Loading...
040198 CC BR AgP BOARD OF REVIEW CITY OF SHOREWOOD WEDNESDAY, APRIL 1, 1998 5755 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD COUNCIL CHAMBERS 7:00 P.M. AGENDA 1 . CONVENE BOARD OF REVIEW MEETING A. Roll Call Mayor Dahlberg _ Stover McCarty. _ O'Neill_ Garfunkel B. Review Agenda 2. PRESENTATION BY CITY ASSESSOR (Att.-#2 Assessor's Report) 3. TESTIMONY BY RESIDENTS 4. COUNCIL DIRECTION TO ASSESSOR 5. ESTABLISH DATE FOR BOARD TO RECONVENE 6. ADJOURN Clerk's Notice to Post and Publish - He 1163 ASSESSMENT NOTICE , NonCE IS HEREBY GIVEN, That the Board of Review of tb~ City of Shorewood In Hpnnppin County, Minn., City Hall Council Chambers - ) will meet at the office of the C i t Y at 7 : 00 o' clock -!.....M., on aerk, in said Wednesday , the 1st 'day of April , 19~, for the purpose of reviewing and correcting the assessment of said C i t Y for the year 19 98 All persons considering themselves aggrieved by said assessment or who wish to complain that the property of another is assessed too low, are hereby notified to appear at said meeting and show cause for having such assessment corrected. No complaint that another person is assessed too low will be acted upon until the person so assessed, or his agent, shall have been notified of such complaint. Dated this 18 tfay of February J 19 ~ l'/~ ' j , ,i/~,{//\Q4 .' . .... . Cl~k of the City of Shorewood co ,Ill 10") I Q? 1=.- I 1((.:..:0 I '.::: LL1 Illi~ LL . LC~]:~~..~I pagei _j?-.h9(~~_ nOAIW OF nlwmw MEETING SIGN-IN SHEET Please Print Please Print -Gp~. 11)1) <\ NAME STREET & ZIP CODE PHONE PID# APPT. 1 ~/'/ tJJ~Ka d-71.?()SMrJA~-!;.,II'~ f57-5{J). 2 J~,tLL.l k C:XJs!Jchd-idd- 'I'lY-'13 iff 3 <f l.AIA/~_---r::~( ~7Jr ~j'S,~~h QJ. lJ"7LJ-oJ r-, 5'):., JJ7-23'-1I-00Y I 4 rr"td \\'tOd..\J\- ~\\~sc1w,t'\'A I~. 414-31Cf1 "3S"-\\'1-J.1or#-()()O'- 5 /v1AR( S7f\t7t1X~ ;}-UY7S- n/!';/!sroA} ((0) Y7[)"/l{d-~ :3 (- / I q - J0~ II (}o?~ 6 /If:!r .I3;n~)}~~~7 27ZZS ~7' /1:hwwKL 474-Z48;~J-IJ7-Z3- 4/~~~ 7 Jea? r;,~' 5-Z70 HOI.uQ.""As f'f. 1h'l-71J1~ l\1"'~~ 8 ~~ 1+-1\ (nfJ 9J JYY') ,<)mrLuYn'"l/~h(~ .Ltf..f3~1 k3?,-Ul-;?3-LiLl--&()c 9 KF../A././I /... - J~ 2b1~O~A-/Jt~"IiLJh L/7cj-?Jlt II .3S-111-2?-IJ-&t7/ k- 10 1(fiV/ 7:>, Ii! l,_ AI. 4 A 2to~T ~e"?5an Qtf) 47{)I.!JO~? 11 d I'JI,"".... i\~ ~ !~ 0, I r a"JJ~;&-'" L.c. I) (//t.(- ,(.I.l.' :Ss -, n - 2..s-Y..z "00.1.. " _ I 12 '\~11hI ~~Bt ~~~) ~ M.. 47-0~~;~\ 13 /;)' /L/i/ 1- ,{J ~q (' ~ -. ~...~0'-," ff7L/:J75~/ 14 lAA~~~ ~/J// loSO JI~~.A O.J' t{7q.-sY1i3?t:'-I(?-~3-'4<f ~) ~, , 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 . 24 25 ~/ .' TO: Shorewood Mayor and City Council Members Jim Hurm, Shorewood City Administrator FROM: Rolf Erickson, City Assessor, 473-1844 DATE: March 24, 1998 RE: Local Board of Review for January 2, 1998 Assessment The sales used for the January 2, 1998 Assessment (taxes payable in 1999) occurred between October 1, 1996 and September 30, 1997. Values for these properties that were established for the previous assessment (1-2-97) were compared with the purchase prices to determine what changes were needed to more accurately reflect market value. Properties indicated on the enclosed map in the yellow area were physically inspected for the January 2, 1998 assessment. All properties in the city are recalculated every year. AGGREGATE PROPERTY TYPE GROWTH (Total market value growth of each property type) Lakeshore 10.8% Off Lake Residential 1.3% Town houses 1.5% CommerciallIndustrial 5.7% Apartment 12% Individual property increases varied from 0% to over 20% in extreme cases. The Local Board of Review can address only questions of "Estimated Market Value" and "Classification" (see definitions below) for the January 2, 1998 Assessment (taxes payable in 1999). The Board can make reductions in value not exceed one percent of the current total market value of the City. There is no limit to the change allowed of individual properties. Market Value: The most probable price in terms of money which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently, knowledgeably and assuming the price in not affected by undue stimulus. Classification: The use of a property as defined by state law. The most common classifications apartment, double bungalow, triplex, commercial, farm, residential homestead and residential non-homestead. We have enclosed a book of the sales considered for the current assessment as a reference for you to use at the Board of Review. PLEASE BRING THIS BOOK TO THE BOARD OF REVIEW! A copy of the local board review section from the Minnesota Property Tax Administrators Manual is included for your information. If you have any questions, please call me. ...--- ,. to. vll>H4l ,.". -t".f H :ii ~ 3 ~ tl ,')I \\'i "~! MAP OF SHOREWOOD HENNEPIN COUNTY POP. j-J 1.1.. ';;'" OIOUND 1',' ~'!" .. . .. -..---- . .: ~. .. 0" .. .... ." .:':'.:"0:.: ~"'" 00 .. ~.. .:.. . .'~ ._;:~. ..:.;~.. ~. DATE: 09/95 SECI10N:4120 PAGE: 1 '-..... LOCAL BOARD OF REVIEW - DUTIES The town board of each town, the council or other governing body of each city, is the board of review except in cities whose charters provide for a board of equalization. The county assessor shall fix a day and time when the board or the board of equalization shall meet in the assessment districts of the county. On or before February 15 of each year the assessor shall give written notice of the time to the city or town clerk. Notwithstanding the provisions of any charter to the contrary, the meetings must be held between April 1 and May 31 each year. The clerk shall give published and posted notice of the meeting at least ten days before the date of the meeting. The board shall meet at the office of the clerk to review the assessment and classification of property in the town or city. No changes in valuation or classification which are intended to correct errors in judgment by the county assessor may be made by the county assessor after the board of review or the county board of equalization has adjourned; however, corrections of errors that are merely clerical in nature or changes that extend homestead treatment to property are permitted after adjournment until the tax extension date for that assessment year. The changes must be fully documented and maintained in the assessor's office and must be available for review by any person. A copy of the changes made during this period must be sent to the county board no later than December 31 of the assessment year. "--~ The board shall determine whether the taxable property in the town or city has been properly placed on the list and properly valued by the assessor. If real ,or personal property has been omitted, the board shall place it on the list with its market value, and correct the assessment so that each tract or lot of real property, and each article, parcel, or class of personal property, is entered on the assessment list at its market value. No assessment of the property, of any person may be raised unless the person has been duly notified of the intent of the board to do so. On application of any person feeling aggrieved, the board shall review the assessment or classification, or both, and correct it as appears just. A local board of review may reduce assessments upon petition of the taxpayer but the total reductions must not reduce the aggregate assessment made by the county assessor by more than one percent. If the total reductions would lower the aggregate assessments , made by the county assessor by more than one percent, none of the adjustments may be made. The assessor shall correct any clerical errors or double assessments discovered by the board of review without regard to the one percent limitation. ... -.l.' \,--- DATE: 09/95 SECTION:4120 PAGE: 2 A majority of the members may act at the meeting, and adjourn from day to day until they finish hearing the cases presented. The asse~sor shall attend, with the assessment books and papers, and take part in the proceedings, but must not vote. The county assessor shall attend the meetings. The board shall list separately, on a fonn appended to the assessment book, aU omitted property added to the list by the board and aU items of property increased or decreased, with the market value of each item of property, added or changed by the board, placed opposite the item. The county assessor shall enter aU changes made by the board in the assessment book. If a person fails to appear in person, by counsel, or by written communication before the board after being duly notified of the board's intent to raise the assessment of the property, or if a person feeling aggrieved by an assessment or classification fails to apply for a review of the assessment or classification, the person may not appear before the county board of equalization for a review of the assessment or classification. This paragraph does not apply if an assessment was made after the board meeting, as provided in Section 273.01, or lfthe person can establish not having received notice of market value at least five days before the local board of review meeting. "-....-. The board of review or the board of equalization must complete its work and adjourn within 20 days from the time of convening stated in the notice of the clerk, unless a longer period is approved by the Commissioner of Revenue. No action taken after that date is valid. All complaints about an assessment or classification, made after the meeting of the board must be heard and detennined by the county board of equalization. A nonresident may, at any time, before the meeting of the board of review file written objections to an assessment or classification with the county assessor. The objections must be presented to the board of review at its meeting by the county assessor for its consideration. (M.S. 274.01) '--/ DATE: 7/86 SECTION: 4121 PAGE: 1 '--' SPECIAL BOARD OF REVIEW The council or other governing body of any city, including cities whose charters provide for a board of equalization, may appoint a special board of review to which it may delegate all of the powers and duties of the board of review or board of equali- zation. The special board of review shall serve at the direction and discretion of the appointing body, subject to the restrictions imposed by law on the appointing body. The appointing body shall determine the number of members to be appointed thereto, the compensation and expenses to be paid, and the term of office of each member. At least one member of the special board of review shall be an appraiser, realtor or other person familiar with property valuations in the assessment district. (M.S. 274.01) ./ DATE: 8/88 SECTION: 4122 PAGE: 1 '-- LIMITATIONS A local board of review may reduce assessments upon petition of the taxpayer but the total adjustments must not reduce the aggregate assessment made by the county assessor by more than one pel"cent. If the total adjustments would lower the by more than one percent, none aggregate assessments made by the county assessor of the adjustments may be mad~. The assessor shall correct any clerical errors or . double assessments discovered by the board of review without affecting the one percent referred to above. (M.S. 274.01) '" Summarv of a Studv Conducted bv the Office of Minnesota State Auditor and Three Studies Made bv the Minnesota Department of Revenue "Securing Minnesota's Financial Future: Property Tax Reform in the 1990s" Minnesota Office of the State Auditor Research and Information Division August 1994 Disparities in Property Taxes · Homeowners pay dramatically different property taxes depending on where in Minnesota they live. . Homeowners with approximately the same incomes had markedly different property tax liabilities. · Geographic location is a major determinant of tax burden. In a few areas, homeowners paid less in average property taxes than for cable television. · Property taxes in Minnesota are regressive. . Property taxes differ for homes of similar value. . Counties with similar needs for public services had very different average taxes. Disparities in the Distribution of Minnesota's Property Tax Base · Minnesota's effective property tax rate for a typical commercial firm ranked second in the nation and a typical industrial firm ranked sixth but a high tech factory with a large proportion of personal property ranked 32nd. · Property classification is an inefficient method of tax relief. . Market values of homes are unreliable indicators of homeowners' ability to pay property taxes. Distribution of State Aid · The average metro property taxed are nearly twice the second highest average property tax. · Disparities are found withing economic regions. · The ability of homeowners to pay property taxes is more dependent on those individuals' incomes than on their property values. . The classification system provides a property tax break to all homeowners regardless of their incomes. · Lower income homeowners pay a higher percentage of their incomes on property taxes than higher income homeowners. The regressivity of the property tax illustrates the inequities created by the system particularly for low income homeowners living in the metro area. "Property Tax Regressivity In Minnesota" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division January 1993 \ · This report documents a regressive relationship between income and market value that is only moderately reduced by existing tax relief programs. · The classification system treats all market value the same regardless of ability-to-pay. · While the expectation of the Property Tax Refund (PTR) program would be to reduce the overall regressivity of the property tax system, analysis shows that the impact is very slight. · If the goal is to alleviate the regressivity of the property tax, then greater emphasis should be placed on the property tax refind program which directly links property tax relief to tax burden measured relative to household income. . A state paid property tax refund can then be provided to those households which have high taxes relative to their income and less relief or no refund to higher income households . .,. "1993 Property Tax Relief For Minnesotans, Analysis of Trends 1975-1993" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division . The average net tax of homeowners is $1,412 and the average net tax of renters is $667 yet the limit on the property tax refund for homeowners is $400 (now $470) while renters can receive a property tax refund of up to $1,000 (now $1090). . After the property tax refund, the percentage of income spent on property taxes by homeowners is 5.4% while the renter's percentage is 2.6%. "1997 Minnesota Tax Incidence Study" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division Table 1. Shows that at all levels except for the first decile, residential property taxes take a greater percentage of a household's income than business property takes from a business' income. The same relationship exists for the income tax as well. Effective tax rates increased for the individual income tax and homeowner property taxes; effective tax rates fell for business property taxes and especially for rental housing. Between 1994 and 1996, homestead property values rose more than twice as rapidly as business property values, which failed to keep up with inflation. (page viii) Table 2.2. Shows the amounts and percentage distribution of state and local tax collections by type of tax and taxpayer category in millions of dollars. In 1994, the taxes paid on a $120,000 home were 2.8 times those on a $60,000 home; the taxes on a $360,000 home were over 10.8 times those on a $60,000 home because of the class rate structure. Table 6.3. This table shows that the the average percent of income spent on property