HomeMy WebLinkAbout092302 CC Ws AgP
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. ~HOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331,,;8927. (952) 474-3,236
FAX (952) 474-0128 . www.cLshorewood.mn.us ~ cityhall@cLshOrewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayar and City Cadncil
Park Cammissian
Planning Cammissian
Craig Dawsan,CityAdministratar
Larry Brow~, Director of Public Vf odcs ~
September 21,2002
FROM:
DA TE:
RE:
Wark Sessian an Smithtawn Raad and Trail Pracess
During "the ,September 9th City Cauncil meeting, an~genda item far the Appraval of Plans
Specificatians and E~timat~ was placed befare th~ City Cotmcil far cansideratian. During the
discus sian af that item, and well afterwards, there was considerable canfusian as to. why this item was
placed on' th~ agenda ip the time and the way that it was. Out df those questians and canfusian arase /
the need far a wark sessianta discuss these issues. '
Ilackground
Since September 9th, Staff has discussed this internally and det~rmined that the first item af business
was to. prepare a chranalagy af what has taken place thus far. In an attempt to. do. this, we discavered
that it is virtually impassible to. separate the Smithtawn Raad aff ,street trail issue from the
camprehensive trail planning pracess. After all, bath af these items have been around abaut the same
time! As s,uch, I am proaf pasitive that despite many haurs af pauring aver a ma~mtain af minutes,
agendas and files" t-hatwe that we may have, thaugh nat intentianally, amitted a key part arstep that
was taken during the pracess. We discavered tha.t to. try to. dacument all af the events wauld take an
inardinate amaunt af time. Nanetheless, a ~ummary af events has been campiled as Attachment 1.
During the research campleted, Staff also. excerpted a dacument dated September 1, 1998 far the Trail
PlanningPracess. This has alSo. been included in yaur packet as Attachment 2. This dacument was
ariginally drafted by Mr. Mark Kaegler, af Haisingtan Kaegler Group, Inc., to. assist the City in
develaping the aver all Trail Plan fat the Camprehensive Plan. Guided by the Park Commissian, a
Trail Process was'campiled to assist the Park Cammissian, City Cauncil,and ultimately the public in a
process that provided vehicles far feedback in a reasai1a~le faShian, far development af the averalf
Trail Plan. Far reference, ,the bady af the steps far the process has been excerpted belaw.
~
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Mayor, Council, and Commissions
Work Session Smithtown Road Trail
September 21, 2002
Page 2 of 5
"Step 1 - The Park Commission and City Council meeting jointly and/or separately agree that the trail
evaluation process should continue and both parties adopt a common commitment statement.
Step 2 - Building on information collected from the public participation process to date, the Park
Commission completes additional data gathering analysis. Items to be addressed include:
.
Plans of adjacent municipalities
Goals for trails related to safety, quality of life, community connections, etc.
Gather information on value, use, safety, national standards, financial implications, right-of-way
constraints, etc.
.
.
Step 3 - Based upon information gathered in Step 2, the Park Commission assembles a trail concept
depicting trail alignments (verbal and/or graphic) that satisfy identified issues and needs. This step
creates a working concept rather than an overall plan. The concept will be further refined by public
input into the process.
Step 4 - Publicize the concept. State for example, that the City of Shorewood is interested in
providing some type of trail from point A to point B and that the residents in the vicinity of AB will be
invited to a local meeting to learn more and to offer input.
Step 5 - Hold a local (neighborhood) meeting for each geographic area described in the trail concept.
The purpose of the on site meeting is to review the interest in constructing a trail, seek input on the
type of trail that might be appropriate, provide computer graphics or actual photographs of areas with
trails and similar landscape characteristics, and record comments, concerns and issues raised by
meeting participants. Before, during and after the meeting, complete a uniform site evaluation form
that may include:
· The purpose and anticipated function of the trail segment
· A description of the physical characteristics of the alignment area.
· Photographs of the alignment
· Comments on consistency with identified overall objectives
· Trail options (types)
· Preliminary project costs and funding sources
· Comments offered by meeting participants
Step 6 - Collect and revise the results of Step 5. Based upon responses received, eliminate trail
segments that seem unfeasible and assign priorities to those that appear workable.
Step 7 - Inclusive Trail Design - For high priority segments, invite all area residents to be involved in
the trail design process. Provide those who participate with parameters for trail construction
established by the City Council. Depending on the circumstances, the design process could be
facilitated by a design consultant or individual with mediation training. Staff should be available to
Mayor, Council, and Commissions
Work Session Smithtown Road Trail
September 21, 2002
Page 3 of 5
provide technical assistance. The role of the neighborhood design group could be to present a package
of recommendations to the City Council within established parameters on plan details including trail
width, locations, landscaping, etc. The group could continue some lever of involvement through the
actual construction phase of the project. .
Step 8 - Build a trail segment with neighborhood involvement.
Step 9 - Continue the process by moving on to the next trail segment in the priority listing.
Step 10 - As time passes, revisit the alignment areas identified in Step 5 to determine if conditions
have changed.
The ten steps identified above could serve as the foundation for an ongoing process to add trails in
Shorewood. Admittedly, this process may be costly and time consuming. However, it may be the best
way to involve the community in a manner that results in the construction of trails in a cooperative
fashion without promoting dissention and possibly litigation." 1
The document cited above refers to a "Common Commitment Statement" in Step 1 of the process.
