HomeMy WebLinkAbout042400 CC Reg AgP
i"
. ...
...
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, APRIL 24, 2000
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
1. CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
A. Roll Call
Garfunkel____
Lizee
Zerby _
Mayor Love_
Stover
B. Review Agenda
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. City Council Special Meeting Minutes, April 10, 2090 (Att.-#2A Minutes)
B. City Council Regular Meeting Minutes, April 10, 2000 (Att.-#2B Minutes)
C. City Council Special Meeting Minutes, April 18, 2000 (Att.-#2C Minutes)
3. CONSENT AGENDA - Motion to approve items on Consent Agenda & Adopt Resolutions
Therein:
NOTE: Give the public an opportunity to request an item be removed from the
Consent Agenda. Comments can be ttzken or questions askedfollowing removal from
Consent Agenda.
A. Motion adopting a resolution making Commission appointments (Att.-#3A)
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR (No Council action will be taken.)
5. PARKS - Report by Representative
A. Report on Park Commission Meeting Held April 11, 2000 (Att.-#5A Draft Minutes)
6. PLANNING - Report by Representative
A. A Motion to Direct Staff to Prepare a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit
Applicant: U.S. West
Location: 19395 State Highway 7
'..,
.~
..
..
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA-APRIL 24, 2000
Page 2 of2
B. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit (Att.-#6B
Planner's Memorandum, Engineer's Memorandum, Resident E-mails, School District
Letter, Proposed Resolution, Draft Lease Agreement)
Applicant: AT&T
Location: 26352 Smithtown Road
C. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit ( Att.-#6C
Planner's Memorandum, Proposed Resolution)
Applicant: Basim Sabris
Location: 6125 Apple Road
D. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Making Certain Amendments to the Tree Preservation
and Reforestation Policy (Att.-#6D Proposed Resolution)
7. GENERAL
A. Discussion of Proposed Revisions to Joint Powers Agreement for Fire Services (Att.-#7A)
B. Direct Staff to Prepare Request for Proposals for Strategic Planning Consultant Services
8. ENGINEERING/PUBLIC WORKS
A. Discussion Regarding Leave of Absence - Public Works (Att.-#8A Engineer's
Memorandum)
9. REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
I. Gideon Glen
2. Skate Park
3. Freeman Park Multipurpose Building
4. Finance Director Position
5. Administrator Position
6. Southshore Senior Center
B. Mayor & City Council
10. ADJOURN SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF CLAIMS (Att.-#10)
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us'cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
Executive Summary
Shorewood City Council Regular Meeting
Monday, 24 April 2000
.,
#.J
f'~1
'.
Reminder: The Board of Review will reconvene at 6:00 P.M. before the regular meeting.
:<
Agenda Item #3A: The Park and Planning Commission appointments were adopted on February
28, 2000. This item is a housekeeping task which appoints the Park and Planning
Commission Chairperson and Vice Chairperson for the year 2000.
Agenda Item #6A: Garrett Lysiak, the City's Telecommunications consultant, will be present to
address issues of coverage related to US West's request for a conditional use permit at
19395 State Highway 7. Since we are running out of time on the 601120-day rule, it is
necessary for the Council to direct staff to prepare a resolution and findings of fact for the
next meeting. Approval of the conditional use permit requires a four-fifths vote by the
Council.
.' f.
. '1
"
"
t '
. , 0
:-- ~
~' . ~
": "'-
~Iol'!
~r ;~
i ," of
F~
eo
Agenda Item #6B: In March of this year the Planning Commission held a public hearing to
consider a request by AT&T Wireless Services to locate telecommunications equipment
at the west end water tower site (Minnewashta). The Commission voted unanimously to
recommend approval of the Conditional Use Permit. We have since received comments
from the School District per our easement agreement for the property. It is worth noting
that the proposed equipment building is being constructed large enough to house an
additional carrier, so as to avoid another building in the future. In addition to staff
reports, a proposed resolution is included in the packet. Also, a draft lease agreement is
provided for your review. Approval of the Conditional Use Permit requires a four-fifths
vote by the City Council. It is recommended that approval be conditioned upon
execution of the lease agreement and the City's ability to obtain a utility easement on the
west side of the school parking lot.
Agenda Item #6C: The Planning Commission has voted unanimously to recommend approval of
a Conditional Use Permit that would allow Basim Sabris to build an attached garage on
his property at 6125 Apple Road. The request complies with the requirements of
Shorewood's Zoning Code. The Commission attached a number of conditions relative to
maintenance of the property and the existing nonconforming barn on the property.
Approval requires a four-fifths vote by the Council.
n
~.1 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Executive Summary ....; City Council meeting of April 24, 2000
Page 2 of2
Agenda Item #6D: At the last meeting staff presented three proposed areas of change to the
City's Tree Preservation and Reforestation Policy. The resolution containing these
changes will be delivered under separate cover. Approval of the resolution requires a
simple majority vote.
Agenda Item #7 A: We are soooooo close on this! Apparently there is consensus of four of the
South Lake cities on the joint powers agreement for fire services. Hopefully, with some
minor modifications, the fifth will jump on board. The proposed revisions are being
drafted as this is being written and will be delivered under separate cover.
Agenda Item #7B: This ball has been bobbled a bit, but not dropped! This year's budget
allocates $6000 for consultant services relative to strategic planning. This appears to be
the next step. The Council should direct staff to prepare an RFP for these consultant
services.
Agenda Item #8A: The City Council requested that this item appear on this agenda, regarding the
leave of absence for Mr. Jeff Jensen. Due to the timing of the leave, it is desirable to
review the needs for the Public Works Department for the coming season.
.
.
~ 0'
.
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING
MONDAY, APRIL 10,2000
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
6:00 P.M.
MINUTES
Do t\ 1:1
.. i-~t\ I
1.
CONVENE SPECIAL MEETING
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m.
A.
Roll Call
Present:
Mayor Woody Love, Councilmembers Zerby, Garfunkel, Lizee and Stover; Public
Works DirectorlEngineer Brown, Planning Director Nielsen; Friends of the Southshore
Senior Community Center: Bob Gagne, Lee Paris, Jim Hillis, Glen Froberg, J oAnn
Kvem, Dorothy Huffman, Bob Bean, Karla Thomson, Joyce Flury and Phil Hallin.
Absent:
None
B. Review Agenda
Mayor Love made a correction to the agenda, noting this meeting is a "Special Meeting" and not an
"Executive Session."
Lizee moved, Zerby seconded, approving the agenda as amended. Motion passed 5/0.
2. MEETING WITH THE FRIENDS OF THE SOUmSHORE SENIOR COMMUNITY
CENTER
Mayor Love stated the intent of this meeting is to facilitate communication to better handle issues that
may come up in the future.
Director Brown reviewed the current issue at hand. He stated that the Friends previously submitted a bill
to the City for $1537.41 for repair of the HV AC system at the Southshore Senior Community Center. He
stated the Friends felt that this repair item arose due to improper original construction and not due to
maintenance of the HV AC system. Director Brown noted that because this work was completed by a
contractor ordered by the Friends, Merit Heating and Cooling, it prohibits the City from being able to
seek reimbursement from the bonding company, the original contractor or the original sub-contractor for
the project. Staff felt it was not appropriate for the City to pay for a bill without first seeking resolution
through the bonding company. Director Brown noted that this has been a long-standing issue and that the
City has been in litigation with the bonding company. He stated that Staff supports the effort of the
Friends and expressed the importance of identifying the responsibilities of each party to better handle
these types of issues in the future.
Mayor Love opened the discussion to all those present and stated his interest in the process used for the
claim.
~J-ft
." '!
.
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING - April 10, 2000
Page 2 of 4
Mr. Gagne clarified the breakdown of the bill and the work that was completed by Merit on the HV AC
system. He reported on the details of the incident that occurred which created the bill. He stated that due
to past history of contacting the City with maintenance issues and knowing that the City was in litigation,
the Friends determined that this was a problem which needed immediate attention. He clarified that
Merit determined that the HV AC system was not constructed correctly.
Mr. Bean stated that none of the original subcontractors want anything to do with this project because of
the bad situation they were in with the general contractor. He expressed the efforts the Friends made in
accommodating the original construction schedule and in their fundraising efforts. He feels that the
Friends should not have to pay to redo something that was not done right in the first place. Mr. Bean
also expressed that although this is a frustrating issue, the Friends appreciate the leadership Shorewood
took and continues to take on this project. He questioned the schedule for work to be completed on the
fire hydrant and the parking lot.
Director Brown expressed that City staff has also faced frustration with this project. He stated that the
Friends should expect to see some action on the work to be completed in a couple of months. He noted
that Staff would need to discuss the scheduling of this work with the Friends. .
Councilmember Stover questioned how issues like this would be handled in the future.
Mayor Love noted that the purpose of this meeting is not only to discuss this specific issue with this bill,
but also to determine a process for dealing with these issues in the future.
Ms. Kvern expressed her positive experience with those who have rented the building and how much
they appreciate the facility. She stated that having a facility for seniors shows the community cares about
its aged population.
Ms. Flury also noted that the facility is used not only for the senior residents, but it is also being used
more as a community center.
Mr. Froberg questioned how the Friends should handle future problems that may arise that might be
determined to be defective original equipment. He noted that this particular situation was a matter that .
had to be attended to immediately, so the Friends took immediate action that was required of them and
incurred this particular charge.
Mr. Bean stated that because the Friends couldn't get the original contractor to do work, they hired Merit
and have continued to use Merit since they are familiar with the system.
Engineer Brown stated that he didn't see harm in specifically having Merit do the work. This particular
issue is with the Friends calling out a contractor prior to Staff having an opportunity notify the bonding
company. This process nullified the City's claim to resolve this issue.
Mayor Love confirmed that the building is an asset to the community. He also expressed his concern
that the City was bumped out of its position of recourse.
Councilmember Garfunkel confirmed that the City has no recourse on this item; that is it not possible to
go back to the bonding company. He didn't feel this was a Shorewood issue now.
II . "if'
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING - April 10, 2000
Page 3 of 4
Mr. Gagne stated that the Friends brought this back to Shorewood based on history, noting that of the
five cities involved, Shorewood took the lead on this project.
Councilmember Zerby expressed that there seems to be an expectation of warranty on this building, and
questioned how much warranty service the City can provide.
Councilmember Stover asked what alternative did the Friends have when this situation occurred.
Mayor Love asked Engineer Brown what process would have changed his recommendation on this issue.
Engineer Brown stated his understanding of the service Merit provided which created the bill.
Mr. Gagne clarified that Merit had been out two days prior to work on the system and the Friends paid
that bill which was $145. He stated that the HV AC system was turned on, it didn't work properly, so the
Friends called Merit a second time. They determined they needed to contact Trane and both Trane and
Merit came out to repair the system, which created the bill for $1537.41.
.
Engineer Brown noted that if a warranty issue exists, the City has to notify the bonding company of the
plan of action to fix the problem. It is hoped that the bonding company would respond immediately to
the request. This communication with the bonding company puts them on notice legally that there is a
problem. Engineer Brown clarified that if there is a warranty issue or if something major goes wrong
with the Building, the Friends should call him.
Ms. K vern stated that in her past experience with the former Administration, she got the impression that
the Friends should not call Engineer Brown. She agreed that the procedure is probably correct if the
Friends could simply say we have a problem and if they were told they could correct it. She felt though,
from past history, this doesn't look like it will work.
.
Councilmember Stover stated that Shorewood took the lead in this project. She stated that they hired the
contractor; they had the money and got some money from other cities. She expressed that Shorewood
took responsibility for the building and that the council at that time had every intention of having the
building fully completed before it was turned over to the Friends. The building didn't get done on
schedule, but the Friends were willing to take it over anyhow. She believes the council should keep some
of that past history in mind. She believes this is an issue of a malfunctioning system and not a
maintenance item. She also noted there remains an outstanding punch list of items to be completed on
this project.
Mayor Love stated that staff based their recommendation on Shorewood not having any recourse for this
item. He expressed the importance of establishing a process to avoid having this kind of
misunderstanding in the future.
Mr. Bean noted the revenue loss the Friends suffered from failure to occupy the building when promised,
noting the $500 per diem penalty for failure to take occupancy. There was never a final resolution on
what this revenue number might be or if the Friends will see any of this lost revenue come out of the
litigation.
Mayor Love asked if council was in clear agreement on how to proceed. He expressed that we need to
come up with an agreement that clearly states how to handle future items.
-i!'-' "
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING - April 10, 2000
Page 4 of 4
Ms. Flury commented that the Friends didn't have any guidelines for this particular issue. They didn't
know that they were putting the City in a position of not having recourse.
Mr. Bean stated that the Friends will take whatever direction is decided relative to calling Engineer
Brown. He asked for clarification in defining what types of situations or items require the Friends to first
contact Engineer Brown.
Mayor Love requested Engineer Brown to put together a proposal. Mayor Love, Engineer Brown,
Acting City Administrator Nielsen and Mr. Gagne and any other Friends representatives could meet to
discuss the procedure and define issues which would require the Friends to contact Engineer Brown
when problems arise. It is hoped that this can be completed within the next couple of weeks and reported
on at the next council meeting.
Mr. Bean noted that it will be necessary to come up with a new vendor list, for plumbing, heating, etc.
Engineer Brown stated that there are certain things, like the sprinkler system, that both he and the Public
Works crew are trained to repair and that they are on call for major items like this.
Mayor Love noted that the Council will considered this particular incident at tonight's Regular Council
meeting and will report back to the Friends Board on establishing a procedure for future issues.
.
On behalf ofthe.Council, Mayor Love thanked everyone in attendance at the meeting.
3. ADJOURN
Garfunkel moved, Lizee seconded adjourning the Special Meeting with the Friends of the
Southshore Senior Community Center at 6:55 p.m.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.
Jean Panchyshyn,
Recording Secretary
.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
BRADLEY J. NIELSEN, ACTING CITY ADMINISTRATOR
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
MONDAY, APRIL 10, 2000
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
n RJ\fl
1.
CONVENE CITY COUNCIL MEETING
Mayor Woody Love called the meeting to order at 7 :03 p.m.
A.
RoD Call
Present:
Mayor Love, Councilmembers Garfunkel, Lizee, Zerby and Stover; City Attorney Keane;
Planning Director Nielsen, Public Works Director/Engineer Brown
Absent:
None
.
B.
Review Agenda
Director Nielsen noted that a resolution was not available for Item 6C but requested this item remain on
the agenda for discussion only.
Garfunkel moved, Zerby seconded approving the Agenda as amended. Motion passed 5/0.
C. Presentation of Pre-Board of Review Report by City Assessor Tom Carroll and
Rob Winge
Tom Carroll presented the 1999 sales books to the Council and explained the process. used in determining
assessments. He noted that he has received over 100 phone calls and is currently conducting reviews on
32 properties. If further review is needed, property owners may come to the Board of Review meeting on
Monday, April 17. The Council thanked Mr. Carroll for his report.
.
D.
Report by Tom Skramstad - LMCD
Tom Skramstad, LMCD representative, reported on the items as detailed in his April 5 written report. He
noted the biggest issue being Cruiser's Cove at Big Island. Other items he reported on included plans for
harvesting Eurasian Water Milfoil, the public education program for Zebra Mussels, the Marina re-
development program, a boat density survey, a user attitude survey, water quality issues and liquor and
dock license renewals.
Councilmember Lizee asked Mr. Skramstad for the LMCD's assistance in finding volunteers for the 4th
of July events on Lake Minnetonka in the City of Excelsior, specifically water patrol duties for the
fireworks. Mr. Skramstad stated he would be happy to try to help out in this event.
Mr. Skramstad will provide quarterly reports to the Council on the LMCD activities and additional
reports if other issues come up which would require more frequent notices. The Council thanked Mr.
Skramstad for his report.
t/f3Jj
<=
<=
<=
M
=
~
~
<
I
r.n
~
p
~
~
~
~
~
~
<
~
p
~
~
~
=
U
Z<=
p~
0....
U 0
~~
I-l ell
Ut:l..
00
~
;;;J
~
~
o
~
<
>
o
~
t
<
~
=
=
=
N
r-:
N
.c:
~
~
~
i
=
=
~
~
=
~
0)
0)
~
=
o
...
II}
fJ
00
~
~
=
CJ
0)
~
~
r-:
("l
.c:
CJ
""
~
~
"Q
fJ .
..."tS
= 0)
= .5
~!
~,.Q
= ~
~~
O),.Q
0) ""
~~
="tS
.$l =
I:I.l ~
II} ""
0) 0)
00 ~
0) 0
~...
~oo
= ~
CJ 0)
~,.Q
~ 5
0) 0)
~.a
bfl'O
= =
'5: =
o 0
""U
=.,.
=.,~
~ff"l
"'''Cl
"Cl 0)
i ~
o =.,
~ =
I:I.l 0
~;::
'0) 0
.~ ~
~.
"'''Cl
"0 0)
0)...
~=
o 5
5,.Q
- =
0) I:I.l
~ I:I.l
= ~
cE=
~=
~~
-
...
CJ
=
=
o
U
.e-
U
<
=
=
=
N
r-:
("l
.c:
~
~
~
i
=
=
~
bfl
=
~
0)
~
""
~
i
~
I:I.l
~
=
=
=
("l
r-:
("l
.c:
~
~
~
....
o
fJ-o
... 0)
= =
= .~
~~
~,.Q
= ~
... ~
~-e
~~
",,"0
~ =
- ~
~""
0) ~
~ 0
0)'"
.c:oo
... I:I.l
bfl""
= 0)
'5: ,.Q
e ~
=.,5
Q.=
~ CJ
'" =
"Cl =
0) 0
"ClU
= .
0=
~~
II} "0
0) 0)
'0) I:I.l
.~ ~
~=.,
'" =
"Cl 0
O)~
~ 0
e~
-
...
CJ
=
=
o
U
.e-
U
~
- .
0)"Cl
~ 0)
=t:
= ...
t: 5
~,.Q
~ ;l
r-:-
("l
.c:
~
~
~
=
=
=
("l
r-:
("l
.c:
~
~
~
i
...
=
=
~
bfl
=
...
...
0)
0)
~
=
o
...
II}
fJ
00
~
""
o
~
....
o
~'ti
... 0)
= .5
.5 ~
~j
~~
= ~
~,.Q
0) ""
0) 0)
~N
"Cl
= =
o ~
'!iJ ""
fJ 0)
00 ~
...
~oo
~ ~
~~
0) 5
.c: 0)
... 5
c.>=
= CJ
'5: =
o =
"" 0
=.,u
=.,.
~~
"'ff"l
"0"0
0) 0)
"Cl I:I.l
S ~
CJ =.,
~ =
o
,~ ~
N 0
:S~
-
...
CJ
=
=
o
U
.e-
U
"'-0
"0 0)
~t:
o ...
5 5
,.Q
- =
0) I:I.l
~ I:I.l
= ~
cE=
~=
~~
u
.
<
~
~
~
<
~
Z
~
00
Z
o
U
'"
Q)
-
-
::l
0..
Q)
.0
Cl
('l")
S
Q)
,::
'"
Q)
.....
Vl
Q)
g.
e
Q)
'Q)
N
;.J
I-<
Q)
.0
S
~
'u
c::
::l
o .
UCl
. r-
~ S
53 2
00-
<2
i:5Cl
Q)('t')
~ S
o Q)
U,::
Q)'"
.c:: Q)
..... >
S ~
S ~
Q) 0
.-::: ...:l
Q) I-<
..c:: 0
..... ~
]~
e d
Q) 0
> .....
o ~
...:l ::l
I-< ~
o .....