taxes by households is 2.1 percent. Minnesota Senior Federation Survey of Its Membership 1996 · While the average Minnesotan pays 2.1 percent of their income on property taxes (see Table 6.3 above), the respondents to the Federation survey paid an average of 4 percent of their income. · A total of 25 percent paid over 6 percent of their income on property taxes. This is almost three. times what the average Minnesotan paid. · A total of 1.4 percent of the respondents paid over 20 percent of their income on property taxes. Some respondents were paying from 30 to 50 percent of their income on property taxes. · This is while the wealthiest Minnesotan pays only 8.5 percent of their income on income taxes. . All taxes: Sales, income, and property taxes are paid from one's income. Homesteaded property produces no income with which to pay property taxes. ,., Property Tax Resolution: Limiting the Property Tax to a Percentage of Income WHEREAS, The present property tax system is a regressive tax, adversely affecting those homeowners who have lived a long time in their homes; and WHEREAS, The amount of residential property taxes assessed depends upon the market value of one's home; and WHEREAS, Studies made on the subject have shown that the value of a person's home has no relationship to the ability of the homeowner to pay the assessed property tax; and WHEREAS, Unlike the income tax system which limits the percentage of a taxpayer's income that can be collected, and unlike the sales tax which limits the amount of tax that can be collected from a purchase as a percentage of its cost, the present property tax system does not limit the amount of property tax that can be collected from a renter or homeowner; and WHEREAS, It has been documented that many Minnesotans are paying a percentage of their income on property taxes far beyond the 1.8 percent which the average Minnesotan pays; some homeowners are paying up to 40 percent of their income on property taxes; and WHEREAS, This method of unlimited taxation is driving many Minnesotans from their homes, especially the widowed and the elderly; and WHEREAS, The finances of the State of Minnesota are in such good order that the past excuse that the injustices perpetuated by the present property tax system could not be corrected because of a lack of funds is no longer valid; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City of Shorewood to support the enactment into law by the 1998 Minnesota Legislature of a limit to the amount of a person's income that can be assessed for property taxes, and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that funding for the limitation be achieved through an expanded state tax credit based on income, and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this protection be extended to all citizens of the State of Minnesota regardless of age or place of residence. Dated: Mayor City of Shorewood .. Minnesota Senior Federation Tax Committee Marlowe Hamerston, Chairman. 1885 University Ave. W.. Suite 190. St. Paul, MN 55104.612-645-0261 Home: 771 Larson Lane. Shoreview, MN 55126.612-484-4615. e-mail: hamerlH2@tc.umn.edu Dear Mayor and City Council Members: Members of the Minnesota Senior Federation residing in your community, as well as the 30,000 members throughout our state, need your help to gain passage of legislation to instill fairness in Minnesota's property tax system.You may have heard citizens from your community express displeasure with the property tax system. And I am sure you told them that your city government uses property taxes for the legitimate operations of your city but that city government has little to say about the structure of Minnesota's property tax. The state legislature continues to pass on to city government, mandates to be implemented but no funding to carry them out. When city governments levy property taxes for these programs, it is the city that gets the blame for the increased taxes while the state legislature takes credit for not raising taxes. It is the ever-increasing property tax rate that is literally driving older Minnesotans from their homes. The loss of this segment of our society from any community has a detrimental effect on the mix of its population. Forcing seniors from the familiar surroundings of their community cannot be justified by any means. The seniors of your community are the pillars upon which your churches and service organizations are built. The cost of housing seniors in nursing homes or subsidizing their rents far exceeds the cost of implementing a property tax circuit breaker system that will allow many seniors to remain in their homes. Our proposal is not restricted to senior citizens; our proposal would apply to all Minnesota taxpayers who are faced with the same problem - renters and homeowners, young and old. It would also help protect younger families who may face temporary unemployment allowing them to stay on their feet and in their home. This is easily accomplished by placing a reasonable limit to the amount of a household's income which can be collected in property taxes. Our proposal would not effect state funding to cities. The proposal is to expand the present circuit breaker program by placing a percentage limit on the amount that can be collected from a taxpayer. The state would be responsible for the amount of tax refund and the city's funding from the state would not change. I have. enclosed some literature explaining the need for limiting the property tax. · The reverse side of this letter lists ten of the many reasons for reforming the present property tax system. This legislation will not cure all the problems of the property tax. system but will be a giant step toward making it fair. · The next page is a summary of four studies conducted by the Minnesota Department of Revenue and one study made by the office of State Auditor and a study by the Minnesota Senior Federation. These studies support the need for making the change put forth in the accompanying resolution. -The final sheet is a resolution, which I hope you and your council will pass. It supports the enactment of legislation to establish a limit as the percentage of a person's income can be collected in property taxes. City government is government at the grass roots level. Too often the legislature listens to the paid lobbyists whose agenda is not the same as your community's citizens. The taxpayers of your city need their city government to speak up for them through the passage of this resolution. The passage of this resolution by you and other city governments throughout the state of Minnesota should get the attention of our legislature. This resolution is the vehicle for you to make a statement to the 1998 legislature on behalf of the citizens of your community. They must hear the message: Do something about the unlimited nature of the property tax! If you have any questions or would like to discuss the resolution further, feel free to call or write to me at the address given above. I would appreciate your letting me know of the disposition of the resolution by your city government so that your actions can be properly recognized at the legislature and by the media. Sincerely, .---- / ~J~j{z~d: . The Top Ten Reasons for Property Tax Reform 10. The Property Tax is the only unlimited form of taxation in existence. There is no limit as to the percentage of a person's income that can be assessed in property taxes. The sales tax is limited to 6.5% of the amount of a sale and the top income tax rate is limited to 8.5% of a person's income. The present property tax system has been documented to be taking from 10% to even 50% of many Minnesotan's income. 9. There is no relationship between the market value of a taxpayer's property and their ability to pay the taxes levied. Numerous studies have been made by the State Auditor and Department of Revenue and no connection between the market value of a property and the homeowner's ability to pay the associated taxes has been shown. Using the market value of a home to determine the property tax is proven in-valid. 8. The property tax is universally recognized as a regressive tax which affects our most vulnerable citizens to the greatest degree. It is the elderly and the widowed, who have lived in their homes many years and have seen their market values grow far beyond their incomes, who are being driven from their homes by this tax. 7. Most taxes tax your assets. The present property tax system also taxes your debt. If you purchased a $75,000 home today and put down $5,000, tomorrow, the present property tax system would begin taxing not only your equity, but would also require you to pay property taxes on your $70,000 debt. 6. A community with a "rich" property tax base does not mean an individual taxpayer in that community is rich. The practice of "blanket" reassessment is outrageously unfair. It gives no consideration to the individual properties nor to the harm caused to the neighborhood by raising taxes without consideration as to the condition of any individual property. 5. Allowing property taxes to force seniors from their homes creates a great a loss to churches, schools, and the community as a whole. At a time when the president is caIling for more volunteerism, we should not be forcing the greatest reservoir of volunteers that society has, our retired population, to leave their communities. 4. The property tax taxes on the basis of future earnings. Earnings you may collect ~upon the sale of the property if such a sale ever takes place. You are being taxed on the. basis of a sale that has not taken place to a buyer who does not exist. There is no basis for the use of a taxation system based upon projected earnings. You can not pay present day taxes with future earnings. You can not pay the taxes due now, with future earnings. 3 . The present property tax system is anti-family and a slum producing machine. Our property tax system penalizes homeowners who try to maintain and improve their property. The reward for providing a clean, safe environment for their family is higher taxes. A landlord has little incentive to keep rental properties in an acceptable condition when he knows his improvements will result in higher property taxes. 2 . The property tax is a relic of the 1800's and it is long over-due to be reformed, not just tinkered with, but reformed to conform to the realities of the 21st century. While property ownership created and was a measure of wealth in the rural society of the 18oos, the urban residential property of today creates no wealth with which to pay property taxes. 1. The property tax refund system must be modified to protect Minnesotans from being driven from their homes by our present archaic and unfair system. Minnesota has become a state where citizens do not own property, but rent it from the state with property taxes. Finally, the constitutionality of the property tax is questionable. If it is not unconstitutional, it is surely unconscionable. Which is worse? There must be a limitation to the amount of one's income which can be levied on a taxpayer's property. The passage of Senate File 1835 or House File 1258/Senate File 1147 will provide the protection needed and deserved by the citizens of the State of Minnesota. Join in the efforts to make the passage of this legislation happen during the 1998 legislative session. Hennepin County An Equal Opportunity Employer June 24, 1997 William Wicka 27930 Smithtown Road Shorewood, MN 55331 Dear Mr. Wicka: In response to your request for a hearing, the 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization has determined that the 1997 market value for the property listed should be as indicated below. The market value will be entered into the assessment records and used to compute the property tax payable in 1998. Propertv Identification Number 31-117-23-34-0001 Market Value After Local Board of Review $716,000 Market Value After County Board of Eaualization $695,000 The 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization adjourned Sine Die on June 20, 1997. A new Board of Equalization will be appointed during 1998 and will be authorized to hear appeals of 1998 Market Value or Classification for the June, 1998 Hennepin County Board of Equalization. If you wish to appeal the decision of the 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization regarding the 1997 Estimated Market Value or Classification of your property, you may file a Petition with Minnesota Tax Court. Filing instructions, including offices where Petitions must be filed, deadline for filing and information regarding other pertinent filing requirements, may be obtained from Minnesota Tax Court at 296-2806. since~ut >I-{)~ Patrick H. O'Connor, Manager Taxpayer Services Division (Recorder, Hennepin County Board of Equalization) PHO:jmb (w:benotif97) Hennepin County General Services Taxpayer Services Division A-600 Hennepin County Government Center Minneapolis, Minnesota 55487 -0060 Recycled Paper - .. Jabs-Property Tax Protest 20915 Radisson Road PID # 35-117-23-11-0081 Supporting Exhibit .Imm A) Percentage Increases Are Excessive Percentage Increase 1995-1998 1997-1998 1 2 Compared to MLS Statistics for Minnetonka Area Compared to Neighbor's Assessments Neighbor to East Neighbor to West 16.12% 23.08% 29.38% 14.36% 12.39% 14.23% Jabs Increase 48.0496 16.2396 3 B) Christmas Lake Sales Do Not Support Increases Exhibit 1 Comparison with MLS Statistics for Minnetonka Area Year End 1994 1996 1997 Median Sold Price $1 65,000 $167,000 $188,700 Percent Increase 94/97: ($165,000 vs. $18'8,700) 14.36% Percent Increase 96/97: ($167,000 vs. $188,700) 12.99% Source: MLS - Lake Minnetonka District 381, which includes Deephaven, Excelsoir, Greenwood, Long Lake, Minnetonka Beak, Minnetrista, Mound, Orono, Shorewood, Spring Park, St. Bonifacus, Tonka Bay and Wayzata. Exhibit 2 'Comparison With Neighboring Properties ~ 35-117-23-11-0081 1995 Assessor's Value 1996 Assessor's Value 1997 Assessor's Value 1998 Assessor's Value Percent Increase 95/98: ($179,000 vs. $265,000) Percent Increase 97/98: ($228,000 vs. $265,000) Huno-NeiQhbor to East 35-117-23-11-0011 1995 Assessor's Value 1996 Assessor's Value 1997 Assessor's Value 1998 Assessor's Value Percent Inc(ease 95/98: ($286,000 vs. $352,000) Percent Increase 97/98: ($313,000 vs. $352,000) Peterson-Neighbor to West 35-117-23-11-0004 1995 Assessor's Value 1996 Assessor's Value 1997 Assessor's Value 1998 Assessor's Value , Percent Increase 95/98: ($211,000 vs. $273,000) Percent Increase 97/98: ($239,000 vs. $273,000) $179,000 $216,000 $228,000 $265,000 48.04% 16.23% $286,000 $297,000 $313,200 $352,000 23.08% 12.39% $211,000 $226,000 $239,000 . $273,000 29.38% 14.23% Exhibit 3 Christmas Lake Sales Per Assessor Location 5630 Christmas Lake Point 5640 Covington Road 5790 Christmas Lake Point 21135 Christmas Lane Sale Price $685,000 $732,500 $562,000 $635,000 Comments Not comparable Not comparable Not comparable Not comparable, -~-''',J :. ! ~';''-1i , Sale lot lakeshore , Type of Age or "",..to;,," ~ S1~e (sf) ~ JigWm Structure Comments 5790 Christmas lake Road $278,000 62,000 67 Sand 1956 10096 newly remodeled. Road bIt lake 5755 Merry lane $297,000 43,000+ 150 Hard sand 1958 Newer garage. abs '0915 Radisson Road 23,000s f 50 Muck 1922 House sits on road at dangerous turn Comparison of Lots: The two comparable sales have much larger lots.with more lake frontage and sandy lakeshore. Comparison of Homes: The structures are much newer. ,. .../ / .. / / . .-;:,;;---..-.--....:..-...... -~ 'vi 1. CJ \..r: .{.. : ~. ~.. fl~ n:-.C~_l=O-~:~ at"T(\ ,,~{ r nO~\C& I I (J- // / \J; - ... ~ \"0- a\.s] ~ ,.("\ ~ '~ _.--~----- :!l:::r --- . -------- .