nice environmentally to allow the
CITY OF SBOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 2, 2000
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
. 7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Bailey called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Chair Bailey; Commissioners Anderson, Callies, Turgeon, and Woodruff; Council
Liaison Lizee, and Planning Director Nielsen;
Absent:
Commissioners Boehm and Rosenberger; Engineer Brown
. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Chair Bailey briefly reviewed this evening"s Agenda and noted the Commission had received the
Planning Commission minutes from October 3,2000, immediately prior to this meeting and thus, no one
had time to review them.
Turgeon moved, Woodruff seconded, amending the Agenda to move this item to follow Item 4.
Motion passed 5/0.
1. CONTINUATION OF DISCUSSION FROM OCTOBER 3, 2000 PLANNING
COMMISSION MEETING REGARDING SBOREWOOD YACHT CLUB
.
. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
. REZONING FROM R.IA TO L.R
. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
. VARIANCE
Annlicant:
Location:
Minnetonka Moorings
600 West Lake Street
*For future reference, please note there are two Planning Commission memorandums onfile at City Hall
related to this meeting's discussions. One is a memorandum from Brad Nielson, dated November 1,
2000-referencing File No. 405(00.27). The second memorandum is from Larry Brown, dated November
1, 200O-referencing the Shorewood Yacht Club Proposed Rezoning, Compo Plan Amendment,
Conditional Use Permit, and Variance. Both these memorandums provide detailed analysis and
explanation in response to Commission's concerns as well as being specifically referenced as part of
motions for approval.
Chair Bailey briefly reviewed the process used in a Public Hearing, noting this item, if approved, would
appear on the City Council Agenda for November 13, 2000.
Director Nielsen summarized the history related to this matter. He also reminded the Commission it was
a continuation of a discussion held on October 3,2000, and changes could still be made in this matter.
He also noted some items of concern had been rectified.
Planning Commission Meeting Minutes-November 2, 2000
Page2of6
In review, Director Nielsen explained the Shorewood Yacht Club was comprised of three areas of land.
The main portion of the facility is located north of the Hennepin County Regional Rail Authority Right-
of-Way, also known as the LRT, which bisects the entire property. This portion of the site was bounded
by Lake Minnetonka, Minnetonka Portable Dredging Company, and the trail to the south. A second
portion of the facility, which lies immediately south of the LRT, was mainly comprised of wetland and
boat storage. The applicant had recently acquired an additional parcel of land located immediately west
of the main portion of the facility, north of the LRT, and east of Timber Lane. The acquisition of this
third parcel of land prompted a request to amend the Comprehensive Plan as well as rezoning,
conditional use permits and variance requests for additional dockage and structures on site.
.
At the October 3, 2000, Planning Commission Meeting, various issues were presented for discussion and
consideration. Director Nielsen reviewed them as the following: additional dockage of thirty~five boat
slips, a seasonal shelter near the Sailing Camp-now requested as permanent, an overflow parkinglboat
storage area, addition of an accessory building, and the construction of a small footbridge between the
main facility and the Sailing Camp area. He also noted the L~R district allowed for all proposed
constuction on this site. In addition, he commented the applicant stated, with regard to the overflow
parking area, the parking areas nearest the main facility were rarely filled to capacity and the overflow lot
was to be used only if absolutely necessary. Director Nielsen stated he believed it would be beneficial
for the applicant to leave the overflow portion of the site kept in a natural state as much as possible to
avoid hardcover problems as well as avoiding safety problems with accessing this area from County
Road 19.
Director Nielsen also explained he had met with the applicant to suggest locations where additional
landscaping might help to buffer the view of the facility from surrounding neighbors. The Fire Marshall
had examined the site as well and recommended the installation of a solid core steel door on the gasoline .
storage shed.
.
Director Nielsen thanked Commissioner Woodruff for her considerable time and effort spent trying to
obtain information from various public agencies, such as the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District, the
Department of Natural Resources, the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, and the Pollution Control
Agency, regarding the phosphates perhaps suspended in the bottom of Gideon's Bay. All agencies
contacted did not have any concrete information about potential phosphate problems for this area to share
at this time. However, hydrologists at WSB, Shorewood's Engineering Consultant, stated it was their
understanding that phosphates do attach to silt and will eventually settle out to the bottom of the lake.
However, wave action in shallow areas will continue to suspend the particles until they can settle out in
quieter, deeper waters.
The Army Corp of Engineers was also contacted, and while they do not currently maintain jurisdiction
over dredging permits for Lake Minnetonka, they were able to concur with the findings of the
hyrdrologist at WSB, noting there are three zones found in the lake related to phosphate particles. The
first is an erosional zone, where particles are subject to the action of the waves. A second zone was
referred to as transitional where matter fmds its way from one area to another, and the third zone was
depositional where the particles settle out in deeper water. Also, they reported, with regard to
construction of new pilings in that area, pile driving would produce a localized effect on the area.
However, if a "jet" process was utilized, the effects to the area could be more severe. It was
recommended, should dredging be required, that the pilings be "driven" rather than using the "jet"
method. The applicant reported there would be no need for dredging as part of this request for additional
dockage.
With regard to the issues of accessing Timber Lane for transporting children to. the Sailing Camp, the
applicants report current process has children dropped off at the main facility rather than utilizing Timber
Lane. It was recommended by Director Nielsen the chain, currently being used, be replaced with a more
.
.
Planning Commission Meeting Minutes-November 2, 2000
Page 3 of6
permanent barrier-such as a gate. Also, access to the driveway should be restricted to maintenance for
the Yacht Club, and access for the homeowner with an easement to the existing dock on the west end of
the property. In addition, it was recommended the situation be monitored in the future and consideration
of "No Parking" signs take place if access to the area becomes a problem. Recommendation for a shelter
near a storage rack included the use of a seasonal, rather than permanent structure for the children of the
sailing camp. Ultimately, Director Nielsen reported any approval of these plans should be subject to the
requirements of the LMCD through the dock permitting process.
Director Nielsen then summarized a memorandum from City EngineerlDirector of Public Works, Larry
Brown. Engineer Brown addressed issues of right-of-way, easements, and parking; grading, drainage,
and erosion controls; and made final recommendations about these issues of concern. He noted, with
regard to right-of-way issues, it appeared as if Mr. Cross had resolved the issues related to the acquisition
of approximately twenty-five feet from the Hennepin County Regional Rail Authority for the
parking/boat storage area. Director Nielsen also recommended the new parcel of land be legally
combined with other two parcels currently part of the Shorewood Yacht Club as a condition of approval.
Also, Director Nielsen stated, the proposed plan does not comply with the American Disabilities
Act(ADA) requirements. The new addition required designation of handicapped accessible parking
spaces-one "van accessible" and four additional handicapped parking spaces-all of which must be
paved to provide a suitable surface for ramp loading and unloading. It should also be noted the ADA
requirements may differ in number from the determination of the Uniform Building Code which is based
upon the total number of parking stalls proposed. Since this number is uncertain, some revision may
need to be made to the final recommendations of Engineer Brown, provided the applicant's engineer can
certify the State ADA requirements may justify a fewer number of parking spaces than what is currently
being proposed in the Engineering memorandum.
Concern over the parking area being so close to the lake were also examined. Findings, after an onsite
visit, indicated the lot actually drained away from the lake and sometimes had water standing on the
eastern edge. A brief review of the advantages/disadvantages were presented to the Commission
regarding the possiblity of paving this area as it pertained to drainage in the area. Final review of the
issue concluded the main parking area should remain an aggregate surface, with the exception of the
handicapped parking area referenced previously. Since the parking area would not be paved, a
recommendation to use curbstones to designate parking stalls was issued. Director Nielsen also reported
it appeared the existing wetland area provided good retention on site as part of the City's Stonnwater
Management Plan.
Erosion control measures shall be reviewed and approved by the City Building Official and the
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District as part of Engineer Brown's final recommendations.
In conclusion, Director Nielsen reported, it seemed as though all proposed plans, subject to final
recommendations of the Planning Director and City Engineer, concur with the L-R District zoning
requirements.
John and Judy Cross, owners of the Shorewood Yacht Club, were in attendance, and addressed the
Commission. Mr. Cross stated they appreciated the time spent on these matters; He stated the gate
would not be a problem to install as part of his plan, and he was willing to make adjustments, as needed,
to the parking areas.
Mrs. Cross commented she was responsible for the suggestion to incorporate a more permanent cedar
shelter, such as the one at Freeman Park, because it would look prettier than the originally proposed
seasonal shelter.
Planning Commission Meeting Minutes-November 2, 2000
. Page 4 of6
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 7:47 P.M.
Joann Schaub, 5465 Timber Lane, asked Mr. Cross the number of additional boat slips to be built in this
proposal. He replied there would be twenty-eight, plus the seven that are already there, totaling thirty-
five. She also commented most neighbors she had spoken with did not have a problem with the marina.
There were concerns about the parking taking place on Timber Lane and would appreciate the use of the
"No Parking". signs.
Dr. Thomas Alt, 23760 Lawtonka Drive, stated the vast majority of the townhome owners support the
proposed changes at the marina and thought the marina was quite pretty to look at as part of their view.
He viewed the parking on Timber Lane differently, noting people can pull off the street into the grass
area to park so the street would not be quite so congested.
.
Commissioner Callies stated this matter did not seem to be an appropriate part of the process involving
the marina issues. Commissioner Anderson asked if this matter of parking along Timber Lane could be
better solved through the parking permit process. Director Nielsen commented if the parking problem
came about as a concern from the marina it would be appropriate to this discussion, otherwise, it should
be dealt with as a separate matter at a different time.
Hearing no further testimony pertaining to the matter appearing before the Commission, Chair Bailey
closed the Public Hearing at 7:52 P.M.
Commissioner Callies asked Director Nielsen about the different viewpoints regarding the use of canvas
or cedar on the shelter in the Sailing Camp area. He explained the cedar would be very visible during the
winter months in that area versus the use of the seasonal canvas being removed, and allowing the area to
be more natural looking.
.
Commissioner Woodruff stated she had a number of comments to share with the Commission. First, she
confirmed the curbstones would be included as part of the parking permit process. Secondly, she
questioned the possible use of landscaping around the parking lot area to slow the amount of runoff to the
lake. Director Nielsen explained there is a ridge from grading around the lot currently to deter the water
from running into the lake, and also the space in that area appeared to be rather limited for landscaping.
She also asked if it seemed necessary to get runoff to the pond area. Director Nielsen responded he did
not believe this to be a critical issue at this time. In addition, Commissioner Woodruff stated she had
deep concerns regarding the potential in the future for driving pilings and potential phosphates in the.bay
area. She strongly believed a study should be conducted in the area as she believed there were as many
as seven treatment plants draining to that area into the 1970's. Her main concern with this matter was the
potential for heavy metals, such as mercury, to be entering the food chain as a result of previous uses of
the bay area.
Commissioner Turgeon expressed concern for the specifics of the details being discussed. She stated her
concern about the legal combination of parcels, as well as potential dredging in the future at this site.
She also stated her preference for the seasonal canopy on the shelter in the Sailing Camp area. She
clarified wording to be used related to the overflow parking area, noting the City's preference that no
parking take place there unless absolutely necessary.
Director Nielsen stated it would be sensible to clarify the large number of potential additions being
discussed by the Commission this evening. The following items were specified as additional conditions
for approval by the Planning Commission.
Planning Commission Meeting Minutes-November 2, 2000
.. Page5of6
1) The new parcel of land, referenced as "Parcel Bn in the November I, 2000,
Memorandum from Larry Brown, be legally combined the remainder of the Shorewood
Yacht Club property.
2) The shelter at the Sailing Camp shall be a seasonal canopy, rather than a permanent
covering.
3) There will be no dredging taking place as part of the City's approval in this request. Any
requests in the future would be subject to normal dredging permit process procedures.
4) Any future proper use of the overflow parking area, shown on the Site Plan in the
southwest corner of the site, would be subject to review and approval by the Planning
Conunission.
5)
The American Disibilities Act parking spaces must be consistent with the Uniform
Building Code requirements and subject to conditions imposed by the Lake Minnetonka
Conservation District.
.
6)
Any pilings needing to be installed would be "driven" rather than using the "jet" method
of installation.
7) The gate referenced in Item Four of the November 1, 2000, memorandum from Brad
Nielsen, will be installed in place of the current chain as detailed in that memorandum.
8) Curbstones shall be placed for each parking stall on site.
Director Nielsen stated these conditions could be included in the Conditional Use Permit if approved.
Anderson moved, Callies seconded,. amending the Shorewood Comprehensive Plan to include
''Parcel B," referenced in the November 1, 2000, Memorandum from Larry Brown regarding this
matter, be placed into the L-R District. Motion passed 5/0.
.
Anderson moved, Callies seconded, recommending approval of the Conditional Use Pennit as
approved at the October 3, 2000, Planning Commission Meeting as well as including the conditions
listed previously, and in staff recommendations found in Memorandums, dated November 1, 2000,
from Larry Brown and Brad Nielsen, to the Planning Commission and City Council regarding this
matter.
Commissioner Callies commented she was not sure the dredging issue was necessarily appropriate as part
of the specified conditions.
Motion passed 4/1, with Woodruff dissenting, because of the uncertainty of what lies on the lake
bottom in this bay area.
Commissioner Anderson excused himself from the meeting at 8:27 P.M.
Mr. and Mrs. Cross thanked the Conunission for their efforts related to this matter.
2. MATTERS FRO~ THE FLOOR
There was no one present wishing to address matters from the floor this evening.
PLANNING COMMISSION MIl'" "'BS
,OCTOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 3
-
The public hearing was opened at 7 :35 P.M.
Mrs. Jeannie Polston, 28215 Boulder Circle was in attendance and addressed the Commission to explain
there was a title search in progress related to the unbuildable parcel to be combined. Barring any
contrary findings, she did not anticipate any problems with these suggestions.
Mr. Darrell Carver, 27910 Smithtown Road, asked Mrs. Polston if there were to be trees planted around
the new garage. She responded the area around the garage is quite wooded, and while no new additional
trees were to be planted on the south side of the garage, she did not believe Mr. Carver would be able to
see the new garage.
The public hearing was closed at 7:40 P.M.
Commissioner Woodruff questioned whether there was a plan to plant trees to screen the garage from the
east. Mrs. Polston stated they were planning to plant a few evergreen trees on that side of the garage in
an effort to provide screening.
.
Anderson moved, Woodruff seconded, recommending approval of a Conditional Use Permit for
Accessory Space in Excess of 1200 Square Feet, for Steve and Jeannie Polston, 28215 Boulder
Circle, subject to the applicant providing a landscape plan showing where trees would be planted
for screening. Motion passed 5/0.
3. 7:30 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING
. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
. REZONING FROM R-1A TO L-R
. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
. VARIANCE
Applicant:
Location:
Minnetonka Moorings
600 West Lake Street
.
*For future reference, please note there is a Planning Commission memorandum on file at City Hall
from Brad Nielsen, dated September 27, 2000-referencing File No. 405(00.27). This memorandum
explains. in significant detail, the history cind analysis surrounding these requests.
Director Nielsen provided a detailed explanation of the issues involved in these requests. He explained
John and Judy Cross, representing Minnetonka Moorings and working through the Shorewood Yacht
Club facility, had submitted an application for rezoning of their property. In doing so, a Conditional Use
Permit, Variance, and an amendment to the Shorewood Comprehensive Plan were necessitated. Involved
in this property and further complicating matters was the recent acquisition of a parcel of land
immediately west of the Yacht Club where Mr. and Mrs. Cross were proposing additional dockage in an
effort to expand their business. In reviewing this matter, Director Nielsen provided information as it
pertained to the existing site and then regarding the expansion site. Some issues pertain to both sites.
First, Director Nielsen explained that any rezoning must be guided by the Comprehensive Plan set forth
by the City. When amended last, efforts were made to pave the way, should an opportunity arise, to
bring the marinas into compliance with the Lakeshore Recreational (L-R) zoning district. In considering
the L-R District Requirements, there are Permitted Uses, Accessory Uses, and Conditional Uses relating
to Single-Family Dwellings, Open and Outdoor Dry Land Storage of Boats and Trailers, Lot
Requirements and Setbacks, Building Requirements, and Special and Specific Conditions. Following is a
brief summary of the comparison between the subject property and these requirements as detailed by
PLANNING COMMISsioN MIl' "SS
9CTOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 4
..
Director Nielsen. A more significantly detailed discussion of these issues can be found in the Planning
Commission referendum referenced at the beginning of this Item.
The permitted use in the L-R district was subject to annual licensing procedure and had as its only use
the water-harboring of boats. Specifically, the L-R district stated the water-harboring of boats in
Gideon's Bay must be limited to sailing boats.
The L-R District had off-street parking, a clubhouse building, a storage building, gas dispensing
equipment and boat rental as allowable uses for this area. The Shorewood Yacht Club had all of these.