This has been included as Attachment 3 to this report. Also included for reference, as Attachment 4 is
the Comprehensive Trail Plan, excerpted from the current Comprehensive Plan.
Many of the questions fielded after September 9th centered on "Just which step are we in for the Trail
Planning Process?" and "Why was the Smithtown Road Plans placed on the agenda in what appeared
to be for the action of approval, for the final set of construction documents?"
The answer to the first question? Hopefully, a consensus can be reached during Monday night's work
session as to where the process is at this point in time.
The second question I can address...
Smithtown Road and Trail
The Council and Commissions may recall that Smithtown Road is not an ordinary right of way
process. The City Attorney was directed to prepare a right of way study known as an "Owners and
Encumbrances Report." Quite simply, this report was to document who had control or interest in what
appeared to be the right of way and adjacent parcels along the entire length of Smithtown Road. This
report is included for reference as Attachment 5.
After the Owners and Encumbrances report was completed, an open house meeting was conducted in
September 2000, utilizing the roadway section with a widened shoulder on the North side of the
roadway. Comments were received during that meeting, including those requesting that consideration
Mayor, Council, and Commissions
Work Session Smith town Road Trail
September 21, 2002
Page 4 of 5
be given to an off street trail. Throughout the following days and weeks, several comments and
petitions were received asking for, and protesting against further consideration of an off street trail.
On January 28 th, 2002 the City Council directed Staff to proceed with the design of widened shoulders
and an off street trail west of the LRT (refer to Attachment 6). The west portion would be decided
after a neighborhood meeting.
The City's consultant proceeded on that direction. Preliminary plans were undertaken, based on the
direction given. On April 22, 2002 a work session was conducted to provide direction into the design
process. Since the time of the last authorization many petitions and comments had been received
regarding an off street trail along Smithtown Road. Staff was directed to proceed with the design
based upon at trail west of the LRT. The exact dimensions and type of trail would be determined as
part of a neighborhood meeting.
From that point in time, the timing of the design appeared to slowly drag on. The consultant plowed
ahead despite the many issues of drainage, safety and right of way issues that needed to be resolved.
During several meetings the City Council inquired as to the status of the plans.
Two issues remained before Staff:
One: Get plans to a point that the City Council, Park Commission, and Planning Commission could
be apprised that the project was moving forward. With ink still drying, Staff presented the plans to the
City Council for the first time on September 9th.
Second: The Smithtown Road right of way process has deviated from what one would call a normal
process! Over several years of discussion, the direction has been that the right of way for Smithtown
Road would not be obtained by dedication. The goal is to obtain the approval from residents for those
segments where the right of way has not been formally dedicated. If successful, rights of entries could
be obtained, thereby minimizing the cost to the City. Without these rights of entries, it is very possible
(and likely) that a homeowner along one of these segments could protest amidst the construction
process and bring the entire project to a halt mid stream.
While the question of "Who controlled the right of way?" had been answered by the Owners and
Encumbrances Report, the question of "Who was opposed to the project, based on the latest
construction impacts in areas where the right of way was not under the City's control?" had not been
answered. The objective was to get the plans completed (based upon the widest footprint of the trail),
determine what impacts construction limits created for the property owners, and then hit the streets to
determine if there are three, or thirty three property owners who are opposed to the latest proposal.
The agenda item of September 9th, 2002 was for the City Council to accept the proposal given, to
provide Staff the authority to go door to door to discuss the impacts to with each property owner. It
was planned that Staff was to return to the Council and Commissions with that feedback. From there,
plans could be revised for presentation at a neighborhood meeting.
Mayor, Council, and Commissions
Work Session Smithtown Road Trail
September 21 i 2002
Page 5 of 5
The agenda item, as stated for September 9th, City Council meeting, appeared to be approving the final
construction plans for the project, with no other process to be conducted. This was painfully evident
by the discussion that occurred at that meeting. If this were the case, this would have circumvented
what was directed and intended by the City Council and Commissions. For that I apologize in writing.
It was never the intent of Staff to shortcut the public planning process, or the ability of any of the
Commissions to review the construction documents. What was being sought out was the authority, by
motion, to go door to door to answer the looming right of way questions. In hindsight the wording of
the action item on the agenda should have been revised to reflect a more accurate statement of what
was being presented.
City of Shorewood
Chronology of Trail Planning Process with Smithtown Road
Date Council or Action
Commission
02/21/96 Council Council directed Staft to consider oft street trail with
32-foot wide roadway section.
03/11/96 Council Public Hearing Smithtown Road, watermain,
reconstruction of roadway and oft street trail.
Motion ordering watermain and roadway
improvements. Oft street trail portion delayed.
03/26/96 Park Recommended that City Council reconsider oft-
street trail on Smithtown Road.
04/08/96 Council Received motion by Park Commission for off-street
trail on Smithtown Road.
05/13/96 Council Received comments matter from the floor; residents
requesting off-street trail.
09/23/96 Council Petition received in favor of oft-street trail.
10/14/96 Council Petition received in favor of oft-street trail.
01/28/97 Park Discussion regarding Trail plan
03/11/97 Park Trail Plan review
06/10/97 Park Discussion of Trail Plan mapping
06/24/97 Park Koegler discusses Trail Plan issues
08/06/97 Koegler Memo Trail Planning
09/22/97 Council Approve professional services agreement Mark
Koegler for trail process.