---'-- ...... ... c:J r- .:r-- ~ ~ .;::z- ~ ....... ~ ~ ( \4; " - ~ \y \Y ~ - l.... 'l.; ,1- ~~ . r>..) B~ ~..) ~ ~ (j.......... "-J '\J"'~ ::: : .-.",. .:~ - . or> ~< '-t-. , ( i) ':J'. \i'"\ ....... it C~ -~'< ....:.::: .{2 .,.... '.- ....:,. '-.", --'-. .5Ot/~ /JJ c.r}f':!} q /I 8/05-3' ('- . x /s e /I I 9 9 t; J C'~k .Ed tuOvrJ3/ 91 7 /c;~~ (J Ct. r t-Oiv-) !-!o i /]1 d i Cj y '-f. I '9&'5 /3 2- i"lck5cl! / 9 ?is /6- " ' l~/ 1-/.-50/1 19 fSfs/lo /98c2 IS ~ i '7 []\5-)'5- /~Ir'>(?/lf(j'lt) /973/7 /JJc!~ec!.5f-y /9- 7S/'7 /l <- l,/r:'-n i1 (5 ;3o.lr-{r /97 i/3 n 'J, eta. it. -f{:. rei I 9 &.S- /fi!(cf! 199/J /-I-~.) ;j r / 7 ~ ) 'Ic't//;~ 19 ~ 7 O~tL 0/ "70 )/ciJ..;.arcf5;P1- RJr 6/ ')0 ifeu.ad.5 ~f. I?cI ~ It II \.} ;( 90 f... 1..S-3cZl 1'" "J- ..33 c..? 6330 -S33C;- 0~ '70 kjJOO 0":J;.30 } I 0-;270 ;, l ' I ' '.3--~ 70 \S;J., I () /-:h U-4 refs If II II '1 / ) I I " / " '/ /'1, ffd- \6 - ~ \.5C? I ' "/ 'I r.:.... /.....r":l J.J. '1 . 0..J~ 0 / C)l '7' S.,< 35" lS 0< &5- l.s- .;{ Ch./C;- ,,-5' .3 / .s~- 030 ..f Jt " 60()./ctY t:?~ 600 68'10CZ) .;../ rY~t~ ,-,8'~c~ ,3 0~ Ct:'"0 ;;(. 0~ Q:izJ :/ ~ v~/9qz 0--;( crdZ' V I / 7 cJ(:;-Z; :./ .s- .d,~ c-e.JZ 3;Z Y: OiSv ,/ ~r-.5~cco .Fs~ l( ~6'./Oz;7 , .. .. Jeffrey A. Fox 5270 Howard's Point Road Excelsior, MN 55331 (612)474-7118 (612)443-2811 FAX 3 PAGES TO THE ATTENTION OF: ROLF ERICKSON DECEMBER 2, 1997 Upon reviewing 11 properties of the 15 total properties in my area I have found a considerable difference in the land value. The 4 remaining properties could not be reviewed due to insufficient information from available property records. There is not any correlation between lake-shore front footage and total square footage of lot, height of land above lake level, number and size of mature trees (foliage coverage), concrete or brick pavers for driveway, lake-shore rip rap or shrubs. See the following examples: · 5330 Howard's Point Rd. has 235' of lake frontage. vs. 5270 Howard's Point Rd. has 160' of lake frontage, 32% less. · 5330 has 64,037 sq. ft. (1.5 acres) of land. vs. 5270 has 28,275 sq. ft.(.667 acres) of land, 56% less total footage. I believe these factors above, along with the latest sale on each existing lot would set the starting point for new calculations. Our property has substantially less lake-shore frontage, less than half the square footage, and has been under the same ownership while 5330 has changed owners 3 times. Yet, our property value has increased at a faster rate. It's very frustrating as we are wanting to add to our existing house, but find it is not possible based on the square footage we have. However, 5330 is adding with no problems when the hard surface footprint that currently exists was already greater to begin with. I believe the numbers on my site plan are accurate to your 1996 county data. If so, the only fair and appropriate way to resolve this is by re-evaluation of these properties that are in question. Either 5330 and some other's should be adjusted up in value, or 5270,5250 &. 5230 should be adjusted down in value, or they all should be adjusted up or down accordingly. I am awaiting your response regarding this information, and I thank-you for your consideration to this issue. Sincerely, Jeffrey A. Fox ltIo2:J SCAlE: 2 INCHES. 600FT 1 INCH . 300FT 112 INCH . 150FT 114 INCH . 75FT rEX~lEt~I(o)Ifl-~3 ~~tD~IEW(o)(o)\P)-~~ ~ "". -4 "" ... . "" .. @ GOVT LOT 6 @ GOVT LOT 6 70 (26) '[ i -Me i __' l __--T'" ,- _J...------------- I ----- I I I ~ I I ~ I ! I I I I I I I (ZT) (2) ,', ,,:-.~-,. ~.....:.... ..... ..:-.. " (26) (6} OE1All OF lRACT 0, R l S NO ~71 SCALE- 1'.20 _ "-..... ~, .--_._~ (7) .. :.~ OElAIl OF lRACT E, R l S NO ~71 SCALE- "'~ "'" 185 ..,;,~ 37.05 )'?~.!1r!.:. (.7 :.. ... __ ~'.t \~t:~:,. .- ll~ ""'i':..'. ~__q~_~_-,~~---,u~s.. · ..-t, ~ DE1All r.F SOIITH lINE OF ",[,_L__ lOi 18S, AUO SUOO NO 120 eftO ____ P""Pf!!'. _.._.._._..a_.._ ..sr "'__:e. ,,;!li:'" ..., , , ~~~:-------.J---- : la.t i ! (16) ! " fWD:l:J SCAlE: 2 INCHES. 600FT 1 INCH . 300FT 112 INCH = 150FT 114 INCH . 75FT [E~@[EIL~I(o)~-~~ ((9~[E[E~OfO)lD)-1~ ~1MI(g~IE!(Q)(Q)/D)-~~ G';" -a:. ~>.. "'- 0. ' ~ wu "" ~ fU1 I' @ T LOT 4 & 8 T1UC1 'II' Il L ;\'~' 110 11I11 ~.... ,jt"" ~tU:~ ~.,~.. S.7 -- I t << ~.'\ 69 lit ,., ..: ~ t: :.....: .... . " '0': ....... 'tf'/. ... . ~ Property Info. 28000 Shorewood Oaks 28010 Shorewood Oaks 28046 Oak Leaf Tr. (Next door) (Across the Street) Total Value $228,700 1999 $ 221,000 1999 $208,000 ' 1998 Land 42,000 1999 84,500 1999 57,500 1998 Bldg 188,700 1999 158,500 1999 150,500 1998 Age 1 year 6 y~ars 4 years Sq. Feet Finished 1725 2268 2200 Location Hwy7 One house In from 7 Hwy7 Purchase Price 21~,000 Appraisal 220,000 Insura..,ce Coverag~ 161.000 ~'dg IRecco~ende~ V.'Lle' : : : . ~ 'i2~,OOO 1 ~ Dar Marketplace Home Mortgage 7625 Metro Blvd. Suite 100 Edina, MN 55439 File Number: 701017SH In accordance with your request, I have personally inspected and appraised the real property at: 26000 Shorewood Oaks Sborewood, MN 55331 The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the market value of the subject property, as improved. The property rights appraised are the fee simple interest in the site and improvements. In my opinion, the estimated market value of the property as of 1/9/97, is: Two Hundred Twenty Thousand Dollars ($220,000) The attached report contains the description, analysis and supportive data for the conclusions, final estimate of value, descriptive photographs, limiting conditions and appropriate certifications. ~~ David R. Ostertag Certified General Real P operty Appraiser " .. 1740 Rice Slree!, Suite 290, SL Pau!' MN 55 j:3 (612) 487-75 I 7 lI'a X 4l\7 -7518 ~ ' ~ ,.- ~ ,-: TOT...1. PREMIUM MERS INSURANCE COMPAN~ 7 080 POUC'I ",UM8 R 'tOUR fl\OR1GAGEEI". HAS BEEN '&lllEu, 'S fOR OKlY THOSE CO~ER~GES OESCR~BEO , ~S PROPERTY ~KO l~~B~l~TY' THERE , THE p~Y Off Of THE HORTG~GE ~K THE "tHE INSURED OR SPOUSE. (>. 356.69 ~ ", '. ' ,l,i,',"'. R C & P J t\EllING I 26000 St\ORE\otOOD OM<.S/ DR I ","o"~ J.ll.Ill\\i!iI~." ""'" ~ "ili.~"j,.,."" - '" I "" po,,,.od ,,,,,, _"""-' "'0.... '1""..... -" "" .I R C & p J HELLING ~~~t~~T~~ ~~~~G~~~tO~~i~~5~~:\~5 ~GT~O~~~Y1~~3b:~\~60-10-S6 PROP. lOC.' 26000 SHOREHOOO O~~S OR~~E HEKKEP~K COUKTY EXCElSIOR fPD MINNES01A 55331 fR~HE COHST _ pRoT Cl~SS 05 - PREH GRP 56 - YE~R COKST 97 $500 DEDUC1I'&lE o~scOUHTS _ HOK-SHO~ER, PROTEctIVE OE~tCES, ElECTRtC~l SYSTEM OESCRtPT~OK Of Co~ER~GE5 ~HOUHT Of tKSUR~KCE OWEll~KG IKCl. EXTEKOEO REPl. COST 136,000 OTHER STRUCTURES 13,600 PERSOH~l PROPERTY 103.500 lOSS Of USE 69 000 PERSOK~l lt~BIlITY 30 ' HEO~C~l p~YHEHlS TB OTHERS ~:~~~ CON1EN1S REPlACEMENl Cosl PROPER1~ flOA1ER - SCt\ED.J~LR't- Olt\ER (SEE POlIC~) For current coverage. retalll w"h your policy recordS P.,_ 01 "" ""....... ",,, -. '" ....."'... .>,. -- ""'..... """ "",,- '''~. -"''' ",- DUE DAlE 04/09/98 o 9,500 lOTAl PREMIUM ~ i3 c;. ~ ~ t PREMIUM 27 0 . 9 5 INC\. INCl INCL INCL INCL INCL 85.74 tNCL 356.69 ..- '''' _ ""'~.. ... "'~ .- """..... -"'" ~ '" _. .,...._ ,..,.'" '" _'" . ..~II'; If __ 10,,, . ~. ,..,... 01 ~. "'_ ""._ 01 ..... o. ". _.d " ."..... . · .. 00 ",,,..ge "', 'b:t .. ---Xg \ i'\ ijL 8661 1 B d~. ~l.. ~ ~\ //\\ II ..=:51 l~~-'---~".'< ~?/~ 5~ Y Jtl-rt? 5!~-z6~ ~I'O ~2tP-6fY J r~'Vy ;'~4 ;)/---u?j S J>dYJ~~ ~ 7 ~ -ovlP0Y[? 7vz:l (JVVJ? ~~! d-~ 5~Jjj(7 ~ ~-.d -~tI~~7/h ~j'!~~ rv --rnrV/~~/~~/ ~~'?I J ; ~~ v ?/jf. -cJtIttJ. bfi OC?-/Jfi -E. 2 -I.JI/ -52 -rt (/fvJ J ocr/ -/ / -- ~ Z -!J II - ') 'i:. -fI a:ccJ I I f'~.551 dW foo<Y??JIcvyP, r~~tYf;!> f!4 W ~~Jrh jQ ~ ~~ jL/-3 -hL.h "~ J f ~ ~5~ rlr/I f ~nC??voy? of ~ ~09 'Od ?"'iJ 1771/ ~'1~ 5S fS ~(){)/?d(] Otv1lf/ ~ bioi ~ ~tJltI (Y(?Srlfl9J; (YO iJ C, Ie.: fr::, ~ n \\ fl ~ ~ 110) ~ ''-''C; II \VI Ie; n l~~ MAR ;3 11998 U \ By March 31, 1998 local Board of Review City Of ShoreYrOOd 5755 Country Club Road Shor~.MN 55331 Dear local Board: I wish to appeal my 1998 Hennepin Court,' Real Estate Valuation Notice tor property 10 130-117-23 42 0008 (5185 Shady Island Road). I discussed the situation with City assessor Tom Haller on March 18, 1998, but will be unable to altend tomorrow's meeting due to a "NOrk cortlict. The reason I am appealing the val~ is because of the percentage increase. The increase from 1996 to 1997 was 5% and the value from 1997 to 1998 is double/ or 10%. No improvements 'nWe made during this time. A check with other neighbors indicates to me that this double iocrease Is unreasonable. AIso,ln 1996 and 1991 tax value notices the Estimated Market Value equaled the Market Value For Taxation. In 1998 the Estimated Market Value Is listed at 324/000, while the Market Value For Taxation Is listed at 298,1 00. That's a 9% dtrrereoce and I can only assll'l'le the "'MiI:ing on the VY'a.lf' tor the 1999 Valuation Notice if this Is not contested. Apparently a "'<<alk through" inspection was denied in the SlJl'l"'lmer of 1997. If that had a bearing on this double percentage increase over previous years than I suggest scheduling another inspection to resolve this maU:er. I appreciate your consideration and inv&stigation into this maU:er. Sincerely/ ~!v{.~ David W. Greer 5185 Shady Island Road homeowner March 25, 1998 l~~(~ I~JI \Vll~'r~~ \... MAR ;3 01998 iU ( I 8Y\ ,_., ,~,.,~_... --.u City Assessor 5755 Country Club Road Shorewood, MN 55331 Dear Sir, I am writing to protest, or at least understand, how my property assessment was arrived at. My name is Robert Carr, and I live at 6080 Sierra Circle. My home telephone number is 470-5020, and my work number is 595-6713. As background, our Estimated Market Value was $393,100 in 1996, rose to $412,000 in 1997 and is now set at $438,000 for 1998. This represents a $44,900 (11.4%) increase over two years and a $26,000 (6.3%) increase for just the last year. I am not one who usually pro~ests this sort of thing. However, I can't for the life of me understand where such increases are coming from. The house across the street from us (6145 Sierra Circle) sat on the market for nearly a year, and I'm sure sold at a greatly reduced price from the original asking price. And while our house is very nice, it's at the low end of the price range in Sweetwater. I will follow up with a phone call to better understand how these valuations are determined, and more specifically, how mine was determined. In today's world, the general cost of living and wage inflation are running at historically low levels. I don't see how an 11 % increase in market valuation over two years can be justified, and would like to see compelling evidence that actual sale prices in our neighborhood have been at that level. Since~y, ;JJ~ Robert Carr 1997 VALUE fOR TAXES PAYABLE IN 1998 ... SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR ADDnONAL tNFORMA nON ... CITY ASSESSOR 5755 COUNTRY CLUB RD S HOR,::WOOO MN 55331 He 207 (11/96) HENNEPIN COUNTY REAL ESTATE VALUATION NOTICE RESIDENTIAL HOM[SfEAO PROPERTYID 36-117-23 43 OQ23 TO APPEAL YOUR VALUATION OR CLASSIFICATION First. read the back of this notice! MUNICIPALITY SHOREwUGO PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION S~ep 1: TO discuss your Valuation Notice with an Assessor. call the nUIT I listed below within the next five (5) days. ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE 473-1544 438.,000 LIMITED MARKET VALUE 433,000 Step 2: Local Board of Review: You may appeal by appearing in perso: sending a letter or representative to the board. Call your assessor: appointment may be necessary. QUALIFYING VALUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS MARKET VALUE FOR TAXATION VALUE FOR NEW IMPROVEMENTS 438",OO:J AP~ 2. 1997 AT 7:JU PM AT SHORE wOOD CITY HALL Step 3: The County Board of Equalization: Ycu must appe,,; to the Local BOard of Review to be eligible to appea.l tc County Board of Equalization. Information on Hennepin County's Boare Equalization is on the baok of {his notice. JJNNA CARP, 6080 SIeRRA eIR EXCELSIOR MN 55331-8147 ilf.Ha. 1.I.I't.I.I"'ltl...lluuIH..l.".uHlh..Hu.U..J,il"uL.l.i HENNEPIN COUNTY REAL ESTATE VALUATION NOTICE " "jf,jS"':: 1'996 VAt.UEF!fIR TAXES PAYABLE IN 1997 ee ... SEE R SESlDE FOR AOonONAL INFORMAnON'" CITY ASSESSOR 5755 COUNTRY CLUB RD SHOREWOOD MN 55331 RESIDfNTrAl HOMESTEAD PROPERTY 10 36-117-23 43 0023 TO APPEAL YOURVALU~'l First, read the back of this notice! Step 1: To disouss your Valuation Notice with an Assessor, call the num: listed below within the next five (5) days. MUNICIPALITY S H OR E ~.IOO D PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE 473-1844 4-12.000 LIMITED MARKET VALUE 412,000 Step 2: Local Board of Review: You may appeal by appearing in person sending a letter or representative to the board. Call your assessor; appointment may be necessary. QUALIFYING VALUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS MARKET VALUE FOR TAXATION VALUE FOR NEW IMPROVEMENTS 412,000 APR 3, 1996 AT 7:30 PM AT SHOREWOOO CITY HALL Step 3: The County Board of Equalization: You must appeal to the Local Board of Review to be eligible to appeal to t County Board of Equalization. Information on Hennepin County's Board Equalization is on the back of this notice. DONNA CARR. 6080 SIERRA CIR. EXCELSIOR ~N 55331-3147 '" " " '."-." , \ I f / i' I;!,; I i 1." il, I 'e' Ill, ,I,; ..11,1..11" ,II. i l.ll..ItI,LI . HENNEPIN COUNTY 1997 PROPERTY TAX STATEMENT PLEASE READ BACK OF FORM FOR PENALTY. PAYMENT AND ESCROW INFORMATION PROPERTYIDNO. 36-117-23 43 0023 Property Class(es): . ~:Ie in 1996 Taxes 1997 Pa b1e in ..HOMESTEAD HOMESTEA New Improvements: . Estimated Market Value:.. Taxable Market Value: o 393,100 393,100 o 412,000 412,000 1. Use this amount on Form M-1 PR to see if you're eligible for a property tax refund . 2. Use this amount for the special property tax refund on schedule 1 of Form M-1 PR . 9,877.01 Your Property Tax and How It Is Reduced By The State 3. Property tax before reduction by state paid aids and credits . 13, 703 . 99 14 , 109 . 61 4. Aid paid by the state of Minnesota to reduce your property tax . 2,662. 53 2,534 . 69 5. Credits paid by the state of Minnesota to reduce your property tax: a. Homestead and agricultural credit . co co co 1 , 164 . 45 b. Other credits n n 6. Property tax after reduction by state paid aids and credits 9 ,877 . 01 Where Your Property Tax Dollars Go 10,409.39 1,165.53 00 10,409.39 7. County. 8. Municipality 9A. School District Excess Levy Referenda Tax 9B. School District Remaining School Tax 10A. Metropolitan Special Taxing Districts 10B. Other Special Taxing Districts 2,661.81 1,244.91 1,641.51 3,810.67 325.17 192.94 2,670.72 1,314.42 1,725.53 4,171.64 332.08 195.00 COUNTY COLLECTED SOLID WASTE MGMT FEE .00 9,877 .01 73.31 nn 10,409.39 78.36 11. Non-School Voter Approved Referenda Levies 12. Property Taxes Before Fees and Special Assessments 13. Special Assessments Added to This Property Tax Bill SPECIALS ASSESSMENT PRINCIPAL SPECIALS ASSESSMENT INTEREST 101.33 45.57 101. 33 37.98 14. TOTAL PROPERTY TAX AND SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS 10,097.22 10,627.06 Make Check Payable to HENNEPIN COUNTY TREASURER Pay this amount no later than May 15. 1997 Pay this amount no later than October 15. 1997 co 5,313.53 5,313.53 DETACH PAYMENT STUB HERE BEFORE MAILING MAR :3 0 1998 I ~~':Y fbiw 8'1 ~~ 'jjdL J( ~J- (JUvt-- /7( AMuvOIJ , mill J'J/33 / Thunderbird Hotel And Convention Center 2201 East 78th Street Bloomington, MN 55425-1228 (61 2) 854-3411 Fax (612) 854-1183 For Reservations Call 1-800-328-1931 bJttij ;IaV : I#- /#11' Iud ti' #V ~ ht ~ hd ~L~.. pJ.ac~ p;t ~ d<7 /414/ j~ 1'::~ 11 d ~J ~ J/~/ #U ~- ~w:L :P?f' 12rtt f7U ~ ~;P ~d6 ~ C1Iil-o ~~.lL tUl ~L 4U1-AWL.J ;lAd ~ ~ r-~L ~a&v~. ~;dJ;J U/~ (a-ud~) a ~ UdP ~d--/!f/'lL.. a-- ~ ~ .A-~ /1/.1-:' '-/!c/ frd 4 ~ ~ ~ d ):J01cL WL ~. -~.. v:;l(?r7 .. I/YV.' NO cf_~~~, r ~drl!7."';NUJ /AdM tZ~. c:I~... 