HomeMy WebLinkAbout112805 CC Reg AgP
.
.
.
.1
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 28,2005
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
1. CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
A. Roll Call
Mayor Love _
Lizee
Turgeon ___
Callies
Wellens
B. Review Agenda
2.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. City Council Special Meeting Minutes, November 7,2005 (Att. - Minutes)
B. City Council Work Session Minutes, November 7, 2005 (Att. - Minutes)
C. City Council Regular Meeting Minutes, November 14,2005 (Att.- Minutes)
3.
CONSENT AGENDA - Motion to approve items on Consent Agenda & Adopt Resolutions
Therein:
NOTE: Give the public an opportunity to request an item be removedfrom the
Consent Agenda. Comments can be taken or questions askedfollowing removalfrom
Consent Agenda.
A.
Approval of the Verified Claims List (Att.- Claims List)
B. Staffing - No action required
C. Property and Liability Insurance Renewal (Att. - Finance Director's memorandum)
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR (No Council action will be taken.)
5. REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS
6. PUBLIC HEARING
7. PARKS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA - NOVEMBER 28, 2005
PAGE 2 OF 2
.
8.
PLANNING - Report by Representative
A. Conditional Use Permit for Accessory Space in Excess of 1200 Square Feet (Att.-
Planning Director's memorandum, Draft Resolution)
Applicant: Michael Catain
Location: 4550 Enchanted Point
B. Conditional Use Permit for Fill in Excess of 100 Cu. Y ds. (Att. - Planning Director's
memorandum, Draft Resolution)
Applicant: Mark Guidinger
Location: 19735 Muirfield Circle
C. . Preliminary Plat - Apple Ridge 3rd Addition (Att. - Planning Director's memorandum,
Draft Resolution)
Applicant: Lecy Construction, Inc.
Location: Outlots A and B of Apple Ridge 2nd (Apple Road)
.
9.
GENERAL/NEW BUSINESS
A. SLMPD Proposal (Att. - City Administrator's memorandum)
10. ENGINEERING/PUBLIC WORKS
. 11. STAFF AND COUNCIL REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
1. County Road 19 Intersection
B. Mayor & City Council
. 12. ADJOURN
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us' cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
Executive Summary
Shorewood City Council Regular Meeting
Monday, 28 November 2005
. A 5:45 p.m. Work Session is scheduled this evening; dinner will be available at 5:30.
. Agenda Item #3A: Enclosed is the Verified Claims List for Council approval.
Agenda Item #3B:
Staffing - no action required.
.
Agenda Item #3C: The City's Property/Liability insurance package renewed on November 1,
2005. The total package renewal premium for 2006 is $113,013, compared with $90,595
for this past year. The City's Experience Loss Mod went from 1.06 last year to 1.30
currently, which resulted in a considerable increase in premium. For example, the
proposed expense for the property and liability portion of the package increased from
$49,776 for 2005 to $64,433 for 2006. The City's 2006 Budget has allocated $103,500
for this coverage across all funds for all lines.
.
Agenda Item #8A: Michael Catain has requested a conditional use permit to construct a,
detached garage, the area of which, when combined with existing accessory space on the
property, will exceed 1200 square feet. The applicant's request complies with the criteria
for granting this type of C.U.P. It is worth noting that Mr.. Catain revised his original
plans to address concerns expressed by neighbors at the public hearing. The Planning
Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval. A draft resolution is included
in your packet.
Agenda Item #8B: Mark Guidinger has requested a conditional use permit to bring more than
100 cubic yards offill onto his property at 19735 Muirfield Circle. He intends to level
off a portion of his rear yard to accommodate a swimming pool. The City's engineering
consultant has reviewed the plans from a drainage and structural perspective. It is worth
noting that the applicant has agreed, based on the concerns of a nearby landowner, to
conduct any pool drainage to the City's sanitary or storm sewers. This is reflected in a
draft resolution prepared for your consideration. If you have any questions relative to
this item, you are urged to contact the Planning Director prior to the meeting.
.
#!>
t.J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Executive Summary - City Council Meeting of November 28, 2005
Page 2 of2
Agenda Item #8C: When Apple Ridge Second Addition was approved for Lecy Construction,
they were to have conveyed certain outlots to adjoining property owners, so as not to
leave landlocked parcels. Due to the legal problems of one of the adjoining owners, this
was never accomplished. Lecy now wishes to replat the outlots for conveyance to other
surrounding owners. Staff had recommended approval subject to a new deadline for
compliance. The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval with
an abbreviated deadline. The draft resolution reflects the Planning Commission's
recommendation.
Agenda Item #9A: The "Saunders Proposal" for resolution ofSLMPD matters among the
member cities has been continued from the Council's November 14 meeting. At that
time, the Greenwood City Council had approved the proposal, and the Tonka Bay City
Council had approved the proposal in concept. The Excelsior City Council had not acted
on the proposal at that time, and has taken no action since. It is expected that Excelsior
will likely act at a special meeting on November 30, when it will consider whether to
launch the legal action it has authorized, or at its regular meeting on December 5. Ifit
were to approve the Saunders Proposal, it is expected that Excelsior would make
modifications - at least by adding some expectations regarding the scope of the matters to
be considered in arbitration of the funding allocation.
It would be prudent for the Council to continue this matter to its December 12,2005,
meeting.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 7,2005
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
CONFERENCE ROOM
6:00 P.M.
MINUTES
DR fl j
1.
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 6:00 P.M.
A.
Roll Call
Present:
Mayor Love; Councilmembers Callies, Lizee, Turgeon, and Wellens; Administrator
Dawson; Engineer Brown; and Finance Director Burton
Absent:
Planning Director Nielsen
B.
Review Agenda
Without objection from Council, Mayor Love proceeded with the Agenda for the meeting.
2. CONSENT AGENDA
Lizee moved, Wellens seconded, Approving the Motion Contained on the Consent Agenda and
Adopting the Resolution Therein:
A. Approval of Recording Secretary Agreement
Motion passed 5/0.
3. GENERAL/NEW BUSINESS
A.
Resolution Requesting Appeal Hearing Regarding Metropolitan Council Systems
Statement for Shorewood
Administrator Dawson explained that the City of Shorewood has received the Metropolitan Council
System Statement for Shorewood. City staff and Council Member Wellens have reviewed the System
Statement and have identified a few items of disagreement that to date there has not been resolution on
the administrative level. The items in disagreement are: 1) the City believes that its designation as a
"developing community" should be revised to a "developed community"; 2) the population and
household projections contained within the System Statement are inconsistent with Shorewood's
Comprehensive Plan and the information contained in the Metropolitan Council's website; and, 3) in
light of the incorrect population and household information, the projected wastewater flows are
considered unrealistically low. Any disagreements with the System Statement must either be resolved
within 60 days of receipt of the statement, or the City may request a hearing before the Metropolitan
Council Land Use Advisory Committee. While it is entirely possible that the City and Met Council staffs
can resolve the items that have been raised, a City Council resolution has been prepared to request a
hearing with the Metropolitan Land Use Committee to discuss the items in disagreement in the System
Statement. The deadline for requesting the hearing is November 11,2005.
:It- ;l f1
CITY OF SHOREWOOD SPECIAL MEETING
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 2 of 4
Councilmember Callies asked what the significance is of the items in disagreement.
Administrator Dawson explained the Metropolitan Council has a different set of policies for
"developing" and "developed" communities that the Metropolitan Council would want the City to fulfill.
A "developing community" has more objectives that the Metropolitan Council would want the
community to meet.
Councilmember Wellens pointed out the System Statement has wastewater flow decreasing while the
population is increasing in ten years.
Mayor Love stated the City has had success with the dialogue with the Metropolitan Council and would
like to see that continue.
Councilmember Turgeon would like to know the date of the hearing once it has been scheduled and who
that attendees would be.
Wellens moved, Turgeon seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 05-098, "A Resolution
Requesting Appeal Hearing Regarding Metropolitan Council Systems Statement for Shorewood."
Motion passed 5/0.
B. Katrina Evacuee Housing
Administrator Dawson introduced guests Reverend Linus Nyambu, Program Coordinator for the
Ascending Praise Church Relief Fund, and Shorewood resident Katherine Kennedy.
Administrator Dawson explained that the City had received inquiries about what roles it would take to
assist any evacuees of Hurricane Katrina. One idea that came up several times was to make the house the
City owns at 5795 Country Road available. Council previously indicated that it would like to make the
house available, but that the housing arrangements be done through an agency as the City did not have
relevant expertise. Shorewood resident Katherine Kennedy contacted Administrator Dawson about a
program run and organized by Ascending Praise Church Relief Fund, and with which Our Savior
Lutheran Church was partnering. The program is designed to place families on fmancial self-sufficiency
within twelve months. Administrator Dawson related that the City was looking at potential use to the
property for an addition to City Hall, and could not guarantee the house would be available for a full
year. The Relief Fund said it would need housing through the end ofthe school year.
Administrator Dawson explained there were questions about whether making the house available blurred
the lines between what the City can do vis-a-vis charitable organizations. The City Attorney has reviewed
and determined the City would not run afoul of State law. Administrator Dawson stated the property
would be subject to property taxes in 2006 if it were not to be used for City government operations. The
property taxes in 2005 were nearly $3000.
:
.
.
.
.
Administrator Dawson explained the proposed rent would be $750 per month with a $1,000 damage
deposit. He stated that the Church would be the lessee, and would be responsible for payment of all
utilities and insurance. The Church will ensure the house is fully furnished, and that furnishings will be
removed when vacated. There is a contact family and organization in Shorewood that will work with the
tenants. Any tenant must be an evacuee from the Hurricane Katrina area. Administrator Dawson
explained that the Ascending Praise Church Relief Fund has several families placed in Lakeville. The
apartment management staff reported there have been no issues with tenants they have placed.
Background and criminal reference checks of the organization's officers were satisfactory. .
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD SPECIAL MEETING
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 3 of 4
Administrator Dawson said this idea has been worked through on a concept level. He reviewed certain
conditions that should be added to a standard lease.
Administrator Dawson stated if the Council is sufficiently satisfied with the concept and wishes to
proceed, it should direct the City Attorney to draw up a lease with the conditions specified in the City
Administrator memo, and then authorize its execution subject to those terms being satisfied. He noted
time is of the essence.
Mayor Love wanted to make sure that the Attorney had identified any exposure that this would put the
City in, and he liked the idea of someone being in the house.
Councilmember Turgeon asked how the rental amount was determined and what are other cities doing.
Administrator Dawson stated that with seven-months' rent, funds will be recovered for the tax liability
and incidental wear-and-tear. The City did not have to charge market rents. Few other suburbs had City-
owned housing.
Councilmember Lizee stated she supports the idea, and that she agrees the rental rate is fair for everyone.
She also indicated it would be nice to have someone in the house. Councilmember Callies concurred.
Councilmember Turgeon agrees with the idea and rental rate, but she questioned the process.
Callies moved, Wellens seconded, Approving that the Council will direct the City Attorney to
prepare a lease per the conditions listed stated above, and authorize the execution of the lease upon
. the satisfaction of the City Attorney. Motion passed 5/0.
4. STAFF AND COUNCIL REPORTS
.
.
A. Administrator & Staff
Administrator Dawson extended an invitation by the Planning Commission to the City Council to attend
the Planning Commission's Study Session on November 15,2005, to discuss planning issues in the area
of Shore wood Yacht Club and Shorewood Nursery.
Administrator Dawson explained the Hennepin County Regional Rail Authority contacted him last week
and wants to schedule a presentation about encroachments in its right-of-way. Administrator Dawson
wanted to mow if the presentation should be in front of the Council, or if the Council wants to have or if
the Council wants to have a community meeting scheduled by the HCRRA. Council indicated
Administrator Dawson should ask the HCRRA to plan for a community informational meeting.
Administrator Dawson stated the Police will be holding a meeting on November 14,2005, at 10:30 AM
for the Emergency Preparedness Plan. Council is invited to attend, but the Mayors and City
Administrators are expected to attend. A special presentation will be made to the Council at another time.
A special meeting of the SLMPD Coordinating Committee would be held at 12:30 P.M.
B. Mayor and City Council
Mayor Love explained that following the meeting on November 14, 2005, he will be spending the night
in a tent to raise money for the homeless. He would appreciate all contributions that Council members
would choose to make.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD SPECIAL MEETING
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 4 of 4
5.
ADJOURN
Turgeon moved, Wellens seconded, Adjourning the City Council Special Meeting of November 7, 2005,
at 6:15 P.M. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Christine Freeman, Recorder
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
.
.
.
.
.
A.
Present:
. Absent:
B.
f
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2005
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
6:15 P.M. or Immediately Following
Special Council meeting
MINUTES
1.
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
\)
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 6: 15 PM.
Roll Call
Mayor Love; Councilmembers Callies, Lizee, Turgeon, and Wellens; Administrator
Dawson; Engineer Brown; and Finance Director Burton
Planning Director Nielsen
Review Agenda
Without objection from Council, Mayor Love proceeded with the Agenda for the meeting.
2. EMPLOYEE BENEFITS COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
Administrator Dawson explained that a Benefits Committee was formed in March 2005 to improve
communications to employees regarding benefits and to expand staff participation in the design of
benefits offered by the City. The Committee represented every department and all levels of the City
organization.
Administrator Dawson explained the Committee began with a review of current benefits, recent changes
affecting them, and the 5 types of insurance being offered to employees by the City. Administrator
Dawson clarified the purpose of this meeting was to solicit Council feedback on these potential changes
in benefits programming.
Administrator Dawson explained that it has been the idea for many years not to have disruption in health
care providers which is why the City stays with Medica. The Committee learned that Health Savings
Accounts (HSA) with Medica are not an option because 100% participation is required. With regard to
dental insurance, there was a change to Delta from MetLife on September 1, 2005. Employees were
appreciative of long-term Disability (LID), which was an employer-paid benefit at the initiative of City
Council. In 2005 the life insurance benefit was changed to Ix salary. The Committee recommended
going back to a basic life insurance policy of $20,OQO. Employees would like to be able to purchase
additional life insurance through the City provider; the feasibility of this needs to be determined. The
short-term disability (STD), was added as a benefit at the initiative of the City Council. There are
differing opinions on whether SID is a benefit for those employees with a sick leave balance greater than
520:l: hours.
There was a lot of interest in having some type of cafeteria plan. However, after talking to a number of
providers it was apparent it was difficult to do for an employer the size of the City of Shorewood. The
Committee prefers insurance quotes be requested for optional participation so that elements of a cafeteria
~*J8
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MINUTES
NOVEMBER 7, 2005
Page 2 ofS
plan could be possible. Administrator Dawson also noted the Committee conducted a quick survey
generating feedback that employees were generally satisfied with current benefits, though there was some
in disagreement with different parts of the benefits package.
Administrator Dawson stated that the current vacation and holiday benefits were comparable to other
cities. The Committee recommends changing the sick leave plan by: 1) establishing a wellness
reimbursement benefit; 2) placing a cap on accrued sick leave hours; and, 3) making changes to sick
leave severance. The "wellness reimbursement benefit" for eligible actives would be reimbursed up to
$40/month, and deduction of 1 hour of sick leave for each $20 or portion thereof. There is still some
work to be done on the wellness benefit but the committee wanted to bring the concept to Council. The
sick leave accrual cap would be 800 hours which would limit the City's liability. At each year end, all
accrued sick leave hours in excess of 800 would convert 50% to another benefit (e.g., deferred
compensation, add to vacation balance, place in next year's Section 125 Plan account, pay as cash, use in
combination, etc.). At termination, 50% of sick leave hours on balance would be paid with a minimum of
5 years of employment. On December 31, 2005, payout to those employees currently in excess of the
800-hour max with one-time use of City's fund balance. Three employees would be affected, and the
City's payout to them would be approximately $60,000.
The Benefits Committee remains a "standing committee" that would convene in the spring every year,
review benefits, identify changes to research, identify recommended changes to place in the budget
process in July, and serve as information liaisons to their departments. Members of the Committee
suggested hiring a benefits consultant to review the benefits offered as well as any redesign of current
benefits.
Councilmember Callies complimented the Committee on its efforts. She stated having a consultant with
experience in the benefits field assess the benefits package would be prudent. Councilmember Turgeon
agreed. Councilmember Callies went on to state it was good to review the benefits package periodically.
She thought the vacation benefit generous and having a cap on sick leave accrual hours was good but
perhaps the cap was too high. In many companies if sick leave isn't used it's lost. She expressed concern
about the one-time payout option explained.
Councilmember Wellens stated he had no objection to the life insurance benefit. His career experience
had been that sick leave accumulates without limit but is lost at termination. He stated having a cap on
sick leave encourages employees to use their sick leave and perhaps sick leave and short-term disability
should be linked together.
In response to a question by Councilmember Turgeon, Administrator Dawson stated sick leave and
vacation "carry forward" with a cap was a very common practice.
Mayor Love stated he appreciated all the hard work that was done by the Committee. In addition, he
would appreciate having a benefits consultant review the recommendation.
Councilmember Turgeon stated a benefits specialist should be hired to assess the impact of the potential
change on employees before any change was made, conduct all employee information meetings about the
change, and minimize disruption in benefits to the employees where possible. The benefits consultant
should be the same individual annually, someone with the City's best interest at stake.
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MINUTES
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 3 ofS
Councilmember Callies expressed concern the benefits consultant had no loyalty to any insurance service
provider to ensure objectivity.
Administrator Dawson stated he will report back to Council within the next two meetings with ideas on a
benefits consultant.
3. ENTERPRISE BUDGETS
A. Water Budget
Finance Director Burton explained the Water Fund budget was comprised of two parts: the Water Debt
Service budget and the Water Operating Budget. The 2006 Water Debt Service budget included
payments for the existing bond issues, including the 2005 issue for financing major water and well
improvements in 2005 and 2006. These debt service payments were programmed at approximately
$375,000 and would be paid for by a transfer from the Water Operating budget. She went on to explain
the 2006 Water Operating Budget revenues were projected to be approximately $587,000, while
expenses (including depreciation) were forecast to be approximately $1,900,000. Proposed capital
expenditures to be funded from 2006 bond proceeds included the Amesbury Well enhancements, Badger
Well House reconstruction, Woodhaven Interconnection, and Radio Read meter project.
Finance Director Burton also stated in order for the Water Funds to be self-supporting, to assure the
system could provide for improvements, and to preserve fund balance at current levels, a three-year step
approach to water rate increases was discussed and approved by Council several years ago. The rate
increase for 2006 was the final year of the three-year rate increase approach. Based on that plan, the
current rates were: $35 for up to 10,000 gallons: $2.95/1000 gallons for 10,000-50,000 gallons usage, and
$3.7511000 gallons for 50,000+ gallons usage. She noted there are approximately 1,225 water
connections (this number is fairly accurate) using an average of 30,000 gallons per quarter. The 2006
budget includes $8,000 for possible feasibility studies.
Council would like a more accurate connection and consumption data reflected in the budget.
B. Sanitary Sewer Budget
With regard to the Sanitary Sewer Budget, Finance Director Burton stated the City currently had about
2,800 connections to its Sanitary Sewer system. Engineer Brown stated there were currently three
residences that are not connected to City sewer.
Council requested more accurate connection figures be provided.
Finance Director Burton went on to state the sewer fund had a substantial fund balance.
Proposed operating revenues and expenditures for year 2006 were contemplated at approximately
$890,000, with capital improvements $192,000 planned for the year as well. Capital improvements for
year 2006 included refurbishment of two lift stations. Funds of $50,000 had also been designated for
Inflow & Infiltration (1&1) Control and reduction projects.
Administrator Dawson explained that he, Finance Director Burton, and Director Brown met with the
Metropolitan Council Environmental Services (MCES) on November 7, 2005, for a preview of a new
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MINUTES
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 4 of5
program they will be doing over the next five years at minimum. MCES is studying ways to maximize the
capacity of the Metropolitan Sanitary Sewer System without making rnajor investments. One option
MCES studied was to anticipate future demand and build more plants, parallel pipes, etc. for a cost of
approximately $1 billion for correction of 1&1 problems metro wide. The City was doing fine with 1&1
until 2005 Labor Day weekend when there was a heavy storm which created a 5,000,000 gallon overage
of the 1&1 goal. MCES explained the way the policy is written the City has to mitigate the full amount of
1&1 which by MCES calculations is approximately $335,000 per year for five years. He stated there are
two MCES plans that the City can follow. Plan A included a surcharge of $335,000 a year for 2007
through 2011 to the City; the City can do a number of activities and essential draw the money back. Plan
B included negotiation of an agreement with MCES where the City can identify a number of programs
that would help with 1&1, allocate capital dollars to implement these programs, and follow through on the
programs.
Administrator Dawson stated it would be prudent for the City to hire an Engineering Consultant to assess
the current 1&1 situation and to establish additional monitoring practices to provide additional and/or
more accurate data for determining responsibility of project cost. He recommended that the proposed
budget 2006 budget amount of $50,000 for 1&1 be increased to $100,000.
Engineer Brown explained his concerns with the 1&1 data provided by MCES.
Mayor Love expressed his concerns with the accuracy of the data provided as he compared the Tonka
Bay 1&1 increase to the City's increase and the sanitary sewer systems were installed approximately the
same time for both cities.
C. Recycling Budget
The Recycling Budget contemplated revenues and expenditures of approximately $118,200. The City
anticipated receiving approximately $21,000 in grant monies from Hennepin County Grant Funds.
Finance Director Burton noted the number of households participating in the recycling program remained
stable. No rate increases were proposed at this time.
Finance Director Burton explained that the 135% increase in supplies was a result of purchasing 300
recycling bins which would last approximately one year. These bins are, in turn, sold to residential
customers.
D. Stormwater Management Budget
Finance Director Burton stated the 2006 Stormwater Management Budget contemplated revenues of
$165,000 and expenditures of$210,899.
E. Liquor Operations
Finance Director Burton explained the City anticipated reasonable profit levels at its two current
municipal stores; however, the 2006 budget had been prepared quite conservatively.
Council is supportive of a year-end transfer from Tonka Bay reserves to eliminate the Waterford (East)
store deficit and transfer the remainder of the Tonka Bay reserves to Shorewood Plaza (West).
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION MINUTES
NOVEMBER 7,2005
Page 5 of5
4. TIMBER LANE WATERMAIN
Administrator Dawson explained there was discussion held regarding the petitioned Timber Lane
Watermain Project at the last Regular City Council meeting. He questioned, for the Council, what if any
budget implications would result from the Timber Lane project, and how the process could be improved
in the future.
Engineer Brown explained the Timber Lane project was brought through a public bidding process, and
rejected due to the high costs received. It was the intent of Staff that the project would be re-bid in 2006
in conjunction with the proposed SE Area - Amesbury Interconnect project currently under design - due
to economies of scale with the project. Since that time Mr. Haskins, representing the residents affected
by the project, requested the petition be formally withdrawn due to high costs. He went on to explain
under current policy, the petitioners would be responsible to satisfy any and all cost for consideration of
the feasibility and design portion of the project. The costs for the feasibility study, design and soil
borings totaled $34,000. This did not include costs associated with public hearings and administrative
costs, etc.
Engineer Brown stated the City ordinance for petitioning projects was somewhat vague regarding
petitioners bearing responsibility for the design costs. Staff recommends the City bear the design costs
and the Timber Lane residents bear the cost of the feasibility study because of the lack of clarity in the
City ordinance. Engineer Brown stated he would provide a breakdown of cost for the Timber Lane
Watermain Project.
Discussion ensured regarding appropriate costs to petitioners of projects. It was the consensus of Council
that the City may need to bear some project costs; however, petitioners should share in funding some of
the costs for feasibility studies, etc.
Engineer Brown stated a more effective means of communicating the potential liabilities to the petitioner
needed to be determined. Information should be added to the City web-site including brochures for all
infrastructures, answers to frequently asked questions, and any other information that would be beneficial
to City residents.
5. ADJOURN
Turgeon moved, Wellens seconded, Adjourning the City Council Work Session Meeting of
November 7, 2005, at 8:13 P.M. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Christine Freeman, Recorder
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
. Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2005
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
1.
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
D
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
A.
Roll Call
Present:
Mayor Love, Councilmembers Callies, Turgeon, and Wellens; Administrator Dawson;
and Engineer Brown
Absent:
Councilmember Lizee, Finance Director Burton, Planning Director Nielsen; Attorney
Keane
B.
Review Agenda
Turgeon moved, Wellens seconded, Approving the Agenda as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A.
City Council Regular Meeting Minutes, October 24, 2005
Wellens moved, Turgeon seconded, Approving the City Council Regular Meeting Minutes of
October 24, 2005, as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
B. City Council Executive Session Minutes, October 24, 2005
Turgeon moved, Wellens seconded, Approving the City Council Executive Session Minutes of
. October 24, 2005, as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
3. CONSENT AGENDA
.
Callies moved, Wellens seconded, Approving the Motions Contained on the Consent
Agenda and Adopting the Resolutions Therein:
A. Approval of the Verified Claims List
B. Staffing - Liquor Store staff
C. Authorize Expenditure of Funds - Stormwater Fund Culvert Replacements
D. Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 05-099, "A Resolution Approving Change Order #1-
Instrument Control Systems, Inc. for Badger Well House Project"
E.
Authorization for Professional Services for Chanhassen Interconnect - Woodhaven
Well
F. SLMPD Proposal
1f::-2C..-
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
NOVEMBER 14, 2005
Page 2 of3
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were not matters from the floor presented this evening.
5. REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS
None.
6. PUBLIC HEARING
None.
7. PARKS
Engineer Brown reported on the fIrst annual Buckthorn Bust held on November 5, 2005, which he and
Councilmember Wellens attended. There was a brief education on how Buckthorn spreads, how to
eradicate it, and several comments on the volume of Buckthorn that exists. He explained the City has two
weed wrenches that were used during the Buckthorn Bust which worked effectively. Residents can
contact the City to sign these weed wrenches out for two days after paying a deposit of $20. City staff
will continue to put articles about Buckthorn removal in its newsletter and on its web page.
Councilmember Callies thought this was a great program and off to a good start, but was disappointed it
was held on the same day as the Parks Foundation Art Show. This should be kept in mind when planning
for next year.
Councilmember Turgeon explained how the date of November 5, 2005, was established for the
Buckthorn Bust.
8. PLANNING
Commissioner Gagne reported on the matters considered and actions taken at the November 1, 2005,
Planning Commission meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting).
Councilmember Turgeon stated that a number of residents had called her regarding the potential
development on a vacant property in Chanhassen immediately south of West 62nd Street. She also stated
that the new owners of the Shorewood Yacht Club had contacted her.
Administrator Dawson reminded Council that they were invited to the Planning Commission Study
Session on November 15, 2005.
9. GENERAL/NEW BUSINESS
None.
10.
ENGINEERING/PUBLIC WORKS
None.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
NOVEMBER 14, 2005
Page 3 of3
11. STAFF AND COUNCIL REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
1. County Road 19 Intersection
Engineer Brown stated that the County Road 19 traffIc control lights are scheduled to go on at 8:30 AM on
November 15, 2005. It is expected that the decorative street ighting will begin to go up in the next two
weeks.