10/14/97 Park, Approved preferred trail plan approach by Koegler
11/11/97 Park Discussion of Detailed Trail Plan with Koegler
12/09/97 Joint C & P Consensus reached regarding trail process
01/13/98 Park Commenced with Trail Subcommittee -
01/28/98 Park Ordered survey from Decision Resources regarding
trails
01/28/98 Park Consensus to send post cards inviting open house
for February 19th, 1998.
03/02/98 Joint C & P Council and Park Commission discussed the pros
and cons of the survey process.
03/30/98 Joint C & P Council and Park Commission discussed survey
compiled by Decision Resources regarding trails,
open space, and parks
04/06/98 Council Work Session Trails
OS/27/98 Park Requested volunteers for Citizen Review
Committee
Attachment 1
07/09/98 1 st Mtg. Identified property impact, safety, and vandalism as
Citizen priorities to be considered.
Review.
Comm
07/16/98 2nd Mtg. Discussed impact of trail on the community and
Citizen strategies to gain support for trails.
Review
Comm
07/23/98 3rd Mtg. Urged the Park Commission to continue with a trail.
Citizen
Review
Comm
09/21/98 Council Work Session to discuss findings of Citizen Review
Committee and survey
09/28/98 Council Approved Statement of Commitment to Trail
Process
10/13/98 Park Approved Statement of Commitment to Trail
Process
01/13/99 Park Park Commission identified trail west of LRT as
Concept
01/25/99 Council Park liaison outlined trail process
02/09/99 . Park Recommended mailing to each house inviting
residents to open forum.
02/23/99 Open House Discussion regarding potential trails
04/10/99 Trail Walk Park Commission performed Trail Walk west of
LRT.
04/10/99 Open House Park Commission conduCted Open House to
receive input on Trail section west of LRT.
05/03/99 Council Comp plan with addition of trail map and 6 new
policies added to Transportation Section of Comp
Plan n
05/10/99 Park Open house conducted to receive input on Trails
06/08/99 Park Park Commission reviewed preliminary design and
cost estimates for trail segment west of
Minnewashta School. Park recommended that the
trail segment be extended to LRT.
06/22/99 Park Passed motion asking Council and Planning
Commission to support trail segment west of the
LRT.
07/26/99 Council Discussion regarding right of way and trail
possibilities
09/14/99 Park Approved the standard surface for trails
constructed, as part of the trail process would be
bituminous and 8 foot in width. This basic standard
is recommended for the following reasons: limited
funding, suitable durability and consistency with trail
construction in other west metro communities. The
intent is to have a consistent appearance.
Variations in standards for a series of properties will
be considered provided affected property owners
are in agreement. Residents may petition to
j exceed the standard, but will be expected to fund
the difference in cost.
09/27/99 Council Park Liaison presented Trail Standards
12/131,99 Council Comp Plan discussion prioritizing trail segments
and inclusion of trail map in comprehensive plan.
09/11/00 Park Conducted public meeting to receive input
11/05/00 Open House
01/28/02 Council Approved concept plans with widened shoulder and
off-street trail to be presented at public info meeting
04/04/02 Open House Public Info meeting conducted to receive input on
Smithtown Road with widened shoulders
04/22/02 Council Discussion of open house, with direction to proceed
with design of widened shoulders and off-street trail
to the west. West portion would be decided after
neighborhood meeting.
04/27/02 Park Park Commission approves Comp Plan with Trail
Concept Map
06/12/02 Council Approved mailing to residents regarding trail
09/09/02 Council Accepting preliminary concept plans and
authorizing right of way process.
OS/28/02 Council Authorization for Engineering proposal for
, Smithtown Road Improvement Project
612-3386838
HOISINGTON KOEGLER
119 P02
SEP 02 '98 14:08
MEMORANDUM
Hoisington Koegler Group Inc.
11113
1MB
TO: Shorewood Park COmmission
DATE: September 1) 1998
SUBJECT: Trail Planning Process - Next Step
FROM: Mark Koegler
At the Park Commission meeting on August 11 th, we conducted a review of the public participation
process related to trails in Shorewood. Specific comments focused on the vision session that was
held, on the survey that was completed by Decision Resources, and on the input and
recommendations provided by the Citizen Review Group. After considering the results of
participation process to date, the Park Commission requested information on the next step.
Specifically stated, where do we go from here? This memorandum is intended to be a working
response to this question. It lays out my preliminary thoughts and those of City Administrator, Jim
Hurm pertaining to a suggested way to proceed at tbis time. The steps that are outlined herein do
not pretend to be the definitive way in which we need to proceed with this effort but rather, a
suggested program for consideration and modification as deemed appropriate by the Park
Commission and City Council.
What lessons have we learned from the process to date?
One of the principal reasons for conducting an extensive public participation process was the
objective of making trail planning a community-oriented, grassroots effort. All parties agreed that
in order for trails to be built in Shorewood, the process would have to involve citizens in defining.
needs, issues, problem.~ and potential solutions. This has been accomplished in several ways,
perhaps the most significant of which was the involvement of the Citizen Review Group that met
on three occasions. One of their specific recommendations was to update the trail plan. In further
reflecting on the work that the Group completed, it appears that continuing to emphasize the trail
"plan" and an update of the plan is probably notthe most productive way to proceed. When the
Citizen Review Group talked about updating the plan) they were more focused on the information
that the plan would contain rather than a plan document per se. Taking a cue from their fmdings,
we need to focus on trail planning. as a process in Shorewood rather than establishing another trail
plan. Creating a documented plan may be perceived as being too definitive, too all encompassing
and lacking in flexibility. Rather than focusing on a plan, our attention sbould be focused on
creating an ongoing process that accomplishes constroction of trails in Shorewood where they seem
to make sense. Lesson learned - process) not plan.