7J~. ~. 1M r 71Uf/, ~ ~~ ffl4. ry ~d- ~CL ~ dvrr~ M ~ ;;~ ~. 8-, i" I siA4 ~L- ~ 'J d .v: Ii. l-.3 :J-'-f () 0 OJ /" .LjqyO F///)/ . ~~le\.n @ Thunderbird Hotel And Convention Center 2201 East 78th Street Bloomington, MN 55425-1228 (612) 854-3411 Fax (612) 854-1183 For Reservations Call 1 -800-328-1931 JU ~ 14~.. ~. ~ L/dt4L ~'~ L -t> P':f'" tikd k ~L> '{/ .~?~ ud~rU. ;Us; __ -.L u' .2.f'J/,tJ ~ ~ ~ ~, rY?r ~ fi1,<V n<tiL- ,;,.dl ~ Jud7' 61(~~~M ~ t? /,L. p ~ '7't-- V~.Hi ~ r i;y~ fM ~. ~ a. "nr" pi ~1; WM-d -ptr2/1- ~ ~. 41p~ · .3 'f" I Viti- Av"~"i It 6r~ Vi /If!! A- -V- 1'5'IY ,It{~~/ 191Y ,fall C71cK.sd'1.- ' (?, ty A-ss f2.sS()~ ~7 ~5' t2 001'111 c/()), ,-rtL Sh ctYe woo~. /J?}/' S-~g,~1 If~~ Vd/(/dt~ fl-,r-d-I If'I 0 ~-- 117 -)-3 .:1.3 OG?-S7 I ..19. ~ e-t!ql~~...1 i~ MAN, 0 1998 ~i L~yli '""u .,.- .... ..... . ~~ St'y: --- -1-' WI I/b-L ;;.., /f >"1 ~cJ Y1 ~ AI''''; J 1st- So ;::/etJ.1~ L'fT>? ~ ; oI4,y ~; ~ oJ$' a y-~ <{''/ t 'f.:5 /0 w../i;f~ tI.r/t(~ ~ (!)<.Jy A-m't! bv7 (!(Iv~~a:--#ame... yc~ ~ "7' ~e>rrt'4_;rr4~t-.J: ~?,<,>./ntf' ~ ~.bi-f~)?1~o* ~uY".199'7 ~cl /9?'Y f<.o x ~f.t-ds:r.zJ' ~,~ ~a/ <9.17 jf-S:.1'~$ .,.,....-~ ~ h t..p; '1. {?tP.J?t it. I ~ s'pe~ L (') v.,.,-?"p 51 ~L a...,. cI WJ-s 70 "'>'€.yiuJ, ['"'1,<1.- C>br'>\.t;~.6/v -p,,q- t!l-// SD/<L ;..., 1hc,hrla'ct'/e.- '~~c?dO-;'" Qy lou.J~. /15 ,ref') .::/- ho4re...-nQi" -ftJ~ d.-.-,/ r~.s',P&1$~c/>i'n. ~"rr", ~cJ7Z~. /fJ~ +: ~sk.~&>....., "to.'()~ed,-~~';) shr'<-' ~,.~ ~~nJ?epnt ~C}1'7'" A-sSPS$d. tF/U$-L- A V6(~r ~ V6-/VL- tf()w(fWa..r'- j-rv" n.k"J ~~L6/.e..--./# /99'9'. l..l CITY ASSESSOR 5155' COUNTRY CLUB RD SHOREWOOO MN 55331 First, read the back of this notice! To discuss your Valuation Notice with an Assessor, call the number listed below within the next five (5) days. 473-1844 LIMITED MARKET VALUE 278.000 11!!!~11 Local Board of Review: You may appeal by appearing in person or '~en iri!'r a letter or representative to the board. Call your assessor; an appointment may be necessary. QUALIFYING VALUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS MARKET VALUE FOR TAXATION VALUE FOR NEW IMPROVEMENTS 278.000 APR 1. 1998 AT 7=00 PM AT SHOREWOOD CITY HALL The County Board of Equalization: must appeal to the Local Board of Review to be eligible to appeal to the County Board of Equalization. Information on Hennepin County's Board of Equalization is on the back of this notice. ARNO W WINDSOR 4940 SUSSEX PL EXCELSIOR MN 5533 WXNDq~O T~533'~020 ~1qe 21 03"9/98 WINDSOR 3~bi VIA AVEFRIA GREEN VALLEY AZ e5bi~ .~~='- l~ ~Ii"'f'... II , " .,.., ~'.~~ , '" i .,. . ';:[,;(:'~" ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE is defined as the most probable price that a well-informed buyer would pay a well-informed seller for a property without either party being unduly forced to buy or sell. In other words, this is what the property would likely sell for, in terms of money, if it were sold in an arms-length transaction. The classification of your property is mandated by state law and is based on the use of your property. LIMITED MARKET VALUE applies to residential, agricultural and seasonal-residential recreational properties. If the property's estimated market value increases by 10% or more over the previous year's value, the property will then receive a limited market value. This limitation does not apply to new improvements. QUALIFYING VALUES for IMPROVEMENTS is the amount of improvement value excluded from taxation on homestead property if the property is 35 years of age or older (M.S. 273.11, Subd. 16). The qualifying amount is excluded for ten years or until the property no longer qualifies, whichever comes first. After 10 years, 20% of the excluded value will be placed back on the tax rolls for five consecutive years. When the property sells or no longer qualifies for a homestead, the excluded value will become taxable the following year. Call your Assessor for further details. MARKET VALUE FOR TAXATION i~ the net'valuation that will be used for the calculation of your tax next year. It's the final valuation after all reductions. VALUE FOR NEW IMPROVEMENTS is the value placed on the property because of additions, remodeling and other changes which add value to the property. STEP 1: You should first try to collect information about properties similar to yours that have sold. If this information indicates the valuation or classification is incorrect, you should call your assessor within the next 5 days and discuss this information with the assessor. The telephone number for the assessor is listed on the front of this card. Many times questions and concerns can be addressed in advance of Local Board meetings. STEP 2: Local Board of Review: If, after discussing this information with the assessor, you still feel you have reason to appeal, you may appear before the Local Board of Review. Please call your assessor first, an appointment may be necessary. The date and time of the meeting are listed on the front of this card. STEP 3: County Board of Equalization: To be eligible to appear before the County Board of Equalization, you must first appear before the Local Board of Review. If you wish to appeal the decision of the Local Board of Review to the County Board of Equalization, you must schedule an appointment. The County Board of Equalization will begin meeting on June 15, 1998. All appointments for the County Board of Equalization must be scheduled before June 8, 1998 by calling 348-5076. For all other assessment information, call your local assessor at the number on the front of this notice. State law also provides that a property owner can appeal to the Minnesota Tax Court. For information on the Tax Court please contact the Tax Court Office, Minnesota Judicial Center, 25 Constitution Ave., St. Paul MN, 55155. All appeals to the Tax Court must be made ON OR BEFORE March 31 of the year in which the tax is payable. Also note: Income and expense data, on income producing properties, must be filed with the assessor within sixty (60) days of filing a petition. Printed on recycied paper MAR-27~1998 08:11 CITY OF MINNETONKA 612 939 8244 P.01/01 TO: JIM HURM, CITY OF SHOREWOOD, FAX# 474--0128 FROM: BETTY NORTON 23730 MCLAIN ROAD DATE: MARCH 27, 1998 Jim, Re; Board of Review By way of this fax, I wish to notify the Board of Review that I am appealing the valuation of my property at 23730 Mclain Road, Shorewood (34-117-23 23 0030). The assessor has valued the property at $130,000. I believe, due to the flooding problems (wet basement, etc.), the property would never sell at that price, and I request that the Board decrease that value. I understand that the Board will meet at 7;00 p.m. on April 1. Please Jet me know when they will be hearing this appeal. Thank you, Betty Norton wo: 939-8214 ho: 474-8534 TOTAL P.01 Hennepin County An Equal Opportunity Employer June 24, 1997 William Wicka 27930 Smithtown Road Shorewood, MN 55331 Dear Mr. Wicka: In response to your request for a hearing, the 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization has determined that the 1997 market value for the property listed should be as indicated below. The market value will be entered into the assessment records and used to compute the property tax payable in 1998. Property Identification Number 31-117-23-34-0001 Market Value After Local Board of Review $716,000 Market Value After County Board of Eaualization $695,000 The 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization adjourned Sine Die on June 20,1997. A new Board of Equalization will be appointed during 1998 and will be authorized to hear appeals of 1998 Market Value or Classification for the June, 1998 Hennepin County Board of Equalization. If you wish to appeal the decision of the 1997 Hennepin County Board of Equalization regarding the 1997 Estimated Market Value or Classification of your property, you may file a Petition with Minnesota Tax Court. Filing instructions, including offices where Petitions must be filed, deadline for filing and information regarding other pertinent filing requirements, may be obtained from Minnesota Tax Court at 296-2806. sinc~d )I-{)~ Patrick H. O'Connor, Manager Taxpayer Services Division (Recorder, Hennepin County Board of Equalization) PHO:jmb (w:benotif97) Hennepin County General Services Taxpayer Services Division A-600 Hennepin County Government Center Minneapolis, Minnesota 55487-0060 Recycled Paper ~ ., Summary of a Study Conducted bv the Office of Minnesota State Auditor and Three Studies Made bv the Minnesota Department of Revenue "Securing Minnesota's Financial Future: Property Tax Reform in the 1990s" Minnesota Office of the State Auditor Research and Information Division August 1994 Disparities in Property Taxes . Homeowners pay dramatically different property taxes depending on where in Minnesota they live. . Homeowners with approximately the same incomes had markedly different property tax liabilities. . Geographic location is a major determinant of tax burden. In a few areas, homeowners paid less in average property taxes than for cable television. . Property taxes in Minnesota are regressive. . Property taxes differ for homes of similar value. . Counties with similar needs for public services had very different average taxes. Disparities in the Distribution of Minnesota's Property Tax Base . Minnesota's effective property tax rate for a typical commercial firm ranked second in the nation and a typical industrial firm ranked sixth but a high tech factory with a large proportion of personal property ranked 32nd. . Property classification is an inefficient method of tax relief. . Market values of homes are unreliable indicators of homeowners' ability to pay property taxes. Distribution of State Aid . The average metro property taxed are nearly twice the second highest average property tax. . Disparities are found withing economic regions. . The ability of homeowners to pay property taxes is more dependent on those individuals' incomes than on their property values. . The classification system provides a property tax break to all homeowners regardless of their incomes. . Lower income homeowners pay a higher percentage of their incomes on property taxes than higher income homeowners. The regressivity of the property tax illustrates the inequities created by the system particularly for low income homeowners living in the metro area. "Property Tax Regressivity In Minnesota" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division January 1993 . This report documents a regressive relationship between income and market value that is only moderately reduced by existing tax relief programs. . The classification system treats all market value the same regardless of ability-to-pay. . While the expectation of the Property Tax Refund (PTR) program would be to reduce the overall regressivity of the property tax system, analysis shows that the impact is very slight. . If the goal is to alleviate the regressivity of the property tax, then greater emphasis should be placed on the property tax refind program which directly links property tax relief to tax burden measured relative to household income. . A state paid property tax refund can then be provided to those households which have high taxes relative to their income and less relief or no refund to higher income households . ~/-~ ~ "1993 Property Tax Relief For Minnesotans, Analysis of Trends 1975-1993" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division . The average net tax of homeowners is $1,412 and the average net tax of renters is $667 yet the limit on the property tax refund for homeowners is $400 (now $470) while renters can receive a property tax refund of up to $1,000 (now $1090). · After the property tax refund, the percentage of income spent on property taxes by homeowners is 5.4% while the renter's percentage is 2.6%. "1997 Minnesota Tax Incidence Study" Minnesota Department of Revenue Tax Research Division Table 1. Shows that at all levels except for the first decile, residential property taxes take a greater percentage of a household's income than business property takes from a business' income. The same relationship exists for the income tax as well. Effective tax rates ircreased for the individual income tax and homeowner property taxes; effective tax rates fell for business property taxes and especially for rental housing. Between 1994 and 1996, homestead property values rose more than twice as rapidly as business property values, which failed to keep up with inflation. (page viii) Table 2.2. Shows the amounts and percentage distribution of state and local tax collections by type of tax and taxpayer category in millions of dollars. In 1994, the taxes paid on a $120,000 home were 2.8 times those on a $60,000 home; the taxes on a $360,000 home were over 10.8 times those on a $60,000 home because of the class rate structure. Table 6.3. This table shows that the the average percent of income spent on property taxes by households is 2.1 percent. Minnesota Senior Federation Survey of Its Membership 1996 . While the average Minnesotan pays 2.1 percent of their income on property taxes (see Table 6.3 above), the respondents to the Federation survey paid an average of 4 percent of their income. · A total of 25 percent paid over 6 percent of their income on property taxes. This is almost three times what the average Minnesotan paid. · A total of 1.4 percent of the respondents paid over 20 percent of their income on property taxes. Some respondents were paying from 30 to 50 percent of their income on property taxes. · This is while the wealthiest Minnesotan pays only 8.5 percent of their income on income taxes. · All taxes: Sales, income, and property taxes are paid from one's income. Homesteaded property produces no income with which to pay property taxes. Property Tax Resolution: Limiting the Property Tax to a Percentage of Income WHEREAS, The present property tax system is a regressive tax, adversely affecting those homeowners who have lived a long time in their homes; and WHEREAS, The amount of residential property taxes assessed depends upon the market value of one's home; and WHEREAS, Studies made on the subject have shown that the value of a person's home has no relationship to the ability of the homeowner to pay the assessed property tax; and WHEREAS, Unlike the income tax system which limits the percentage of a taxpayer's income that can be collected, and unlike the sales tax which limits the amount of tax that can be collected from a purchase as a percentage of its cost, the present property tax system does not limit the amount of property tax that can be collected from a renter or homeowner; and WHEREAS, It has been documented that many Minnesotans are paying a percentage of their income on property taxes far beyond the 1.8 percent which the average Minnesotan pays; some homeowners are paying up to 40 percent of their income on property taxes; and WHEREAS, This method of unlimited taxation is driving many Minnesotans from their homes, especially the widowed and the elderly; and WHEREAS, The finances of the State of Minnesota are in such good order that the past excuse that the injustices perpetuated by the present property tax system could not be corrected because of a lack of funds is no longer valid; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City of Shorewood to support the enactment into law by the 1998 Minnesota Legislature of a limit to the amount of a person's income that can be assessed for property taxes, and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that funding for the limitation be achieved through an expanded state tax credit based on income, and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this protection be extended to all citizens of the State of Minnesota regardless of age or place of residence. Dated: Mayor City of Shore wood Minnesota Senior Federation Tax Committee Marlowe Hamerston, Chairman. 