;>-,"0
co;! I-<
~r.8
l"'i
"0
=
~
~
"Cl
=
0)
~
<
...
=
0)
II}
=
o
U
0)
~
=
o
"0
0)
=
] ..
=~
8 5
0)
1:I.l'"
=~
0....
~ 0
o =
~:8
0) ec
oS CJ
~
bflO)
= 0)
'5: .=
0'"
"".=
=.,;;:
=.,~
< '"
=
'" ...
~ f
"tS ~
=-
0'"
~ ~
I:I.l 0
~;:
,.Q":
"" 0
0) II}
N~
-00)
O).c:
~ ...
o ~
5~
0) =.,
'QJ 0
.~ "0
~-<
bfl
=
...
"0
""
~
~
-<
'g
~
II}
"Cl
=
bfl
=
~
=.,
QJ
CJ
CJ
1-
("l
ff"l
=
I
=
=
o
Z
z=:
Os
~~
S~
~ct::
0...
oo~
~1
~
~3
...
...;;..,
=""0
o ~
"0.=
~l
.$l CJ
o e
~=
o
-<u
<
""
QJ
~
...
-
~
.c:
l:l.
<
=
~
""
oS
II)
"0
=
rZ
....
o
f
.a
:a
=
QJ
a-
~
bfl
=
.~
'C
o
~
=
-<
=
o
...
...
o
~
<
~
.
""
QJ
~
o
~
""
~
~
~
""
oS
II}
"0
=
=
~
....
o
QJ
""
.a
:a
=
0)
a-
~
bfl
=
.~
'C
o
.c:
...
=
<
=
o
...
...
o
~
<
o ""
... 0
QJ....
~~
o
Z 5
=tl
.=~
... -
... ~
~ ""
0) QJ
CJ =
~~
:.= 0
=.,...
5 =
0"0
U =
0)
"" ~
oS-<
0)'"
= =
... QJ
~ ~
QJ 0
~u
QJ QJ
~oS
....5-
00=
Sct;::8
... "I:l =
II} Q;i ""
= ... QJ
QJ .... "0
~ 0...
~ 5 ~
= ~ e
~~"O
~5~
'5: tl =
o ~ 0
"" ...
... I:I.l I:I.l
_... ~
~E9 CJ
'-' .~
SQJ"O
... ~ ""
o 0 QJ
~~~
<~.E
u
~
""
cS
.~
QJ
~
QJ
II}
;;;J ""
QJ
'i ~
S~
~ ""
:atl
= =
o~
U ~
~ f
""<
oS...
,e.~
l:l.oS
~S
000
~.s
CJ =
.s 0
",'"
5 ~
8 5
:S'S"
~:
bflll}
= =
.~ 0
::;:~
..Sl e
- 'S
-< =
= 5
:8 5
o 0
~]
0)
<~
~
II} =
- 0
o II}
o II}
.c: QJ
J:l~
bfl
CJ =
:= -8
~ s
~ ...
~
=00
~"Cl.=
= = CJ
,g ~ =
QJ QJ 0)
=CJ=
= ... ...
-= i: =
2; QJ QJ
00 CJ
QJ "Cl t
oS~u
;; reS
'i = =
~ 0
... "" ~
~oS~
5~bfl
~ CJ.5
",,'1: 5
~"'5
-< ~'i
="000
===
==
~==
=o("l
'5: ~ QJ
eeoS
=.,=~
=""Cl =
< ~'C
.e-=
= ... ~
:8 = 5
o = ~
~ 5 ""
~5bfl
o 0
-<u~
r.:
""
oS
=
o
...
...
=
CJ
...
'a
l:l.
-<
...
=
e
~
bfl
=
.~
'1:
o
~
=
-<
ff"l
ff"l
=
.
=
=bfl
. =
O:a
z_
z'S
0=
t:: QJ
b ~
~e-
os.
oo~
~=
bfl~
~~
l:l.~
o~
"0 =
< =
= 5
o QJ
... QJ
... ""
o~
~ QJ
-<~
d
~
=
...
;Q
i
~
-
~
'S
=
QJ
=
~
~
=
'5:
e
=.,
=.,
-<
~
ff"l
=
I
=
=
o
z'"
z~
0*
s!
~ =
~.~
~~
bfl=
= e
~ 'C
l:l.QJ
~~
= ""
ocS
;:3. <U
o II}
~ ~
CJ
<:s
==
~
It)
"0
QJ
~
=
l:l.
=
o
...
...
o
~
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 3 of 10
4. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
There were no matters from the floor.
5. PARKS - Report by Representative
A. Report on Park Commission Meeting Held March 28, 2000
Commissioner Puzak reported on the matters considered and actions taken at the March 28, 2000 Park
Commission meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting). Mayor Love requested an estimate of
what the proposed park user fees would yield. Director Nielsen estimated that the park user fees would
yield approximately $ 19,OOO/year, based on 1997 park user figures. He further stated the Park
Foundation has committed to raise $lO,OOO/year and Park dedication fees are estimated at$7500/year.
Mr. Puzak also stated the potential of revenue from the concession stand is favorable, however they do
not have a way of obtaining a good estimate of revenue from this source.
.
Mayor Love thanked Mr. Puzak and the Park Commission for their hard work and commitment to the
Freeman Park Multipurpose Building. Mr. Puzak thanked the Council for their support of this project.
6. PLANNING - Report by Representative
Commissioner Anderson reported on the matters considered and actions taken at the April 4, 2000
Planning Commission meeting (as detailed in the minutes of that meeting).
A. Motion to Direct Staff to Prepare a Resolution Approving a Conditional Use Permit
Applicant: US West
Location: 19395 State Highway 7
.
Director Nielsen noted that this item was continued from the March 27 Council meeting in order to ask
Garrett Lysiak, Shorewood's Telecommunications Consultant, to report on the antenna coverage area.
Unfortunately, Mr. Lysiak was not able to be present for tonight's meeting. US West representatives
Phyllis O'Connell and Scott Hines reported on their needs, stating that locating an antenna on the
Shorewood water tower does not meet their requirements to provide coverage to the area in need-
specifically Hwy. 7 and surrounding areas. Mr. Hines noted that US West began their search for
appropriate antenna locations in 1998 and that the Mini Storage site met their coverage needs and the
City's Telecommunications Ordinance.
Councilmember Garfunkel stated that he understood the water tower doesn't meet 100% of US West's
requirements, however he would like to have a better sense of what percentage it does meet. US West
representatives were not able to clarify this question.
Commissioner Anderson reported that he was the only negative vote on this item when it came before the
Planning Commission, stating that based on the reports he heard, he felt there were very limited 'poor
coverage' areas that existed. He also stated that the area US West is in need of coverage includes an area
outside ofthe Shorewood community-near Hwy 101 and Hwy 7. He noted that a site at the Minnetonka
High School was also looked at by US West, but not pursued by them for unknown reasons. He felt there
was significant public testimony in opposition of the Mini Storage site.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 4 of 10
Councilmember Garfunkel stated he would like to see the report from Mr. Lysiak before making a
decision on this issue and asked when this might be likely to occur. Staff reported that Mr. Lysiak would
be asked to be present at the April 24 council meeting.
Director Brown asked Mr. Hines if there were a height that would work on the southeast water tower.
Mr. Hines stated he would have to perform some dry test results and further analysis at a height that
would work as none had been performed. He stated that based on prior experience, they knew a height of
65 feet not meet most of their objectives. From what Mr. Hines has seen, there is not an available height
on the water tower that will meet their objectives.
Lizee moved, Garfunkel seconded, to continue the request to prepare a resolution for a Conditional
Use Permit application by US West to the April 24 Regular Council meeting. Motion passed 5/0.
B. A Motion Adopting a Resolution Approving an Amendment to the Development
Agreement for Shorewood Ponds
Director Nielsen reported that the Developers of Shorewood Ponds requested an amendment to the .
Development Agreement with regards to notifying prospective buyers of the proposed trail to be
constructed in the development area. He noted that the original Agreement stated that the trail would
have been constructed by the time the homes along the east and north sides of the project were ready to
be occupied. Due to a number of construction circumstances, the trail is not yet completed; however
there are units ready for occupancy. Director Nielsen read the suggested amended language as stated in
the proposed Resolution. This amendment would put the people that buy the units near the trail on notice
that there will be a trial and where it will be located.
Bill Gleason of Eaglecrest Northwest, distributed a sample document depicting the development site and
trail location. He stated that a document similar to this would accompany all closings and is generally
signed 15 days prior to closing. Mayor Love questioned the accuracy of the trail location. Mr. Gleason
stated that they very clear on the northern part of the trail, but that along Eureka there was some question
of accuracy. Units 1 and 2 of Block 2 would be the only units affected by that part of the trail location.
When asked if the north end of the trail could be constructed prior to occupancy of the homes, Mr.
Gleason stated that they could try to accomplish this as soon as weight restrictions are off.
Councilmember Garfunkel questioned the tracking of the process, noting there may be several .
'prospective' buyers. Mayor Love recommended striking the word 'prospective' from the proposed
Resolution.
Stover moved, Lizee seconded, adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-035. "Approving an Amendment
to the Development Agreement for Shorewood Ponds as amended, striking the word 'prospective'
from the proposed Resolution." Motion passed 5/0.
C. A Motion Adopting a Resolution Approving Revisions to Shorewood's Tree Policy
(This item 6C was moved to Item 7E for discussion.)
7. GENERAL
A. A Motion Regarding Billing for the Southshore Community Center
Director Brown stated that the Friends of Southshore Senior Community Center forwarded a bill to the
City for $1,537.41 for repairs to the HV AC system. The Friends felt this was a warranty work item and
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 5 of 10
therefore asked the City to pay the bill, because of the warranty issues currently outstanding. Staff is
recommending the City not pay this item.
Bob Gagne, Friends of the Southshore Senior Community Center stated that if this were a repair item, the
Friends would pay it. But it was determined to be defective original construction and not a maintenance
item.
Councilmember Stover stated that from the information she received, she believed the installation of the
HV AC system was incorrect by the original contractor. The contractor hired by the Friends to fix the
system replaced erroneous work with correct work. She believes this was a basic construction issue and
not a maintenance item.
Councilmember Garfunkel asked Councilmember Stover to clarify her position as to her membership on
the Friends Board and whether a conflict of interest exists.
.
Councilmember Stover confirmed that she was on the Friends Board and stated that whether she were a
member of the Friends or not, she would vote the same on this issue-she did not believe there was a
conflict of interest.
Mayor Love noted that the Friends have done a noble job of running the Center under trying
circumstances. His concern lies with what process is available for the City to mitigate these damages, and
therefore cannot support a motion to reimburse the Friends.
Councilmember Lizee stated she feels the process wasn't in place to begin with, and sees that this item
was a problem that surfaced with the initial construction. A written procedure/ process needs to be
developed in looking at future problems. She feels that the City should help pay for the repair of this
system.
Council member Garfunkel stated that he didn't see this as a Shorewood taxpayer issue. He noted it is
unfortunate how this occurred but that he cannot support the City covering this expense.
.
Councilmember Zerby stated that Shorewood taxpayers are users of this building. He feels that we paid
too little for the original work; therefore the work was done improperly at low cost. He views this like a
budget overrun and supports Shorewood paying their fair share of the bill. He is also concerned that
there isn't procedure for going back to the original cities for support. He felt that the contractor that was
chosen was not a responsible contractor.
Mayor Love noted that this has been an issue the City has worked with the Friends on and it has been an
issue that the City has been involved in litigation in attempting to resolve. He further stated this is not the
first discussion on problems with this project and that tonight's vote is on this one issue.
Zerby moved, Lizee seconded, Approving a motion to make payment to the Friends of the
Southshore Senior Community Center in an amount based on Shorewood's original percentage of
contribution to the project. Motion passed 3/2, Garfunkel and Love dissenting.
Mayor Love noted that at the preceding special meeting with the Friends on this issue that there is an
agreement that representatives of the Friends, the Staff and the Council would meet to discuss a process
for working through future major mechanical and structural type of building problems.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 6 of 10
B. A Motion Committing to Reimburse Excelsior for Expenses Associated with Hiring
a Fire District Transition Coordinator
Mayor Love stated that the cities involved are close to resolving this issue; Shorewood will be
the first City to vote on the acceptance of the Joint Powers Agreement. He noted that this has taken a lot
of time from the City Administrators. One agreement is to have a Board in place by July and ownership
of the Fire Department by December 1, 2000. Mr. James Hurm, the City's prior administrator has
submitted a proposal for coordinating this transition. It was agreed to structure this on a percentage
basis, and the position would phase out when the tasks are completed, approximately at the time of hiring
a Fire Chief. Mr. Garfunkel stated that there is a lot of work to be done and to get this done correctly and
to have someone focus on it is very important.
Councilmember Zerby asked for clarification of the name of committee. Excelsior Fire Chief Ringate,
clarified that is started out as the Excelsior Fire Department Review Committee and about a month ago
the name change to the Fire Department Transition Committee. He noted that the Support Committee is
another entity that Excelsior has asked for participation from the other cities dealing with immediate
concerns of the fire department.
.
The City of Excelsior will direct Mr. Hurm's efforts.
Garfunkel moved, Stover seconded, Committing to Reimburse Excelsior for Expenses Associated
with Hiring a Fire District Transition Coordinator. Motion passed 5/0.
Mayor Love thanked the fire department members for their service. Those fire members present at
tonight's meeting introduced themselves, included John Sweeney, who Mayor Love noted was the
longest serving volunteer fire member in the state of Minnesota and has been on the force for 50 years;
Dana George, Assistant Fire Chief, Cory Latterner, Captain; Doug Sweeney, First Captain; and David
Hoo, Trustee.
C. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the Mayor and City Administrator to
Enter Into a Joint Powers Agreement for Fire Services.
.
Garfunkel moved, Lizee seconded, adopting RESOLUTION NO. 0-036. "Authorizing the Mayor
and City Administrator to Enter Into a Joint Powers Agreement for Fire Services." Motion passed
5/0.
It was noted that Shorewood is the first City to vote on this issue. Councilmember Garfunkel thanked the
Mayor for his effort.and leadership on this issue. Mayor Love thanked the Council for their support and
also the firefighters for their involvement on this issue.
D. (former Item 3D)
A Motion to Approve an Extension of the Deadline for Compliance with a Notice to
Remove.
Applicant: James and Valerie Keefer
Location: 20925 Forest Drive
Director Nielsen stated that the Keefers were sent a notice in March requesting that they clean up their
property. They have requested additional time than what was given in order to take advantage of spring
clean up which is scheduled for May 20.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 7 of 10
Council and Staff discussed the amount of debris to be cleaned up. It was noted there is about 30 cubic
yards of debris, which represents about 3-112 garden style dump trucks. Staff stated that construction
debris is not allowed at spring clean up and that there is a limit to how much can be set out at curbside.
There is a fee schedule for items brought to the spring clean up site. Staff will need to make an itemized
list of what exists and make it clear to the Keefers the amount of and what type of materials are accepted
at curbside and at the drop off site.
Director Nielsen recommended changing the language to state that anything that would be taken by
spring clean up should be sent aside, but the rest of the debris should be taken care of within 30 days.
Stover moved, Zerby seconded, Approving that items accepted by Spring Clean Up may remain
until May 20, and items not accepted by Spring Clean Up be taken care of within 30 days.
Councilmember Stover noted that Staff should provide an itemized list to the Keefers of what is not
accepted at spring clean up, and any items remaining after 30 days would be cleaned up by the City and
billed to the Keefers.
.
Motion passed 5/0.
E. A Motion Adopting a Resolution Approving Revisions to Shorewood's Tree Policy.
(Item 7E was moved from Item 6C for discussion.)
.
Director Nielsen explained the standards used by foresters and nurseries in determining the size
of trees, stating there are two standards of measurement used-DBH and caliper inches. He is
recomfnending that the tree preservation policy be amended to read that replacement trees be specified in
caliper inches, with a 3" standard. Another issue is with whom can prepare the tree preservation plants.
The current policy states that landscape architects or foresters can prepare plants. Director Nielsen noted
the strengths and weaknesses of each. It is suggested that a third classification of professional-
Arborists-be allowed to prepare the plants. Director Nielsen noted that some of the best plants are done
by Arborists and is confident in recommending this change. The last item deals with planting
replacement trees on a wooded site. If it is not practical to have replacement trees on a site, it is being
suggested that the replacement trees be contributed to City property or, during off-season, the developer
could contribute to a fund for planting trees on City owned property.
Director Nielsen noted that the Planning Commission recommended in favor of these revisions. He also
noted the possibility of using the fund, if established, to purchase land for tree preservation; this is
something that could be looked at as the fund develops.
Councilmember Zerby questioned the credentials of an Arborist. Director Nielsen stated that they would
have a certificate or degree demonstrating they are trained in that field.
Director Nielsen stated that this item will be brought to the April 24 Council meeting, with a Resolution.
8. ENGINEERINGIPUBLIC WORKS
Mayor Love requested Item 8C be discussed first. The Council agreed to this amendment to the agenda.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 8 of 10
C. A Motion to Adopt a Resolution Approving Plans and Specifications and
Authorizing Advertisement of Bids for Freeman Park Multipurpose Building
Engineer Brown stated that Council was familiar with this item. It includes the construction of
restrooms, a multipurpose area, concessions, allows for rental space of family get-togethers and an open
picnic pavilion. It has been the goal of the Council and Park Commission to provide permanent restroom
facilities for Freeman Park.
Engineer Brown reviewed the change of stainless steel countertops and sink, which will be bid out as Bid
Alternate #1, and the open picnic pavilion, which will be Bid Alternate #2. He noted that if Bid Alternate
#2 is rejected, Bid Alternate #1 must also be rejected. However, under this scenario, this didn't seem to
be an issue. Another revision noted was the change of the interior restrooms from a granite surface to a
block surface with a graffiti resistant paint.
Engineer Brown reported that Reliant Energy (formerly Minnegasco), has committed to installing a
natural gas service to the building at no cost to the City of Shorewood. This will contribute to a
significant cost saving with the installation of a gas furnace and water heater.
.
He noted that Staff is recommended approval of the authorizing of advertisement for bid and accepting
plans. The bid opening would be held at 10:30 a.m. on May 17, 2000 at City Hall.
Mayor Love thanked Director Brown for his effort in working with Reliant Energy on this project.
Councilmember Garfunkel asked whether or not the issue of the funding not being narrowed down has an
impact on going forward with advertising for bids. Director Brown stated that we are approaching the
tail end of the optimal bidding season, therefore it is important to get this item out to bid. It is still
possible to reject the bids, should funding be an issue.
Director Nielsen noted that a finance plan would be available at the time the bids are in.
Mayor Love stated that the City has about half of the funds necessary to build the building in reserve. He
stated that we are looking at this expense over a lO-year time period, estimating the various funding .
sources being user fees of $12,000; park dedication fees of $7500; the Park Foundation commitment of
$10,000, and an undetermined amount from the concession stand.
Lizee moved, Garfunkel seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-037, "Approving Plans and
Specifications Authorizing Advertisement of Bids for Freeman Park Multipurpose Building."
Motion passed 5/0.
At 9:03 P.M. a short break was taken. Mayor Love reconvened the meeting at 9:18 P.M.