The process also served as a reminder that implementing a trail system in a community like
Shorewood that is almost fully developed is a difficult task. Retrofitting established neighborhoods
with trails is a straightforward concept on paper but a much harder to accomplish in the field.
123 North Third Street, Suite 100 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401
(612) 338-0800 Fax (612) 338-6838
ATTACHMENT 2
612-3386838
HOISINGTON KOEGLER
119 P03
Park Commission Memorandum
Page 2
SSP 02 '98 14:0~
Physical obstacles, attitudinal obstacles and other barriers create a number of challenges that need
to be overcome to implement a trail system. It was obvious that the members of the Citizen Review
Group reached this conclusion during their deliberations.
Where do we go from here?
At this pomt in time, the next step seems to have three components. First, as the Citizen Review
Group suggested, the City needs to agree that completing a trail planning process is a community
goal. Second, we need to agree on the components of the process and third, staff should begin to
provide the Park Commission with background information on various funding sources that might
be available to constroCt trails in Shorewood. Of these three items, it is important that the Park
Commission and City Council agree on the ftrst two. The third item can be provided as background
information.
Making trail planning a goal or priority
If trail planning is to be viewed as a process, the process needs to run its course before you can
establish formal goals related to the results. At this time, it is difficult to definitively state that the
implementation oia trail system is a formal goal of the City of Shorewood. Clearly, the body of
information collected to date states that the public. wants trails. However, the public has also
recognized that the implementation of trails presents a number of issues that need to be researched
and addressed. As the Citizen Review Group learned in its deliberations, a trail system is a complex
issue that creates varied opinions and concerns that change depending on people's perception of what
trails look like, where they will be located, etc. As a re.emIt, it is suggested that the Park Commission
and City Council endorse a common statement of commitment regarding a trail planning process
in Shorewood.
Such a commitment statement might be worded in the following manner: "The Shorewood City
<:::ouncil and Park Commission recognize that residents have a substantial interest in establishing a
trail system in the community; As a result, both groups are committed to establishing and carrying
out an ongoing process that with continuing public involvement, will identify opportunities and
address concerns xesulting in the constrUction of trails where deemed appropriate bytbe community."
Establishing the Process
The process used to establish trails in Shorewood will evolve and in 3111ikelihood. will change over
time. Initial efforts should be focused on defining the primary steps and then based on experience,
subsequent steps can be more clearly delineated. This approach was used for the Citizen Review
Group meetings. The results of each meeting were used to tailor the agenda for the subsequent
meeting. We told the Group at the beginning that we didn't have a precise road map but in the end,
we managed to get where we needed to go!
123 North Third Street, Suite 100 Minneapolis, Minnesota. 55401
(612) 338-0800 Pax (612) 338-6838
....-.... ~-_..
612-3386838
HOISINGTON KOEELER
119 P04
SEP 02 '98 14:09
Park Commission Memorandum
Page 3
For discussion pwposes, the following is offered as a process to continue addressing trails in the City
of Shorewood.
Steo I - The Park Commission and City Council meeting jointly and/or separately agree that the trail
evaluation process should continue and both parties adopt a common commitment statement.
~ - Building on infonnation collected from the public participation process to date, the Park
Commission completes additional data gathering and analysis. Items to be addressed include:
· Plans of adjacent municipalities
.. Goals for trails related to safety, quality of life, community connections, etc.
III Gather information on value, use, impacts, safety, national standards, financial implications,
right-of-way constraints, etc.
Step 3 - Based on infonnation gathered in Step 2, the Park Commission assembles a trail concept
depicting potential trail alignments (verbal and/or graphic) that satisfy identified issues and needc;.
This step create.c; a working concept rather than an overall plan. The concept will be further refined
by public input into the process.
Ste~ 4' - Publicize the concept. State, for example, that the City of Shorewood is interested in
providing some type of trail from point A to point B and that residents in the vicinity of AB will be
invited to a local meeting to learn more and to offer their input.
~ - Hold a local (neighborhood) meeting for each geographic area described in the trail concept
The purpose of the on~site meeting is to review the interest in constructing a trail, seek input on the
type of trail that might be appropriate, provide computer graphics or actual photographs of areas with
trails and similar landscape characteristics. and record. comments. concerns and issues raised by
meeting participants. Before, during and after the meeting, complete a uniform site evaluation fonn
that may include: .
. The purpose and anticipated function of the trail segment
· A description of the physical characteristics of the alignment area
· Photographs of the alignment .
· Comments on consistency with identified overall objectives
· Trail options (types)
· Preliminary project cost and funding sources
· Comments offered by meeting participants
Step 6 - Collect and review the results of Step 5. Based on responses received, eliminate trail
segments that seem unfeasible and assign priorities to those that appear workable.
~ _ Inclusive Trail Design - For high priority segments, invite all area residents to be involved
in the trail design process. Provide those who p3.rtlcipate with parameters for trail construction
established by the CIty Council. Depending on the circumstances, the design process could be
facilitated by a design consultant or an individual with mediation training. Staff should be available
123 North Third Street Suite 100 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401
(612) 338-0800 Fax (612) 338-6838
612-3386836
HOISINGTON KOEGLER
11':::1 M::l::l
~t:t"' ~<! . ':::I~ 14: 1,0
Park Commission Memorandum
Page 4
to provide technical assistance. The role of the neighborhood design group could be to present a
package of recommendations to the City Council within established parameters on plan details
including trail width. locations, landscaping, etc. The group could continue some level of
involvement though the actual construction phase of a project.