Administrator Dawson stated that a Work Session is being planned for the next meeting and asked the
Council if they preferred the Work Session to be held before or after the regular session. Councilmembers
stated their preference as prior to the Regular meeting. Administrator Dawson will inform Council of the
start time of the work session.
Administrator Dawson stated the next Excelsior Fire District Board Meeting is scheduled for November 23,
2005; City Hall is closed on November 24 and November 25,2005; and Public Works and the Liquor Stores
are open on November 25, 2005. Public Works has Columbus Day off instead of the day after Thanksgiving.
B. Mayor & City Council
Mayor Love stated that the Emergency Operations Plan presented at the Police meeting on November 14,
2005, was informative and thought it will be well received by the Council when presented to them.
Mayor Love explained that at the November 14, 2005, Coordinating Committee meeting the four Mayors
of SLMPD motioned to continue with the two-tier system for 2006 based on anticipated contributions
from the cities. Mayor Love stated they did see a flat line budget. Administrator Dawson stated that
Council would receive copies of what has been distributed, and he believes the Police Chief will have an
Executive Summary ready for budget deliberations in December 2005. He also stated the Work Session
on the Emergency Operations Plan will be 1 - 1 Vz hours long.
Mayor Love reminded Council of the fundraiser for the homeless that is occurring tonight, November 14.
12. ADJOURN
Wellens moved, Turgeon seconded, Adjourning the Regular City Council Meeting of November 14,
2005, at 7:17 P.M. Motion passed 4/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Christine Freeman, Recorder
ATTEST:
Woody Love, Mayor
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
PAYABLESAPPROVALS
. . .
For 11/28/05 Council Meeting
Prepared by:
Michelle T. Ng
~.
. nce Director
Approved by:
Cr .
wson, City Administrator
Date: J \ .1...3.05
*,-3 A
PAYROLL APPROVALS
For 11/28/05 Council Meeting
. . .' . .
Prepared by:. Date: / / kL:; /os-
Michelle T. N gu n, r. Accounting Clerk I I
Reviewed by: . ~ ~ Date: If ~S"
Bonnie urton, Fin e Director
Date: \1.23.05
,
"
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
.
DATE:
November 18, 2005
TO:
Honorable Mayor and Councilmembers fA ~
Bonnie Burton, Finance Director/Treasurer ~
FROM:
.
RE:
Annual Property & Liability Insurance Renewal
CC:
Craig Dawson, City Administrator ~
.
Background
The City's Property and Liability Insurance package renewed on November 1, 2005. The
City's municipal insurance coverage is through the League of Cities Insurance Trust.
The total package renewal premium for next year (2006) is $113,013 compared with
$90,595 this past year (2005). This municipal package includes property, liability,
worker's compensation, liquor liability, bond, and umbrella coverage.
Premium Summary
The proposed expense for the property and liability portion of the package increased from
$49,776 for 2005 to $64,433 for 2006. The annual Umbrella premium for 2006 is $9,715
compared to $7,287 for 2005. The City's Experience Loss Mod went from 1.06 last year
to 1.30 currently, which resulted in a considerable increase in premium. The City has
experienced several incidents resulting in claims, including land use lawsuits, water
~ system issues, vandalism, and vehicle incidents.
.
ft
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
-it3G
Insurance Renewal - Page 2
A summary of the city's coverage is attached for your review. Please note the grand total
for the package is $113,013 and the 2005 City budget allocated $103,500 across all funds
for all lines.
Liability Coverage Limits
This motion is considered by the City Council each year. Minnesota State Statutes set
tort liability limits for governmental units at $300,000 per claim/$750,000 total claims
per occurrence. The City carries tort liability at statutory limits and has excess liability
coverage of $1,000,000.
The City's insurer allows cities the option of waiving this limit, thereby allowing
payment of a larger claim. By waiving the statutory limit, the city opens itself to larger
claims and higher insurance costs.
In prior years, staff has recommended, and the City Council has elected, to not waive the
statutory limits. It is again the staff's recommendation that the Council approve a motion
that does not waive the statutory tort liability limits for the 2005/2006 insurance renewal.
Recommended Action
The City Council is requested to accept the property and liability insurance renewal and
elect to not waive the statutory limits as described above.
.
I'
.
.
.
.
.
'T\
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
INSURANCE PROGRAM
NOVEMBER 2005
The City of Sho..ewood has been insured with the League of Minnesota Cities
Insurance Trust since 1986. This program was established in the early 1980's with
the intent of insuring cities without producing profit for the insurance carrier.
Ninety percent of the cities that are eligible a..e enrolled in the program. The
program has been very successful in maintaining competitive rates in addition to
paying dividends based on the program's loss ..atio, not the loss ratio of the
individual city. Loss ratios are based on the annual renewal premiums excluding
any dividends paid. the City of Shorewood has qualified for a dividend most years
and the following is a list of the most recent dividends paid:
1995 - $18,763.00
1996 - $25,519.00
1997 - $22,722.00
1998 - $18,306.00
1999 - $13,179.00
2000 - $ 9,113.00
2001 - $12,388.00
2002 - $14,121.00
2003 - $13,598.00
2004 - $11,682.00
Attached are cu....ent Loss runs. As we discussed your Experience Loss Mod went
from 1.06 last year to 1.30 currently which resulted in a considerable increase of
premium.
Our agency has w..itten coverage for Shorewood since 1984, originally with Ma..inco
Insurance Company out of Texas, and then through the League program.
Annual premiums are based on the total program's experience and Shorewood's
experience within the program. The total package renewal premium for 2005-2006
is $64,433.00 compared to $49,766.00 last year. The annual Umbrella premium for
2005-2006 is $9,715.00 compared to $7,287.00. This includes any exposure changes
per the application that was submitted.
Page -2-
The City of Shorewood has always elected to renew "without the waiver of
monetary limits on tort liability established by Minnesota Statue 466.04". Our
underwriter at the League has informed us that a large majority of cities she works
with choose this option.
Coverages for the 2005-2006 policy period have been renewed per the attached
schedule of limits and coverages.
The liquor stores are covered under a specialty program with St. Paul Companies
for Off Sale Liquor establishments.
The League was unable to quote the No Fault Sewer Back Up coverage as to date as
their underwriting guidelines require that tile lines be cleaned every three years.
If you would like a quote for an additional $1,000,000. of Excess Liability coverage
please let us know. You currently have a $1,000,000. limit. The Open Meeting Law
coverage is $459.00 annually and is now included.
Thanks much for this renewal business. If you have any questions or need any
changes made please give us a call.
Sincerely,
KEN JARCHO AGENCY LLP
Kenneth J. Jarcho
.T
.
.
.
.
.
.'.
.
.
.
.
.
~.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
NOVEMBER 2005
POLICY/COVERAGES
POLICY PERIOD PREMIUM
CMC 25411
$5,29,165.00
5,529,164.00
606,189.00
264,095.00
$ 1,000,000.00
1,000,000.00
-League of Minnesota Cities 11/1/05 - 11/1/06
Blanket on Building & Personal
Property - $500.00 Deductible
Boiler Coverage
Mobile Equipment - Scheduled - Over $25,000.
Mobile Equipment - Unscheduled - Under $25,000.
$500.00 Deductible
Commercial General Liability - $500.00 Deductible
Public Oficials Liability - $2,500.00 Deductible
1,000,000.00 Business Auto Liability
Basic PIP
1,000,000.00 Uninsured & Underinsured Motol-ists
$500.00 Deductible - Comprehensive - Per Schedule
$500.00 Deductible - Collision - Per Schedule
15,000.00 Garagekeepers Coverage - $500.00 Deductible
MEL - 4124 League of Minnesota Cities
1,000,000.00 Umbrella
11/1/05 11/1/06
$ 64,433.00
9,715.00
.If
Page -2-
.
I6806556H118IND05 St. Paul Companies
Liquor Store
$ 341,960.00 Special Form, Replacement Cost on Contents
Including Improvements & Betterments
23720 Highway 7, Shorewood, MN 5533
11/1/05 - 11/1/06
240,539.00 Special Form, i.eplacement Cost on Contents
19905 Highway 7, Shorewood MN 55331
$500.00 Deductible
Commerical General Liability
$1,000,000.00 General Aggregate
500,000.00 Each Occurrence
.
Liquor Liability
500,000.00 Liability Limit
23720 Highway 7
19905 Highway 7
.
10,000.00 Money & Securities - Inside
10,000.00 Money & Securities - Outside
$ 9,629.00
1058982 United Fire & Casualty
100,000.00 Public Employees Bond
100,000.00 Depositor's Forgery
11/1/05 - 11/1/06
.
$ 969.00
02000276234 League of Minnesota Citities 11/1/05- 11/1/06
Workmen's Compensation & Employer's
Liability
$1,000,000.00 Bodily Injury - Each Occurrence
1,000,000.00 Bodily Injury by Disease - Agreement Limit
Based on Payrolls Per Attached $27,715.00
.
'- , .
.
Page -3-
906006-08506295-04 Auto Owners
76,179.00 Computer Equipment
Per Schedule
4,000.00 Toshiba Laptop
2,565.00 Dell Laptop
$500.00 Deductible
11/1105 - 11/1106
.
.
.
.
552.00
1'l",.lV' .. I .....'-'-- ----
Lo -:>5 L'?
~~~J
League of Minnesota Cities
Insurance Trust
145 University Avenue West, St, Paul. MN 55103.2044
(551) 281.1200 · (800) 925-1122
Fax: (651) 281.1298 . TOO: (651) 281.1290
www.lmnc,org
LMC
/.",agu" uF Mi",,_14 Cjiffu
Otin p""",ol;"9 1m,1kmco
November 16, 2005
~r _ , S' 2.- g f rf ~ (. s-cf 0
Re: City of Shorewood
." J
.
Ken Jarcho Agency
9052 Lyndale Avenue South
Bloomington, MN 55420 Effective Date: 11/01/05
~ ~-" S RENEWAL PREMIUM SUMMARY AND BINDER
.:. Property _~~J,I] Vo<~<J....~f:,{J
.:. Mobile Property '" ,',
J ~(~
~~" f' @7
$14,306. '-b,yJ
,1 "
,4,008,
.:. Municipal Liability
.:. Automobile Liability
.:. UM/UIM 1,000,000. Excluding unregistered vehicles
.:. Basic Economic Loss Benefits (PIP) . Excluding unregistered vehicles
36,554.
4.593.
238.
Included.
c'._-.........
.',':,\
.. ':~ '. :.\ \
,.~,:,\" r .1) ,
. ',I """)
1....1, 01""
\(~
2,929.
.:. Automobile Physical Damage
.:. Crime
Included.
.:. Bonds
Equipment Breakdown
Excess Liability Limit: $1,000,000
Open Meeting Law 100%
Garage Keepers Legal Liability (GKLL)
No Fault Sewer Backup
Not Covered.
1,220.
9,715./
459.
126.
Not Covered.
TOTAL
$74,148.
TORT LIMIT $300,000./$1,000,000.
.:. Deductible: $500.
REMARKS: DO NOT PAY UNTIL YOU RECEIVE INVOICES!
Subject to a signed and dated Waiver Election Form.
Renewal coverage is bound up to 60 days pending issuance of renewal based on LMCIT forms and
practices in effect on renewal date,
S&~pO/
Underwriter
.
.
.
j~
I
~~f~ /..., (pc..cA'"' ~r/'~~..ov-,I ~~
;" 4'.... S - ~ d:"'r'-;""-' s - /t1-':"'Y..i-
L ..~.. ( :/- A-.Jo L. ~.}!." -f. Z:f / G,)t-G.d F
t. " ~ " ( . ~I e<-r ,,--...e.e. ..... r "-S ~ 1 "
or-" "" t I:;; ~,((fJ4') ~ ;1<. '" J . {. i.
13ft ,r;" h<o J . }. (;, 'is .
AN EQVAl ",,,IVNI" "",,,'nVE 210M 'MPLO'" ~
ST
& ~..fl I fA.?< e.o.-s-e.-
,$ J~f 1v v~
dvJ~ J{,~ .
LM rr2
1119 2)( 1104 )(Rev. 3/04)
J
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, 4 OCTOBER 2005
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Acting Chair Gagne called the meeting to order at 7:03 P.M.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Chair Bailey (arrived 7:09 P.M.); Commissioners Conley, Gagne, Gniffke, White (arrived
7:07 P,M.) and Woodruff; and Planning Director Nielsen and Council Liaison Wellens
Absent:
Commissioner Meyer
. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
· 20 September 2005
.
.
.
Conley moved, Gniftke seconded, Approving the September 20, 2005, Planning Commission Meeting
as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
1.
7:00 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING- C.U.P. FOR ACCESSORY SPACE OVER 1200 SO.FT.
Applicant: Mike Catain
Location: 4550 Enchanted Point
Acting Chair Gagne opened the Public Hearing at 7:04 P.M., noting the procedures utilized in a Public
Hearing. He also noted any items recommended for approval at this meeting would appear on the October
24, 2005, Regular City Council Meeting Agenda for further review and consideration.
Director Nielsen explained the applicant had applied for a conditional use permit to construct accessory
space in excess of 1200 square feet on the property located at 4550 Enchanted Point. Mr. Catain proposed
building a detached, single-story garage on the west side of his property. Since the area of the garage, when
added to existing accessory structures on the site, exceeded 1200 square feet, a C.D.P. was required.
He went on to explain the property was zoned R-1C/S, Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland and contained
60,000 square feet of area. He also noted the location of Mr. Catain's house, which was currently
undergoing a significant remodeling and addition project, and the proposed new garage. The garage was
intended to replace a nonconforming boathouse/garage removed as part of the current construction project.
The existing home had an attached garage containing 781 square feet of floor area, and the new detached
garage would have 738 square feet of area, bringing the total area of accessory structures on the site to 1519
square feet. The existing home contained 5866 square feet of floor area above grade, between two levels.
Elevations were noted, including the front elevation of the house that illustrated the architectural character
and type of materials used for the home.
In addition, Director Nielsen explained the property had an easement for a dry fire hydrant system that
served Island residents. The turn-around on the north side of the garage was intended for fire fighting
equipment. Mr. Catain was exploring the possibility of relocating the dry hydrant out to the public right-of-
way of Enchanted Point, assuming costs were reasonable to do so. The relocation of neither the fire
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISION MEETING MINUTES
October 4, 2005
Page2of6
\.
hydrant, nor the proposed garage would interfere with fire department access to the hydrant system.
.
Chair Bailey assumed the leadership role of the meeting from Acting Chair Gagne at 7:08 P.M.
Michael Catain, applicant, stated he had revised the proposal to include moving the proposed garage closer
to the driveway near the drainpipe depicted in the site plan. He stated he would not be blocking anyone's
view with this revised proposal and requested the Commission review the proposal with this change in mind
this evening.
Scott Brown, 4560 Enchanted Point, stated he understood the tradeoffs being made as part ofthis site;
however, he asked that the proposed garage be redesigned to limit its height since the proposed structure
would severely limit the lake view from his property. He also explained that since Mr. Catain had owned
the property his view ofthe lake had been limited repeatedly in Mr. Catain's efforts to improve the property.
He also noted concern for the fencing at the lake shore with regard to its appropriate setback requirements.
He also stated he was concerned that the gate to the property remained locked at various times throughout
the project. This was concerning because the fire hydrant was currently located within the gated portion of
the Catain property and should there be a fire within the neighborhood, the hydrant could not be .
appropriately accessed.
Dee McMasters, 4530 Enchanted Point, stated she had met with Mr. Catain recently to discuss the proposed
garage. She stated she would lose over half of the lake view from her property should this garage be placed
in its original location, noting she believed this action would hinder her from maximizing the full value of
her property should she ever decide to sell it. She stated she appreciated Mr. Catain's efforts to work with
her family to remedy the situation by moving the garage structure to the right of the driveway as he .
explained to the Commission this evening.
Mike Hayes, builder for Mr. Catain, stated he had staked the originally proposed location last week. Mr.
Catain had considered the garage be moved to a different location at that time as he was aware that views to
the lake would be blocked for his neighbors. With regard to the gate to the property, he stated, it was not
locked but was simply held by a bungee cord during the construction phase on the property.
Mr. Catain stated he was attempting to remedy issues of concern with his neighbors, however, he thought
the garage needed to be built to scale with the rest of the buildings on site. He stated he had developed .
other properties previously and had attempted to do the right thing in each case. He stated he had a good
working relationship with the Mound Fire Chief with regard to the location of the hydrant for this area.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:21 P.M.
Commissioner Woodruff stated he would like to see a revised plan that more accurately reflected the
proposed location of the garage. Commissioners agreed.
Chair Bailey stated it was important to understand that a resident could not own a view of the lake over
someone else's property. Residents were allowed to make changes to property under their ownership,
regardless of disruption of a view of the lake for others. He also noted the height of the building had been
reduced and met the minimum height requirements specified by City ordinance.
Commissioner White suggested the relocation of the dry hydrant from its current location would be
beneficial to all residents in the area.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISION MEETING MINUTES
October 4, 2005
Page 3 of6
Conley moved, Gniftke seconded, Continuing this case to the November 1, 2005, Planning
Commission Meeting. Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 7:33 P.M.
2. MINOR SUBDIVISION
Applicant: George Danser
Location: 5840 Christmas Lake Road
Director Nielsen explained Mr. George Danser, on behalf of his mother, Pamela Danser, proposed
subdividing the property located at 5840 Christmas Lake Road. The subject property was located in the R-
IAlS, Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland zoning district and contained 173,800 square feet of area
(approximately four acres). The property was occupied by two single-family dwellings - the main house
and a guest house. The site was also occupied by a fairly large wetland area, from which the land rose to
the south and to the west.
As proposed, the subdivision would result in one lot (with the house on it) containing 40,010 square feet of
area, and a vacant lot with 133,790 square feet, approximately half of which was occupied by the wetland
area. The property was subject to a private driveway easement that provided access to the house to the
southwest. The owner also owned two small parcels on the other side of the street, abutting Christmas
Lake. Director Nielsen stated the request included legally combining those parcels with the two new lots.
Director Nielsen then explained with regard to the analysis of the case, that the R-1A1S zoning district
required lots to be at least 40,000 square feet in area, 120 feet wide at the building line, and at least 120 feet
deep. Both lots would comply with the setbacks of the R-1A1S district. Despite the existing wetland, the
new lot had ample buildable area at the west end of the property. To minimize altering the wetland area to
accommodate a driveway for the new property, the new lot would need to share a common driveway with
the existing home. The new driveway would then extend over to the south side of the property where it
would extend west to the buildable portion of the property.
He noted there were several issues that required address in this request.
1. Christmas Lake Road was substandard in width (33 feet vs. 50 feet required). Any approval of the
division/combination should require dedication of an additional 17 feet of right-of-way. The
applicant's surveyor should provide a legal description for the r.o.w. and his attorney should
incorporate the description into a deed to the City.
2. The r.o.w. referenced above would necessitate moving the rear lot line of Parcel B 17 feet, in order to
maintain 40,000 square feet of area.
3. The applicant's surveyor should provide legal descriptions for the wetland area and the required 35-foot
buffer area. The applicant's attorney should incorporate the legal descriptions into drainage and
conservation easement deeds to the City. The buffer must be staked with wetland monuments.
Proposed staking should be shown on the survey.
4. The applicant's surveyor should provide legal descriptions for the drainage and utility easements (10
feet around each of the lots). From these descriptions the applicant's attorney should prepare easement
deeds to the City.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISION MEETING MINUTES '.
October 4, 2005
Page 4 of 6
5. The driveway easement across Parcel B, in favor of Parcel A, was incomplete and too narrow. Due to .
the distance from the street to the buildable portion of Parcel A, a fIre access road was required,
pursuant to the State Fire Code. This required a 20-foot wide paved surface. Allowing a very minimal
fIve feet on each side of the driveway for snow storage, the easement should be 30 feet wide. The
applicant's attorney should also provide an easement and maintenance agreement for the shared portion
of the driveway.
6. The applicant must submit a grading plan for the new driveway. While it was assumed the amount of
fIll necessary to accommodate the driveway would be minimal, it would require review and approval by
the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District.
7. The two parcels on the east side of the road should be split more evenly, in order to provide adequate
room for a dock on Parcel C. It should be made large enough so that a dock can be located in frontof
Parcel A. The combination of Parcels C and D with Parcels A and B, respectively, was subject to
approval by Hennepin County.
8. It may be necessary for the applicant to obtain consent for the conservation easement that coincides
with the existing driveway easement from the adjoining property owner. This issue has been referred to
the City Attorney for his recommendation.
.
9. The existing nonconforming guest house must be relocated (or removed) on the site and converted to
accessory space. It should be noted that items 2. and 5., above, will necessitate a slightly different
location for the structure. If this will not be resolved prior to recording a resolution for the
division/combination, a letter of credit or cash escrow for one and one-half times the amount of the
work must be provided by the applicant. The applicant must provide bids for this work in order to
determine the amount of the letter of credit.
.
10. The proposed subdivision did not require the removal of any trees. Any tree removal necessary for the
construction of a house on the new lot could be addressed with the building permit for that lot.
11. The applicant must provide an up-to-date (within 30 days) title opinion or title commitment for review
by the City Attorney.
12. Prior to release of the resolution approving the subdivision, the applicant must pay a park dedication fee
($2000), and a local sanitary sewer connection charge ($1200) for the new lot. Credit was given for the
lot with the existing home on it.
.
13. Once the applicant had received the Council resolution approving the subdivision, he must record it
with Hennepin County within 30 days or the approval is void.
Director Nielsen stated often times it was recommended that a division/combination be approved subject to
the attached conditions. In this instance, there were enough issues to be resolved that Director Nielsen
suggested that the application be continued, pending completion of the required items.
George Danser, applicant, stated this was an opportunity for his family to subdivide the property. His
mother had owned the property since 1975 and his grandmother before her since 1941. He noted his
mother's current health situation and the purpose for the request. Mr. Danser suggested the easement be
paved, widened and accessible as a fire lane. He noted other lots would then have future access as the
current owner had access rights. He also stated it would mitigate additional access off Christmas Lake .
Road.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISION MEETING MINUTES
October 4, 2005
Page 5of6
Bruce Benson, 5820 Christmas Lake Road, stated he had lived on his property his entire life, and while he
had no problem with the proposed request, he would like the idea of having an owner live on the site. He
stated he was concerned about the wetland in that area as it acted as a drainage basin for an extensive area.
He also stated he did not want to see the wetland blocked in any way. He also noted the two to three lots to
the north of this property were landlocked. He believed controlling the road access points to be a safe and
good idea. He also thought the drainage from the north and south into and out of the wetland area needed to
be addressed as well.
Eric Danser, brother of the applicant, stated he was concerned about the request regarding Lot C in this
case. It had been forty feet in length since 1941 and a dock had always been in place there. With regard to
the easement issue, he stated there would be a maximum of three owners utilizing one driveway in this case.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:56 P.M.
Commissioner White stated she agreed with the suggestion to retain the driveway location on the easement.
Director Nielsen stated the applicants were trying to avoid putting in a City street, however, there would be
fIve homes served by the driveway and that necessitated a City Street in this matter.
Discussion ensued about the driveway issue and several Commissioners agreed with Director Nielsen's
recommendation to continue the case.
Conley moved, Gagne seconded, Continuing this case to November 1,2005, Planning Commission
Meeting Agenda. Motion passed 6/0.
3. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
Commissioner Woodruff explained the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District (LMCD) had notifIed
residents of Enchanted Island that a multiple dock license had been requested for the property located at
4320 Enchanted Drive. A Public Hearing on this issue had been scheduled for October 12,2005.
Commissioner Woodruff requested the Commission consider discussing City ordinances related to the
defInition of dock and whether the City wished to be more restrictive than the LMCD in its ordinances.
4. DRAFT NEXT MEETING AGENDA
Director Nielsen stated the two items continued from this meeting this evening, as well as Public Hearings
on sign regulations and other applications, were slated for the November 1, 2005, Planning Commission
Meeting Agenda. He reminded the Commission there would be no Planning Commission Meeting on
October 18, 2005. Commissioner Woodruff stated he would be unable to attend the November 1, 2005,
Planning Commission meeting.
5. REPORTS
· Liaison to Council
Commissioner Gniffre reported on matters considered and actions taken at the September 26,2005,
Regular City Council Meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting).
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISION MEETING MINUTES
October 4, 2005
Page 6 of 6
,.
.
.
· SLUC
No report was given for the Sensible Land Use Coalition (SLUe) meeting.
· Other
None.
6. ADJOURN
Gagne moved, White seconded, Adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of October 4, 2005.
Motion passed 6/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Sally Keefe
Recording Secretary
.
.
.
.
'l
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, 1 NOVEMBER 2005
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Bailey called the meeting to order at 7:00 P.M.
Present:
Chair Bailey; Commissioners Conley (arrived 7:03 P.M.), Gagne, Gniffke, Meyer and
White; Planning Director Nielsen and Council Liaison Wellens
Absent:
Commissioner Woodruff
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
· 4 October 2005
Gagne moved, Gniftke seconded, Approving the October 4, 2005, Planning Commission Meeting
Minutes as amended on Page 2, Item 1, Paragraph 4, Sentence 2, change "his efforts" to "Mr.
Catain's efforts" and in the next sentence of that same item and paragraph, omit the "ed" from
"concerned." Motion passed 4/0/1, Meyer abstaining due to his absence at that meeting.
1.
PUBLIC HEARING - C.U.P. FOR ACCESSORY SPACE OVER 1200 SO.FT.
Applicant: Mike Catain
Location: 4550 Enchanted Point
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 7:02 P.M., noting the procedures utilized inthe Public Hearing
process. In addition, he stated any items recommended for approval this evening would be placed on the
November 28, 2005, Regular City Council Meeting Agenda for further consideration.
Commissioner Conley arrived at 7:03 P.M.
Director Nielsen explained that this case was continued from the October Planning Commission Meeting
pending the applicant's submission of a revised site plan for the project. Director Nielsen then briefly
reviewed the revised site plan noting the garage had been shifted approximately 20 feet to the south to
address neighborhood concerns regarding sight lines to the lake. Director Nielsen went on to state that
recommendations from the October meeting still remained for this case, however, he recommended
approval of this case with those Staff recommendations included. He also stated no additional landscaping
was necessary.
Michael Catain, applicant, stated he had met the guidelines outlined in the City ordinances, and he was
trying to work the neighbors as best he could. He stated the view was best he could manage to work with
on the site as proposed.
In response to a question by John McMasters, 4530 Enchanted Point, Director Nielsen clarified the setback
requirements and criteria necessary for a Conditional Use Permit. He noted all criteria had been met in this
case.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7: lOP .M.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 2 of8
There were no questions from the Planning Commission on this case.