A. Motion Adopting a Resolution Accepting Appraisals and Authorizing
Compensation for Easements and Right of Way Acquisition for the m 7 - 41
Intersection Project
Director Brown noted that the document outlines the easements needed for this project. He stated that
MnlDOT has signed off on the plans and has provided a letter stating they would reimburse the City for
Right of Way costs incurred. He noted that all the affected parties have been contacted and are working
with the City on this project. The property impacted the most is the Shorewood Shopping Center, which
has the most land being requested. However, they have a lot to benefit from this project and are eager to
see it move forward. Director Brown noted that Shorewood has committed to being the project lead,
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 9 of 10
which includes a commitment to being a financier on a short-term basis. Staff will make sure the time
commitment with those dollars is held to the least amount of time as possible. Staff is recommended
approval of this Resolution.
Garfunkel moved, Stover seconded Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-038. "Accepting Appraisals
and Authorizing Compensation for Easements and Right of Way Acquisition for the TH 7 _ 41
Intersection Project." Motion passed 5/0.
B. Motion Adopting a Resolution Approving Plans and Specifications and Authorizing
Advertisement of Bids for Covington Road and Vine Hill Road Trail Project
Engineer Brown described the location of the proposed trail. He noted that a portion of the trail would be
constructed out of concrete, as requested. He stated the neighborhood has given the City a great amount
of feedback on this project. Staff recommends approval of this Resolution.
.
Mayor Love noted that he attended the end of neighborhood meeting, noting the cooperation and support
from the neighborhood, and congratulated the Park Board on the process used for this project.
Councilmember Garfunkel asked for clarification of the funding summary.
Engineer Brown clarified the funding summary, noting that with the proposed projects, the trail fund will
have an estimated balance at the end of year 2000 of $18,388. This will forego other projects until the
balance can be built back up in that fund. It is projected that it will take until 2005 to build up the
balance. Director Brown noted that this issue is on the Park Commission agenda for tomorrow night.
Councilmember Zerby noted he is very excited about this project and how it is addresses some of the
serious issues the neighbors on Vine Hill Road have brought up. He believes the plan we have now
addresses these issues very well.
.
Zerby moved, Lizee seconded, Adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-039 "Approving Plans and
Specifications and Authorizing Advertisement of Bids for Covington Road and Vine Hill Road
Trail Project." Motion passed 5/0.
D. Motion Adopting a Resolution Approving Plans and Specifications and Authorizing
Advertisement of Bids for 2000 Bituminous Seal Coat Project
Engineer Brown noted that this is a joint effort with the cities of Excelsior and Tonka Bay. The roadways
proposed to be seal coated are Howards Point Road, Brent Ridge Drive, Pine Bend, Edgewood Road,
Grant Lorenze Road, Birch Bluff Drive and tentatively Eureka Road South, which will be based on other
activities to be finalized on Eureka Road.
Stover moved, Zerby seconded, adopting RESOLUTION NO. 00-040. "Approving Plans and
Specifications and Authorizing Advertisement of Bids for 2000 Bituminous Seal Coat Project."
Motion passed 5/0.
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES - APRIL 10,2000
Page 10 of 10
9. REPORTS
A. Administrator & Staff
1. Gideon Glen
Director Nielsen reported that Staff is consulting with the City assessor for names of
appraisers.
2. Skate Park
Director Nielsen reported that the public hearing is being scheduled for May 2. The
Planning Commission will hold that public hearing and the Park Commission will also be
discussing this at their April 11 meeting.
3. Freeman Park Multipurpose Building
Director Nielsen noted that this item was discussed earlier in this meeting and he had
nothing further to report at this time.
.
Director Nielsen reported that we have a number of applicants for the Finance Director position and Staff
plans to begin the review process and interviews next week.
B. Mayor & City Council
Councilmember Lizee asked if any Staff or Council would be able to attend a Hennepin County Parks
meeting on April 13. There are issues on the agenda pertaining to western suburbs. Councilmember
Zerby noted he would plan to attend the meeting.
Mayor Love reported that he attended the LCEC's meeting and reported on items which were covered at
that meeting.
10.
ADJOURN SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
.
Lizee moved, Garfunkel seconded, adjourning the Regular Meeting at 9:35 P.M., subject to
approval of claims. Motion passed 5/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.
Jean Panchyshyn,
Recording Secretary
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
BRADLEY J. NIELSEN, ACTING CITY ADMINISTRATOR
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING
TUESDAY, APRIL 18, 2000
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
1. CONVENE SPECIAL MEETING
Mayor Love called the meeting to order at 7: 18 P.M.
DRAFT
A. Roll Call
Present: Mayor Love; Councilmembers Garfunkel, Lizee, and Stover, Planning
Director Nielsen, and Public Works DirectorlEngineer Brown
Absent:
Councilmember Zerby
Also present: Planning Commissioners Anderson, Bailey, Callies, Rosenberger,
Turgeon, and Woodruff; Land Conservation and Environment
Committee Members Berndt, Bruno, Jurgens, Kircher, and Pini; Pete
Willenbring - WSB and Associates, and Glenda Spiotta - Minnehaha
Creek Watershed District
B. Review Agenda
Lizee moved, Garfunkel seconded, approving the agenda as presented. Motion passed 4/0.
2.
JOINT MEETING WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND THE LAND
CONSERVATION AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE (LCEC) TO DISCUSS
THE STORMW ATER MANAGEMENT PLAN
Engineer Brown introduced Mr. Pete Willenbring, of WSB and Associates, to the group and
explained the purpose of this meeting was to review the Stormwater Management Plan for the
Year 2000 in its draft form. He noted that Mr. Willenbring has a particular specialty for
knowledge in this area, and thanked him for his efforts in assisting the City with preparation of
this document.
Mr. Willenbring provided an impressive overview of the Stormwater Management Plan,
explaining the purpose of the Plan was to provide the City with identified goals and policies
related to stormwater management practices as well as examine prioritization for scheduling and
cost of implementation for these goals and policies. He also noted this Plan to be an excellent
information tool relating to the City's land and water resources. The Plan provides information
on the following goal and policy areas: Water Quantity; Water Quality; Recreation, Fish and
Wildlife; Enhancement of Public Participation Information and Education; Public Ditch Systems;
Groundwater; Wetlands; and Erosion.
-:/F ~L
CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING - APRIL 18,2000
Page 2 of2
Of particular interest to the group was the possible intention of the City to utilize natural ponding
areas, such as wetlands, for the use and treatment of surface water runoff, so long as these areas
met significant stringent criteria. Much discussion centered on this issue with the decision of the
group being to view this not so much as a likelihood, but rather, an option should these specific
criteria arise in the future.
Mr. Willenbring also explained Watershed Districts are encouraging enhanced infiltration
processes as part of cities' water quality issues as long as these infiltration practices would not
have significant potential to contaminate the storm water runoff.
Mr. Jay Venero, 5985 Seaman's Drive, expressed great concern about possible contamination to
the groundwater supply due to incorrect construction and maintenance of well heads.
Mayor Love thanked everyone for attending this meeting and engaging in dialogue about the
acceptance of minimum standards in the stormwater management practices.
All groups involved in this discussion have until May 2, 2000, to further review this plan and
provide written comment about any other revisions deemed necessary.
.
3. ADJOURNMENT
Lizee moved, Stover seconded, adjourning the Special Meeting Session at 9:47 P.M.
Motion passed 4/0.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
Sally Keefe,
Recording Secretary
.
Woody Love, Mayor
Bradley J. Nielsen, Acting City Administrator
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO. 00-
A RESOLUTION MAKING COMMISSION APPOINTMENTS
WHEREAS, at their regular meeting held February 28, 2000, the City Council adopted
Resolution No. 00-021 and Resolution No. 00-022 making appointments to the Planning
and Park Commissions.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council shall make the
following Planning and Park Commission position appointments for the year 2000:
.
Planning Commission:
Chairperson Jeff Bailey
Vice Chairperson Laura Turgeon
Park Commission:
Chairperson Pat Arnst
Vice Chairperson Mark Themig
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHOREWOOD
this 24th day of April, 2000.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
. BRADLEY J NIELSEN, ACTING CITY ADMINISTRATOR
:t3A
.
.
'1'
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
PARK COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, APRIL 11,2000
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:30 P.M.
MINUTES
1. CONVENE PARK COMMISSION MEETING
DRAFT
Chair Arnst called the meeting to order at 7:35 P.M.
A.
RollCall
Present:
Chair Arnst; Vice-chair Themig; Commissioners Puzak, Dallman, Berndt and
Young; Director of Public Works Larry Brown; Planning Liaison Callies
Absent:
Commissioner Bix
Later Arrivals: Council Liaison Scott Zerby
B. Review Agenda
Puzak moved, Themig seconded to approve the agenda as presented. Motion passed 6/0.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Themig moved, Puzak seconded to approve the minutes as presented. Motion passed 6/0.
3. MATTERS FROM THE FLOOR
Commissioner Berndt said that a member of the Land Conservation & Environment Committee
has requested that the Cathcart Park tennis courts have a white stripe painted on the practice
board (like the one at Badger Park). Brown will follow up on that request.
Chair Arnst introduced Planning Commissioner Paula Callies, explaining that a representative
from the Planning Commission will attend Park Commission meetings when needed. This
meeting will include discussion about a public hearing for the proposed skate park.
4. REPORTS
A. Report on City Council Meeting of April 10, 2000
Commissioner Puzak reported that the Council approved to put out to bid the Freeman Park
multipurpose building with the modifications as suggested, and with bid alternates for a picnic
shelter and for stainless steel fixtures. The Council also voted to put the Vine Hill/ Covington
trail project out to bid.
.t:f 5 A
..
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 2
The Council did not take action on the request to approve a $5-per-athlete user fee for the sports
organizations. Brown explained that the reason for no formal action is because it requires an
ordinance draft to be first approved by the Park Commission. (To be discussed under item 10.)
LCEC Report - Commissioner Berndt reported that the Land Conservation & Environment
Committee has been preparing for their April 29 community open house. Also, the Committee is
considering a citywide ban on phosphorus in lawn fertilizers. The Mayor attended their last
meeting and expressed support for that idea. The Committee has been checking with a few other
Cities that have a no-phosphorus policy. On another topic, there were 22 responses to the
question of deer problems within Shorewood. About half were in favor of some type of deer
control and half opposed.
5. DISCUSSION OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S PUBLIC HEARING FOR
SKATE PARK (MAY 2,2000)
Chair Arnst explained that Planning Director Nielsen recommends that the Park Commissioners .
attend the public hearing. All residents within 500 feet of the property will be notified. One
resident has already expressed concern about safety in the crossing of High way 7.
Planning Commissioner Callies described the public hearing process. Arnst said that Nielsen
will put together a staff report and would like to meet with Park Commissioners on April 29
before the Smithtown neighborhood meeting. It will be noticed as a work session.
Themig asked if the kids who are requesting a skate park will attend the public hearing. Puzak
asked why this project requires a C.U.P. Brown explained that it is considered a more intensive
use of the land. Puzak asked what the proposal would have to accomplish in order to be
accepted. Callies described the general requirements, stating that there are no specific criteria for
a skate park. The City can add conditions that are appropriate for the use being proposed.
Dallman asked if it is a two-part process-first for the dedication of the land and second, for its .
use as a skate park. Puzak asked about zoning of the land. Brown said it is zoned R-2A, which
is Single and Two-family Residential. He further explained that it was formerly interpreted as
just parkland, which is allowed in residential use. It is because of the intensification of use that a
public hearing and C.U.P. are required.
Puzak said the issue seems to be the addition of apparatus and asked if a C.U.P. would be
required if we were adding a swing set. Callies said she is not sure it is just apparatus, but found
no definition in a quick check of the code book to clarify the issue.
Puzak asked what are we doing that is different and how do we prepare. Commissioner Young
reported that he has received calls from neighbors of the property. He said that in the absence of
specifics, there will be negative reaction. Some residents of the Seasons development are not
favorable to the idea of a skate park. In terms of preparation, he suspects that neighbors would
have a concern about parking and about minimal supervision. Puzak didn't think parking would
be a problem.
,
..
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 3
Callies offered to ask for clarification of conditions that would require a C.U.P. Puzak agreed
that a public hearing is necessary to address concerns, but questioned the purpose of a C.U.P.
Dallman asked if the property has been dedicated as parkland. Brown said it would be a separate
motion to formally dedicate it as parkland. Dallman said that even if it does not become a skate
park, he would still want the site to be dedicated as parkland. Brown said that two meetings ago,
the Park Commission made a motion recommending that it be parkland. Staff has recommended
that it be brought in as full package in the public hearing phase.
Callies will talk with Nielsen for clarification. The Commission will meet with him on Saturday,
April 29 from 10:30 AM. to 11:00 AM., which will be noticed as a work session.
.
Callies added that some of the Planning Commissioners have asked about the possibility of a
future cell antenna at Freeman Park. Themig, Puzak, Arnst and Dallman all expressed support
for that idea as it is on the Park Commission's list of possible revenue sources. Puzak added that
two additional sites may become options-the Highway 7 picnic area pull-off and the picnic area
on the north side of highway 7. Both are high points in the City. Themig added that the Park
Commission would not be opposed and would like to be involved in location decisions.
Brown pointed out that the Planning Commission went through a long process with the
Comprehensive Plan to determine likely sites and it is best to work with those sites first. They
are not locked into those, but should try and make use of the foundation that has been laid.
6. CONSENSUS FOR DATES AND FORMATS OF PARK TOURS
Chair Arnst asked if the schedule proposed on the agenda outline will work for everyone and
explained the park tour process to the new Commissioners. All agreed to the May 9 and May 23
dates with June 13 for a rain date.
.
7.
APPROVE LOCATION OF ARBOR DAY TREE TO BE PLANTED ON APRIL
29, 2000 AND DETERMINE TlME
Arnst said she has discussed this with Acting Administrator Nielsen, explaining that some
residents are donating a red oak tree in memory of Cynthia Krieg. City Hall property has been
proposed as the best site, and the exact location and preparation will be up to staff.
The Commission agreed to hold a tree-planting ceremony at 11 :00 AM. on Saturday, April 29.
8. DISCUSSION IN REGARDS TO THE TRAIL CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT
PROGRAM (CIP)
Brown explained that this item is on the agenda because the City Council approved authorization
of advertising for bid on the Covington! Vine Hill trail. With that in mind, he wanted to alert the
Commission to the fact that the last CIP was approved in September of 1999. At that time, there
was a different scenario and trails were a definite part of the picture.
,
,.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 4
Brown referred to Page 3 of his memo to point out that this project will drain the trail fund. It is
estimated that it will take until the year 2005 to bring the trail fund balance back up to where it is
now, assuming there is no change in philosophy or approach.
Arnst said she thinks the Commission knew that and she is happy to see that some balance will
remain. Brown noted that it is contrary to the last CIP approved by the Park Commission
because the last CIP had a number of other potential funding sources listed. This does not mean
the other projects are out the window, but staff is trying to work with real numbers. Brown said
he wanted to show a reflection of that in this report.
9. FINALIZE FORMAT FOR OPEN HOUSE FOR SMITHTOWN ROAD WEST
NEIGHBORS REGARDING TRAIL/ SIDEWALK SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 29,
9:00 A.M. -10:30 A.M. AT CITY HALL
Arnst explained that Planning Director Nielsen will be available for this meeting and Brown will .
try to attend as well. The plan is to display the map, showing the result of the rights-of':way
study and to let neighbors know that the project is a much bigger issue than originally thought.
The Commission also wants to communicate (as they promised to keep residents informed) that
they are still interested in the project and are making efforts toward that end. Arnst said that all
neighbors on both sides of Smithtown Road from the LRT trail to the west end will be noticed.
Brown explained the map and reviewed the results of the study for the Commission, saying that
overall, it was good news for the Council.
Themig asked about the intent of the public hearing and if there is a future direction for the
project. Arnst added that neighbors will ask what's next. Brown said it comes down to 2
options-either there will be no trail or we seek MSA funds for a trail.
Berndt asked about individuals who own right-of-way and are opposed to a trail. Brown cited
the example of Mn/DoT, saying even they move on to another project because it is too expensive .
and complicated to acquire the land. It may mean we would choose another, unopposed project.
There was discussion about how to address the possibility that some residents may donate their
easement to the City. Brown explained what would have to take place before that could happen.
Dallman added that even donated land will cost the City money, but if this is an option, the City
will need to be prepared to accept it.
Puzak pointed out that MSA funding was part of the picture even before the map was created.
The map didn't lead us to MSA and state funding should not be a new issue. He recommended
going back to basics and simply be honest and open with the facts, both positive and negative.
He said the reason we are having the meeting is to communicate new information about the need
to acquire easement right-of-way on 40% of the area.
Brown clarified which parts of the street easement the City owns. He suggested giving residents
the facts of the research. The question is, if the City is faced with the burden of acquiring
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 5
parcels, a trail may not happen. Dallman asked if the road will eventually have to be built with
MSA funds and Brown said yes it would. There was discussion about the timing of that process
as it relates to a future trail.
Brown asked what is the goal of the meeting. Puzak said, to tell neighbors where we are at and
what it would take to complete a trail along that corridor. If asked what kind of trail, it would be
designed around the issues along with the MSA standard of an 8-foot width. Berndt said there
will be a lot of different responses between old-time and newer residents.
8:37 P.M. Councilmember Zerby arrived.
There was further discussion on how to handle possible donations of land and the idea of using
roadway funds toward the project. Brown pointed out that there is a tax benefit for donations of
land, which may be a consideration for some people
.
Arnst stated that the purpose of the neighborhood meeting is to update citizens on where we are.
With that in mind, she asked what information the Park Commission can prepare for the
residents. Themig suggested a simple I-page handout that shows where we are, where we have
come from and where it leads.
Brown cautioned that we do not have design plans and can't quantify things. People will want
specifics and it's too early to address those details. He added that it is valid to generate
discussion on the need of the residents' cooperation if it were ever going to work. Themig
suggested asking the general question of, "Would you be willing to offer land?" Puzak said he
would also want to explain the probability of an 8-foot wide trail.
.
Arnst said she will work with Larry Brown to create a draft and get a copy to each Commissioner
for review before the meeting. There was discussion on how to handle the question of land
donations. The message for now is that the City wants to work with the residents and ask them
for their perception for a trail. Would they be interested in someday donating land? Ask them
how they feel and if this is a project we should pursue.
10. DISCUSS SPORTS ORGANIZATION POLICIES RELATIVE TO USER FEES
Arnst explained that a $5 per athlete charge has been decided upon, but the Commission has
deferred on the question of how to implement the user fee. A plan should be in place before
contacting the sports organizations.
Dallman asked what he should report at the next Parks Foundation meeting. Puzak suggested
saying that the Commission has passed a motion and presented this plan to City Council. Brown
pointed out that the motion was for the City Council to draft an ordinance, which has not been
approved. It's not a done deal.
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 6
Themig suggested meeting with the athletic associations first and then formalizing the plan with
an ordinance. Arnst said the policy should be finalized before meeting with the organizations.
Puzak recommended they at least prepare an intended policy to present to the sports associations.
The Commission discussed how the fee would be assessed, collected, and documented and what
to do if anyone does not want to pay. The role of Minnetonka Community Education & Services
in field scheduling and park use also was reviewed.
Brown pointed out that, once the sports organizations have a copy of the new policy, they can
react to it and decide if they wish to use the fields. Arnst added that they do have the option to
play on other fields. Puzak stated that the point is that we are assessing the cost of park
maintenance to each of the organizations. Some will embrace it and some will question it.