Ste1? 8 - Build a trail segment with neighborhood involvement.
Step 9 - Continue the process by moving on to the next trail segment in the priority listing.
Step 10 - As time passes, revisit the alignment areas identified in Step 5 to. determine if conditions
hav~ changed.
The ten steps identified above could serve as the foundation for an ongoing process to add trails in
Shorewood. Admittedly, this process may be more costly and time consuming, However, it may
be the best way to involve the community in a manner that results in the construction of trails in a
cooperative fashion without promoting dissention and possibly litigation.
Funding Sources.
Constructing trails in Shorewood will involve funding from a variety of sources. In general, the
following may be utilized:
TraU Fund - The Trail Fund was initiated in 1993 to begin setting aside funds for implementation
of the trail plan which had just been adopted. Over the years, funds have been transferred from the
Public Utilities Fund and the Street Fund. Funding for the trail along vine Hill Road came from the
Trail Fund.
The Trail Fund balance is now estimated to be $153,000 at the end of 1998. The transfer from
PUblic Facilities and street funds are scheduled. as follows:
1999 - $30,250.00
2000 - $26,250.00
2001 - $22,250.00
2002 - $18.250.00
The planned reduction is due to an anticipated reduction in funds available to be transferred from
the Public Utilities Fund.
123 North Third Street, Suite 100 Minneapolis, Minne.~otaS5401
(612) 338-0800 Fax (612) 338-6838
612-3386838
HOISINGTON KOEGLER
119 PI2I6
Park Commission Memorandum
Page S
SSP 1212 '98 14:1121
Municipal State Aid ( MSA) - Only certain "collector" streets are designated as MSA routes. If
the City has an improvement project on one of these streets and meets minimum state design
standards, MSA funds which are reserved at the state for Shorewood may be used. Generally, ninety
to ninety-five percent of the cost of a trail along the project can be paid for by MSA funds. The Old
Market Road trail was done largely with MSA funds because it was along an MSA route and met
the appropriate design criteria.
The list of MSA designated streets is currently being reviewed along with the transportation section
of the comprehensive plan. The current designations (and those being considered for designation)
are identified on the attached map. For the immediate future, no street reconstruction projects are
planned along MSA designated. routes.
Street Fund - When the Trail Fund was initiated in 1993, it was determined that the funds could
be set aside by designating five percent of dollars levied for the Street Fund to go to the Trail Fund.
That practice has continued through 1998 and is programmed to continue indefinitely in the Capital
Improvement Program (ClF).
DNR Grants -The Department of Natural Resources (DNR) offers a number of trail programs, some
of which may be applicable to Shorewood. For the most part. the DNR programs are oriented to
larger scale recreational interests such as off-road vehicle trails, snowmobile trails, cross-country
skiing, etc. When specific trail segment~ are identified in Shorewood., they can be compared to the
current offering of DNR grant programs. One. of the potential grant sources is a DNR program
known as the Regional Trail Initiative Grant Program. The program provides up to 50% of the
eligible costs for trail construction, however, funding is only available through November 31, 1999.
It is possible that the program will be extended beyond that date.
TEA-21 Grants - One of the more promising programs for trail funding is the Transportation Equity
Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21). This program which replaces the ISTEA program is the nation' s
largest public works law with an authorized funding level of $217 billion. The transportation
enhancements program which supports community projects like trails could receive up to $600
million per year over the next six years which is a 40% increase in funding compared to the previous
ISTEA program. It is likely that the fll'St round of TEA-21 grant applications will be due sometime
in the spring of 1999 . We can continue to monitor the program at the state and regional levels to
identify potential trail funding opportunities for the City of Shorewood.
123 North Third Street, Suite 100 Minneapolis. Minnesota 55401
(612) 338-0800 Fax (612) 338-6838
STATEMENT OF COMMITMENT
The Shorewood City Council and Park Commission recognize that residents
have a substantial interest in establishing atrail system in the community.
As a result, both groups are committed to establishing and carrying out an
on-going process that with continuing public involvement, will identify
opportunities and address concerns resulting in the construction of trails
where deemed appropriate by the community.
Reviewed and adopted by the City Council on September 28, 1998.
Reviewed and adopted by the Park Commission on October 13, 1998.
ATTACHMENT 3
It must be realized that only limited mileage can be constructed annually. As a result the only
street being considered for reconstmction in the near future is Smith town Road. The current
~~ .
Improvements program suggests that the portion of Smithtown Road between Eureka Road
(north) and Country Club Road could be programmed as early as 2001. MSA funds could also
potentially be used for the City's portion of the cost of the County Road 19/Country Club Road
intersection.
Mass Transit
Mass transit to Shorewood is currently limited due to the community's low density.
Concentrations of population in Shorewood are not considered enough to justify increased
regular
service. The City should, however, attempt to promote service in any way possible (e:g.
providing park and ride locations within the community) in order to equalize the level of service
with the current rate of taxation.
Four options for improving service have been identified:
1. Lobby the state legislature to provide new opportunities to opt out of the Metropolitan
Transit System. Then join with other communities to establish an autonomous
"subregional" system.