White moved, Meyer seconded, Approving the Conditional Use Permit for Accessory Space Over
1200 Square Feet for Mike Catain, 4550 Enchanted Point. Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 7: lOP .M.
2. MINOR SUBDIVISION
Applicant: George Danser
Location: 5840 Christmas Lake Road
Director Nielsen explained this item had been continued from the October Planning Commission Meeting
pending the applicant resolving numerous issues raised by City Staff. He noted the applicant had not
submitted revised plans to date. In addition, he went on to explain, the property owner to the south had
disputed the common property boundary between his and the Danser property. In a letter dated 7 October,
the neighbo.r pro.vided information indicating that the pro.perty line might be 12 feet further to the no.rth than
that sho.wn by the Dansers' surveyo.r. Director Nielsen stated if the line must be adjusted, the so.utherly lo.t
on the Danser pro.perty could still be made to. co.mply with zoning requirements. It wo.uld, however require
the rear lot line to be moved further to the west in order to maintain 40,000 square feet of area. He also
noted this action was necessary anyway, due to the requirement o.f additional road right-of-way for
Christmas Lake Road. Director Nielsen went on to explain there were procedures for settling property line
disputes, through neighborly discussion or through the legal system.
George Danser, applicant, stated he had discussed the issue of the property line with his mother, the o.wner
of the property, and would make every effort to work with the neighbor to resolve the dispute. He noted a
letter of description of events regarding the property line had been submitted to Staff for further
clarification. He still remained concerned for the necessity of Lot C being combined with other proposed
lots as the current configuration had proven successful historically for his family. In addition, he stated he
had remo.ved the dock on the lot as requested by the City. He stated several issues had been addressed and
he was concerned that Staffhad the opinion that nothing had been resolved in this case in the past month as
he believed the opposite was true. He requested the Commission consider the hardship of the owner's
current health care issues and work to move the request forward expeditiously.
After a brief discussion of the Commission and clarification of issues with Mr. Danser, Mr. Danser stated
he would need to speak with members of his family about the remaining issues of concern.
Gagne moved, Conley seconded, Continuing the case to the November 15, 2005, Planning
Commission Meeting. Motion passed 6/0.
3. 7:15 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - C.U.P. FOR FILL IN EXCESS OF 100 CU. YDS.
Applicant: Mark Guidinger
Location: 19735 Muirfield Circle
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 7 :43 P.M.
.'
.
.
.
.
Director Nielsen explained the history of the case, noting Mark Guidinger was the owner of the property at
19735 Muirfield Circle. Mr. Guidinger proposed building a swimming pool in his rear yard that would
necessitate up to 400 cubic yards of fill to create a level area for the pool. Because Shorewood' s zoning .
regulations required a conditional use permit for fill in excess of 100 cubic yards, Mr. Guidinger had
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 3 of 8
submitted a request far such a canditianal use permit. Directar Nielsen then nated the lacatian af the paal
and retaining wall system as prapased an the lat. He also. reviewed a crass-sectian drawing illustrating haw
the retaining walls, paal and hause related to. the existing grade. The fill material wauld be canfined by two.
baulder retaining walls, faur to. six feet in height, terraced with a faur-faat wide landscaped area between
the walls. The lawer afthe two. walls was appraximately 50 feet fram the rear praperty line. The
applicant's engineer has pravided a written plan to. the City regarding canstructian afthe retaining walls far
the praject.
In additian, Directar Nielsen explained the praperty was zaned P.U.D., Planned Unit Develapment (Single-
Family), and cantained appraximately 26,361 square feet af area. The lat was characterized by a significant
drap in elevatian at the rear af the existing hame. While the area immediately behind the hame was
relatively apen, the sautheasterly partian afthe lat was quite heavily waaded.
With regard to. the issues af analysis far this case, Directar Nielsen stated Sharewaad' s Zaning Cade
required a canditianal use permit whenever mare than 100 cubic yards af material was brought an to. a site.
This equated to. appraximately 10 dump truck laads af dirt. Issues assaciated with these types af request
were typically engineering related. Cansequently, the plans were farwarded to. the City's engineering
cansultant, WSB & Assaciates. Steve Gurney had reviewed the plans relative to. grading, drainage and the
structural aspect afthe propased retaining walls, and his recammendatians were included in his repart,
dated 26 Octaber 2005.
With regard to. issues af grading and drainage, the specifics were detailed in Mr. Gurney's repart, hawever,
the main issue was the effect af the grading and filling an the existing trees an the site. The applicant
prapased to. maintain significant tree caver in the rear 50 feet af the praperty. Directar Nielsen also. stated
the Pallutian Cantral Agency recammended that paal drainage be canducted to. the sanitary sewer system
unless the paal water had nat been treated far at least seven days. While it was fairly camman practice to.
drain paals to. streets and ultimately into. the starm system, this shauld nat be allawed far any paal that has
been treated within the last seven days. Directar Nielsen explained the City had received carrespandence
fram a cancerned praperty awner to. the east afthe prapased praject regarding this case.
Directar Nielsen stated any appraval afthe canditianal use permit shauld be subject to. the
recammendatians afthe City's Cansulting Engineer. He nated the applicant was present this evening, as
well as the applicant's landscape cantractar.
Mr. Guidinger stated he had submitted a landscape design far the praject, as requested by Staff, nating the
design firm cantracted far the praject had warked with the engineering recammendatians far the site as
well. He nated in praviding a level area far the paal, it wauld drain apprapriately. He stated the paal
drainage wauld mast likely drain to. the starm sewer at the end afthe driveway.
Ran Jahnsan, 5355 Shady Hills Circle, stated he abjected to. this request, and stated the City Planning
Directar had no. knawledge af farm drainage ar suppart af craps. He stated this public hearing was ane in a
series af public hearings regarding public water being drapped an to. his praperty. He then summarized the
histary af his abjectian to. this case. He stated the City had to. affer him campensatian far drapping public
water an to. his praperty.
Hans Free, applicant's landscape cantractar, stated he was warking with the engineering recammendatians
regarding drainage far the site.
Mr. Jahnson stated there were several instances were the City had nat fixed the prablem af allawing water
to. enter his property.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1,2005
Page 4 of8
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:57 P.M.
Director Nielsen stated, with regard to the pool drainage, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency
recommended the pool discharge not be directed to wetland areas, preferring instead that the discharge be
directed to sanitary sewer systems if chemically treated. He stated most homeowners, in his experience, ran
a drainage line to the storm sewer or to a yard area. These practices would work acceptably as long as
homeowners did not treat the pool with chemicals for seven days prior to drainage into the storm sewer or
yard.
Commissioner Gagne questioned whether Mr. Guidinger had met the necessary approvals as outlined in
City ordinances associated with a request such as this one. Director Nielsen stated the Engineering and
Planning Departments had recommended approval of this project.
In response to a question by Council Liaison Wellens, Mr. Johnson demonstrated the location of his land on
a site location map associated with the pool project being requested. Mr. Johnson went on to state drain
tiles had been placed in that area that would outlet onto his property.
Conley moved, Gagne seconded, Recommending Approval of a Conditional Use Permit for Mark
Guidinger, 19735 Muirfield Circle, subject to City Engineering recommendations.
Chair Bailey stated he believed the issue at hand was not to solve Mr. Johnson's drainage issue, but to
allow Mr. Guidinger to develop his property.
.
.
Commissioner Conley stated he agreed, and with all due respect to Mr. Johnson, the issues presented by Mr.
Johnson were large scale issues. He further stated he was not convinced that the quantity of water drained .
from a pool once a year would contribute in a meaningful way to the larger engineering issues. He also
stated he thought a property owner had a right to develop his own property.
Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 8:08 P.M.
4.
7:30 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - PRELIMINARY PLAT - APPLE RIDGE 3RD ADDN.
Applicant: Lecy Construction, Inc.
Location: Outlots A and B of Apple Ridge 2nd Addn (Apple Road)
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 8:15 P.M.
Director Nielsen explained in 2002, Lecy Construction, Inc. was granted approval for Apple Ridge 2nd
Addition, a four-lot, residential subdivision located on the east side of Apple Road, just north of the
Shorewood/Chanhassen border. The project was processed as a planned unit development that allowed the
developer to cluster the four new lots and included a conservation easement over the easterly 56,916 square
feet (1.31 acres) ofthe site. The easement, originally platted as Outlot A, was in favor of the City of
Shorewood. A second outlot, Outlot B, was to be conveyed to the property owner to the north. This
conveyance never occurred due to that property owner's legal difficulties.
Lecy Construction now proposed replatting the two outlots into four outlots in order to convey them to
adjoining property owners. In their letter, dated 4 October 2005, the applicants explained the properties
would be resubdivided into four outlots, and how the outlots would be conveyed. This public hearing was
held for the purpose of considering a preliminary plat for the property.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1,2005
Page 5 of8
Director Nielsen went on to explain this request was somewhat unusual, primarily for the resulting lot
configurations proposed by the applicant. He stated it must be noted that Outlots A-C would still be subject
to the original conservation easement. Only the ownership would be changed. As explained in the
applicant's letter, Outlot D would be the same size as the original Outlot B, with proposed ownership
undetermined at this time.
Since the proposed plat did not result in additional building lots, the principal concern with this "replat" was
making sure that all of the prospective land owners were fully aware that Outlots A-C was subject to the
conservation easement. In this regard, the resolution approving a final plat should clearly inform future
owners of the existence of the easement. Approval ofthe preliminary plat should also be subject to the
following:
1.
The developer should submit a protective covenant stating that Outlot A would not be sold
separately from its adjoining property. This property was located in Chanhassen and can not be
legally combined in another way. The applicant's attorney should submit the covenant before the
final plat was scheduled for Council review and approval.
2. Outlot B should be legally combined with Lot 3, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded with the
final plat for the Third Addition.
3.
Outlot C should be legally combined with Lot 2, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded with the
final plat for the Third Addition. Outlot C and Lot 2 were both owned by Lecy Construction, so
there should be no delay.
4.
The legal status ofthe property owner to the north of Outlot D was unknown as of this writing. If
Outlot D can not be conveyed within one year, the outlot should be legally combined with Lot 2.
This outlot would be of no benefit to the property owner to the east of Apple Ridge.
5. The applicant must provide evidence of recording for items 1-3 within 30 days of Council approval,
or the approval would be void.
. Director Nielsen noted a representative of Lecy Construction was present this evening.
.
Andy Johnsrud, of Lecy Construction Inc., stated the recommendations were acceptable as presented by
Director Nielsen. He stated the only possible problem that could be foreseen related to Item 4 of the
recommendations.
Seeing no one present wishing to comment on this case, Chair Bailey opened and closed the Public Hearing
at 8:21 P.M.
Discussion ensued by the Commission regarding the best possible method and timeline necessary for
working with the conveyance of Outlot D.
White moved, Gagne seconded, Recommending Approval of a Preliminary Plat for Apple Ridge, 3rd
Addition, subject to Staff Recommendations 1-3 and 5, and that Outlot D would be legally combined
with Lot 2 by March 1, 2005, as detailed in the Staff Memorandum from Director Nielsen regarding
this case, dated October 30, 2005. Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 8:30 P.M.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 6 of8
5.
MINOR SUBDIVISION
Applicant: Ann Meldahl
Location: 6180 Cathcart Drive
.
This item had been removed from the agenda for this meeting at the request of the applicant.
6. MINOR SUBDIVISIONS
Applicant: Timothy Anderson
Location: 20520 and 20540 Excelsior Boulevard
Director Nielsen explained 10Spring, Inc., representing Timothy Anderson, had requested approval of a
minor subdivision ofthe two lots located at 20520 and 20540 Excelsior Boulevard. The easterly lot
(20520) lot was currently occupied by a single-family dwelling. The westerly lot was vacant. Pursuant to
Section 1201.03 Subd.16 of the Shorewood Zoning Ordinance, the applicant proposed dividing the lots in
order to build two, two-family dwellings that are subdivided for individual ownership. He went on to
explain the subject properties were located in the R-2A, Single and Two-Family Residential Zoning .
District. The easterly lot contained 30,687 square feet of area. The existing home and detached garage
would be demolished and replaced with a new two-family dwelling. The westerly lot contained 30,507
square feet. All four of the proposed unit lots would exceed 15,000 square feet.
With regard to analysis for the case, Director Nielsen explained that although the existing lots were platted
prior to Shorewood having any provision in its zoning ordinance for dividing lots with two-family
dwellings on them, both ofthe base lots met the minimum 30,000 square-foot requirement. Similarly, the
four new unit lots all met the minimum area requirement of 15,000 square feet. Based upon the provisions .
of the Shorewood Zoning Code, the request was consistent with Shorewood's zoning regulations and
Comprehensive Plan. Staff recommended that the divisions be approved subject to the following:
1. The applicant must provide a maintenance agreement, suitable for recording, addressing
how future owners would agree on the upkeep of the property.
2.
The unit lots would all require separate City utilities. It should be noted that City water
was available to the subject properties but not required.
.
3. The divisions and maintenance agreements must be recorded within 30 days of the
applicant receiving a certified copy of the Council resolutions approving the divisions.
4. Prior to release of the resolutions, the applicant must pay park dedication fees for the new
lots ($2000 x 3 = $6000). Credit was allowed for the lot with the existing house on it.
5. Prior to release of the resolutions, the applicant must pay local sanitary sewer access
charges for the new lots ($1200 x 3 = $3600). Credit was allowed for the lot with the
existing house on it.
Director Nielsen stated representatives were present for this case this evening.
Jamie Rosen, of 10Spring Inc., stated he would be happy to answer any questions the Commission might
have of him regarding this case.
Various Commissioners requested clarification on the common area and proposed driveways for the project.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 7of8
Gniftke moved, Conley seconded, Recommending Approval of the Request for Minor Subdivision for
Timothy Anderson, 20520 and 20540 Excelsior Boulevard. Motion passed 6/0.
7. 8:00 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - ZONING CODE AMENDMENT REGARDING SIGN
REGULATIONS
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 8:38 P.M.
Director Nielsen explained the Commission had reviewed draft language regarding sign regulations for the
City's Zoning Code at its September 20,2005, Study Session Meeting. He then reviewed the proposed
changes to the zoning code as a result of discussions held at that meeting. He noted changes to menu board,
signage, general provisions, non-conforming signage, zoning district regulations, and permit issuance and
application issues.
Seeing no one present wishing to comment on this matter, Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion
of the Public Hearing at 8:46 P.M.
Discussion ensued regarding the necessity of exempting barber poles from the code.
Gagne moved, Recommending allowing the current ordinance provisions regarding moving barber
poles be retained as currently stated.
Motion failed for lack of a second.
Discussion ensued regarding other various issues requiring clarification with the proposed ordinance
changes.
Gagne moved, Gniftke seconded, Continuing this item to the November 15, 2005, Planning
Commission Meeting Agenda. Motion passed 6/0.
8. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were no matters from the floor presented this evening.
9. DRAFT NEXT MEETING AGENDA
Director Nielsen stated there would be a Joint Meeting of the Planning Commission and City Council as
well as the two items from this meeting continued to the next meeting of the Planning Commission slated
for the November 15,2005, Planning Commission Meeting. Commissioner White stated she would not be
present at that meeting.
10. REPORTS
· Liaison to Council
Director Nielsen reported on matters considered and actions taken at the October 26,2005, Regular City
Council Meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting).
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 8 of 8
· SLUC
.
No report given.
· Other
None.
11. ADJOURNMENT
White moved, Gagne seconded, Adjourning the Planning Commission Meeting of November 1, 2005.
Motion passed 6/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.
Sally Keefe
Recording Secretary
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 . www.ci.shorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
. FROM:
DATE:
RE:
. FILE NO.:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen
29 September 2005
Catain, Michael- C.U.P. for Accessory Space in Excess of 1200 Square
Feet
405 (05.23)
BACKGROUND
.
Mr. Michael Catain has applied for a conditional use permit to construct accessory space in
excess of 1200 square feet on the property located at 4550 Enchanted Point (see Site Location
map - Exhibit A, attached). Mr. Catain proposes to build a detached, single-story garage on
the west side of his property (see Exhibit B). Since the area ofthe garage, when added to
existing accessory structures on the site, exceeds 1200 square feet, a C.U.P. is required.
The property is zoned R-1C/S, Single-Family ResidentiallShoreland and contains 60,000
square feet of area. Exhibit B shows the location of Mr. Catain's home, which is currently
undergoing a significant remodeling and addition project, and the proposed new garage. The
garage is intended to replace a nonconforming boathouse/garage that was removed as part of
the current construction project.. The existing home has an attached garage containing 781
square feet of floor area. The new detached garage will have 738 square feet of area, bringing
the total area of accessory structures on the site to 1519 square feet.
.
Elevations ofthe proposed garage are shown on Exhibits C and D. The existing home
contains 5866 square feet of floor area above grade, between two levels. The front elevation
of the house (Exhibit E) illustrates the architectural character and type of materials used for
the home.
#91
'-~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#8A.
.
Memorandum
Re: Catain CUP
29 September 2005
The property has an easement for a dry fire hydrant system that serves Island residents. The
turn-around on the north side of the garage is intended for fire fighting equipment. Mr. Catain
is exploring the possibility of relocating the dry hydrant out to the public right-of-way of
Enchanted Point, assuming costs are reasonable to do so. Whether the hydrant is relocated or
not the proposed garage does not interfere with fire department access to the hydrant system.
ANAL YSIS/RECOMMENDATION
Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.d.(4) of the Zoning Code prescribes criteria for granting conditional
use permits for accessory space over 1200 square feet. Following is how the applicant's plans
comply with the Code:
a. The total area of accessory buildings (1519 square feet) does not exceed the floor area
. above grade ofthe existing home (5866 square feet).
b. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed 10 percent of the minimum lot size
for the R-IC/S zoning district (.10 x 20,000 = 2000 square feet).
.
c. The proposed garage complies with R-1 CIS setback requirements. The new garage is 50
feet from the ordinary high water level of the lake and 16 feet from the west side lot line.
The existing house is 14.8 feet from the southerly lot line. Total hardcover on the site,
exclusive ofthe fire department turn-around on the north side of the garage amounts to
23.98 percent.
.
d. The design and materials for the detached garage are very consistent with the proposed
high quality architectural character of the existing home. Often times it is recommended
that additional landscaping be provided to soften the view of larger accessory buildings.
In this case the applicant has already planted a row of arborvitae along both of his side lot
lines. No additional landscaping is recommended to be required.
Based upon the preceding analysis, it is recommended that the applicant's request for a
conditional use permit be granted as proposed.
cc: Tim Keane
Joe pazandak
Michael Catain
Michael Hayes
.
-2-
$'
r ~'~~i.a-n.&}j~'-lm~~.~"ii~~:+MMY:~'
:il
i
I
.
.
'.
.I.
.I.
.
I
L."Kc"
t-l\ \ f\ t\ &-~ontc..O\
.
N
A
o
,
250
500
1,000
,Feet
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
Catain c.u.P.
, 9ERTIFICA TE OF SURVEY FOR
MICHAEL CA T AIN
OF,'l:OT':"16,.AND.PART OF' LOTS 9, 15 &. 17, AUD. SUB. NO. 354
OF L9TS, .~, ~.. 3, :SLOCK 3, AND ~ART OF LOT' 4, BLOCK 4, ENCHANTED PARK
",'" . 'H~NNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA
:.RT
: '.
. .. .:. .. .,~ .
,:..'
. .....
ADDRESS : 45$0 ENCHANTED POINT
. ,'. '.
"
., '.,
.
. .:
. .... .
........ '
..:.......1.
... ',':
....::.~. >-
.'
'. ~ I :.. :
:....
'.' .'
'. \~ ". ..
'. . '
'.: "
. ....
. ......",
LDESCRIPTION OF, PREMsiES .;; '" ,
'/ '" " -.
16, Auditor' 's ,Subdivlsic;.n No,:354, Hennepin County. Minnesota. ond that
of Lot 4" Blp*' 4. E:NC!:lAI:IT~D 'PARK, t;lennepin COunty; Minnesota, Iyin~
erly of, the following desQrlbe(f. line. hetlllnafter refered to as, "Line A>:
nencing at the" mOst' we,terly,' .cotner of Lot.'.16; Aud(tor' s Subdivision
i54.Hennepin .Caunty;' Mihnesata:....thence 'easterly' along, the southerly line
.' ot 16 0 distonc.e.of. 237.80 feet to the point of begjnnlng of the
being described; t/:iern:e .lMellterly 240,90 feet to a 1I0int on the
of' said Lot 4,:8Ioc;k .4.,dlstant 32.4>' .feet souther! of the
terly corner of said.,' Lpt . 1 S, ,and there terminoting. Arso, that part'
.ts 2 and 3.. Block 3, 'Eneharited Park. lying northerly ol the westerly
,sion of the -above des~i!)e~ .lIn~ A and lying easterly of the following
'ibed "Line B", and thQt.,part of Lot 15 and 17.. Auditor'. Subdivision
i54 lying easterly'Of tf\e:following. clescrlblld ,"Line 8". LIne B. commencing
e most southerly, cOrrilll: 'of, sC!id . Lot 2. Block 3; thence sC!utherly to the
'southerly comer' of Lot, 1 of '-sold Block 3; thence deflecting 163 degrees
linutes"to the right for.':128.35~ feet tei the intersection with.the westerly
Ision of said "Un$,..A',.. ai"l being the point of beginning; thenCe. continuing
,erIy on last described ,cllur.se. 38.25 feet: thence deflecting 42 degrees
linutes 'to th~. right- 69.?:'+' f"st:.. thence deflecting 20 degr~s ~8 minutes .
Ie' Jef.t, to the northwestedy. -fioe of Lot 15, Auditor's SubdiviSion No. 354,.
there terminating:, Also"', that part 'of Lot 9. Auditor s Subdivision No. 354,
southerly, and southviester'l~ 'of: the southerly shore of Lagoon and adjacent
)ts 15 and 16, said sirbdivlsiori;'1ogethetwlth an easement for private
way as created in DQc!Jinent ~o. 4554064. Subject to an easement for rood
)ses over'said ,Lot 17; :. . '" ",
. ~ . .
, : 'that. part of, Vaed~Mt . Hick~r'y ~one lying no~erly of said "Line A:' was
neluded In the ,obb.ve legal desCription as shown .n Stewart Title Commlttment
iT-28815, doted May' 6,.2,004, 'This ,shol:lld be Q!Xled to the description in order'
,"form to currentitax 'IT1Ops~ '. . .. " . ,
: No ecisements ore listed' In' ~ ab.ove title. eommlttmsnt for this property ,
, than In the legal des~rlp~on.,. ,...,. , .
..::..:....:..., ,.....
.ee Iran'marKer '.. " ":" '.
own ore' based., ~~~: ~n a;isumed datum.
.." .
survey inte~s to' show: the 'baUlldarTes: of the aP9ve' described roperty,
)cation of two existinll' bUildings.. the location of: all visible "hor!cover".
:he propose'd location, df a, .propased garo.ge" and' two proposed additions
on. It does riot. pur.por-t,}a' :show' ony other Improvements or encroachments.
MINNt;TUNKA
Fife ~pt...:,:,
T \Xn-~('oJ~
"
"
" "
" ,
" "
, ,
LOT
14
~SURVEY
/, ., L1NE\
. -..::7,\ )'
, "i.
~
g, PROPOSED ~
. ADDITION
6.17 '
..a
I
I
I~
1C'i
~
\-
Ix
I-
I~r
I
I
I
I
I.
~
I
...1")-,..
... I
EXISTING
17.7
~ ..-
~;
PORCIl
,.
,
, "
"
,
'z
(' \
\ .."
.~If
~
7..
HOUSE
,f45S0
~
l
-----/' /
I I /
I 1/
t",;., W'LY _.-it-
1000lDr II, --____
I --
, / , . , ----.....
I '-<" I --
, > ~ ---
____ t.I Ul' ' I c.;~ 11_ ~ --__
---- ~ ". ..9.-" , it " ' fiI ----.?JZ:.80
'r 14'. .-<.. ...'l ~.p.a ---- - ,... . I. tv--
.... \~~......~..~. ____ ."..... -oJ I
, ~ ____ "'-Sl"XOOC- ____ ::e".- 27.01 ~ _ 34.00' , ..A.I'lE "AN
'~/' ..~ ~:;"---- ~ , I r..,. ( ~~_ "'{ 6:.7 ~ ~,_ 79.00 / ~ -
, y. ., ........', I .-) I
"<", "... " . 2 I .~ I r(\. N 86026' 25" W
, " I (\ I \ \."
, 'II ,':~ I \.,
, , -_ I
", 'I I
" I I
" ',I C, I
, I I~ I
, ;:;', I 1_ r-------
" ~', f ~. f
, i ' I..... I
, ,I () I
{s.~ " <:::1..- I
-"0', I'" I
, I n T ... ~I I -... I
, ....... I !:l I I
" t I I
, I I
" i I I
" I I
I I
" I I
, I 'I
, I' I
)<;; ;:
163o!z,. ''::''~-M'\''''''/
\ ,...eU I
~ /
I
IU :I
PAll)
,.',,:\'
, 'Mi!- Qo,I,\.oW). I
...,., 'I FW +v,,, QI""..J ;l'iClI O>C" "'2.
.(M . l;lt:.'" "I'~ ' 7
"",Je""'''''' ......l.tu,.......;..J "13ll"O~\~.j- "2
, . l':llA . ,. . .
T~.s..1 t-\..,Jc.-. ISIU~ - Co";"", ~~~l' ,~n'O't S\~~ I.
he_^ F'..... 1Io'.Ic....- 1.0, 0' I
n~~~ '. "'~ 'loa ,,, '
1107'." .\UO. = .. . /
\'l,"~O , "
(,/
Mi,,';''''') IJ4'1G~, .f
q/2.7 Ie!. .,'
./
_/
.....
Z :t.Ui,
"'" .:U
""DJ~,;
t!J III ::!:;:
~, ~ I!~"t
- ,;
m E:J 6~ l;l
Z ~.!;O>
O,I!~
o OJ .~
~ UJ iz'
t!J <~~
Co>
70.99
-.......
241.54__ 240.90__
302.89
EXISTING
HOUSE
It-\
,',~.
"' <
9~h '~
~ g<, 'i' 1I
,C~ d'
l-
t)
W
-:>
o
tt:
(L
!i~ ~I
Ii! ~
lig >,1:
~~'its , !
~h~\5
>-i!i~ ~
' ~!l!>I. ,'" '"
1':'~~ \ ,
~fil<! ..
"~~5 ~ .:.
!5l~~ . l!!
~~~. ~
II~ I~
~
I
'Ii I
I II
,I U
J I ~
Exhibit B
PROPERTY SURVEY
REVISED HARDCOVER CALCULATIONS :
Total lot area.. 60,600 Sq. ft.
Existing House (wi th two proposed additions)
Deck at shoreline .. 321 sq. ft.
Blacktop Driveway .. 7~' 2 sq. ft.
Porch ... 342 sq. ft.
Patio .. 100 sq. ft.
. Proposed Garage .. 768 sq. ft.
.. S86S sq. ft.
Total hardcover'" 6,1 09 Sq. ft.
14.696 I 60.600 x 100 .. 24.93"
.
.
.
.
.
~,
'4
ll.
j ~
p ,
III
r
I I
~ I
I
,;5i11 j vI
~;"J'~ ~
O-J':.