There was further discussion about the timing of noticing the sports organizations. It was agreed
to have the policy in place by the end of September 2000. The effective date of the policy .
change is yet to be determined. Brown said it would be wise to see a policy draft before
committing to a meeting date. It will require a public hearing. The Commission agreed that
there is plenty of time to work out the details.
11. REVIEW 1999 "TO DO LIST GOALS"
Chair Arnst recommended they close out the 1999 list and move to 2000. She asked the
Commissioners what they would like to include on a new list. Ideas were listed as:
· Plastic recycling in the parks.
· Implement user fees.
· Meet financial goals.
· Build the skate park.
· Investigate a skating rink at Freeman Park to go beside the new building.
· Continue to meet and communicate with residents.
.
Puzak reported that Brown has negotiated with the Gas Company to install a gas line to the
multipurpose building at no charge. This allows for economical gas heat and a less expensive
electrical system for lighting, etc.
Brown also noted that a future ice rink location needs to be considered now because of its
proximity to the building plan in order to ensure visibility from inside the multipurpose building.
12. NEW BUSINESS
Puzak asked Council member Zerby why a C.U.P. would be required for the proposed skate park.
Zerby asked about the step to first adopt the property as parkland. Puzak said the Commission
has asked, but Council has not taken action. Brown explained that it would probably require a
resolution and both proposals would be incorporated as one package.
.
.
<,
PARK COMMISSION MINUTES
APRIL 11,2000 - PAGE 7
Puzak said he is a little concerned about naming it as a skate park because the property has other
potential. He listed other possible amenities and pointed out that the property is larger than
Silverwood Park. Brown said a request could go to Council at one of the next meetings. Zerby
preferred that it be dedicated as parkland first.
Brown reported that the DNR grant application for the multipurpose building was submitted.
Th~mig reported that there is a bill moving through committee to dedicate a percent of tax dollars
for natural resources and it has potential to do something for parks. He offered to get the bill
number for anyone who wants to contact his or her representative. This could have a long-term
impact on parks and recreation in the State of Minnesota.
13 ADJOURNMENT
Puzak moved, Young seconded to adjourn. Motion passed 6/0.
The meeting adjourned at 9: 17 P.M.
RESPECTFULL Y SUBMITTED,
Connie Bastyr
RECORDING SECRETARY
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (612) 474-3236
FAX (612) 474-0128 . www.cLshorewood.mn.us . cityhaJl@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
2 March 2000
RE:
AT&T Wireless Services - Conditional Use Permit for
Telecommunications Facilities at West End Water Tower Site
FILE NO.:
405(00.02)
BACKGROUND
.
In January of this year the City Council authorized AT&T Wireless Services to make an
application for a conditional use permit to locate telecommunications facilities at 26352
Smithtown Road (see Site Location map - Exhibit A, attached). The property is the site
of the MinnewashtaElementary School and Shorewood's west end water tower. AT&T
proposes to erect telecommunications antennae around the stem of the water tower and
build a small equipment shelter at the base of the tower.
The property in question is zoned R-IA, Single-family Residential. The school property
contains approximately 15 acres, of which the City leases a 100' x 100' parcel for the
water tower. The lease agreement between the City and the School District specifically
provides for the use of the site for telecommunication facilities as well as the water tower.
The School District will be asked to comment prior to the City Council taking formal
action on the conditional use permit. Planning Commission recommendations will be
forwarded to the District after the public hearing for the C.U.P. As you are aware, APT
was granted a C.U.P. to locate on this site last year.
The proposed antennae will be located around the stem of the water tower, approximately
100 feet high (see Elevation Drawing - Exhibit B). As with the APT request, staff
n
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
#{,6
Memorandum
Re: AT&T Conditional Use Permit
2 March 2000
advised AT&T that any equipment should be housed in a shelter. The proposed single-
story, brick-faced building measures 24' x 28', containing approximately 672 square feet.
It will be located on the west side of the water tower, just north of the new APT building
(see Exhibits C and D). The brick will match the color of the school building, and the
roof will have cedar shakes.
Telecommunications facilities are addressed in Section 1201.03 Subd. 21 of the City
Code. This section of the Code was adopted in October of 1998, following a moratorium
that extended from February to the end of October last year.
A public hearing is scheduled for Tuesday, 7 March 2000. Garrett Lysiak, the City's
telecommunications consultant will be there to answer technical questions. He will
report on this application under separate cover.
. ANALYSIS/RECOMMENDATION
Telecommunications facilities are governed by the Telecommunications Act of 1995.
Shorewood has adopted its local regulations consistent Federal requirements. These are
found in Section 1201.03 Subd. 21 of the City Code.
A. Land Use. For the most part, telecommunications facilities have been limited to
commercial zoning districts within the city, although the Code does allow the use of
public property for this purpose by conditional use permit. While the Code states that
there is no obligation on the part of the City to sell or lease public property to
telecommunications carriers, the Planning Commission had at one time recommended
existing tower facilities (Le. City water towers) be used first before constructing
additional freestanding towers.
.
B. Code Requirements. Much of the current Code is intended to address new,
freestanding tower sites. Several provisions, however, are relevant to location of
facilities on existing towers:
1. Finish. The proposed antennae must be finished to match the color of the existing
water tower. It should be noted that the antennas installed by APT do not match
the color of the Minnewashta water tower. This will be corrected as soon as
weather permits.
2. Proposed Building. Early in the discussions with AT&T representatives, staff
suggested that the proposed building be designed to be expanded in order to
accommodate a third carrier. Ultimately it was agreed that the applicant would
build a building large enough to house another carrier. Language will be
incorporated into a lease agreement for the site providing for AT&T to lease the
additional space to a future carrier. The intent is to limit the number of buildings
-2-
Memorandum
Re: AT&T Conditional Use Permit
2 March 2000
on the property and for the new building to compliment the APT and school
buildings.
It is worth mentioning that the original plans for the building included HV AC
equipment on the west end of the building. At staff's suggestion the applicant has
redesigned their layout so that this equipment is on the east side of the new
building, away from nearby residents.
The new building is shown with a gable roof, whereas the APT building has a hip
roof. The City may wish to require that the new roof match the existing building.
.
3. Fencing. As shown on Exhibit D, the applicant proposes an eight-foot high, chain
link fence enclosure between their proposed building and the APT building.
Although the plan shows this as a storage area, it is restricted to temporary storage
of portable generators only in emergency situations. Although allowed by the
Code, barbed wire security strands at the top of the fence are not proposed.
4. Landscaping. During initial meetings with the applicant, staff advised that the
building and landscaping should be similar to that which are located at the
southeast area water tower site. This is considered to be one of the more effective
examples of screening found in Shorewood. Both the building and the
landscaping are consistent with southeast area design. Proposed landscaping is
shown on Exhibit D.
.
5. Stealth. As difficult as it can be to disguise antenna facilities, locating them on
existing towers or water towers is undoubtedly less visually obtrusive than
building new freestanding towers. As evidenced by the facilities located at the
southeast area water tower, the ground facilities can be screened from view quite
effectively.
One issue that arose from the construction of the APT facilities was the use of a
portable generator prior to power being supplied to the site. Noise from that
generator became a problem for nearby residents. It is recommended that
AT &T' s equipment must have underground power available prior to operation of
their equipment. A portable generator is only to be used during emergency power
outage situations.
6. Evaluation and Monitoring. The new code requirements provide for initial and
ongoing monitoring of FCC radiation emission requirements. The City's
telecommunications consultant will address emissions in a separate report. Any
future lease agreements between telecommunications carriers and the City will
provide for annual monitoring and, if necessary, testing.
-3-
a.
b.
c.
d.
. e.
Cc:
.
Memorandum
Re: AT&T Conditional Use Permit
2 March 2000
7. Engineering. The City Engineer will address structural concerns and issues
related to the use of the water tower under separate cover.
RECOMMENDATION
Any approval of this conditional use permit should be subject to the following:
Review and comment by the Minnetonka School District.
The recommendations of the City Engineer with respect to structural and
operational issues.
The recommendations of the City's Telecommunications Consultant.
The applicant must enter into the City's lease agreement including provisions for
annual monitoring.
Prior to any construction the applicant must provide bids for the proposed
landscaping, from which bids a letter of credit, one and one-half times the amount
of the landscaping will be required. The L.G.c. must extend for two growing
seasons. If construction is to take place this year, required landscaping must be in
place before the end of the growing season.
f. Prior to any construction the City Engineer will require an additional letter of
credit or cash escrow relative to the work being done on public property and to
the tower itself.
If you have any questions relative to this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me prior
to the 7 March meeting.
Larry Brown
Tim Keane
Garrett Lysiak
Julie Townsend
-4-
I \ _NO I ~ I~~ p:: )1\, ~'Y~ ~
~ ~~ ~ I~f;;;; ~l:.. J..~ ~y..
~'i-/... - Y:: ~ ..
e \. ~~ 15; I ____ ---{O ~..'\.. ~ --'
/ e---- 1);: I l~~ ~I .5 v;~~
.. .~~ ~.J' C{Y "- ITiLD -
... ~ v 1'1?(a CII.lJ -
... .." ......- . l Subject ~c )1 A I II I -
. '~2 Prop -, ~ --1111 LIT :;;
i -. .' · _ ~/cJ_ =:J <<r:~ -:s: /~~0f./:~
, ~ 1.M~HPOINTECOURT.,-. ~ c- 2~ ,./ J
~ 2. J\t ~H POINTE CIRCLE" ~ m / V
~. CJ. ~ II eM/' / ~ mS~IT TO N
~\. C7.' L _ ~ W WAY ~
~~. · "0 "' 1 ~ " E~ - l7 =
\ ---i~ ..
I--
~_/~
;rTL ~
~ 1- I \y ~p
_ h1--J STRAWS RRY~~ ---, ~ I
1\ f--J EN RL~ DR ..J ~IR j I
~r -I is LE I /
IriJ ~Am~ ~O~ r-I:>:>D"F==
I'~ ~ ~/~ : t--
,.. l~ ~ a:: ~ J
\I~CITY (F ~ H JRE~/O<tH:~ I~ ~ -/1 r
.
.
'--
Cf
.. ...~
~ . ... .'"
~.
'-
./
'-- t---,
r----
IlK I 11t-
-
-....-
-
CITY OF CHANHASSEN 62ND ST W
500
I
o
500 1 ~o Feel b..
N
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
AT&T CUP (Minnewashta)
~EXISTJNG PAINTERS RINGS
\. EXISTING APT ANTENNAS
(SCALA API9-1900/090D>
I 10'11I
ATLT VIRELESS SERVICES
24'x28' EQUIP. BUILDING.
APT EQUIPMENT BUILDING
NOT SHOIJN FOR CLARITY.
o
SOUTH ELEVATION
\. ANTENNAS
+t
'"
I
"
!:!
b
I
b
~
EA~T ELEVATION
DESCRIPTION AT&T WIRELESS SERVICES OF MINNESOTA, INC.
SOUTH LAKE MINNETONKA (SHOREWOODJ WATER TOWER SITE
ULTEIG ENGINEERS, INC.
aDI EAST RIVER ROAD
SUITE 3DI
~. YNNESOTA 'SUI
PHONE (1Sr2J 671-2SOD
w_. u/t.lfI. com
FAX flU} 17""11I'
~
SECTOR
ALPHA
GAMMA
ANT. TYPE
PDlO 77
P 10177
PD 0200
H IJ
86 10.38
I .38
4 7
D
5
5
4.5'
t
(EXISTING 10' DIA.
VATER TOIJER STEM
@.3' IlOVHTlLT
90'
~
>-
~
ALPHA
b
I
"
!. @ 3' _TILT
BETA NEV ATLT VIRELESS
EXISTING APT /- SERVICES ANTENNAS.
COAXIAL CABLES /@." IlOIINTILT MOUNTING PIPE AND
225' BRACKETS PAINTED TO
MATCH VATER TOVER.
TYPICAL (6) PLACES
...
M
o
N
Q;) :I::~A~~N
'JEST [LEVA TIDN
NORTH ELEV A TIDN
ACTIVE SCALE:
NONE
LIJRARY SCALE
DI
Exhibit B
ELEVATION DRAWING
Shows tower,antenna and new building
D.
CI
L: \1999\99-5872\dwg\SITEPLAN,dwg Frj Jan 21 10: 12: 25 2000 KBA
.., ~
0 ","
"'w
.. ~ ~~ ~
. z..
. II
... "':;
U
l:f~'
...-
0 0.. !!IW
!!! a:z 0I,~ 01,\ i~
~1Il .-
z~ .-
./
ti... ./ '1~ ~ ~'b
/
0 _ ~o
..
,\;
0 .;.,
..
I I
:M I ::! I
0 I
.. I
I
. I
.. I
u
.. 0 I
I
I
I
...... 5....: m ~ ..8 O..c: ~ ..a ri5ti~ 1! 8 0_ IDC
.fl. C ~c.::~UO"N'O
~o ri-i 5~ _0 ~d ~_ _ :; ~11",wJ!r=:
~i ;JI ~f-i5fl:jB~:~fi ~f "Ut: 8:
.. .,,,, &-.11.- "010-":'.1:"" - -:5lCII~c.
, c;- .~ COo olu-i.'.O.IS~ C~D_.._ .::881 O~-
... . HN:~:.:~5~ ~o~~~5==Il~~~ ~~~~
[II ~~ ., ~N5:;:~li!~:~~.~si:E3
>11 , !! :ii~,,:'5: filii . 5IJ~U~fi:~_~:o9Ii
,.. :i~~t::;-~:1~=i"'~5~~~
o~ 0 .... ~ c::J aas DI'.8O'...:: fi:g g'o'O....
E, l' t.1i ~w ~DCO NZU ~-iO~M~.. "U~ ::,I)~5-.r
h~ 0 ...' 5.!~i~i'~lJ!Jt r~I:~~ 5~f.g.i.!c~ ,,; ~i=-f~mli"'~1115~~
> !:..
. dO ~ oU.li"-B;~8-_.ti.
....N S- iip -~c
0.... ;; ,lOt ~ S5diiE~ d-oE:8..8u!gu~! -d r c- 1~!t~Jli!~I~!:ili
... . . ~d" ,.: t!~jliii!~~jfi~~ji;:8! .t~1lj 11 o.d~
".
U~ , =ia .. a: III
> .. ~w 2~!~l1!!~~f!~~~~~:li~ oo.!~~~:~~; ~o_.. II D&~S"'. j
0 n o ~ ~iN~~li~~=~E:-~~f
~.i l Iii .. -' -......... cn.S~ ..c
.. } W c~illi .3:105_l15 -!lNtJ9~ z~ jj~~h~ B I~; c~io:~=~- J~!i808
~-). 0 "if' U W ~~ '1-~~2 ~z~. Z~h"..-~~g
EX" , '" .~ ~ ~ o a: III H!Ulr~~"!8.i~Mi8e ~- 1=IKI~~..5t ~~Wb~~m~i~j.f58;a
l' :I: :r ~~ -'
p- . O~M ~ w a: .. ~ _en I__~_ u~_I_~~.~= e-cnc"i.s..,.e_ 3~si~;-~I!e~""a j~
0" . i w'" ~~ Io!! .. '" Ob__~___.~5icO~: -!~- r:di!~ i
l ,~ u. i i I Io!! ~::~~i:O!:15:~~!alsti~ . ~iodf!l~aj~~~B~E=
-nl . 00.. olo!! III I!! 0 0
. ~Zd ~ j'...I'."'....'.'
u. . o ::J "'''' o Z w W fic~!~l~~~jaU35~~~~e8~! . .".... ,
!:l .. . :l~ 0 z z z W III Vl 5o~B aJi-~~G~5a.~
z ...... .. ti:f ~ '" ~ 0 0 a: 50~oc_Uo'_ U:V_ Z_D! _ 5D~tsc:55.5..2
00 0 Ul . f,=;~~~ l5 l5 g f.~d6-5deoti-~e~~fi~ fi.g ~ l:gd~OQ~!-g ~ D...cl-"Q'C ~"":58 ..:Eg.
.... .tl::Ja . a: '" .B,;;::j .il8-R~~ ;:ti-N.E
<<.. , g '" :I: E;8~~ a: '" &O~_u:~-gu5g-i~5~~BS~e
Cl ... . ~!8 In In U .. .. Z 0. -.a 0......8 0 n:iJ.:~ 0 01 gzti:O'rr-c
.... n. - 0 ~iD.5~ n".5~,..;~UZ.c!!o~.:{lIb -< ii i'i:a.~:: m ti-~"O.c" J.:_c~.s
.J ;< I j I U <- Jt-UJI-u'" ou-. 8 -0- -c U~lIuU'i:B' u- !:!It):JS-
a: ... ~~~cfi 5~;~1~55~~~~sB~ .:2~.c c: c U.c_ <15~~~;S~5tiu~~~&D
~ C i 0 - .uifib'riri-a ~go~~iiEm}sJ~~o~o
" J 0 ~S~~B ~~gd~~is~~5g&=5 .$ Sz::r: Im"Oz Q.
.... 0 ..
.0 Z I i W
w Z
In 0
. .
ON/Hi 'f'110 OllO:J311
-
A8
~NHJ1InB 03SlI\311 L I
lN31'1JSY' JO NOI1V:xn 03Slll3ll L I
SNOISI1I311 31. YO
I
Iw
."
"''''
...:!O
-..
"'r
"'0
'Ill
,
sf
Z
o
G
Ill...,
....
o~
15z
z'"
IS "'.
uh
...:::
........
~~
a:i
i!1?
I
I
I
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
~B9"-IL!; (~'9J Xtl:l OOg~-IL!; (~'9J 3NOHd NVi aOOM3~OHS avo~ NMOIHllViS Z~r9Z
,~~gg tI.l.OS3NNIW 'SI70dtl3NNIW S301^~3S SS313~IM J.Jf1Y
80f: 3.l.InS ~3M01 ~31YM OOOM3~OHS
OtlOIl 1l3ll11l .l.Stl3 'O~g SJ.N3"3SV3 SS300V 'I lOV~l 3SV31
-ONI 'SIIi!li!lNIDNiI Dli!I.J. -rn a3S0dO~d / M NV1d 31lS 03S0dO~d
z
-<
a3. s:
tLI ~
"
,01: ~
66- l-I
00.
Q
~
uoo.
.....0
:.s~
....0
~~
~~
,...
ad, :-::r",:att ='~~-=
.,., AM IBIIWl . :. A' OllfGhl 1'11'10 ........ 10
lIOIl'l3lJl:lM 1W'1or ...... 1'l'1U AJllQ) AOOt I
.JJ.J.3)JSfI Iv:iO.uw :JoIl J.DN oltONn:XJCl
1:J3IM:I:J JH.L It !)HI"". IJN!:U 3M!
'"
N
W
'"
:f
'"
~..
-~
~i
~f2~
WNw
z"''''
::Jz:i!
;:l!1'"
~~~
~ ,"...... ' -ll~, · / '
1 ~: -- "~ -NMO.LH.LII'lS '!> - - -: ~ -
... ~ :r .- .- I \ ..... __ _ 3 .H,D.S9 N
v"" ... I!! ~ _3_ .~~.~:: ~- - I \ i:l -- LntL --
I" g I!! \
· ~ - L,.--).,
:..'..... l? .-'-1' I
i, \ -- _2; _3_ .~:~:: ~_ I
: 1 15
I! ~
.1
I'
,I
i!