2. Work with the Metropolitan Council Transit Organization (MCTO) to enhance the
current Dial-a-Ride program. If successful, this type of program should be renewed
annually.
3. Convince the MCTO that the south Lake Minnetonka communities (i.e. Shorewood,
Tonka Bay, Excelsior and Greenwood) be designated as a transit hub and connected to
other outer-ring suburban hub areas.
4. Consider joining another transit system, such as Southwest Metro Transit. This would
require legislative approval by the State.
The City should work with area communities and the MCTO to maintain the level of service of
the Metro Mobility program. Services such as this will become increasingly important as the
population continues to age.
The Metropolitan Council Transit Organization continues to study and analyze ridership levels in
the area. Shorewood should seek citizen input to determine the level of service desired by the
community.
BicycIe/Pedestrian Trails
As noted in the Concept Plan section of the Land Use Chapter, trails. are viewed as an effective
way to connect neighborhoods, thereby enhancing a sense of community in Shorewood. Trails
are primarily considered as an element of parks and recreation, but due to their interrelationship
with other transportation elements, they will also be discussed in the Transportation chapter.
7/99
TR-28
ATTACHMENT 4
In 1998, after a series of community meetings and a survey of Shorewood residents, the Park
Commission developed a planning process that places an emphasis on early and continuing
neighborhood involvement in the establishment of an overall network of trails within the
community. The Trail Concept Plan, shown on page TR-31, identifies a potential system of
trails within Shorewood that concentrates on the connection of neighborhoods to one another and
to various points of interest within the community. The trail planning process continues with the
following steps:
1. Periodically the Park Commission identifies potential segments of trails to be considered
in the coming years. .
2. Trail walks, including area residents, are scheduled to identify issues specific to various
segments of trails.
3. Trail segments are incorporated into the City's Capital Improvement Program.*
4. Meetings are conducted with affected neighborhoods to determine the best trail design for
the various segments of trails.
5. Trail segments are constructed based upon the availability of funding.
*It should be noted that not all trail segments will be incorporated into the Capital
Improvement Program. Due to limited funding resources, trails will be constructed in
areas where resident demand is highest, as opposed to areas where it is demonstrated that
resident desire for trails is low.
It is recommended that the Trail Concept Plan, as may be amended, be consulted for all
development proposals and street construction projects. Where trails are designated on or
adjacent to roadways, right-of-way should be required as part of the subdivision approval
process. Construction of trails on or along roadways should be incorporated into street
improvement planning.
Although the right-of-way currently owned by the Hennepin County Regional Railroad
Authority (HCRRA) has been identified for future light rail transit, it has become an important
recreational feature in the South Lake Area. The City should be proactive to ensure that the
right-of-way remains open for recreational use if light rail transit does not materialize.
Snowmobiles
Snowmobiles have been a continued source of controversy in recent years, despite increased
efforts to enforce City codes regulating their use. Private property trespass and damage have
been raised as issues relative to snowmobiling. Shorewood has adopted rules intended to address
issues of compatibility between snowmobiles, pedestrians and motor vehicles. These rules will
be periodically monitored to evaluate their eff~ctiveness.
7/99
TR-29
---- :-:
~...............
,f1./;;P ...............
!<.:fl..? LAKEMINNETONKA .........
,to.~<; . ....
~i ,...._~ lJ ...........~.C?~.~~~........g,
r.uunu...~ ~==: I; """VdI,MfI) CIlYOFSHOREWOOO O:~
, ,~..; ~,,,,
1 PHELPS BAY - t;~""lID ~, ~ ij
! ,- t .::If! 4 ,t lAKE MtNNETONKA i5 : e
:,' ~ '.ff. :: ~i~
V ~,I:. ~l~
i' -- . ~1IUlG (J :.~.....
. ,
11
j ,J'
.~
..... ~~~
w..S8 --.......
~ :=:::
_RASTJWC'!\II!E. .. eotlEERS. . flt.AtitlIRS-
2000
L_
o
2000 Feet
r--~- ~T~
I
I
Trail Concept Plan
00
--
Possible Trail
Parksl Open Space
*
Connecting Points
TR-31
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Residents Along Smithtown Road
Mayor and City Council,
Brad Nielsen, Acting City Administrator
FROM:
. Larry Brown, City Engineer
DATE:
April 28, 2000 .
RE:
Smithtown Road Trail and Right of Way Discussions
The Park Commission has taken the opportunity to walk Smithtown Road, and other roadways
within the City, to seek feedback from residents as to whether an on street or off street trail would
be desirable in their neighborhood.
This has proven to be a very valuable process, as evidenced by the Covington Road and Vine Hill
Road Trail Project that is currently underway. Residents of that area stated their desire for the trail,
worked with the City to resolve des!gn and right of way issues, and continued to follow the project
through the bidding phase. It is anticipated that that project will be constructed this summer.
During the trail walk along Smithtown Road, many residents asked questions with regard to right of
way ownership. The Park Commission made the commitment of studying the issue with the City
Council, and to report back to the neighborhood of the findings of the study. The City Council
ordered that the' City Attorney's Office' research each parcel along Smithtown Road as to the
"ownership and encumbrances." In more simple terms, an ownership and encumbrances report lists
all the parties that have an interest in aproperty that are recorded atthe Hennepin County Recorders
Office. If the right of way for Smithtown Road was dedicated by creation of a subdivision or by
easements for any of the parcels along Smithtown Road, this was documented in the report=
The attached pages are a graphic summary of the findings. There are three patterns which indicate
some sort of dedication to the City of Shorewood for roadway purposes. The first is a 'star pattern
which demonstr~tes that the area was dedicated by a recorded easement agreement. The second
pattern is a crosshatched pattern which indicates that the City owns the land within the right of way
and adjacent to the right of way. The third pattern is a shaded pattern which denotes that the area
was formally dedicated by a plat. Areas that are not shaded indicate that a formal dedication of the
right of way was not found on record.