" :;;;
It
'-1
I
e..__-_
~
?,
I'\}
1...l
: ~
:_"u
;~
-
,/
(l:.~,
.'0
:1':,
, l,
:<1
'?
,Ill
, ~')
-,
; ill
;?t
,
, --
i..::S'
i!0
\~..
'~
~
:::.=:. i
"Q;
t. ~
-.....;..
~~\
~
'~
. .c_,:.;,
~
p
:~
, .....,
; (.~. \
''-;',"
j
,UJ
.f
""::S
Q
-.i
=>
\Jll
5
~
~
l~j
rl
'~,I-"
f
"
.~
,~''''
Q
-
"
\)}
t1J
~.
---r
\\ \
~
\l
..:t..
""'l
'-:J.
~,'
p,
J
lS)
CJ \-\
'- ~.
,,~ t \
"~ ~
\, \:\ l
i"'-.J \..'i/
" -.-
~
"':;L.
cr-
.....,.
./
.Eo-
".";)
"i;\
~,
~:~~.
.::;:-..-
r'j
~'..;
~
<'"
'"J>
,\
\,1
~
~
=r
_ti
i
;~?
<~,..
,\, \
-u)
-=r
'.J
..---
-'-
L-
I
Exhibit C
PROPOSED ELEVATIONS -
LAKE AND DRIVEWAY
.
.
.
il
;]
.
.
-:::.
\)
. l
-......
l\
~.
~
4-,
Q
~.
"'t
")
uJ
;j
ill
J
ll.1 .
7
.,..
2
~
1
\j:
~
t:-
~
-.J.
1\
--
-~
'S:
-
"
\i.
=-.."
~
r
':1;;,
~,
..;;..
111
\j
'-:f
~
:1
-
::;:5
ill
.~
B
tlJ
~- I
"',,,,,~../,
.~
1/:....... ,-
i:
!. II j'
,l,.-,~
"~~'''''i
\ \~
-..':...-
.,n
ill
s:L
~\\
15\~
J
~
-(
/
~-'"
~\ ~\
'0 ":."
i '\
..- \;,.'~
;~ ()
\,,~ ~-
'" t--!J
/
'----
\3"
\Sl
~)
~
~.-....
'\""'~'''')
~r-
-----.;.,;..
. S.....
,,~, '\
I ~;)
,~. 'I...
4~-
-<')=-
~-1
..:.,,,,..\0
:r
\
,""",:a",..--
4~~~
f\}j
<.1;;-:,.
=[
eJ
>, -
~
~
L
Exhibit D ELEVATIONS _
PROPOSED
WEST AND NORTH
'1--'
\1
\,,;..
1
.
~
1"",;
<C,"!"""'" ~
->"''i-
~_..~
~q
\J
~
.....'-r
Dc6 PAtlC:1A
LOUYe_ WI HeEC:T 6C:::IIE
. ""'" BAFPU!
c:c:NT. ~ YEMT
-/
/
tJ~
1)(4 ovetIt DCa oveJt Ix. 9/
FA6I::IA . ltAKI P9llC.I. /.
..............,.. I: /1
!d/ ~. 0
d:J,'/
. ,
~'.
Jrm[: ~~ ~
~
~
~I::::
~~M
~
~
\>
IX4 M" oae;A.eC;1,4
1)(.""'.. I!IO)d!DQUT6'
.
..
~$~
~... IIlOClC nu1
")(to WClOC_6lLL
I
I
I
~:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
III I
ti
/
,
..
A
E~~
M
~
/
n
a::wT. RlCIOI WN'I
I
...
~
/~
~ ~~"
~I::::
I::::
iT
/
-l /
I /
I /
1/
I /
}/
-q__, -~.f
t::::::j ITIJII[ !A~
$-
,
" r-
, I
" I
, I
, I
'"
I'
I ,
I '
I:::: ....--
\.\": '<(
~
~~
~~ ~ ''''' :;=
... IlIIiXO nIlH
I2xG TrlMR
~ ~~
. - . -
I
I
I
I
I
----------------~~-----
----------------~------
-- -
-~-
Em:::
I III/ .
11111 i::L-
I
I
I
1
-------1
-------'"
HIll
- i--
'--~iICl2 T....
-'"
~ ":'1 :
I ~ .Ii :
j;RJ;: : :
~I :
1-' - -- - =,- -I--
,--------'
! 11\ F~T ELEVATION
\!:}.) 1/4' ~'.(J'
.. PI,\I6lol Q\l'I-..u:>> ClOCI'6
lUf ..........'ICl TJU1
CQNT, IIIClC3II VlMT
2
..
lie" OVI. >><18 ...uclA
...
eo.
.t
. .
. .
.'
1
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I - -- I -
- r=-= - -- .::....r-
'-- - - __ -.l
--. -.5m -
~ <:.:-..:...-,..;.E 1IE3~-
~ ~~~I~}lEVATION
.
'\JM
.
'\JM
,f^~
I ~~'\
1/ ~~
A"^ ~~
~ ,",;=' lli."~~
/'1 ~ ,,~
I t5J __
f-'!i:7
.
. - . . -
.
'\J..
nnn
....,.,.,....."""~_ .1. ~I:::: I)~ /7
=':'Am ~ ~ ~ \ <(]" /'
~, ~ /~+. '~ ,;~;;/
-p - mE8 · mO' E I -{l~_~
~i-- '-- ----, I
E:::::::: ~ ,/.--.- '3
.~""-HQ. ~ ~
- - - - ~- - - '. ---
. - . .-
,. .....F.....oo.~cur.,
~'J;.
-
-
.
. . - . -
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
"cur .
I ·
h
YK
~ '--
It'"
.~ -
... . - -
- . -
Q.ATI'L'I!w-c.:ne
IO'QI1"TCN!~'"
2 "" . CUT 6TClNI IHLCIllI
"
RE-1U1.0 IDCl6TM11 CloIMNI,.
~
~~Ult~'"
_LOCI........."'....._..
\..
-
-
ill
(j
Z
ill
D
(j)
w
oc~
2
w
{}!Z2
().- ~
u., 'L.
~ <1 .
z "l a
::i 11- ()
~<1~
() "'l ~
1: ()
~UJi
r
No. RC'f/lawe Oul.
~n
Exhibit E
HOME ELEVATION. FRONT
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474.0128. www.ci.shorewood.mn.us. cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
. FROM:
DATE:
RE:
FILE NO,
.
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen
26 October 2005
Catain C.D.P. - Revised Site Plan
405 (05,23)
.
Michael Catain's application for a conditional use permit was continued from the October
Planning Commission meeting to the 1 November meeting, pending his submission of a revised
site plan for the project. The revised plan is attached for your review. As described by the
applicant's builder at the initial public hearing, the garage has been shifted approximately 20 feet
to the south to address concerns from the neighboring property owner regarding sight lines to the
lake.
Staffs recommendation remains the same as the 29 September 2005 staff report.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Michael Catain
Michael Hayes
Chad McKenney
.
f"~
tJ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
LAKE
.
R
IN
" AUD. SUB. NO. 354
'4, BLOCK 4, ENCHANTED PARK
A
^.....
/ .....
/ ..........
/ .....
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
I
/
/
/
/
I.
I.
929.4 CONTOUR LINE.........
.
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
....--
........
-........
Original location
(shown shaded)
10..
PROPOSED ~
ADDITION
.
location
~
r~
;..,
~ EXISTING 7.4,
, ,..
'4550 i
.
,
,
,
, /
, -----7 /
" I /
, " I I /
~~ I 1/1
"'-0 " I.-W'LT--.ll-
~ l'J JOFLOT II -.--fi,.---__
...- .-3 t.l I I -
-- _ , en. ' I . 'I ----
~ ~, I ~J ---_
...- ...- ~ ~ ~', I < lfr:T'lo ----
...- ~i'~t~Olj~ >t""\ " . ~ ~ ...f,- ------~7.80
~.. _~tl'~i'-< ~. Ii ...- ...-.. ,~-..i I ,~---
......~.$:Ijl.\!lOOc....- :=E '. ~-- 27.01"':--..-- 34.00. If /-LINE "A"
/I'€ ...- i i......... , -.... .' 79.00
.I ...- ! I -....... ,I >_ '-'_
If ...- I I I ---'_ -..J ''''-_' I
Y /' , L. Or I ! ::5 !
, '\ '") I _...... I
" I "'- I (~ J
, i J :;:= I
',\ I -l. I
',i I I
, I J J
,1 J C' I
, \ I l:;j I
~1', I I- ,--------
, ...\ , I~. I
(Il!' J .... I
~i ' I () I
I i ',-, -x- I
i I::..... 1
_i 1 1 1
~i 1 1
:.\ 1 1
"',i J J
I / "j
ill
i J J
, 1//
',/""1 J 1
/\. ;11 1
i '~j{ 1
163-&7' ,~..... S'LV COR 1
~ : ""CF LOT 1 I
\ f "otX~ ,
'..... ! 1
"s..; 1
f I
EXISTING
HOUSE
..'~JJ. .
~.
-... .....-
70.99
r,\
\ \..-
\.'
N 86026' 25" W
241.54_ 240.90_
302.89
.
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
7ft'
il'o',
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
= 5826 sq. ft.
LOT
REVISED HARDCOVER CALCULATIONS :
Total lot' area = . 60,600 Sq. ft.
Existing House (with two proposed additions)
Deck at shoreline = 321 sq. ft.
Blacktop Driveway = 7404 sq. ft.
Porch = 342 sq. ft.
Patio = 100 sq. ft.
Proposed Garage = 768 sq. ft.
Total hardcover = 14,761 Sq. ft.
14,761 / 60,600 x 100 = 24.36%
MINNETONKA
"f(,)
.______SURVEY
/ LINE \
i__ \
"'..... :
-' ji j
~/
___ b,t
-r=-----..
I
I
I~
I~
\-
1:1:
I-
I~
I
I
I
I
I
....
PORCH
PAllO
........, 929.4
'CONTOUR '
L.tlE
a
z
(
l!I
~
bJ
m
Z
C
~
l!I
~
'"
o
I
N
N'
I
'"
f-
U
W
J
o
0:::
D-.
l~~
"~15
~a
~~w
Iii
~Jj
lt~o
~~~
~!!h.
>1DB
l!:oc
~h
>-~-
i~i
2-
~
i
I
>-
01
..
U~
"i ~ 1
w'
!;:
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
FOR ADDITIONAL ACCESSORY SPACE
TO MICHAEL CATAlN
WHEREAS, Michael Catain (Applicant) is the owner of real property located at 4550
Enchanted Point, in the City of Shorewood, County of Hennepin, legally described in Exhibit
A, attached hereto and made a part hereof; and
WHEREAS, the Shorewood City Code requires a Conditional Use Permit for the
construction of accessory space exceeding 1200 square feet; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a Conditional Use Permit for
the construction of a dettached garage which, when combined with other accessory space on
the site will amount to more than 1200 square feet; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the City Phinner, and his
recommendations were duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated 29
September 2005, which memorandum is on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, after required notice, a public hearing was held and the application was
reviewed by the Planning Commission at their regular meeting on 4 October 2005, the
minutes of which meeting are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was considered by the City Council at their
regular meeting on 28 November 2005, at which time the Planner's memorandum and the
minutes of the PlaJ.ming Commission were reviewed and comments were heard by the Council
from the City staff.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The total area of accessory space (1519 square feet) does not exceed the floor area
above grade of the principal structure (5866 square feet),
2. The Applicant's lot contains approximately 60,000 square feet of area, and that the
total area of accessory space on the property will not exceed 10% of the minimum lot area for
the R-IC/S Zoning District in which it is located (2000 square feet).
3, The design and materials ofthe garage are compatible with the architectural
character of the existing home.
-1-
.
.
.
.
.
4. The proposed garage complies with all setback requirements for the R-IC/S
District.
CONCLUSION
1. That the application of Michael Catain for a Conditional Use Permit as set
forth herein above be and hereby is granted.
2. That this approval is subject to the following:
a. The proposed garage will be used strictly for purposes of a residential
nature.
b.
The Applicant is hereby advised that the City Code provides specific
regulations relative to home occupations and any future use of the
garage for other than allowable residential purposes would have to
comply with such regulations.
3. That the City Administrator/Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to provide
a certified copy of this Resolution for filing with the Hennepin County Recorder or Registrar
of Titles.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL ofthe City of Shorewood this 28th day of
November 2005.
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
-2-
.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PREMSIES :
Lot 16, Auditor's Subdivision No. 354, Hennepin County, Minnesota, and that
part of Lot 4, Block 4, ENCHANTED PARK, Hennepin County, Minnesota, lying
northerly of the following described line, hereinafter refered to as "Line. A";
Commencing at the most westerly corner of. Lot. ..16, Auditor' s Subdivision
No. 354,Hennepin County, Minnesota; thence easterly along the southerly line
of said Lot 16 a distance of 237.80 feet to the point of beginning of the
a;>roperty being described; thence westerly 240.90 feet to a point on the
Wvvesterly line or said Lot 4, Block 4, distant 32.4 feet southerly of the
most westerly corner of said Lot 16, and there terminating. Also. that part
of Lots 2 and 3, Block 3. Enchanted Park, lying northerly of the westerly
extension of the above described line A and lying easterly of the following
described "Line B", and that part of Lot 15 and 17, Auditor' Subdivision
No. 354 lying easterly of the following described "Line B". Line B, commencing
at the most southerly corner of said Lot 2, Block 3; thence southerly to the
. most southerly corner of Lot 1 of said Block 3; thence deflecting 163 degrees
27 minutes to the right for 128.35 feet to the intersection with the westerly
extension of said "Line A' , and being the point of beginning; thence continuing
northerly on last described course 38.25 feet; thence deflecting 42 degrees
17 minutes to the right 69.74 feet; thence deflecting 20 degrees 58 minutes
to the left, to the northwesterly line of Lot 15, Auditor's Subdivision No. 354,
and there terminating. Also that part of Lot 9, Auditor's Subdivision No. 354,
lying southerly and southwesterly of the southerly shore of Lagoon and adjacent
eto Lots 15 and 16, said subdivision, together with an easement for private
driveway as created in Document No. 4554064. Subject to an easement for road
purposes over said Lot 17.
NOTE: that part of Vacated Hickory Lane lying northerly of said "Line A" was
not included in the above legal description as shown in Stewart Title Committment
No. ST -28815, dated May 6, 2004. This should be added to the description in order
to conform to current tax maps.
NOTE: No easements are listed in the above title committment for this property
other than in the legal description.
.
Exhibit A
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128 . www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
. Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
.
DATE:
26 October 2005
RE:
Guidinger, Mark - Conditional Use Permit for Fill In Excess of
100 Cubic Yards
FILE NO.:
405 (05.25)
.
BACKGROUND
.
Mark Guidinger is the owner ofthe property at 19735 Muirfield Circle (see Site Location
map - Exhibit A, attached). He proposes to build a swimming pool in his rear yard
which will necessitate up to 400 cubic yards of fill to create a level area for the pool.
Shorewood's zoning regulations require a conditional use permit for fill in excess of 100
cubic yards. Mr. Guidinger has requested a c.u.P. and a public hearing has been
scheduled for 1 November 2005.
Exhibit B shows the location of the pool and retaining wall system as it is proposed on
the lot. At staffs request, the applicant has provided a cross-section drawing (Exhibit C)
illustrating how the retaining walls, pool and house relate to the existing grade. The fill
material will be confined by two boulder retaining walls, four to six feet in height,
terraced with a four-foot wide landscaped area between the walls. The lower of the two
walls is approximately 50 feet from the rear property line. The applicant's engineer has
provided a written plan for how the retaining walls should be constructed (see Exhibit D).
.
The property is zoned P.U.D., Planned Unit Development (Single-Family), and contains
approximately 26,361 square feet of area. The lot is characterized by a significant drop
in elevation at the rear of the existing home. While the area immediately behind the
home is relatively open, the southeasterly portion of the lot is quite heavily wooded.
ft
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
-# B. Ep
.
.
.
.
.
Memorandum
Re: Guidinger CUP
26 October 2005
ANALYSIS/RECOMMENDATION
Shorewood's Zoning Code requires a conditional use permit whenever more than 100
cubic yards of material is brought on to a site. This equates to approximately 10 dump
truck loads of dirt. Issues associated with these types of request are typically engineering
related. Consequently, the plans were forwarded to the City's engineering consultant,
WSB. Steve Gurney has reviewed the plans relative to grading, drainage and the
structural aspect of the proposed retaining walls, and his recommendations are included
in his report, dated 26 October 2005 (Exhibit E).
Grading. Mr. Gurney's report addresses the engineering issues associated with the
applicant's plans for grading. From a City Code perspective, the main issue is the effect
of the grading and filling on the existing trees on the site. As mentioned earlier in this
report the area proposed to be altered is relatively open and will result in little tree
removaL The applicant proposes to maintain significant tree cover in the rear 50 feet of
the property.
Drainage. Again, this issue has been addressed by Mr. Gurney. It is worth noting that
the Pollution Control Agency recommends that pool drainage be conducted to the
sanitary sewer system unless the pool water has not been treated for at least seven days.
While it is fairly common practice to drain pools to streets and ultimately into the storm
system, this should not be allowed for any pool. A letter from a concerned resident to the
east is attached as Exhibit F. Mr. Gurney's letter addresses the concerns of the resident.
Any approval ofthe conditional use permit should be subject to the recommendations of
the City's Consulting Engineer. It is also recommended that the applicant prepare a
landscape plan for the area between the two retaining walls. Landscaping should include,
but need not be limited to, evergreen plant materials.
Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Mark Guidinger
Hans Free
-2-
~:
i
$
~
i
".
I
~
i
i
'l'
~
~
ill
,~
i
,}j
i
i
<:~
_J~
~i
::I:~
=~
~i
SIl$
Q.lj;
I
j
~
~
~
O~~
::;:l~
'<'"
;{;
2.~
3:!i
_..~
:J!
~i ,.
o~~
~
SIll
~
~~
g1j
-',
I
~
1\1
i
~
~
'h
,~
~
'i-~
t'il
I
~
~
:}:
Ell
,~
:{~
009 osz
.
o
z
O.
_P-i
E-c'
<~
UU
<e:O~
..... ' bJj
.- - ~
~~;a
..c E-i .-
>< _ ::l
j:ilood
y
N
a>te1 SeWlSIJlI::>
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
6005"~:O'2,~sl'~(
, ...' .:'1. ._
.. . . --
,,/.
../
...
,
'"
~
::l
. .,.
FOR: 'STG'INE'I2" R: ltOPPL~MAN
Prepared By:
SCHOELL & MADSON, INC.
Engineers. Surveyors. Planners. Solis TestIng
" ::'l 10550 Wayzata Boulevard
""......~? Mlnnetonka. Mn. 55343
Tel. 546-7601
,.' EY
~
:".
r /\ /.~
'" ;t) (,."
'. ~) ,\,...,
\ .. l rt-. ~.'i.!'
/ :vi '\ .
,~t'
~:.
......
" .
1.(,"
.(. .....
if oC\-'
-!?
GENERAL NOTES:
)
)
3)
4)
'S)
6)
7)
8)
. _ Denotes iron monument found.
c - Denotes wood stake.
x9S6.0 - Denotes existihg spot "
elevation. \ ~_.
x(985.6) - Denotes proposed. spot / ....~J.o..
elevation. DESCRIPTION:
" .
. ..: :.' ~'':: .
: .~~.~.
.. .....
'1~
~ - Denotes direction of
surface drainage.
Proposed top of foundation
elevation = 1003.0.
Proposed garage floor elevation =
1002.6.
proposed basement floor elevation x
993.2.
t2eY, od.', l'\'O!.l-o ':5onow poC"'ch \ dec:.\<s.~ dl"'\le.
Lot 12, Block 1, WATERFORD 2KD ,ADDITIQN.
BENCHMARK:
SpiKe in 'lath in lO-inch oak tree:'as ";':,
shown. Elevation. 1003.0 (NGVD-1929Y~','"
I hereby certify that this survey was prepared under my supervision and that y..,.
. am I Li censed Land Surveyor under the laws o!{jfe Sbat~ of H{j~la. ". ,.,' /.... ,,":',
Date: September 20. 1988 ~~..R". ~ /~,.rd~., . ..
Theodore D. Kemna . Exhibit B
land Surveyor MH Lie. No.. SITE
. PLAN
JUN-22-2004 rUE 11:37AM 10:
p (- '-.,'1\ 1 ....1 \......c-rr-C\ "'.
'f~.',:, \~~J'"'1;.'.) \..J (':> \ OC;i: :'",L ."j '\,\:, X"'; :~ _.1..' V -..".
\
1,
'\
~
-<
>
~
-<
~
I
Z
o
""""
E-<
U
~
U~
.....00
,- 00
:90
...c~
&jU
~._.__._-_..,.._...,~..",
--
/
.,/
(/ , , . ---..... '..''''). ,. --" "-'''n' ..",..-. ..'. '.'i).'.'. ''" ..... -'.""'7'~. -;'."'). -,....~_.':J...,._-'.--.'J-.,- .....--,.7.. .'.."; . ~._
. ,. C,.)~I)~.._IG~I).C~""JC, "f~:{;,:;:q.-';="'1.'. ~-:c~;",~-,'7~:F"E~i>-";;"''''0.L.(.,~"~...'....., '0 ~",,;?(!.}':~":i"'~:'.' .Jt...V,S~~':", ~~,:,;Js....~..,~\. ,\<~.:,,;X;~,s.\;,1k'':)>>~'''';
~~b. .,>,.. ,.
. -'Jt-~.~'"'"""_ -",.' '. {..I ~ (,,' -.. _' -r:'''..-.~._,,'"-:~r..--.....__. () ,). >f.._-r,~Jl,~t~ ..(L\....., (J \1.....,....\..1....,." .
I .' 1-' .~, d',,', (~,,' " \: ";(t~,'i>,1.,,,,l,~"\~..,,.t;t~' ''';e' '.,",,'." .(i''1' L tb:"",~-->.J,I,,:-';0\"';.':';"" ~~I,..J~~r-;"'!1.f)"''). \,.. ~.,"'~)
\,;;, (.,~\... :;~..\~::~~~::.i~{~'''''' (i;(":~:~(:~I~"~!;P;r~~(~-~)C~:ci!~~~~:\~~"~)(i~";\'~~i:i::;;T~,l..5.~)~ZJ~~~~~j; ~~,.,>,:?~z\*~{?~~st~;;:~f!
'0 J '~l / ,L~c'r"""'''''\h,\.....t'C'''h'''{~'-'''O''''"'''''C-"'''"-''';''''''.fi~'''~~C_",..,""(',,,-,......, ,}, 1 . l' .,'. th t) . .. lJ 0 II \....::(."...'w\) {~ C:l l~\) j
.'~::,(il'r~(;;~j''-''''{'>'''i. \,L,\.~\..,.l<;~;:,\.. c'," 9', ,;f..,....'~', . .....' "''- '"'.',.;"'., '''' ";.'" '.": ~_."'.c -''-.'''''--'' '-"~'"'r),
V t?:t"
i
c
f"O~~ ""'W~.
.'3=3'1-r1~
(
, IGl
.. .. k 0"1t
_ """lO~J
- 1I11l-
~- "(;),
-'
:.-------~.
n~\>~
~'~5 , \ - \\l~/,
.
.
.
.
-zj';;;1J\@? ~
~J..~'~
~
,'8 ,.
~\JO~' c;.~ott7
(~ "
(.-_...,
.
.
.
.'
.
",on .....UI'i.::>UI....I J.1'i~
t-'A(:jl=. ~LIl:j4
KBH CONSULTING; INC.
P31irD~MsciiiUiiiOWili:'o:wner"""'-"''''''''-''-'Y'''''''-''''''''''''''''....................................M....................M...............__M.........--...................................
October 5,2005
(Revised October 7,2005)
Hans Frees
Outdoor Excapes
6980 Oxford street:, #100
St.Louis Park, MN55426
RE: Boulder Retaining Design P~eters
19735 Muirfield Circle
Shorewood, Minnesota
KBHNo. 2005.103
Dear Mr. Frees;
Geos)1rthetic reinforcement :fabric (geogrid) should be installed as follows:
For the lower wall., place geogrid to a length of 1.67 times the wall height (lO'long for a 6' high
wall) at each course of boulders due to the surcharge loading of the upper wall on the lower wall.
For the upper wall, place 4.5' geogrid at each course of boulders.
Using a select granular sand backfi1J would dec:rease tho geagrid lengths behind the bottom walt to
lengths of 1.25 times the wall height.
Special note should be made of the wall embedment depth and the geosynthetic fabric (geo-grid) length as
measured. from the front face of the wall. 'Refer to industry standard pmctice references for installation
information, specifications, and details.
KBH CODSI.11ting. Inc.
7226 39th Street North. Suite 100
Oakdale, MN 55128
(n51) 779-7700
Exhibit D
APPLICANT'S ENGINEER'S LETTER
Dated 7 October 2005
.
.
.
.
.
".wI i \..JUI "1..:JUL- I J.1"tl.:l
t"'Al:li=. l::J.::l/~4
19735 Muirfield Circle, Shorewood, Minne:sota
October 5,2005 (Revised October 7. 2005)
, Page 2
Boulders shall be placed to avoid continuous joint planes in vertical or lateral directions.
Each boulder shall bear on two or more rocks below it with good flat-to-fiat contact.
Place a 4" diameter couugated perforated draintile with sock at the finished grade ofwalls. Outlet
the draintile at 50' on-cerny( and at low points along the walL
Compact any structural fill place behind the drainage zone to 95% standard proctor.
Drainage stone shall consist of clean 1" minus crushed stone (100% passing 1", 75-100% passing
%").
The design of the wall system assumes the following:
Soil conditioti.s: Silt/clay, fiiction angle = 28.0 degrees, unit weight of 125.0 Ib/ft3
- Allowable soil bearing capacity "'" 1,500 psf
- No external surcharge loadlng behind walls
Slope at bottom of lower wall"'" 4: 1; slope at top :;;; 10: 1
Slope at top and bottom of upper wall = 10: 1
Minimum embedment depth = 6"
Boulder Type: 24"-36" (base courses); 12"-24" (upper cou11!es); retaining wall specific boulders
Geosynthetic Fabric Type: Mirafi 3XT OJ" equivalent
Direct all surface c1rainaSe away from the wall. The wall design was performed using the design
guidelines presented in the second addition of the "'Design Manual for Segmental Retaining Walls"
(DMSRW) published by NCMA in 1996. If soil conditions, proposed wall1ayoots, or other design
parameters vary from thai assumed, a revised analysis may be needed. Please call me if you have any
questions or need more infonnation. Thank you.
S~ff~..
,
Paulo'Schimnowski, PE
MN #40126
KBH Consulting. Inc.
7226 39th Street North, Suite 100
Oakdale, MN S5128
(651) 779-7700
.
.
.
.
.
I '''-'I I '-''-'I "-''-II...,. I ..LI'.....
rH\,:Il:. tJ4l t:l4
19735 Muirfield Circle, Shorewood, Minnesota
October 5, 2005 (Revised October 7, 2005)
Page 3
;DESIGN P.A.RAMETERS AN>> PROVISION'S
1. REFER TO BOULDER RETAINING WALL INDUSTRY STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS.
2. SEE PRODUCT MANUF AC'I'URER INSTALLATION RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CONSTRUCTION
SEQUENCE AND INSTALLATION NOTES.