The storage building on the site was to be removed, however, its proposed use as a dumpster enclosure
was deemed more useful, as a roof over the area would help to conceal it from the Hennepin County
Regional Railroad Authority trail which bisects the property.
With regard to the single family dwelling on the property as part of its Conditional Uses, all setback
requirements were observed, however, it would need to comply with the Shorewood Rental Housing
Code and would need to be inspected for conformance.
.
While there were many issues to be examined regarding Open and Outdoor Dry Land Storage of Boats
and Trailers, the most significant matter seemed to be a need for a detailed landscaping plan for the area
demonstrating a plan for screening of evergreen trees between the parking lot and shoreline, along the
South edge of the property facing County Road 19, as well as maintaining existing vegetation abutting
the Right-of-Way near the H.C.R.R.A trail.
Director Nielsen complimented the Yacht Club on their lighting noting it was very well done for its use
as well as being sensitive in its impact on the neighbors.
There was concern for the boat storage on the site, noting that if aU parking sites would be utilized and .
boats stored on the site as well, the need would exceed supply. An alternative parking/storage area was
proposed in. the vacant southwest comer of the site abutting County Road 19. Parking was considered an
area to monitor and adjust as needed.
.
The most significant concern overall seemed to be the proximity of parking and storage so close to the
shoreline. While enhanced landscaping would help to mitigate potential problems, it was recommended
that the parking areas near the lake be examined by many agencies in an effort to address issues of
drainage directly into the lake from this site.
With regard to Signage found in the Special and Specific Conditions portion of the L-R District Zoning
Code, the Shorewood Yacht Club had three signs while the requirements stated that only two signs would
be allowed.
At this point, Director Nielsen explored the background related to the expansion site and requests made
regarding this portion of land as it related to the Shorewood Yacht Club. He noted three additional docks
existed on this site primarily for the use of certain residents on Timber Lane.
The applicants would like to add a fourth dock to the existing system, providing thirty-five additional
slips. One of the docks would be maintained as a slip for a property owner at 5585 Timber Lane. The
easternmost of the three docks would be for one of their management boats utilized in assisting
customers in need of help.
PLANNING COMMISSION Mil" 138
pcrOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 5
When considering issues involved in the expansion site, Director Nielsen explained, it would be
important to consider issues of Parking and Access, as well as Boat Traffic and Existing Dock Rights.
Parking and Access on the expansion site was recommended to include emergency vehicles only. With
the exception of a proposed boat canopy used to protect the Sailing School students from the elements
and a sailboat storage rack, the site should remain in a natural undeveloped state.
Boat traffic was believed to increase by approximately forty percent as a result of the proposed plans for
this site, however, no dredging of the lake bottom would be required to accommodate the additional slips.
Existing Dock Rights should be maintained for the exclusive use of the residents of 5585 Timber Lane
only as part of consideration of the expansion site.
Director Nielsen summarized his comments noting he believed the plans to be well done and addressed
many issues identified in the past. He stated there would be many improvements to the property and the
expansion and rezoning would allow the City to gain more control over the property. He also noted a list
of names had been submitted to the City noting no opposition to the proposed plans for this site.
.
John and Judy Cross were in attendance and seized the opportunity to address the Commission. Mr.
Cross noted he had few disagreements to the recommendations Director Nielsen had reviewed. He also
noted there was no current need for the overflow parking/storage area, but did not want this to be an issue
at the time it would be needed in the future.
Mrs. Cross addressed the issue of the third sign facing the lake. She stated she considered it more of a
"landscape embellishment" as it was made of rope and occupied a flower bed. She stated the members
liked it, and it could only be seen from the lake, however, it was not needed. She also stated the
neighbors that can see the property have no objection to it being there.
Mr. Cross also expressed disappointment in the necessary delay for formal approval of the
Comprehensive Plan Amendment. Mrs. Cross noted there are forty-one .people on a waiting list for the
proposed slips, and they were hoping to have the dockage ready next spring. The timeframe that would
occur as part of the formal approval process would not allow that to happen.
.
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 8:40 P.M.
Dwayne V., 5585 Timber Lane, stated his concern regarding the noise coming from the hollow booms on
the sailboats, and a concern over the potential overflow lot on the southwesterly comer of the property.
He stated he had lived at his address for twenty-eight years and knew the locale of the proposed driveway
onto County Road 19. He voiced concern for safety in that area should the overflow lot be needed.
James Hancock, 23800 Lawtonka Drive, stated he was very much in favor of these requests as he
believed it to be a more favorable use of property.
Steve and Nancy Linder, 23730 Lawtonka Drive, were in attendance. Mr. Linder addressed the
Commission with his request to reconsider dockage for the Gideon Cove residents. He state it was his
prior knowledge that additional docks had been denied in that area as a general rule, and he was surprised
to see this request coming forward for approval.
Joann Schaub, 5465 Timber Lane, was very concerned for traffic utilizing the proposed overflow parking
area. She questioned Mrs. Cross as to whether emergency vehicles were currently utilizing that area.
Mrs. Cross responded the police may be monitoring that area, but she was not sure. Mrs. Schaub
commented she had seen vehicles removing the chain and driving in on previous occasions.
PLANNING COMMISSION MTI ES
DCTOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 6
.
Julie Ingelman, 23720 Lawtonka Drive, stated her concerns over the timing of this issue, and the Gideon
Cove request for additional dockage being denied. She also noted parking seemed to be quite crowded
on the Yacht Club property, and she would like to see the mess along the H.C.R.R.A. trail cleaned up as
she utilized the trail daily
Dan Puzak, 23830 Smithtown Road, expressed concern over the lakeshore and lake bottom. He stated
this area previously served as a drainage area for the Excelsior Sanitary Sewer Treatment facility and it
was his belief that it was one of the most polluted areas of lake bottom in that area. He stated he would
like to see a viable business run in that area with clean-up of the lake bottom. He did not support these
requests due to the muck on the lake bottom potentially being disturbed. He also had concerns for traffic
on Lawtonka Drive. He believed if it was not fenced off, it would create an eyesore in that area.
Donna Delaney, 23760 Lawtonka Drive, stated her support for the improvements to the existing marina
site. She noted she did not hear any noise, and the sailboats are a beautiful view. She did, however, have
concerns regarding the proposed drive down Timber Lane. Regarding the muck on the bottom, she
believed Lake Minnetonka to be a large lake, and she did not see the muck on the bottom affecting the
rest of the lake as a whole.
.
Judy Cross again spoke to address concerns regarding the proposed driveway entrance. She stated there
is a process in place used for pick-up and drop-off of students for the sailing school. She did not want
the additional responsibility of dealing with students being dropped off in the proposed driveway
entrance area. The current process would continue to be enforced regarding the students being
transported to the sailing school.
John Cross also stated that by removing the middle dock of the three on the expansion site, the area
would be left in a more natural state.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 9:04 P.M.
Commissioner Anderson stated his two concerns to be related to storage and screening of the boats, and
the close proximity of the parking to the lake. Also, he believed access to Timber Lane should be
controlled.
.
Commissioner Turgeon commented she had concerns related to proposed versus actual numbers of
parking spaces on the site. Also, she did not want to see another driveway placed onto County Road 19
in that area. Furthermore, she believed sensitivity should be used when considering implications from
the muck on the bottom of the lake. She stated she would like to approach appropriate agencies and
authorities to fmd out what is on the lake bottom in this area.
Commissioner Woodruff echoed Commissioner Turgeon's comments regarding the environmental
impacts in and around this area. Commissioner Boehm also supported concerns regarding environmental
impacts on this site. He also expressed concern for the parking situation and proposed overflow area.
Chair Bailey reminded the Planning Commission of the efforts put into the Comprehensive Plan. He
believed these plans to be a positive step forward, and he did not want to lose sight of the opportunity to
bring this property incompliance.
Much discussion centered on how to allow the applicants to move forward with plans' although a formal
Comprehensive Plan amendment could not be approved this evening.
.
.
PLANNING COMMISSION MIJ ES
.OCTOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 7
'lI
Commissioner Anderson commented it seemed as though Mr. Cross had acted in good faith and. he
wanted to see the Yacht Club brought into compliance. He noted the approval process can sometimes
appear daunting, and he believed it best to work with the Yacht Club on these matters.
Anderson moved, Boehm seconded, recommending approval of rezoning the parcels in question,
the Conditional Use Permits as presented, and a variance-for John and Judy Cross, representing
Minnetonka Moorings, 600 West Lake Street, subject to fmal approval of the Comprehensive Plan
Amendment and submittal of a professional Landscape Plan, also a plan for controlling the access
to Timber Lane, and an Engineering Report on the matters of the new proposed parking spaces
and existing parking near the lake to be presented on November 2, 2000, as well as scheduling a
public hearing for a formal Comprehensive Plan Amendment on November 2, 2000.
Commissioner Turgeon stated she believed it would be possible to move forward with these requests.
Commissioner Anderson reiterated that it can be a cumbersome process to move government along, but
he believed the Shorewood Yacht Club to be an asset to the City, and he would like to work with the
Yacht Club to move matters forward.
Motion passed 5/0.
4. RECOMMENDATION REGARDING GIDEON GLEN
Director Nielsen stated the City Council had authorized up to $175,000 for the acquisition of the Gideon
Glen property. The Minnehaha Creek Watershed District had agreed to provide up to $200,000 to help in
the acquisition. Other funding sources were being considered as well in an effort to minimize
expenditures for the property.
He also explaiIied there are a number of purposes for securing this property-one of them being wetland
preservation. He also noted the acquisition of this property would be consistent with the Comprehensive
Plan for the City.
Woodruff moved, Anderson seconded, recommending approval for the purchase of the Gideon
Glen property. Motion passed 5/0.
5. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
Mr. Jerry Brekke, Howard's Point Marina, was in attendance and stated it was good to see the Planning
Commission work as a group to resolve tough issues. He state he had remained at this meeting because
he wanted to pay the Planning Commission the compliment of doing a good job.
Chair Bailey thanked him for his fme compliment.
6. DRAFT NEXT MEETING AGENDA
The next meeting for the Planning Commission would be November 21, 2000, and would include two
items as well as a discussion regarding Right-of-Way issues.
7. REPORTS
Chair Bailey stated he would be the City Council Liaison for the month of October, 2000.
.
.
PLANNING COMMISSION MI 'ES
OCTOBER 3, 2000 - PAGE 8
~
8. ADJO~NT
Anderson moved, Woodruff seconded, adjourning the meeting at 10:02 P.M. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Sally Keefe,
Recording Secretary
~.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO. 00-111
A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AND VARIANCE
FOR A YACHT CLUB TO MINNETONKA MOORINGS, INC.
WHEREAS, Minnetonka Moorings, Inc. (Applicant) has an interest in certain real
property located at 600 West Lake Street in the City of Shorewood, County of Hennepin, State of
Minnesota, legally described in Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant proposes to ex.pand the Shorewood Yacht Club, which
currently occupies the property, add an accessory storage building and additional dock slips; and
.
WHEREAS, the existing Shorewood Yacht Club is a nonconforming use in the R-1AlS
and R-3A1S zoning districts and operates under a court-ordered conditional use permit which was
issued by the City of Shorewood in Council Resolution 24-79, which resolution is on file in the
Shorewood City offices; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has agreed to rezone the subject property to the L-R,
Lakeshore Recreational District, in which the existing caretaker dwelling on the property and the
outdoor storage of boats require a conditional use permit, pursuant to Section 1201.24 Subd. 4 of
the Shorewood City Code; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has requested a variance to the setback requirements for on-
site parking on the property; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the City l?lanner, and his
recommendations were duly set forth in memoranda to the Planning Commission dated 27
September 2000, and 1 November 2000 which memoranda are on file at City Hall; and
.
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the City Engineer, and his
recommendations were duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated
1 November 2000, which memorandum is on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, after required notice, a public hearing Was held and the application was
reviewed by the Planning Commission at their regular meeting on 3 October 2000, the minutes
of which meeting are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request for a conditional use permit and variance was
considered by the City Council at its regular meeting on 13 November 2000, at which time the
Planner's memoranda, the City Engineer's memorandum and the minutes of the Planning
Commission were reviewed and comments were heard by the Council from the City Staff.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
Attachment VI
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. That the Subject Property is located in an R-I/A, Single-Family
ResidentiaVShoreland and R-3A1Multiple-Farnily Residential/Shoreland zoning district and
contains approximately 4.7 acres.
2. That the subject property currently exists as two parcels of land as described in
Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
3. That the westernmost parcel is currently occupied by three dock structures that
were originally intended for use by certain residents on Timber Lane. The westernmost dock is
accessed by an easement in favor of the owner of the property located at 5585 Timber Lane.
.
4. That the Shorewood City Council has agreed to rezone the subject property to the
L-R, Lakeshore Recreational District, upon proof of recording of the deed conveying property
described in Exhibit A to Shorewood Yacht Club that shall contain the following language:
"Grantee shall not convey this property to any other person or entity without including in
the conveyance, the property described on the attached Exhibit A (being the property
immediately contiguous to the subject property lying to the east), without prior written
consent of the City of Shorewood."
5. That a clubhouse facility, a caretaker dwelling, a boat launch ramp and boat
docking for 80 sailboats plus 2 management slips currently occupy the site.
6. That, in addition to the water harboring of boats, the Applicant's application
proposes the following activities for the subject property: 1) sailboat rental; 2) sailing school; 3)
incidental boat sales; and 4) storage of weed harvesting equipment.
.
7: That the Applicant proposes to extend a fourth pier from the westernmost existing
pier on the site, increasing the number of boat slips from 82 to 117.
8. That the Applicant proposes to construct a small pedestrian bridge between the
existing Yacht Club property and the newly acquired westerly parcel.
9. That the Applicant proposes to locate a small sailboat storage rack for the use of a
youth sailing school which will be conducted on the westerly parcel.
10. That the Applicant proposes to erect a boat dock frame and canopy on the
westerly parcel to be used as a shelter for the youth sailing school.
11. That the Applicant's plans show parking for 121 vehicles.
12. That the Applicant's plans are illustrated in the site plans shown on Exhibits B
and C, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
2
~
13. That the subject property is located on a lake with at least two public accesses and
is at least 5000 feet away from any other multiple dock facility.
14~ That the subject property currently displays three signs, whereas the Shorewood
City Code limits the number of signs in the L-R District to two.
15. That the City has no record of complaints of noise in recent years relative to the
subject property.
16. That the Applicant proposes additional landscaping and screening along the west
side of the site, abutting the shoreline of the lake and along the south side of the H.C.R.R.A.
right-of-way and along the south side of the site abutting County Road 19, as shown on Exhibit
D, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
CONCLUSIONS
. 1. That based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby grants the Applicant's
request for a conditional use permit for a sailing yacht club at 600 West Lake Street.
2. That this approval is subject to the following conditions:
a. The Applicant must comply with the requirements of Section 1201.24 of the
Shorewood City Code and must obtain an annual license for the facility, pursuant
to Subd. 10 of that section.
b. The Applicant must obtain a multiple dock license, special density license and
necessary variances from the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District.
c.
The permit shall be limited to the docking of sailboats, except for three power
boats used by the management of the Yacht Club. In addition, the dock located at
the westernmost end of the subject property shall be limited to one boat owned by
the residents of 5585 Timber Lane. Weed harvesting equipment shall not count
against the allowable number of power boats.
.
d. The proposed buildings shall be constructed as shown on Exhibits B and C,
attached hereto and made a part hereof, and must be constructed in compliance
with the Minnesota StateBuilding Code.
e. Landscaping shall be installed and maintained according to the approved
landscape plan as shown on Exhibit D, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
Landscaping shall be completed by 15 June 2001.
f.
Hours of operation shall be as follows:
Sunday through Thursday:
Friday through Saturday:
6:00 A.M. to 10:00 P.M.
6:00 A.M. to 1 :00 A.M.
3
g. Dock quiet hours shall be between the hours of 10:00 P.M and 6:00 A.M.
h. Sailboats, when not in use, shall have their halyards secured by such devices as
will minimize any noise that may be caused by them.
1. Right-of-way shall be given to all barges and work boats being used by the
adjacent dredging company.
J. Any radios utilized on-board sailboats shall be kept below decks with their
volume at a discreet level.
k. The Applicant shall install a solid core steel door on the gasoline storage shed, per
the requirements of the Fire Marshall. Gasoline storage shall be limited to that
which is used by the management of the Yacht Club.
1.
The shelter for the youth sailing camp shall be a seasonal boat dock canopy to be
taken down at the end of the sailing season.
.
m.
The storage rack for the youth sailing camp shall be located 50 feet back from the
. ordinary. high water level of Lake Minnetonka.
n. The access drive from Timber Lane to the westerly portion of the site shall be
gated and locked except for occasional maintenance activities. The driveway
shall not be used as access to the youth sailing camp.
o. No dredging is anticipated as part of this permit. Any future dredging requests
will be subject to normal dredging permit procedures.
p. Any dock pilings to be installed must be driven as opposed to ajetting method.
.
q.