1885 University Ave. W. . Suite 190. St. Paul, MN 55104.612-645-0261 Home: 771 Larson Lane. Shoreview, MN 55126.612-484-4615. e-mail: hamerOl2@tc.umn.edu Dear Mayor and City Council Members: Members of the Minnesota Senior Federation residing in your community, as well as the 30,000 members throughout our state, need your help to gain passage of legislation to instill fairness in Minnesota's property tax system.You may have heard citizens from your community express displeasure with the property tax system. And J am sure you told them that your city government uses property taxes for the legitimate operations of your city but that city. government has little to say about the structure of Minnesota's property tax. The state legislature continues to pass on to city government, mandates to be implemented but no funding to carry them out. When city governments levy property taxes for these programs, it is the city that gets the blame for the increased taxes while the state legislature takes credit for not raising taxes. It is the ever-increasing property tax rate that is literally driving older Minnesotans from their homes. The loss of this segment of our society from any community has a detrimental effect on the mix of its population. Forcing seniors from the familiar surroundings of their community cannot be justified by any means. The seniors of your community are the pillars upon which your churches and service organizations are built. The cost of housing seniors in nursing homes or subsidizing their rents far exceeds the cost of implementing a property tax circuit breaker system that will allow many seniors to remain in their homes. Our proposal is not restricted to senior citizens; our proposal would apply to all Minnesota taxpayers who are faced with the same problem - renters and homeowners, young and old. It would also help. protect younger families who may face temporary unemployment allowing them to stay on their feet and in their home. This is easily accomplished by placing a reasonable limit to the amount of a household's income which can be collected in property taxes. Our proposal would not effect state funding to cities. The proposal is to expand the present circuit breaker program by placing a percentage limit on the amount that can be collected from a taxpayer. The state would be responsible for the amount of tax refund and the city's funding from the state would not change. I have enclosed some literature explaining the need for limiting the property tax. - The reverse side of this letter lists ten of the many reasons for reforming the present property tax system. This legislation will not cure all the problems of the property tax. system but will be a giant. step toward making it fair. - The next page is a summary of four studies conducted by the Minnesota Department of Revenue and one study made by the off/ceof State Auditor and a study by the Minnesota Senior Federation. These studies support the need for making the change put forth in the accompanying resolution. -The tinal sheet is a resolution, which I hope you and your council will pass. It supports the enactment of legislation to establish a limit as the percentage of a person's income can be collected in property taxes. City government is government at the grass roots level. Too often the legislature listens to the paid lobbyists whose agenda is not the same as your community's citizens. The taxpayers of your city need their city government to speak up for them through the passage of this resolution. The passage of this resolution by you and other city governments throughout the state of Minnesota should get the attention of our legislature. This resolution is the vehicle for you to make a statement to the 1998 legislature on behalf of the citizens of your community. They must hear the message: Do something about the unlimited nature of the property taxI If you have any questions or would like to discuss the resolution further, feel free to call or write to me at the address given above. I would appreciate your letting me know of the disposition of the. resolution by your city government so that your actions can be properly recognized at the legislature and by the media. Sincerely, ...---, / ~J~~#te'__d: The Top Ten Reasons for Property Tax Reform 10. The Property Tax is the only unlimited form of taxation in existence. There is no limit as to the percentage of a person's income that can be assessed in property taxes. The sales tax is limited to 6.5% of the amount of a sale and the top income tax rate is limited to 8.5% of a person's income. The present property tax system has been documented to be taking from 10% to even 50% of many Minnesotan's income. 9. There is no relationship between the market value of a taxpayer's property and their ability to pay the taxes levied. Numerous studies have been made by the State Auditor and Department of Revenue and no connection between the market value of a property and the homeowner's ability to pay the associated taxes has been shown. Using the market value of a home to determine the property tax is proven in-valid. 8. The property tax is universally recognized as a regressive tax which affects our most vulnerable citizens to the greatest degree. It is the elderly and the widowed, who have lived in their homes many years and have seen their market values grow far beyond their incomes, who are being driven from their homes by this tax. 7. Most taxes tax your assets. The present property tax system also taxes your debt. If you purchased a $75,000 home today and put down $5,000, tomorrow, the present property tax system would begin taxing not only your equity, but would also require you to pay property taxes on your $70,000 debt. 6. A community with a "rich" property tax base does not mean an individual taxpayer in that community is rich. The practice of "blanket" reassessment is outrageously unfair. It gives no consideration to the individual properties nor to the harm caused to the neighborhood by raising taxes without consideration as to the condition of any individual property. 5. Allowing property taxes to force seniors from their homes creates a great a loss to churches, schools, and the community as a whole. At a time when the president is calling for more volunteerism, we should not be forcing the greatest reservoir of volunteers that society has, our retired population, to leave their communities. 4. The property tax taxes on the basis of future earnings. Earnings you may collect upon the sale of the property if such a sale ever takes place. You are being taxed on the basis of a sale that has not taken place to a buyer who does not exist. There is no basis for the use of a taxation system based upon projected earnings. You can not pay present day taxes with future earnings. You can not pay the taxes due now, with future earnings. 3 . The present property tax system is anti-family and a slum producing machine. Our property tax system penalizes homeowners who try to maintain and improve their property. The reward for providing a clean, safe environment for their family is higher taxes. A landlord has little incentive to keep rental properties in an acceptable condition when he knows his improvements will result in higher property taxes. 2 . The property tax is a relic of the 1800's and it is long over-due to be reformed, not just tinkered with, but reformed to conform to the realities of the 21st century. While property ownership created and was a measure of wealth in the rural society of the 1800s, the urban residential property of today creates no wealth with which to pay property taxes. 1. The property tax refund system must be modified to protect Minnesotans from being driven from their homes by our present archaic and unfair system. Minnesota has become a state where citizens do not own property, but rent it from the state with property taxes. Finally, the constitutionality of the property tax is questionable. If it is not unconstitutional, it is surely unconscionable. Which is worse? There must be a limitation to the amount of one's income which can be levied on a taxpayer's property. The passage of Senate File 1835 or House File 1258/Senate File 1147 will provide the protection needed and deserved by the citizens of the State of Minnesota. Join in the efforts to make the passage of this legislation happen during the 1998 legislative session. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 24775 AMLEE RD PID#: 33-117-23-12-0011 SALE PRICE: $ 114,950 YEAR BUILT: 1955 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 912 GROUND FLR. AREA: 912 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199612 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 50 ~ 0 PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 20,145 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 1 I I I I I I I I I I I, I I I I I I I I SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 3 WITH PID 34-117-23-42-0064 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 2 RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5910 GALPIN LAKE RD PID#: 34-117-23-42-0017 142,500 1960 960 960 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199704 1 STORY 80 % o 2 YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 8,712 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25545 BIRCH BLUFF RD PID#: 28-117-23-33-0023 SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: GARAGE #1: # OF CARS: 0 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199704 1 STORY 112,000 1919 1054 1054 DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 10,620 SF 2 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 3 \ I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 20115 EXCELSIOR BLVD PID#: 25-117-23-34-0011 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199706 1 STORY SALE PRICE: $ 141,500 YEAR BUILT: 1965 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1080 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1080 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 70 % YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 38,333 SF 3 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 4 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5805 MINNETONKA DR PID#: 34-117-23-32-0005 SALE PRICE: $ 138,500 YEAR BUILT: 1961 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1170 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1170 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199612 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 30 g,. 0 PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 81,893 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 5 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25685 SUNNYVALE LA PID#: 32-117-23-11-0015 SALE PRICE: $ 155,000 YEAR BUILT: 1963 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1172 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1172 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199709 1 STORY DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 20,025 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 6 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 21115 MINNETONKA BLVD PID#: 26-117-23-14-0074 SALE PRICE: $ 92,000 YEAR BUILT: 1950 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1192 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1192 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199708 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 8,103 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 7 I 'I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5680 MINNETONKA DR PID#: 34-117-23-23-0024 SALE PRICE: $ 136,500 YEAR BUILT: 1957 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1196 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1196 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 70 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 20,810 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 8 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 20515 MANOR RD PID#: 25-117-23-32-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 117,000 YEAR BUILT: 1958 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1204 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1204 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199705 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 17,500 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 9 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6010 APPLE RD PID#: 35-117-23-31-0054 SALE PRICE: $ 135,000 YEAR BUILT: 1956 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1264 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1264 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 1 GARAGE #2: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199705 1 STORY BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 25,950 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 10 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27475 PINE BEND PID#: 31-117-23-14-0009 SALE PRICE: $ 156,000 YEAR BUILT: 1971 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1312 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1312 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199706 1 STORY 80 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 27,007 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 11 I I .1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5760 MINNETONKA DR PID#: 34-117-23-23-0035 SALE PRICE: $ 170,000 YEAR BUILT: 1956 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1384 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1384 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199706 1 STORY 50 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 36,155 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 12 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25140 GLEN RD PID#: 33-117-23-21-0047 SALE PRICE: $ 120,000 YEAR BUILT: 1953 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1399 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1399 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 2 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 13 199705 1 STORY 00 % o 1 o o 55,320 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5500 GIDEONS LA PID#: 33-117-23-12-0073 SALE PRICE: $ 205,000 YEAR BUILT: 1994 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1402 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1402 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 14 199611 1 STORY 80 % 1 1 o 1 117,099 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4460 ENCHANTED DR PID#: 30-117-23-32-0017 SALE PRICE: $ 238,000 YEAR BUILT: 1993 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1444 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1444 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: 199707 1 STORY 60 % BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 15 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5320 SHADY HILLS CIR PID#: 25-117-23-44-0035 SALE PRICE: $ 180,000 YEAR BUILT: 1959 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1456 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1456 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199705 1 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 50 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 19,180 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 16 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4820 SUBURBAN