3. NO PRODUCfIMATElUAL SUBSnnmONS Wll.l. BB ALLOWED WIlHOur PRIOR WlUTI'EN
PERMISSION OF KBH CONSULTING, INC.
4. OWNER OR OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ENSUlUNG '!HE CONDmONS
STATED HEREIN ARE ACCURATE PRIOR TO AND DURING CONSTRUCTION. NOTIFY KBH
CONSULTING, INe.IN WRITING OF ANYDISCREPANClES OR CHANGES TO THE CONDmONS
SHOWN ON 11fESE DOCUMENTS.
5. REFER TO WALL ELEV AllON NOTES FOR W.AJ.L SURCHARGE LOADINGS AND SLOPES AT TOP
AND BOTTOM OF W ALL(S). REFER TO W AJ.L CALCULATIONS FORBEARING CAPACITY
REQt.l1:RBMEl\iTS:
6. FINAl, SITE GRADES AND ROOF DRAINS SHALL DIRECT RUNOFF AWAY FROM ANY
RETAINING WALLS.
7. KBH CONSULTIN'G,lNC. ASSUMES NO LIABlllTYFOR INTERPRETATION OF SUBSURFACE
CONDITIONS, SUITABILITY OF SOn. DESIGN PARAMETERS AND lNI'ERPRETATIONS OF
SUBSURFACE GROUNDWATER CONDITIONS.
8. THE OWNER OR OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CONTACTING THE W.AlL
DESIGN BNGINEER 'l'O SCHEDULE A 8m VISIT PlUOR TO THE START OF :aLOCK PLACEMENT.
9. THE WALL DESIGN WAS PERFORMED USING DESIGN GUIDELINES PRESENTED IN THE SECOND
EDITION OF THE "DESIGN MANUAL FOR SEGMENTAL RETAINING WALLS" (DMSRW). PUBLISHED
BYNCMAIN 1996.
10. THE PESIGN OF TIITS RETAINING WALL WAS BASED UPON lNFORMATION NOlED ON TIm
KEY PLAN.
11. nIB INFORMATION PROVIDED wmnN TEESE DOCUMENTS IS FOR TIlE STRUCTURAL
DESIGN OF THE PROPOSED W ALL(S) ONLY. THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AND/OR WORK RELATED
TO HANDRAILS, GUARDRAILS, OR OTHER LIFE/SAFETY ISSUES ARE EXCLUDED FROM THESE
DOCUMENTS AND ARE '1'0 BE PROVlDED BY OTHERS.
12. RESPONSIBILITY FOR. GLOBAL/SLOPE STABILITY RESTS wrm THE SITE CIVIL OR
GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEER..
KBH Consulting, Inc.
7226 39th Street North, Suite 100
Oakdale, MN 55128
(651) 779-7700
.
. WSB
& Associates, Inc.
Memorandum
To:
Brad Nielsen, City of Shorewood
Steve Gurney, P.E., WSB & Associates, lnc. Y
October 26, 2005
From:
Date:
Re:
J9735 MuirfieldCircle
Conditional Use Permit Review
City of Shorewood, MN
WSB Project No, J 459-04
.
.
We have reviewed the grading plan submittal, dated October 7, 2005 and prepared by Frank
Cardarelle, for construction of a swimming pool at 19735 Muirfield Circle. In addition, a.letter
outlining the design parameters for a boulder retaining wall, dated October 7, 2005 and prepared
by KBH Consulting, Inc. was reviewed. Based on this review, we have the following comments:
"
Boulder Retaining Wall
1.
In addition to the design parameters outlined in the design memo, it is recommended
that the following items be incorporated into the plan:
a. Place a six inch (minimum) compacted base under walls
b. Provide 12 inches of free draining aggregate behind wall system for drainage
.
2. The construction requirements must be shown on a construction plan signed by a
Registered Engineer, registered in the State of Minnesota.
3. It is recommended that, as a condition of the building permit, the Engineer submit an
as-built drawing certifying that the wall was constructed according to the construction
plan.
Site Drainage
1. The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency recommends that, when draining swimming
pools, the water pumped from the swimming pool be discharged to the sanitary
.
Exhibit E
WSB RECOMMENDATIONS
Letter from Steve Gurney,
Dated 26 October 2005
.
.
.
.
.
Brad Nielsen, City of Shorewood
October 26, 2005
Page 2
sewer, or, alternatively, the water be held for a week or more (after treatment has
stopped) before discharging to a pervious area.
2.
Should the homeowner discharge to pervious areas in the back of their own
residential lot, the runoff will flow approximately 500 feet to the pond located on
Outlot A, which outlets to the south. The anticipated flow path is shown on the
attached contour map of the area.
3.
Because the rate of flow would be relatively minor, it is anticipated that the runoff
will most likely infiltrate into thegro:und before it reaches the pond.
4.
Surface water runoff also would be improved slightly by this project. Under existing
conditions, the runoff from the hill will be conveyed directly off-site, eventually
flowing to the pond on Outlot A. With the proposed construction, runoff from the
area surrounding the pool will collect within the pool area rather than be conveyed
down the hill to the pond.
Attachment
cc: Larry Brown, P .E., City of Shorewood
C:\DOCllnJCllts ami Seuillgs\wsb.WSBLT-03J\DesklopIMEMO.., hI/ie/sell.., 10:6Q5.doc
,'" \\\ \~'\, ~~~~"--
.""~~ ,~~~~'~~..~ -- r
~, ,k' ,~~ sse ~ ~ OJ
~~ L~'~~'~" ~*) .~\Q L i//flr~
_ L........, .t"'-''- - ---' ~ ~./ ~-~~
" _-"" ,-;:'-d' ., · ~ /' I -
~,-,-"" / -r~m · · '--[---: - -= -? --=' .~~
"' :::s:~,f _ .. ~=---o~
~~l _ ~~~--\t ~
~\~% Q ~ ~
~ _~ _ _-=====.= III .. Q \I T;~
, . ' _ ' _ ......, ",,," L ~ --= "'~
~ r-- '/ ~
~_ \ J~~-.c--- ,,;" ::,r!Arlig~
i _,11"'-- '-----~~ ~/~ -
r--cl J _("/ a-....: '- "1t. 1/,
=; ,~ - - ~ '/ /'
,~~~\I['-"'f~ ~~ Y=.-- _ - .Jr-!, It v " ~. ,A
~~,'t(' \'C~~ " \-' ' ~,r- I u '/~ ,U:
\' ~~ "'~'" ",~ ',_ _ ,__ rlJ/.~ a ~
~~ ~ so ,," ~ ,,~~~:L~'" >r'\- ^, i~ ~ 0<,.
'- v 'I \ 1:)'<0 ~.~ ~ y ~~~~ ~J~ f\\ ,;.. ) 'j ....'
,..........rx~~~/ Wj"". === \.... &..~ -~~ J2(~'
'-...'--~ . + .. _~ ~ ~ I ., ~
~.~SlkN r__~ ~...,~ ~ " ~~\' fj~~1
~ ~~ " ~~ ,--,4 ! ~,-..~ 1\ ,,~" lQ'" ,
, ~ . . 'sr, :;:-....,,-,,-\\\' ~L_ --r~ \ ) ." ..~ ~ "'"
, ~ i'{ _'""'/ ~ :::;:,"'" "y ~ ~ [fi" - - ~~'~ ""'"
~
~ ~ ~~~~~ ' }/:.'.~: .. 6>>\ ~'\..~:-... ~_'-.# \~~~ ~~
" ~ " ~ ,,~. ,~ ~". y .;A ....:,%' J, -"1 \\\~
::-...--. ~ ~,,_y ., " ~ ~ -, -1l~ ~ ;'. ,-" ~ ~
':"'~'V ,,' · " tJ "I, We.........' I\. \\' \ I G 1, "'. \,'" , ~
.j :v> "",:<0-~ 1>. I g;: " '. ,'. ~~
~ ) \
~~\
/;,~ .,~:\ + ~
~
~
-
-l
.
.
.
.
.
RON JOHNSON
October 22, 2005
5355 Shady Hill Circle
Shorewood, MN 5533 I
Craig W. Dawson
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
r- RECEIVED
OCT 2 5 2005
Re: Proposed In-Ground Pool at 19735 Muirfield Circle
Dear Mr. Dawson:
CITY OF SHOREWOOO",
Due to unprofessional Shorewood planning, the current City administration's
misconduct, arid City Code ~ 904.09, reluctantly I am forced to object to the proposed
pool as adversely impacting my (posted) 20 acre hobby farm property and backyard.
According to your October 18, 2005 letter the property owner of 19735 Murfield Circle
must first make arrangement with me to pay for the perpetual pool drainage disposals to
my property as City Code ~ 904.09 precludes pool drainage to the City's sanitary sewer
system. Pool overland drainage would be diverted to my property southwest parcel by
the Waterford stump landfill the City's planners placed on my property without my
consent. Also without my consent, Murfield Circle and other public waters enter my
private drainage ditch resulting in perpetual flooding and my perpetual clean up and ditch
maintenance. Flood frequency and volumes increase with each new adjoining land
developments in a creeping taking.
My objection would not have occurred had you and other members of Mayor Love's
administration followed former Mayor Dahlberg's leadership and action plan I agreed to
in overly reasonable compromise on my part.
To create the Waterford Pond the City's planners dammed my ditch to impound public
storm sewage. I Judge Ann D. Montgomery - - ordering the City to pay U.S. Constitution
Fifth Amendment damages. Chief Judge Kevin S. Burke - - as of May 21, 2004 the City
still had not paid condemnation damages and the City (Mayor Love's administration)
breached a settlement agreement (by Mayor Dahlberg's administration). Mayor Love
could have fixed the problems for about fifty thousand and other non cash reasonable
compromise consideration but instead chose to bicker with me in court wasting the
taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars and continuing. In fact, I offered to fix the
City created problems2 at my expense hut Shorewood's planner objected including to the
Watershed District.
J City planners intended to ultimately create on my dry farmland a public opel) space wetland to impound
public storm sewage. See the City's 1975 storm water study.. The City's notation of natural wetland
symbols over my property in the Public Notice is a fraud by the City planner that the City's current contract
engineers refused to endorse and Mayor Dahlberg denounced as a City artifice. Indeed, the City planner
and two former City engineers testified in court they had no idea whether natural wetland existed on my
property as noted on City maps. ~ transcripts.
2 The fix would have retained the Waterford Pond but isolate my ditch and land from its effects.
Exhibit F
LETTER FROM RON JOHNSON
Dated 22 October 2005
.
.
.
.
.
As now presumably scheduled, on October 24, 2005 the City will again hear my
administrative claim that City Code ~ 904.06 public sump waters, including from existing
area swimming pools, collectively along with other new north and east adjoining storm
sewage, cut a perpetual huge gully in my property lawn wrecking it. Instead of paying
me for such public water disposals, you asseqed that instead my neighbors should pay me
and that I should pay the City for my presumed sump pump water disposals. Your
argument is nutso and contravenes the U.S. Constitution as amended and U.S. Supreme
Court case law.3,4
You left me no alternative hut to ohject to the proposed new pool.
S/fJL
Ron ~~~
C: Martin R. Wellens,4th Ward Councilmember
Other Councilmembers and Mayor Love
Planning Commissioners
Erick G. Kaardal, Mohrman & Kaardal
3 See Palazzz% v. Rhode Is/and, 533 U.S. 606, 617 (2001) and its cited progeny - . permanent physical
intrusions of private property caused by government, no matter how minute, require compensation.
4 City officials, on oath, swore to uphold the constitution no matter what, their self imposed continuing
duty.
-2-
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us' cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
October 26, 2005
Ron J olmson
5355 Shady Hill circle
Shorewood, Mimlesota 55331
.
Re: Proposed In-Ground Pool at 19735 Muirfield Circle
Dear Mr. Johnson,
I had your letter of October 22 in my in-box this morning. I forwarded it to the Planning Director, so
that it would be included in the information provided to the Planning Commission for its November 1
meeting, and thus be made part of the record.
.
.
I would like to correct a misstatement made in your letter about a comment I made. I did not state to
you that "the property owner of19735 Muirfield Circle must first make arrangements with me
[Johnson] to pay for the perpetual pool drainage disposals to my property. .. ." I stated that matters of
drainage from one property directly (i.e., across the common property line) onto another property are
private ones. No "first" arrangements would be required by the City. The City's action is whether
and under what conditions to grant permission. If the conditional use permit (CUP) were granted,
the property owner would then need to address any outstanding private matters (and without City
involvement).
.
iYViI
toJ PRINTED ON RECYCLEO PAPER
A.
WSB
Infrastructure I Engineering I Planning I Construction
701 Xenia Avenue South
Suite 300
Minneapolis, MN 55416
Tel: 763-541-4800
Fax: 763-541-1700
. & Associates. fllc.
November 21,2005
Brad Nielsen
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331-8926
Re: Correspondence from Mr. Ron Johnson Relating to
Permit Review of 19735 Muirfield Circle
City of Shorewood, MN
WSB Project No. 1459-04
.
Dear Nielsen:
.
Please be advised that we have received the attached letter from Mr. Ron Jolmson dated
November 5,2005 in which Mr. Jolmson asserts that runoff created by discharging waters from
the in-ground pool at the above address will enter his property. He further asserts that the project
would effect a "taking" of his property. In an effort to provide information in response to these
concerns of Mr. Johnson, please be advised of the following:
.
. The attached memo from the pool supplier, Atlantis Pools, Inc., indicates water will be
left in the pond year-round. The type of pool they are installing requires no seasonal
draw down pumping.
. The filter system does not require back flushing, as discussed in the memo from Atlantis
Pools, Inc., so there will be no routine discharge related to operation of the pool.
. In the event that the pool would need to be emptied, the pool water could be pumped to
Muirfield Circle and into the storm sewer system or the sanitary sewer, if authorized by
the City. If directed to the storm sewer, it would not likely impact Mr. Johnson's
, property for the following reasons:
.
o The Muirfield Circle storm sewer discharges directly to the pond located on
Outlot A, which, according to information obtained from the County's property
record website, is owned by the City of Shorewood. An outlet structure is located
within the pond in the southeast comer of the pond. A November 11,2005 field
visit indicates that this outlet is functioning as designed. It was also observed that
runoffwas leaving the pond through an outlet in the manhole wall, approximately
four feet below the top of the manhole. Based on record drawings, this elevation
is approximately 910, which is two feet lower than the elevation of the ditch on
Mr. Johnson's property (based on the City's one foot contour infonnation.) The
runoff is then conveyed under Waterford Place and south in an existing drainage
swale, away from Mr. Jolmson's property.
K.'101./59.0./ILTR.BNid.\'clI-11 :105.'/oc
Minneapolis II St. Cloud
Equal Opportunity Employer
.
.
.
.
.
Brad Nielsen
November 21, 2005
Page 2
o The ditch on Mr. Johnson's property flows into the pond on Outlot A. This was
verified during the field visit. During this low flow condition, no water was
observed backing up onto Mr. Johnson's property from the pond. As a result, no
impact would be anticipated should the discharge occur during similar low flow
conditions.
o It should be noted that if the entire pool volume where to be discharged, the
Outlot A pond would bounce only 2 1,14 inches when distributed over the 0.4 acre
surface of the pond. This is based on no discharge from the pond. Since there is
an outlet from this pond, it is anticipated that the bounce would actually be less.
In sumrnary,itis not anticipated that pool water frornthe pool will leave the pool under most
conditions, and if the pool should need to be drawn down, the water will be conveyed away from
Mr. Johnson's property.
If the City feels Mr. Johnson's concerns have merit, it is recommended that the City's permit for
pool installation include a requirement that only allows discharge to the storm sewer system
when the water level ofthe pond on Outlot A is at, or near, the Normal Water Level and that no
flows enter Mr. Johnson's property. If a discharge is required during periods of high water, it is
recommended that the discharge be directed to the sanitary sewer.
As to the question of this project creating a "taking" of Mr. Johnson's property, we would defer
this to the City attorney as this is a legal matter.
I am available to discuss this if you would like. Please contact me at 763-287-7164.
Sincerely,
WSB & Associates, Inc.
s~
Water Resources Engineer
Attachments
cc: Craig Dawson, City of Shorewood
kw
fY1'14'L ~ ~ (~
\~ ;<.t2~
.~L !'4ft
/) 'fl,
Ie L"-ry i)Jl_'1iA'(;7'-'"
{;,~:
K:101./59-0./ILTR-BNiclsCII-1 J :105.'/0<
.
.
.
.
.
RON JOHNSON
November 5, 2005
5355 Shady Hill Circle
:ShotewOod, MN 55331
.\:':~ 7-!~'in:i
TeT:'952-474-8171
Steve Gurney, P.E.
WSB & Associates, Inc.
701 Xenia Ave. S.
Golden Valley, MN 55416
Re: 19735 Muirfield Circle Permit Review City of Shorewood, MN;
WSBProject No. 1459-04
Dear Mr. Gurney:
I have your memo dated October 26, 2005, exhibit E of City planner, Bradley
Nielsen's memo dated October 26,2005, in the above-referenced matter. Your false and
misleading memorandum subjects you and your firm to liability for damages.
I note that Mr. Nielsen's memo exhibit F is my letter dated October 22,2005
objecting to the project as yet another new uncompensated taking of my farmland, one of
three (3) such 2005 takings. Mr. Nielsen noted that your memo addressed my concerns.
It did not. You failed to note another current apparently like project on Muirfield Circle
with run-off also to Waterford Outlot A, run-off the City will also dump on my property
as it does with existing in-ground pool waters, etc.
Further, your topographic map exhibit to memo failed to locate my property and
failed to locate the intervening west adjoining Outlot A owned by Shorewood. Your
noted project water flow route traverses Outlot A; will enter my property; and flow
around the stump land fill put there, without my knowledge or consent, by the Waterford
developer and the City, another uncompensated taking. Your noted "pond" is my
farmland ditch dammed up 12 feet impounding public storm sewage dumped on my
property from the adjoining west, south, north and east. As predicted by my consulting
engineers, McCombs Frank Roos & Associates, Inc., (MFRA), the resultant silt and
debris mound build up in my ditch since 1995 has now submerged my 42" ODtractor
crossing culvert at the midpoint length of the ditch on my property.l MFRA estimated
the flooding problems could largely be abated for $50,000 (1995). Your firm was given a
copy.
Finally, Mr. Willenbring of your firm in 1998 was involved with former
Shorewood mayor Dahlberg's plan to fix, "improve", the City's existing storm sewer in
1 See the Shorewood 199_ WSB topo of my property. At this location the crossing and land where the
ditch, shown on the City's 1967 OSM topo, was excavated is within inches of elevation 914 feet MSL,
same as located by MFRA in 1995 and MFRA located at elevation 910 feet my culvert's invert. Mr.
Willenbring was given copies ofMFRA's ditch profile drawings of that excavated in the mid-1950's which
MFRA located.
.
.
.
.
.
my 1f4 mile private ditch in lieu of the City paying condemnation damages. The concept
plan by your firm is dated December 30, 1998. Your firm knew the plan was never
revised and implemented by the successor Mayor Love's administration and that your
firm knew or should have known that Shorewood, so far, has paid zero condemnation
damages for its storm sewage dumpings and impoundments.2
I demand that you and your firm respond within 10 days as to what you and your
firm are prepared to do to pay damages. To mitigate continuing damages I suggest you
revise your memo for purposes of the November 15,2005 Shorewood Planning
Commission meeting and the November 28, 2005 City Council hearing. You should
indicate that the project would effect a taking of my property.3
Since....:r,e.~/,/;~y..- - .. -
flat-
Ron Jol~:
C: Martin R. Wellens, Shorewood 4th Ward Councilmember
Erick G. Kaardal
2 The fact Shorewood paid zero was confirmed in findings of fact by Hennepin County District Court then
Chief Judge Kevin S. Burke in his order dated May 21,2004 in Case No. 03-20830, titled: Johnson v. City
of Shorewood, et al.
3 The U.s. Supreme Court mandated that all physical takings caused by State government (or political
subdivisions thereof), no matter how minute, require the payment of Fifth Amend. just compensation.
Palazzolo v. Rhode Island, 533 U.S. 606 (2001), citing, inter alia, Loretto v. Teleprompter Manhatten
CATV Corp., 458 U.S. 419 (1982). In its sole available alternative, Shorewood can fix the flooding and
pay temporary taking damages.
2
t 'YV ....u '-___ - . .-
~V(Am.
.~~
ATLANTIS POOLS, INC.
4321 68th Ave. N. · Brooklyn Center, MN 55429
763-560-0103 · Fax: 763-560..8619
November 15,2005
Rose and Mark Guidinger
19735 Murfield Circle
Shorewood, MN 55331
Dear Rose & Mark,
.
Thank you for the time you have spent with me on your new swimming pool project.
Your new pool will be a steel, wall, vinyl1ined pool with an under track automatic cover.
Because your pool will have an automatic cover the water stays in the pool at operating
level year round. \Vllen the pool is winterized the water is not drained down at all. The
auto cover is supported by the water in the summer and the winter. The opening and
closing procedures do not require removing any water.
.
Enclosed is a copy of the pool owner's manual. Please note the last page as it relates to
the closing of an automatic cover pool. '
It would be rare that the water would ever be drained down. Should this be necessary a
collapsible drain line is used so the water could be routed to a desirable location.
Consequently there should be no drainage issues.
.
The filtration system is cartridge based. This is the latest technology. In addition to
providing superior water clarity this system eliminates the need to "back-wash" the
media. As a result no water is drained or emptied from the pool.
If you have any further questions, please give me a, call. We look forward to building
your pool in the spring.
Mark Richgels
Atlantis Pools, Inc.
.
~ 71te ~ efJ#t.e 7'Ua!
TOTRL P.02
.
.
.
.
.
-D-R-A-F-T-
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
TO PLACE FILL IN EXCESS OF 100 CUBIC YARDS FOR
MARK GUIDINGER
WHEREAS, Mark Guidinger (Applicant) is the owner of real property located at 19735
Muirfield Circle, in the City of Shorewood, County of Hennepin, legally described as:
"Lot 12, Block. 6, Waterford 2nd Addition"; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a Conditional Use Permit to
place up to 400 cubic yards of fill to level off an area for a swimming pool on the above-
referenced property; and
WHEREAS, the Shorewood City Code requires a Conditional Use Permit to place fill
in excess of 100 cubic yards; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the Planning Director, and his
recommendations were duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission, Mayor
and City Council dated 26 October 2005; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the City's Engineering
Consultant, and his recommendations were duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning
Director, dated 26 October 2005 and a letter to the Planning Director, dated 2l November
2005, which memorandum and letter are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, after required notice, a public hearing was held and the application was
reviewed by the Planning Commission at their regular meeting on 1 November 2005, the
minutes of which meeting are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was considered by the City Council at their
regular meeting on 28 November 2005, at which time the Planner's memorandum, the
Consulting Engineer's memorandum and letter, and the minutes of the Planning Commission
were reviewed and comments were heard by the Council from the City staff.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The subject property is located in the P.U.D., Planned Unit Development zoning
district and contains approximately 26,361 square feet of area.
2. The proposed fill will be contained by a terraced boulder retaining wall and will
be used to level off the rear yard ofthe Applicant's property to accommodate a swimming pool.
.
3. The area of fill shall be limited to that which is shown on Exhibit A, attached
hereto and made a part hereof.
4. The design of the proposed retaining walls has been addressed by Paul D.
Schimnowski, KBH Consulting, Inc., a registered professional engineer, whose
recommendations are set forth in a letter to the applicant's contractor, dated 5 October 2005, a
copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit B.
CONCLUSION
a. The application of Mark Guidinger for a Conditional Use Pennit as set forth
hereinabove be and hereby is granted.
.
b. The pool and retaining wall shall be constructed in accordance with the
recommendations ofKBH Consulting, Inc., contained in Exhibit B, and the recommendations
ofthe City's consulting engineer, contained in Exhibit C, both attached hereto and made a part
hereof.
c. Any discharge of water from the pool shall be directed to the City storm sewer
system when the pond located in Outlot A, Block 2, Waterford is at or below an elevation of
910 feet. At such times as the elevation ofthe pond is over 910 feet elevation, any discharge of
pool water shall be directed to the City sanitary sewer system.
.
d.
Final grading shall be subject to approval by the City Engineer.
e.
Erosion control measures must be in place prior to filling.
f. That the City Administrator/Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to provide a
certified copy of this Resolution for filing with the Hennepin County Recorder or Registrar of
Titles.
. ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL of the City of Shorewood this 28th day of November,
2005.
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
.
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
-2-
..' . ...' ~..
. ~ . . --
, /,
...~
, '/
.
,
.
c:
,...
600 5"~:O'2,~s~(4t
. , ~
"
.... .
EY
FOR: '6T8'INE'12" ~ ItOPPLEMAN
Prepared By:
SCHOELL & MADSON, INC.
Engineers. Surveyora. Planners. Solis Testing
10550 Wayzata Boulevard
Mlnnetanka. Mn. 55343
Tel. 546-7601
'" 0:1
.....If..
0.,0.. a'V
o
~
~
r...\ l~
,.~ ~!) ~,
.. ~ _ t"
\ I~r ':v
/ '1. "
-,/ '
.\...,
'. i
.,,'
......
.. '
l.t.......'
(, .....
if orJ..'
~
GENERAL NOTES:
1)
2)
3)
4)
'5 )
6)
7)
8)
'1)
. _ Denotes iron monument found.
c - Denotes wood stake.
x9S5.0 - Denotes existing spot
elevation. ~
x(985.6) - Denotes proposed. spot ,.,/ ...",;.'
elevation.
.....-- - Denotes di rection of
surface drainage.
Proposed top of foundation
elevation = 1003.0.
Proposed garage floor elevation =
1002.6.
proposed basement floor elevation c
993.2.
Qe'o'. Od",lC\~ l.o ~hQW pot"'ch \ d.ec:.\<s_~ drIVe.
," .
,.~~.{:~'
DESCRIPTION:
lot 12,51 OCK 1, WATERFORO ZNO ,ADDITlO,N,'
BENCHMARK:
Spike in 'lath in lO-inch oaK tree:'as "'; ':,
shown. Elevation. 1003.0 (NGVO-1929Y..,,:-'
I hereby certify that this survey was prepared under my supervision and that I""
_ am a Li censed land Surveyor under the 1 aws o!{jfe shat~ of M{jWla." :. :,'~:::\ "",',
Date: September 20, 1988 ijI'~...R,.. ~ /~i'YnW-" ,:
theodore
land Surveyor
Exhibit A
TI 1I--'_;:J?_?G\l'Aa TIII= 11 ~ "\7CM TII:
.
.
.
.
.
......... ~I t __..._
KBH CONSULTING; INC.
'PaiirD~~schiiDii~,Qo:wne.r'-"""''''-'''''''''''-''--'''''''''''''''''''-...--...,.................-,...........,...--..-.............-.........-................,..,...........,...,.