The American Disabilities Act parking spaces must be constructed consistent with
the State Building Code and are subject to the conditions imposed by the Lake
Minnetonka Conservation District.
r. Curbstones shall be installed for each parking stall on the site.
s. The overflow parking area shown on Exhibit B in the southwest comer of the site
is not approved as part of this permit.
t. Prior to any further work being done on the site, the Applicant must provide in
recorded form, evidence that the deed for the land described in Exhibit A, attached
hereto and made a part hereof, contains the following language:
"Grantee shall not convey this property to any other person or entity without
including in the conveyance, the property described on the attached Exhibit A
(being the property immediately contiguous to the subject property lying to the
east), without prior written consent of the City of Shorewood."
4
.
.
u. The Applicant shall submit a signage plan for the property in compliance with the
requirements of the Shorewood City Code.
3. That the Applicants have satisfied the criteria for the grant of a variance under the
Shorewood City Code and has established an undue hardship as defined by Minnesota Statutes.
4. That based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby grants to the Applicants a
setback variance for the parking lot as shown on Exhibit B, subject to the conditions set forth
herein.
5. That the City Administrator/Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to provide a
certified copy of this resolution for filing with the Hennepin County Recorder or Registrar of
Titles.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 27th day of
November 2000.
ar:;;J
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
&4I/ri fbd~
BRADLEY J. EN, CTING CITY ADMINISTRATOR/CLERK
5
:lescri -et:ion &
?a:rce:' 1':
rhat :part of Goveroment Lot; 2, Section 34, ToWnship 117, Range 23, described
is follows: Beginning at the intersection of the Southerly extension of the
Sast line of Lot 24, "Auditor's SUbdivision NUmber 313, Hezmepin County,
<!innesota" with a line drawn parallel "with and 25.00 feet Southerly from the
:enter line of the railroad track of the Chicago and North Western
rransportation C01l\l;la11Y (formerlY tbe Minneapolis and st. Louis Railway
:0It\PUY); thence Westerly along said parallel line a distance of 621.26 feet;
:he.."lce southeasterlY 29.64 feet, more or less, to a point which is on a line
1rawn parallel with and 50.00 feet southerly from center line of said railroad.
:rac)c and 606.53 feet Westerly along the last described'pa.rallel line from the
iloutherly extension of the East line of said Lot 24; thence westerly along the
Last described. parallel line to the west line of said GOverDllllimt. Lot 21 thence
ilouth along sald Westlina to the.center line of 'county Road Number 19; thence
lJorthe&sterly along the center line of county Roa4 Nwllber 19 to the southerly
extension of the East line of said Lot 24; thence North alnng said extension
to ~e point of beginning. Hennepin County, Kitrneso.ti'a.
Parcel 2:
.
that part of Government Lot 2, Section 34, Township 117, Range 23, described
alii follows: Beginning at the intersection of the East line of Lot 24,
"Audicor's SUbdivision NUmber 313, Hennepin county, Minnesota",' with a line
drawn parallel with and 18.00 feet Northerly from the center line of the
rdJ.road track of the Chicago and lforth Western 'l'ransportation Conp~
(formerly the Minneo.poUs end St. Louis :Railway Company); thence Westerly
along sa.id parall.l line a distance of 639.2'1 feet; thence Northwesterly to
the southwest corner of Lot 25, -Auditor'S SUbdivision lfWllber 313, Hennepin
CountY, Kinnesota", thence East.Jt'ly &long the Southerly line of said Lot 2S to
the Southerly extension of the Bast line of said Lot 24; thence South alonsi
sa:l.11 ex.tension to. the point of beiJinning.
Exeept," that por.tion' of tbe above parcels 1 end 2 embrace4 within Lot 291
luditor!8 SUbdivision Number 13,5 Hennepin~, Minnesota.
~
.
Parc~li 3& .
rhat .p~rt of Lot 25. lying Westerly of the following described line: .
Commencing at .the southeasterly corner of Lot 24: thence South along the Bast
line of said Lot 2S a distance of 24.30 teet: thence deflecting right 79
degrees 25' minutes 40 seconds a distance of 406.48 feet: thence deflecting
right ~ degrees 49 minutes 20 seconds t:o a point on the southerly line of
said Lot 2S \IIhich is the true point ()f beginning of the line beinq described.,
thence continuing along last described line to the shore line of.Lake
Kinnetonka and there ending, "Auditorls Subdivision Number 313, Hennepin
Cnunty, Hinnesota. II '
Together with a 12 foot easement for road purposes, the center ltne of \IIhich
is described as follows& Commencing at the southeast corner of Lot 24 af
said Auditorls Subdivision: thence South along the Bast line Qf said Lot 25, a
distance of 24.30 feet to the point of beginning of the line bein~ described,
thence deflecting right 81 degrees S9 minutes a distance of 379.0 feet: thence
deflecting right 58 degrees 52 minutes a distance" of 46.06 feet to a point on
the Bast line of above-described property and there ending, as shown in aeed
Document NUmber 1052891, Files of Registrar of Tities7 (as to Parcel 3)
,Parcel 4.:
That part: of Gove:rmnent Lot 1, Section 34, township 117, Range 23, described.
as Lot: 293, Auditor's.Suhdivision No. 135 and adjacent 60 feet of
Minneapolis and St. Paul SUburban Railway abandoned right-of-way (lVO'l'B: Lot:
293 all under water)."
Exhibit A
J21
'r
- ,
~
- .
-t
GJ
..d.
1M
J.,JJ
IIJl?1
~"\~IJI
i1'T~
'rJJ-
1:!;!iI'i'
1~1':11~,;
" ; ~:
,y' .!
, '"
I ~~~
1,-
t :~,,~;,~~ ~
! ? r: ~:;'-." II
..-.....~....~-..,
[I i ;;->"
\HWII
fe "I"d-!
". ,. I
1..'; i
I . ::,,1
"I'r,'~
. .r:l~
'. 'I ;.,
., :,:F, r
d.L..
I . I ....
;.t:41:.~i~i
,. ~IJY!~
.n .L!t.~.,
;~l'ntt~__.
!
I
I
I
I
. ~ ~. .0"
/C::::~rf:<"'~:" .'
. "'~,o!'_.....'.....
1;!.\'~;' \
~~~~~~~~
\ ;.~-:.~, ~
..".
"' ...
.
"
.:
.~....::~~ ~~~:',~;:.~~~;.;' .:c:-.,"~~::i.~~~~~;,
.
.
\.
A:'l.
Y \0
I ~. "'-,
Ii'
i
i
..1."
.":'Lo..."
i:~ .
\~t:
;~7.~
:l:a
~~
~.l
."
.
!
'\
.\.
\
;
\
\
i-- .
. \~~"'~~';::--...~~.~~-.....-..=-
p"
.~'
\
\
....\
. ~. ....
__ '. T" .~.: .'.--
. ..' !.~~' -:, [ i'" ...
o ~ : i /....\F: ';.-<
}Jt-.:~:-:\,~\j1~:i:'; ~)
".'. i'T' 1 .-/.".,' .-y'.. .-
-:"~ ....-i..~....... )...,-- \'
\'~-;~J~tj;~~;,~t"::.~."
1.-, :". ;j::{.~ \'~
. :~"
~::
~,
'-":,..,
~'lo"
~I
-l':~i
. (~
.
"
,
. ..~
"
\
~
\
~
\
I:' ~
. ...
J,-
r...
.. i, r,.!
f'- r-. ).' -
. f-"
-',h
t...._......"..
""'", .
.1.
---..r......
)'r
--_._..._--_.'--_.""...~---_.__...__.-.
.
. .,;."'. --'./1-
'.'r~r" "7.1; .~
. -..,::'
I. ...
,~~ "~<... 0""
, ..........:::..i>
'\ '- ?''':''.
.\ ,\"'lJ
A llJ \ .
.,:;t I.'
.:..-(l,QIJ_) .
~ I, U. ~..=---
;:"" J -.--
~ t~~/ .', :;~~i.
t-:~- ~' :; . f. - j1.,Jl:~ ;If.],, \;. .
Y" 'Q. Ji~. ,fi1'f;.7?'N:;."'-~;G' tV"-?
~ l't-".' ...- ......... ~I;'"
'. oliI r~:r(-.:I)'f.) .~ .-
'''''is=l.~J..-.''flF.~,,, .
~l I. &}" .'
~{?:/ ! ~ ~-
,$...;:.~.-. ;
. ' . i:Li Ill' 11. ~/~ 4. -Jij~j\ ,.
. "~J.,.Yt.1~.:J~~~r~~ ~
~/),. ~- ""'\..~~ ..~ :-
.. '-_ 1" ->; ~ ~ ': ~ . '\). . . . .,
. ..'
.l it!
. R~~ ~';_!C)fdi:l6-Yt~1r:..j&~~~'l'~,
~~~\~l\~~'~ ~ ~\ ~
~ ~ ~- " ~ . "~ .\~ ' )
....
...
~.il.. ~./ ~Il.: ~~ ;I(~ .~ (I '-.~
.. I..... CJUc...1 _........l -.
~ f~ ..~~~J;7l ;
h.e. ~..\). ~ f'-\'''~ . \
IlfJl!Jf#li/dJi!!fA
.,
.-....
:::
<:~
. ~--
n:',.'
..,....
"
,..,
...:
;:::~.~
~. ., ;:-::
..--.-...--..----- ...-.--.....-...--- -.--
I
I
.-1
~ +~<=\\'1q
",. .., ..~~t... ....i.~~..,a
,~ A...... . .......:;:~i"?;:!.=:~~..~.~....:}i~:~'.~..~~~ .
";!:4'i:J(~;$;:'~;~1~1:'f;ii,~n~;~,f::i._._ -.---..-. - I 1\" ~1~4Xx:r,J;,~.:1~ Il'f;;:O;-~~~-;f;:f:-.~:J~=: ;
. I' I . ~I"'=. . . . \. :'l -j I .' f 1L 1-"", _ ._._.__... . . _........c... .
' " ,I.. ''\.!.,. ~ --f'"--'---",--_:o.... -..-,'.-...-"......--.. _,'-~r'" 'r -'1- .__. _.. .. .
. ! : ~ I? ;j>4-'~- .-r.-.l;:",.~-'---,.,J,- \' ->-'-'_!--"!'".--L--:..~..,...,....JJ:::f.--'''''- . Jl . -....:_~..::.C-.:.~.
""~.'." ,1~1.', '1\ ,e -~-~. ."~ .L._-...J:r_-f.....~:....'-_.!~""-;:..~I-L';:z:..':..;:-:-:..r'I.'I\:.I'I.FI..,,;
t.,-t. "'-~~'.:~~.~:' 'I' :-- '11<~JI' 'Ifi ll.!.:~:.;F;~l:-... ~;: iI:'4, F~1;r' - ~{'. n\'~w7.jll\I-.~~\ ;~rlij!li;:~ III :\1'1: ;.": .;\':, ':' .11.1
;":" 1'1 ....-:~ -._~... ,. .-.-. ~ ", I __.o.;:-Il '/\1." J I...... ..---::- I ""~ :,'1.11 1. .:..-=-.._ 1: .\;/ I ":--:',1 ~ J : Ij I. I' ....: .1 I -_.
. ---I ,.-- ,I.t ... .,. ---.., ~/'I ..'" "'-""""'1 ,...-...-... "'j" 11-'" 1.1 II """.~",.1 '.' "'1
t:::-;:.:- I -".: ....__~.M.O..... i 1 .::: ~ ;:~I !;' , I: \ '..~:.-.-~...~::. :: " /. :L.. o..::..::-~:::: .~:-: i :\'... II I,; .~'.; I ; J: i I II 1 : I: I ! ~ ::. . (:.t~. "
I.:':,,::. I 'I ,- - ., I' . .. I' ./ . - "." I ~ n I", I ,- ", / I' 'I ..__.j",,,,,..,.I~-...,...., ....,_.. , .'. '.'
.~ '. ..... /\' . I 'f'" "..,.... . _.
:il'I:.::~.ji I'l:-",,:~~=:~:'i-',: ..j "" j i.. .~--;: :1 ;-1'" i.-'\'i ii' :I'''::::'::'':~:::':~ .! Ii'" ')'l:O-/i'i: I . p..~::f_;::.'. :':'j(':> 11\-/- Iii i -::-:.:: '1" "I . .
":...\. ".~:-=...-:-::...-..
t,;,.rij,l .". I:' 1 I"-~ .' : I ~,:~:.::-:.=: -':;:-" ~ I 'iL'--";-'-::' : 'I' I II l'~ '. .
WIt..;,-:." ",.- r "..d 'I:, ,"I; /.111:.. .';h /IIJ/1, ~:_ -~_. . II. /11' 1:-:..:..:.....,1 I ,_,' 1;/1..
.;"'.:. .jl' :... ,..,,': :It. ;1 \ I .,;, ':';'/!:!':iii: - ",,:..,= d j'-" !,' I' . :L~"-=-:=="-j Ii II'; ! 1. "j I i r__~lmn."'.'t:
~... !:;--~;:::'-::-~~tr~-I.i~~~c.;:-:;~~,~-tr;7 ~ b~~=~~? Jl ,--
. '" . J --l.....__._..._____.........___._
r'- ....------- ------.-:-['0- T'
, i I
! .
VI
"'\1" .
.:.... _., .,~,Ii '0"'" '_-.-.,_, _ _......~.~--:..-..'~..-~ij'1.~..~...~~r7...:...=:.!...,~~. '__"" "_...'_ '~"'.' . ~~..:;..1':!:5i.......,-....._-. ,:.~.,.,"'i._.::.~.;~:.~..?~.:.-.,..:,.:.1....~.
~.-> ~:".. '''~';':''~ ". If
,.!,~;~~;~~:.;:~:~~~~~.- . ,,/li'rTl\II,!l\'{!\ ~~:L.l'1m(;~~~i?~~'~~~~~~... ...... "1" '.\- \I::'} ... .....t=I~
:i~:,' ,,~~,~=,j~i?1- ~~.... _11~ ; '/ii 11"'1~ 'Y~l\~. _..~-------5i---- ..~:~~ , .; ,...._... ~ .. f\
\~; 'li':'~' I if:/'if;~ :..-t..-:l1'--fi-.J~l?fl to 1/' ~ /,.1\ Ii'-. l[r. ,,"'0 (;j~:"'-,i'l~'~"""''' ,." '.,~. ~~"" i I~I ! ~. '..-. ..'.....--.-..---ij . 1
' :. , I 'I .// II I. 'I' L' (\ :!1~ 4""-,...,.... '"a.:.- " \ . I II ' 'j l
'.. \1 1\ ......,_._~_.. ;~~77~;:r~V~'7.;'~~~I' . _~~..-lf;~f:.'~":C''':':::-;':, ';~~j_. ~"':'1!"'~'~[" ri 'J~H,:" .......-...",.......-..----.....~ II
. ---....... """"''''''''1''' 0 ;;;.-- , H~br'l t 1_.-.-..".,....,... -.00 " l ... '1__'" . . --...-.--.-..,. ..-......<. I
: I "..' ...........o:v... y -,;;;-,.. . .\ ' .. .,_._..., '!f\t,.--:;. "-1' Loo. -" ;, . I
\ \;;.J'=~~f:,]~.:'~.:.{:/l~~~~:~-=~l~\.....~t;>-.... '-~.~"=I;__-~t:;.I~j, ,~:'"i~='~~1 :;i-: ~:I.'''" L. .,,-1-:21~~~~1~1::~;1;~~~1~1:~~;~\\\... d"'I!.' II \
I l_. 'C. ' .., I . .:. i! .1 ' 1l,"j. hi'" i: ol! ",,', . '".' II.... U'. /1 t' l!' I
'=.' ,. . . '.: :"".;;,-;;, .::. " . P d.i;'--". I r"~ III.. . J ,:;~ ,( i :-'. '1" 't 3, I q ,,~~-.- .: I i
Ii -c~~~~;~:~.-.i..~::....-..-::._.-,.~~...~~;.:,~.-...-.-,;.:.~.~i~~~~'.~=~!~=-~-.j;E~~~Ik:":,;~~~-=~~:~]
-' - '11~5~~W-"
. 1.-_oo'J '
lrr=jl:
IUI
~..~ .~.~I~~.;:
\
~ . -....- .'
\,.~-' /
\.)
'. :j
)'
I=;<'
.'
.
'"
. ...:[/
-- I
- '';/",' ~"...:...
f!.nu..M . :"'~. ~ " "',
~t~ ,((t,~.~~"~;;, "
. "
;
.t.
t;
",: ~'\. .
~.\"'"
~.
!. '\..
,..I l-
,-
..-~, ~
~ ~~l~~ ..
~ ~\ -
. 0 I --
O!