.1
:1
!i
:1
Ii
:1 :w
Ii 8:;
:1 cON
ii Nb
, l~
Ii
!
Ii
:!
'I I
ii/
'(
I'
i
~
~~
~S
~~
~~..,
I:;~:
e5lii~
~W'"
8;;..:
t;~~
WwiJ!
;;:i
5l~1?
3 .Lt,o.S9 N
-- ;s',ln --
--
'"
::J
lw
8~
.,;N
Ng
I
,Ill
.
,'1," _
.' ,
C'._'(. Y'
. , ,
'-.;'r -I
. "
~ - -~-.'>
-..;;r .. .,;'1
~
~
-~
1-\1:
~ .1,
f\! -p,.-
.-
l'
.-
:......
I~ 3 .L~,Q.S9 N
~ ~---
i is 8; ~
!/~; ~ ~ i
I! ww 0
:i !~ ~
I' IS;;? 13 ._
'.1 a.::J g: \(i~
Ii
j!
,I
i
I-
Z
w
~
w
(/)
<(
w
a::
w
I-
...J
W
:c
(/)
.....
o
...J
:;(
I-
W
o
..
Z
III
M
III I?
c
~::f
:8i5
....'"
~~
W'"
if:;:'
15~
\
\
\
\
....-
....-
.-
~.~
~
I
I
I
I
I i ~ i
L_I_
I III
~ !!Ie
~ II
c
~ Z
, ~ '" I II
, J:!
...... ....-,-"" ~
~
:i!
'"
...
CD":
t;:::
~g,
wili
ifj
...I?
o .
Ill"
0'"
f?ilj
-'"
NU
...Ill
~...
w......
w;
iEz
~I
w'"
i:';:--
~t>f
~~
:w
lll~
~'N
"'s
I III
iw
Je~
1ii'N
hr
,8
,~
..,
..
~
~
~f'
-- . .-
t~
tl.~
3 .6,.lllh68 N
-- It'9t, --
~1Il sf
;:~15iS..,
~N~frl:
w'-OVlU
if~:~~
... "'-
~~~~~
5~~1!ib
;:l:jgt
~~~lllg
\
\
\
\
.-
....-
./
\
f
. ..... UlIM I
~i
~tll
z 0
oz
:>
~.
---JZ
.. ":)lo.
-..'r- "I
Additional Notes
1. All plants shall be nul88l')' grown stock with
normal well developed bnmches and vigorous
root systems. They shall be healthy and free
from defects, 1t1uJy. disease and Infection.
2. Cover aD pIanfIngs with a mk'Ilmum or 4w
hardwood mulch over geotextOe fabrtc.
3. Vertry location of underground utilities prior
. to digging. '.
4. Site dimensions based on UIteig Englneers
uvey.
Maintenance ReQuirements
1. For one year aft8r planting, soak trees and
stwubs once to twice a week during the growing
season, 88 needed depending upon rainfall.
2. Plant materials to be guaranteed 88 thriving
one year after Installation or be replaced by the
contractor.
.
- de8Ign PIuvIded by:
UIIIIg EnaI,.... lno.
/
PIIIntIntI Schedule
. Medora Rocky Mountain Juniper
JunlpetU8 ecopu/otum
tr 8&8 - Qty. 26
......
r-----
o
, ': :~. ; ~";'
. ""'.,
'.... ..... .~ :. .',
. ";:,' }.'~ :.....:
~ ~
--..
r .. · . ....4'''''
I ·
I
I Pvopa..d Aw
pin Shelter
I 6' o.c.
~
APT 8heII8r
*
~
~
if"
~
F,~A E-n~~'&'"
I
if
.......
n
J!
Ii
II
I.
.t
~
J!
1Dc
.ccu
UJii:
=8-
..!!~
~cn
~~
~s
!<
~
IS
~i
~ c
J! .5
~~
Ii
l!o
0.1:
.l:UJ
C1J
.........7 ...._
---.,..........
.................-
- .....
..............
--
..... lItI-18-00
wja
- 1/2MJO
Exhibit D
PROPOSED LANDSCAPING
\
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (612) 474-3236
FAX (612) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen, Acting City Administrator
Larry Brown, Director of Public Works ~#tf!
March 3, 2000 V
.
FROM:
DATE:
RE: AT&T Antenna Application - Site Plan Review
Minnewashta Water Tower
AT&T has applied for a Conditional Use Permit to install panel type antennas on the
Minnewashta Water Tower located at 26352 Smithtown Road (refer to Attachment 1).
Background:
.
The proposed antenna will be located on the stem of the water tower at an elevation of 100 feet
above ground level (refer to Attachment 2). These antenna panels will be located approximately
37.5 feet below the existing antennas installed recently by APT Communications.
Site Plan/Building Review:
AT&T is proposing to construct a masonry building 24' x 28'. At the request of City St3ft: the
building has been proposed as a double bay building to permit an additional carrier within the
same site. This will minimize site disruption and inconvenience to Minnewashata Elementary
School.
At the time APT applied for a conditional use permit, a fence plan was reviewed and approved for
their site. Since that time, City Staff has asked that APT hold off on installation of the fencing to
consider a joint fence project with this proposal, should it be approved. The concept is to create a
single "corral" for the telecommunication facilities to maintain their equipment and to park a
generator on site in a secured area, should the need arise. APT has agreed to work with other site
vendors with regard to the location of the fence. As such, AT&T will be required to coordinate
the proposed fencing for this site plan with City Staff and APT communications at the time of the
building permit application. Fencing for the site shall also provide adequate clearance and free
access to the City of Shorewood electrical service panel for the water tower.
n
'i.J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
.J
Planning Commission, Mayor
and City Council
AT&T Telecommunications-
West Water Tower
March 3, 2000
Page 2 of3
Similar to the new APT site, all cabling between the proposed building and ground structure is to
be buried and enclosed in conduit. The applicant's engineer shall provide the City with details of
all penetrations into the water tower. In addition, calculations shall be provided for the
installation of all antenna mounts, panels and appurtenances for a design to withstand a lOa-mile
per hour wind with the appropriate wind gust factors applied. Three copies of all of the structural
calculations shall be provided for the antennas, penetrations, and appurtenances, and shall be
performed by a registered professional engineer within the state of Minnesota .
Any generators brought to the site for emergency electrical power are to remain at the site only
during periods of power outages. Any and all generators shall be sound attenuated to a level of
75 decibels of sound at a distance of 7 meters from the generator under 85 percent of the full
capacity of the machine.
Telecommunications Analysis:
Staff has requested that the City's Engineering Consultant, Garret Lysiak review this application
for conformance to the City's code. Mr. Lysiac's determination has found that this application is
in conformance to the requirements for telecommunications equipment (refer to Attachment 3).
Mr. Lysiac will be present at Tuesday night's meeting to address any additional concerns the
Commission may have.
Easemen ts/Legal:
.
The City of Shorewood has an easement agreement with the School District for location, access,
maintenance and operation of the Minnewashata water tower. This lease agreement provides for
telecommunications equipment to locate and operate equipment within that easement. The
School District is to be provided an opportunity to review and comment on the application for
each telecommunications vendor.
It is to be noted that the City. of Shorewood has a. 20-inch watermain located within the access
easement for the Minnewashta School parking lot. Telecommunication vendors are required to
obtain individual easements for installation of utilities on the property. Utilities are not to be
located within the easement. Exceptions may be reviewed and approved by the Director of Public
Works for crossings of the easement area for access. This is to allow for repair of the central
distribution main for the City of Shorewood.
Planning Commission, Mayor
and City Council
AT&T Telecommunications-
West Water Tower
March 3, 2000
Page 3 of3
The applicant shall be required to enter into a lease agreement with the City which includes, but is
not limited to lease rates, schedules, modifications to equipment, periodic inspections of all
equipment by the City's Consultant, on going monitoring requirements and notification
procedures.
The applicant shall be required to provide the City of Shorewood with a cash escrow or letter of
credit in the amount of $5,000 to insure that the water tower construction/modifications are
completed properly.
. Recommendations:
1. The applicant's engineer shall provide the City with details of all penetrations into the
water tower. Details shall include penetrations for cables, conduits, mounting brackets or
other appurtenances.
2. The applicant's engineer shall provide the City of Shorewood with calculations which
demonstrate the structural integrity of all equipment mounted the water tower for a 100
mile per hour wind design (with appropriate gust factors applied) and for all penetrations
into the water tower. All calculations submitted shall be perfonned by a registered
professional engineer within the state of Minnesota.
3.
The applicant shall coordinate fence locations with City S tafT, and APT Communications.
The location of the fence shall provide free access for the City of Shorewood electrical
service pane for the water tower.
.
4. Any generators brought to the sight shall remain at the site during periods of electrical
outages. Any and all generators shall be sound attenuated and shall meet not exceed 75
decibels of sound at a horizontal distance of 7 meters from the generator under 85 percent
of full capacity of the machine.
5. The applicant shall be required to enter into a lease agreement with the City which
includes, but is not limited to lease rates, schedules, modifications to equipment, periodic
inspections of all equipment by the City's Consultant and on going monitoring
requirements and notification procedures.
6. The applicant shall be required to provide the City of Shorewood with a cash escrow or
letter of credit in the amount of $5,000 to insure that the water tower
construction/modifications are completed properly.
0'
KF~ ~~ f ~~.~~
~ ' ~ ~dh.-~[J( I ~ .~~ ~ :/~ ~ : ~
,I . \. ---c_ ~.~ CIR ----'l~.~R:~ ~ ~ ~~ 1. .
-' '. ~T- ~ ' ~Cl_ :; r----.D~;r' ~ '"
S< · I /~ \ · ,I --r ~~0 --- c:IhLIl ~
r> · <, / l}; l~"<ef.:./; ~ ~
\7 · .~~ I '" .J" 19 ~ CLrIJ
~.. 1M . ~l V . I '1?<<> [III] =
o · .. .. b Subject ~c 5; A I I f-
. . ~
\ . 2 Pro... ~ I _
' *. ~ -~
" . ~ ~//
P' 2.N"""POmn;CIR<ll' ~.. - - =1 ~ V ~' J____c
WAY
~ ~ · ;F 1 "IJ)- ~
~ * · 0 ~~~ ~ k
Lr=n-~ ~ ^"/ I
~EU ~ - I
r::U~ I ~~cf
p; ~ EV Rl OR "' ~:~>- [ :~
I\~ ~~m'F i~ It~_p~p~
> ~ ~ w lL- -
'.., I~ ~ << ~ I c- ~
\=--CI1V (F ~BHOREV~O<i>q I~ t 71 f 1 1jR I r"' t
I--
I--
~
-
. *~
~...'\
~~
./
L.-
-
CITY OF CHANHASSEN
62ND ST W
500
I
o
500 1000 Feet ^
I W
N
Attachment 1
~~
~ EXISTING PAINTERS RINGS
{ EXISTING flPT ANTENNAS
<SCALA API8-19DD/D9DDl
1111111
AnT 'WIRELESS SERVICES
24',,28' EQUIP. BUILDING.
APT EQUIPMENT BUILDING
NOT SHO'WN fOR CLARITY,
ID'Ill
{ ANTENNAS
J"
'"
I
;...
!:!
b
I
b
2
ANT. TYPE
PDI0177
P 1 177
POlO 00
H 'W D
86' 10,38" 5'
86 1. 8
94' 7' 4,5"
SOUTH ELEVATION
t
(EXISTING 10' DIA.
'WATER TO'WER STEM
@3"Cll'o/>ITII.T
90.
..:
>-
...
ALPHA
b
I
;...
EAST D....EVATlIlN
DESCRIPTION AT&T WIRELESS SERVICES OF MINNESOTA, INC.
SOUTH LAKE MINNETONKA (SHOREWOOO) WATER TOWER SITE
ULTEIG ENGINEERS, INC.
~
!. @ 3' """"TILT
BET A NE'W A TL T ....IRELESS
EXISTING APT L. SERVICES ANTENNAS.
COAXIAL CABLES /@HO lIO\/IITILT MOUNTING PIPE AND
225' BRACKETS PAINTED TO
MATCH ....ATER re....ER.
TYPICAL (6) PLACES
...
M
o
C\I
~ ~I:::A~~N
o
~.ult.lliI.cam
1201 EAST RIVER ROAD
SUITE 308
MIIINEAPOLlS. IMINESOTA 6$421
PHONE (1Ir2J S11-2fSOO
FAX fIIr2J S11-'1IIII
~
\lrST rt...EVA TIIlN
NORTH ELE:VATION
ACTIVE SCALE
NONE
LIJRARY SCALE
DRAIoIN K
DATE 2
CHECKED B
REVISION
Attachment 2
..
OWL ENGINEERING &E C TEST LABS, INC.
cmmn..... OOMMnmCAnm a~
!MCmT WR'fDmS
.. Had.$!. U.. ~..US.lUI S6449
(m2i 1i5-4115 .. '.It i112) 11S-4Stl
1.-1914338
March 1, 2000
City of Shorewood
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, Minnesota 55331-8927
RE: AT&T Application for Cellular Site
Dear Mr. Larry Brown
.
I have reviewed the application from AT&T for a pes telecommunications
facility proposed to be located on the west water tower,
performed an interference study (intermodulation) using all the present
frequencies on the water tower as well as aU city and county frequenc,ies that could be
located on the tower. My analysis does not reveal any predicted interference problems
with the proposal.
Based on my review and analysis of the AT&T proposal it satisfies all of the
technical requirements of the city and can be approved,
.
If you bave any questions in this matter please contact me,
Sincerely,
Garrett G. Lysiak, P.E.
Attachment 3
r li.1. ~ en D ~1
~.1 ~ . ~H
Ii' ....i. u~
A-~-._. / \ ) 0
\ ---- ~ \...., \ \J. ,t '# ~"".
I i~. \
'. . .'" .....,.. r..: .:..,...-)
I i '.L~ r...., -' . -. - .
March 6, 2000
City of Shorewood
cio Planning Dept.
5755 Country Club Road
Shorewood, MN 55331
Dear Members of the Planning Dept:
.
We are concerned by the continuous negative impact the water tower structure at the
Minnewashta Elementary has on the local neighborhood's property value and appearance. The
city of Shorewood has embarked on a path to sell space on the water tower for antennae
appendages and degrade the valuation oflocal residents property values.
Enclosed is a copy ofa photo of the Medina water tower at MN55 and HN 116. How far will
this go? Will Shorewood eventually look like this?! What is the goal of the City of Shorewood?
Do they have a line they will not cross?
Each time more space is rented on the water tower the City of Shorewood collects more rent
income and the nearby residents receive reduced property values. It is a great injustice that the
City of Shorewood should profit at the expense of a few unfortunate neighbors of the water
tower. Please stop the expansion of antennae on the water tower.
.
Sincerely,
~~
S-8~5"5)fZA 'vMitfL~~
.:; f(~wiJ-[)IJ/ ;U 1/ 5"""S3:3 (
..
ec.,
.r
.....; i4 ..., If \.)-t"'t"\. d'"'' .
.. ! ,;L.., '--"'~ I --r '-
C oJ. r d' .f)
.......-<..t......:'-.A- ......c~.
o
i~~,~,~n"l7:r\
.tlIl ,,1M - 20UO ~
!
'By -=
. ...,.,
. .......' II'
-
-.. -.
.
11I-
liB.
'P;-'iJ;'
';:rftli
IIIl
..... .. -.'11 -
-, -."11 ........ -r,.;.. 11IIII_11-1." 1\1 ., III_ -=
..:' ." ..'~ .:. · II _"".. III
.. --- - I II, _... III. ...... III., .
.. .. .... ::': -II - · Ill. . ' '" ...
III ..... ..11I.._ r".. -.... -._. .....;,.'. I..
.-. .- -.'.. ...J_
. - .. ---.- . .'.
III ..... . ....11 .... .., ..
· . .. ..... II . I
II 1.-.. ." .. 11II .. 11._ !.. _
III ." ... ".._ '0. .
III iIIIl : IIIl II .""'1'1' .:,; .....0-, _ II..: .. W' B.,i." III
- ' .. '-. · :. - -. i,; III
.II,,~. '.11._ ',';.:". III .. ...'
.. . .'-.. ,III'
-1111 III.'. _. . _Ij
... ...... :&If
II 111 :._11 1J'l
.".. r
lfJI .....""11":'1-11' - ~IIJ i;~
.
I
:W([[!;::jj
,"""j ,:.".,tt.
!.I ,("~,, ). r
i;~;:;iii!!f{
x~~;f;~' l;.!jl :'
'Vi\t.;;.~. +h',
J.llo~: ,j. ~;:t'(:, I
. H..r
..
I,
.
..
I
I-
.gl
III
file:!/ A:\M VC-655S.JPG
.
Page I or I
-II II II
11II11
,R
-. ..
.. -. B
III -
.
.
!II II
..
II
IIlII1Il
III
.
03/0:"/]( IO()
.
.
Twila Grout
From:
To:
Sent:
Subject:
Jane Moen <Imoen@speakeasy.org>
<8rad.Nielsen.cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us>
Thursday, February 24, 2000 4:02 PM
At&T Wireless
I will not be able to make it to your meeting regarding the Equipment
Shelter at Minnewashta Elementary but wanted to voice my concern.
Page 1 of 1
FILE COpy
AI" ~,...-
With the addition of each utility builing there is the potential for
increased noise with the heating and cooling systems. I would like you to
consider researching the noise factor of the equipment they each plan to
use. In the past I have heard very noisy equipment. Because our home at
Marsh Pointe and others on Smithtown Road are so close to the buildings it
would a good idea to be proactive about the noise level.
We live at 26805 Marsh Pointe Circle. I also appreciated your consideration
with the generator noise this winter and hope such noise does not occur with
this new building.
Thanks again, we love Shorewood!
Jane Moen
2/24/00
Minnetonka Public Schools
Finance and Operations
Memo
FILE COpy
.
To: Mr. Brad Nielsen, Planning Director
City of Shorewood (: i \
From: Tom Berge, Executive Director of Finance and Operations \; V
\J '
CC: Dan Jett, Board of Education
Date: April 13, 2000
Re: Telecommunications Facility on Water Tower Located on Minnewashta
School Site April 24, 2000 City Council Meeting
.
The City request to the Minnetonka School District for a "review and comment"
regarding the proposal from AT&T to install telecommunications equipment on the
water tower located on the Minnewashta School site was discussed by the Board of
Education on April 13, 2000. In the process, the Board reviewed past District
discussions regarding a previously proposed installation at Minnewashta Elementary
and a previously proposed installation at Groveland Elementary.
Following the deliberations, the Board of Education directed the below
communication be conveyed to the City of Shorewood:
The Board of Education believes that it is undesirable to locate an
additional cell antenna on the Shorewood water tower located on the
Minnewasl1ta Elementary School site. Given the location of the tOvvei
in the middle of an elementary school playground and given the
uncertainty of the impact of the technology on the growth and
development of children, we respectfully request the City of
Shorewood refrain from approval of this installation or any future
installation of cellular antenna on the Minnewashta water tower.
Should a decision be made by the City Council to proceed, we request that City staff
maintain a close liaison with District staff when developing plans thus permitting the
district to keep the city appraised of the impact of the installation on school
operations. In addition, if the City authorizes a permit to install the antenna, the City
require that AT&T construct the garage in such a way to give the district access to a
portion of the building for storage purposes.
i ,-- (G -- l ; \ \ I ' I-r=:
',0 i~ Ie:. il \\/ ';::::: .