DR PID#: 25-117-23-23-0021 SALE PRICE: $ 319,000 YEAR BUILT: 1992 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1487 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1487 GARAGE # 1 : ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 17 199702 1 STORY 40 % YES YES 1 1 o 1 86,282 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5025 SUBURBAN DR PID#: 25-117-23-32-0012 SALE PRICE: $ 138,500 YEAR BUILT: 1964 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1742 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1742 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199705 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 48,690 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 19 I ,Ii I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 20370 EXCELSIOR BLVD PID#: 25-117-23-34-0006 SALE PRICE: $ 160,000 YEAR BUILT: 1961 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1797 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1797 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 5 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 20 199707 1 STORY 70 % o 1 1 1 37,026 SF 'I I I I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5885 MINNETONKA DR PID#: 34-117-23-32-0024 SALE PRICE: $ 235,000 YEAR BUILT: 1984 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1877 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1877 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 21 199701 1 STORY 80 % YES o 2 2 o 28,000 SF I I I 'I I I ,I " I I I II I I I I I i I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27865 BRYNMAWR PL PID#: 31-117-23-13-0031 SALE PRICE: $ 400,000 YEAR BUILT: 1994 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1911 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1911 G.]).RAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199703 1 STORY 70 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 44,188 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 22 I Ii I I I I I I I I I I I, I I .1 I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27745 BRYNMAWR PL PID#: 31-117-23-13-0028 SALE PRICE: $ 479,000 YEAR BUILT: 1996 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1915 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1915 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 4 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199611 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 40,333 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 23 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5955 BOULDER BRIDGE LA PID#: 31-117-23-41-0012 SALE PRICE: $ 510,000 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1997 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1997 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199707 1 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 47,200 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 24 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5580 OLD MARKET RD PID#: 36-117-23-12-0055 SALE PRICE: $ 289,900 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2023 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2023 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 3 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 25 199706 1 STORY 70 % YES o 2 o 1 26,500 SF I I I I I I I I. I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27430 PINE BEND PID#: 31-117-23-14-0012 SALE PRICE: $ 185,000 YEAR BUILT: 1967 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2182 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2182 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199705 1 STORY BSMT. FINISHING: 50 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 43,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 26 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26075 BIRCH BLUFF RD PID#: 29-117-23-43-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 215,000 YEAR BUILT: 1978 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2184 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2184 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199707 1 STORY 00 % GAFAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 86,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 27 I I I I I I I I I I ,I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26665 EDGEWOOD RD PID#: 32-117-23-21-0003 SALE PRICE: $ 178,000 YEAR BUILT: 1957 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2394 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2394 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199704 1 STORY 60 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 31,165 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 28 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5880 BOULDER BRIDGE LA PID#: 31-117-23-42-0027 SALE PRICE: $ 450,000 YEAR BUILT: 1986 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2461 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2461 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199612 1 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 90 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 2 LOT SIZE: 52,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 29 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19680 CHARTWELL HILL PID#: 36-117-23-13-0025 SALE PRICE: $ 435,000 YEAR BUILT: 1986 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2488 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2488 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199610 1 STORY 70 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 24,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 30 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 21000 IVY LA PID#: 26-117-23-14-0025 SALE PRICE: $ 129,000 YEAR BUILT: 1958 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1050 GROUND FLR. AREA: 840 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 1 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: 199704 1 1/4 STORY 40 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 14,810 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 31 SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: GARAGE #1: # OF CARS: GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: House demoed after sale I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5885 SEAMANS DR PID#: 33-117-23-32-0033 160,000 1900 1116 792 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199701 1 3/4 STORY DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 158,124 SF o o INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 32 .1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5815 CLUB LA PID#: 33-117-23-42-0001 SALE PRICE: $ 121,000 YEAR BUILT: 1959 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1160 GROUND FLR. AREA: 928 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199707 1 1/4 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 21,780 SF 2 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 33 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5615 EUREKA RD PID#: 33-117-23-23-0060 SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: 94,000 1910 1225 796 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: 199611 1 3/4 STORY GARAGE #1: # OF CARS: 0 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 93,218 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 34 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I II I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 22630 MURRAY ST PID#: 34-117-23-44-0011 SALE PRICE: $ 163,500 YEAR BUILT: 1932 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1275 GROUND FLR. AREA : 1020 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 2 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 35 199704 1 1/4 STORY 00 % o 1 o o 74,052 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 20050 EXCELSIOR BLVD PID#: 25-117-23-31-0025 SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 95,000 1918 1300 880 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199701 1 3/4 STORY 00 % o OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 40,500 SF 3 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 36 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25905 WILD ROSE LA PID#: 32-117-23-14-0035 SALE PRICE: $ 154,900 YEAR BUILT: 1915 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1573 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1261 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 1 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 1 1/2 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 40,432 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 37 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27015 EDGEWOOD RD PID#: 32-117-23-22-0005 SALE PRICE: $ 189,900 YEAR BUILT: 1900 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1617 GROUND FLR. AREA: 924 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199610 1 3/4 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 1 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 60 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 42,360 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 38 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6020 GALPIN LAKE RD PID#: 34-117-23-43-0036 SALE PRICE: $ 270,000 YEAR BUILT: 1900 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1857 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1178 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199705 1 3/4 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 60984 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 39 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 40 RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25585 BIRCH BLUFF RD PID#: 28-117-23-33-0022 SALE PRICE: $ 148,500 YEAR BUILT: 1908 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1914 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1458 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 1 GARAGE #2: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: 199611 1 1/2 STORY 00 % o 1 o 1 11,100 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6125 RIDGE RD PID#: 36-117-23-34-0004 SALE PRICE: $ 192,500 YEAR BUILT: 1973 GROSS BLDG. AREA : 1444 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1144 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199610 2 STORY 00 % BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 51,836 SF 3 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 41 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 22015 STRATFORD PL PID#: 35-117-23-33-0023 SALE PRICE: $ 189,900 YEAR BUILT: 1985 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1507 GROUND FLR. AREA: 975 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199704 2 STORY 60 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 18,966 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 42 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4948 RUSTIC WAY PID#: 26-117-23-14-0033 SALE PRICE: $ 115,000 YEAR BUILT: 1960 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1600 GROUND FLR. AREA: 800 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 199708 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 8,712 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 43 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6130 CHESTNUT TER PID#: 36-117-23-44-0009 229,000 1988 1864 980 199707 2 STORY SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 70 % o 2 YES OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 16,800 SF 4 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 44 I I I I I I I I .1 I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6050 MCKINLEY PL PID#: 36-117-23-44-0042 SALE PRICE: $ 193,500 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1864 GROUND FLR. AREA: 980 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199610 2 STORY 00 % FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 12,500 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 45 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6065 MAPLE LEAF CIR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0019 SALE PRICE: $ 231,500 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1920 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1140 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199702 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,442 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 46 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19495 VINE RIDGE RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0015 SALE PRICE: $ 187,900 YEAR BUILT: 1987 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2006 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1018 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 0 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199702 2 STORY 00 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 10,800 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 47 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 48 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19555 VINE RIDGE RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0009 SALE PRICE: $ 190,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2022 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1018 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: 199707 2 STORY 20 % YES 1 1 1 1 12,000 SF I .1 I \1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26025 BIRCH BLUFF RD PID#: 29-117-23-43-0028 SALE PRICE: $ 212,000 YEAR BUILT: 1992 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2034 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1183 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199701 2 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 22,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 49 I I I ;1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19705 NEAR MOUNTAIN BLVD PID#: 36-117-23-44-0077 SALE PRICE: $ 222,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2064 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1038 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 0 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 50 199709 2 STORY 20 % 1 1 o 1 15,733 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6165 MCKINLEY CIR PID#: 36-117-23-44-0069 SALE PRICE: $ 219,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2102 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1166 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199706 2 STORY FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 51 I I I I I I I ,I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6045 MCKINLEY PL PID#: 36-117-23-44-0034 SALE PRICE: $ 222,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2122 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1223 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199703 2 STORY 50 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 12,800 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 52 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I. I- I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5950 MCKINLEY PL PID#: 36-117-23-41-0038 SALE PRICE: $ 226,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2136 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1110 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199704 2 STORY 00 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 10,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 53 I I , I I I 'I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6185 STRAWBERRY LA PID#: 32-117-23-43-0042 SALE PRICE: $ 225,000 YEAR BUILT: 1993 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2145 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1089 