~:
\
" -
. or
:.0,
L
I
~
'b"+ 0'
E.)<.h \ \ ,
Shorewood Planning Commission
Shorewood, Minnesota
May 28, 2003
MAY 3 0 2003
.:.___,~,,=...,,-...- :....;p".,'~......."..=,;=--,~..;.;~.':,..~..=.........,t
'L"",~",>>,. _~",.~,",=,.,="=,~,=~=~=-=-=,~..~....J
Dear Planning Commission Members:
My husband and I are Shorewood residents and live at 5465 Timber Lane. We
are not able to attend the meeting Tuesday, June 3rd, regarding the discusion of
the Shorewood Marina, but would like to share our concerns with you.
.
I attended the Planning Commission meetings when John Cross and his wife
applied for permission to expand their marina, adding more boat slips and their
boat repair building. The Timber Lane residents agreed to give approval to the
expansion of a sailboat only marina. Mr. and Mrs. Cross asked the Commission
at that time to speed up the process of the approval because the weather was
getting cold, they would be in Florida and wanted to get the expansion done
quickly. The commission acted quickly and the expansion was completed.
John Cross thanked the Commission by illegally adding motor boats to a sailboat
only marina. At various times there were from 16-21 motor boats docked at the
Shorewood Marina. It appears that wetlands have been filled in at some points
to accomodate more sailboat winter storage and the area around the marina is
littered with old wood and garbage. If you walk the adjoining trail(Henn. co,) you
can see the garbage in the water by the marina.
We feel Mr. Cross has not acted in good faith in working with our city and its
processes and seems only to be interested in marina expansion to increase the
value of his property for a future sale. Mr. Cross does not have the best interests
of Shorewood and its future in his new plan.
We would like to see the marina remain a sailboat only marina.
.
Thank you for your consideration.
Kathy and Nick Ruehl
456 Lafayette Avenue
Excelsior, Minnesota 55331
r';':
-- -;~-;;::-;--7~:~;~:='l
May 29, 2003
Mr. Bradley J. Nielsen, Planning Director
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, Minnesota 55331-8927
MAY 3 0 2003
"~._...-._,..",~=-...,,-, ,....~,..~.......,~-=,..~=-'"=".;'".:-=~..n'"."..-
~:
;,
"
I
._ _,.=-:.."'.,..,...r.':,,,...,,.,....,.c~-~-:.~...:'l,~.":'l""~~
Re: Proposed Zoning / Conditional Use Revisions
Shorewood Yacht Club
Dear Mr. Nielsen:
.
I am writing to object to any change in the current zoning ordinance / conditional use that would allow more
powerboat storage than the current ordinance. I am quite upset and bewildered at the request of Mr. Cross
for changing the use.
Four years ago I generally supported the zoning revisions for the Lakeshore Recreational District; however
I did specifically express 5 concerns at the Planning Commission meeting and reiterated those concerns in
the attached letter dated March 21, 1999. As noted, Mr. Cross stated at the meeting that he had no problem
restricting the dock space to sailboats. My understanding is that the final ordinance allowed dockage for 4
powerboats.
In May of2000, I supported the expansion ofthe sailboat docks for Mr. Cross (see the second attached
. letter), as up until that time he was quite responsive to the concerns of our residential neighborhood relative
to halyard/mast and people noise.
.
Over the past two summers, however, we have had nothing but problems with the occupants of two
particular sailboats - "Ooh Baby" and "Pinch Me." Well into the evening the people are loud and most
times their behavior is obnoxious. No end of complaining to the management of the marina has resulted in
either a relocation of the boats or reduction of noise. This year we intend to contact the Police rather than
the management.
I cannot think of anything worse than introducing more powerboats to the marina. For all of the previously-
stated reasons this is a terrible idea. Add to those, the reality that powerboats are more conducive to late
night gatherings of people (and alcohol), and the result will be more noise (engine / people) and a huge
disturbance in a predominantly residential neighborhood.
Based on the above, I ask the Planning Commission to reject the request to expand powerboat dockage.
I intend to be at the upcoming public hearing. Thank you.
Sincerely,
cjwaNtlO (tvZA4L---
Nick Ruehl
J. Nicholas Ruehl, Architect
456 Lafayette Avenue
Excelsior, Minnesota 55331
March 21, 1999
Mr. Bradley J. Nielsen, Planning Director
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, Minnesota 55331-8927
Re: Proposed Zoning Revisions
Marina & Yacht Club
.
Dear Mr. Nielsen:
.
Thank you for the opportunity to meet with the Planning Commission members and City Staff
last Tuesday. At the meeting I was able to respond to the second draft of the proposed
ordinance for Lakeshore Recreational Districts. We discussed the following issues relative to
the Shorewood Yacht Club:
1. In 1975, John Cross was successful in establishing the Yacht Club, over the objections of
many. During his application process, I told John that I would support his project with the
following reservations:
. There would be no powerboats docked at the Yacht Club;
. There would be no gas sales from the docks;
. There would be no late night parties allowed on the sailboats;
. There would be little, if any, noise from howling masts or snapping halyards.
2. The proposed ordinance appears to allow powerboats and gas sales.
3. Powerboat docking and gas sales would fundamentally change the character of the back
bay of Guideon's in a negative way, by encouraging higher intensity usage. This would
generate more traffic, noise, and certainly affect water quality, as the bay is rather shallow.
4. Guideon's Bay, particularly the Back Bay, is essentially residential in character. I am very
concerned about anything that would affect the quiet neighborhood.
5. John Cross was present at the 3/16 meeting and indicated that he had no problem with
restricting the Shorewood Yacht Club to sailboats and no gas dock sales.
Based on the above, I ask the Planning Commission to limit the Shorewood Yacht Club to
sailboats and not allow gas sales at the dock.
Thank you for your consideration. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you need additional
information.
Sincerely,
5:::~
J. Nicholas Ruehl, Architect
456 Lafayette Avenue
Excelsior, Minnesota 55331
May 31, 2000
Mr. John Cross
600 West Lake Street
Shorewood, Minnesota 55331
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club Dock Addition
.
Dear John:
Thank you for sharing with me your plans to add additional dock slips at the Yacht Club.
Based on the plan presented, the additional slips will have no detrimental effect to our
enjoyment of the lake or our property values.
For over 20 years, John, the Yacht Club has been a very fine neighbor. We have had no issues
with noise, pollution, or safety. You have managed the Club in a manner that has been nothing
but "neighborly."
Best wishes for continued success.
Sincerely,
.
6[1.'\100 ~
Nick Ruehl
.
I,{'omlr!! ';\'1. :\ddinglr)!l
N. \\"IIt., Crall
^.\1l1'1I P. Barllard
Bolwrl,l. Chrislii.llISPll. Jr.
Frullk Vogl
\'larillUS W. \'..lll Plllli'l1- .II'.
Morris t~. knopf
.Inllu A. Burlnn..I1".
JUllWSC. Di mt'I(:.~
HOfl'T H. Hot,. Jr.
.'II1t'. L. P..l.lllstltl
,...,11.. Mt.'I..,.J..
,udilh A. Hogoslw.~kl:'
:-;".,1111. [lIt.,
Cllarlt's C. Ih,'llIUisl
.I.Hllt'S M. C1lrisll~nl"nJ\
E. .10.-;'1:'1-'11 l.nhJn~
Cn';.::ury n. :-\oule
C'-llhy F. Corlin
I'nlri"k B. Ht'IlIw."s~'
Timothy ,\. Sulli\'iln
IhllliI'IIL\\'. Nt.l~ol1
Havid .I. Zubke
Sll:'\'t'1l H. Knl~('r
1'.lId 1::. Ki.II11iw..ki
n.o;;s c. {-'unllt,-II
Lnryn S. (;10\'("'1'
Milr." E. Sla',IH"1I
H.lrlHln\ M. Bliss
Cnllll'rilll' J. COllrll'lt.y
Si.lrah CL"ipP('H Madison
Holler! n. !\lulU-I"
U'risloplwl' D. .Iollllsun
.Iill B. L.lorl"
I )allie! A. I'i.lplun
.llor:\.S('IWfTlPl'
"i.IIIII'\" F. \\"'illialll~
Ly"lllla L. 1-lq!.U1Y
MidnwllJ.lliI(.kt.,
Ihl\id C. Murph,'
lI"z"\ .I. I,.
t;ll'IIlIu:-:;. ~Il'ullwrs
Hri.lII C. I':dtly
Ht'!,P(TiJ A. CllaITc-'\'
Th(JIlHl~ (;. CillTY
11",id C. :-;du..Izt..J
I)F(:lil.-~~LJ.
\\anl B. L;,>wi:-;
.\n.hibi.dd ~Iwllt.(>r
Hulwrt M. :-:kal't'
.Iohll It Carroll
J..lllW":, D. nl~ol1
ltnlll.'rl I.. Crn.-ihy
Lary L. t;r;ppl-Il
I. ,,,,,k .I. lIalz
~('o!i P. Ml,It"'ll
Hi("llClnl :\. P.-.!er......ull
JnllH':' I. Bt:'~l
J' ~j::.lqll',
H.nlu'rl .I. Fblla;':,1Il
J :;'I;~-lq: I
HJt \llI-:D 1..12(,
BEST & FLANAGAN LLP
ATTOHNEYS AT LAW
22:3 South Sixlh Streel. Suite 4000
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55'l02-4.(j90
Telephone 6123397121
Facsimile 6123395897
www.hestlaw.com
JUN
2 2003
Direct Dial: (612) 349-5648
E-mail: rmeller~bestIaw.com
May 29, 2003
I
h
..,....."'_.J
Shorewood Planning Commission
c/o Bradley J. Nielsen
City of Shorewood
Planning Department
5755 County Club Road
Shorewood,~ 55331
Re: Shorewood Yacht Club, 600 West Lake Street
Dear Planning Commission Members:
This is to respectfully submit strong opposition to a Shorewood Yacht Club request to
dramatically change their operation from a sailing yacht club to a motorboat marina. Such a
change would have a dramatically negative impact on the Yacht Club's Gideon's Bay
neighbors.
I am an owner of property at 446 Lafayette, and the Yacht Club sailboats ingress and egress
from the Yacht Club via a narrow, dredged channel in front of my property. The sailboats are
obviously slow, quiet, attractive, and safe. Conversely, powerboats are far noisier, faster,
create wakes, and pose a significantly increased safety hazard. Because of the location of the
dredged channel close to shore, it is common to have children swimming and on rafts within
the channel. Because the shore off of Frog Island is extremely shallow for a long way
towards my property, there is only a very narrow channel which will permit ingress and
egress, unlike the unfettered access which other marinas enjoy. This unique ingress and
egress limitation renders the conversion to over 100 powerboats completely inappropriate.
The sailboat Yacht Club has an attractive, New England sailing village positive visual impact
which would obviously be destroyed by conversion to common powerboats. Sailboats are
also environmentally friendly compared to powerboats as there is very limited use of fuel,
and virtually non-existent gasoline leakage into the lake.
For these reasons of safety, noise, visual impact, and environmental degradation, and because
there is no counter-balancing reasoning justifying this conversion, we request that this
application be summarily denied.
Thank you for your patience and attention to my concerns.
Very yury.your-s)
/ \/ U ..'
(1 ) Ii
, Ii ,
/~ 9i?
" . '-'
.... ert L. Meller, Jr.
RLM/sm
245609
May 30, 2003
rr~-~--~~:~'--~~'~~" .~. "" u,~.,". ....
~ ,. '.' .
',-j: :
! ~,. ,
i'd.. ,
!; ,
1': f"';.
n ~ .
---:--,
'. ,~
.
The Planning Commission
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
JUN
r' '.:~- ~~:=-=-"=J
2 2003
Re: The Shorewood Yacht Club's request for amendments which would allow the Yacht Club to
harbor either sailboats or powerboats at its dock slips.
.
My wife, Lucille Goodwyne, and I own the property and live at 5525 Timber Lane, Shorewood.
Ours is the first home on the lake west of the Yacht Club. We write to oppose the requested
amendments.
Several years ago when the Yacht Club was requesting permission to increase its number of
slips we were visited by John Cross who promised us that the proposed increase in the number
of slips was only for sailboats. We, therefore, made no objection to his request for permission
for additional slips.
As you surely know, the Yacht Club proceeded to violate the revised zoning ordinance and its
promise to neighbors by renting sips to a number of powerboats. Having been granted an
amendment to increase the number of sailboat slips which was immediately violated, we see no
reason to reward the Yacht Club with a new amendment to the zoning ordinance.
.
This portion of Gideon's Bay is small and shallow and is heavily infested with milfoil. It
already has heavy barge and sailboat traffic. The requested amendments to the zoning ordinance
would allow the Yacht Cub to provide slips for more than one hundred powerboats. While it is
likely that at the present time slips would only be used by approximately twenty-five
powerboats (in itself far too many), all one hundred or more slips could be used by powerboats.
Even twenty-five additional powerboats coming in and out of this small section of the bay
would over use the area. A full contingent of powerboats would be intolerable.
We urge the Planning Commission to reject the request.
~~~V
~chard A Lundy ~le Goodwyne
Dick Lundy, 5525 Timber Lane, Excelsior, MN 55332, email: dlundy@mchsi.com
~UN Ul ~UU~ lU:41~M ~X~~~~~I ~~U~~~IY ~UN~ULI ~~~4~4~U~4
p.~
Richard R. Tradewell
5515 Timber Lane
Shorewood, MN. 55331
Shorewood Planning Commission
City of Shorewood
G~, ;':,'::::-":,~;~~.'--- r:"( ,,'
t. j. I'" ~. .'
,\\ \\ it
ii' .1'1
\\\:'::, JUN 2 2003 j;
\ t\ "L..,,_,w~<"~"..""-'-"-- '\
r- L ,_ " ",__..,._.._."__,~.--J
~~~~W"~.~--;,......, ~
6/112003
Dear Shorewood Planning Commission:
.
I did not receive direct notice of hearing regarding Shorewood Yacht
Club request, but receive copy of notice from neighbor.
I would appreciate bein$J notified as I would be effected bv chanaes
to zonina reauest.
I did not object to the expansion of the Shorewood Yacht Club
several years ago, but I very much object to the request to allowing
more than the current limit of four powerboats.
There request would be a major change of business as zoned and
would have a adverse impact to my neighborhood in the bay, with
increased noise and other impacts that the powerboats would have.
Sincerely,
· ~2~~c:;?~~
Richard R. Tradewell
Peter S. Wattson
5495 Timber Lane
Shorewood, MN 55331
(952) 474-7988
peterwattson@earthlink.net
June 1,2003
1:' JUN 2 2003
H L :;
[P ,~"==--_~== _____. "~__ i
=--=- --'-'~=.~=~_b-.J
Bradley J. Nielsen
c/o Planning Department
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
Dear Mr. Nielsen:
.
I regret that I will be out of town Tuesday night, June 3, when the Planning Commission will
consider the application of the Shorewood Yacht Club to amend the zoning ordinance and amend its
conditional use permit to allow it to moor an unlimited number of powerboats in the slips currently limited
to sailboats. I submit this letter in opposition to the request.
In 1975, John Cross sought a permit from the City of Shorewood to construct a commercial marina
to moor 270 boats of all kinds. My neighbors on Gideon's Bay and I opposed the request, and the City
voted to deny it. Mr. Cross challenged the City's decision in district court and was successful in getting an
order compelling the City to issue the permit. The Gideon's Bay Homeowner's Association and I
intervened in the case on behalf of the City and appealed the district court's decision to the Minnesota
Supreme Court. In 1979, the Court denied our appeal. The City and the LMCD granted Mr. Cross, doing
business as the Shorewood Yacht Club; the right to construct a marina to moor 80 sailboats.
.
Until the last year or so, Mr. Cross has run an exemplary operation. The sailboats are no bother at
all. The sailors keep their halyards tied off so they don't clang against the mast, they don't have loud
parties, and they don't cause any trouble. The boats are a pretty sight. The Shorewood Yacht Club runs
occasional races and someone runs a modest sailing school. They have been good neighbors.
I understand that the Shorewood Yacht Club has had some trouble with the City in the last year for
exceeding the number of powerboats aHowed under its conditional use permit. If the Club needed a couple
more boats to help run races or teach sailing, I would have no objection. However, I have been told that
the Club's current application is for an unlimited number of powerboats, apparently because the new slips
it recently added have not all been rented for sailboats. It is unfortunate that the recent expansion may
have been too ambitious for the market. I don't see that as sufficient reason to permit the entire operation
to be converted from sailboats to powerboats.
I respectfully request that you deny the application for unlimited mooring of powerboats at the
Shorewood Yacht Club.
Sincerely,
~~~V-
Peter S. Watts on
.
.
..
..
June 2,203
City of Shorewood
Subject; Zoning amendment! Shorewood Yacht Club
The request to amend ; allowing power boat in what has been for years a
sailboat marina seems to break the trust and understanding that
was established years ago.
The quiet waters and low wake that now exists would be lost.
Although I don't want to try to control their growth it does break the
original agreement that the neighbors have understood to be a good one.
.r\
Thank you.
R.H. Cole
458 Lafayette Avenue
Excelsior. MN.