#1>
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPEFl
AlTACHMENT 5
There are 29 parcels on the north side of Smithtown Road (from the Victoria City boundary to
Country Club Road) that are not patterned, and 24 parcels on the south side. Due to funding
constraints' in the trail fund, if the City were petitioned to move ahead with a project on Smithtown
Road, the purchase of right of way combined with the costs of construction would result in a deficit
in the trail fund. Therefore, it appears that under the current funding conditions, if residents who
live along Smithtown Road desire a trail, the right of way would have to be obtained by the City at a
minimal cost.
'---
o '00
J'
~
Smith town Road
Improvements
Right of Way Strip Map
,
'00
~
. ~
/--:----_--~
l:_ ' ~ \
---... "-
........ !-__.....J
,k ~.~\ \
....t."-'
~
,k
~
~
;J.,
~-~--:---~~~~~:~~-- ..~~
- -lIi- /="-.~'- - ~., ~
'~tr) ~ .. r"":pr
..... ~/
[o-nl:!..~irl
~
'<:l
~'............
f=' .."
~. \.
"-~""'-l" 'Il-~~_~..
... t "' ~
--~--.;~~i
\ 11"-
ExlsfTng
...
WSB
......-..
"'~IIIC. 'AXSI1-11Otl
INfRASTRUCrulU! . INGlNE!RS - Pl.ANH!RI
350Wutwood lAb OIIce
1U1W8)'Ul1rBouClMlld
MfmMpc&. UN 55128
\...iiJ' f"J ~:;~ '\::--3)...... / ~~ ~ 0;
'".." \.......
~11,-p--'-._
l__~
.1
. - .:. .
..../. L . . ."
.1 bcn:by catilY IhoI this p,,", or noport_ ,..,....t by me
lorundcr my du..""p..._.... t1w!.. adaly.ll.._
-~ Sunreyor-1Irider lite ~ of~"" OfM"mncIOla..
~~..-r. ~-
S1EYEN V.1SCHE
DAlE IIWDO lEG. NO. mil
SHEET 1 OF 6 SHEETS
&.UlrIlIS 9 dO C .If/rIllS
~
sa:a........... . IIBINlONI . ~
ootNI'SX'l1 '*I~"
lWM....lI. ---
SSM
T
~
~
~
i
ADM JO /L/6jcl 6uusjX3
..... ...-
fUeMINlI ~ I-m
1lClIf08IIfII1~O!it
.._.\.;::....r~-.--.ll i
'1'1
, ,
'\
o' '""\71!1'/
..... <.__.1"...... l, rr~..~:::11 .
/, ~\ ,~--~~=:..___ _~_ ! I t (:>,'
'. t j\. ~II I P
. /;/~,.;\ "'~.t ...(..: '; "~' .;, /f'
.". " . ~ o~'\.
~,.( 1I - . !,! '.J ::1,'-
'. \:~" ! \ 'I S -.i--' 0
.~ \;'~\ \0';; L3 ~
j~i i / LJ ..... "'-_.>--~ II'
,rl.r-.-I ~.,. 'oJ/v,,' ., 1. 1 I '1"110 .~ (;
,.,.-.<'..1 _ '" I I~;r-'. i
;(.0. \...........,J".< (..:. ') j I ,LJ" I
. '-'- ./ '._l.._ ~j I. .-'J
o - -.~. i. i "
--.,.-:---~-- eo L ,,~
o t nl
c
.
, .
"\ tit 'J
I...... l/ "'u
cJ "'J..-.~.......
"
!
~~!~
" ,;!
.'
lit>
...~"..
.
.
.
. c
r\
U
. z!
l,j Q! IS]
o
o
~-:-
.-- -i"
~.~ '-.:..~:,:..
. -
,.,r
.Ji
r -
,
~
.~
~
(; L--~l",
---,
Trt
.J
_Ii ..
.,
n
il
l!
~ QQ ji
:,~1
... /"Ijl
, Y ~,t.
,-
~
.'
~
~'
/?7"j \
~
;' r)
:/ .
if ~......
.'1
00<
,
00' .
.......~
~h!~L~ "1
\~"''-'''''~
1~- ! ,-:- 0 p
o C-l
.~ I
( I L .'1 I:.
I" . 1- "-i_
II ~" ~J1~ I"
I . I jJ' I
~-:.... I l'-"\. 1--.. I
(1 ~I
'\ {.. I'
1 ! II
~
dlJW<<!.lJS {lJA1!O 11{8!H
SIU;JW;J{f.oJ.dw/
PVOH UMOII{I!WS
~
;(
I
~
'III ,<
,/ C.-
'n 0
V ):
'\7.l
!~
I......... .
! '3.......
; '\1
\.....- "',
. ,; r"tf
_ r -,
,11-"
:} ,
'1,1
" ~ I
/
~\\
jf
i
\..
!
I
,
i
j
l
'-
\ \
l.... ;~
Smithtown Road
Improvements
Right of Way Strip Map
.'