!IO\&\,r- '-, .
1D~ APR 18 2000 .~
: 8y ~__...~__
. -------~-
.
.
Page 1 of 1
From:
To:
Cc:
Sent:
Subject:
Julie Townsend <julietownsend@email.msn.com>
Shorewood Attny <tkeane@lhdl.com>
<cityhall@ci.shorewood.mn.us>
Thursday, April 20, 200010:26 AM
Lease Agreement City of Shorewood/AT&T
Good Morning, Tim.
Legal will agree to change Section 2(b)2 as you suggested yesterday afternoon.
Legal would like to add the following language to section 6 at the end of the paragraph. This language
supports A T& T's need for third party interference protection but does not get the city involved as an arbitrator.
It makes the carriers and an independent consultant work thinks out if there is interference.
"Additionally, the City will require that any third party (excepting any such governmental unit) desiring to locate
communications equipment on the Tower will first cause to be performed, by an independent, qualified
communications engineer, a radio frequency interference study, showing that the third party's use of the Tower
will not interfere with the operations of Lessee. Lessee shall have the right to review and approve such
interference study, and will not unreasonably withhold or delay its approval."
Please let me know if you approve.
Julie Townsend
Wireless Site Specialists
952-851-7877
612-819-9569 (wireless)
952-858-7377 (fax)
Apn', ~4f tocM\~1 M~+r~J
'#hB
4/21/00
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO. 00-_
A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDmONAL USE PERMIT TO
AT&T WIRELESS SERVICES
WHEREAS, AT&T Wireless Services (Applicant) is a communications common carrier
licensed by the Federal Communications Commission to provide personal communications
services to the Minneapolis/St. Paul metropolitan area; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has determined that, in order to provide uninterrupted
personal communications services to the western segment of its territory, it requires an antenna
site in the westerly one-half of the City of Shorewood; and
.
WHEREAS, the Applicant has therefore applied for a Conditional Use Permit for the
construction of a communications equipment enclosure on the site of the Shorewood west end
water tower and proposes to install as many as twelve (12) communications antennae on the
water tower itself; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant proposes to lease from the City of Shorewood the necessary
premises for the construction of a 9-foot by IS-foot communications equipment building and the
required space on the water tower pursuant to a long-tenn lease on a portion of the property
legally described as:
"The north 100.00 feet of the south 452.50 feet of the east 100.00 feet of the west
1057.50 feet of the Southeast Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of Section 32, Township
117, Range 23, Hennepin County, Minnesota."; and
.
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request has been reviewed by the City Planner, and his
recommendations have been duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated
2 March 2000, which memorandum is on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request has been reviewed by the City Engineer, and his
recommendations have been duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated
3 March 2000, which memorandum is on file at City Hail; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request has been reviewed by the City's Consulting
Telecommunications Engineer, and his recommendations have been duly set forth in a letter to
the City Engineer, dated 1 March 2000, which letter is on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, after required notice, a public hearing was held and the application
reviewed by the Planning Commission at its regular meeting on 7 March 2000, the minutes of
which meeting are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's application was considered by the City Council at its
regular meeting held on 24 April 2000, at which time the City Planner's and City Engineer's
:#'0
memoranda, the Consulting Engineer's letter, and a letter from the Minnetonka School District
were reviewed, the minutes of the Planning Commission were reviewed, comments were heard
from City Council members and staff, and approval given for the Conditional Use Permit, subject
to review and completion of a satisfactory lease agreement between the City and the Applicant.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. That the subject water tower site is located on the Minnewashta Elementary
School property and is presently zoned R-lA, single-family residential. The site is currently
occupied by the Shorewood water tower, an equipment shelter owned by American Portable
Telecom, the Minnewashta Elementary School, its parking areas and playground facilities.
.
2.
That the land use surrounding the site is single-family residential, zoned R-IA.
3. That Section 1201.23, Subd. 4a. of the Shorewood City Code provides for
governmental and public regulated utility buildings and structures to be constructed within the R-
IA zoning district by Conditional Use Permit, subject to certain requirements of screening and
landscaping when abutting a residential use in a residential district.
4. That the Applicant's activity serves a valuable purpose in the community, and
there is a need for the activity and services provided by the Applicant in order that the
community be properly serviced, and that the Federal Telecommunications Act requires that local
governments accommodate personal communications services within their boundaries.
.
5. That the proposed use of the land is in accordance with the official City
Comprehensive Plan and will not adversely affect the general welfare, public health and safety of
the community.
6. That approval of the proposed Conditional Use Permit should be in the form of a
lease agreement setting forth the rights and obligations of the parties to the Agreement.
CONCLUSIONS
That the Applicant's application for a Conditional Use Permit for the construction of a
communications equipment building as shown on Exhibit A and antenna array as shown on
Exhibit B is hereby granted, subject to the provisions of City Code, Section 1201.04, Subd.
l.d.C I), the recommendations of city staff, the City's telecommunication consultant, and the
following additional conditions:
1. That the grant and term of the Conditional Use Permit shall comply and be subject
to all of the terms and conditions set forth in a Water Tower Space Lease Agreement to be
negotiated between the City and the Applicant.
2
.
.
2. That the site shall be restored and landscaped in accordance with the approved
landscape plan shown on Exhibit C. For the purpose of assuring and guaranteeing to the City
that the landscape improvements to be constructed, installed and furnished by the Applicant,
shall be completed according to the plans shown on Exhibit C, the Applicant agrees to escrow
with the City a cash deposit or provide the City with an irrevocable letter of credit approved by
the City in an amount equal to 150% of the total cost of said improvements. Said escrow deposit
or letter of credit shall remain in effect for a period of two growing seasons following the
completion of the required improvements. The said escrow deposit or letter of credit may be
reduced in its amount or replaced by a maintenance bond at the discretion of the City upon
acceptance by the City of the improvements.
3. That the Water Tower Space Lease Agreement shall contain provisions allowing
the Applicant to sublease part of the proposed equipment shelter to a future telecommunications
carrier, subject to approval by the City of Shorewood;
4. That permanent power is to be provided to the equipment building prior to
operation of the telecommunication facilities. The use of portable generators shall be limited to
emergency power outage situations only.
5. That this resolution, together with the Exhibits attached hereto and the Water
Tower Space Lease Agreement, be filed and recorded with the Hennepin County Recorder or
Registrar of Titles within thirty (30) days of certification hereof.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SHORE WOOD this 24th day of
April 2000.
WOODY LOVE, MAYOR
ATTEST:
BRADLEY J. NIELSEN, ACTING CITY ADMINISTRATOR
3
L: \1~~!J\Y!J-~)1l/2\lIWY\SlIEPL^N.lIWY Fr'i Jail 21 10: 12: 25 2000 KU^
ON/MYIIO 01103311
11 .
All
~ a
. "!!
.
...
a
"!I
.:
I
'3
N I
I
-X I
. I
A I
n I
,
I
I
- ~""-IL' "''' XV~ 0"'-'<$ 'ZIOI """"'" Nrl O00M3~OHS OVO~ NMOll-llIrlS ZSI:~Z
- ,ngg V.J.OS3NNIW 'S170dV3NNIW S301^H3S SS313HIM l~ 1 V
BO~ :/J/ns H3MOl H31VM OOOM3HOHS
OVOll1l3ll111 .J.SV3'O~g SlN3r43SV3 SS300V )g lOVHl 3SV31
.ONI 'SlJililNIDNiI D13.J.7n 03S0dOHd 1M NVld 31lS 03S0dOHd
- ..... ..,.
--....f
......-c
.,::1
...~
~!
Ill!:"
l'l~
~t --
~f2 ./.,; ..-
,/
"'I&.!ll~rO+]:tf~ .:
'JJ.:':I:~.73..i..~~I;=-,.u -
~
~
'i
b
ii
~I
l!;~::l
3~~
j!;~$
~I;!~
~ .~-!:~!- '1!~' J - ~ .
I ~ au NMO.LHJ.U'iS:!> ~..... _
1 - - /~......
.. .0. '0 ] .tt.o.ee N _ - ... I " ................ _~ .at~:: ~_
I IV'" eo g -- OO'DEE -- I \ OJ_
- :.~ - ---~-\
i j ~-J }_.~t~::~_ - I I
I j i
,! g I
i I
i i
II' , I ,_:,. . I'"
, !!~ ~- " !~ I
,'. I: 7~ C '0::-,') . 0 I.. I
~ '~-:~l
, I
. : .-
I i I \
: II ~ \
j : \
I )
I :
] .it.D.', N
-- ~8'[I[1 --
......
.-
,.c
.-
...c:
:><:
~
--
,/~
4-~
...
I
:J I
I
I
::J
i
~
Ii
~b::l
b.:t
Ii!
i~i
~bJ
;:.
I'll
Itt
!~
wI;!
r:;
l!Il
~;
] .tt .0.,' N
-- OO'DEE --
/
_/
~
~~/
'1-
Z
w
:::!i
w
V)
<(
w
a:::
~
(j
:c
Vl
......
o
-1
~
W
o
I...
=!~
-..
~l;
,..
,
I'"
l!!~
~t
I..
,,'
I
w
\!Ie
Ii
II
:'"
~~
,8
I"
" ",., a
'- ,
...... ......,'
--
...
,..,
\-
....
~
-<)f'
QJ .-
t~
r1:~
~.. ~
j!;~l!IA::I
:iti~1
:1-
l!Il!Il;j_!:"
~~ 1Il"'-
~i:~i
~i
:go-:
~::
~i
l!I
I~
,.A
~~
........
ri
l!Il
~:;
e:
I
~ I
Ii ,
[j I
1:f;:j I
l'JI ,
I.. \
!;:. ,
~l \
II \
\
,
,
,
~ .8l.".9~.8V H
-- Wltr --
j, R&J I~ I i~ g ~ i" rl&i~ s i 4 ~ij;ift~i
~J ~;I iflliJ'II!!ljil ;1 j!lli~ '.":"~;iljjl.j:
ti;~r:~ij,~j ;l~!i,.. fi~~f'!j". II!jA'Jli~.I...lj
i~jjlllj!:!~I!:!I!'!1 l~!jlliill iijl!Ii;lji:I!~i;
) il=r]f!l"',l.fllh!! hi .!I~JII"1 ~r~lh is:l:1j,J1!,
i!~~J.J~ if ! ~N81 ~i is!~~J'I!. &jn."f5_~ :~li
lui IH"i81l'l;d:;~fJ IUUJ".II~H l~i~~;:!I~.'tl.J .I~
ft.. J;".~il!..ia'ii~ D".~;~! '.dRJt. a~ ; leu
k 11Ui!n.I!~lI:~IJ.t~f't jl ~Jej!Hi'l ~1~i!.ln I:~l :d]H~
. U::~''l:~;8::aili!h:lle!il'[ k i':~E::~8a~ ~ lli~::fol!l!I:'!8lhli~"~'~
<5Ir.s'1l1l;E'~li::f-u 5~'O"<{1I_ <5';.lrl!.~& m <Ii .~j.HIl' 115-~ah
l..i!fill h5jiJ;i~hli.8a'il; . l.ififi.hH ~EB:1I.~UEf:i5liii~l:.=
~s~% ~~;o~Ni5~e aft5 ~Szx m~Zft kO~2~ nGZ _Neovo
,-,
'"
u:
r ! i
t:
I~ I !!!
I !i! I
I"
..~t r. ~
i~, l .ei i Ii
J~~ r ili i ~~~I ~I~
.,
C' . . \.: ..
D- . ! ~" II r~~w..t!inin~
<" : HJ i
_n,
~ . ~ ."
::c , it & !&IJ.~~fii
...
..
... l .'i,.'! m
...
...
it IJ' i i I! I ~
~
'1 2 S I i I I I ...
~, i5
_0 Ci Ii: i I ~
m ~
i::~
,
-l!!!!!1J!:!!!Il
~
I':
t.;
,,'
, !Ie I
v, ~ oX
3:
"
-=l~
.
.
..
904'
H './ D
6 D.JS" S'
..
r 04,5
-NEV COAXIAL
CABLE 9RACl<ET
o
+
I
/"'mlNG I< '" I
. './ A TER TO'./E.~ STe:x
@7'2l\dII1Lr
--
90"
~OCISTING PAINTE:lU RlNG3:
r! EXISTING N'T AH1!1fCAS.
1 <ICAl.A API8-19lIlIIG9DlD
.
t
~
,.
-
ALPHA
..
I
....
NE'./ A TIoT \(!R(LESS
S(aVrCE:S AHTENNAS
PAlHre:D TO HATCH
'./A TEil TO'./Eil
~
. I @n...m.r
BETA \ . LN(V ATLT \(IRELE:SS
OCISTL'<<i APT SEIMce:s ANTENNAS,
COAXIAL CASLE:S 4101 llMlI1I.r MOUHTlHG PIPI: AHD
m' BRAO<tTS ?AINTE:D TO
MATCH \(AT(R TO\IER.
TYPICAL (6) ?LACE:S
r \. AHTOiNAS
*
'"
..
N
~ SECTION
e:a e 100' E!.tVATION
100iI
*
.
...
I
..
!:!
b
I
b
..
A TL T 'w'lRtl..E:SS SERVIctS
c04'xcS' e:gurp, BUILDING.
APT (QUJPMENT BUILDING
NOT SHO'w'H F1JR CLARITY.
o
SOUTH ELEVATION
~AST R~A1"IDtf 'JEST R~ATTrIN
DESCltlPTlON AT&T WI RELESS SERVICES OF MINNESOTA. INC. ACTlVt SCAU: NONE
SOUTH LAKE MINNETONKA (SHOREWOOOJ WATER TOWER SITE UJRARY SC\l.t
NORTH ELEY A TTON
ULTEIG ENGINEERS, INC.
Of
FAX fnZJ D1-,IU
~:
Exhibit B
CO, EAST IlIVE1I ROAD
6IITE 308
MNlI!.UOUS. ~OTA S6421
PHCNI! ,.rv ~/ID(J
_.u/t./g.cClm
.......,... O~O~-UPII "UCIZ~'''' Iltl~ ~
QIlI.....~ lfIll8l1lUMy~_ UBld adeospuBl BlosauulW 'poOM9J04S 1III ~ ~
~ J9JI911S SS919JIM Ul V J9A'\OlJ9J8M pooM9JOllS J I 15 -t!ll
u
....
.-
,.0
.-
..t::
~
l:.Ll
SHVI>OSSV
WVHVIl9NI
/'
<
""'-
I
.,
1
I ;el
I ,I~
II!
.
I
o
..
J
I
~
"-
"-
"
'" ~
,"" }
"0~ ! f
~
--I-L -=---__
\i.
:f
~=:.t
\tJ 3
\~ JCC
v-. J
,. i :j
'----~--
o .~a
tile" I i lb ~~
t~ IiI hi.! i! ~ 81
I 1 I ....,a lit I!
if!! f- I I . III i
I 1111 wi !. i I Is; II~
i :Iu h ~f ~I i Hr ~n
"
.
. .
~
Ii
II
al
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD · SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927 · (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
.
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DA TE:
19 April 2000
RE:
Sabris CUP - Revised
FILE NO.
405 (00.04)
.
Just prior to the Planning Commission meeting at which this item was discussed, Mr.
Sabris revised his plans to include a larger garage. The revised plans and the total areas
of accessory structures were presented at the meeting, but are not reflected in the 30
March staff report. The revised figures are:
New garage:
Total accessory space:
1010 square feet
2280 square feet
The revised figures are included in the proposed resolution.
Cc: Tim Keane
Larry Brown
Basim Sabris
n
~ . PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
...
~(,~
.
>
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (612) 474-3236
FAX (612) 474-0128. www.cLshorewood.mn.us. cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Planning Commission, Mayor and City Council
.
FROM:
Brad Nielsen
DATE:
30 March 2000
RE:
Sabris, Basim - C.U.P. for Accessory Space in Excess of 1200 Square Feet
FILE NO.:
405 (00.04)
BACKGROUND
.
Basim Sabris has applied for a conditional use permit to construct accessory space in excess of
1200 square feet on the property located at 6125 Apple Road (see Site Location map - Exhibit
A, attached). Mr. Sabris has plans for remodeling and adding on to the existing home on the
property, part of which includes building an attached garage on the east end of the house.
Since the area of the garage, when added to existing accessory structures on the site, exceeds
1200 square feet, a C. U.P. is required.
The property is zoned R-1A, Single-Family Residential and contains 89,050 square feet (2.04
acres) in area. As shown on Exhibit B the site is occupied by the applicant's home, a small
brick detached garage, and a nonconforming barn to the southeast of the home. The existing
garage contains 280 square feet of area. The barn has approximately 570 square feet on the
upper level and 420 square feet on the lower level. Since accessory buildings are limited to
one story in height, the bam is nonconforming. The new attached garage will have 700 square
feet of area, bringing the total area of accessory structures on the site to 1970 square feet.
Exhibit C shows how the garage will be situated on the site.
The after the remodeling is completed will contain 2486 square feet of area on the main floor
and 2223 square feet on the upper level. The total floor area above grade of the house will be
4709 square feet.
n
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
.
.
Memorandum
Re: Sabris CUP
30 March 2000
Exhibit C is the proposed main level floor plan. Exhibit D shows the south elevation of the
house with the garage on the right side.
ANAL YSISIRECOMMENDATION
Section 1201.03 Subd. 2.d.(4) of the Zoning Code provides criteria for granting conditional
use permits for accessory space over 1200 square feet. Following is how the applicant's plans
comply with the Code:
a. The total area of accessory buildings (1970 square feet) does not exceed the proposed
floor area (4709 square feet) above grade of the existing home.
b. The total area of accessory buildings does not exceed 10 percent of the minimum lot size
for the R-IA zoning district (.10 x 40,000 = 4000 square feet).
c. The proposed garage addition complies with R-IA setback requirements. Although the
property is not located in a shore land area, it should be noted that the total area of
impervious surface on the site will be approximately 11 percent. It is also worth
mentioning that the house and all of the accessory buildings are well buffered from
surrounding properties by existing vegetation.
d. Since the new garage is an integral part of the existing house and garage architectural
compatibility is not considered to be an issue.
Based upon the preceding analysis, it is recommended that the applicant's request for a
conditional use permit be granted as proposed.
cc: Tim Keane
Basim Sabris
-2-
Chanhassen
HOllY LA.
~
N
500
I
o
500 Feet
I
Exhibit A
SITE LOCATION
Sabris - Conditional Use Permit
.
-
~
~~
,\GoO
,--
11?' /'
/
/
I
q10
I \ t:=.. .
I~I
J
I ~ I
l 1 I
^' a::.1t~i~ ~
r I.) J16"
I i - l
" r \
("712.. \..
'" '" '"
"" " '1-, ~~
--- 9 /it>
7S-
@ SITE F~ 0"
A I ! " .. t?O -
D
NDf'Ti-l
Exhibit B ED SITE PLAN
PROPOS
,I
\' .
-----M~:;;: ~~~~':'f -;.-; --"~'."~ ----~~~~~::':~i.~{::.lL=:~::
k-.---l~".~ ' l-f=---==,,--7'-;; --f-,-
I,T' -'~~I I
l' \~) F"" t' I
: I I .
~ J' .'. t-' I. ' ___"".'.'
- - -- - _. . _ ! J--. --- ~~ - - --1 --r.:--
, . J,_. · . . '-'---'---T[. ==f.-:~-.(,~--~~,+,
r-'-----j..' f:
!: I, eN1J<'( Ii' H
.: I I . ::
.-----........- ...