October 5, 2005
(Revised October 1, 2005)
Hans Frees
Outdoor Ex-capes
6980 Oxford Street, # 1 00
St. Louis Park,MN55426 . "
RB: Boulder Retai.ning De::sign P~eters
19735 Muirfield Circle
Shorewood, Mino.esata
KBH No. 2005.103
Dear Mr. Frees:
This revised letter is l?eing sent to discuss our engineering design paxameters for the proposed boulder
retaining wall at the 19735 Muirlle1d Circle project in Shorewoo~ Minnesota.. This design was based on.
information provided by you on October 3, 2005. which included a site survey prepared by Schoel1 &
Madson dated September 20, 1988, and other wall layout information. No formal soil report was
provided for this project.
I understand that the proposed boulder retaining wans on this project are located southeast of the existing
house in the backyard. A two-tiered wall system \viU be used to retain a section. of the backyard in which
an in..ground swimming pool is proposed. The lower wall will be 6' exposed in height; will be
approximately 150' long; and will have a maximum 4:1 slope in front of the wall. The upper wan will be
6' behind the lower wall (face-to-face distance); will be 6' high exposed.; will be approximately 100'
long; and will have level slopes at the front and back of the wall. No e'.6.'temal surcharge or groundwater
loads were d,esigned for these retaining walls. h is assumed that DO load is being imposed on the retaining
walls from the swimming pool. Therefore. the pool should be back from the upper walt a minimum of 10
feet. M embedment depth of 6" should be main.tained at the base of the walls and a minimum wall
ba.tter/setback of 200 (3.5 inchesNertical foot) should be used.
Geos)11thetic reinforcement fabric (geogrid) should be installed as follows:
For the lower wa~ place geogrid to a length of 1.67 times the wall height (10' long for a 6' bigh
wall) at each course of boulders due to the surcharge loading of the upper wall on the lower wall,
For the upper wall. place 4.5' geogrid at each course of boulders.
Using a select granular sand backfill would deorease tho geogrid lengths behind the bottom walt to
lengths of L25 times the wall height,
Special note should be made of the wall embedment depth and the geosynthe1ic fabric (gea-grid) length as
measured from the front face of the wall. 'Refer to industry standard practice references for installati.on
information, specifications. and details.
KBH Consl1lting, Inc.
1226 39th Street North, Scite 100
Oakdale. :MN 55128
(651) 779.7700
Exhibit B
.
.
.
.
.
--. -.. ----
19735 Muirfie1d Circle, Shorewood, MUmc;sota
October 5, 2005 (Revised October 7. 2005)
. Page 2
Boulders shall be placed. to avoid continuous joint planes in vertical or lateral directions.
Each boulder shall bear on two or more rocks below i:t with good fiat-to-flat contact.
Place a 4" diameter corrugated perforated draintile with sock at the finished grade ofwalls. Outlet
the draintUe at 50' on-ce1Jl:~ and at low points along the wall.
Compa.ct any structural fill place behind the drainage zone to 95% standard proctor.
_ Drainage stone shall consist of clean 1" minus crushed stone (100% passing 1", 75-100% passing
%").
The design of the wall system assumes the following:
Soil eonditions: Si1tlclaYi frictiou angle =28.0 degrees. unit weight of 125.0 Ib/ft3
Allowable soil bearing capacity :::: 1,500 psf
_ No e:dernaI surcharge loading behind walls
Slope at bottom onower wall:= 4:1~ sLope at top::: 10:1
Slope at top and bottom of upper wall = 10: I
Minimum embedment depth = 6"
Boulder Type: 24"-36" (base courses); 12".24" (upper COUtl!es); retsining wall specific boulders
Geosynthetic Fabric Type: Mira:fi 3XT or equivalent
Direct all surface drainaSe away from the wall. The wall design. was performed using the design
guidelines presented in the second addition. of the ."Design Manual for Segments! Retaining Walls"
(DMSRW) published by NCMA in 1996. If soil conditions, proposed wa11layouts, or other design.
parameters vary from that assumed, a revised analysis may be needed. Please call roe if you have any
questions or need more information. Thank you.
S~ff~'
. ~
,
Paul'SchiInnowsld, PE
MN #40l26
KBH Consulting. Inc.
7226 39th Street North. Suite 100
Oakdale. MN 55128
(651) 779-7700
.
.
.
.
.
. __I ...." ----
19735 Muirfield Circle, Shorewood, Minnesota
Oerober 5, 2005 (Revised October 7,2005)
page 3
;DESIGN PARAMETERS ANJ) PROVISIONS
1. REFER TO BOULDER RETAINING WALL INDUSTRY 5T ANDARD SPECIFICATIONS.
2. SEE PRODUCT MANUF ACT'IJ'RER INSTALLATION :RECO'MMENDATIONS FOR CONSTRUCTION
SEQUENCE AND INSTALLATION NOTES.
3. NO PRODUcr/MATERIAL SUBSTITUTIONS WIlL:BE AlLOWED wrreour PRIOR WRlTl'EN
PEFMISSION OFKBH CONSULTING. INC.
4. O"WNER OR OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ENSURING '!BE CONDffiONS
STATED EEREIN ARE ACCURATE PRIOR TO AND DURING CONSTRUCTION. NOTIFY KBH
CONSULTING, mC.IN WRITING OF ANYDISCREPANClES OR CHANGES TO nm CONDmONS
SHOWN ON THESE DOCUMENTS.
5. REFER to WAlL ELEVATION NOTES FOR W.ALL SURCHARGE LOADINGS AND SLOPES AT TOP
AND aOTIOM OF W ALL(S). REFER TO W }J.LCALCULATIONS FORJ3EARlNG CAFACITY .
REQUIF.EMBNtS. . ....
6. FrnAl, SITE GRADES AND ROOF DRAINS SHALL DIRECT RUNOFF AWAY FROM ~
RET AlWNG W JU.,LS.
7. KBH CONSULTING, INC. ASSUMES NO LIABILITY FOR INTBRPlUITATION OF SUBSURFACE
CONDITIONS, SUITABILITY OF SOn.. DBSIGN PARAMETERS AND lNI'ERP'RETATIONS OF
SUl3StJRF ACE GROUNPW ATER CONDITIONS.
8. THE OWNER OR OWNER:S REPRESENI'ATIVE IS JmsPONSIBLE FOR CONTACTING TIlE WAlL
DESIGN ENGINEER ro SCHEDUL."8 A SITE VISIT PRIOR TO THE START OF ELOCK PLACEMENT.
9. THE W NJ.., DESIGN WAS PERFO:RMED USING DESIGN GUIDELlNES PRESENTED IN TEE SECOND
EDmONOFTHE "DESIGN MANUALFORSBGMBNTALRETAlNING WALLS" (DMSRW). PUBLISHED
BYNCMAlN 1996.
10. TIlE DESIGN OF THIS RETAINING Wp.;jL WAS BASED UPON INFORMATION NOTED ONum
KEY PLAN.
11. nm INFORMATION PROVIDED Wl1'BIN TE'ESE DOCUMENTS IS FOR THE STRUCTURAL
DESIGN OF THE PROPOSED WALL(S) ONLY. THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AND/OR WORK RELATED
TO HANDRAILS, GUARDRAILS, OR OUiER LIFE/SAfETY ISSUES ARE EXCLUDED FROM THESE
DOCUMENTS AND .ARE TO BE PRoVlDED BY OTHERS.
12. RESPONSIBU-ITY FOR. GLOBAL/SLOPE STABILITY RESTS wrm THE SII'E CIVIL OR
GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEER-
KBH Consulting, Inc.
7226 39th Stteet North, Suite 100
Oakdale,:MN 55128
(651) 779-7700
.
.
.
.
.
..
WSB
Memorandum
& Associates, Inc.
To:
Brad Nielsen, City of Sltorewood
Steve Gurney, P.E., WSB.& Associates, [nC.r
October 26, 2005
. From:
Date:
Re:
19735 Muirfield Circle
Conditional Use Permit Review
City of Sltorewood, MN
WSB Project No. 1459-04
We have reviewed the grading plan submittal, dated October 7, 2005 and prepared by Frank
Cardarelle, for construction of a swimming pool at 19735 Muirfield Circle. In addition, a letter
outlining the design parameters for a boulder retaining wall, dated October 7, 2005 and prepared
byKBH Consulting, Inc. was reviewed. Based on this review, we have the following comments:
Boulder Retaining Wall
1. In addition to the design parameters outlined in the design memo, it is recommended
that the following items be incorporated into the plan:
a. Place a six inch (minimum) compacted base under walls
b. Provide 12 inches of free draining aggregate behind wall system for drainage
2. The construction requirements must be shown on a construction plan signed by a
Registered Engineer, registered in the State of Minnesota.
3. It is recommended that, as a condition of the building permit, the Engineer submit an
as-built drawing certifying that the wall was constructed according to the construction
plan.
Site Drainage
1.
The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency recommends that, when draining swimming
pools, the water pumped from the swimming pool be discharged to the sanitary
Exhibit C
C:\DocltmCIIlS ",ul Settil/gs\wsb.WS
.
.
.
.
.
Brad Nielsen, City of Shorewood
October 26, 2005
Page 2
sewer, or, alternatively, the water be held for a week or more (after treatment has
stopped) before discharging to a pervious area.
2. Should the homeowner discharge to pervious areas in the back of their own
residential lot, the runoff will flow approximately 500 feet to the pond located on
Outlot A, which outlets to the south. The anticipated flow path is shown on the
attached contour map of the area.
3. Because the rate of flow would be relatively minor, it is anticipated that the runoff
will most likely infiltrate into the ground before it reaches the pond.
4.
Surface water runoff also would be improved slightly by this project. Under existing
conditions, the runoff from the hill will be conveyed directly off-site, eventually
flowing to the pond on Outlot A. With the proposed construction, runoff from the
area surrounding the pool will collect within the pool area rather than be conveyed
down the hill to the pond.
Attachment
cc:
Larry Brown, P .E., City of Shorewood
C:\DocumcIIlS (lmJ Scuillgs\wsb.JVSBLT.03J\Dcsktop\MEMO - bnie!sell- J0:1605.cloc
,\' ~~~~~~~I~o III'!'IJ/J/J/~ /!~.._.~
l \ \ ~ ....~~~~ ::::"<lr6 ~,,\ 1-1 ,~, ~..-. ljfJ .~
'\ \ \ \ . -t '~;;::..~;:;:-.:.:: ~ ~ ~ :.-'. ~
~"~ --- - ~~ '(~..... .
\: '" '\." } '=1 ~9lO
~ ~"",, ~ \ / . . J... \. f.
~ ~ \ ~ . L_ ~~ ...
'k .~ . -j · ~~::\YJ @. --
\~ /~ /~wr~ ~ '/':? ~
~~, ,r ~~ ~~ ~.~ ''1 ~ ~ ~
,. ",W, ~~ ~ ~_\' ~~ ~ ,@~ ~,
"~~kl~fJ.(rJ- ~ =~,~C\i~\~~l~:__~ ,;~", ~ :~
~ \ ~ )~V .--f ~\\ /'-~-=-c z@~f%I~ ~
~/ "--- t=i 0 ~ aa II IJ~~ ~:~d> .,.. ~,h
~'-" '\. j-ll:~" -'( ~ 1'. ,,'/ ~ ~'J iN_ I ;",-~
~.J~~ ''-'" '/ '/ '/ '- ~ -~
- ~ -- ,c{\? W':..~\
-~~. ;u~..~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~~"
filS - \"1 ..." "" :'-:'\ ...../"/:/- \\.-... [.P/ M
~~, ~ ,f,.\ ~~ "\.'-\ " ~~ ~ M ~ ~ ~ )/ \ ~ ..
~ ":;:: ~'Io.~ 8,: ~ il / ~A
\ ;> ~ 5f""- ~ \.\ L y- ......... ~" 0
\ ~ %~ - ~ ~\.l ~ Q ~~~~\\ ~.~~^-
~J~\ ~'t, .. ~. - =- S s.. "ff~~\ ~~, ~~
~~1 + ~" ~\. X -., "~{-;1i ~"2 ~~~ '\ ~~
~'J" ~~::\ '\~~\'\ ~"'~~ l>... r~ .... ....:~. ~ ~'~
~~~ SIb' '" \ ~""':~ .~'\\\ ~~ V It '- \ . \ ~ ,\
:::> \~ ~~'rA::-- "pr. Af.-~~'"" ".:\:\ Q \ .l. /~.lt.Tl~:l "~''-- ...... &~~
~. '\ . ~ ~l?' .' ~ ~ I ,....
l)W~ '-~ ~ ,~~-J' /- :\~ ~$ ~'i!l: ~, - ~ '\ ,". ''\ ~ '\
i ~ A \ . ~ [j ""c- ",,"%~ ~ ~>( \: · ;iSm '. ',". ' ~
. ~~ ->>.'...."-~ ,~t"<i. ~ ~~.~~~ ~ G \ ~ ~\ .~ .....~~~..... ~
~" l "\" ~ ~.~~: 'vi_~ ~~"IT~ 'JI g;: 7 ~~'~ ." ~
i=~ "~~~"W~~ 'Jl!J 'l~' ~~ )J~ i=:JJ~-~~
= ~ ~ L~ vA'" "-,, il;. v ~;s,.'
~~'Z · - .~~~..--- - ~ \ I~~ <t'~ ~~ ~~ ' ~
.~ - ~\:\:~~ ~( ~. -{ ~~ ~ ~~~\t\~ + ~
:\'It
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
Planning Commission
Brad Nielsen
30 October 2005
Apple Ridge Third Addition - Preliminary Plat
405(05.26)
.
In 2002, Lecy Construction, Inc. was granted approval for Apple Ridge 2nd Addition, a four-lot,
residential subdivision located on the east side of Apple Road, just north of the
ShorewoodfChanhassen border (see Site Location map - Exhibit A, attached). The project was
processed as a planned unit development that allowed the developer to cluster the four new lots
and included a conservation easement over the easterly 56,916 square feet (1.31 acres) of the site.
The easement, originally platted as Outlot A, is in favor of the City of Shorewood. A second
outlot, Outlot B, was to be conveyed to the property owner to the north. This conveyance never
occurred due to that property owners legal difficulties.
Lecy Construction now proposes to replat the two outlots into four outlots (Exhibit B) in order to
convey them to adjoining property owners. In their letter (Exhibit C), dated 4 October 2005, they
explain that the properties would be resubdivided into four outlots, and how the oultlots would
be conveyed. A public hearing has been scheduled for 1 November to consider a preliminary plat
for the property.
ANALYSISIRECOMMENDATION
.
This request is somewhat unusual, primarily for the resulting lot configurations proposed by the
applicant. It must be noted that OutlotsA-C will still be subject to the original conservation
easement. Only the ownership will be changed. As explained in the applicant's letter, Outlot D
will be the same size as the original Outlot B, with proposed ownership undetermined at this
time.
n
~~ PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
:lFs.t.
.
.
.
Memorandum
Re: Apple Ridge Third Addition
30 October 2005
Since the proposed plat does not result in additional building lots, the principal concern with this
replat is making sure that all of the prospective land owners are fully aware that Outlots A-C is
subject to the conservation easement. In this regard, the resolution approving a final plat should
clearly place future owners of the existence of the easement. . Approval of the preliminary plat
should also be subject to the following:
1. The developer should submit a protective covenant stating that Outlot A will not be sold
separately from its adjoining property, This property is located in Chanhassen and can
not be legally combined in another way. The applicant's attorney should submit the
covenant before the final plat is scheduled for Council review and approval.
Outlot B should be legally combined with Lot 3, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded
with the final plat for the Third Addition.
3. Outlot C should be legally combined with Lot 2, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded
with the final plat for the Third Addition. Outlot C and Lot 2 are both owned by Lecy
Construction, so there should be no delay.
2.
4.
The legal status of the property owner to the north of Outlot D is unknown as of this
writing. If Outlot D can not be conveyed within one year, the outlot should be legally
combined with Lot 2. This outlot will be of no benefit to the property owner to the east
of Apple Ridge.
5. The applicant must provide evidence of recording for items 1-3 within 30 days of Council
approval, or the approval will be void.
. Cc: Craig Dawson
Tim Keane
Buzz Myers
.
-2-
laa,:j'
OOO'~
oos
osz
,
o
,
i:;'/":U-;:;J~}l;Z'.';;;;.Z.~':..""7E'-:".~~3.;:';T..:n.'v:"";':~:-,ii!J;;"~~B-:e.3:V~~~-!,~.r:':i:.rD:-e~"::~;V%~lJ.;'.l~"{1t~:Jo13:{.~ ..'
y
JapJoq uasselluell:J jO ~J!::>
'I"
'I" 'I"
'I"
~' ~.:~.:..A!';I;~!~_'A-.::.(Y~!i.~ :.7.::'t":L>t~'!IDt'P~3_.;-.j~~}',r..,
~
~
r=~j
~~
~,
~
[~
I
f
I
f
I
e--- j
--r-
...... --_/
_.--
. ------ ~~,
,. ,,-----~,-- "
''''''Diy ::j- .- - ;:::>-,\
6~1 - \ \
.10:-0\",> I
.. -fG \
\ \
\
\
,
,
~\ 1--
o _. V')
gll'J 8 ~
~~ ~ ~r
~:27 O~
Q;f!:~~ t--
<n I
~l.u!d~
~-.J-
.O:~~
,,~~
~sa::
;
;
/i
IO~
I _<-
; ,....1
I . I
; ~~
_ li~
_./ ,
"",><-_ 11;1
/ 0-
~
~
.
.
0
~
0
'"
3 0
...
0
... .~
0
..
(Q
.
-I
I I
I I
I
_...I
.~
(Y'
_W
I
IQ
: Iq '----:::::".--:
.I. r: '"::'<... (
~.;! 1- :::::;>- )
01~; I /J/",~ "-,,-
· l:t; I /I'f I"'",'" /' ........
, /, 111;/ -7 "-
111,,11 .::.
I I ," J I - .....
"'1--11,,1'
J "I" I ",J-
J 1 ' 1 I I ·
~~I " II / / ~.::: I- -
111--/ /
"'-//II/~ ()
",,/,,/ ,;J I.......... - J
tt'Y"'/ "- "-
..... "-
.....
:z
\
\,>
V, "J
-C~
.....rJ
"Y
"
U ..,
~.' Il'l g
'1-'
"ZoO ::p;
~... ~ ~
~>-~<>a
!l:~ r!..
'"':z:....-
!;@e" lC -
o i':;: I
U '" ~ lq
Go~~
~~~ a::
_J
~-
1--
()
ll'J I-~
iji g .., ()
0
ll:: _0
~ .., I _J
:;:j;:l;
Oil'll
(!i:z"" ",-I- -
>-ll::~1' .
~~ci~
0- 1-'-
oll el p I
:z ~~ C)
OIC'lll::"""
~...o 0
"Stci15a:: I
_-l
--
,
-...I
-
,
, ,>.
V >
.....r)....
"'r)....
'-t-C
.....,
,,01...;
It
0"1
I V"'" '1
\.....\,., :) ("'\
...""\.,)
^ I'
I V ,) it
'.J; I...;
, J; l.;
"0"'"
L,O~
; r1
........
........ ........
o 12............-
0).. ~
OJ-I v
~~I ~ Exhibit B
Vi~'~ PRELIMINARY PLAT
~ful t.
:z c
6i5 ~
UJ: ,
\vfP
.
.
.
.
.
15012 Highway 7 - Minnetonka, MN 55345
Office: (952) 944-9499 · Fax: (952) 942-1068
Lecy Bros. Homes
www.lecybros.com
license 120325555
Oct. 4, 2005
Brad Nielsen, Planning Director
City of Shorewood
5755 COlliltry Club Road
Shorewood MN 55331
Dear Brad:
After several attempts we have now reached agreement with prospective buyers on the division of Outlot A,
Apple Ridge Second Addition. The former Outlot A has been divided into three parcels as shown on the
attached copy of the Preliminary Plat for Apple Ridge Third Addition. The tour outlots in Apple Ridge
Third Addition will be deeded as follows:
OOTLOT A To be purchased by John Knoblauch of 1450 Knob Hill Lane whose existing
property is adjacent to Outlot A on the South. Purchase Agreement attached,
OUTLOT B To be purchased by Jason Ballsrud of 6175 Apple Road whose existing property is
aqjacent to Outlot B on the West. Purchase Agreement attached.
OUTLOT C To be deeded to the future owner of Lot 2 of Apple Ridge Second Addition. Leey
Construction, Inc. currently owns Lot 2.
OUTLOT D This property is currently owned by Lecy Construction, Inc. but will be sold in the
future to another owner whose property is contiguous to Outlot D, i.e., the owner of
the property immediately West, North or East of Outlot D.
In summary,
. Outlot D, Apple Ridge TIlird Addition is identical to that area identified as Outlot B, Apple Ridge
Second Addition. As such, it does not have a conservation easement on the property and may be
combined with other property to meet the City of Shorewood requirements for development (Note that
Outlot B was not used in the lot density calculation for Apple Ridge Second Addition).
. Similarly, Outlots A, Band C, Apple Ridge Third Addition were subdivided from Outlot A, Apple Ridge
Second Addition. As such, none of these parcels is buildable and each is subject to the terms of the
conservation easement recorded contemporaneously with the Final Plat of Apple Ridge Second Addition.
We believe that tlle sale of Outlots A, B and C to the adjacent landowners is the best way to ensure that the
provisions/restrictions in the Conservation Easement are met. We feel it is in the best interest of all
concerned for the owners to "self-police" each other voluntarily and thereby eliminate the need for constant
oversight and entorcement by others.
Sincerely,
,';
,~/
Buzz Myers
cc:
Roy Lecy
Exhibit C
APPLICANT'S REQUEST LETTER
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION APPROVING A PRELIMINARY PLAT OF
APPLE RIDGE THIRD ADDITION
WHEREAS, a preliminary plat of Apple Ridge Third Addition has been submitted in the
manner required for the platting of land under the Shorewood City Code and under Chapter 462
of Minnesota Statutes, and all proceedings have been duly had thereunder; and
WHEREAS, said plat is consistent with the Shorewood Comprehensive Plan and the
regulations and requirements of the laws ofthe State of Minnesota and the City Code ofthe City
of Shorewood.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
1. The preliminary plat of Apple Ridge Third Addition, as shown on Exhibit A,
attached hereto and made a part hereof, is hereby approved, subject to the
recommendations of the Shorewood Planning Commission as stated in the
minutes oftheir regular meeting held on 1 November 2005, an excerpt of which
minutes is contained in Exhibit B, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
2.
A final plat for the subdivision must be submitted within six months of the date of
the City Council's approval ofthe preliminary plat.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD this 28th day of
November 2005.
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator/Clerk
ILl
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
,
/
r-
............----_/
,,-
'.-----/
-----/
--------
....
----------""-
/
/
/l
'C!.h
I _..-
, /.,
, . I
/ ~~
_ _ // i5
..../><-_ :0;1
0-
}
~2
."
~
....
J
.
r)
tJ '>,
(,t,
Q I
o I~
~~I~~
ilj<J1 ~a
~ ~
~ ~ ~E Itl~
~ zr-..:g ~~ s~
~ c>, Ol l:;) ~"'l
~ ~~~ $ij: a~ t: 5~ t:
A ~~~~~ ~~ ~. ~~ ~
~CCi~2; I .ll<l '(). ~ lr,)
~ ~g~l! I~a I! ~
.'~ ~
;"'''
'-"I '
"
" ,
, """
\....,,,
.
_-I
'.~t
~
.r: ~-
,- :.:::;s-. ()
I I'r,'" /"
I , /' "
, I 'I ,," /', "
111'// "
// ,::// 7'""
I .....-1' I" I I I .c. - "
0., I I / r I I I
. ' II I I I
I '/ I { , I
I.....J 'l// '
- -/-J./~/
~_ I I I / /
"/ " 'I...
.,,/;-/ /' I / ..........
rl"// "
J" "
"
.....
z
",J-
.
~~
1--
()
_J
1--
()
_J
"'./.-
~
1--
()
I
_-I
" ,
, "0',
'''-./''1
'v0\"'"
v
"I"
'1.." ,,''''
\""','l:-,
J.....0
,...oJ\,.,) .
," "'1 .
" ' "
'J" I.....,
I V lJ
, '0'"
\....,04
',,1
.
.
.
~
~
fI:I~
~I -..: ~ III ~ ~ ~ f..
f-..cv . 10<, l::l~
~ 'OCl)8~B~f-..C
rtj E;:!'()...:l ...:l 'Ot!
cllil ~coS'OI--<'Ot::...
~g 'O~'Oq2~ ~~
g;~ ~ ~ <"i '0 "'I
... .... -
~
~
--:::,
<>
"+
W
I-
>-<
Q..
~ Q)
<,,'0
c:i u
j:::U)
~ 0
02:
-J
z~
.
<C
+-'
......
..0
......
~
~
0>-'
E::~:2:;
~~~
~::r::
t'\.> ~ ~
hl-..j .
rJ)b:j;)
~ ~
CC\l~
r,'-!O
......Oh
~~~
C,.,) ~
~ t;:j
t-:l <;
I\:
~
p
~
i{
~
IJ..
:2;
a
E::
t-.;
h~
:s~
~~
~~
~~
~
t;::kl
~ .t..b
~~
~~
o...kl
....:j
~
~
~~
li'~
it
~~
yt'i
,,0 ~
t~.~
~-~
~I
~
0.
01'
"
~
.,,"l
q..~. '
~o.
,,;f Jj
, ""-.
~~
.~ '\
'\
~
~
~ii~
:;-~~
i:~1;
HE
'6:i ~
s.~_ ~
$'''} 0 I
8 ts 8-'
k~ '- l.J
fs~
..: ~~ ~
Q
~
l~
~~
3.1
J.~
~
I~ !~ii
I ~ ~~",;
I;i!!:
]" 'l!
Of
0:
.
.
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 4 of 8
Chair Bailey closed the Public Testimony portion of the Public Hearing at 7:57 P.M.
Director Nielsen stated, with regard to the pool drainage, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency
recommended the pool discharge not be directed to wetland areas, preferring instead that the discharge be
directed to sanitary sewer systems if chemically treated. He stated most homeowners, in his experience, ran
a drainage line to the storm sewer or to a yard area. These practices would work acceptably as long as
homeowners did not treat the pool with chemicals for seven days prior to drainage into the storm sewer or
yard.
Commissioner Gagne questioned whether Mr. Guidinger had met the necessary approvals as outlined in
City ordinances associated with a request such as this one. Director Nielsen stated the Engineering and
Planning Departments had recommended approval of this project. .
In response to a question by Council Liaison Wellens, Mr. Johnson demonstrated the location of his land on
a site location map associated with the pool project being requested. Mr. Johnson went on to state drain
tiles had been placed in that area that would outlet onto his property.
Conley moved, Gagne seconded, Recommending Approval of a Conditional Use Permit for Mark
Guidinger, 19735 Muirfield Circle, subject to City Engineering recommendations.