'Irr~') IS:; <<;.,.-..; ~'ti;"~~\",;~r-'"\l
I I r '...., \, ," : r-.....'. '.1. ',..f f,.- I: ".:"<>\d.
r "'d >, l"..... r,.... ., .~, .'
"/1 I f.t"'. .." ....__..~_~._'::.- \.J l. '.... '..... P'".'
, I. f r 0"""',1' 1 H
lfuL- .-1. I~I
.
t
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD - SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927- (952) 474-3236 .
FAX (952) 474-0128 - www.cLshorewood.mn.us' cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
10 J\lly 2003
RE:
Shorewood Yacht Club - Planning CoInmission Findings
FILE NO.
405(03.16)
Attached are the Planning Commission's findings relative to the Shorewood Yacht
Club's text and C.D.P. amendment request. The highlighted areas are minor changes
suggested by the City Attorney.
.
Cc: Planning Commission
Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
John Cross
n
~" PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION
FINDINGS OF FACT
REGARDING SHOREWOOD YACHT CLUB REQUEST FOR AMENDMENTS TO L-R
ZONING DISTRICT PROVISIONS AND TERMS OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
WHEREAS, John Cross (Applicant), representing Minnetonka Moorings, Inc., has an
interest in the property (Subject Property) located at 600 West Lake Street, legally described in
Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Subject Property is subject to the requirements of the L-R, Lakeshore
Recreational zoning district, a conditional use permit as set forth in Shorewood City Council
Resolution No. 00-111, and a multiple dock facility license approved by the City Council at its
regular meeting of28 April 2003; and
.
WHEREAS, both the L-R zoning district and the conditional used permit referenced
above limit the number of powerboats that may be kept at the Subject Property to four; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a zoning ordinance text
amendment and an amendment to the terms of the existing conditional use permit, eliminating
the restrictions relative to the number of powerboats that may be kept on the Subject Property;
and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's application was reviewed by the Shorewood Planning
Director, and his recommendations have been set forth in a memorandum to the Planning
Commission, Mayor and City Council, dated 29 May 2003; and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held and the Applicant's application was reviewed by
the Planning Commission on 3 June 2003, the minutes of which meeting are on file at the
Shorewood City Hall;
.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The Subject Property is zoned L-R, Lakeshore Residential and is subject to a conditional
use permit as set forth in Shorewood City Council Resolution No. 00-111.
2. The Subject Property contains approximately 2.84 acres ofland, separated through the
middle by the Hennepin County Regional Railroad Authority right-of-way.
3. The Subject Property is located on Gideon's Bay, Lake Minnetonka.
4. Zoning and land use surrounding the Subject Property are as follows:
North:
Lake Minnetonka
South:
Minnetonka Portable Dredging Company; zoned C-4, Service Commercial
and single-family residential, zonedR-1A/S, Single and Two-Family
Residential
County Road 19, then commercial (The Garden Patch and Shorewood
Nursery); zoned C-4, Service Commercial and R-C, Residential
Commercial
Townhouse common area, then single-family residential; zoned R-1B/S,
Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland
.
East:
West:
5. Land use zoned for single-family residential development is located within 300 feet of
adjacent to the Subject Property.*
6. Water access to the Subject Property is via a well-defined, dredged channel located
between two small islands known as Duck Island and Frog Island. Concerns have been
raised that additional powerboat traffic will accelerate erosion on the shorelines of those
islands.
.
7.
A former sewage treatment plant, operated by the City of Excelsior, drained into
Gideon's Bay through the Subject Property. raisin-g concerns were raised about
powerboat traffic churning phosphorous ~ and other freshwater contaminants
residing in the silt at the bottom of the bay. *
8. Residents have expressed concerns about additional powerboats adversely affecting the
safety for users of small boats in Gideon's Bay.
CONCLUSIONS
A.
Based upon the findings contained herein, the Planning Commission determines that the
Applicant's Plans are inconsistent with the following policies of the Shorewood
Comprehensive Plan 2000 (hereinafter the "Plan") and recommends that the City Council
deny the Applicant's request for a zoning ordinance text amendment:
.
1. The natural and aesthetic quality of Shorewood' s lakeshore environment is to be
maintained and where possible improved. (plan pg. NR-8)
2. Support shall be given to efforts aimed at reducing lake pollution. (Plan pg. NR-
8)
3. Shorewood's lakeshore shall be protected from overintensification of use and
development. (plan pg. LU-8)
4. Residential neighborhoods shall be protected from adverse environmental
impacts, including noise, air and visual pollution. (plan pg. LU-9)
B. The Planning Commission recommends the Applicant's requests for an amendment to its
conditional use permit be denied, since it is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan
and the existing zoning of the Subject Property.
-2-
.
.
.
C. The Planning Commission recommends the Applicant's request for an amendment to its
Conditional Use Permit be denied, since the applicant failed to demonstrate a compelling
public purpose for changing an agreement freely entered into three years prior to this
request, and the justification presented appeared to be economic in nature.
ADOPTED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this
1st day of July, 2003.
Respectfully submitted
Jim Pisula, Acting Chair
* Changes shown by strikeouts and italics are suggested by the City Attorney
-3-
.
.
-D-R-A-F-T-
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION DENYING SHOREWOOD YACHT CLUB REQUESTS FOR
AMENDMENTS TO L-R ZONING DISTRICT PROVISIONS AND TERMS OF
CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
WHEREAS, John Cross (Applicant), representing Minnetonka Moorings, Inc., has an
interest in the property (Subject Property) located at 600 West Lake Street, legally described in
Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Subject Property is subject to the requirements ofthe L-R, Lakeshore
Recreational zoning district, a conditional use permit as set forth in Shorewood City Council
Resolution No. 00-111, and a multiple dock facility license approved by the City Council at its
regular meeting of 28 April 2003; and
WHEREAS, both the L-R zoning district and the conditional used permit referenced
above limit the number of powerboats that may be kept at the Subject Property to four; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a zoning ordinance text
amendment and an amendment to the terms of the existing conditional use permit, eliminating
the restrictions relative to the number of powerboats that may be kept on the Subject Property;
and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's application was reviewed by the Shorewood Planning
Director, and his recommendations have been set forth in a memorandum to the Planning
Commission, Mayor and City Council, dated 29 May 2003; and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held and the Applicant's application was reviewed by
the Planning Commission on 3 June 2003, the minutes of which meeting are on file at the
Shorewood City Hall;
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was considered by the City Council at its regular
meeting on 28 July 2003, at which time the Planner's memorandum, the minutes of the Planning
Commission, and a findings of fact prepared by the Planning Commission were reviewed and
comments were heard by the Council from the City Staff.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOL YED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The Subject Property is zoned L-R, Lakeshore Residential and is subject to a conditional
use permit as set forth in Shorewood City Council Resolution No. 00-111.
11:18
2. The Subject Property contains approximately 2.84 acres ofland, separated through the
middle by the Hennepin County Regional Railroad Authority right-of-way.
3. The Subject Property is located on Gideon's Bay, Lake Minnetonka.
4. Zoning and land use surrounding the Subject Property are as follows:
North:
East:
Lake Minnetonka
Minnetonka Portable Dredging Company; zoned C-4, Service Commercial
and single-family residential, zoned R-IA/S, Single and Two-Family
Residential
County Road 19, then commercial (The Garden Patch and Shorewood
Nursery); zoned C-4, Service Commercial and R-C, Residential
Commercial
Townhouse common area, then single-family residential; zoned R-IB/S,
Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland
South:
West:
5.
Land use zoned for single-family residential development is located adjacent to the
Subject Property.
6. Water access to the Subject Property is via a well-defined, dredged channel located
between two small islands mown as Duck Island and Frog Island. Concerns have been
raised that additional powerboat traffic will accelerate erosion on the shorelines of those
islands.
7. A former sewage treatment plant, operated by the City of Excelsior, drained into
Gideon's Bay through the Subject Property. concerns were raised about powerboat traffic
churning phosphorous and other freshwater contaminants residing in the silt at the bottom
of the bay. *
8.
Residents have expressed concerns about additional powerboats adversely affecting the
safety for users of small boats in Gideon's Bay.
CONCLUSIONS
A. Based upon the findings contained herein, the City Council determines that the
Applicant's Plans are inconsistent with the following policies of the Shorewood
Comprehensive Plan 2000 (hereinafter the "Plan") and hereby denies the Applicant's
request for a zoning ordinance text amendment:
1. The natural and aesthetic quality of Shorewood' s lakeshore environment is to be
maintained and where possible improved. (plan pg. NR-8)
2. Support shall be given to efforts aimed at reducing lake pollution. (plan pg. NR-
8)
3. Shorewood's lakeshore shall be protected from overintensification of use and
development. (Plan pg. LV-8)
-2-
.
.
f
..
.
.
4. Residential neighborhoods shall be protected from adverse environmental
impacts, including noise, air and visual pollution. (Plan pg. LU-9)
B. The City Council hereby denies the Applicant's requests for an amendment to its
conditional use permit be denied, since it is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan
and the existing zoning of the Subject Property and the applicant failed to demonstrate a
compelling public purpose for changing an agreement freely entered into three years prior
to this request, and the justification presented appeared to be economic in nature.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 28TH day of
July, 2003.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
CRAIG W. DAWSON, CITY ADMINISTRATOR/CLERK
-3-
scrivtion:
ree: 1:
at ~art of Government Lot 2, Section 34, ToWnship 117, Range 23, described
follows: Beginning at the intersection of the Southerly extension of the
st line of Lot 24, "Auditor's SUbdivision Number 313, HeXlnepin county,
anesota" wi th a line drall1n parallel :with and 25.00 feet Southerly from the
nter line of the railroad track of the Chicago and North Western
ansportation Company (formerly the Minneapolis and St. Louis Railway
mpar.y) i thence westerly along said parallel line a distance of 621.26 feet;
e.~ce southeasterly 29.64 feet, more or less, to a point which is on a line
awn parallel with and 50.00 feet Southerly from center line of said railroad
aek and 606.53 feet Westerly along the last described parallel line from the
,utherlY extension of the !last line of said Lot 24; thence Westerly along the
.st described parallel line to the West line of said Government Lot 21 thence
uth along said West line to the. center line of 'county Road Number 19; thence
,rtheasterly along the center line of county Road Number 19 to the southerly
:tension of the East line of said Lot 24 i thence North along said extension
I the point of beginning. Hennepin County, Mitxnesotia .
Lrcel 2:
u;. t part of Government Lot 2, Section 34, 'l'ownship 117, Range 23 I described
; follows: Beginning at the intersection of the !last line of Lot 24,
ludi ear' s SUbdivision Number 313, Hennepin county, Minnesota",' with a line
~awn parallel with and 18.00 feet Northerly from the center line of the
lilroad track of the chicago and North Western Transportation Company
Eormerly the Minneapolis and St. Louis Railway Company), thence Westerly
Long said parall'ill line a distance of 639.27 feet, thence Northwes terly to
~e southwest corner of Lot 25, -Auditor'S SUbdivision EUmber 313, Hennepin
ounty, Minnesota., thence East.Jrly along the Southerly line of said Lot 25 to
ne southerly extension of the Bast line of said Lot 24; thence South along
aid extension to the point of beSJinning.
ltcept, tbat portion' of the above parcels 1 ar1d 2 embraced within Lot 297
.J.di tor,' I SWX'li vision ltumber 13,5 Hennepin coun.t~, Minnesota.
.
"
arc~1!3:
hat ~rt of Lot 25 lying Westerly of the following described line:
:ommencing at.the southeasterly corner of Lot 24, thence South along the Bast
.ine of said Lot 2S a distance of 24.30 feet1 thence deflecting right 79
Legrees 25 minutes 40 seconds a distance of 406.48 feet1 thence deflecting
~ight ~ degrees 49 minutes 20 seconds to a point on the Southerly line of
iaid Lot 25 which is the true point of beginning of the line being described1
:hence continuing along last described line to the shore line of Lake
Sinnetonka and t:here ending, "Auditor's subdivision Number 313, Hennepin
:nunty, Minnesota." '
..
.
~ogether with a 12 foot easement for road purposes, the center line of which
Ls described as follows: Commencing at the southeast corner of Lot 24 of
5ald Auditor's SUbdivision1 thence South along the Bast line Qf said Lot 25, a
iistance of 24.30 feet to the point of beginning of the line being described;
~hence deflecting right Bl degrees 59 minutes a distance of 379.0 feet: thence
!ef1ecting right 58 degrees 52 minutes a distance of 46.06 feet to a point on
the Bast line of above-described property and there ending, as shown in deed
Document NUmber 1052891, Files of Registrar of Tities7 (as to Parcel 3)
Parcel 4:
That part of Government Lot 1, Section 34, township 117, Range 23, described
as Lot 293, Auditor'S Subdivision No. 135 and adjacent 60 feet of
Minneapolis and St. Paul Suburban Railway abandoned right-of-way (NOTE: Lotr293 all under water).
Exhibit A
..
.
"
.
.
~
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 .www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission~ Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
19 June 2003
RE:
Fence Ordinance Amendments
FILE NO.:
Zoning (1201.03 Subd. 2.f.)
Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.f. of the City Code prescribes regulations for the construction of
fences in various zoning districts. There are a couple of recurring issues that have arisen
over the years that need to be addressed: I) fence height; and 2) fences around swimming
pools.
Fence Height
Shorewood~s maximum fence height requirements range from four feet to six feet~
depending on where on the property the fence is located. These regulations are generally
in tune with what is offered by fence manufacturers and installers, with one exception.
Very often fence designs will include posts that extend over the top of the plane of the
fence by as much as six to eight inches (see ExhIbit A, attached). This allows for
decorative caps or carvings at the top of the post. Since the fence height is a maximum~
the owner is faced with reducing the height ofthe fence plane~ or foregoing the
decorative post tops.
While it is tempting to look the other way and consider the height to be a "nominal
measurement" (i.e. as long as it isn't over half a foot, round the measurement down), it
would be preferable to clarify the Code. Staff is therefore offering the following
amendment to Section 1201.03 Subd.2.f.:
"(12) Fence Height: The height offences prescribed herein shall be considered
to be the maximum height allowed. Fenceposts may extend above the specified height by
no more than eight inches (8 "). "
n
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#3. ~.
Memorandum
Re: Fence Ordinance Amendments
19 June 2003
Staff considers this to be a relatively minor, bu~ useful change to the Code that will be of
benefit to property owners without undermining the intent of the height requirements.
Fences Around Swimming Pools
Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.f.(7) requires that all pools be completely enclosed by a
minimum four-foot high, nonclimbable fence with a self-closing gate. The primary intent
ofthis regulation is to provide at least a four-foot high barrier to prevent small children
and occasionally stray pets from falling into unattended pools. While this requirement
makes absolute sense, we occasionally receive complaints from property owners wishing
to build above ground pools. They argue that the side of the pool itself, plus guardrails,
satisfies the barrier requirement, as long as any stair or ladder into the pool is enclosed
and provided with a self-closing gate. While this may be the case, it does not provide a
secondary benefit of fencing - screening. Although many aboveground pools come with
decorative skirting, many can have a rather structural appearance which, when combined .
with color, can become quire obtrusive.
It should be noted that the City debated this issue several years ago, and after
considerable discussion, it was decided that the fence enclosure requirement should
remain in the Code. Staff is not advocating either way on this issue, but simply wishes to
reaffirm the City's present policy.
Aboveground Swimming Pools - Setbacks
Somewhat related to fencing for aboveground pools, is the location of the pool itself on
the property. Section 1201.03 Subd. 3.c.(6) ofthe City Code relaxes the rear yard
setback requirement for swimming pools to 60 percent of what is allowed for other
structures. For example, in the R-IA zoning district, a house, garage, or other accessory
building must be at least 50 feet from the rear property line. Swimming pools in that
district are allowed to be as close as 30 feet from the rear of the lot. While this makes
some sense relative to in-ground pools, there is some question as to whether it should
apply to aboveground pools. The cause for concern is primarily the ultimate height of the
structure. It is not uncommon for pool owners to want some sort of guardrail around the
pool. A three-foot guardrail on top of a four-foot or higher pool results in a structure that
is taller than other structures (e.g. fences) that are allowed to encroach in the setback area.
.
A solution to this question may be to simply limit the height of aboveground pools to no .
more than six feet, including any kind of guardrail. This would make them no more
obtrusive than a six-foot high fence. Subd. 3.c.(6) could be modified as follows:
"(6) The minimum rear yard setbackfor swimming pools shall be sixty percent
(60%) of that which is requiredfor the zoning district in which the pool is located. No
part of any such pool. including guardrails. shall exceed six feet (6 ') above grade in
height. Decking. patios and 0001 aprons shall not encroach into the required rear yard
setback area. Rear yard setbacks for lakeshore lots shall be as provided in Section
1201.26 of this Ordinance. JJ
-2-
"
..,
.
I
Memorandum
Re: Fence Ordinance Amendments
19 June 2003
If you have any questions relative to these recommendations, please do not hesitate to
contact me prior to the meeting on 1 July. I will be on vacation next week, returning on
Sunday, 29 June. You may contact me at home via e-mail (abinielsen@msn.com) or by
phone (763-566-8355).