:: --.,...... .--:: L_____.u._..J ~+=-'.:r::-~..l--r--l.r
.. t-'1
:;' r' llPtNINGo ')4
L~t=+ 1=1''1=-:rl
.
--_._-~-
___._. -00 _._____.. '" _ .. ___ ____=\__ .__
-----.:.-.-~. -.. ~-
-----h-'fUT~-J:;.~h,;-'o;illll>K. - ". '":.
'--
.
-r-- -- "I
"-_-II I
I I I, I
I Ne"" .......... ~/;I" I
Ii J'.-? PI I
I ~~I I
I II I
II I
. I I I
-. I
L_ - -4 L I )
- --t ...
'1 :.
.1,
I
I .
r!1ll/l<E IZ. 7 '''1> ~
-J"
2..;' . ,.
'"0
_, vr
't-
,~~'~-'"~._--_.. .---
to tJff' ~c.", L__
I--~--
I \r~
I ~
,/ r.....cl\
I....
rIl-
I
'>
"
/
l --.
J.~__ 7
/
n
"
..i
I ~ ' 'i i
: ,+ f~~I1I~ 'z +-H- UP
rt,"'Y"! j, '11"", \.LL.
I ~'.:C..:' . '~:~ 'r~
'>
,
)
-:- ~~~~.;_ _'3;:~
r
w.t.. "---.
0"::'('
o
.'
~ I
I
I
~T~
: : .f:e.Pf:-t1
.'
"
~ WE'i>T Bl.-EY' (!..' W-"L.I'''' J:D'.'
,10,7. I.e.", I' . 01'
.-... -- "--'----::;&'T",-(,ii--- -. . ---.---.--
.
u
-~
"
~~r-FLLlEUP I'J)
I I ,,;,
I I ,\(:
---".t- ---It - - ~-~
z... !I ')~ ~ 1"~ I
I~" .,.
,,'
"
In
;.
. ,:~e
, v-"""",,,
!
~;...~~
L1VII"!~___~(J"'!..
I: !r'l
I N
:::-= =: ==- == --=-- -=6=' =::O~~ == -= :;'.' =o=- ::::
''\-, ~p\1i~ (NioJ:~c.'f~)
uw-otlJ" of:~;.
l,\
>
..
t~ l
~~ 4
- - {<..;,~, -",,,::~~., ~,._-,.. -~ ., ~- .:,,'~-';::.' . :.'~ ;-, -
2,.." S' ~ I!>
---1
2."~
-,.
- - -- - - -, ::..~ ~....:- -
.-...---- -
v-:.~
------------
I
I
L_ __~
'?
-~
Q;) KAIN .u:'{f:.!:"JL'::Vr-- FL-N-I
-\1 1/1'" .,. I' _t?"
.."':~
MUD ~ ;Y
~ "
CU':>EL
c:um!~ -
t-__~'IDfl .
J
L
------...-.
.- - -.-.
:...~~ '_...~,...~,
- - ---..~..:---
Exhibit C
FLOOR PLAN - MAIN LEVEL
~
.
....
I
I
I
I
~l
I,
I'
if
; J
Ii
: j
: t
~ l
1 :
.
Ii
.,
, I
Dff~p... ~,v ~,- ; !
- -,-_.~-
~. .~
iI
: I
, I
. .
! i
, .
i!
I
L.
i i
, '
i,
.
.
I'
lL
: ]t: L....~. f~
.
, .
...-
n
,! 1
:i
.
I
.
i
I
.
I
I
I
I
I
i,
,j
~
II :i 1
1 ' :
J :! 'J
:t ' ~i
.LJ "
;j j ,I
J :a ,f
I
.
I
I I
'-'
'J' --==r ':, - ...,..---
','I 1 :,1 ,'I!l ,1..-- -, - -I
',' ~a. ~ lj 'I' ,~;' ' ; : :i
, ,r~\ Ii !; · ~:
.:..r~:. :1._.._":. ,,"!~
"~I"""I
~ ,IIi::: "I;u li;j ;\I:J iii'
1 ,--"" --.1 t-.'
~Jf.,~~ .~' T' ,
\ ~-~ ~l'
, I l----r"':::
\ --~ H""'--
~ ---....... ~
.~---.;. .
II
11lf" t:f' ~ ."E::..::F=' L-At-IO~~{N(,
t::::r
r
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
'j
:j
I
!t
,i
i
,:
r--
~-
_1-...1
I "
/ 't. i 0 t;i'~T ~ ' Si~e.
~~ ~Vlvl)lt-lb ,,~~ $e-'-1i/rJ$
r~ t"l~lr ~rz..f1loN5
..---~' .
m.l,!"i
': 'I :
'I' , :1
' ' ,
'1 ' :
i, :1 il
W,I
.f ' :
,,- ~F- FL-~ ftNJ7 ~ 'NDW. SI!C.)'
~~ Ft.J"1'(J#'e ~ r'~H
/- I ~w ~Nf., l~t?ICA~_
//'<, ~ I ' Ftl1lJF* ~ f?1'4l I
~ ''':::..>:'- _ if' .J ~-=::I I _.~"11DN -1"1''f'''''1X<<
~. ::/...... rf) _ $J- -"< ~ ~ - -;Jrr / ~.., ~A""'~(..
I "1--':' 'II I-,P~.i I' I ~ I
, i :; I 'I i !. 'I'" j' Ii~"'- ,-,., - - - --..,.......1
! "'j'; ;1; I I :,' II: ,; ',': ; Ii! ,..-- - - -- I
i! 'Ikd'l' iilUi! ;i! ':;, :; .. ....~- 1'1 r -1' ,~--
; I ,I II ,I . 'I' 'j, :1 I '
i =*i: ,: I I 1'1 i;:l :1' f='" ,.+-fUTIU t;..~K. I
I - ;1__, - 1- - ~ll ~A J ~'I: ! n_
, ,I j
T-L
I
I
L
-------~
I ,
; ,
'-
Exhibit D
BUILDING ELEVATION - SOUTH SIDE
\,
.
.
CITY OF SHOREWOOD
RESOLUTION NO. 00-_
A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
FOR ADDITIONAL ACCESSORY SPACE
TO BASIM SARRIS
WHEREAS, Basim Sabris (Applicant) is the owner of real property located at 6125
Apple Road, in the City of Shorewood, County of Hennepin, legally described as:
"Tract B, Registered Land Survey Number 463, Hennepin County, Minnesota"; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant has applied to the City for a Conditional Use Permit for the
construction of an attached garage, the area of which, when added to the area of existing
accessory space on the property, will bring the total area of accessory space on the property up to
2280 square feet; and
WHEREAS, the Shorewood City Code requires a Conditional use Permit for the
construction of accessory space exceeding 1200 square feet; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was reviewed by the City Planner, and his
recommendations were duly set forth in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated 30
March 2000, which memorandum is on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, after required notice, a public hearing was held and the application was
reviewed by the Planning Commission at their regular meeting on 5 January 1999, the minutes of
which meeting are on file at City Hall; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant's request was considered by the City Council at their regular
meeting on 4 April 2000, at which time the Planner's memorandum and the minutes of the
Planning Commission were reviewed and comments were heard by the Council from the City
staff.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of
Shorewood as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
I. That the subject property is located in a R-IA, Single-family Residential zoning
district and contains approximately 89,050 square feet of area.
2. That existing accessory buildings located on the property include a detached
garage, and a nonconforming barn.
3 . That the total proposed accessory space (2280 square feet) does not exceed the floor
area above grade of the principal structure (4709 square feet).
"
.
.
4. That the total area of accessory space does not exceed 10% of the minimum lot
area for the R- 1 A zoning district in which it is located (4000 square feet).
5. That the design and materials of the proposed attached garage are consistent with the
architectural character of the existing home.
6. That the proposed attached garage complies with all setback requirements for the R-IA
zoning- district.
7. That the proposed garage will bring the total amount of impervious surface on the site to
only 11 percent of the total lot area.
CONCLUSION
A. That the application of Basim Sabris for a Conditional Use Permit as set forth herein above
be and hereby is granted.
B. That this approval is subject to the following:
1 That the proposed garage will be used strictly for purposes of a residential nature.
2 . That the Applicant is hereby advised that the City Code provides specific regulations
relative to home occupations and any future use of the garage for other than
allowable residential purposes would have to comply with such regulations.
3. That prior to occupancy of the home the Applicant shall paint the existing barn and
fix the soffit fascia on the barn, clean up the site and control construction debris, and
comply with the requirements of the local Fire Marshall regarding spilled fuel.
C. That the City Administrator/Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to provide the Applicant
with a certified copy of this Resolution for filing with the Hennepin County Recorder or Registrar of Titles.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY SHOREWOOD this 24th day of April 2000.
Woody Love, Mayor
ATTEST:
Bradley J. Nielsen, Acting City Administrator
-2-
Hpr ~U UU U~:~lp
~lt~ oT ~XCelS10r
~b~4'/4o::JUU
p. 1
City of Excelsior
339 Third Street
Excelsior, MN 55331
(952) 474-5233
(952) 474-6300 (fax)
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
.
(952) 474-6300
DATE:
.
N. l
FROM: ~oJ~'Mrr-
RE: -r<<~ :jfA:
TO:
FAX:
NUMBER OFP AGES (INCLUDING COVER SHEET)
--1tAJ1)
COMMENTS: ~ ~ the L,~~~\I'- ~~ .
itLjkt JqA · .
v('
~~;tJ1\ Wovrlik'b cMANt/J" ~ hJ:!.we
~fy;~~~~ ..'
# 7A
Hpr ~U UU U~:~lp
~lt~ oT ~XCelS10r
~b~4'/4o::JUU
p.~
Revision to Section 11.2 ofEFD JP A
2nd draft (April 20, 2000)
11.2 Dissolution. The District shall be dissolved upon the affirmative vote of a two-thirds
majority of the Member City councils. Dissolution shall occur at the end of the second fhll
calendar year after the date of the agreement to dissolve, unless this joint powers entity is
reestablished as a special unit of government.
Dissolution shall also occur if:
(1) a Capital Improvement ProgramlFinance Plan that includes approximately $3,000,000 or
more to renovate adequately the existing fire station or construct a new fire station(s) is
not approved by July I, 2002, the plan and budget for which has been determined by the
Board and recommended to the city councils as what is necessary to provide the best
service for the District based upon a disinterested, professional feasibility study; or .
(2) said renovation or construction does not begin by June 30, 2004.
Dissolution under the terms in (1) above shall occur on December 31, 2002.
Dissolution under the terms in (2) above shall occur on December 31, 2004.
In the event that the District dissolves under either of these conditions, all assets of the District
shall become the property of the City of Excelsior and all other Sections of this Agreement
regarding the distribution of assets or disposition of equipment shall be superseded.
.
.
CITY OF
SHOREWOOD
5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD. SHOREWOOD, MINNESOTA 55331-8927. (952) 474-3236
FAX (952) 474-0128' www.cLshorewood.mn.us' cityhall@cLshorewood.mn.us
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
Brad Nielsen, Acting City Administrator lh
Lany Brown, Director of Public Works J~ /
April 20, 2000 /
.
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
Discussion Regarding Leave of Absence for Public Works
The City Council requested that this item appear on this agenda, regarding the leave of absence for
Mr. Jeff Jensen.
Currently, Jeff has not been authorized to return to work as a light equipment operator by his
physician. However, occupational therapists are working with Jeff towards returning to work.
.
Due to the timing of the leave, it is desirable to review the needs for the Public Works Department
for the coming season.
n
~J PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
BA.
Check Approval List for 4/24/00 Council Meeting
Check # Vellder Name Descriptioll Check Date Illvoice # Amount
27774 PERA PERA PR ENDING 4/8/00 4/12/00 $1,672.20
27774 PERA PERA PR ENDING 4/8/00 4/12/00 $1,533.39
TOTAL FOR PERA $3,205.59
27775 ICMA RETIREMENT TR DEFERRED COMP 4/12/00 $1,152.69
TOTAL FOR ICMA RETIREMENT TRUST-457 $1,152.69
27776 CITY COUNTY CREDIT PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS 4/12/00 $576.00
TOTAL FOR CITY COUNTY CREDIT UNION $576.00
27777 AFSCME COUNCIL 14 APRIL UNION DUES 4/12/00 $153.00
TOTAL FOR A FSCME COUNCIL 14 $153.00
27778 AMSTERDAM PRINTIN LASER MAILING LABELS 4/12/00 008889 $67.75
TOTAL FOR AMSTERDAM PRINTING/LITHO $67.75
27779 BROWNING FERRIS IN GARBAGE SVC - TB LIQUORS 4/12/00 03000-0200 $43.78
TOTAL FOR BROWNING FERRIS IND. $43.78
27780 CHAMPION AUTO STO PARTS FOR PW VEHICLES 4/12/00 0331STMT $167.17
TOTAL FOR CHAMPION AUTO STORE #344 $167.17
. 27781 G & K SERVICES MARCH SERVICE 4/12/00 0331STMT $483.33
TOTAL FOR G & K SERVICES $483.33
27782 KEN JARCHO INSURAN ADDL INS CHG BFOOOO0472580 4/12/00 23420 $7.59
27782 KEN JARCHO INSURAN ADDL INS CHG BFOOOO0472580 4/12/00 23420 $9.72
27782 KEN JARCHO INSURAN ADDL INS CHG BFOOO00472580 4/12/00 23420 $3.69
TOTAL FOR KEN JARCHO INSURANCE $21.00
27783 METRO SALES, INC. INK FOR PRINTER 4/12/00 61052A $46.33
TOTAL FOR METRO SALES, INC $46.33
27784 MN CHILD SUPPORT P CHILD SUPPORT - C SCHMID 4/12/00 $173.51
TOTAL FOR MN CHlLD SUPPORT PMT CTR $173.51
27785 MINNESOTA GFOA MAILING LABELS 4/12/00 200004001 $15.00
TOTAL FOR MINNESOTA GFOA $15.00
27786 MN SUN PUBLICATION ASSESSMENT NOTICE 4/12/00 309957 $35.75
TOTAL FOR MN SUN PUBLICATIONS $35.75
. 27787 PAZANDAK, JOSEPH MILEAGE/SUPPLIES/NEW PHONE 4/12/00 $83.43
27787 PAZANDAK, JOSEPH MILEAGE/SUPPLIES/NEW PHONE 4/12/00 $6.90
27787 PAZANDAK, JOSEPH MILEAGE/SUPPLIES/NEW PHONE 4/12/00 $10.65
TOTAL FOR PAZANDAK, JOSEPH $100.98
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP CREDIT 4/12/00 37645393 ($62.52)
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP 4/12/00 41318080 $52.05
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP 4/12/00 41318096 $23.75
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP 4/12/00 41318185 $62.60
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP 4/12/00 41318290 $27.36
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP 4/12/00 41318294 $30.00
27788 PEPSI COLA COMPANY POP FOR CITY HALL 4/12/00 42718243 $34.95
TOTAL FOR PEPSI COLA COMPANY $168.19
27789 PROTOCOL COMMUNI 2ND QTR 2000 INTERNET/DSL SVC 4/12/00 952204663 $195.00
TOTAL FOR PROTOCOL COMMUNICATIONS, INC $195.00
27790 RGIS INVENTORY SPE TB LIQUOR INVENTORY 4/12/00 697572 $203.49
TOTAL FOR RGIS INVENTORY SPECIALIST $203.49
27791 ROGERS, DON DELIVERY OF COUNCIL PKTS 4/12/00 $100.00
TOTAL FOR ROGERS, DON $100.00
27792 SENSIBLE LAND USE C SEMINAR 4/12/00 $30.00
Wednesday, April 19, 2000 Page I of7
Check # Vender Name
27793
27793
27793
27793
27793
27793
27794
27795
27795
27795
27796
27796
27796
.
27797
27797
27797
27797
27797
27797
27798
27798
27798
27798
27798
27798
.