Chair Bailey stated he believed the issue at hand was not to solve Mr. Johnson's drainage issue, but to
allow Mr. Guidinger to develop his property.
Commissioner Conley stated he agreed, and with all due respect to Mr. Johnson, the issues presented by Mr.
Johnson were large scale issues. He further stated he was not convinced that the quantity of water drained
from a pool once a year would contribute in a meaningful way to the larger engineering issues. He also
stated he thought a property owner had a right to develop his own property.
Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 8:08 P.M.
4.
7:30 P.M. PUBLIC HEARING - PRELIMINARY PLAT - APPLE RIDGE 3RD ADDN.
Applicant: Lecy Construction, Inc.
Location: Outlots A and B of Apple Ridge 2nd Addn (Apple Road)
Chair Bailey opened the Public Hearing at 8: 15 P.M.
Director Nielsen explained in 2002, Lecy Construction, Inc. was granted approval for Apple Ridge 2nd
Addition, a four-lot, residential subdivision located on the east side of Apple Road, just north of the
ShorewoodlChanhassen border. The project was processed as a planned unit development that allowed the
developer to cluster the four new lots and included a conservation easement over the easterly 56,916 square
feet (1.31 acres) of the site. The easement, originally platted as Outlot A, was in favor of the City of
Shorewood. A second outlot, Outlot B, was to be conveyed to the property owner to the north. This
conveyance never occurred due to that property owner's legal difficulties.
Lecy Construction now proposed replatting the two outlots into four outlots in order to convey them to
adjoining property owners. In their letter, dated 4 October 2005, the applicants explained the properties
would be resubdivided into four outlots, and how the outlots would be conveyed. This public hearing was
held for the purpose of considering a preliminary plat for the property.
Exhibit B
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES
November 1, 2005
Page 5 of 8
Director Nielsen went on to explain this request was somewhat unusual, primarily for the resulting lot
configurations proposed by the applicant. He stated it must be noted that Outlots A-C would still be subject
to the original conservation easement. Only the ownership would be changed. As explained in the
applicant's letter, Outlot D would be the same size as the original Outlot B, with proposed ownership
undetermined at this time.
Since the proposed plat did not result in additional building lots, the principal concem with this "replat" was
making sure that all of the prospective land owners were fully aware that Outlots A-C was subject to the
conservation easement. In this regard, the resolution approving a final plat should clearly inform future
owners ofthe existence of the easement. Approval of the preliminary plat should also be subject to the
following:
1.
The developer should submit a protective covenant stating that Outlot A would not be sold
separately from its adjoining property. This property was located in Chanhassen and can not be
legally combined in another way. The applicant's attorney should submit the covenant before the
final plat was scheduled for Council review and approval.
2. Outlot B should be legally combined with Lot 3, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded with the
final plat for the Third Addition.
Outlot C should be legally combined with Lot 2, Apple Ridge 2nd Addition and recorded with the
final plat for the Third Addition. Outlot C and Lot 2 were both owned by Lecy Construction, so
there should be no delay.
3.
4.
The legal status of the property owner to the north of Outlot D was unknown as of this writing. If
Outlot D can not be conveyed within one year, the outlot should be legally combined with Lot 2.
This outlot would be of no benefit to the property owner to the east of Apple Ridge.
5. The applicant must provide evidence of recording for items 1-3 within 30 days of Council approval,
or the approval would be void.
. Director Nielsen noted a representative of Lecy Construction was present this evening.
.
Andy Johnsrud, of Lecy Construction Inc., stated the recommendations were acceptable as presented by
Director Nielsen. He stated the only possible problem that could be foreseen related to Item 4 of the
recommendations.
Seeing no one present wishing to comment on this case, Chair Bailey opened and closed the Public Hearing
at 8:21 P.M.
Discussion ensued by the Commission regarding the best possible method and timeline necessary for
working with the conveyance of Outlot D.
White moved, Gagne seconded, Recommending Approval of a Preliminary Plat for Apple Ridge, 3rd
Addition, subject to Staff Recommendations 1-3 and 5, and that Outlot D would be legally combined
with Lot 2 by March 1, 2005, as detailed in the Staff Memorandum from Director Nielsen regarding
this case, dated October 30, 2005. Motion passed 6/0.
Chair Bailey closed the Public Hearing at 8:30 P.M.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952).474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.ci.shorewood.mn.us. cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
City Council
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator ~
November 23, 20005
The "Saunders Proposal" regarding Resolution of SLMPD Matters
.
This matter has been continued from the November 14 City Council meeting. A copy ofthe staff
report and the Saunders Proposal is attached.
.
Since November 14, there has been no additional action on the Saunders Proposal. The Excelsior
City Council removed this item from the agenda at its November 21 meeting. The Greenwood and
Tonka Bay city councils have approve the proposal, at least in concept, at this time. The Excelsior
and Shorewood city councils have yet to approve or decline the proposal.
City Council Action:
The City Council should consider continuation of this item to its December 12,2005, meeting.
.
.
-=t~A
~'li1
~." PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.ci.shorewood.mn.us . cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
City Council .. . .. . ^ t\
Craig W. Dawson, City Administrator (J-V
. November 10, 2005 . .".
The "Saunders Proposal" regarding Resolution of SLMPDMatters
The SLMPD Coordinating Committee heard a proposal from Greenwood Councilmember Matt
Saunders at a special meeting held October 28,2005. The Coordinating Committee endorsed this .
latest proposal for resolution of SLMPD issues, and the Coordinating Committee members stated
they would bring it to their city councils for consideration.
Maj or points of the proposal are:
1). Full service to all parties in 2006, with Excelsior paying 27.0% ($420,000) and Shorewood
paying 48.5% (-$754,000) to. SLMPD. TIus agreement needs to be approved before going; to.
the following; steps. .
2) Develop the following:
a. a withdrawal provision to add to the JP A, modeled after the proposal in the Issues
Group recommendations.
b. a dispute resolution provision to add to the lP A, modeled after the proposal in the
Issues Group recommendations.
i. Cost of mediation service will be paid by the aggrieved city unless the .
Coordinating Committee decides unanimously to do otherwise.
11. If dispute then goes to binding arbitration, the costs of arbitration will be paid
by the losing party unless the Coordinating Committee decides unanimously to
do otherwise. .
c. a budget approval provision that, in the event of "no determination on budget matters
by September 1," would have automatic adjustments as are contained in the lPA of the
Excelsior Fire District.
i. These adjustments would apply only to operating expenses. AU cities would be
required to increase their payments to meet cost obligations in union contracts.
3) After agreement on Steps 1 and 2 above, then the funding; formula would be put into binding
. arbitration. Excelsior would have 30 days to initiate the arbitration process from the date that
the JPA is formally amended to include the matters in Step 2.
Status: The Greenwood and Tonka Bay city councils have approved the proposal. The Excelsior
City Council has continued the matter to its next meeting (November 21). .
RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that this item be continued to November 28,2005.
q'b
li..,J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
-H- .3 F
-rr '.
.
REVISED--Binding Arbitration Proposal-IO/28/0S
This proposal is made in continuation of the idea that Excelsior surfaced to bring a long-
term resolution to the SLMPD JP A situation.
The following need to happen in chronological order:
1. Service/funding levels for 2006 need to be decided. Three choices are available.
.
a. PREFERRED-Excelsior pays $420K with the balance to be made up by
Shorewood. , .
i. Full service restored to Excelsior immediately upon approval.
ii: Allows all energy moving forward to focus on issue.
resolution.
111. This is a one-time adjustment for 2006 and should not be
interpreted as a permanent adjustment of funding levels.
.
b. NOT PREFERRED-Base level services for all four cities are determined
based on Bob Newman's 10/12 proposal.
i. Service to Excelsior will decrease.
ii. Base level service to other three cities will also decrease,
but overall service will be maintained or increased through the
purchase of additional services.
iii. Going this direction will be disruptive and will not allow all
energy to be focused on issue resolution.
.
c. NOT PREFERRED-The Coordinating Committee determines a
service/funding direction for 2006 that is an alternative to the Bob
Newman proposal referenced above. Any solution agreed to by the
Coordinating Committee that does not restore full service to Excelsior will
not be a preferred solution.
A decision must be made regarding 2006 service/funding levels before
moving forward toward issue resolution.
2. Coordinating Committee agrees upon and brings to their respective councils
solutions regarding the issues ofWITHDRA W AL, DISPUTE RESOLUTION and
BUDGET APPROV AL. These three issues can be solved by the cities; the
funding dispute cannot. Once these three issues are solved, Excelsior will have
the ability to move the funding issue to arbitration if it so chooses.
.
d. WITHDRAWAL-Although a final solution was not determined by the
Issues Group, significant progress was made toward the crafting of a
solution. The following proposal for withdrawal is made consistent with
the work of the Issues Group.
i. Written notice of withdrawal must be made be made by May 1 for
o ..... l-1 -
>-+, en (1) >-+,
a~~Ef'
(1) (1) 8" (1)
~ S ::to a
P> cr" 0 (1)
o.,....l::l ~
o l::l 0 .
:::s p. >-+, a
. S' .....
.-3 0Cl g. g
s: ~ o..~
{/l cT.......
P. ......{g g
p> R" s:: (1)
..... p> ....... en
(1) ::to (1) en
oop.p..
p> :::s ..... 0
::J en (1)
cr"\O~{/l
(1)Oo:::S
(1) p.~ 0
xP>g......
<t ~ (1) cr"
P p>::I.
~0'0Cl~
p.. :=: ~ 0
~ 0 (1)' 0
..... ~ <: g
po S. (1) (1)
0Cl p..:::s
g ~ s. ~
~....-<{/l
i=l (1) l-1
~. 0 0 CD
:::s0~0Cl
g a a ~
en~o~
0:::s<:0Cl
g 0 (1)
~ S Ef
1:$ CD (1)
.....1:$
.......
.
~ cfci ~ Q cfci ~
S. qq <: ~ qq Ef'
p.. ~. (S. ~. (1)
(1) (1) (1) (1) p..
en <:. .....<:....
....... (1) ::+ (1) en .
o p.. (') (1) p. 00
p..oo(1)oS::
O ..... en ~............
....... ...... 0........ (1)
o '< rn 'j ~ .....
Ef'~o~::ren
q~~~~g
~enl::r'p..Er""'"
..... 00 (1) g. (1) 01
~ Er g (1) ::I. ~
(1). p.. p. 0Cl --
(') p;'~' g: ~
Q g.g. S ~
p. l::l (1) p......
[~SS~
t:r 3. ~ ~ ~
OCl~~P.g
(') ~ 00 Ef' \0
~0~8ao
--00 ....... p.
eT::I l::r' p>
..... (1) p>' (1) '<
&= 00 s- (') 00
(1) e.t:i 0 ~
p.. po,....
s:: (1) l-1 0
:::s I::l"lo p. 0.. P.
~ l-1 p;' ff u
Ej' cr" 0. a Er
p '< 0 ...... (1)
o ....... P l::l
s:: l::r' 0Cl
{/l CD
.z
8 (')0 ~ S. ~ 8 ~ a (')0 ~ a ~
~ en"'" en s:: en (1) p> p>
goo~ g p'1:l S a ct'< (1)
p. g. 8 00 s. a tr a a . l::l
(1) ~'(1) s:: 00 _(1) (1) .....(1) ~.~
:::s .... P> P ~ t:i ...... l-1 ::+ :::s O.::J
o a......o;:rpOrn(1)......P>'<
S' S' Er :=.: (1) g Er a, (1) 0 ct a
{JQ {JQ (1) en ~::t. (1) ;:r. a g. p> (1)
~ () l=j' g,.{g ~ l=j' (1) o~ ~ p. a
d:: 0 01 p> s:: 00 ~ () l::l . bi' tr
;:r~ .............. '" (1) '1:1(1)
~ _ (1) .{g 0 0 {JQ s:: l-1
g: . - a a ; 8 g >-+';:r. ct g.
en ::+ ~ g ...... (1) ..... P. ~ (1) l-1 ~':t
t:i (1) - p...... ..... t::. 00 (1)--'
p (1)'< _en (')<: p l-1 0..00-
(1) 00 v P 0 (1) p> (1) ~o....
~ ::r 0 ~ (1) 0 0 ::to 0Cl.{g - ~
~. ~ ::r 0 x l-1 _::t. {JQl::l s:: s:: a p>
..... CD....... ro+ ~ '< ........ ........ .-.
{JQ p> p..::t. ~ . '"" ~ (1) 0 P.
. \0 s:: (1) '" 0 \.J - 0 P .....
o G' 00 ~ ~. g ~o ~ l-1 '1:1 .{g
p..p.::r-l::lP rnp.l-1S::
p> 0 p> ~ (JQ 0 g. ..... 0 . <t
GoO 0 <: _ .......... rn 0
--. s:: (1) '< (') - ::+ (1) p> (1) l-1
~ l::l l-1 rn 0 : (1) g.~ ~ ~
,. 0 (1) 0 ~ ..... (1) - (1) cr' E\)
::I. ..... <:::r ~ ~ (1) s ~ I-t
o - (D' (1) ;:r ;s. p. p..
P. t:i ~ Po . (1) - t:i en.....
...... p <; ~ ::+ ....... - p ~ s:: l::l
o (1) (1) - (1) ,., ~ (1) :=.. tr {JQ
l-1~p.g.(1)l::lg(1).....ar+
(1) S' Er ~ 0 P ::to 0 ..... l::r'
~ ~ (1) ~ E::: a cr' Jg Er;::t. ~
<" ~. ~ (1) ~ ::I. ~ (1) S ""C
~g.~g.~.z~ ~Q~.?>
g- a{JQ~~Erg"o~;:r.
p. (1) e. s ::r a a ::1. a
bi' g. cr (1) s. ::+ 0
'1:1 0 l-1 E: a g .~.
a >-+, Er (\) s. '<:
(1) (1) Po {JQ
.
.
00 d
g.t;j
:3 ~
ff~
p.tr1
~fg
~Cf.l
00
~S
o' .-3
l-1 l-I
......0
~T
(1) ~
(')::r
g (1)
l-1 0'
~:=:
p> 0
1:1". ~.
l::l l::l
{JQ{JQ
(')'1:1
~.g
~.~
::+-
(1) .....
(1) 00
o ~
~ p..
\O~
Net
~p.
~~
. a
;:r.
a
9>
:< <' :::: p:
o 00 p. 0 S' '1:1' r-" 1-1 a ~
cr' g.. (1) 0 0 ~ g 0 ;:I.
~ (1)~~~a ~ N _I=SEr
~ Po ~ OJ. p.. ::r ::t. .' p:. go
..... ~ cr' S' p> i-' en p>
g';i ~ (1)' @:.{JQ [; ~ 9. ~ @ a, ~ ~ ~ a. ~
r+(1) 0.00 (1)-(1)-o.....r+P>.....~.......
o ~ cr' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~'1:1 g t:n g- (S. p. (). :::. 0
Ef' ;:I. - P>..... rn '1:1 ..... t:Il l-1"t:1 00 ~ (1) e-: (1) :3 S.
(1) Ef' ~ o. (1) II? Er 0 -8 ~ fJ ;:I. cr" ::to ~ ~ P-
eT go 0. Et-.g ~ p. ~ (1) ~ - po ~ 0 ff i3 S
Op> g(1)~~~oo~(1)~gogil-1:::s~
g.~. o-8.s ;:r.~.~p.o'S.~ ~ ~'< ~g..s.
o p p. (1) (1) p >-+, '1:1 en <; A (1) p> a l::l
l::l{JQ Hl-1Ef'oOClen~~-~P>~'<~{JQ
r+o (1) a(1)'1:jO pjg~ au.,<' -. '--i
~ ~ ~ {JQS' ~ ~ ~ ~ <-1 g. ~ ~. - ~ ~
cr' cr'..... p> l-1 ""C ...... ~ ..... s::
~. ~. g ~ Er g. bi' S?>'Ef: a.: 8 ::;: ~
_ :=: ~ '1:1 go {JQ ~ p> p> pi H (1) ~
~ H (1) p> .....::t. r+ ~.... ,.D -
l::l' (5 <: l::l ~ cr' 1:1". i-' '1:1 <; 0 s::
~..... e- ~ ~. & go g ~ ~ ; l=j' @
eT (1)rn{JQ{JQp..p a ~p. (1) 0
(1)ooOa~~~ i =~ g. t:n
l-1 Q) >-+,..... en 0 00 - p (1) rn
~ ~Er~~en~ (\) 00 ~ fJ
p> 0. (1) rn~ l-1 ::r g p. 0 (1) ;:I. -
~ ~~0l6~OO g ~Ef' g. a
p. ~>p)~og, p. (1)(1) go ~
~ (1)~~::r~p. ~ I=Sg ~ rn
g s. a: ~ (1)] (\) Er ~:3 S' ~
p ~;:r ,.D s:: Cf.l (1) 0 a 0Cl ,.,(1)
~. o. < s.~. t: cr ~ CD 0
en P~ ~a~ s. '--i~ -~ ~
s:: ....... (1) I=i3 ...... ~" '<: 0
~ gad 8 s::s 8"
o 0' ~ (1) ~
cr' '< a <:
(1) _ e.
.....
.
.
.
ofthe Coordinating Committee. The aggrieved city must initiate
binding arbitration within 150 days from the commencement of
mediation. This date can be extended with unanimous consent of
the Coordinating Committee. The city or cities whose position
does not prevail in arbitration shall be responsible for all costs of
arbitration unless the Coordinating Committee unanimously
decided to do otherwise.
f. BUDGET AFPROV AL- This proposal is also an adaptation from the
9/28/05 version submitted by Excelsior.
Delete the last sentence of Section 7 oftheJPA and replace it With the
, following language:
.
"If no determination is reached on budget matters by September
1st of each year, the amount of the previous year's budget will be
increased by the lesser of the following:
a.) The increase in the July Minneapolis/St. Paul Consumer
Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) over the
previous 12-month period; or
.
b.)
The percentage increase in the most restrictive statutory
levy limit applicable to the budget year plac'ed on any of
the Member Cities over the levy limit for that Member City
for the prior year.
c) In the event that (a) or (b) decreases, the operating budget shall
remain the same."
.
d) The above formula applies only to operating expenses not
governed by union contracts. All cities must pay increases as
required by union contracts; other expenses can have ceilings
applied per the above formula.
3. Once #1 and #2 are decided upon, Excelsior can choose to move the funding
dispute into binding arbitration. The decision of the arbitrator will be for 2007
and years thereafter. Excelsior shall be given credit for having satisfied the
Dispute Resolution process up through the point of concluding mediation.
Excelsior shall have 30 days to initiate the arbitration process from the date that
the JP A is formally amended with the three issues covered in #2.
.
RECEIVED
.
1.,0\/ 2 8 7005
RON JOHNSON
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
5355 Shady Hill Circle
Shorewood, MN 55331
Tel: 952~474-8171
November 25, 2005 SCANNED
Mayor and City Council
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Rd.
Shorewood, MN 55331
Re; Proposed motion to amend draft Resolution regarding
19735 Muirfield Circle permit action.
Dear Mayor and Council:
Belatedly, today at 4:30 PM by U.S. Mail, I received copies of the draft: Resolution and
November 21, 2005 WSB letter regarding. I object to the Resolution as crafted and offer the
following proposed amendments.
1. Whereas it is noted the applicant submitted a dated 1988 Certificate of Survey and
site plan by a contractor and surveyor not the applicant's, approval shall be
conditioned on the submission of a current site plan for the instant project, including
proposed final grading topography signed by the permitee's planner.
2. Whereas the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency indicated that pool waters can
reach toxic levels and suggested sanitary disposal, any discharges from the pool shall
be to the City's sanitary sewer system and not overland nor to the City's storm sewer
system;
3. Whereas pursuant to City Code Chapter 904.09, the permitee's property utility bill
shall be charged the amount of $300 per quarter for pool water disposals 1;
4. Whereas in conjunction herewith, City staff is instructed to prepare Chapter 904.09
amendment for near term public notice and hearing to require all in-ground
swimming pools in the City to dispose pool waters to the City's sanitary system; and
5. Whereas regarding hard surface pool adjoining run-off and pool spillage, an on-site
dry well of sufficient capacity shall be required with its design approved by the City
Engineer.
I The City could easily revise its utility billing software to effectively meter and charge for exceptional City
water consumption attributable to equivalent sanitary pool disposal.
Together these amendments it is believed will comply with present City policies and other
applicable public policies and law as follows.
First, for equal treatment the project plans should be current and prepared and signed by the
applicant's engineer/surveyor.
Second, to mitigate the effects of potentially toxic in~ground pool waters not part of the
normal land watershed, all such waters should be disposed of in the City's sanitary system
because there is no assurance the water will be otherwise properly disposed of.
Third, to mitigate pool adjacent hard surfacing run-off and spillage generally to neighbors'
properties, a pool area curb should be installed with drainage to an on-site dry well, e.g., a
below ground septic tank.
Fourth, in conjunction herewith, the Mayor and Council should formulate a general City
policy, Code if necessary, regarding in~ground pools.
ubmitted,
.:;
RECEIVED
.
:
NOV 2 8 2005
RON JOHNSON
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
November 25, 2005
5355 Shady Hill Circle
Shorewood, MN 55331
Tel: 952-474-8171
Steve Gurney~ P.E.
WSB & Associates, Inc.
702 Xenia Ave. South, Suite 300
Mpls., MN 55416
Re: Your letter dated November 21,2005 to the City of Shore wood, re: 19735
Muirfield Circle permit review.
Dear Mr. Gurney:
Belatedly, today, Shorewood forwarded a copy of your insufficient and inaccurate analyses
of the project run-off, including hard surfacing and in-ground pool disposals. I respond.
First, since there is no certainty that the new run-off will not enter my property crossing on or
under (Muirfield Circle sewer) City owned Waterford Outlot A, the pool should be
permanently plumbed to the City's sanitary sewer and new surface waters including pool
spillage directed to an on-site dry well. I note that your October 26, 2005 memo indicated
the Minn. Pollution Control Agency recommends sanitary disposal because chlorinated water
is considered toxic, i.e. a hazardous substance the other sanitary water will greatly dilute in
1
proper treatment.
Second, your flawed analyses merely considered one such project when there is at least
possibly another, three lots northeast of 19735 and on Muirfield Circle, and additionally
existing in-ground pools which now discharge to City sewers which waters the City dumps
on my property as a result of City Code Chapter 904.09.2
Third, Peter Willenbring of your firm was given report(s) and ditch profile drawings (1950's
depth and width) prepared by the ground truth supervision of Greg Frank, then President of
McCombs. Enclosed is a copy of Greg's analyses of the "pond" created in my drainage ditch
by the 12 foot damming; the sewers to my ditch, including the one you referenced; and his
plan to improve public sewers to abate the resultant flooding and the silt build-up in my
ditch.3 MFRA estimated plan cost at $50,000 (1995). And, I was prepared to pay that.
I Independently I am aware of this from my family's involvement in the manufacture and sale of specialized
food processing waste treatment capital equipment. Other members of my family operate the excavating firm
my father founded in 1921, roads, treatment plants, municipal utilities, subdivision developments. I am a
graduate engineer and once was an ass't. professor of engineering (circa early 1960's).
2 Enforcing the code, the City demanded that such discharges not be put in the City's sanitary system.
3 If you cannot find WSB's copy of the MFRA drawings I can have them provide another copy as part of their
continuing inspections of my ditch conditions.
..
Shorewood refused to discuss the plan and affirmatively objected to the Watershed District
who approved it rebuking Shorewood; the U.S. Corps also approved it.
Fourth, enclosed is WSB detail sheet 3 dated December 30, 1998 bearing the name and P.E.
No. of Mr. Willenbring for the project entitled: "Ron Johnson Property Channel
Improvement For City of Shore wood, Minnesota", noting WSB No. 1074.35. This concept
plan authorized by Shorewood refutes your instant analyses. Note the following.
(b)
My ditch throughout its entire length lies below elevation 914 feet MSL which
Judge Montgomery ruled in 1993 constituted an uncompensated City taking. 4
The concept plan indicates partial restoration of my ditch outlet down to elevation
906/907 feet MSL in overly reasonable compromise, i.e. the sta-tite plug in the
existing water level control structure (ditch dam) would be removed and my ditch
widened for compensating temporary impoundment for 6 inch rainfall events. 5
Now a 6 inch event floods to elevation 917.1 feet MSL (OSM).
(a)
Finally, your observations and analyses did not consider the public silt and debris already
built-up in my ditch as MFRA predicted. nor the effect of the damming and flow including
existing flows impacting my crops and property subsurface drainage pre-existing the
adjoining developments.
I look forward to, and indeed demand, your corrected analyses forthwith.
since~7J
/{it~
Ron Johnson
Enclosures
C: Mayor and City Council
4 As I previously indicated, then Chief Judge Kevin S. Burke in his May 21, 2004 order found that Shorewood
still had not paid condemnation damages and breached (current holdover City administration) a "settlement
agreement" (by the prior City administration to cure the flooding in lieu of paying damages). The WSB
concept plan was prepared pursuant to the latter as agreed.
5 Since widening my ditch as indicated would be an unacceptable taking I offered to (l) clean out the ditch
myself; (2) donate to the City an easement over the ditch water; and (3) if necessary, donate additional land in
the lower reaches to deepen and enlarge the impoundment area. In contrast MFRA proposed that the Waterford
Place culvert/sewer line be extended to daylight at my southern property boundary and over that a pond north
berm be constructed to isolate its effects on my ditch and property.
'"
-,
.......,
'"
"
'.
" ....
, ............ .-
........_~..~ .....---.'_----.... ----.1
.'. -- ~
~.
./#"";.~.
, ,
11J\LE'&, REPLACE CULVERT .....--- .
~ "
,/, ". "
/ ", ". '
II ...... ~
.' ....-......
:/-- - IIU '
/~/;;\
! I :. ,.":
',,~./:
!
~
i
;
~- \ --1--\ -~~---i! !
-:. . --,._---'.,---_.::,.
-, ----r---...--y..-.-----r- \-:-:-'~"'1 -. -. r
! 1 ! I . . . . ! : I : : : : ! : :: I \
\ __ ~;.,~ _ "'.':_ ! 'EX~ DITCH ...~ ~~~C!~O:B~ ~J!Gr~W~' I t
,. - i,. ---t,_.....-t"", .------
. I,.". ': /". /', ~~i""-' -, -. ~:
i ! t i;!
~ \. I I I Ii' /.. ! .. . .
~~~ : : : \ : .. i.... i . . . , i . , " , I . i .. ;'~", ...-- :-:-: -:. ~~,!,"~:-:---1~." --
....>;\J--~ . .. . .. 1.. -- .. :-.-..~,~-:-:"':"+.. "':-- ....._~. .. .. --
:~~~:...~4~';: :..~;-.-.-:~-:- ~- . ' -"-:~~ . : -: , I ' . . '
, , i ' ., \ . . . . . . . ' \ . . . . \ . . . . i . . . . \ VFI'ST .. 2T~6\ 00" \
-\ \ ---- : 1::1:: :TT I ;~~~ .:~~:
~.- j--------- 't~-l-:.~-:--~T~- , . ~. ~- 1 .