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199702 2 STORY 00 % BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 54 I I I -I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5985 MCKINLEY PL PID#: 36-117-23-41-0024 SALE PRICE: $ 234,000 YEAR BUILT: 1990 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2155 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1099 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199703 2 STORY 80 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 15,600 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 55 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19305 MCKINLEY CT PID#: 36-117-23-44-0063 SALE PRICE: $ 217,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2174 GROUND FLR. AREA : 1094 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 2 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 14,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 56 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 261 7 0 OAK LEAF TR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0039 SALE PRICE: $ 225,000 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2208 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1128 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199612 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 57 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6040 BURLWOOD CT PID#: 32-117-23-43-0025 SALE PRICE: $ 262,500 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2216 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1116 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199610 2 STORY 00 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 21,053 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 58 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6060 BURLWOOD CT PID#: 32-117-23-43-0023 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: 199707 STORY HEIGHT: 2 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 28,235 SF SALE PRICE: $ 250,000 YEAR BUILT: 1990 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2216 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1172 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 59 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19565 VINE RIDGE RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0008 SALE PRICE: $ 229,000 YEAR BUILT: 1987 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2220 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1116 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199709 2 STORY 60 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 14,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 60 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19445 VINE RIDGE RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 220,000 YEAR BUILT: 1987 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2290 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1152 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199707 2 STORY FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 10,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 61 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6025 BURLWOOD CT PID#: 32-117-23-44-0012 SALE PRICE: $ 265,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2300 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1220 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199709 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,519 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 62 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26185 OAK LEAF TR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0054 SALE PRICE: $ 243,000 YEAR BUILT: 1993 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2308 GROUND FLR. AREA : 1348 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199709 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 63 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26190 OAK LEAF TR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0040 SALE PRICE: $ 258,000 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2312 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1168 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199706 2 STORY 40 % YES 0 BATH-DELUXE: 1 1 FULL: 1 YES 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 23,000 SF 4 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 64 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26785 EDGEWOOD RD PID#: 32-117-23-21-0012 SALE PRICE: $ 279,900 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2314 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1342 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199705 2 STORY 80 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 108,900 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 65 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5745 KATHLEEN CT PID#: 31-117-23-13-0023 SALE PRICE: $ 308,000 YEAR BUILT: 1985 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2350 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1420 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH~DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 66 199707 2 STORY 50 % YES YES o 2 o 1 44,400 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6045 WHITNEY CIR PID#: 36-~~7-23-4~-0053 SALE PRICE: $ 224,900 YEAR BUILT: ~988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2364 GROUND FLR. AREA: ~266 GARAGE #~: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S): ~ CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES ~99703 2 STORY BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: ~ FULL: ~ 3/4: 0 ~/2: ~ LOT SIZE: ~5,333 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 67 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5775 BRENTRIDGE DR PID#: 31-117-23-14-0030 SALE PRICE: $ 250,720 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2368 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1240 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199709 2 STORY 00 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 1 COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 26,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 68 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26155 SHOREWOOD OAKS DR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0031 SALE PRICE: $ 260,000 YEAR BUILT: 1990 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2370 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1224 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199702 2 STORY 30 % YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 69 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5630 VINE HILL RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0062 SALE PRICE: $ 234,000 YEAR BUILT: 1986 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2410 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1240 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199708 2 STORY FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 17,680 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 70 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6100 CATHCART DR PID#: 32-117-23-33-0036 SALE PRICE: $ 273,000 YEAR BUILT: 1994 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2443 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1270 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199705 2 STORY 00 % GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 86,100 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 71 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4530 ENCHANTED DR PID#: 30-117-23-32-0019 SALE PRICE: $ 257,000 YEAR BUILT: 1990 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2450 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1342 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199708 2 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 40 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 25,000 SF 3 WITH PID 30-117-23-32-0022 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 72 I I- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5930 SWEETWATER CIR PID#: 36-117-23-42-0009 SALE PRICE: $ 353,000 YEAR BUILT: 1987 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2452 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1228 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199708 2 STORY 70 % YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 35,762 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 73 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 74 RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27410 MAPLE RIDGE LA PID#: 31-117-23-44-0015 SALE PRICE: $ 215,000 YEAR BUILT: 1961 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2495 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1291 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: 199610 2 STORY 20 % YES YES o 1 1. 1 29,640 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 26285 OAK LEAF TR PID#: 32-117-23-43-0049 SALE PRICE: $ 280,000 YEAR BUILT: 1993 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2538 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1390 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 75 199708 2 STORY 50 % YES 1 2 o 1 26,900 SF - I I- I I I I I I I I I I 'I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19710 SWEETWATER CUR PID#: 36-117-23-42-0007 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199705 2 STORY SALE PRICE: $ 380,000 YEAR BUILT: 1987 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2616 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1802 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 10 % YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 40,642 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 76 - I I 'I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5925 SWEETWATER CIR PID#: 36-117-23-41-0017 SALE PRICE: $ 357,500 YEAR BUILT: 1990 GROSS BLDG. AREA : 2846 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1696 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199705 2 STORY 00 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 28,488 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 77 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27665 BRYNMAWR PL PID#: 31-117-23-13-0026 SALE PRICE: $ 473,750 YEAR BUILT: 1994 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2914 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2109 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199707 2 STORY 70 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 40,300 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 78 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5650 OLD MARKET RD PID#: 36-117-23-13-0033 SALE PRICE: $ 335,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2948 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1612 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199612 2 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 70 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 49,333 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 79 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5935 SWEETWATER CIR PID#: 36-117-23-41-0018 SALE PRICE: $ 389,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2958 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2053 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 4 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 80 199705 2 STORY 50 % o 2 1 1 38,000 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6145 SIERRA CIR PID#: 36-117-23-43-0033 SALE PRICE: $ 377,500 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2999 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1570 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199708 2 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 6 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 60 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 21,780 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 81 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19635 SILVER LAKE TR PID#: 36-117-23-43-0022 SALE PRICE: $ 450,000 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3087 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1920 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 2 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 23,522 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 82 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19675 SILVER LAKE TR PID#: 36-117-23-43-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 512,700 YEAR BUILT: 1992 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3148 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1706 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199704 2 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 90 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 24,829 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 83 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19705 MUIRFIELD CIR PID#: 36-117-23-12-0033 SALE PRICE: $ 550,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3214 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2636 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199610 2 STORY 70 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 7 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 3 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 30,800 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 84 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19700 MUIRFIELD CIR PID#: 36-117-23-12-0047 SALE PRICE: $ 399,500 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3236 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1715 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199708 2 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 2 LOT SIZE: 22,800 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 85 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5715 KATHLEEN CT PID#: 31-117-23-13-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 307,500 YEAR BUILT: 1982 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3267 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1911 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: 199611 2 STORY 00 % YES 0 BATH-DELUXE: 0 2 FULL: 2 YES 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 50,800 SF 4 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 86 I -I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19730 SWEETWATER CUR PID#: 36-117-23-42-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 480,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3269 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1653 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199707 2 STORY FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 39,200 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 87 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6160 SIERRA CIR PID#: 36-117-23-43-0027 SALE PRICE: $ 465,000 YEAR BUILT: 1991 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3311 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1897 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: 199701 2 STORY 50 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SCREEN: YES OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 22,216 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 88 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27995 BOULDER CIR PID#: 31-117-23-34-0024 SALE PRICE: $ 450,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3327 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2557 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199611 2 STORY BSMT. FINISHING: 90 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 54,450 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 89 