27799
27799
27800
27800
27800
27801
27801
27801
27801
27801
27801
27801
27802
27802
27802
27802
27802
Descriptioll
Check Date /1lvoice #
TOTAL FOR SENSIBLE LAND USE COAL/TN
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
SWANDBY, DONALD MARCH MILEAGE/STAMPS FOR L1Q 4/12/00
TOTAL FOR SJVANDBY, DONALD
US POSTMASTER RENEW PERMIT 128 4/12/00
. TOTAL FOR US POSTMASTER
DAHLHEIMER DIST INC BEER
DAHLHEIMER DIST INC BEER
DAHLHEIMER DIST INC BEER
TOTAL FOR DAHLHEIMER DIST INC
DAY DISTRIBUTING BEER
DAY DISTRIBUTING BEER
DAY DISTRIBUTING BEER
TOTAL FOR DAY DISTRIBUTING
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 S36OQ-03310
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 S3600-03310
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 S3630-03310
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 S3630-03310
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 T7535-03310
EAST SIDE BEVERAGE BEERlMISC 4/12/00 T7535-03310
TOTAL FOR EAST SlDE BEVERAGE COMPAN
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 21873-03310
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 21873-03310
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 26369-03310
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 26369-03310
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 49163-03310
BEERlMISC 4/12/00 49163-03310
TOTAL FOR MARK V/l
4/12/00 5069-033100
4/12/00 5090-033100
4/12/00 5146-033100
4/12/00 1150-040300
4/12/00 1152-040300
4/12/00 1315-040300
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARK VII
MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT
MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT
TOTAL FOR MARLIN'S TRUCKING
NORTH STAR ICE ICE
NORTH STAR ICE ICE
NORTH STAR ICE ICE
TOTAL FOR NORTH STAR ICE
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI LIQUOR CREDIT 4/12/00 821180-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI LIQUOR CREDIT 4/12/00 821231-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI LIQUOR 4/12/00 822943-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/12/00 822960-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/12/00 822960-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/12/00 822963-00
QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/12/00 822963-00
TOTAL FOR QUALITY WINE & SPIRITS CO
THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEERlMISC 4/12/00 30080-04030
THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEERlMISC 4/12/00 30080-04030
THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEERlMISC 4/12/00 30100-04030
THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEERlMISC 4/12/00 30100-04030
THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEERlMISC 4/12/00 30210-04030
4/12/00 7280/7310/73
4/12/00 7280/7310/73
4/12/00 13006608
4/12/00 31008717
4/12/00 60950
April 19, 2000
Amount
$30.00
$33.00
$33.00
$33.00
$26.51
$26.51
$26.51
$178.53
$200.00
$200.00
$220.80
$220.70
$240.00
$681.50
$1,497.75
$1,456.65
$935.55
$3,889.95
$81.45
$6,614.45
$6,249.70
$21.20
$26.50
$7,078.80
$20,072.10
$71.15
$5,539.36
$60.20
$4.716.60
$26.10
$4,663.20
$15,076.61
$82.80
$82.80
$165.60
$67.32
$39.60
$79.20
$186.12
($16.17)
($46.64)
$544.45
$1,473.61
$1,725.83
$171.90
$356.61
$4,209.59
$141.35
$6,425.05
$105.05
$6,977.85
$55.55
Page 2 of7
Check # Vender Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
27802 THORPE DISTRIBUTIN BEER/MISC 4/12/00 30210-04030 $7,141.30
TOTAL FOR THORPE DISTRIBUTING COMPA $20,846.15
27803 T.W.E. WHOLESALERS WINE ENTHUSIAST SUBS FOR L1QU 4/12/00 0401STMT $24.95
27803 T.W.E. WHOLESALERS WINE ENTHUSIAST SUBS FOR L1QU 4/12/00 0401STMT $24.95
TOTAL FOR T. W.E. WHOLESALERS INC $49.90
27804 BASTYR, CONNIE LAMPS FOR LOBBY/MILEAGE 4/19/00 $12.68
27804 BASTYR, CONNIE LAMPS FOR LOBBY/MILEAGE 4/19/00 $108.57
TOTAL FOR BASTYR, CONNIE $121.25
27805 BRYAN ROCK PRODUC ROCK/RIP RAP 4/19/00 0331STMT $148.07
27805 BRYAN ROCK PRODUC ROCK/RIP RAP 4/19/00 0331STMT $644.39
TOTAL FOR BRYAN ROCK PRODUCTS,INC. $792.46
27806 COORDINATED BUSIN TONER FOR PRINTERS 4/19/00 153627 $361.74
TOTAL FOR COORDINATED BUSINESS SYST $361.74
27807 OFFICE DEPOT OFFICE SUPPLIES 4/19/00 094558570 $165.36
27807 OFFICE DEPOT OFFICE SUPPLIES 4/19/00 094560792 $165.36
27807 OFFICE DEPOT CREDIT FOR DUPL BILLING 4/19/00 094724142 ($165.36)
27807 OFFICE DEPOT OFFICE SUPPLIES 4/19/00 094724238 $5.51
. 27807 OFFICE DEPOT NOTARY STAMP - C. ELKE 4/19/00 094822565 $22.59
TOTAL FOR OFFICE DEPOT $193.46
27808 MINNCOMM PAGING PAGER SVC 4/19/00 52006804000 $8.63
TOTAL FOR MINNCOMM PAGING $8.63
27809 NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/19/00 $7.98
27809 NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/19/00 $382.89
27809 NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/19/00 $16.81
27809 NORTHERN STATES P 4/19/00 $100.48
27809 NORTHERN STATES P 4/19/00 $15.52
27809 NORTHERN STATES P LIFT STATIONS 4/19/00 $214.67
TOTAL FOR NORTHERN STATES POWER $738.35
27810 PROTOCOL COMMUNI SETUP OF E-MAIL SITES FOR DEPT 4/19/00 952204663-0 $100.00
TOTAL FOR PROTOCOL COMMUNICATIONS, /NC $100.00
27811 VIKING LAND TREE CA TREE REMOVAL 4/19/00 1766 $567.43
TOTAL FOR VIKING LAND TREE CARE INC $567.43
. 27812 TIMBERWALL LANDSC SEALER FOR MANHOLES 4/19/00 100864 $49.46
TOTAL FOR T1MBERWALL LANDSCAPING INC $49.46
27813 US WEST PHONE 4/19/00 $294.37
27813 US WEST PHONE 4/19/00 $115.23
TOTAL FOR US WEST $409.60
27814 BELLBOY CORPORA TI LIQUOR 4/19/00 18298900 $388.55
TOTAL FOR BELLBOY CORPORATION $388.55
27815 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY NON RESELL 4/19/00 31369300 $79.88
TOTAL FOR BELLBOY BAR SUPPL Y $79.88
27816 MIDWEST COCA-COLA POP 4/19/00 033100STMT $176.74
27816 MIDWEST COCA-COLA POP 4/19/00 033100STMT $305.24
27816 MIDWEST COCA-COLA POP 4/19/00 033100STMT $310.36
TOTAL FOR MlDWESTCOCA-COLA BOTTLIN $792.34
27817 ELKE, CATHERINE SEC 125 REIMBURSEMENT 4/19/00 $318.00
TOTAL FOR ELKE, CATHERINE $318.00
27818 LEEF BROS MATS FOR TB LIQUOR 4/19/00 221827 $28.04
TOTAL FOR LEEF BROS $28.04
27819 PAUSTIS WINE COMPA WINE 4/19/00 126973 $84.00
Wednesday, 19, 1000 Page 3 of7
Check # Vender Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
27819 PAUSTIS WINE COMPA WINE 4/19/00 126973 $229.00
27819 PAUSTIS WINE COMPA WINE 4/19/00 126977 $1,309.00
TOTAL FOR PAUSTlS WINE COMPANY $1,622.00
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/19/00 825319-00 $85.63
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/19/00 825319-00 $652.80
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/19/00 825320-00 $393.52
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LlQUOR 4/19/00 825320-00 $1,734.65
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINEILlQUOR 4/19/00 825321-00 $2,320.80
27820 QUALITY WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/19/00 825321-00 $298.76
TOTAL FOR QUALITY WINE & SPIRITS CO $5,486.16
27821 WASTE MANAGEMENT GARBAGE SVC - LIQUOR #2 4/19/00 1593-000878 $90.05
27821 WASTE MANAGEMENT APRIL GARBAGE SVC - PW 4/19/00 1593-000878 $110.84
TOTAL FOR WASTE MANAGEMENT $200.89
27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT 4/25/00 100666 $480.00
27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT . 4/25/00 100666 $480.00
27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT 4/25/00 100666 $480.00
27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT 4/25/00 100666 $480.00
27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT 4/25/00 100666 $480.00
. 27822 ABDO, ABDO, AND EIC DEC 1999 AUDIT 4/25/00 100666 $3,600.00
TOTAL FOR ABDO, ABDO, AND EICK $6,000.00
27823 ADAM'S PEST CONTRO QTRL Y PEST CONTROL SVC 4/25/00 0330stmt $60.17
TOTAL FOR ADAM'S PEST CONTROL, INC $60.17
27824 AMERICAN ENGINEERI ENG SVCS - SHOREWOOD PONDS 4/25/00 3585 $3,051.51
TOTAL FOR AMERICAN ENGINEERING $3,051.51
27825 BOB'S PERSONAL COF COFFEE/SUPPLIES - PW 4/25/00 36008 $57.00
27825 BOB'S PERSONAL COF COFFEE/SUPPLIES - CITY OFFICES 4/25/00 36010 $54.00
TOTAL FOR BOB'S PERSONAL COFFEE SVC $111.00
27826 DRISKILL'S SUPER VAL FIRE DEPT MTG 4/25/00 0401STMT $6.38
TOTAL FOR DRISKILL'S SUPER VALl! $6.38
27827 EXCELSIOR-CITY OF 2ND QTR FIRE CONTRACT 2000 4/25/00 $40,984.75
TOTAL FOR EXCELSIOR-CITY OF $40,984.75
27828 HAWKINS WATER TRE CONTAINER CHG 4/25/00 DM 38695 $60.00
TOTAL FOR HAWKINS WATER TREATJ1ENT $60.00
. 27829 HENN CTY TREASURE TIF ADMIN COSTS 4/25/00 $853.45
TOTAL FOR HENNCTYTREASURER $853.45
27830 LK MTKA CONSERV. DI 2ND QTR 2000 LEVY PYMT 4/25/00 $5,261.69
TOTAL FOR LK MTKA CONSERV. DISTRICT $5,261.69
27831 LEAGUE OF MN CITIES APRIL DENTAL - NON-UNION 4/25/00 $317.04
27831 LEAGUE OF MN.CITIES APRIL DENTAL - NON-UNION 4/25/00 $67.00
27831 LEAGUE OF MN CITIES APRIL DENTAL - NON-UNION 4/25/00 $35.99
27831 LEAGUE OF MN CITIES APRIL DENTAL - NON-UNION 4/25/00 $35.99
TOTAL FOR LEAGUE OF MN CITIES $456.02
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $114.22
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $57.20
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $481.07
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $217.12
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $102.72
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $51.36
27832 MCLEOD USA MAR PHONE BILL 4/25/00 4868608 $109.61
TOTAL FOR MCLEOD USA $1,133.30
27833 METRO COUNCIL ENVI MAY 2000 WASTEWATER SVC 4/25/00 701702 $21,624.00
Wednesday, Apri/19, 2000 Page 4
Check # Vemler Name
Description
Check Date Invoice #
27834
Amollnt
27835
27836
27836
27837
27838
27838
.
27839
27839
27839
27839
27839
27840
27841
27841
27841
27841
27841
27841
27841
27841
27842
27842
27842
.
27843
27844
27845
27845
27845
27846
27847
27848
27849
TOTAL FOR METRO COUNCIL ENVIRONMENT
METRO COUNCIL ENVI MARCH SAC REPORT 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR METRO COUNCIL ENVIRONMENT
MINNESOTA DEPT OF WATER SVC CONNECTION FEEc1S 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR MINNESOTA DEPTOF HEALTH
MINNESOTA STATE TR 1ST QTR 2000 BLDG PERMIT SURC 4/25/00
MINNESOTA STATE TR 2000 SPRING BLDG CODE SEMINA 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR MINNESOTA STATE TREASURER
MCES, YOUTH PROGR CITY SHARE OF MTKA COMM ED P 4/25/00 0028
TOTAL FOR MCES, YOUTH PROGRAMS
MUNITECH, INC. MAY 2000 WATER/SEWER MAl NT
MUNITECH, INC. . MAY 2000 WATER/SEWER MAINT
TOTAL FOR MUNITECH,INC.
NAVARRE TRUE VALU PW SUPPLIES/PARTS
NAVARRE TRUE VALU PW SUPPLIES/PARTS
NAVARRE TRUE VALU PW SUPPLIES/PARTS
NAVARRE TRUE VALU PW SUPPLIES/PARTS
NAVARRE TRUE VALU PW SUPPLIES/PARTS
TOTAL FOR NAVARRE TRUE VALUE
NORTHERN TOOL & EQ PARTS/SUPPLIES PW 4/25/00 82223826
TOTAL FOR NORTHERN TOOL & EQI/lP CO
NORTHERN STATES P LIFT STATIONS 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P STREET LIGHTING 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P 4/25/00
NORTHERN STATES P UTILITIES 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR NORTHERN STATES POWER
SUPPLIES FOR LIQUOR STORES
SUPPLIES FOR L1QUORSTORES
SUPPLIES FOR LIQUOR STORES
TOTAL FOR SAM'S CLUB
4/25/00 7432
4/25/00 7432
4/25/00 0331STMT
4/25/00 0331STMT
4/25/00 0331STMT
4/25/00 0331STMT
4/25/00 0331STMT
SAM'S CLUB
SAM'S CLUB
SAM'S CLUB
4/25/00
4/25/00
4/25/00
SO LK MTKA POLICE 0 MAY 2000 BUDGET 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR SO LK MTKA POLICE DEPT
SUN PATRIOT NEWSP ADS - LEGALS 4/25/00 0331STMT
TOTAL FOR SUN PATRIOT NEWSPAPERS INC
TONKA BAY-CITY OF 1ST QTR 2000 WATER/SEWER 4/25/00
TONKA BAY-CITY OF 1ST QTR 2000 WATER/SEWER 4/25/00
TONKA BAY-CITY OF 1ST QTR 2000 WATER/SEWER 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR TONKA BA Y-C1TY OF
TWIN CITY WATER CLI BACTERIA ANALYSIS - MARCH 4/25/00 6277
TOTAL FOR TWIN CITY WATER CLINIC
US POSTAL SERVICE PSTG METER FILL 4/25/00
TOTAL FOR US POSTA.L SERVICE
US WEST PHONE 4/25/00
TOTA.L FOR US WEST
VINIFERA MINNESOTA WINE
TOTAL FOR VINIFERA MINNESOTA
4/25/00 320118
Wedllesday, April 19, 2000
$21,624.00
$8,712.00
$8,712.00
$1,422.00
$1,422.00
$4,050.49
$30.00
$4,080.49
$3,497.50
$3,497.50
$2,130.00
$4,970.00
$7,100.00
$23.90
$21.24
$15.94
$5.50
$28.82
$95.40
$179.95
$179.95
$41.05
$1.689.81
$178.1.1
$2.446.14
$15.39
$13.33
$3.14
$98.54
$4,485.51
$14.42
$14.42
$14.42
$43.26
$43,276.00
$43,276.00
$125.47
$125.47
$103.97
$256.35
$289.29
$649.61
$20.00
$20.00
$1,500.00
$1,500.00
$50.87
$50.87
$703.95
$703.95
Page 5 of7
Check # Vender Name Description Check Date Invoice # Amount
27850 BELLBOY CORPORATI WINE 4/25/00 18590500 $127.70
27850 BELLBOY CORPORATI WINE 4/25/00 18590600 $191.55
27850 BELLBOY CORPORATI LIQUOR CREDIT 4/25/00 18614400 ($9.21 )
TOTAL FOR BELLBOY CORPORATION $3/0.04
27851 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY MISC CREDIT 4/25/00 31603500 ($5.31)
27851 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY NON-RESELL 4/25/00 31651200 $43.94
27851 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY MISC/NON-RESELL 4/25/00 31652800 $56.44
27851 BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY MISC/NON-RESELL 4/25/00 31652800 $57.62
TOTAL FOR BELLBOY BAR SUPPLY $/52.69
27852 GRAPE BEGINNINGS, I WINE 4/25/00 30444 $204.00
TOTAL FOR GRAPE BEGINNINGS, INC $204.00
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE 4/25/00 196361 $881.94
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 196362 $2,589.89
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE 4/25/00 196366 $427.86
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 196367 $1,262.42
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE 4/25/00 196380 $155.13
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 1.96381 $437.74
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 199608 $14.48
. 27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 199608 $453.17
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 199609 $669.15
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 199612 $326.09
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE 4/25/00 199613 $806.26
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR 4/25/00 199623 $111.37
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C WINE 4/25/00 1. 99624 $115.81
27853 GRIGGS, COOPER & C LIQUOR CREDIT 4/25/00 533686 ($10.83)
TOTAL FOR GRIGGS, COOPER & COMPANY $8,240.48
27854 HONEYWELL PROTECT SEMI-ANNUAL CHG - 5/1 - 10/31/00 4/25/00 555PS617 $214.50
TOTAL FOR HONEYWELL PROTECTION SERV $214.50
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097123 $636.43
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097123 $1,675.61
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097124 $2,170.04
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097124 $2,171.08
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097125 $895.94
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1097125 $1,470.29
. 27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099746 $346.50
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099746 $776.82
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099747 $319.10
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099747 $1,189.77
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099748 $84.65
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 1099748 $716.63
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE 4/25/00 11. 00334 $49.60
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE CREDIT 4/25/00 117866 ($6.88)
27855 JOHNSON BROS L1QU WINE CREDIT 4/25/00 117867 ($4.13)
TOTA.L FOR JOHNSON BROS LIQUOR CO. $/2,491.45
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8143 $228.56
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8144 $228.56
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8145 $285.70
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8164 $228.56
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8165 $257.13
27856 LAKE REGION VENDIN CIGS 4/25/00 8166 $257.13
TOTAL FOR LAKE REGION VENDING $/,485.64
27857 LAKE SHORE WEEKLY ADS FOR LIQUOR STORES 4/25/00 00059650 $124.80
27857 LAKE SHORE WEEKLY ADS FOR LIQUOR STORES 4/25/00 00059650 $124.80
Wednesday, April/9, 2000 Page 6 of
Check # Vellder Name Descriptioll Check Date Illvoice # A III Ollllt
27857 LAKESHORE WEEKLY ADS FOR LIQUOR STORES 4/25/00 00059650 $124.80
27857 LAKE SHORE WEEKLY WINE AD 4/25/00 59536 $124.80
27857 LAKE SHORE WEEKLY WINE AD 4/25/00 59536 $124.80
27857 LAKESHORE WEEKLY WINE AD 4/25/00 59536 $124.80
TOTAL FOR LAKESHORE WEEKLY NEWS $748.80
27858 MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT 4/25/00 7281/7311 $85.05
27858 MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT 4/25/00 7281/7311 $85.05
27858 MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT 4/25/00 7282/7312/73 $62.10
27858 MARLIN'S TRUCKING FREIGHT 4/25/00 7282/7312/73 $62.10
TOTAL FOR MARLIN'S TRUCKING $294.30
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE CREDIT 4/25/00 3212914 ($3.54)
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE CREDIT 4/25/00 3212915 ($6.41)
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE CREDITS 4/25/00 3212916-291 ($26.03)
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRt WINE CREDITS 4/25/00 3212920-292 ($27.97)
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 593182 $46.50
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 593182 $2,583.00
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE 4/25/00 593183 $3,156.05
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 593184 $323.80
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 593184 $946.50
. 27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI LIQUOR 4/25/00 595309 $101.50
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 595310 $75.00
27859 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRI WINE/LIQUOR 4/25/00 595310 $254.72
TOTAL FOR PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRITS $7,423.12
27860 WINE COMPANY (THE) WINE 4/25/00 37907 $87.00
27860 WINE COMPANY (THE) WINE 4/25/00 37910 $529:7r--~-
27860 WINE COMPANY (THE) WINE 4/25/00 37911 $432.37
TOTAL FOR WINE COMPANY (THE) $1,049.07
TOTAL CHECKS $272,911.22
.
Page 7 of 7
Wednesday, April 19, 2000
Payroll Register
Check # Last Name First Name MI Check Amt Check Date
215424 BASTYR CONNIE D 570.05 4/1 1100
215425 BROWN LA WRENCE A 1,707.63 4/11100
215426 BUHL SUSAN E 85.84 4/11/00
215427 CARIGNAN DEANN M 71.57 4/11100
215428 DAVIS CHARLES S 936.98 4/11100
215429 DUFFY DA VID C 158.56 4/11100
215430 EHRKE DANIEL D 162.37 4/11/00
215431 EISCHENS JAMES E 450.22 4/11100
215432 ELKE CATHERINE M 683.95 4/11100
215433 FASCHING PATRICIA L 736.58 4/11100
215434 GROUT TWILA R 815.19 4/1 1100
215435 GUSTAFSON DA VID W 161.04 41 II 100
215436 HELLING PAMELA J 664.26 4/11100
. 215437 JOHNSON DENNIS D 971.54 4/11100
215438 KALLEST AD STEPHEN N 854.38 4/11/00
215439 KARELS PAUL C 159.27 4/11100
215440 LA TTERt'\fER SUSAN M 308.08 4/11/00
215441 LEDWITH JAMES R 85.88 4/11100
215442 LUGOWSKI JOSEPH P 937.45 4/11/00
215443 MALUCHNIK KRIS A 241.40 4/11/00
215444 MARRON RUSSELL R 40.10 4/11100
215445 MASON BRADLEY J 949.03 4/11100
215446 MITL YNG SARA J 237.63 4/11100
215447 NICCUM LAWRENCE A 1,216.24 4/11/00
215448 NIELSEN BRADLEY J 959.22 4/11100
215449 PANCHYSHY JEAN M 1,089.38 4/11/00
. 215450 PAZANDAK JOSEPH E 1,269.25 4/1 1100
215451 PELCL VINCENT H 28.63 4/11100
215452 POUNDER CHRISTOPHER J 987.91 4/11100
215453 RANDALL DANIEL J 998.29 4/11100
215454 ROLEK ALAN J 809.76 4/11100
215455 SCHMID CHRISTOPHER E 496.61 4/11/00
215456 SCHNEEWIN JACQUELYN K 871.29 4/11/00
215457 STALBERGE PATRICIA A 152.31 4/11/00
215458 SW ANDBY DONALD R 995.84 4/1 1100
Total of Checks $21,863.73
Thursday, April 13, 2000
Page 1 of 1