~.. .... ~.. .... t .. .. .. ~ g;;
. -, i
~!.....
iIli....
viti
L H':
---:-1-:--:-; , --.-:--T-:---:-t-:-----i-~-~.:..-+-..-.-....--+------
lDl~ "'1,., CDI- "'I""'" o~:i. ';;':v ~..:. :...,
:,n:; ~l~, ~\:~ ~l~ ~,,- ::~ ;~ ;:,r-_:..
~:~ ~!~ ~!~ ~l~ ;l~ ~!~ \~ ,~
--3--(
~\
...... .., .l.
" "1.(
................. Q
.
.
,
"'
"'
,...
-1&5
.....'--.
--.-""-"',
..t
i
.I
t
/
-
-.z
--
I ..
--r--
-;--
-_.j
.. i ..
N: .-
..~-
.. ~---;
::~ ~,:.~.~.
.;~~~ ...!.,~
;; ~ r;: ;; ~ ;];
"" I -r,
.,.;0(".
.: ..
_!..t
.' ..
....!-::"
'!""I-::'
crt;."
-:-
Crt: :i.
23--<)0
24+00
'..J./
:~
,~
,
,
,,'" ~...,.
/.--. ,""-'- ......./'
I
I
I
\
/
i
EXTEND DITCH E1sT
BV :",: ENOl?
(+
\
"
~
.......""..........
-+-
AS
;I
/' :
,,' ".--'
",,,,,-' ".---
~/ I,"/;':I~-;::::'
! I:l/),"'''' -
, . ...;:.~
" ,". r?--
1..-
o so
I
\00
NOTE: SPOILS DISPOSAL AREA TO BE LOCATEO
BY PROPERTY OWNER.
BENCH MARK ELEV
~
-----~.__._._-+--_.
I -
;
. ~ ----r----
it> ,,;
.. N
.; ....
0- '"
27+00
28--<)0
25+00 26+00
CIlY PROJ. NO.
WSB PROJ. NO. 1074,35
sHEET
t
a=
:a
i
.
-
~
!
IIi
III
I II
itl.
s!-;
1.!1
,-I-
-Ill:
i..!
::iw
iR.;
~t!; i
laii :
930
E-c
~
Z~~
0> ...
l:I.lO~
~~O
O~~
"'-f;I;l
Z.::l~
i~~
ZtI.l
<.
=
c;.)
925
920
915
910
B1'a
!1!
!{'
1-1
gi
..
i!Jn~
~- ...
ii i
:i ~ ~
-.
90S
'"
CI:
<II
~
~
...
900
~II~ ;
<4~d!
895
690
3 Of' 3
SHEETS
~
l"\
",,JI'
-
=~"':
,
RIOG~lTC:'-CRoSSJNG -
-..., --. '.
,
-'-..
..'............
-"-
- "'...
'''\
!
..
BENCH MARK ELEV
930
925
920
915
910
90S
f. 900
...
...
~
.
9 B9s
".
".
1
D
".
lit a90
:.
g,
".
i
t
,
: i ~
":-~~+_-':_+~-~:.f-:_---+------i.:_:--+--_:-+.:...:...t~i----r--l~+.:..:.:t-
~ 1 1 t ~ !
i 'i i i !
, i i i i! i
-,,-,-~-"-"-r-----r-- t -r---r-' ----t-
! !.', l ,! i
I \ \
i: .
i - , . .... .
....;...., !_ !' , ! ...,....l. j. .! "'!' 1....E~lST..ClJL
. . . . i . . . . i . . . . ! . . . . i . . . . i . . . . \ . . . . ! . . . . i . . . . i . . . . i . . . . i . . . . \ . . . - i . . . . I .
. . . . ~ . . . '~l . . . ExptoVAnONj8El.OW .~TER.~~CE. I \ ! i i i . \ . . . . i .
-:-':-:-:'-r:-'~-""'-:-'r'--~T:--.-~--:-r. .\.... i....!... .\... .\.... \.... j... .\... .\.... \.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . : . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
:~:.:=:;,:::~:\=~~-::~:.;.; ~ t;.~ ~ ~:~::"::::A ~~-::f:~~: ~~;: ;::~;=--: ~ r --~-= r ---i~
,.,. . ~' ., -- T'! · i ! i
o .--..,.--t---.-,......---.,--..-,--..;----..-....--t---.-'-----+-.--....---..-4-.-.-'--.--+
o .; i
o
Gi
~--_."---_.~.---r-----.-l -
u
II:
>.
. . . .
..-.-.-..-..--..~......-........--.'.-r-'.-..-....-'--r---
-'r
--~..._..__.-t--'''''---8'
. +
::::\::::;<::
_..._,.....,__.. ...'-_.....-......-",...' ....... -....c
t:-
III
...
L
>
:
---1-------4---
t
\
~
. i .
at: "1
ci-
.: ..
.. ! (":
~;~
. .
--~
, .
0\'"
N;'''
.:~~
~I"
......_..."...._.~-_._. ......,......_.....
,
'"~'"
",i'D
ci~';
;; ~ :;;
. i .
ca:!PI
cr:~-:
o;~
-; -
c7a~:n
, .
. . .
. ' . .
.._~..... ..~.~..,..~_._......____.~'_..._....__ ----r---.-. "'--'r-' ,._,._.....~.. ..'!.....-- ..........._.,~.n.... '
~: ~ :g1 ~ 8 ~ f. :: l ~ ~ : ~ ~ \ :;;
~~;
cii";
7;~~
. , .
....:.....
<<1;-
0\'';
~ ~~;
:l~
.' .
. , .
"" ~ .,. I
""TO
O~.;
;~;;
20+00
0 . . 0 ! .; 0'
",""i..~ -' .. t- o' 0 , .'
.0: .g~ ~~ ;'0; .,. ~ ... , ...
CI" :: ~ '" '" '" !'"'.
15+00 16+00 17+00
O!'"
; ~ i~
21 ..00
18..00
1'3+00
r~
~
a1f'B'1 'a~'1 JaAns 'A.rnw aJ{'B'1 'a~'1 S'BmlS1-I1{O
'a)[9'1 u~dfBD ''B1fUOlcmu~w a)[9'1 JO aUH aJoqs aql
aq Ol paqsnq'BlSa pu-e pauyap S~ ''Ba.m palaalOJd
alp S'B Ol paJ.IaJ8J JalJ8u~8Jaq 'pootAaJoqs JO a~'BI
-UA aql ~l~tA S'BaJ"B UO~l'BA.I~SUoa pu-enatA at{J,
V~HV NOI.LV AH~SNOO aNV'1.L~M. dO .LN~W
-HSI'1HV.LS2: am NOI.LINld~a '~ NOI.L03:S
:sal'BlS OL 'ON a:lu-eu!pJO '~UO!l:laS lY
'awq lBqll"B pa,ya U! IHlS S'BtA OL 'oN a:luuu!pJO
Sal"B:lWu! (';861 '9('; A.rnnu'Bf pal'BP luamn:>op WSO uv
'6L6I pal'BP d'BW spu-enaM. S,Al~O aql 'pU'B ~OL 'oN aaU"BU
-!P.10 ~upuaJaJaJ (WSO) 9L6I palBp ApnlS Jal"BtAtILIOlS
~~L6I pal'BP OL 'oN a:lu'BuW.10 pu-enaM. pu-e Pu-eltAo'1
Sl~ 'CWSO) sd'Bm :lNd'B~odol L961 s,poo.M.a.Ioqs patAa~aJ
oSfB aA"Bq aM. .UI.ItJ SNl JO A'BJdog AHa)i Aq 9661 '~ .1aq
-maAoN P81'Bp lJoda.I a:>u"Bss~uuooaJ aql pa.M.a~a.1 PU'B al~s
aql pal~s~ (VHI!!W) 'auI 'Sal"Bpossy sOOM 1fU'B.Id sqmo~:PW
:aldda)i 'JW .I"Baa
8(';tOl# WdW
AlJado.Id pootAa.Ioqs s,uosuqof :.L03:fHIlS
(';Ot99 "BlOSauu~:w 'snoduauu~w
.look! pu(';(';
laa.IlS qlX~S qlnos 0(';(';
Aaul~ ~ AaS.10a
aldda)i '1' m-enUM. '.IW
9661 's('; JaqmaAoN
xul!! (';C9S-9Lt/(';19 6~Lt-Ltt99
0109-9Lt1619 '9l0Sauu~:w 'qlnomAld
auoqdala.L 'qlJoN anuaAV p.1~('; 09091
':lUI 'Sal'Bpossy sOOM }fUlud sqmoO:lW
'Jall'9l
'9 aA'9a{
Ol al"Bl!
[ ODO'1]
aq lsm
~U~l
IHtA Am
-.mddy
a,qnb:l'9
atH pua
aql a.1o}
'AI~uTIJ
as'9ald 'I
-doJd AU
- Pu-eI ~t
upu-enaM
lOU S'9tA
S.10AaA.Ins
SJ8UU"Bld
sJaau~u~
9~t 'ddy
t
App, 137
Virginia, and the low areas adjoining any water
course and drainageway or body of water subject
to meandering, flowing or overflow, including ar-
eas of marsh, wooded marsh, submerged marsh,
inundation areas as shown upon the attached
wetlands map, Said map is hereby made a part of
this Ordinance and two copies thereof shall re-
side on file of the office of the Village Clerk for
public inspection, (Ordinance No, 70 dated
March 12, 1973,)
locate
the C
1985 J
MFIU
behin<
expos\
done a
statioI
be dor
cantly
There
the dil
lower
upper
bottom
point II
A subsequent Ordinance, Chapter 1102, entitled, ''Wetland
Developments," at 1102,3 contains substantially the same
language. A map captioned Nielsen August 20, 1992,
Exhibit 1, bears the handwritte\l title, "Wetland Ordi-
nance Map (79)," and includes the subject property,
However, prior to the 1984 taking, Johnson's property
would not have been a "lowland adjoining any water
course and drainageway or body of water subject to mean-
dering, flowing or overflowing," Simply stated, the subject
property beyond the ditch boundaries was not a wetland
and, by the language intent of the City Ordinances, No, 70
or Chapter 1102, was not subject to the terms of the
Ordinance prior to the 1984 taking, The property slopes
southwest to a natural drainageway through which the
ditch outlet was dug (USGS & 1967 OSM topos), The scope
and effect of the ditch on Mr, Johnson's property lowered
the water table and eliminated surface ponding as obvi- .
ously intended. (Bopray report,)
MFRA estimates that roughly 2,740 cubic yards of spoil
was excavated and placed in intermittent piles along and
approximately 15 feet from the ditch banks, The ditch was
dug long ago as indicated by mature trees growing in the
spoil and mature (10-1211 diameter) stumps at the 912
contour which grew inside the ditch banks. These were
Shore\'
(OSM)
storm"
procurl
north (
drainal
storm",
The h)
with G
over ar
culvert
the SUI
have b
range c
would
OSM d
,
'l,,""J
~.
'O:>saA!-IJ. Sal"B:>~pu~ 'tS61 'f: A{I\f pal"Bp luamn:>op WSO
UV 'lanno q:>l~P aql JO UO!l"B{I\d~m "B a+nl!lsuo:> P{I\OM
J1asl! 906 l"B la101 +1aA{I\:> a"tn l"BL(l q:>ns t06 Ol ~06 JO a~u-e~
A1a~ aql ~ uorrBAa1a sNl M01aq. pal"BA"B:>xa uaaq aA"Bt{
P1noM. q:>ln> at{.L . A"BM.a~"BUre~ reml"BU a"t{l JO a:>"BJms at{l
JO uO~l"BAa1a aql l"B ny: tn.Iaq aql t{~no~l pa:>"B1d S"BM +1aA{I\J
~alam-an> 119f: y 'A"B.M.a~"BUre~ paq:>l~ at{l sso~:>"B PU"B ~aAO
tn.Iaq laa~lS a:>"BlcI p~oFal"B.M. aql JO uoq:>tu.lsuo:> AlK) ql!M.
t861 U! pa~u-eq:> pU"B{.M.O{ paq:>l~ aql JO ~oIo~PAq attI,
'pal"B{I\d~tXI s-8.M.lanno aql ssa'(Ufi ~al"BMtn.IOlS
puod lOU PlnoM. A+1ado~d alp 'lanno aql pUll q:>ln> a~"BU1"B~P
aql Ol anp '~aAaM.OH '(q:>l~ aql JO p"Baq aql .mau) q+10U
at{l mo.IJ sa~~"Bq:>sW ~al"8M.tn.IOlS ~OJ sluamas-ea a~n:>o~d
AlK) aql papuaunno:>a~ 1I 'U!S"Bq ~U~Ptoq ~al-e.M.tn.IolS
"B S"B A+1ado~d aql asn ol papUalU! AlK) aql Sal"B:>WU! (WSO)
ApnlS ~al"BM.tII.IOlS aA!suaqa.Idmo;) gL61 S,poo.M.a.Ioqs
'qJHP aql JO q~uaI lU10d
p~ aql l1:l 016 Ol sado{s PU1:I ~16 UOp"BAa{a l"B s1 mo~noq
qJlW aql p1:laq Sl~ lY 'qJl!P aql JO suo~~od p~ pu-e .Iaddn
aql U! Ul:Iql SlUa1p"B~ q:>l!P .Iaq~!t{ pUl:l SUO~l"8Aa{a ~aM.01
AnUl:l;)Y:~~s pal-eJWu~ suo!l1:lJOI asat{.1 'monoq qJl!P aql
aAoq1:l lHs aql u~ sfioI ~Upt~lS 'paqo~d S"B.M. t{JlW aql a.Iat{.L
'lua~as AlHs dn-lunq Ol anp al~s aql ~u~qmls~ Anu-e:>
-y:~~s lnoql!M. TPl!P aql JO saq:>1:IaI .IaM.oI aql U1 auop aq
lOU P{I\o:> s!'ltL 'a~p~q lOOJ aql JO lS"Ba laaj 06 'gL+S UO~l"BlS
Ol 00+0 UOnlllS l1:l p1:laq q:>lW uaaM.laq SUO~l"B:>ol 9~ l"B auop
S"BM. s~ 'ent.mm la]{:>nq aUH~"B~ palJ"Bdmo:> JO a.msodxa
aql ~~pnpu! AaA.InS aql ~~p paAOmaJ lHs pUNaq
pUl:l .Iapun UO!l:>asSOJ:> q:>lW reu~~o aql pal"BJOl VHdW
(A"B~doH ~uosJalad) 'sDtoqd l-e~a"B AlUrtO:) u~dauuaH 9861
PU1:I gL61 aqlll1 pug (WSO) At{d1:l~odol L961 SIAl!:) aql
uo pal-e:>WU! S! q:>l!P at{.L 'a~p~q lOOj aql JO lS"Ba pal-e;)OI
a.IaM
~T6 ~
aql U
Sl:I.M.q
PU"B ~
Hods .
. -~qo
pa.IaM
ado;)s
aql q;
sadols
aql JO
OL 'oN
pu-ena
pafqn!
-U"Bam
.Ial1:lM.
A+1ado.
"A:}.Iado
-~p.IO .
'~66T
aures a
pU"Bna 1
pa:
.10]
-a.I
jO:
pal
't{S
-.re
lJa
.Ial
8Rl 'ddy
App. 139
developer of the south and west adjoining Waterford
Subdivision, requested Shorewood to raise the culvert
above the ditch bottom to create a pond or, alternately,
deepen the ditch bottom, The topo and as-builts (OSM)
indicate the City chose the former approach,
The culvert inlet north of the Waterford Place berm is not
to daylight, A 36" diameter plugged T-section with vertical
riser was added. The riser was a 6'1 diameter inlet at
909,98, a 12" diameter inlet at 911.40 and a 36" diameter
drop inlet at 914,08 (OSM), This further manipulated the
ditch outlet, During fair weather the resultant ponded
water level had been observed at or near 911.5 (Waterford
2nd Addition as-built by S&M, August 28, 1986; Court
Order August 17, 1983, finding No, 18; Bopray report
photo near station 11+50 mid October 1995). During
moderate to heavy rainfall events, events having frequen-
cies of recurrence of less than once per year, the water
level would rise to 914. The design high-water level is
917,1 (OSM),
whi
WIU
MFRA staked the 914 contour in the ditch to its head,
(Bopray photo and Existing Conditions Exhibits), The
bottom of the stakes were placed at elevation 914, This is
the elevation of the 36" diameter drop inlet of the City's
control structure. The smaller control structure orifices at
910 and 911,5 would only provide limited capacity outlet.
Simply stated, the bottom of the stakes are at the eleva-
tion to which the City substantially raised Mr. Johnson's
ditch outlet, The ditch contour 914 is outside the ditch
banks in the lower reaches; is at the bank top 100 feet
west of the foot bridge; and is nearly at the top in the mid
portion of the ditch, A taking to elevation 914 substan-
tially eliminated the scope and effect of the ditch and
would reduce the effect of the natural surface drainageway
In 1
son
frer
thn
dis<
adje
Hill
Ash
ofT .
cont
froD
and
bad
pOlD
di tel
Wat
tion
proJ'
sout
198~
Off-~
east
to p
nort:
di tel
resp'
UppE
and,
builc
..........-...-;.
~-, ..,
...n.:~.
...:~~
.tPl1P aq+ U~ dn PUnq
Plnoh\ 'lua~-e~ qal~p al-enbap-e Aq p~.reap ssapm 'pu-e
q:>l~ aql U1 dn spua saamos q:>ns tIIo.Ij lHS 'saq:>-ea~ ~addn
Sl1 u~ sasd-eno:> ~q qal~ ql-Iou lua:>a~ ~oJ alq1suodsa~
aq Ol smadd-e s"!ll.L ('sodOl WSO ~l-Ioda~ A-e~dog) .tPl1P
atll Ol samn.3 .8U1qs-eM U1 pallnsa.I aUH A1.Iado.Id ql-Iou
aql .8UOl"B .Ial-eM. papuod at.{J. . L I6 uonllAala l-e puod. Ol
~al-eM. pasn-e:> pu-e lIa~-e aql OllUatII~aS pal1sodap aA-eq ls-ea
pu-e ql-IOU aql tIIO.Ij A1.Iado~d atll OluO sa.8.retl:>s~ al1s-lJO
('odOl WSO L961 ~.Ia~naI 17861
l:>~s1a paqs~al-e 111) 'au~-e~ aql ~no.rql A1.Iado~d qlnos
.8u1U10fp-e aql uo 006 Ol a.8-eupup l"B~nl-eu p-eq 'l:>afo~d
17861 aql Ol ~o~CI 'q:>NM. 'pullIMoI aql .IeAO ,[,6I6 JO uon
-uAala p.reoqaa.Ij u~IdpoolJ -e pasodtII1 p~ls1a paqs.Ial-eM
at.{J. 'q+.8uaI Sl~ JO Al~Or-eUI aql lnot{.8no.It{l qu-eq qOl1P
aql puoAaq pu-e ~aAO puod prnOM. ~al-eM l'LI6 lV 'lu10d
-p~ Sl~ III sdOl ~q aql Ol AI.reau pu-e puaq sl1 Ol dn-JI:mq
prnOM tPl~ aql tI6 lV ('Ul-ep p~lS~a paqs~elu fA pUB
WSO) 'luaAa ,,9 II .IO} l'L 160+ pUll luaAa Il"BJU~.I IIg.t 11 tIIO~J
tt6 Ol as~ Ol .IalllM. aql asnllo prnOM. 'amla~ls IO~luo:>
aql pu-e m.zaq aql Aq dn-paJIo-eq 'sa~unos asaql tIIO~J JJo
-unH 'Al-Iado~d aql OlUO a.8.r-eq:>s~ 'lUatIIdoIaAap uo~:>qsV
~66I .8~ofpu ls-ea UIO.Ij sso~ou 'al"BMSnn:>-qm:> PllOH lUH
a~A aql pu-e l-IaAlno u01s~~qns surn Apu-eS .8u!U10fpll
ql-IOU "t~ aql 'q:>+1P aqlJo pua .Iaddn aql .reaN 'a.8.r-eqos1P
(.Ialam-ew IIt~ ..I~ '..8I) s~aM.as m.zOlS p~opalu.M aa.It{l
'm.zaq aql tIIo.Ij m-ea.Ilsdn 'sluamdolaAap .8u!U~ofp-e tIIo.IJ
al!S aq'.}. Ol sa.8.reqos~ JJo-un.I. Aq pal:>udtII~ s~ Al-Iado.Id uos
-Ut{or aql 'lanno qO'l~ aql JO u01lUrnd!UlltII Ol uon~pll uI
'.8np SUM
qOlW aql a~oJaq aun Al-Iado~d aql lU 806 'l-e lanno q:>NM
A-eM.a.8-eUl
pu-e qo:m
-u-elsqns
p~ aq'l t:
laa] OOt
qOlW aql
s,uosUt{O[
--eAala aq:
'lallno At'
III saom-zc
S.Al1D aqi
s~ sNJ. '17
at{.L '(S'l~(
'puaq Sl~
s~ IaAal ~
~al-elt\ aqi
-uanba~J ~
.8u~a ,(
1.Ioda~ AU.
1.InoD ~98
p~o.J.1al-e M
papuod II
aql pal-eln
~alaUIu~p I
lU laru~ ~
l"Bo~1.IaA ql
'lou s~ tIUa
(WSO) Sll
'Alal-eU.Iall
l-IaAlno at
p~o.J.1alu fA
O-v1 'ddV
App, 141
In addition to manipulation of the ditch outlet elevation
and discharges to the site, the 9-itch's hydraulic gradient
has been manipulated, The original ditch gradient indi-
cates that prior to the 1984 taking, higher water velocities
would have carried silt to the City designated wetland
south of Waterford, There the gradient levels off which
could allow silt to settle out prior to entering the Purga-
tory Creek ditch, Since 1984, additional silt discharges to
Mr, Johnson's site backed-up by the berm would result in
more silt and lower water velocities allowing silt to settle
in the ditch, A silt mound (elevation 912,6) had built-up in
the lower reaches of the ditch higher than the ditch bottom
elevation at the head. Water standing in the mid-section of
the ditch would reduce its scope and effect, Without
maiptenance, silt accumulations would be expected to
continue up the ditch beyond the southwest portion of the
property, This maintenance task would apparently be left
to the landowner, Mr, Johnson, It is reasonable to con-
clude that he would have to perform minor ditch mainte-
nance through the built-up silt tq, at best, utilize the
limited capacity 910 and 912 control structure outlets,
A retrofit for the City's Waterford system would be unplug
and extend the culvert inlet to daylight at the property
line and wrap the berm completely around the pond
created by the control structure. At the upper end of the
ditch, a curb and catch basin retrofit on the west side of
Vine Hill Road could return Ashcroft Subdivision run-off
back to the existing Minnetonka storm sewer east of the
road, The Shady Hills Subdivision 24" storm sewer could
be extended down the slope north of the property line and
buried under Mr, Johnson's land discharging directly into
his ditch, Altogether, these improvements would cost on
the order of $50,000 (1995),
The
Sew.
stub
platt
Wed
lots,
sam.
prop
lots.
nortJ
1m pc:!
deve:
requ
Whel
WatE
Impo
Acce:
later
Outl.
hIe u
modi
a str,
propl
could
the I
exter
cept'
FinaJ
oped
knoll
u-e +-toddns PlnoM. tp~qM. PU-SIM.OI aql u~ pa.1awao nOIDl
pu-eldn Utl paluooI W.!IW 'aStla.10tl tIUtlJ AqqOq OlU~ pado
-laAap aq Ol ItlnualOd puq PUtllM.OI paqol~p aql 'AntlU~.i[
'Su~SS0.10 laa.1lS aql JO lStla qalW aqlldaa
-.1alU~ Ol uosuqor '.1W Aq ls-eaq+-tou paU.1nl PUtl papua':p'a
.Iaq+-tnJ aq PInoo l.IaAlna aql 'qalW aql JO ql.IOU slol aql
Ol ssaaau ap~o.Id OJ. 'laa.Ils MaU sNl .Iapun paatlld aq Plnoa
'puod aql ~U~SStldAq uo~sua':p'a +-taAma al.{J. 'auH Al.1ado.Id
atH Oll.IaArnO qal!P aql pualxa Ol asoqo Al~O at{l J~ laa.1lS tl
apu.tS Ol UY fSuonwpu l.IOdUI~ Plnoa uosUt{o r '.1Vi 'paYTI'om
a.1aM. lanno sNl .IaAO suo~la~lsa.I paep lua.z-eddtl Jl 'asn a1q
-!ltldmoa u aq prnOM laa.Ils Y 'AlK) aql Aq pauM.o Y lOnno
p.IOpalU M ~ S~ puod al.{J. 'aatl1d p.10paltl M Ol Itl.1alU1
puod p.IOpaltl M. aql JO lStla pap~o.Id aq prnoa ssaoay
'ssaOOtllSaMql.IOU sapnpa.zd lOnno aql uo pasodm~
Anuanbasqns suona~lSa.I paap lUa.Itlddtl '(ap.1!O p.IOpalUM.
.
~u!ssasstl 0 lOnno p.10palU M) papualu~ StlM. sNl a.Iat{M.
'aun Al.Iado.Id aql Ol lq~no.Iq slaatlS p.1oparSM pa.1!nba.1
aoUtlu~p.IO AlK) 'slol 6 y-euomppu u-s JO luamd01aAap
su~pnpa.1d pa~polPUtlI S! 1I 'ua.zv UOntlA.Iasuoo pasodm!
at{l pUt! SU~l aql Aq pa.1aAaS uaaq sut{ 1ao.z-ed lsaMt{+-tOU
aqJ, ("SlUnq-su Al~O pUt! omam tS61 'E Arnr ViSO) 'slol
t .10j sqnls &mnn palotulsuoa Al!:J at{l pu-e slol t pasodo.1d
oasaA~ 'slol ap.I!O p.IOpaltl M. a1q~ssod t Ol 1 t{l~M. au:res
at{l ~tl~al~a sNl .Iapun alqtllltlld aq lOU prnOM t .10 E 'Slol
lUH aU~A a1qtlHtlAU 9 JO lno 'tla.zv uO!ltlA.IasuoD pU'8na M.
tl ap~su~ (laaJ a.I-enbs OOO'Og) tla.I'8 lOI mnUI~~ S~ll-eld
SMolfSsW aau-euw.IO Al~O '.1aAaM.oH 'Al.Iado.Id aql Ol sqnls
pu-e lspca pUO([ urn aU~A aql u~ sanmln .IawM. putl.IaM.as
'SAtlM. .Iaqlo U~ Al.Iado.1d aql pala-edUI~ SU~l tS61 aqJ,
Zt{ 'ddy
App, 143
agricultural building site (as outlined by Mr, Johnson)
with access east and west along the'ditch bank,
Very truly yours,
McCOMBS FRANK ROOS ASSOCIATES, INC,
Is! Gregory J, Franke
Gregory J, Frank, P,E,
Is! Kelly J, Bopray
Kelly J, Bopray, CPSS
Certified Professional Soil Scientist