Cc: Craig Dawson
Patti Helgesen
Pamela Helling
Joe pazandak
.
.
-3-
.
.
,
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952)474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us,
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
21 July 2003
RE:
LaRose, David - Minor Subdivision/Combination
FILE NO.:
405 (03.13)
BACKGROUND
Mr. David LaRose owns the property at 5985 Chaska Road (see Site Location map -
Exhibit A, attached. Several months ago Mr. David LaRose applied for a setback
variance to build an addition to his home that was only five feet from his side lot line.
That variance was ultimately denied by the City Council, based upon the
recommendations ofthe Planning Commission. Since then, Mr. LaRose has worked out
a deal with his neighbor to purchase five feet of the neighbor's property (see Exhibit B).
The properties in question are zoned R-1C, Single-Family Residential and are occupied
by the applicants' respective homes.
ANAL YSIS/RECOMMENDATION
This request is considered to be very simple. Both properties will still comply with all
zoning requirements for the R-1C district (area, width and building setbacks). The
Planning Commission recommended unanimously to approve the division/combination as
presented by the applicant. After resolving some problems with legal descriptions of the
two lots, staffhas prepared the attached resolution for consideration by the Council.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
David LaRose
ft
t.J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
4P 8. D.
'iP",,~1
.,., . 'i'\, .~
, .
i ~?~~ ,.I
"'t.. '" i~!
, '. < 'Ii
~ ... i ~
-.. i6 . . s
.
't... I <
, "
~
II',,~. . '"
.
,j .
~
" '""q.
'. '. ~ ~
'\ ,,)
",. '<".d-
o \\.~ 'd>
.r . "
,:
.' I
". . .
. '.. ~hl i
'..
.'
'. . .
..... "
~ ",'
r:?
g
"Ii
. \
/1 .......'" "
## \
,
" .
......'"
I
1ii
o CD
oLL.
<=!.
z""'lllll(
o
o
Ll')
o
Ll')
C\l
o
fG'
.LS~.L"'M
..
..
.
Ill"",.,
"'ot"Q
"<"
."
'.
....
r$"
o~
I
6:-
.,
"
~
...
/"
.f
..~~
'. .
",.
.:""'"
"
...... ......
.'
.
~
>-
::E
w
!i
~
Iii
'"
"
it
'.
\\
. .
.
.t""....
..
<9..,.."
. .
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
LaRose/Mahoney
Lot Line Rearrangement
~ b.~
~ @ ~
==~~
~ ~~
== ~~
tf:: b '=
Yl ~-;:
~~~
.
~.
4-
~ '.
<; ,
.;::.
:=
WI
b
2>
/?)
b
~
Yl
==
-6
t'
-:::.
~.j
-- ~~
~""~'l:\
.....,. \" ~
...
-~
..
i
- 0
III
..J
ct:
U
III
I
,~ ::'...
. ">oJ. )
~.; rV
v
--,\
\
\.
'\
I
~.. (\
,-'1
. -- +ei~''r.(}I_.:.
~:VT5
~("';lF.: ..h""'1YI
/1 ';0 ;j
,....
-:7 (9 /
S1i?/
/ -I- .
7 /0 ~/
.... ~ -I.' '/ Jy~
Co)
'J
,
~-
1~
c::t.~
..:::!:
\jr'~
CS"-.,L.
-I-~
o
-.(~
~
~ ~
-,)+
_0;; 1-
-=~
. l:\
~<(
Exhibit B
~
~1
I
':1-'
J~
~<.;
~~
..
.
.
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION APPROVING SUBDIVISION AND COMBINATION
OF REAL PROPERTY
WHEREAS, David LaRose and James Mahoney (Applicants) are the owners of certain
real properties in the City of Shore wood, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota, legally
described in Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Applicants have applied to the City for a subdivision and combination
of said real property into two parcels legally described in Exhibits B and C, attached hereto and
made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the subdivision and combination requested by the Applicants complies in
all respects with the Shorewood Zoning Code.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
1. That the real property legally described in Exhibit A be divided into two parcels,
legally described in Exhibits B and C, attached hereto and made a part hereof..
2. That the City Clerk furnish the Applicants with a certified copy of this resolution
for recording purposes.
3. That the Applicants record this resolution with the Hennepin County Recorder or
Registrar of Titles within thirty (30) days of the date of the certification of this resolution.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 28th day of
July 2003.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
CRAIG w. DAWSON, CITY CLERK/ADMINISTRATOR
#1D
Existing Legal Description of Northerly Parcel:
(par 1): Lot 183, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, together
with that part of Water Street, vacated, lying northwesterly of the center line of said street,
easterly of the easterly line of State Highway No. 12 and southerly of an extension easterly of the
south line of Lot 185, said Auditor's Subdivision No. 135;
That part of Lot 192, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, lying
between two lines drawn across said lot parallel with and 120.00 and 220.00 feet respectively,
measured at right angles from the south line of said lot and westerly of a line drawn south at right
angles from the more northerly of said two lines at a point thereon 250.00 feet west of the
easterly line of said Lot 192; together with that part of Water Street, vacated, lying easterly of the
center line of said street and between extensions westerly of the northerly and southerly lines of
said part of Lot 192, according to the plat thereof on file or of record in the office of the Register
of Deeds in and for said County. Subject to a reservation by State of Minnesota of mineral and
mineral rights in and to said Lot 183; AND
(par 2): Lot 182, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, together .
with that part of Water Street vacated west of the center line thereof, north of an extension
eastward of the south line of Lot 185, and south of an extension westward of the south line of Lot
191 of said subdivision, according to the plat thereof on file or of record in the office of the
Register of Deeds in and for said County. The boundaries of which line in Par 2 are marked by
judicial monument at point shown upon plat of said land filed with the Registrar of Titles as
Document No. 177869.
Existing Legal Description of Southerly Parcel:
That part of Lot 95, ACADEMY ADDITION TO EXCELSIOR, lying southerly of a line
drawn parallel with and 60 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95 and westerly of the
following described line: Beginning at a point on the south line of said Lot 95, which point is also
the northeast comer of Lot 177, AUDITOR'S SUBDMSIONNUMBER 135, Hennepin
County, lMinnesota, thence north at right angles to said south line, a distance of 60 feet and there .
terminating;
ALSO includirig that part of Water Street (now vacated), contiguous and adjacent to the above
described premises.
ALSO that part of Lot 95, ACADEMY ADDmON TO EXCELSIOR lying northerly of a line
drawn parallel with and 60 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95 and southerly of a line drawn
parallel with and 120 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95, said distances of60 feet and 120
feet being measured at right angles to the south line of said lot, the same being part of Lot 192,
AUDITOR'S SUBDMSION NUMBER 135, Hennepin County, lMinnesota,
TOGETHER wrm the easterly 1/2 of Water Street, now vacated, contiguous and adjoining the
above described premises.
EXCEPT all that part of the above described property lying east of a line drawn parallel with and
300 feet west of the east line ofLat 95, according to the recorded plat thereof on file and of
record in the office of Register of Deeds, in and for Hennepin County, Minnesota.
Exhibit A
..
.
.
Proposed Legal Description of Northerly Parcel:
(par 1): Lot 183, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, together
with that part of Water Street, vacated, lying northwesterly of the center line of said street,
easterly of the easterly line of State Highway No. 12 and southerly of an extension easterly ofthe
south line of Lot 185, said Auditor's Subdivision No. 135;
That part of Lot 192, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, lying
between two lines drawn across said lot parallel with and 120.00 and 220.00 feet respectively,
measured at right angles from the south line of said lot and westerly of a line drawn south at right
angles from the more northerly of said two lines at a point thereon 250.00 feet west of the
easterly line of said Lot 192; together with that part of Water Street, vacated, lying easterly of the
center line of said street and between extensions westerly of the northerly and southerly lines of
said part of Lot 192, according to the plat thereof on file or of record in the office of the Register
of Deeds in and for said County. Subject to a reservation by State of Minnesota of mineral and
mineral rights in and to said Lot 183;
AND
(Par 2): Lot 182, Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, together
with that part of Water Street vacated west of the center line thereof, north of an extension
eastward of the south line of Lot 185, and south ofan extension westward of the south line of Lot
191 of said subdivision, according to the plat thereof on file or of record in the office of the
Register of Deeds in and for said County. The boundaries of which line in Par 2 are marked by
judicial monument at point shown upon plat of said land filed with the Registrar of Titles as
Document No. 177869.
AND
(Par 3): The south 5.00 feet of the north 105.00 feet of the south 220.00 feet of Lot 192,
Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, which lies west of the east 300.00
feet of said Lot 192.
Exhibit B
Proposed Legal Description of Southerly Parcel:
That.part of Lot 95, ACADEMY ADDmON TO EXCELSIOR, lying southerly of a line
drawn parallel with and 60 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95 and westerly of the
following described line: Beginning at a point on the south line of said Lot 95, which point is also
the northeast comer of Lot 177, AUDITOR'S SUBDMSIONNUMBER 135, Hennepin
County, Minnesota, thence north at right angles to said south line, a distance of 60 feet and there
terminating;
ALSO includirig that part of Water Street (now vacated), contiguous and adjacent to the above
described premises.
ALSO that part of Lot 95, ACADEMY ADDITION TO EXCELSIOR lying northerly of a line
drawn parallel with and 60 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95 and southerly of a line drawn
parallel with and 120 feet north of the south line of said Lot 95, said distances of 60 feet and 120
feet being measured at right angles to the south line of said lot, the same being part of Lot 192,
AUDITOR'S SUBDMSION NUMBER 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota,
TOGETHER WITH the easterly 1/2 of Water Street, now vacated, contiguous and adjoining the
above described premises.
EXCEPT all that part of the above described property lying east of a line drawn parallel with and
300 feet west of the east line of Lot 95, according to the recorded plat thereof on file and of
record in the office of Register of Deeds, in and for Hennepin County, Minnesota.
EXCEPT the south 5.00 feet of the north 105.00 feet of the south 220.00 feet of Lot 192,
Auditor's Subdivision No. 135, Hennepin County, Minnesota, which lies west of the east 300.00
feet of said Lot 192.
Exhibit C
.
.
..
,~
t
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
.
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us.cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
6 May 2003
RE:
Kawell, Mark - Minor Subdivision
FILE NO.:
405 (03.14)
BACKGROUND
Mr. Mark Kawell, on behalf of Richard Bowman, proposes to subdivide the property located
at 20025 Manor Road (see Site Location map - Exhibit A, attached). Mr. Kawell's request is
explained in a letter, dated 26 March 2003 (Exhibit B). Exhibit C illustrates the configuration
of the new lot.
The subject property is located in the R-IA, Single-Family Residential zoning district and
contains 186,794 square feet of area (4.29 acres). The property is occupied by Mr. Bowan's
single- family residence. The site changes elevation somewhat dramatically, rising from a
955.0 elevation at the north lot line to the high point where the house sits at approximately
988.0 feet.
As proposed the subdivision would result in one lot (with the house on it) containing 141,251
square feet of area, and one lot with 45,542 square feet.
ANAL YSISIRECOMMENDATION
The R-IA zoning district requires lots to be at least 40,000 square feet in area, 120 feet wide at
the building line, and at least 120 feet deep. Both lots will comply with the setbacks of the R-
IA district. Despite the existing topography, the new lot has a sort of natural shelf on which a
new house could be situated.
There are two issues that need to be addressed in this request: 1) lot configuration; and 2) a
development agreement that currently burdens the property.
#8. E.
ft
~.1 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Memorandum
Re: Kawell Minor Subdivision
6 May 2003
1. Lot Configuration. Although the proposed new lot complies with the dimensional
requirements of the R-1A zoning district, it has an unusual configuration along the
southerly boundary, where it jogs drastically to the south. Ordinarily, this would not be
viewed favorably. However, it has been done in this case to allow for the proposed
driveway to take advantage of the existing terrain. There is an old cut into the hill where
a previous access to the Bowman property had been located. In this location, the grade of
the new driveway can be kept to no more than eight percent.
.
2. Development Agreement. Several years ago the Bowman property, which straddles the
boundary between Deephaven and Shorewood was subdivided to create two building sites
on the Deephaven portion of the property. Since, access and utilities were through
Shorewood, the two cities and the land owner executed an agreement stating that no
additional development of the property could occur until such time as the road (see
Exhibits D and E) was built. This was consistent with Shorewood's policy of allowing
two ,lots to share a common driveway.
That development agreement was intended to address future lots on the Deephaven side
of the property. The proposed lot will not use, nor does it necessitate the construction of
the street. It is therefore recommended that the development agreement be amended,
subject to the approval of the City of Deep haven, and subject to the City Engineer's
review and comment regarding the location ofthe proposed driveway.
Although the property is relatively wooded, the proposed subdivision does not require the
removal of any trees. Any tree removal necessary for the construction of a house on the new lot
can be addressed with the building permit for that lot.
It is recommended that the proposed minor division be approved subject to the following:
. a. The applicant's surveyor should prepare legal descriptions for the property as it exists
today, as well as for the two newly described lots.
b. The applicant's surveyor must prepare legal descriptions for drainage and utility
easements which are required 10 feet on each side of each rear and side lot line.
c. The applicant's attorney must prepare deeds to the City for the drainage and utility
easements referenced in 2. above.
d. The applicant must provide an up-to-date (within 30 days) title opinion or title
commitment for review by the City Attorney.
e. The items listed in a.- d. above must be completed prior to the preparation of a resolution
approving the subdivision.
-2-
.
.
Memorandum
Re: Kawell Minor Subdivision
6 May 2003
f. Prior to release of the resolution approving the subdivision, the applicant must pay a park
dedication fee ($1500), and a local sanitary sewer connection charge ($1200) for the new
lot. Credit is given for the lot with the existing home on it.
g. Grading and drainage plans for the new home on the new lot must be approved by the
City Engineer.
h. Once the applicant has received the Council resolution approving the subdivision, he must
record it with Hennepin County within 30 days or the approval is void.
1. The resolution approving the minor division should state that any future division of the
property must be done by a formal platting process.
cc: Craig Dawson
Larry Brown
Tim Keane
Mark Kawell
-3-
'\
L
t .
.. \. l
i:m;
'" .."
.
.
. -
~i Q)
· Q) 0
, lL.o
o.
>.
-t::
g Q)
..... c.
.co
:::J _
U)c.
\
\\
..-
'\
'..
'\....~
o
o
10
'.
~~~
....oq. --.....
...
0
10
N
, J'
0 !
~.
~f
.'0-
il
1/
;>,'
<(
W-
..... ~ ...,I
~.:J
<(-
-1$
A ChtS)liiM of'
"t.1 '" 1-.. ""~.~...... S ,.r.."lf'f.
"""\'"
\\
Exhibit A
SITE LOCA ~I?~
Kawell SubdIvIsIon
.."
,
\:"" .~
...~.. <<to.. ..~/
...;;;: .,.~
:/
.~
"~;i1
f
..l
:/
~.t
'..
",
"'" '""
WEll rnOOnEY SAWYE,,-
A R....C I=l iT E C T S & B v i L DE R.S
March 26, 2003
.
Mr. Brad Nielson
Planning Director
City of Shorewood
5755 COlmtry Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
RE: Lot division of Richard Bowman Property.
.
I am requesting a lot division of R Bowman Addition. There is a development agreement
between the city and Mr. Bowman, resolution 94.,83 and amendment 98-073, a portions
of which, are pertinent to this reql1~"t. I have attached copies of those portions of the
agreement and highlighted the paragraphs that must be considered. As we discussed in
our meeting on March 19th the agreement prevents conveying any portion of R Bowman
Addition separately from Outlot A which is part ofR Bowman 2nd Addition. According
to city records the restriction was placed in the agreement to prevent the creation of a
land-locked parcel. This assumes that access to all of the property, in future
development, would be through Bowman Court, which was created as a part of the plat.
However, as I have shown you, this is not practical because of site topography and the
location of Mr. Bowmans existing home. Granting this request would in know way
compromise the development of the balance of the property. The northerly portion ofR
Bowman Addition is directly accessible from Manor Road and as I propose in the
attached survey it is the only lot that is entirely within the City of Shorewood. The lot
meets all of the city's requirements for an R-IA Single Family Residential District.
I am presently working on a proposal for the replatting of the balance of the property and
will be submitting it for consideration in the near future. All of the other lots in that plan
are either in Deephaven or the buildable portion of the lot is in Deephaven.
sideration,
IJ
6452 City Wesi Parkway, Edell Prairie IVIf"-J 55344 Tel 952.942.9982 Fax: 9:
Exhibit B
APPLICANT'S REOUEST LETTER
Dated 26 March 2003
'~'!nt;::- rV\lnl'i.:;~;.::-i::J
.
.
\.0
I.S'
C)
./'
....*
/
\.0
~
~- H<;e.
Exi.st,n9 .
'-0
0-.