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19805 WATERFORD PL PID#: 36-117-23-12-0006 SALE PRICE: $ 517,500 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 3798 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2157 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199610 2 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 70 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 2 LOT SIZE: 25,865 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 90 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5275 ST ALBANS BAY RD PID#: 25-117-23-33-0048 SALE PRICE: $ 682,000 YEAR BUILT: 1988 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 4911 GROUND FLR. AREA: 3998 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 91 9611 2 STORY 20 % YES 1 1 3 1 170,000 SF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5650 VINE HILL RD PID#: 36-117-23-14-0060 SALE PRICE: $ 145,000 YEAR BUILT: 1986 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1356 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1356 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199612 SPLIT LEVEL BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 0 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 18,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 92 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RES IDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 6130 CHURCH RD PID#: 32-117-23-34-0058 SALE PRICE: $ 155,000 YEAR BUILT: 1947 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1392 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1392 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199706 SPLIT LEVEL 50 % OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 17,860 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 93 - I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I ~I .1 RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 24400 WOOD DR PID#: 33-117-23-43-0007 SALE PRICE: $ 159,900 YEAR BUILT: 1977 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1449 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1449 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199610 SPLIT ENTRY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 0 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 40 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 0 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 23,087 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 94 SALE PRICE: $ YEAR BUILT: GROSS BLDG. AREA: GROUND FLR. AREA: 14 2 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: FIREPLACE(S) : CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED REtIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 95 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5695 CHRISTOPHER RD PID#: 33-~17-23-13-0028 168,50!0 1988 199704 SPLIT LEVEL SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 90 % o 1 YES OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 20,033 SF 4 - I I I I I I I .1 I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 602S APPLE RD PID#: 35-117-23-34-0025 SALE PRICE: $ 165,000 YEAR BUILT: 1984 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1516 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1S16 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199611 SPLIT LEVEL 80 % FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 37,600 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 96 - I I I I I I I il I I I I I I I 'I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 19240 COVINGTON CT PID#: 36-117-23-14-0054 SALE PRICE: $ 176,900 YEAR BUILT: 1986 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1522 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1522 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 SPLIT LEVEL DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: 50 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 8,285 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 97 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I - I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 25135 GLEN RD PID#: 33-117-23-21-0045 SALE PRICE: $ 155,000 YEAR BUILT: 1977 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1542 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1542 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199705 SPLIT LEVEL 30 % FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 40,000 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 98 I I I I I 'I I 'I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 20025 VINE ST PID#: 25-117-23-31-0027 SALE PRICE: $ 227,000 YEAR BUILT: 1965 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1710 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1710 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199707 SPLIT LEVEL 40 % BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 41,230 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 99 I I- I I I I I I I II I I 'I I I I I I I FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: CHRISTMAS LAKE BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5755 MERRY LA PID#: 35-117-23-14-0002 SALE PRICE: $ 297,000 YEAR BUILT: 1958 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1050 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1050 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 1 GARAGE #2: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: YES OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4 : 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 100 199708 1 STORY 00 % o 1 o o 150 FF I I I I I I. I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5780 CHRISTMAS LAKE RD PID#: 35-117-23-13-0020 SALE PRICE: $ 278,000 YEAR BUILT: 1956 GROSS BLDG. AREA : 1493 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1493 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 1 GARAGE #2: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 1 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: CHRISTMAS LAKE BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SITE BISECTED BY ROAD SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199706 1 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 67 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 101 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 21135 CHRISTMAS LA PID#: 35-117-23-44-0006 SALE PRICE: $ 635,000 YEAR BUILT: 1978 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1858 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1858 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199610 1 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: CHRISTMAS LAKE BEDROOMS: 1 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 40 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4 : 0 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 150 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 102 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: CHRISTMAS LAKE BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: RESIDENTIAL" SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5790 CHRISTMAS LAKE PT PID#: 35-117-23-14-0015 INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 103 SALE PRICE: $ 562,000 YEAR BUILT: 1954 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2076 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2076 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199611 1 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 30 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 2 LOT SIZE: 300 FF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5935 GALPIN LAKE RD PID#: 34-117-23-41-0024 SALE PRICE: $ 345,000 YEAR BUILT: 1900 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1719 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1131 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKE SHORE - BAY: Galpin Lake BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 199707 2 STORY 40 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 134,165 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 104 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5435 TIMBER LA PID#: 34-117-23-22-0017 SALE PRICE: $ 430,000 SALE DATE: 199703 YEAR BUILT: 1953 STORY HEIGHT: 1 STORY GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2434 DECK: YES GROUND FLR. AREA: 2434 BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % GARAGE #1: ATTACHED PORCH-GLAZED: # OF CARS: 2 SCREEN: GARAGE #2: OPEN: # OF CARS: 0 BATH-DELUXE: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 1 FULL: 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES 3/4: 1 WALKOUT: YES 1/2: 0 LAKESHORE-BAY: GIDEONS BAY LOT SIZE: 90 FF BEDROOMS: COMMENTS: 5 ALSO SOLD SEPT-97 FOR $381,500' INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 105 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4795 FERNCROFT DR PID#: 26-117-23-11-0051 SALE PRICE: $ 230,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1392 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1392 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199705 1 STORY GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKE SHORE - BAY: Lake William BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 40 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 19,600 SF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 106 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4960 SHADY ISLAND CIR PID#: 30-117-23-31-0015 SALE PRICE: $ 255,000 YEAR BUILT: 1985 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1206 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1206 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES 199706 1 STORY WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: PHELPS BAY BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: BSMT. FINISHING: 90 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 100 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 107 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4365 ENCHANTED DR PID#: 30-117-23-23-0007 WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: PHELPS BAY BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: HOUSE DEMOLISED SALE DATE: 199703 STORY HEIGHT: 1 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 1 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 90 FF SALE PRICE: $ 175,000 YEAR BUILT: 1997 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2029 GROUND FLR. AREA: 2029 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 108 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 4485 HIGHLAND CIR PID#: 30-117-23-32-0006 SALE PRICE: $ 266,000 YEAR BUILT: 1977 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2374 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1386 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: LAKESHORE-BAY: PHELPS BAY BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: 199701 2 STORY 00 % OPEN: YES BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4 : 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 80 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 109 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I , RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 27920 SMITHTOWN RD PID#: 31-117-23-34-0029 SALE PRICE: $ 405,000 YEAR BUILT: 1956 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1104 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1104 GARAGE #1: DETACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 199705 SPLIT ENTRY 60 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: SMITHTOWN BAY BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: HOUSE DEMOLISHED PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 LOT SIZE: 75 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 110 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 28225 BOULDER CIR PID#: 31-117-23-34-0019 SALE PRICE: $ 594,000 YEAR BUILT: 1955 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1948 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1948 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: SMITHTOWN BAY BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 111 199709 SPLIT ENTRY 80 % o 1 1 1 130 FF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5200 SHADY ISLAND CIR PID#: 30-117-23-13-0016 SALE PRICE: $ 235,000 SALE DATE: 199705 YEAR BUILT: 1930 STORY HEIGHT: 2 STORY GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1806 DECK: GROUND FLR. AREA: 963 BSMT. FINISHING: 00 % GARAGE #1: PORCH-GLAZED: # OF CARS: 0 SCREEN: YES GARAGE #2: OPEN: # OF CARS: 0 BATH-DELUXE: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : FULL: 1 CENTRAL AIR: 3/4: 0 WALKOUT: 1/2: 0 LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE LOT SIZE: 110 FF BEDROOMS: 0 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 112 - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5215 HOWARDS POINT RD PID#: 30-117-23-44-0003 SALE PRICE: $ 550,000 YEAR BUILT: 1964 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 1812 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1812 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE BEDROOMS: 5 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: FULL: 3/4: 1/2: LOT SIZE: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 113 199707 1 STORY 80 % YES o 1 2 o 150 FF I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5260 SHADY ISLAND RD PID#: 30-117-23-42-0003 SALE PRICE: $ 370,000 SALE DATE: 199708 YEAR BUILT: 1974 STORY HEIGHT: 2 STORY GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2192 DECK: YES GROUND FLR. AREA: 1517 BSMT. FINISHING: 50 % GARAGE #1: ATTACHED PORCH-GLAZED: # OF CARS: 2 SCREEN: GARAGE #2: OPEN: # OF CARS: 0 BATH-DELUXE: 0 FIREPLACE (S) : 2 FULL: 1 CENTRAL AIR: 3/4: 0 WALKOUT: YES 1/2: 3 LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE LOT SIZE: 85 FF BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 114 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5355 ELMRIDGE CIR PID#: 29-117-23-34-0011 SALE PRICE: $ 525,000 SALE DATE: 199704 YEAR BUILT: 1975 STORY HEIGHT: 1 1/4 STORY GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2431 DECK: YES GROUND FLR. AREA: 2236 BSMT. FINISHING: 80 % GARAGE #1: ATTACHED PORCH-GLAZED: # OF CARS: 3 SCREEN: GARAGE #2: OPEN: # OF CARS: 0 BATH-DELUXE: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 2 FULL: 1 CENTRAL AIR: YES 3/4: 2 WALKOUT: YES 1/2: 1 LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE LOT SIZE: 86 FF BEDROOMS: 4 COMMENTS: INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 115 .. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5165 SHADY ISLAND RD PID#: 30-117-23-42-0009 SALE PRICE: $ 495,000 YEAR BUILT: 1989 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 2619 GROUND FLR. AREA: 1425 GARAGE #1: ATTACHED # OF CARS: 3 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S): 2 CENTRAL AIR: YES WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE BEDROOMS: 3 COMMENTS: SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: 199702 2 STORY DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: 70 % PORCH-GLAZED: YES SCREEN: OPEN: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 140 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 116 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RESIDENTIAL SALES DATA ADDRESS: 5330 HOWARDS POINT RD PID#: 30-117-23-44-0019 SALE PRICE: $ 805,500 YEAR BUILT: 1948 GROSS BLDG. AREA: 4024 GROUND FLR. AREA: 4024 GARAGE #1: TUCKUNDER # OF CARS: 2 GARAGE #2: # OF CARS: 0 FIREPLACE(S) : 3 CENTRAL AIR: YES SALE DATE: STORY HEIGHT: DECK: YES BSMT. FINISHING: PORCH'-GLAZED: SCREEN: OPEN: 199709 1 STORY 70 % WALKOUT: YES LAKESHORE-BAY: UPPER LAKE BEDROOMS: 2 COMMENTS: BATH-DELUXE: 0 FULL: 2 3/4: 3 1/2: 1 LOT SIZE: 240 FF INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 117