.
1..""-
o 100
,
'00
) I.
, '.>.~.:-:i ;
I 1/.1
/! 0_-'
",/~/...~' ': .;.,,.,~ .:_c:..,\
./
------....
,~ ~ .:.,
l
II
U
o
00
e
o
.,
" ....
::J..__",.__
\~ ; (tef ...._-..~..:~~..
.::::-~;~;:. J;,' :
~/ !
,.' /\
n
C"'\
i 1
-/: I ~ :;3
'].\
'. 1
......J
'1,,\1=
o
.,
"
"
.;~ r:
----
\
(...-................. ~t
Lj 0
"c..::Ii111
t~ '" i'---J. i..,
".....r! , 1!1.2'~
~.lll\l~ ".
" 1! -J r-.. 0',
\. ")~ ...j P.
""
',-...
j
/_..-J
\ .
n .t' Ii
",gj ~,
....-..~.~Il
"'-. I"
),t/."
!,~F4o '
r-Lj~
I
:!
U
':1
rt:j
::'b"<'
"-
! t----;
.....
WSB
...iiiiiiiiiiii .t2-51'-'Idll
. Juod*" IN;. f'AJl54t-17Gl1
"L'RASTRUCTURI .. ENGfHEEAS .. PlANfrd!RS
,
[onS:o~'L
~
II
3!0 WntwDod LiIn 0fftaI
&441 Wayuta BolHvard
-.......
l'
I ,
j \
U
;0
1-1.
\\ .
\ }
.....
!
i
".-
-1" "Mdt} i~__./
'1.~..__....,:::_.._",,\-!-.
\
;
\
\
,. ~~f\.-
srroot~fT6e!fienr-/ "
'_ \It-h.. -r' \ ........
City Ownership
..-...,..-
Existing Right Of Way
SHEET 3 OF 6 SHEETS
!
SLaHHS 9 .!fO I' .LaHHS
.,-
(;" ~ ~-_..~/
: :
~::::~.-,~~~~
LL (
. ,-
L:::J L..;
r---.........-:-.
..L .
. "~~~-';\.
I . _ .
~ . -.....:=_....:_:-~ -
IIl3NWw . SUiBHDlil . itKU..:)f'Qt.1SWfi
_H"~ - ~
........... ~C"""
SZt95 NW~" ai:l/Y'
~~~ 'Y
~
~
~
1
-.
\0.'
'\ ,,:< C.
(.... ,-"
J "--:/~~\---~~!b
't.," ~
.....'C.
.../"~\\
..... "j.:
( - '\)
) . 0-
i
\ ~
I
\
t
\
"~-..
f
-(-';'~~~,~
, ..........
i --)
\" .':' -- - --.
~,--"."'--r\._~.~~
\ I f
\.\. \. .:....:\.
"'-. /' }
"1' ..,' /
I r':~ I
;:.....-C,/ ~:::!.___~
o
I
\
)
J "1
u.
r-'
1
\
~:\
!\
.......l .
,---
"-
., J
rcj: \j
i "JL., I
~~-..._.
( Ib'----..
!.; !~s '. \.
\ U ;,-r-u-. i
\ r1-1~...
.! \ )
.~. '"
( i
\! I
\ 1
. ,
I) l)
\
1\
I'
_J
'\
.......\ {
........
-!
i,
! 1
DOl DOl 0
, --"""
.t
i.
dow d!4S {OM 10 1'18r1/
SIUtJUltJtlo.ldUlI
pOOH UM.Ol'11!UlS
</
Smith town Road
Improvements
Right of Way Strip Map
I
~
IJ'" _ ,
o 100 200
",
t.".._.".
'"\
i
"
{lJ........:..................~
\ 1.__../
\~.
0.,;"":::;:-
I .
1 ~
I
1.11 I:
.~./ .,~/' ! F
10"",/' II"
I /- .'.!] 0
1'../" ,~
o
;-~"
==='if
"c ...
00
"
....
WSB
~
..~'- fAXS4t-tJllO
~ . END1N&RI . PlANNERS
lpr.,q,u'rl
~
.....'"--=-..
.
..,...r>~.........'""
"\1 /<_. }
CIty OwnersNp
3SO WHtMxIdL*eOlb
8441 w.,ulll1auIaIownf
M........ UN S542e
o :"1 ,:
Existing Right Of. Way
\,>) \
.P co, i
nlrJ~~\
[i', '..LJ"
~.' 0 l'1'-
t \\ ~
\.. i
'.\ I
\~\ l' I
.. ,
II
l\
f \
f._";
.;.,
.-
t--r1
.,\
SHEET 5 OF 6 SHEETS
<:
S.LHHHS 9 dO 9.LHHHS
~
.-t::
l'.l
~ ....
~~~
~t::~
~~~
t:::=t::
~~~
-....~
~tt::
~~~
~
....
~
.
IYJNNY'W . SlIaaNIENGI . JaIfl1.:WU.IWMfI
1lOt,-,...xv.. _l~.
....US-Cl.
SSM
T
..... ...-
~IIIRMM ntl
1Cl1UO"~05t
.~e-_~:_!_~~~;:~.==N=:~""~
~:.t::;=~~;~::;::,..;~
o Nn~ .~..o_ .. __a_w .... ~N".
_N . .~::~;.::=:~::~-~~~~~~,...~;::.:=:::~;=~.=~;::2e_O!_e 2 ;:_-::::::~__~__~~~_~_":_~