<...:5'
ex. ,!*,otlf'm1oil7
J!... dl.p. _
\\
\.0
0::-
<..:5'
N
''''",
DEVnOPER:
KAWEll. VOONEY SAWYER
ARCHlffClS &- BUILDERS
645,2 CITY JlTST rARKI$:4Y,
EDEN PRAIRIE; VN 55J,N
PROPOSEO OESCRIPTlON
That pari or Lot I, Block 1, I? BOWMAN AOOI170tY,
which lies south or the norther(y 4000 feet or said
Lot 1, and norlher(y of a line descn'bed os follows:
DEMARS -G4BRIEZ
MNO SlIRtEYOR.s; INC.
.10.10 HClrbor l.one No.
fJ(ymOlltlJ, MN :;:;44/
Pnone:(76.J) 559-0908
Fair': (76.1) 55.Q-IJ479
Beqinninq at 0 point on the west line or said Lot I, 0
distance or /4500 reet southerfy or the northeaster(;-'
corner or said Lot I; thence on an assumed beanng
or North 89 degrees 24 minutes /5 seconds West
154.27reet; thence South 72 degrees 51 minutes 44
seconds West 155. /5 reet,. thence South 2 degrees 47
minutes 00 seconds West 55. 40 reet to the
southwester(y fine of said Lot / and there termInating.
...p..
/' ;-""'~
....., ..J- 1/.-)
C'>~ ..0"" ...J
) ) ')
C ({-.
TRnJR
Proposed Area: 45, 542. 8 ~'"'Q. FT.
Trees:
o Denotes Oak
A -DenOTes Ash
P -Denotes Pine
B -Denotes Basswood
'"'C:ltr.l
~&
o ....
'"'C:l g: a...
o ..... .......
CI.l () ~ INC.
1-.-1 ~ No.
l....J 6141
t:l -0110il
t:l 44'11
<
H
CI.l
H
~
1 Ioorebr oerlJf;r lIoot _ _..... pllul or report .... 1'''''1'....., "". ID.
or u."", IftT <1'.....1 rmp.m.lo. au" rb.1 1 .11I . <lu11 &".10"" ,...""
6untI1fIr lID"" Ill. '.n ot 11oo Stille ot MIn..fOt..
File No.
M flUno"'" "". ID. 110I.
.,. 01
. ZO_,
"BOo/r- ,.
PROPOSED PROPERTY
DIVISION
PREPARBD FOR:
KAWELL MOONEY SAWYER
ARCIll'l'IGTS II BUI1J)IRS
tl46S CITY Jfl!Sf' PARKWAY.
DEN PIW1UE, JIN ItJ344
DAVID B. CROOK. U.
MIIlD. Re,.. No. U41f
Scole
.
.
. 'J~
:::E
.~
..
.~
~
Q
.,
---..-..-...-
i
I
'-, ;;. ~l
'"
R€~i denG.e..
t.
I
I
I
c~ :,:.::,,~
.., .'
U:..'
.--- ....
.....--~.. .
:c
"
~
v:
'>~7"Z3~
,
I
~2.7. ..1
N'ne. t 11111-. d,..,.,.., uf.ll~'1 eo~n" ... be.
"'_~d ....., 1m'." t........ 1M '1"'Ii
--l
I
'Il
""
.....
.
........'
Ho 0 per
Lake i
/.
,/
, .
-'."''It \.". __r
~'l~.
"'~
~-
0..
~. STRf:/!T-
.... \
~.~
''''b
SCALE: , INCH = '00 FEET
DATE : JULV 31. '990
COFFIN & GRONBERG, INC.
ENGINEERS, LAND SURVEYORS, PLANNERS
LONG LAKE, MINNESOTA
Exhibit D
R. BOWMAN ADDITION
..s?:;
.':1(;
--... 00
.
y
C /ry P",r:' .r./;";t~""'O(;O
.
'~I:..b ~. ij
.Y I ,-'
~
JI .' l.'
. '
. o( 0
, ,.
~. .4 . _'
..
~ ...
1/3( i
l i ",.,...'
1
~ CO-Y~' lJe€;P""'AV.
6
... .,
-.
,
55,400t'9' ft:
.,...
.~
I
..
"
,.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION APPROVING A MINOR SUBDIVISION OF REAL PROPERTY
FOR RICHARD BOWMAN
WHEREAS, Richard Bowman (Applicant) is the owner of certain real property in the
City of Shorewood, legally described as:
"Lot 1, Block 1, R. Bowman Addition, except the northerly 40.00 feet thereof, Hennepin
County, Minnesota"; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a subdivision of said real property
into two parcels legally described in Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant and all other parties holding an interest in said real property
have agreed to grant to the City drainage and utility easements legally described in Exhibit B,
attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant and all other parties holding an interest in said real property
have agreed to grant a drainage and utility easement legally described in Exhibit C, attached
hereto and made a part hereof, in favor of the southerly parcel described in Exhibit A; and
WHEREAS, the subdivision requested by the Applicants complies in all respects with
the Shorewood Zoning Code.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
1. The real property legally described herein be divided into two parcels, legally
described in Exhibit A.
2. The City Clerk furnish the Applicant with a certified copy of this resolution for
recording purposes.
3. The Applicant record this resolution, together with the drainage and utility
easements legally described in Exhibits B and C, with the Hennepin County Recorder or
Registrar of Titles within thirty (30) days of the date ofthe certification of this resolution.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 28th day of
July 2003.
ATTEST:
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
CRAIG W. DAWSON, CITY ADMINISTRATOR
.
.
Proposed Legal Description of Northerly Parcel:
That part of Lot 1, Block 1, R. BOWMAN ADDITION, which lies south of the northerly 40.00
feet of said Lot 1, and northerly of a line described as follows:
Beginning at a point on the east line of said Lot 1, a distance of 145.00 feet southerly of the
northeasterly comer of said Lot 1; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 24 minutes
15 seconds West 154.27 feet; thence South 72 degrees 51 minutes 44 seconds West 155.15 feet;
thence South 2 degrees 47 minutes 00 seconds West 55.40 feet to the southwesterly line of said
Lot 1 and there terminating.
Proposed Legal Description of Southerly Parcel:
That part of Lot 1, Block 1, R. BOWMAN ADDITION, which lies southerly of a line described
as follows:
Beginning at a point on the east line of said Lot 1, a distance of 145.00 feet southerly of the
northeasterly comer of said Lot 1; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 24 minutes
15 seconds West 154.27 feet; thence South 72 degrees 51 minutes 44 seconds West 155.15 feet;
thence South 2 degrees 47 minutes 00 seconds West 55.40 feet to the southwesterly line of said
Lot 1 and there terminating.
Exhibit A
I
,
.
.
Proposed Legal Description of Drainage & Utility Easement:
An easement for drainage and utility purposes over, under and across that part of Lot 1, Block 1,
R. BOWMAN ADDITION, which lies 10.00 feet on each side of a line described as follows:
Beginning at a point on the east line of said Lot 1, a distance of 145.00 feet southerly of the
northeasterly comer of said Lot 1; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 24 minutes
15 seconds West 154.27 feet; thence South 72 degrees 51 minutes 44 seconds West 155.15 feet;
thence South 2 degrees 47 minutes 00 seconds West 55.40 feet to the southwesterly line of said
Lot 1 and there terminating.
Exhibit B
f
,
.
.
Proposed Legal Description of Sanitary Sewer Easement:
A 15 foot easement for sanitary sewer purposes over, under and across the property described as
follows:
That part of Lot 1, Block 1, R. BOWMAN ADDITION, which lies south of the northerly 40.00
feet of said Lot 1, and northerly of a line described as follows:
Beginning at a point on the east line of said Lot 1, a distance of 145.00 feet southerly of the
northeasterly comer of said Lot 1; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 24 minutes
15 seconds West 154.27 feet; thence South 72 degrees 51 minutes 44 seconds West 155.15 feet;
thence South 2 degrees 47 minutes 00 seconds West 55.40 feet to the southwesterly line of said
Lot 1 and there terminating.
The centerline of said easement is described as:
Beginning at a point on the east line of said Lot 1, a distance of 145.00 feet southerly of the
northeasterly comer of said Lot 1; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 24 minutes
15 seconds West 132.5 feet to the point of beginning; thence North 12 degrees 10 minutes 12
seconds West 77.5 feet; thence North 68 degrees 38 minutes 08 seconds West 83.0 feet to the
southerly line of the north 40.00 feet of said Lot 1 and there terminating. The side lines of said
easement are intended to intersect the boundary of the subject property.
Exhibit C
~,
~.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD. MINNESOiA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
24 July 2003
RE:
Our Savior's Lutheran Church - Request toExtend Deadline for
Correction of Zoning Violations
FILE NO.
Property(23290 State Highway 7)
For many months staff has been working with Our Savior's Church to resolve zoning
issues with respect to lighting and noise. While some progress has been made in
reducing lighting levels, both noise and light remain problems.
.
This process has been delayed, in part, by state budget constraints that do not allow
for Minnesota Pollution Control Agency personnel to assist cities in monitoring noise
complaints. City staff was ultimately able to borrow the necessary equipment to
verify that noise levels were in fact higher than what is allowed. Subsequently, a
letter was sent to the church, setting forth a deadline for bringing both the noise and
the lighting levels into compliance (see Exhibit A, attached). Exhibit B is a request
by church representatives asking for additional time to make the corrections.
Blind copies ofthis memo have been sent to the area residents who have been more
than patient in waiting for the corrections to be made. It is reasonable to expect that
you will hear from them, ifnot at the meeting, then probably by telephone or e-mail.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
J effMachemehl
n
t..1 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
-=If 8 F
\'
J
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
3 July 2003
Ms. Trina V olbrecht
Our Savior's Lutheran Church
23310 State Highway 7
Shorewood, MN 55331
Re:
Zoning Violations - Our Savior's Church
.
Dear Ms. V olbrecht:
This is to update you on the status of our investigations regarding lighting and noise levels on the
church property. Although some progress appears to have been made on lighting, both lighting
and noise remain in violation of City Codes.
Lighting.
There are two areas in violation. On the east side of the parking lot, the tall fixture still casts
higher light levels into the back yards of the properties to the east. It appears that a shield has
been installed on the rear side of the fixture, which helps, but does not resolve the problem.
Perhaps a more hooded fixture or a larger shield would bring it into compliance.
The second area is behind the building. It appears that some of the security wall packs have .
some sort of shielding, but the light levels at the property line are still in excess of what the codes
allow by approximately 50 percent. Again, it seems as though the lighting manufacturer should
have some sort of hood device that would direct the lighting downward more than outward.
Something that would help immensely would be to simply turn the lights off or down after 9:00
P.M. No one, including this office, understands why the lights need to be on so bright, all night
long, way in excess of what might be needed for reasonable security.
Noise
Although the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency has adequate funding to assist cities with
noise issues, they were willing to loan us the testing equipment to monitor the noise levels from
the H.Y.A.C equipment at the rear of the building. We were at the site between 3:45 P.M and
4:15 P.M on Wednesday, 18 June, and found the following:
. With only one half ofthe units running at a time, the noise levels are within allowable
daytime (7:00 A.M. to 10:00 P.M) levels. Presumably, the noise levels would be greater
during warmer weather, when more ofthe units are running.
{) PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER t:...)(h ~'o ~ -t A.
'"'
.
~.
.
.
Ms. Trina V olbrecht
Re: Zoning Violations - Our Savior's Church
3 July 2003
Page two
. These same noise levels are well in excess of what is allowed for nighttime hours (10:00
P.M. to 7:00 P.M.)
While we appreciate the attempts to comply with City Codes, the site still falls short. Since I was
unable to obtain the assistance from the PCA in a timely manner, I am willing to extend the
deadline for compliance to 15 July. However, this extension is specifically conditioned on the
following: .
1. The lights on the property must be dimmed or shut off at 9:00 P.M. If the system does
not have a timer, please advise your maintenance or custodial staffto manually adjust the
lighting.
2. The H.V.A.C system must not be run between the hours of 10:00 P.M. and 7:00 A.M.
Again, please advise your staff to operate the system manually, ifit can not be set
automatically.
3. Your mechanical contractor must submit a sound attenuation plan to us before 15 July.
Area residents have been more than patient, but are ready to take this problem to the City Council
for legal action, which will no doubt happen if the issues are not resolved immediately. I would
hope that this would not have to happen.
If you have any questions relative to these matters, please do not hesitate to contact my office at
952-474-3236 or bye-mail atpl8.lming@ci.shorewood.mn.us.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
~
Bradley J. Nielsen
Planning Director
Cc: Mayor and City Council
Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Ot.t( GAvIO(
LUTHERAN CHURCH & SCHOOL
15 July 2003
City of Shorewood
c/o Mr. Brad Nielsen
5775 Country Club Road
Shorewood MN 55331
Re: Zoning Violations Response
Cc: Jeff Machemehl
Board of Trustees
Pastor Zahrte
Dear City Council,
On 7 July Our Savior Lutheran Church and School received a letter requesting some site corrections with
regards to our HV AC equipment and property lights. A deadline was given of 15 July to correct 3 violations. On
behalf of Our Savior Lutheran Church and School, I am requesting an extension. OSLCS has been working
cooperatively with the city in every step ofthe way over the last year. We are interested in moving forward and
have made great progress in the last eight days. It simply is not feasible to correct the violations in an efficient
and long term manner.
At 2pm on 15 July OSLCS met with Mr. Nielsen, Mr. Bruce Boerner and Mr. John Gorg both from Egan
Mechanical. The following progress was made:
1. The four back wall lights will have coated bulbs installed reducing the illumination by 10%.
2. The parking lot bulbs will have coated bulbs installed reducing the illumination by 20%.
3. . The east property parking light already had a shield installed. This shield will be extended by six inches
to further reduce the amount of light at the property line.
4. Mr. Boerner and Mr. Nielson retested the HVAC noise levels with the whole system running. The
readings were consistent with the original ones taken by Mr. Nielsen 01') 18 June. We are within 5 dBA
of the nighttime levels. Mr. Boerner has scheduled an appointment for 16 July with a third party
company to evaluate the sound level and provide a corrective solution. This solution will involve
wrapping the noise producing compressors with a sound absorbing blanket. It is a common practice with
this type of equipment.
5. Discussion took place about additional options to further assist in noise reduction including additional
landscaping at the property line and around the HV AC chiller.
It is our belief that the lightening solutions above will correct the problem. This wi!! be done as soon as Egan is
available to do the service. The HVAC is a little more complicated and needs to be assessed for the best
solution. This evaluation will be taking place tomorrow. At that time we will have more detailed information on
the length of time we need to request to comply with the requests. Fixing the sound levels right the first time will
insure a positive outcome for the city, our neighbors and our church.
It is my hope that our request will be evaluated and granted based on our willingness to cooperate and our
actions to date. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
&;?I-<""
Trina Volbrecht
Administrator x20
23290 Highway Seven, Excelsior MN 55331
952.474.5181 f:952.470.1985
f,){ h'lb~1- 0
..~
,J
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
24 July 2003
RE:
Bayside Bank - Request for Limited Certificate of Occupancy
FILE NO.
405(02.01)
.
The approval of the CUB/Shorewood Village Center project was subject to a
condition that CUB would not get a certificate of occupancy until such time as the
Lake Linden Trail is done and at least the perimeter landscaping is completed.
Bayside Bank has requested that they be given a limited C.O. forthe bank only,
possibly earlier than the landscaping would be completed. This will allow them to
relocate only once. As a practical matter, the bank is already there~ as are the other
shopping center tenants. Staff does not feel that allowing a very limited C.O. for the
bank would violate the spirit of the previous approval.
If you have any questions relative to this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me
prior to the meeting.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Robin Roberts
Bob Knudson
Joe pazandak
n
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
1t~
SECOND AMENDMENT
to
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
by and between
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
and
SHOREWOOD VILLAGE SHOPPING CENTER, INC.
DRAFT
THIS AMENDMENT, made this day of July, 2003, by and between the CITY
OF SHOREWOOD, a Minnesota municipal corporation (hereinafter the "City"), and
SHOREWOOD VILLAGE SHOPPING CENTER, INC., a Nevada corporation (hereinafter the
"Developer").
RECITALS
.
WHEREAS, the Developer entered into a Development Agreement dated December 17,
2002, relating to the development of the Shorewood Village Shopping Center; and
WHEREAS, the Developer entered into the First Amendment to the Development
Agreement with the City of Shore wood in that amendment dated March 24,2003; and
WHEREAS, the Developer previously proposed to construct a well and water storage
system for the provision of domestic and fire protection water; and
.
WHEREAS, the Developer, by and through the offices of the City Engineer, has
undertaken a determination as to the feasibility of providing water to the Project through the City
public water system ("Public Water"); and
WHEREAS, the Developer has undertaken to work with and cooperate with the
developer ofthe adjacent Linden Hills subdivision to coordinate the construction of Public Water
to the Proj ect.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and guarantees contained
herein, the parties agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1. Developer agrees to undertake, at its sole cost and expense, the construction of
Public Water according to the terms, conditions and specifications set forth in the Project Manual
prepared by WSB & Associates, Inc. for the Cub Foods Watermain Improvements and
Appurtenant Work (the "Water Improvements") dated June 27, 2003.
2. Developer shall undertake the construction of the Water Improvements within the
rights-of-way and utility easements as provided in the Project Manual.
#1H
.
3. Developer shall provide the restoration of all areas disturbed by the Water
Improvements and provide a cash surety or letter-of-credit to assure restoration of disturbed
streets, and vegetation and other improvements to the satisfaction of the City.
4. Developer shall provide to the City a minimum 20-foot utility easement where the
Water Improvement is located within the Subject Property.
5. Developer understands that the City will withhold the issuance of a certificate of
occupancy for the Cub store Shorewood Village Center until the Water Improvements have been
tested, inspected, and accepted by the City Engineer.
6. Upon completion ofthe Water Improvements and acceptance by the City
Engineer, the Developer shall dedicate the Water Improvements to the City free of liens and
encumbrances.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused these presents to be executed
on the day first above written. .
SHOREWOOD VILLAGE
SHOPPING CENTER, INC.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
By:
Its:
By:
Woody Love
Its: Mayor
ATTEST:
Craig W. Dawson
Its: City Administrator/Clerk
.
By:
DR FT
2.
,
.
.
.
.
STATE OF MINNESOTA)
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
DRAFT
On this day of July, 2003, before me, a Notary Public within and for said
County, personally appeared Woody Love and Craig W. Dawson, to me personally known, who,
being each by me duly sworn, did say that they are respectively the Mayor and City
Administrator/Clerk of the municipal corporation named in the foregoing instrument, and that
said instrument was signed and sealed on behalf of said corporation by authority of its City
Council, and said Mayor and City Administrator/Clerk acknowledged said instrument to be the
free act and deed of said corporation.
Notary
STATE OF MINNESOTA)
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this day of July, 2003, before me, within and for said County, personally
appeared , of Shorewood Village
Shopping Center, Inc., the Developer, described in and who executed the foregoing instrument
and acknowledged that it executed the same as its free act and deed.
Notary Public
THIS INSTRUMENT WAS DRAFTED BY:
LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DALY & LINDGREN, LTD.
1500 WELLS FARGO PLAZA
7900 XERXES AVENUE SOUTH
BLOOMINGTON, MINNESOTA 55431
(952) 835-3800
871671.1
3.
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
by and between
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
and
KELLY BOSWORTH
THIS AGREEMENT, made this day of July, 2003, by and between the CITY
OF SHOREWOOD, a Minnesota municipal corporation (hereinafter the "City"), and KELLY
BOSWORTH d/b/a Bosco, Inc. (the "Property Owner"), relating to the construction of
municipal water service (the Property).
RECITALS
.
WHEREAS, the Property Owner is the owner of that certain real property located in the
City of Shorewood adjacent to Lake Linden Drive and west of Shorewood Village Center
described in the attached Exhibit A; and
WHEREAS, the owner of the Shorewood Village Center proposes to construct the
extension of City water pursuant to the Proj ect Manual prepared by WSB & Associates, Inc. for
the Cub Foods Watermain Improvements and Appurtenant Work dated June 27, 2003, (the
"Water Improvements"); and
WHEREAS, the Water Improvements as proposed will extend city water service to the
east boundary of the Property; and
WHEREAS, the Property Owner has agreed to participate in the cost of the construction
of the Water Improvements in consideration for access to the Water Improvements.
.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and promises contained
hen::in, the parties agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1. The City agrees to approve and facilitate the design of the Water Improvement
plan to provide a six-inch watermain with a design capacity of 410 GPM together with a fire
hydrant and stub to the east property line of the Property.
2. In consideration of the Property Owner's cost participation with the owner of the
Shorewood Village Shopping Center in the construction of the Water Improvements, the City
agrees to waive future assessments, fees or connection charges associated with the construction
of City water to the Property.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Agreement to be duly
executed on the day first above written.
#-
f(. I.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
By:
Woody Love
Its: Mayor
Kelly Bosworth
ATTEST:
By:
Craig W. Dawson
Its: City Administrator/Clerk
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
.
On this day of July, 2003, before me, a Notary Public within and for said
County, personally appeared Woody Love and Craig Dawson, to me personally known, who,
being each by me duly sworn, did say that they are respectively the Mayor and City
Administrator/Clerk of the municipal corporation named in the foregoing instrument, and that
said instrument was signed and sealed on behalf of said corporation by authority of its City
Council, and said Mayor and City Administrator/Clerk acknowledged said instrument to be the
free act and deed of said corporation.
Notary Public
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
.
On this day of July, 2003, before me, within and for said County, personally
appeared Kelly Bosworth, the Property Owner described herein, and who executed the foregoing
instrument and acknowledged that she executed the same as her free act and deed.
Notary Public
THIS INSTRUMENT WAS DRAFTED BY:
LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DALY & LINDGREN, LTD.
1500 WELLS FARGO PLAZA
7900 XERXES AVENUE SOUTH
BLOOMINGTON, MINNESOTA 55431
(952) 835-3800
871988.1
2.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD. MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
DATE:
July 24, 2003
TO:
FROM:
Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director ~
RE:
cc:
Liquor Store Lease Recommendations
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator ~
Liquor Committee Members
.
The lease for the Shorewood Village Shopping Center municipal liquor store has been in
negotiation for several months. The Council will recall that a one year Amendment
extending the current terms and conditions was authorized in December 2002. At that time,
the fate of the CUB development proposal was uncertain and given the current ambiguity of
the situation, and a lease expiration date of December 31, 2002, the landlord proposed a one-
year continuation of the current lease.
Since that time, staff has been negotiating with the leasing agents or owners for many
months to obtain a lease renewal. The Liquor Committee (comprised of Councilmembers
Garfunkle and Zerby, Administrator Dawson, Finance Director Burton, and Liquor Director
Swandby) has been meeting regularly to review and discuss the progress of the lease
negotiations.
The final meeting occurred earlier this week with the Shopping Center owner and leasing
agents and an agreement was reached. The major provisions of the lease are as follows:
. The municipal liquor store will occupy approximately 4,388 square feet in the area
previously occupied by the florist and the pet store.
ft
~.1 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
=/I-qfl
~I
. The lease is for a five-year period, starting November 1, 2003, and concluding
October 31,2008.
. Rents start at $9.60 per square foot and increase to a maximum of $14 per square
foot. Compared to current rents reported by the landlord, the City's rate is quite
favorable.
. The landlord will remove interior walls and old carpet in the new space.
. The landlord will provide the City with a tenant's improvements allowance of
$30,000.
. The lease provides for a three (3)-year out clause, as required by state statute in the
event of three years of consecutive business losses.
This lease agreement is the culmination of many hours of discussion, meetings, and
negotiation. The Liquor Committee and staff believe it is a beneficial agreement for both
the City and the Landlord.
.
Recommended Action
The Liquor Committee and staff recommend that the City Council approve the proposed
Lease Amendment #2 between the Shorewood Village Shopping Center and the City of
Shorewood, and authorize the Mayor and the City Administrator to enter into lease
agreement subject to the review and approval of the City Attorney.
.
.
.
Amendment #3
To Lease Dated July 17, 1998 By and Between
Shorewood Village Shopping Center, Inc., as Landlord
And City of Shorewood, a Minnesota municipal corporation, as Tenant
THIS AMENDMENT TO LEASE is entered into and made as of this 23rd day of July, 2003, by and between
Shorewood Village Shopping Center, Inc., as Landlord and City of Shorewood, a Minnesota municipal corporation, as
Tenant.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant have heretofore entered into a certain lease dated July 17, 1998 (the "Lease"),
containing approximately 3,990 square feet of certain leased premises at Shorewood Village Shopping Center, located at 23730
Highway 7, Shorewood, Minnesota 55331 (the "Premises"), upon terms and conditions described in said Lease; and
WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant entered into an Amendment # 1 dated November 28, 2001, extending Tenant's Lease
for a period of one year, and:
WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant entered into an Amendment #2 dated December 12,2002, extending Tenant's Lease
for a period of one year, and:
WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant desire to amend said Lease as described below:
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the rents received and of the covenants and agreements herein set forth, it is
agreed that the Lease be hereby amended from and after the date hereof as follows:
Premises
The premises shall be relocated to 23670 Highway 7 (defined herein) situated as set forth on Exhibit A, containing
approximately 4,388 square feet including any alterations, additions or repairs made thereto.
Term
The Term of the Lease is extended for a period of five (5) years commencing November 1,2003 and terminating
October 31, 2008.
Minimum Rent
Tenant shall pay Landlord on or before the first day of each month, minimum monthly rent base rent according to the following
schedule:
November 1,2003 - October 31, 2004
November 1,2004 - October 31, 2005
November 1,2005 - October 31, 2006
November 1, 2006 - October 31, 2007
November 1,2007 - October 31, 2008
Rent
p.s.f.
$ 9.60
$12.50
$13.00
$13.50
$14.00
Annual
Rent
$42,124.80
$54,850.00
$57,044.00
$59,238.00
$61,432.00
Monthly
Rent
$3,510.40
$4,570.83
$4,753.67
$4,936.50
$5,119.33
Oneratine Expenses
Effective November 1,2003, Tenant shall pay its new pro rata share of operating expenses (15.37% - Mall and 6.07% - CAM).
Tenants pro-rata share will be adjusted in the event of expansion or contraction of the shopping center.
1
.'
Amendment #3 to Lease
City of Shorewood
Page Two
Landlord's work
Prior to the start of Tenant Work, Landlord shall, at Landlord sole cost and expense, shall remove all interior walls
including demising walls between spaces (to include one 6 foot section of left hand portion of the interior brick wall) and
remove carpet.
Tenant Improvement Allowance
Construction Allowance for Tenant's Work. Provided Tenant is not in default under any of the terms and conditions
contained herein, Landlord shall reimburse Tenant for a portion of the cost of Tenant's Work within the Premises, in the
amount and manner hereinafter provided. The amount of such reimbursement shall hereinafter be referred to as ''Tenant's
Allowance". It is understood and agreed that Tenant's Allowance shall be a reimbursement for a portion of the actual costs
incurred by Tenant to complete Tenant's Work within the Premises as detailed in the plans and specifications therefore to be
approved by Landlord. Tenant's Allowance shall be Thirty Thousand and no/lOOths Dollars ($30,000.00)
.
Landlord shall pay Tenant's Allowance to Tenant when Tenant has opened for business in the Premises, paid the Minimum
Rent and Additional Rent for the first month of the Term of this Lease and furnished to Landlord the following:
~ Copies of paid invoices documenting the actual cost incurred by Tenant to complete Tenant's Work within the
Premises;
~ The affidavit of the general contractor stating that (i) Tenant's Work has been fully completed in accordance with
the plans and specifications approved by Landlord, subject. however, to Landlord's verification thereof and (ii) all
subcontractors, laborers and material supplies have been paid in full;
~ A wavier of lien, with respect to the Premises, executed by every subcontractor, laborer and material supplier
engaged in or supplying labor or materials; and
~ A certificate of use and occupancy for the Premises issued by the appropriate governmental authority.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein, Landlord reserves the right to offset against Tenant's Allowance
any delinquent amounts due to Landlord by Tenant accrued hereunder. In the event this Lease shall be terminated for any
reason prior to the natural expiration of the initial Term of the Lease, Tenant shall pay to Landlord the unamortized portion
of Tenant's Allowance, said amortization to be computed using the "straight-line" method of generally accepted accounting
practices.
.
Tenant agrees that Tenant's Work within the Premises and all other work undertaken by Tenant in the Premises shall be
performed in a first-class and workmanlike manner and all equipment, fixtures and installation shall be new and in usable
condition on the Commencement Date.
Tenant's Option to Terminate
Should tenant operate its business at a loss during any consecutive three (3) year period during this five (5) year term, Tenant
may terminate the Lease by giving Landlord 120 days advance written notice, but not earlier than July 1, 2006. If tenant
exercises its option to terminate the Lease, tenant shall pay the unamortized tenant improvement allowance and unamortized
leasing commission. Payment shall be amortized with an imputed interest rate of 8% and paid at the same time notice is given.
2
.
.
Amendment #3 to Lease
City of Shorewood
Page Three
Options
With the exception of this document, any and all options added to the Lease, Exhibit or Rider to the Lease, either expressed or
implied, will be extinguished with this amendment.
Execution and Deliverv Required
This document shall have no binding effect on the parties unless executed by the landlord and the tenant and a fully executed
copy is delivered to the tenant.
Except as is hereinabove set forth, all terms, provisions and covenants of the Lease shall remain unchanged and in full force and
effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Amendment #2 as of the date and year first
above written.
LANDLORD:
TENANT:
Shorewood Village Shopping Center, Inc.
City of Shorewood
By
By
Its
Its
Date
Date
3
r
Bonnie Burton
,j
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Bonnie Burton
Thursday, July 24, 2003 3:28 PM
'tkeane@lhdl.com'
Craig Dawson
Shorewood Village Liquor Store Lease
Tim -
Attached is the revised amendment to the Shorewood Village Liquor Lease. It is the landlord's preference to amend the
existing lease, rather than enter into an entire new lease. (A copy of which was e-mailed to you.) The amendment seems
to include all that we agreed upon, and staff is recommending approval by the City Council subject to your review and
approval.
Please review and comment!
Thanks -
Bonnie
.
.
.
Memo to Council Liq
Leases 7-2...
LIQUOR-AIIllNDII2-re
visedju123.do.. .
Bonnie Burton
Finance Director
City of Shorewood, MN
bburton@ci.shorewood.mn.us
(952)474-3236
.
1
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhal\@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
July 24,2003
.
TO:
Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director ~
FROM:
RE: Beverage Cooler Purchase: Shorewood Village Liquor Store
CC: Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator ^ ~
Liquor Committee Members ~
In conjunction with the remodeling of the Shorewood Village Liquor Store, staff has been
reviewing specifications for the new beverage cooler for that store. Don Swandby met with
several vendors and anticipates receiving quotes for this purchase within days. As of this
time, it is his expectation that the quotes will be approximately $45,000. If the quotes are
. higher (around $50,000), the City will be required to obtain sealed bids for this purchase.
If sealed bids are necessary, the City Council will be asked to approve specifications and
authorize advertisement for bids for a beverage cooler at the Monday night meeting. After
advertising, and receipt of sealed bids, staff would then recommend a bid award.
Liquor Operations Manager Don Swandby is coordinating this process and purchase
information is still pending as of the time of this writing. Staff anticipates having a full
report available at Monday night's City Council meeting and appreciates the Council's
patience and flexibility.
Recommended Action
For City Council information only. No action is required at this time.
{) PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
1fqB
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 . www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
Craig Dawson, City Administrator
Larry Brown, Director of Public Works .w
.
July 27,2003
FROM:
.
DATE:
RE: Authorization for Expenditure of Funds - Used Paver
The Park Commission has identified the need for construction of a walkway within Freeman Park.
This, based upon the feedback received from residents to have a walkway along the north end of
ballfields 4,5 and 6. This would allow pedestrians to walk around and observe activities in this area,
without having to be in the center of the activity. In addition, this segment of trail creates a large loop
through Shorewood Ponds and Freeman Park.
To minimize costs for the project, it has been recommended that the Department of Public Works
perform this construction, Public Works personnel constructed this type of trail along Eureka Road
last year.
.
Construction of a 5-foot wide trail requires a size paver that is becoming difficult to obtain. Since the
state standards have been revised to a 8.0 foot wide minimum, the smaller pavers have become
difficult to locate or rent. Staff has been able to rent this type of paver from Dawson Blacktopping Inc.
The owner of the firm has indicated the desire to sell the paver, since the wider width trail segments
are in higher demand in the marketplace.
Coincidentally, the City of Excelsior also has the need to construct a substantial trail segment 6.0 feet
in width. It is recommended that the two cities split the cost of purchase of a used paver to construct
the trail segments, and perform the work with city crews.
The total cost of the paver is $7,500 (without sales tax). Each city would pay $3,750, plus sales tax.
Costs of performing the work with the City's crews is very cost beneficial, compared to the cost of
rental or contracting the work to be performed. This type of paver will also provide the ability to
remove and restore larger areas of pavement that have deteriorated.
While this item has been discussed on several occasions, this was not formally included in the previous
Capital Improvement Programs. However, Staff is recommending approval of the joint purchase, with
the City of Excelsior, in the amount of $3,700. If approved, this will be funded from the Equipment
Replacement Fund.
ft
\,: PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#/DA
Mayor and City Council
Expenditure of Funds - Paver
July 24, 2003
Page 2 of 2
Recommendation:
Staff is recommending approval of a motion that authorizes the expenditure of funds in the amount of
$3700 (plus sales tax), to Dawson Blacktopping, Inc. for a used asphalt paver.
.
.